Arthroscopic compared with open repairs for recurrent anterior shoulder instability: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature

Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery

Volumn 89, Issue 2, 2007, Pages 244-254

  Lenters, Tim R ^a   Franta, Amy K ^b   Wolf, Fredric M ^a   Leopold, Seth S ^a   Matsen III, Frederick A ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

^b Aspen Orthopaedic and Rehabilitation   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTHROSCOPIC SURGERY; ARTICLE; CLINICAL TRIAL; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; META ANALYSIS; ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RECURRENT SHOULDER DISLOCATION; REOPERATION; RISK ASSESSMENT; SHOULDER DISLOCATION; SURGICAL APPROACH; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 33846807499     PISSN: 00219355     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2106/JBJS.E.01139     Document Type: Article

References (69)

1. Rowe CR, Patel D, Southmayd WW. The Bankart procedure: a long-term end-result study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1978;60:1-16.
2. Altchek DW, Warren RF, Skyhar MJ, Ortiz G. T-plasty modification of the Bankart procedure for multidirectional instability of the anterior and inferior types. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1991;73:105-12.
3. Bigliani LU, Kurzweil PR, Schwartzbach CC, Wolfe IN, Flatow EL. Inferior capsular shift procedure for anterior-inferior shoulder instability in athletes. Am J Sports Med. 1994;22:578-84.
4. Bigliani LU. Open instability repairs: still the gold standard? In: Orthopedics Today NY CME Course. New York: Orthopedics Today; 2004 Nov 14.
5. Jobe FW, Giangarra CE, Kvitne RS, Glousman RE. Anterior capsulolabral reconstruction of the shoulder in athletes in overhand sports. Am J Sports Med. 1991;19:428-34.
6. Levine WN, Richmond JC, Donaldson WR. Use of the suture anchor in open Bankart reconstruction. A follow-up report. Am J Sports Med. 1994;22:723-6.
7. Richmond JC, Donaldson WR, Fu F, Harner CD. Modification of the Bankart reconstruction with a suture anchor. Report of a new technique. Am J Sports Med. 1991;19:343-6.
8. Matsen FA 3rd, Titelman RM, Lippitt SB, Rockwood CA Jr, Wirth MA. Glenohumeral instability. In: Rockwood CA Jr, Matsen FA 3rd, Wirth MA, Lippitt SB, editors. The shoulder. 3rd ed, vol 2. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2004. p 655-794.
9. Warner JJ, Johnson D, Miller M, Caborn DN. Technique for selecting capsular tightness in repair of anterior-inferior shoulder instability. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1995;4:352-64.
10. Thomas SC, Matsen FA 3rd. An approach to the repair of avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments in the management of traumatic anterior glenohumeral instability. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1989;71:506-13.
11. Warme WJ, Arciero RA, Savoie FH 3rd, Uhorchak JM, Walton M. Nonabsorbable versus absorbable suture anchors for open Bankart repair. A prospective, randomized comparison. Am J Sports Med. 1999;27:742-6.
12. Gill TJ, Micheli LJ, Gebhard F, Binder C. Bankart repair for anterior instability of the shoulder. Long-term outcome. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1997;79:850-7.
13. Jolles BM, Pelet S, Farron A. Traumatic recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder: two- to four-year follow-up of an anatomic open procedure. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2004;13:30-4.
14. Pagnani MJ, Dome DC. Surgical treatment of traumatic anterior shoulder instability in American football players. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2002;84:711-5.
15. Uhorchak JM, Arciero RA, Huggard D, Taylor DC. Recurrent shoulder instability after open reconstruction in athletes involved in collision and contact sports. Am J Sports Med. 2000;28:794-9.
16. Gross RM. Arthroscopic shoulder capsulorraphy: does it work? Am J Sports Med. 1989;17:495-500.
17. O'Neill DB. Arthroscopic Bankart repair of anterior detachments of the glenoid labrum. A prospective study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1999;81:1357-66.
18. Torchia ME, Caspari RB, Asselmeier MA, Beach WR, Gayari M. Arthroscopic transglenoid multiple suture repair: 2 to 8 year results in 150 shoulders. Arthroscopy. 1997;13:609-19.
19. Speer KP, Warren RF, Pagnani M, Warner JJ. An arthroscopic technique for anterior stabilization of the shoulder with a bioabsorbable tack. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1996;78:1801-7.
20. Bacilla P, Field LD, Savoie FH 3rd. Arthroscopic Bankart repair in a high demand patient population. Arthroscopy. 1997;13:51-60.
