Tort, error and talk: What can we learn from the litigation crisis?

International Journal of Risk and Safety in Medicine

Volumn 19, Issue 1-2, 2007, Pages 75-86

  Hugman, Bruce ^a,b,c,d  

^a Uppsala Monitoring Centre ^*  (Thailand)

^b UPPSALA MONITORING CENTRE   (Sweden)

^c Shanghai Pharmacology Institute   (China)

^d RANGSIT UNIVERSITY   (Thailand)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CRISIS THEORY; DOCTOR PATIENT RELATION; ERROR; GENERAL PRACTITIONER; HEALTH CARE PERSONNEL; INFORMED CONSENT; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; LAW SUIT; MALPRACTICE; NEGLIGENCE; REVIEW; RISK REDUCTION; TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT;

EID: 34249325200     PISSN: 09246479     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (83)

1. N. Ambady, D. LaPlante, T. Nguyen, R. Rosenthal, N. Chaumeton and W. Levinson, Surgeons' tone of voice: A clue to malpractice history, Surgery 132(1) (2002), 5-9.
2. American Medical Association Report 35 of the Board of Trustees (A-02), available at: http://www.ama-assn.org/ama1/ upload/mm/annual02/bot35a02.rtf.
3. ASTAR: for example, the national judges' medical school run by ASTAR - the Advanced Science and Technology Adjudication Resource Centre Inc, at: http://einshac.org/.
4. T. Baker, The Medical Malpractice Myth, University of Chiacgo Press, 2005.
5. L.M. Baldwin, L.G. Hart, M. Lloyd, M. Fordyce and R.A. Rosenblatt, Defensive medicine and obstetrics, JAMA 274 (1995) 1606-1610.
6. C. Batchelor, D.J. Owens, M. Read and M. Bloor, Patient satisfaction studies: methodology, management and consumer evaluation, Int. Jnl. Healthcare Quality Assurance 7 (1994), 22-30.
7. R.P. Bergen, Protection against malpractice litigation, Arch. Otolaryngol. 101 (1975), 182-184.
8. M.M. Bismark, T.A. Brennan, R.J. Paterson, P.B. Davis and D.M. Studdert, Relationship between complaints and quality of care in New Zealand: a descriptive analysis of complainants and non-complainants following adverse events, Qual. Saf. Health Care 15 (2006), 22-31.
9. Z.D. Blasi, E. Harkness, A. Georgiou and J. Kleijnen, Influence of context effects on health outcomes: a systematic review, The Lancet 357 (2001), 757-762.
10. K. Bottles, blog at: http://www.soundpractice.net/article.cfm?id=222.
11. S.C. Charles, J.R.Wilbert and E.C. Kennedy, Physicians' self-reports of reactions to malpractice litigation, Am. J. Psychiatry 141 (1984), 563-565.
12. H.R. Clinton and B. Obama, Making patient safety the centrepiece of medical liability reform, NEJM 354 (2005), 2205-2208.
13. CMIRPS: the Canadian Medication Incident Reporting and Prevention System. Health Canada. See: http://www.hcsc. gc.ca/dhp-mps/medeff/advers-react-neg/fs- if/cmirps- scdpim_e.html.
14. Congressional Budget Office, Limiting Tort Liability for Medical Malpractice, January 8, 2004.
15. A.F. Cook, H. Hoas, K. Guttmannova and J.C. Joyner, An error by any other name, Am. J. Nurs. 104 (2004), 32-43.
16. P.M. Danzon, Medical Malpractice: Theory, Evidence and Public Policy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass, 1985.
17. T. Drabsch, Medical negligence: An update. Government of NSW Briefing paper no. 2/2004. Available at: http://www. parliament.nsw.gov.au/prod/parlment/ publications.nsf/0/6C1BDA58607A7808CA256ECF0007223D.
18. P. Fenn, A. Gray and N. Rickman, Enterprise liability, insurance and defensive medicine: UK evidence. http://www.bris.ac. uk/cmpo/events/ seminarseries/fenn.pdf.
19. J. Fuquay J, Filed down: Since the tort systems' overhaul in 2003, the number of malpractice suits has plummeted, Star-Telegram, Mon Aug 21 2006. The reforms also raised the standard of proof required for malpractice cases, and this will have had some effect in filtering out more cases.
20. T.H. Gallagher, A.D. Waterman, J.M. Garbutt, J.M. Knapp, D.K. Chan, W.C. Dunagan, V.J. Fraser and W. Levinson, US and Canadian physicians' attitudes and experiences regarding disclosing errors to patients, Arch. Intern. Med. 166 (2006), 1605-1611.
21. M. Gladwell, Blink: The Power of Thinking without Thinking, Little Brown & Co, 2005. Extract available on: http://www. memag.com/memag/ article/articleDetail.jsp?id=365763.
