A comparison of outcomes resulting from generalist vs specialist care for a single discrete medical condition: A systematic review and methodologic critique

Archives of Internal Medicine

Volumn 167, Issue 1, 2007, Pages 10-20

  Smetana, Gerald W ^a   Landon, Bruce E ^a   Bindman, Andrew B ^b   Burstin, Helen ^c   Davis, Roger B ^a   Tjia, Jennifer ^d   Rich, Eugene C ^e  

^a HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^c AGENCY FOR HEALTHCARE RESEARCH AND QUALITY   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA   (United States)

^e CREIGHTON UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL COMPETENCE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; GENERAL PRACTICE; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HUMAN; MEDICINE; REPRODUCIBILITY; REVIEW; STANDARD;

CLINICAL COMPETENCE; FAMILY PRACTICE; HUMANS; QUALITY OF HEALTH CARE; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SPECIALTIES, MEDICAL;

EID: 33846080763     PISSN: 00039926     EISSN: 15383679     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1001/archinte.167.1.10     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. Ayanian JZ, Guadagnoli E, McNeil BJ, Cleary PD. Treatment and outcomes of acute myocardial infarction among patients of cardiologists and generalist physicians. Arch Intern Med. 1997;157:2570-2576.
2. Chin MH, Friedmann PD, Cassel CK, Lang RM. Differences in generalist and specialist physicians' knowledge and use of angiotensinconverting enzyme inhibitors for congestive heart failure. J Gen Intern Med. 1997;12:523-530.
3. Jollis JG, DeLong ER, Peterson ED, et al. Outcome of acute myocardial infarction according to the specialty of the admitting physician. N Engl J Med. 1996;335:1880-1887.
4. Go AS, Rao RK, Dauterman KW, Massie BM. A systematic review of the effects of physician specialty on the treatment of coronary disease and heart failure in the United States. Am J Med. 2000;108:216-226.
5. Harrold LR, Field TS, Gurwitz JH. Knowledge, patterns of care, and outcomes of care for generalists and specialists. J Gen Intern Med. 1999;14:499-511.
6. Landon BE, Wilson IB, McInnes K, et al. Physician specialization and the quality of care for human immunodeficiency virus infection. Arch Intern Med. 2005;165:1133-1139.
7. Landon BE, Wilson IB, Cohn SE, et al. Physician specialization and antiretroviral therapy for HIV. J Gen Intern Med. 2003;18:233-241.
8. Landon BE, Wilson IB, Wenger N, et al. Specialty training and specialization among physicians who treat HIV/AIDS in the United States. J Gen Intern Med. 2002;17:12-22.
9. Katz JN, Solomon DH, Schaffer JL, Horsky J, Burdick E, Bates DW. Outcomes of care and resource utilization among patients with knee or shoulder disorders treated by general internists, rheumatologists, or orthopedic surgeons. Am J Med. 2000;108:28-35.
10. Rose JH, O'Toole EE, Dawson NV, et al; SUPPORT Investigators. Generalists and oncologists show similar care practices and outcomes for hospitalized late-stage cancer patients. Med Care. 2000;38:1103-1118.
11. Starfield B, Shi L, Grover A, Macinko J. The effects of specialist supply on populations' health: assessing the evidence. Health Aff (Millwood). January-June 2005(suppl Web exclusives):W5-97-W5-107.
12. Starfield B, Shi L, Macinko J. Contribution of primary care to health systems and health. Milbank Q. 2005;83:457-502.
13. Starfield B. Primary care and health: a cross-national comparison. JAMA. 1991;266:2268-2271.
14. Macinko J, Starfield B, Shi L. The contribution of primary care systems to health outcomes within Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries, 1970-1998. Health Serv Res. 2003;38:831-865.
15. Shi L, Macinko J, Starfield B, Politzer R, Wulu J, Xu J. Primary care, social inequalities, and allcause, heart disease, and cancer mortality in US counties, 1990. Am J Public Health. 2005;95:674-680.
