Defining acceptable levels for ecological indicators: An approach for considering social values

Environmental Management

Volumn 39, Issue 3, 2007, Pages 301-315

  Smyth, Robyn L ^a   Watzin, Mary C ^a   Manning, Robert E ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT   (United States)

Author keywords

Acceptable levels; Adaptive management; Ecosystem indicators; Lake Champlain; Normative theory; Social norm curves; Social preferences

Indexed keywords

ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT; ECOSYSTEM INDICATORS; NORMATIVE THEORY; SOCIAL NORM CURVES; SOCIAL PREFERENCES;

ALGAE; ECOSYSTEMS; ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING; LAKES; SOCIAL ASPECTS; STREAM FLOW;

ECOLOGY;

ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT; ECOLOGICAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS; ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATOR; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES; SOCIAL THEORY;

BACTERIUM CONTAMINATION; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; LAKE; REVIEW; SAFETY; SEA POLLUTION; SEASHORE; SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY; SUMMER; THEORY;

DATA COLLECTION; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; FRESH WATER; SOCIAL VALUES;

LAKE CHAMPLAIN; NORTH AMERICA;

ALGAE; BACTERIA (MICROORGANISMS);

EID: 33847144162     PISSN: 0364152X     EISSN: 14321009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00267-005-0282-3     Document Type: Review

References (93)