22. N.K. Grover, Medical liability: litigations and defensive medicine, Journal of the Indian Medical Association, 92(6) 1994, 184.
23. Harris Poll®#22, Most Doctors Report Fear of Malpractice Liability Has Harmed Their Ability to Provide Quality Care; Caused Them to Order Unnecessary Tests, Provide Unnecessary Treatment and Make unnecessary referrals, May 8 2002. http://www.harrisinteractive.com/harris_poll/index.asp?PID=300.
24. Harvard Health Policy Review, Spring 2003, Volume 4, Number 1, In Focus.
25. Harvard Medical Practice Study Group, Patients, Doctors and Lawyers: Medical Injury, Malpractice Litigation, and Patient Compensation in New York, 1990.
26. J.R. Hunter, Americans for Insurance Reform, Medical Malpractice Insurance: Stable Losses/Unstable Rates, October 10, 2002. See also: http://www.insurance-reform.org/StableLosses.pdf.
27. G. Iles, The Quiet Game, Signet Books, 2000, pp. 34-35. A fictitious, but vivid, insightful and moving account of the effect of a malpractice suit on a mature, popular, conscientious physician.
28. D.A. Katz, G.C. Williams, P.L. Brown, T.P. Aufderheide, M. Bogner, P.S. Rahko and H.P. Selker, Emergency physicians' fear of malpractice in evaluating patients with possible acute cardiac ischemia, Annals of Emergency Medicine 46 (2005), 525-533.
29. D.P. Kessler and M. McClellan, Do doctors practice defensive medicine? Quarterly Journal of Economics VIII (1996), 353-390.
30. D.P. Kessler and M. McClellan, 1996, op cit.
31. D.P. Kessler and M. McClellan, Malpractice law and health care reform: optimal liability policy in an era of managed care, Journal of Public Economics 84 (2002), 75-197.
32. D.P. Kessler, N. Summerton and J.R. Graham, Effects of the Medical liability system in Australia, the UK, and the USA, The Lancet 368 (2006), 240-246.
33. D.P. Kessler, N. Summerton and J.R. Graham, 2006, op cit.
34. D.P. Kessler, N. Summerton and J.R. Graham, 2006, op cit.
35. D.P. Kessler, N. Summerton and J.R. Graham, 2006, op cit. The reference list to this article provides extensive further reading on this topic.
36. K.T. Kohn, J.M. Corrigan and M.S. Donalson, National Academy of Sciences, 1999, op cit.
37. L. Kowalcyzk, Premiums to Rise 20% for Mass. Doctors, The Boston Globe, April 17, 2003, A1, A27
38. L.L. Leape and D.M. Berwick, Five years after To Err Is Human: What have we learned? JAMA 293 (2005), 2384-2390.
39. Legalaffairs.org: the debate is entertainingly characterised by two campaigning individuals at: http://www.legalaffairs. org/webexclusive/ debateclub_medmal0305.msp.
40. D.R. Longo, J.E. Hewitt, B. Ge and S. Schubert, The long road to patient safety, JAMA 294 (2005), 2858-2865.
41. K.M. Mazor, G.W. Reed, R.A. Yood, M.A. Fischer, J. Baril and J.H. Gurwitz, Disclosure of medical errors: what factors influence how patients respond?, J. Gen. Intern. Med. 21 (2006), 704-710.
42. National Academy of Sciences, IOM, Crossing the Quality Chasm, National Academy Press, 2001.
43. National Academy of Sciences, IOM; K.T. Kohn, J.M. Corrigan and M.S. Donalson, To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System, National Academy Press, Washington, DC, 1999.
44. National Insurance Commissioners (US). http://www.naic.org/.
45. National Practitioner Data Bank and the Journal of Health Affairs, as quoted by Lorraine Woellert, Commentary: A Second Opinion on the Malpractice Plague, Business Week, March 3, 2003.
46. National Practitioner Data Bank, March 3 2003, op cit.
47. National Practitioner Data Bank, March 3 2003, op cit.
48. NCC MERP: National Coordinating Council for Medication Error Reporting and Prevention. http://www.nccmerp.org.
49. Newrules.org: there is a good presentation of contrasting views at: http://www.newrules.org/voice2004/health /malpractice.html.
50. NHLSA: http://www.nhsla.com.
51. NHS; http://www.npsa.nhs.uk/.
52. NICE: http://www.nice.org.uk.
53. NICE: http://www.nice.org.uk/page.aspx?o=guidelines.completed.
54. NSW: Government of NSW, Special Commission of inquiry into Campbelltown and Camden hospitals. Available at: www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/.../vwFiles/ Interim_Report_31March2004.pdf/$file/Interim_ Report_31March2004.pdf.