16. Keating NL, Zaslavsky AM, Ayanian JZ. Physicians' reports of focused expertise in clinical practice. J Gen Intern Med. 2000;15:417-420.
17. Garrett N, Yasnoff W. Disseminating public health practice guidelines in electronic medical record systems. J Public Health Manag Pract. 2002;8:1-10.
18. Burton LC, Anderson GF, Kues IW. Using electronic health records to help coordinate care. Milbank Q. 2004;82:457-481.
19. Sequist TD, Gandhi TK, Karson AS, et al. A randomized trial of electronic clinical reminders to improve quality of care for diabetes and coronary artery disease. J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2005;12:431-437.
20. Sakakibara M, Kongoji K, Samejima H, et al. Specialty-related disparities of readmission in patients with chronic heart failure: the importance of hospital-clinic cooperation. Intern Med. 1999;38:705-709.
21. Chen J, Radford M, Wang Y, Krumholz H. Care and outcomes of elderly patients with acute myocardial infarction by physician specialty: the effects of comorbidity and functional limitations. Am J Med. 2000;108:460-469.
22. Foody JM, Rathore SS, Wang Y, et al. Predictors of cardiologist care for older patients hospitalized for heart failure. Am Heart J. 2004;147:66-73.
23. Wolff JL, Starfield B, Anderson G. Prevalence, expenditures, and complications of multiple chronic conditions in the elderly. Arch Intern Med. 2002;162:2269-2276.
24. Braunstein JB, Anderson GF, Gerstenblith G, et al. Noncardiac comorbidity increases preventable hospitalizations and mortality among Medicare beneficiaries with chronic heart failure. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2003;42:1226-1233.
25. Donabedian A. Evaluating the quality of medical care. Milbank Mem Fund Q. 1966;44(suppl):166-206.
26. Institute of Medicine. Primary Care: America's Health in a New Era. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1996.
27. Iezzoni LI. Risk Adjustment for Measuring Health Care Outcomes. 3rd ed. Chicago, Ill: Health Administration Press; 2003.
28. McFall SL, Warnecke RB, Kaluzny AD, Aitken M, Ford L. Physician and practice characteristics associated with judgments about breast cancer treatment. Med Care. 1994;32:106-117.
29. Taplin SH, Taylor V, Montano D, Chinn R, Urban N. Specialty differences and the ordering of screening mammography by primary care physicians. J Am Board Fam Pract. 1994;7:375-386.
30. Finison KS, Wellins CA, Wennberg DE, Lucas FL. Screening mammography rates by specialty of the usual care physician. Eff Clin Pract. 1999;2:120-125.
31. Stafford RS, Blumenthal D, Pasternak RC. Variations in cholesterol management practices of US physicians. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1997;29:139-146.
32. Thorndike AN, Rigotti NA, Stafford RS, Singer DE. National patterns in the treatment of smokers by physicians. JAMA. 1998;279:604-608.
33. Edep ME, Shah NB, Tateo IM, Massie BM. Differences between primary care physicians and cardiologists in management of congestive heart failure: relation to practice guidelines. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1997;30:518-526.
34. Reis SE, Holubkov R, Edmundowicz D, et al. Treatment of patients admitted to the hospital with congestive heart failure: specialty-related disparities in practice patterns and outcomes. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1997;30:733-738.
35. Chin MH, Wang JC, Zhang JX, Lang RM. Utilization and dosing of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors for heart failure: effect of physician specialty and patient characteristics. J Gen Intern Med. 1997;12:563-566.
36. Croft JB, Giles WH, Roegner RH, Anda RF, Casper ML, Livengood JR. Pharmacologic management of heart failure among older adults by office-based physicians in the United States. J Fam Pract. 1997;44:382-390.
37. Cujec B, Quan H, Jin Y, Johnson D. Association between physician specialty and volumes of treated patients and mortality among patients hospitalized for newly diagnosed heart failure. Am J Med. 2005;118:35-44.