1. Anderson R. M., B. F. Hobbs, J. F. Koonce, A. B. Locci. 2001. Using decision analysis to choose phosphorus targets for Lake Erie. Environ Manage 27:235-252
2. Aron W., S. Smith. 1971. Ship canals and aquatic systems. Science 174:13-20
3. Bennett E. M., S. R. Carpenter, N. F. Caraco. 2001. Human impact on erodable phosphorus and eutrophication: a global perspective. Bioscience 51(2):227-234
4. Bertram P., N. Stadler-Salt. 2000. Selection of indicators for Great Lakes basin health, Version 4. State of the Lakes Ecosystem Conference (SOLEC), March 2000. Available from http://www.on.ec.gc.ca/solec/indicators2000-e.html
5. Boxall P. C., B. Macnab. 2000. Exploring the preferences of wildlife recreationists for features of boreal forest management: a choice experiment approach. Can J Forest Res 30:1931-1941
6. Breffle W. S., R. D. Rowe. 2002. Comparing choice question formats for evaluating natural resource tradeoffs. Land Econ 78:298-314
7. Budd L., D. Meals. 1994. Lake Champlain nonpoint pollution assessment. Technical Report 6A and 6B, Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, VT
8. Cairns J., P. V. McCormick, B. R. Niederlehner. 1993. A proposed framework for developing indicators of ecosystem health. Hydrobiologia 236:1-44
9. Carpenter S. R. 2005. Eutrophication of aquatic ecosystems: Bistability and soil phosphorus. Proc Natl Acad Sci 102:10,002-10,005
10. Carpenter S. R., D. Ludwig, W. A. Brock. 1999. Management of eutrophication for lakes subject to potentially irreversible change. Ecol Applic 9:751-771
11. Chesapeake Bay Program. 2002. The state of the Chesapeake Bay: A report to the citizens of the Bay regions 2002. Available from http://www. chesapeakebay.net/pubs/sob/sob02/sotb_2002_final.pdf
12. Dale V. H., S. C. Beyeler. 2001. Challenges in the development and use of ecological indicators. Ecol Indicators 1(1):3-10
13. Dillman D. A. 2000. Mail and internet surveys: The tailored design method. Wiley, New York
14. Dorfman M. 2002. Testing the waters: a guide to water quality at vacation beaches. Natural Resources Defense Council, New York
15. Downing J. A., S. B. Watson, E. McCauley. 2001. Predicting cyanobacteria dominance in lakes. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 58:1905-1908
16. Elser J. J. 1999. The pathway to noxious cyanobacteria blooms in lakes: The foodweb as the final turn. Freshwater Biol 42:537-543
17. Hammett W., D. Cole. 1998. Wildland recreation: ecology and management. Wiley, New York
18. Harwell M. A., V. Myers, T. Young, A. Bartuska, N. Gassman, J. H. Gentile, C. C. Harwell, S. Appelbaum, J. Barko, B. Causey, C. Johnson, A. McLean, R. Smola, P. Templet, S. Tosini. 1999. A framework for an ecosystem integrity report card. Bioscience 49:543-556
19. Haskell B. D., B. G. Norton R. Costanza. 1992. What is ecosystem health and why should we worry about it? In R. Costanza, B. G. Norton, B. D. Haskell (eds), Ecosystem health: New goals for environmental management. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp 3-20
20. Heberlein T., G. Alfano, L. Ervin. 1986. Using a social carrying capacity model to estimate the effects of marina development at the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore. Leisure Sci 8:257-274
21. Hegman W., D. Wang, C. Borer. 1999. Estimation of Lake Champlain basinwide nonpoint source phosphorus export. Technical Report 31. Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, VT
22. Holling C. S. 1973. Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 4:1-23
23. Holling C. S. (ed) (1978) Adaptive environmental assessment and management. Wiley, London
24. Huisman J., H. C. P. Matthijs, P. M. Visser. 2005. Harmful cyanobacteria. Springer-Verlag, Dordrecht
25. Hunsaker C. T., D. E. Carpenter. (eds) 1990. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program: Ecological indicators. Atmospheric Research and Exposure Assessment Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, US Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC
26. Hunt T., S. Crawford. 2002. 2001 Water Chestnut Management Program: Lake Champalin and inland waters in Vermont. Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, VT
27. Huszar V.L.dM., N. F. Caraco. 1998. The relationship between phytoplankton composition and physical-chemical variables: A comparison of taxonomic and morphological-functional descriptors in six temperate lakes. Freshwater Biol 40:679-696
28. Jackson J. 1965. Social stratification, social norms, and roles. In I. D. Steiner, M. F. Fishbein (eds), Current studies in psychology. Holt, Rinehart, Winston, New York, pp 301-309
29. Jackson L. E., J. C. Kurtz, W. S. Fisher. (eds). 2000. Evaluation guidelines for ecological indicators. EPA/620/R-99/005. US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Research Triangle Park, NC
30. Jensen J. P., E. Jeppesen, K. Olrik, P. Kristensen. 1994. Impact of nutrients and physical factors on the shift from cyanobacterial to chlorophyte dominance in shallow Danish lakes. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 51:1692-1699
31. Karr J. R. 1992. Ecological integrity: protecting Earth's life support systems. In R. Costanza, B. G. Norton, B. D. Haskell (eds), Ecosystem health: New goals for environmental management. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp 223-238
