Arthroscopic versus open repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability: A meta-analysis

Arthroscopy - Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Volumn 21, Issue 6, 2005, Pages 652-658

  Mohtadi, Nicholas G H ^a   Bitar, Ivan J ^b   Sasyniuk, Treny M ^a   Hollinshead, Robert M ^a   Harper, Wade P ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY   (Canada)

^b Sanatorio Allende   (Argentina)

^c PRINCE OF WALES HOSPITAL   (Australia)

Author keywords

Arthroscopic repair; Open repair; Recurrent traumatic shoulder instability

Indexed keywords

ARTHROSCOPIC SURGERY; CASE CONTROL STUDY; CLINICAL TRIAL; COHORT ANALYSIS; CONFIDENCE INTERVAL; HUMAN; LANGUAGE; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; RECURRENT SHOULDER DISLOCATION; REOPERATION; REVIEW; RISK; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 20344368796     PISSN: 07498063     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2005.02.021     Document Type: Article

References (62)

1. A. Bankart Recurrent or habitual dislocation of the shoulder Joint BMJ 2 1923 1132 1133
2. A. Bankart The pathology and treatment of recurrent dislocation of the shoulder joint Br J Surg 26 1938 23 29
3. J. Dickson, M. Devas Bankart's operation for recurrent dislocation of the shoulder J Bone Joint Surg Br 39 1957 114 119
4. L. Bigliani, P. Kurzweil, C. Schwartzbach Inferior capsular shift procedure for anterior-inferior shoulder instability in athletes Am J Sports Med 10 1994 187 197
5. C. Rowe, D. Patel, W. Southmayd The Bankart procedure A long-term end result study J Bone Joint Surg Am 60 1978 1 16
6. J.K. Weaver, R.S. Derkash Don't forget the Bristow-Latarjet procedure Clin Orthop 308 1994 102 110
7. W.G. Braly, H.S. Tullos A modification of the Bristow procedure for recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation and subluxation Am J Sports Med 13 1985 81 86
8. S.R. Head, B. Grimberg, J. Chesar, M. Soudry [Magnuson-Stack operation for chronic anterior shoulder instability.] Harefuah 130 1996 300 304 358 Hebrew
9. W.D. Regan Jr, S. Webster-Bogaert, R.J. Hawkins, P.J. Fowler Comparative functional analysis of the Bristow, Magnuson-Stack, and Putti-Platt procedures for recurrent dislocation of the shoulder Am J Sports Med 17 1989 42 48
10. J. Karlsson, U. Jarvholm, L. Sward, O. Lansing Repair of Bankart lesions with a suture anchor in recurrent dislocation of the shoulder Scand J Med Sci Sports 5 1995 170 174
11. W. Levine, J. Richmond, W. Donaldson Use of suture anchor in open Bankart reconstruction A follow-up report Am J Sports Med 22 1994 723 726
12. B.F. Morrey, J.M. Janes Recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder. Long-term follow-up of the Putti-Platt and Bankart procedures J Bone Joint Surg Am 58 1976 252 256
13. J.P. Rao, A.M. Francis, J. Hurley, R. Daczkewycz Treatment of recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder by duToit Staple capsulorrhaphy. Results of long-term follow-up study Clin Orthop 204 1986 169 176
14. C. Baker, J.W. Uribe, C. Whitman Arthroscopic evaluation of acute initial anterior shoulder dislocations Am J Sport Med 18 1990 25 28
15. B. Hinterman, A. Gachter Arthroscopic findings after shoulder dislocation Am J Sports Med 23 1996 545 551
16. R. Norlin Intraarticular pathology in acute, first-time anterior shoulder dislocation. An arthroscopic study Arthroscopy 9 1993 546 549
17. D.C. Taylor, R.A. Arciero Pathologic changes associated with shoulder dislocations. Arthroscopic and physical examination findings in first-time, traumatic anterior dislocations Am J Sports Med 25 1997 306 311
18. K. Speer, R. Warren, M. Pagnani An arthroscopic technique for anterior stabilization of the shoulder with a bioabsorbable tack J Bone Joint Surg Am 78 1996 1801 1807