21. Barber FA, Snyder SJ, Abrams JS, Fanelli GC, Savoie FH 3rd. Arthroscopic Bankart reconstruction with a bioabsorbable anchor. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2003;12:535-8.
22. Wolf EM. Arthroscopic capsulolabral repair using suture anchors. Orthop Clin North Am. 1993;24:59-69.
23. Freedman KB, Smith AR Romeo AA, Cole BJ, Bach BR Jr. Open Bankart repair versus arthroscopic repair with transglenoid sutures or bioabsorbable tacks for recurrent anterior instability of the shoulder: a meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2004;32:1520-7.
24. Mohtadi NG, Bitar IJ, Sasyniuk TM, Hollinshead RM, Harper WP. Arthroscopic versus open repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability: a meta-analysis. Arthroscopy. 2005;21:652-8.
25. DerSimonian R, Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials. 1986;7:177-88.
26. Hasselblad V, Hedges LV. Meta-analysis of screening and diagnostic tests. Psychol Bull. 1995;117:167-78.
27. Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ. 1997;315:629-34.
28. Altman DG. Confidence intervals for the number needed to treat. BMJ. 1998;317:1309-12.
29. Armstrong A, Boyer D, Ditsios K, Yamaguchi K. Arthroscopic versus open treatment of anterior shoulder instability. Instr Course Lect. 2004;53:559-63.
30. Cole BJ, Millett PJ, Romeo AA, Burkhart SS, Andrews JR, Dugas JR, Warner JJ. Arthroscopic treatment of anterior glenohumeral instability: indications and techniques. Instr Course Lect. 2004;53:545-58.
31. Cole BJ, Warner JJ. Arthroscopic versus open Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability. Clin Sports Med. 2000;19:19-48.
32. Gartsman GM, Roddey TS, Hammerman SM. Arthroscopic treatment of anterior-inferior glenohumeral instability. Two to five-year follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82:991-1003.
33. Ioannidis JP, Haidich AB, Pappa M, Pantazis N, Kokori SI, Tektonidou MG, Contopoulos-Ioannidis DG, Lau J. Comparison of evidence of treatment effects in randomized and nonrandomized studies. JAMA. 2001;286:821-30.
34. PubMed. National Library of Medicine, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/ query.fcgi?db=PubMed. Accessed 2006 October 10.
35. The Cochrane Collaboration Library. http://www.cochrane.org/indexO.htm. Accessed 2006 October 10.
36. Guanche CA, Quick DC, Sodergren KM, Buss DD. Arthroscopic versus open reconstruction of the shoulder in patients with isolated Bankart lesions. Am J Sports Med. 1996;24:144-8.
37. Roberts SN, Taylor DE, Brown JN, Hayes MG, Saies A. Open and arthroscopic techniques for the treatment of traumatic anterior shoulder instability in Australian rules football players. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1999;8:403-9.
38. Sperling JW, Duncan SF, Torchia ME, O'Driscoll SW, Cofield RH. Bankart repair in patients aged fifty years or greater: results of arthroscopic and open repairs. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2005;14:111-3.
39. Review Manager (RevMan). Version 4.2 for Windows. Oxford, England: The Cochrane Collaboration; 2002. http://www.cc-ims.net/RevMan.
40. Bottoni CR, Berkowitz MJ, Smith EL, Towle RB. Arthroscopic versus open anterior shoulder stabilization: a prospective, randomized, clinical trial. Read at the Annual Open Meeting of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons; 2005 Feb 26; Washington, DC.
41. Fabbriciani C, Milano G, Demontis A, Fadda S, Ziranu F, Mulas PD. Arthroscopic versus open treatment of Bankart lesion of the shoulder: a prospective randomized study. Arthroscopy. 2004;20:456-62.
42. Steinbeck J, Jerosch J. Arthroscopic transglenoid stabilization versus open anchor suturing in traumatic anterior instability of the shoulder. Am J Sports Med. 1998;26:373-8.
43. Karlsson J, Magnusson L, Ejerhed L, Hultenheim I, Lundin O, Kartus J. Comparison of open and arthroscopic stabilization for recurrent shoulder dislocation in patients with a Bankart lesion. Am J Sports Med. 2001;29:538-42.
44. Kim SH, Ha KI, Kim SH. Bankart repair in traumatic anterior shoulder instability: open versus arthroscopic technique. Arthroscopy. 2002;18:755-63.
45. Sisto DJ, Cook DL. Intraoperative decision making in the treatment of shoulder instability. Arthroscopy. 1998;14:389-94.
46. Sperber A, Wredmark T, Hamberg P, Karlsson J, Sward L. Arthroscopic versus open Bankart operation-2-year results in a prospective randomized study. Acta Orthop Scan. 1999;284 Supp:46-7.
47. Jorgensen U, Svend-Hansen H, Bak K, Pedersen I. Recurrent post-traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation - open versus arthroscopic repair. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1999;7:118-24.
