A review on hydropower plant models and control

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews

Volumn 11, Issue 5, 2007, Pages 776-796

  Kishor, Nand ^a   Saini, R P ^a   Singh, S P ^b  

^a INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE   (India)

^b INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE   (India)

Author keywords

Control approach; Hydroturbine; Modeling; Nonlinear

Indexed keywords

DAMPING; LARGE SCALE SYSTEMS; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; MULTIVARIABLE SYSTEMS; OSCILLATIONS; TURBINES;

COMPLEX NONLINEAR SYSTEMS; CONTROL COMMUNITY; HYDROTURBINES; PLANT MODELING;

HYDROELECTRIC POWER PLANTS;

EID: 33751410643     PISSN: 13640321     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.rser.2005.06.003     Document Type: Review

References (111)

1. Zongshu S., Chengang Z., and Wenyuan F. Water-hammer pressure compensation in turbine regulating systems. Water Power & Dam Construction 9 (1986) 25-28
2. Ramey D.G., and Skooglund J.W. Detailed hydro governor representation for system stability studies. IEEE Trans on Power Apparatus and Systems 89 (1970) 106-112
3. Vournas C.D., and Zaharakis A. Hydro turbine transfer functions with hydraulic coupling. IEEE Trans on Energy Conversion 8 (1993) 527-532
4. Hannett L.N., Feltes J.W., Fardanesh B., and Crean W. Modeling and control tuning of a hydro station with units sharing a common penstock section. IEEE Trans on Power Systems 14 (1999) 1407-1414
5. Hovey L.M. Optimum adjustment of hydro governors on Manitoba hydro system. AIEE Trans Power Apparatus and Systems 81 (1962) 581-587
6. Blair P., and Wozniak L. Non-linear simulation of hydraulic turbine governor system. Water Power and Dam Construction (1976)
7. Vournas C.D. Second order hydraulic turbine models for multimachine stability studies. IEEE Trans on Energy Conversion 5 (1990) 239-244
8. Sanathanan C.K. Accurate low order model for hydraulic turbine-penstock. IEEE Trans on Energy Conversion 2 (1987) 196-200
9. Sanathanan C.K. A Frequency domain method for tuning hydro governors. IEEE Trans on Energy Conversion 3 (1988) 14-17
10. Dandeno P.L., Kundur P., and Bayne J.P. Hydraulic unit dynamic performance under normal and islanding conditions-analysis and validation. IEEE Trans 97 (1978) 2134-2143
11. Tripathy S.C. Digital governor for use in computer control of a generating unit. Energy Conv Mgmt 39 (1998) 973-983
12. Luqing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., Zhaohui L.I., Malik O.P., and Hope G.S. Field tests and operation of a duplicate multiprocessor-based governor for water turbine and its further development. IEEE Trans on Energy Conv 5 (1990) 225-231
13. Oldenburger R., and Donelson Jr. J. Dynamic response of a hydroelectric plant. AIEE Trans on Power Appar Syst 81 (1962) 403-419
14. Undrill J., and Woodward J. Nonlinear hydro governing model and improved calculation for determining temporary droop. IEEE Trans on Power Appar Syst 86 (1967) 228-233
15. IEEE Committee. Dynamic models for steam and hydro turbines in power system studies. IEEE Trans on Power Appar Syst 92 (1973) 1904-1915
16. IEEE Working Group. Hydraulic turbine and turbine control models for system dynamic studies. IEEE Trans on Power Syst 7 (1992) 167-179
17. Luqing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., Malik O.P., and Hope G.S. Variable and time varying parameter control for hydroelectric generating unit. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 4 (1989) 293-299
18. Wozniak L. A graphical approach to hydrogenerator tuning. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 5 (1990) 417-421
19. Malik O.P., Hope G.S., Hancock G., Zhaohui L., Luqing Y.E., and Shouping W.E.I. Frequency measurement for use with a microprocessor-based water turbine governor. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1991) 361-366
20. Vournas C.D. Second order hydraulic turbine models for multimachine stability studies. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 5 (1990) 239-244
21. Kundur P. Power system stability and control (1994), Mc Graw-Hill, New York
22. Fangtong Xu, Yonghua Li, Qijuan C. Study of the modeling of hydroturbine generating set. In: International IEEE/IAS Conference on Industrial Automation and Control: Emerging Technologies, 22-27 May, 1995. p. 644-647.
23. Qijuan C, Zhihuai Xiao. Dynamic modeling of hydroturbine generating set. In: IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, 8-11 Oct. 2000. p. 3427-3430.
24. Chang J, Bingwen Liu, Cai W. Nonlinear simulation of hydro turbine governing system based on neural network. In: IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, Cybernetics, 1996. p. 784-787.
25. Vournas C.D., and Zaharakis A. Hydro turbine transfer functions with hydraulic coupling. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 8 (1993) 527-532
26. Hannet L., Fardanesh B., and Feltes J. Field tests to validate hydro turbine-governor model structure and parameters. IEEE Trans Power Syst 9 (1994) 1744-1751
27. De Jaeger E., Janssens N., Malfliet B., and De Meulebroeke F.V. Hydro turbine model for system dynamic studies. IEEE Trans on Power Systems 9 (1994) 1709-1715
28. Hannet L., Feltes J., Fardanesh B., and Crean W. Modeling and control tuning of a hydro station with units sharing a common penstock section. IEEE Trans on Power Systems 14 (1999) 1407-1414