38. Regueiro CR, Hamel MB, Davis RB, Desbiens N, Connors AF, Phillips RS. A comparison of generalist and pulmonologist care for patients hospitalized with severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: resource intensity, hospital costs, and survival. Am J Med. 1998;105:366-372.
39. Ayanian JZ, Hauptman PJ, Guadagnoli E, Antman EM, Pashos CL, McNeil BJ. Knowledge and practices of generalist and specialist physicians regarding drug therapy for acute myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med. 1994;331:1136-1142.
40. Borowsky SJ, Kravitz RL, Laouri M, et al. Effect of physician specialty on use of necessary coronary angiography. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1995;26:1484-1491.
41. Schreiber TL, Elkhatib A, Grines CL, O'Neill WW. Cardiologist versus internist management of patients with unstable angina: patterns and outcomes. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1995;26:577-582.
42. Friedmann PD, Brett AS, Mayo-Smith MF. Differences in generalists' and cardiologists' perceptions of cardiovascular risk and the outcomes of preventive therapy in cardiovascular disease. Ann Intern Med. 1996;124:414-421.
43. Stein JH, Uretz EF, Parrillo JE, Barron JT. Cost and appropriateness of radionuclide exercise stress testing by cardiologists and non-cardiologists. Am J Cardiol. 1996;77:139-142.
44. Whyte JJ, Filly AL, Jollis JG. Treatment of hyperlipidemia by specialists versus generalists as secondary prevention of coronary artery disease. Am J Cardiol. 1997;80:1345-1347.
45. Stafford RS, Blumenthal D. Specialty differences in cardiovascular disease prevention practices. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1998;32:1238-1243.
46. Frances CD, Go AS, Dauterman KW, et al. Outcome following acute myocardial infarction: are differences among physician specialties the result of quality of care or case mix? Arch Intern Med. 1999;159:1429-1436.
47. Nash IS, Corrato RR, Dlutowski MJ, O'Connor JP, Nash DB. Generalist versus specialist care for acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardiol. 1999;83:650-654.
48. Norcini JJ, Kimball HR, Lipner RS. Certification and specialization: do they matter in the outcome of acute myocardial infarction? Acad Med. 2000;75:1193-1198.
49. Gottwik M, Zahn R, Schiele R, et al. Differences in treatment and outcome of patients with acute myocardial infarction admitted to hospitals with compared to without departments of cardiology; results from the pooled data of the Maximal Individual Therapy in Acute Myocardial Infarction (MITRA 1 + 2) Registries and the Myocardial Infarction Registry (MIR). Eur Heart J. 2001;22:1794-1801.
50. Fehrenbach SN, Budnitz DS, Gazmararian JA, Krumholz HM. Physician characteristics and the initiation of beta-adrenergic blocking agent therapy after acute myocardial infarction in amanaged care population. Am J Manag Care. 2001;7:717-723.
51. Majumdar SR, Inui TS, Gurwitz JH, Gillman MW, McLaughlin TJ, Soumerai SB. Influence of physician specialty on adoption and relinquishment of calcium channel blockers and other treatments for myocardial infarction. J Gen Intern Med. 2001;16:351-359.
52. Ayanian JZ, Landrum MB, Guadagnoli E, Gaccione P. Specialty of ambulatory care physicians and mortality among elderly patients after myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med. 2002;347:1678-1686.
53. Tiemeier H, de Vries WJ, van het Loo M, et al. Guideline adherence rates and interprofessional variation in a vignette study of depression. Qual Saf Health Care. 2002;11:214-218.
54. Diabetes Integrated Care Team. Integrated care for diabetes: clinical, psychosocial, and economic evaluation. BMJ. 1994;308:1208-1212.
55. Greenfield S, Rogers W, Mangotich M, Carney MF, Tarlov AR. Outcomes of patients with hypertension and non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus treated by different systems and specialties: results from the medical outcomes study. JAMA. 1995;274:1436-1444.