55. NSW: Government of NSW, Special Commission of inquiry into Campbelltown and Camden hospitals, op cit.
56. R.L. Phillips, L.A. Bartholomew, S.M. Dovey, G.E. Fryer, T.J. Myoshi and L.A. Green, Learning from malpractice claims about negligent, adverse events in primary health care in the United States, Qual. Saf. Health Care 13 (2004), 121-126.
57. Pointoflaw.com: an astonishing range of comment and resources on medical malpractice at: http://www.pointoflaw. com/medicinelaw/category_archive.php.
58. V.S. Rane, Doctors, patients and lawyers: are we all speaking the same language? 10th Greek Australian Legal and Medical Conference, Mykonos, Greece, 2005. http://www.lmconference.com.au/papers/2005/rane.html.
59. B. Rice, 10 Ways to guarantee a lawsuit, Medical Economics, July 8 2005. Available on www.memag.com.
60. S.O. Rogers Jr, A.A. Gawande, M. Kwaan, A.L. Puopolo, C. Yoon, T.A. Brennan and D.M. Studdert, Analysis of surgical errors in closed malpractice claims at 4 liability insurers, Surgery 140 (2006), 25-33.
61. F.A. Sloan, P.M. Mergenhagen, W.B. Burfield, V.V. Bovbjerg and M. Hassan, Medical malpractice of physicians: predictable or haphazard?, JAMA 262 (1989), 3291-3297.
62. F.A. Sloan et al., 1989, op cit.
63. F. Soleimani, Learning from mistakes in New Zealand hospitals: what else do we need besides 'no-fault'?, N. Z. Med. J. 119 (2006), U2099.
64. K. Steadman, Health Policy blog. http://healthypolicy.typepad.com/blog/ medical_malpractice_myth/index.html.
65. D.M. Studdert, M.M. Mello, W.M. Sage, C.M. DesRoches, J. Peugh, K. Zapert and T.A. Brennan, Defensive medicine among high-risk specialist physicians in a volatile malpractice environment, JAMA 293 (2005), 2609-2617.
66. M.I. Taragin, A.P. Wilczek, M.E. Karns, R. Trout and J.L.Carson, Physician demographics and the risk of medical malpractice, Am. J. Med. 93 (1992), 537-542.
67. M.I. Taragin, L.R. Willett, A.P. Wilczek, R. Trout and J.L. Carson , The influence of standard of care and severity of injury on the resolution of malpractice claims, Annals of Internal medicine 117 (1992), 780-784.
68. TATR: for example, The American Tort Reform Association; www.atra.org.
69. U.S. Congress, Office of Technology Assessment, Defensive Medicine and Medical Malpractice, Washington DC, U.S. Government Printing Office, 1994, 13.
70. United Kingdom, Department of Health, Making Amends: A consultation paper setting out proposals for reforming the approach to clinical negligence in the NHS, A report by the Chief Medical Officer, June 2003, p. 9. Available at: www.doh.gov.uk/makingamends/pdf/cmomakingamends.pdf.
71. United States General Accounting Office, Medical Malpractice Insurance: Multiple Factors Have Contributed to Increased Premium Rates, GAO-03-702, June 2003.
72. K.T. Unruh and W. Pratt, Patients as actors: The Patient's role in detecting, preventing and recovering from medical error, Int. J. Med. Inform. (2006).
73. US Bureau of Labor Statistics - Medical Services CPI; Best's Aggregates and Averages.
74. M.B. Van de Weyden, The 'Cam affair': an isolated incident or destined to be repeated?, MJA 180 (2004), 100-101.
75. C. Vincent, M. Young, A. Phillips, Why do people sue doctors? A study of patients and relatives taking legal action, Lancet 25 (1994), 1609-1613.
76. L. Weinstein L, A multifaceted approach to improve patient safety, prevent medical error and resolve the professional liability crisis, Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 194 (2006), 1160-1166.
77. White House Press Office, President Discusses Medical Liability Reform, Gateway Center, Collinsville, Illinois, January 5 2005.
78. White House Press Office, President Discusses Medical Liability Reform, Gateway Center, Collinsville, Illinois, January 5 2005.
79. WHO: http://www.who.int/patientsafety/en/.
80. Wrong diagnosis.com: http://www.wrongdiagnosis.com/malpractice/overview. htm.
81. A.W. Wu, S. Folkman, S.J. McPhee and B. Lo, Do house officers learn from their mistakes?, JAMA 265 (1991), 2089-2094.
82. A.W. Wu et al., 1991, op cit.
83. E.G. Zurad, Don't be a target for a malpractice suit, Family Practice Management 13 (2006), 57-64.