19. R. Arciero, J. Wheeler, J. Ryan, J. McBride Arthroscopic Bankart repair versus nonoperative treatment for acute initial anterior shoulder dislocations Am J Sports Med 22 1994 589 594
20. R. Caspari Arthroscopic reconstruction for anterior shoulder instability Tech Orthop 3 1998 59 66
21. P. Bacilla, L. Field, F. Savoie Arthroscopic Bankart repair in a high demand patient population Arthroscopy 13 1997 51 60
22. K. Benedetto, W. Glotzer Arthroscopic Bankart procedure by suture technique Indication, techniques, and results Arthroscopy 8 1992 111 115
23. J. Belzer, J. Synder Arthroscopic capsulorrhaphy for traumatic anterior shoulder instability using suture anchors and nonabsorbable suture Arthroscopy 11 1995 359
24. L. Coughlin, M. Rubinovich, J. Johansson, B. White, J. Greenspoon Arthroscopic staple capsulorrhaphy for anterior shoulder instability Am J Sports Med 20 1992 253 256
25. S. Fealy, M.C. Drakos, A.A. Allen, R.F. Warren Arthroscopic Bankart repair Experience with an absorbable, transfixing implant Clin Orthop 390 2001 31 41
26. B.J. Goldberg, R.P. Nirschl, J.P. McConnell, F.A. Pettrone Arthroscopic transglenoid suture capsulolabral repairs Preliminary results Am J Sports Med 21 1993 656 665
27. W. Grana, P. Buckley, C. Yates Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair Am J Sports Med 21 1993 348 353
28. R. Hawkins Arthroscopic stapling repair for shoulder instability A retrospective study of 50 cases Arthroscopy 5 1989 122 128
29. F. Hoffman, G. Reif Arthroscopic shoulder stabilization using Mitek anchors Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 3 1995 50 54
30. A. Kirkley, S. Griffin, C. Richards, A. Miniaci, N. Mohtadi Prospective randomized clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of immediate arthroscopic stabilization versus immobilization and rehabilitation in first traumatic anterior dislocations of the shoulder Arthroscopy 15 1999 507 514
31. F. Landsiedl Arthroscopic therapy of recurrent anterior luxation of the shoulder by capsular repair Arthroscopy 8 1992 269 304
32. J.G. Lane, R.A. Sachs, B. Riehl Arthroscopic staple capsulorrhaphy A long-term follow-up Arthroscopy 9 1993 190 194
33. C. Lauencin, S. Stephens, R. Warren Arthroscopic Bankart repair using a degradable tack Clin Orthop 332 1996 132 137
34. M. Marcacci, S. Zaffagnini, A. Petitto Arthroscopic management of recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder Analysis of technical modifications on the Caspari procedure Arthroscopy 12 1996 144 149
35. L. Matthews, W. Vetter, S. Oweida Arthroscopic staple capsulorrhaphy for recurrent anterior shoulder instability Arthroscopy 4 1988 106 111
36. C. Morgan, A. Bodenstab Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair. Technique and early results Arthroscopy 3 1987 111 112
37. M. Pagnani, R. Warren, D. Altchek Arthroscopic shoulder stabilization using transglenoid sutures A four year minimum follow-up Am J Sports Med 24 1996 459 467
38. W.R. Post Percutaneous tensioning of the glenohumeral ligaments during arthroscopic Bankart repair Arthroscopy 12 1996 116 119
39. H. Resch, H.F. Wykypiel, H. Maurer, M. Wambacher The antero-inferior (transmuscular) approach for arthroscopic repair of the Bankart lesion An anatomic and clinical study Arthros-copy 12 1996 309 322
40. H. Resch [Current aspects in the arthroscopic treatment of shoulder instability.] Orthopade 20 1991 273 281 German
41. H. Resch, P. Povacz, M. Wambacher, G. Sperner, K. Golser Arthroscopic extra-articular Bankart repair for the treatment of recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation Arthroscopy 13 1997 188 200