32. Kelly J. R., M. A. Harwell. 1990. Indicators of ecosystem recovery. Environ Manage 14(5):527-545
33. Lake Champlain Fish and Wildlife Management Cooperative, Fisheries Technical Committee. 1999. A comprehensive evaluation of an eight year program of sea lamprey control in Lake Champlain. Lake Champlain Fish and Wildlife Management Cooperative, Ray Brook, NY
34. LMC (Lake Champlain Management Conference). 1996. Opportunities for action: An evolving plan for the future of the Lake Champlain Basin. Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, VT
35. LCSC (Lake Champlain Steering Committee). 2003. Opportunities for action: An evolving plan for the future of the Lake Champlain Basin. Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, VT
36. LCSC (Lake Champlain Steering Committee). 2005. State of the lake: Lake Champlain in 2005: A snapshot for citizens. Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, VT
37. Lawson S., R. Manning. 2002. Tradeoffs among social, resource, and managerial attributes of the Denali wilderness experience: A contextual approach to normative research. Leisure Sci 24:297-312
38. Lawson S., R. Manning. 2003. Research to guide management of wilderness camping at Isle Royale National Park: part II. Prescriptive research. J Park Recreation Admin 21:22-42
39. Lee K. N. 1993. Compass and gyroscope: Integrating science and politics for the environment. Island Press, Washington, DC
40. Manning R. 1999. Indicators and standards of quality: a normative approach. In R. Manning (ed), Studies in outdoor recreation: Search and research for satisfaction. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis, pp 122-155
41. Manning R. 2001. Visitor experience and resource protection: A framework for managing the carrying capacity of national parks. J Park Recreation Admin 19:93-108
42. Manning R., S. Lawson, P. Newman, M. Budrick, W. Valliere, D. Laven, J. Bacon. 2004. Visitor perceptions of recreation-related resource impacts. In R. Buckely (ed) Environment impacts of ecotourism. CAB International, Cambridge, MA, pp 259-272
43. Manning R., S. Lawson, P. Newman, D. Laven, W. Valliere. 2002. Methodological issues in measuring crowding-related norms in outdoor recreation. Leisure Sci 24:339-348
44. Manning R., Y. Leung, M. Budruk. 2005. Research to support management of visitor carrying capacity at Boston Harbor Islands. Northeastern Naturalist 12:201-220
45. Manning R., P, Newman, W. Valliere, B. Wang, S. Lawson. 2001. Respondent self-assessment of research on crowding norms in outdoor recreation. J Leisure Res 33:251
46. Manning R., W. Valliere. 2002. Coping in outdoor recreation: Causes and consequences of crowding and conflict among community residents. J Leisure Res 33:410-426
47. Manning R., W. Valliere, B. Minteer, B. Wang, C. Jacobi. 2000. Crowding in parks and outdoor recreation: A theoretical, empirical and managerial analysis. J Park Recreation Admin 18:57-72
48. Manning R., W. Valliere, B. Wang, C. Jacobi. 1999. Crowding norms: alternative measurement approaches. Leisure Sci 21:97-115
49. Manning R., W. Valliere, B. Wang, S. Lawson, P. Newman. 2003. Estimating day use social carrying capacity in Yosemite National Park. Leisure 27:77-102
50. Manning R. E., S. R. Lawson. 2002. Carrying capacity as "informed judgement": The values of science and the science of values. Environ Manage 30:157-168
51. Manning R. E., D. W. Lime, W. A. Freimund, D. G. Pitt. 1996. Crowding norms at frontcountry sites: A visual approach to setting standards of quality. Leisure Sci 18:39-59
52. Muradian R. 2001. Ecological thresholds: a survey. Ecol Econ 38:7-24
53. Niemi G. J., M. E. McDonald. 2004. Application of ecological indicators. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 35:89-111
54. Nip M. I., H. A. Uno de Haes. 1995. Environmental auditing: ecosystem approach to environmental quality assessment. Environ Manage 19(1):135-145
55. OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 1993. Environmental indicators: OECD core set. OECD, Paris
56. Paerl H. W., R. S. Fulton, P. H. Moisander, J. Dyble. 2001. Harmful freshwater algal blooms, with an emphasis on cyanobacteria. Sci World 1:76-113
57. Paine R. T., M. J. Tegner, E. A. Johnson. 1998. Compounded perturbations yield ecological surprises. Ecosystems 1:535-545
58. Perry D. A., M. F. Amaranthus. 1997. Disturbance, recovery, and stability. In K. A. Kohm, J. F. Franklin (eds), Creating a forestry for the 21st century: The science of ecosystem management. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp 31-56
59. Raikow D. F., O. Sarnelle, A. E. Wilson, S. K. Hamilton. 2004. Dominance of the noxious cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa in low-nutrient lakes is associated with exotic zebra mussels. Limnol Oceanogr 49:482-487
60. Rapport D. J. 1992. Evolution of indicators of ecosystem health. In D. H. McKenzie, D. E. Hyatt, V. J. McDonald (eds), Ecological indicators. Vol. 1. Elsevier Applied Science, London, pp 121-134
61. Rapport D. J., W. G. Whitford. 1999. How ecosystems respond to stress. Bioscience 49:193-203
62. Rogers K., H. Biggs. 1999. Integrating indicators, endpoints and value systems in strategic management of the rivers of the Kruger National Park. Freshwater Biol 41:439-451
63. Roggenbuck J., D. Williams, S. Bange, D. Dean. 1991. River float trip encounter norms: questioning the use of the social norms concept. J Leisure Res 23:133-153