56. Ho M, Marger M, Beart J, Yip I, Shekelle P. Is the quality of diabetes care better in a diabetes clinic or in a general medicine clinic? Diabetes Care. 1997;20:472-475.
57. Zgibor JC, Songer TJ, Kelsey SF, et al. The association of diabetes specialist care with health care practices and glycemic control in patients with type 1 diabetes: a cross-sectional analysis from the Pittsburgh epidemiology of diabetes complications study. Diabetes Care. 2000;23:472-476.
58. Chin MH, Zhang JX, Merrell K. Specialty differences in the care of older patients with diabetes. Med Care. 2000;38:131-140.
59. Zgibor JC, Songer TJ, Kelsey SF, Drash AL, Orchard TJ. Influence of health care providers on the development of diabetes complications. Diabetes Care. 2002;25:1584-1590.
60. Fendrick AM, Hirth RA, Chernew ME. Differences between generalist and specialist physicians regarding Helicobacter pylori and peptic ulcer disease. Am J Gastroenterol. 1996;91:1544-1548.
61. Turner BJ, McKee L, Fanning T, Markson LE. AIDS specialist versus generalist ambulatory care for advanced HIV infection and impact on hospital use. Med Care. 1994;32:902-916.
62. Keitz SA, Box TL, Homan RK, Bartlett JA, Oddone EZ. Primary care for patients infected with human immunodeficiency virus: a randomized controlled trial. J Gen Intern Med. 2001;16:573-582.
63. Stone VE, Mansourati FF, Poses RM, Mayer KH. Relation of physician specialty and HIV/AIDS experience to choice of guideline-recommended antiretroviral therapy. J Gen Intern Med. 2001;16:360-368.
64. Wilson IB, Landon BE, Ding L, et al. A national study of the relationship of care site HIV specialization to early adoption of highly active antiretroviral therapy. Med Care. 2005;43:12-20.
65. Huse DM, Roht LH, Alpert JS, Hartz SC. Physicians' knowledge, attitudes, and practice of pharmacologic treatment of hypertension. Ann Pharmacother. 2001;35:1173-1179.
66. Ren XS, Kazis LE, Lee A, Zhang H, Miller DR. Identifying patient and physician characteristics that affect compliance with antihypertensive medications. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2002;27:47-56.
67. Nichol KL, Zimmerman R. Generalist and subspecialist physicians' knowledge, attitudes, and practices regarding influenza and pneumococcal vaccinations for elderly and other high-risk patients: a nationwide survey. Arch Intern Med. 2001;161:2702-2708.
68. Daniels NA, Nguyen TT, Gildengorin G, Perez-Stable EJ. Adult immunization in university-based primary care and specialty practices. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2004;52:1007-1012.
69. Ko CW, Kelley K, Meyer KE. Physician specialty and the outcomes and cost of admissions for endstage liver disease. Am J Gastroenterol. 2001;96:3411-3418.
70. Shipton D, Glazier RH, Guan J, Badley EM. Effects of use of specialty services on diseasemodifying antirheumatic drug use in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis in an insured elderly population. Med Care. 2004;42:907-913.
71. Sumartojo EM, Geiter LJ, Miller B, Hale BE. Can physicians treat tuberculosis? report on a national survey of physician practices. Am J Public Health. 1997;87:2008-2011.
72. Starr P. The Social Transformation of American Medicine. New York, NY: Basic Books; 1982.
73. Ludmerer KM. Learning to Heal: The Development of American Medical Education. Baltimore, Md: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1996.
74. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. Health at a Glance: 2001. Paris, France: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development; 2001.
75. Starfield B. Primary Care: Concept, Evaluation, and Policy. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 1992.
76. Moore G, Showstack J. Primary care medicine in crisis: toward reconstruction and renewal. Ann Intern Med. 2003;138:244-247.
77. Brennan TA, Horwitz RI, Duffy FD, Cassel CK, Goode LD, Lipner RS. The role of physician specialty board certification status in the quality movement. JAMA. 2004;292:1038-1043.