42. D.J. Rose Arthroscopic transglenoid suture capsulorrhaphy for anterior shoulder instability Instr Course Lect 45 1996 57 64
43. K. Speer, R. Warren Arthroscopic shoulder stabilization A role of biodegradable materials Clin Orthop 291 1993 67 74
44. G. Walch, P. Boileau, C. Levigne Arthroscopic stabilization for recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation Result of 59 cases Arthroscopy 11 1995 173 179
45. J. Warner, X. Deng, R. Warren Arthroscopic Bankart repair utilizing a cannulated absorbable fixation device Orthop Trans 14 1991 761 762
46. J.A. Youssef, C.F. Carr, C.E. Walther, J.M. Murphy Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair for recurrent traumatic unidirectional anterior shoulder dislocations Arthroscopy 11 1995 561 563
47. B.J. Cole, J.J. Warner Arthroscopic versus open Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability Clin Sports Med 19 2000 19 48
48. B.J. Cole, J. L'Insalata, J. Irrgang, J.J. Warner Comparison of arthroscopic and open anterior shoulder stabilization. A two to six-year follow-up study J Bone Joint Surg Am 82 2000 1108 1114
49. M. Green, K. Christensen Magnetic resonance imaging of the glenoid labrum MR imaging of 88 arthroscopically confirmed cases Am J Sports Med 22 1994 493 498
50. C. Guanche, D. Quick, K. Sodergen Arthroscopic versus open reconstruction of the shoulder with isolated Bankart lesions Am J Sports Med 24 1996 144 148
51. D. Geiger, J. Hurley, J. Tovey, J. Rao Results of arthroscopic versus open Bankart suture repair Clin Orthop Rel Res 337 1997 111 117
52. L. Field, F. Savoie, P. Griffith A comparison of open and arthroscopic Bankart repair J Shoulder Elbow Surg 8 1999 195 (abstr)
53. J. Steinbeck, J. Jerosch Arthroscopic transglenoid stabilization versus open anchor suturing in traumatic anterior instability of the shoulder Am J Sports Med 26 1998 373 378
54. W. Meeuwisee Interpretation of research-KNES 490. Chap 5 1998-99 University of Calgary Calgary, AB, Canada
55. Canadian Task Force on the Periodic Health Examination Recommendations by strength of evidence clinical preventative health care 1994 Canada Communication Group Ottawa, ON, Canada vii-xxxvii
56. S.H. Kim, K.I. Ha Bankart repair in traumatic anterior shoulder instability Open versus arthroscopic technique Arthroscopy 18 2002 755 763
57. J. Karlsson, L. Magnusson, L. Ejerhed, I. Hultenheim, O. Lundin, J. Kartus Comparison of open and arthroscopic stabilization for recurrent shoulder dislocation in patients with a Bankart lesion Am J Sports Med 29 2001 538 542
58. S. Roberts, D. Taylor, J. Brown, M. Hayes, A. Saies Open and arthroscopic techniques for the treatment of traumatic anterior shoulder instability in Australian rules football players J Shoulder Elbow Surg 8 1999 403 409
59. A. Sperber, P. Hamberg, J. Karlsson, L. Sward, T. Wredmark Comparison of an arthroscopic and an open procedure for posttraumatic instability of the shoulder A prospective, randomized multicenter study J Shoulder Elbow Surg 10 2001 105 108
60. U. Jorgensen, H. Svend-Hansen, K. Bak, I. Pedersen Recurrent post-traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation-open versus arthroscopic repair Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 7 1999 118 124
61. J. Kartus, L. Ejerhed, E. Funck, K. Kohler, N. Sernert, J. Karlsson Arthroscopic and open shoulder stabilization using absorbable implants. A clinical and radiographic comparison of two methods Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 6 1998 181 188
62. S. Weber A prospective evaluation comparing arthroscopic and open treatment in the management of recurrent anterior glenohumeral dislocation Orthop Trans 15 1991 763