64. Schaeffer D. J., E. E. Herricks, H. W. Kerster. 1988. Ecosystem health: I. measuring ecosystem health. Environ Manage 12(4):445-455
65. Scheffer M., S. Carpenter, J. Foley, C. Folke, B. Walker. 2001. Catastrophic regime shifts in ecosystems. Nature 413:591-596
66. Scheffer M., S. H. Hosper, M. L. Meijer, B. Moss, E. Jeppesen. 1993. Alternative equilibria in shallow lakes. Trends Ecol Evol 8:275-279
67. Scheffer M., S. Rinaldi, A. Gragnani, L. C. Mur, E. H. van Ness. 1997. On the dominance of filamentous cyanobacteria in shallow, turbid lakes. Ecology 78:272-282
68. Sharpley A. N., S. C. Chapra, R. Wedepohl, J. T. Sims, T. C. Daniel, K. R. Reddy. 1994. Managing agricultural phosphorus for protection of surface waters: Issues and options. J Environ Qual 23:437-451
69. Shelby B. 1981. Encounter norms in backcountry settings: studies of three rivers. J Leisure Res 13:129-138
70. Shelby B., T. Heberlein. 1986. Carrying capacity in recreation settings. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis
71. Shelby B., J. Vaske. 1991. Using normative data to develop evaluate standards for resource management: A comment on three recent papers. J Leisure Res 23:173-187
72. Shelby B., J. Vaske, M. Donnelly. 1996. Norms, standards and natural resources. Leisure Sci 18:103-123
73. Shelby B., J. Vaske, R. Harris. 1988. User standards for ecological impacts at wilderness campsites. J Leisure Res 20:245-256
74. Smeltzer E., S. Quinn. 1996. A phosphorus budget, model, and load reduction strategy for Lake Champlain. Lake Reservoir Manage 12:381-393
75. Smith V. H. 1983. Low nitrogen to phosphorus ratios favor dominance by blue-green algae in lake phytoplankton. Science 221:669-671
76. Stankey G. H., R. N. Clark, B. T. Bormann. 2005. Adaptive management of natural resources: theory, concepts, and management institutions. Gen. Tech. Rep. PNW-GTR-654. Portland, OR. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station
77. The Heinz Center. 2002. The state of the nation's ecosystems: Measuring the lands, waters and living resources of the United States. Cambridge University Press, New York
78. US EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency). 1986. Quality criteria for water. EPA440.5-86-001. US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC
79. US GAO (US General Accounting Office). 2003. Great Lakes: An overall strategy and indicators for measuring progress are needed to better achieve restoration goals. GAO-03-515. US GAO, Washington, DC
80. US GAO (US General Accounting Office). 2004. Environmental Indicators: Better coordination is needed to develop environmental indicator sets that inform decisions. GAO-05-52. UA GAO, Washington, DC
81. Vaske J., A. Graefe, B. Shelby, T. Heberlein. 1986. Backcountry encounter norms: Theory, method, and empirical evidence. J Leisure Res 18:137-153
82. Vaske J., O. Whittaker. 2004. Normative approaches to natural resources. Society and natural resources: A summary of knowledge. Modern Liths, Jefferson, MO, pp 198-204
83. Vitousek P. 1990. Biological innovations and ecosystem processes: Towards an integration of population biology and ecosystem studies. Oikos 57:7-13
84. Walters C. J. 1986. Adaptive management of renewable resources. MacMillan, New York
85. Watzin M. C. 2004. Combining scientific data in frameworks for decision-making: Examples from two transboundary lakes (Lake Champlain, USA & Canada, and Lake Ohrid, Macedonia & Albania). In Proceedings of the conference on water observation and information systems for decision support, 25-29 May 2004, Ohrid, Macedonia. Available from www.balwois.net and through the Institute of Research for Development, Montpelier, France
86. Watzin M. C., Brines E. Miller, A. D. Shambaugh, M. K. Kreider. 2006. Application of the WHO Alert Level Framework to cyanobacteria monitoring on Lake Champlain, Vermont. Environ Toxicol 21(3):278-288
87. Watzin M. C., A. W. McIntosh. 1999. Aquatic ecosystems in agricultural landscapes: A review of ecological indicators and achievable ecological outcomes. J Soil Water Conserv Soci 54:636-644
88. Watzin M. C., R. L. Smyth, E. A. Cassell, W. C. Hession, R. Manning, D. Wang. 2005. Ecological indicators and an environmental scorecard for the Lake Champlain Basin Program. Report to the Lake Champlain Basin Program, Grand Isle, Vermont. LCBP Technical Report Series No. 46
89. Whittaker D., B. Shelby. 1988. Types of norms for recreation impact: Extending the social norms concept. J Leisure Res 20:261-273
90. Wiersma Y. F. 2005. Environmental benchmarks vs. ecological benchmarks for assessment and monitoring in Canada: Is there a difference? Environ Monit Assess 1001-1009
91. Wilhelm S. W., J. M. DeBruyn, O. Gillor, M. R. Twiss, K. Livingston, R. A. Bourbonniere, L. D. Pickell, C. G. Trick, A. L. Dean, R. M. L. McKay. 2003. Effect of phosphorus amendments on present day plankton communities in pelagic Lake Erie. Aquat Microbiol Ecol 32:275-285
92. World Health Organization. 1998. Guidelines for drinking water quality, 2nd ed. Addendum to volume 2, Health criteria and other supporting information. World Health Organization, Geneva
93. World Health Organization. 2003. In Guidelines for safe recreational water environments. Vol. 1: Coastal and fresh waters. World Health Organization, Geneva, pp 136-158