48. Tomlinson G, Beyene J. Imputing summary statistics for meta-analysis of continuous data. Read at the Twelfth Annual Cochrane Colloquium; 2004 Oct 2-6; Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. http://www.cochrane.org/colloquia/abstracts/ottawa/P- 148.htm.
49. Geiger DF, Hurley JA, Tovey JA, Rao JP. Results of arthroscopic versus open Bankart suture repair. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1997;337:111-7.
50. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ. 2003;327:557-60.
51. Egger M, Smith GD, Altman DG, editors. Systematic reviews in health care: meta-analysis in context. 2nd ed. London: BMJ; 2001. p 189-94.
52. Green MR, Christensen KP. Arthroscopic versus open Bankart procedures: a comparison of early morbidity and complications. Arthroscopy. 1993;9:371-4.
53. Hubbell JD, Ahmad S, Bezenoff LS, Fond J, Pettrone FA. Comparison of shoulder stabilization using arthroscopic transglenoid sutures versus open capsulolabral repairs: a 5-year minimum follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2004;32:650-4.
54. Sperber A, Hamberg P, Karlsson J, Sward L, Wredmark T. Comparison of an arthroscopic and an open procedure for posttraumatic instability of the shoulder: a prospective, randomized multicenter study. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2001;10:105-8.
55. Weber SC, Kauffman JI. Arthroscopic suture anchor versus open Bankart repair in traumatic glenohumeral instability. Read at the Annual Open Meeting of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons; 2005 Feb 26; Washington, DC.
56. Kartus J, Ejerhed L, Funck E, Kohler K, Sernert N, Karlsson J. Arthroscopic and open shoulder stabilization using absorbable implants. A clinical and radiographic comparison of two methods. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1998;6:181-8.
57. David HG, Misan D, Sandow MJ. Bankart repair using a suture anchor: a comparison between an arthroscopic and open technique. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1996;78(Supp II and III):129.
58. Field L, Savoie F, Griffith P. A comparison of open and arthroscopic Bankart repai. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1999;8:195.
59. Mauch C, Wetzel R, Puhl W. Operative treatment of traumatic unidirectional instability of the shoulder joint: a comparison of four different surgical strategies. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1997;79(Supp II):255.
60. Mozes G, Agar G, Arbel R. The results of open reconstructive surgery and arthroscopic Bankart repair for recurrent anterior dislocations of the shoulder. A comparative study on 206 shoulders. Read at the Biennial Congress of the International Society of Arthroscopy, Knee Surgery and Orthopaedic Sports Medicine; 2001 May 15; Montreux, Switzerland.
61. Bhandari M, Swiontkowski MF, Einhorn TA, Tornetta P 3rd, Schemitsch EH, Leece P, Sprague S, Wright JG. Interobserver agreement in the application of levels of evidence to scientific papers in the American volume of the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004;86:1717-20.
62. Leopold SS, Warme WJ, Fritz Braunlich E, Shott S. Association between funding source and study outcome in orthopaedic research. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2003;415:293-301.
63. Manta JP, Organ S, Nirschl RP, Pettrone FA. Arthroscopic transglenoid suture capsulolabral repair. Five-year followup. Am J Sports Med. 1997;25:614-8.
64. Hayashida K, Yoneda M, Nakagawa S, Okamura K, Fukushima S. Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability: analysis of the causes of a recurrence. Arthroscopy. 1998;14:295-301.
65. Kandziora F, Jager A, Bischof F, Herresthal J, Starker M, Mittlmeier T. Arthroscopic labrum refixation for post-traumatic anterior shoulder instability: suture anchor versus transglenoid fixation technique. Arthroscopy. 2000;16:359-66.
66. De Mulder K, Marynissen H, Van Laere C, Lagae K, Declercq G. Arthroscopic transglenoid suture of Bankart lesions. Acta Orthop Belg. 1998;64:160-6.
67. Burkhart SS, De Beer JF. Traumatic glenohumeral bone defects and their relationship to failure of arthroscopic Bankart repairs: significance of the invertedpear glenoid and the humeral engaging Hill-Sachs lesion. Arthroscopy. 2000;16:677-94.
68. Itoi E, Lee SB, Berglund LJ, Berge LL, An KN. The effect of a glenoid defect on anteroinferior stability of the shoulder after Bankart repair: a cadaveric study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82:35-46.
69. Koss S, Richmond JC, Woodward JS Jr. Two- to five-year followup of arthroscopic Bankart reconstruction using a suture anchor technique. Am J Sports Med. 1997;25:809-12.