78. Mainous AG III, Hagen MD, Rich EC. Patient awareness of and attitudes toward physician board certification. J Am Board Fam Pract. 1993;6:403-406.
79. Association of American Medical Colleges. 2005 Medical School Graduation Questionnaire. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges; 2005.
80. Welch WP, Miller ME, Welch HG, Fisher ES, Wennberg JE. Geographic variation in expenditures for physicians' services in the United States. N Engl J Med. 1993;328:621-627.
81. Keating NL, Weeks JC, Landrum MB, Borbas C, Guadagnoli E. Discussion of treatment options for early-stage breast cancer: effect of provider specialty on type of surgery and satisfaction. Med Care. 2001;39:681-691.
82. Burstin HR, Conn A, Setnik G, et al. Benchmarking and quality improvement: the Harvard Emergency Department Quality Study. Am J Med. 1999; 107:437-449.
83. Rich EC, Kralewski J, Feldman R, Dowd B, Bernhardt TS. Variations in the management of primary care: effect on cost in an HMO network. Arch Intern Med. 1998;158:2363-2371.
84. Schmittdiel J, McMenamin SB, Halpin HA, et al. The use of patient and physician reminders for preventive services: results from a National Study of Physician Organizations. Prev Med. 2004;39:1000-1006.
85. Kaissi A, Kralewski J, Curoe A, Dowd B, Silversmith J. How does the culture of medical group practices influence the types of programs used to assure quality of care? Health Care Manage Rev. 2004;29:129-138.
86. Kralewski JE, Dowd BE, Heaton A, Kaissi A. The influence of the structure and culture of medical group practices on prescription drug errors. Med Care. 2005;43:817-825.
87. Kralewski JE, Rich EC, Feldman R, et al. The effects of medical group practice and physician payment methods on costs of care. Health Serv Res. 2000;35:591-613.
88. Casalino LP. Disease management and the organization of physician practice. JAMA. 2005;293:485-488.
89. Shortell SM, Schmittdiel J, Wang MC, et al. An empirical assessment of high-performing medical groups: results from a national study. Med Care Res Rev. 2005;62:407-434.
90. Forrest CB, Starfield B. Entry into primary care and continuity: the effects of access. Am J Public Health. 1998;88:1330-1336.
91. Shi L, Starfield B, Politzer R, Regan J. Primary care, self-rated health, and reductions in social disparities in health. Health Serv Res. 2002;37:529-550.
92. Starfield B, Shi L. Policy relevant determinants of health: an international perspective. Health Policy. 2002;60:201-218.
93. American College of Physicians. The Impending Collapse of Primary Care Medicine and its Implications for the State of the Nation's Health Care. Philadelphia, Pa: American College of Physicians; 2006.
94. Yarnall KS, Pollak KI, Ostbye T, Krause KM, Michener JL. Primary care: is there enough time for prevention? Am J Public Health. 2003;93:635-641.
95. Ostbye T, Yarnall KS, Krause KM, Pollak KI, Gradison M, Michener JL. Is there time for management of patients with chronic diseases in primary care? Ann Fam Med. 2005;3:209-214.
96. Rich EC, Burke W, Heaton CJ, et al. Reconsidering the family history in primary care. J Gen Intern Med. 2004;19:273-280.
97. The Kaiser Family Foundation, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Harvard Schoolof Public Health. National Survey on Consumers' Experiences With Patient Safety and Quality Information. Menlo Park, Calif: Kaiser Family Foundation; Rockville, Md: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality; Boston, Mass: Harvard School of Public Health; 2005.
98. Schoen C, Osborn R, Huynh PT, et al. Taking the pulse of health care systems: experiences of patients with health problems in six countries [published online ahead of print November 3, 2005]. Health Aff (Millwood). doi:10.1377/hlthaff.w5.509..
99. Wolff JL, Boult C. Moving beyond round pegs and square holes: restructuring Medicare to improve chronic care. Ann Intern Med. 2005;143:439-445.