29. Mahmoud M., Dutton K., and Denman M. Dynamic modeling and simulation of a cascaded reservoirs hydropower plant. Electric Power Syst Research 70 (2004) 129-139
30. Sourja Jr. O.H., Barbieri N., and Santos A.H.M. Study of hydraulic transient in hydropower plants through simulation of nonlinear model of penstock and hydraulic turbine model. IEEE Trans Power Syst 14 (1999) 1269-1272
31. Paynter H.M. A palimpsest on the electronic analog art. A. Philbrick Researches, Inc (1955), Mass, Boston
32. Leum M. The development and field excitation of a transistor electric governor for hydro turbines. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 85 (1966) 750-756
33. Chaudhry M.H. Governing stability of a hydroelectric power plant. Water Power (1970) 131-136
34. Agnew P.W. The governing of Francis turbines. Water Power (1974) 119-127
35. Hagihara S., Yokota H., Goda K., and Isobe K. Stability of a hydraulic turbine-generating unit controlled by PID governor. IEEE Trans Power Apparatus and Systems 98 (1979) 2294-2298
36. Phi D.T., Bourque E.J., Thorne D.H., and Hill E.F. Analysis and application of the stability limits of a hydro-generating unit. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 100 (1981) 3203-3212
37. Findlay D., Davie H., Foord T.R., Marshall A.G., and Winning D.J. Microprocessor based adaptive water turbine governor. Inst Elect Engg C 127 (1980) 360-369
38. Kopacek P., and Zauner E. Governing turbines by microcomputer. Int Water Power Dam Constr 34 (1982) 26-30
39. Murthy M.S.R., and Hariharan M.V. Analysis and improvement of the stability of a hydro turbine generating unit with long penstock. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 102 (1983)
40. Wozniak L., and Bitz D.J. Load-level-sensitive gains for speed control of hydro generators. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 3 (1988) 78-84
41. Murphy L.D., Wozniak L., and Whittemore T.A. A digital governor for hydro generators. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 3 (1988) 780-784
42. Elits L.E., and Schleif F.R. Governing features and performance of the first 600 MW hydrogenating unit at Grand Coulee. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 96 (1977) 457-466
43. Wozniak L., and Filbert T.L. Speed loop cancellation governors for hydro generators Part I- Development. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 3 (1988) 85-90
44. Filbert T.L., and Wozniak L. Speed loop cancellation governors for hydro generators Part II- Application. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 3 (1988) 85-90
45. Kamwa I, Lefebvre D, Loud L. Small signal analysis of hydro-turbine governors in large interconnected power plants. In: Power Engg Society Winter meeting IEEE, 2002 p. 1178-1183.
46. Thorne D.H., and Hill E.F. Field testing and simulation of hydraulic turbine governor performance. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 92 (1973) 1183-1191
47. Dhaliwal N.S., and Wichert H.E. Analysis of PID governors in multimachine system. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 97 (1978) 456-463
48. Taha TS. Digital model for eigenvalue analysis of PID speed-controlled hydro power systems. In: Annual Pittsburg Cong. on Model Simulation, 10, part-3, 1979. pp. 1025-1029.
49. Arnautovic D., and Milijanovic R. An approach to the analysis of large perturbations in hydro-electric plants with Kaplan turbines. Electric Power Syst Res 9 (1985) 115-121
50. Clifton L. Optimal governing of reaction turbines. Water Power Dam Const (1988) 22-28
51. Clifton L. Optimal governing of high head turbines. Water Power Dam Constr (1989) 46-50
52. Orelind G., Wozniak L., Medanic J., and Whittemore T. Optimal PID gain schedule for hydro generators-Design and Application. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 4 (1989) 300-307
53. Luquing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., Haibo X.U., Malik O.P., and Hope G.S. Variable structure and the time-varying parameter control for hydroelectric generating unit. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 4 (1989) 293-299
54. Malik O.P., Hope G.S., Luquing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., and Haibo X.U. An intelligent self-improving control strategy with a variable structure and time-varying parameters for water turbine. Reveu General de l'Electricite 4 (1989) 23-35
55. Herron J., and Wozniak L. A state space pressure and speed sensing governor for hydro generators. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1991) 414-418
56. Arnautovic D.B., and Skataric D.M. Sub optimal design of hydro turbine governors. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1991) 438-444
57. Schniter P., and Wozniak L. Efficiency based optimal control of Kaplan hydro generators. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 10 (1995) 348-353
58. Luqing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., Zhaohui L.I., Malik O.P., Hope G.S., and Hancock G.C. An intelligent self-improving control strategy and its microprocessor-based implementation to a hydro-turbine governing system. Can J Elect Comp Eng 15 (1990) 130-138
59. Zhaohui L.I., Luqing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., Malik O.P., Hope G.S., et al. Field tests with a prototype duplicate microprocessor-based governor for a hydro-turbine. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1991) 349-355
60. Zhaohui L.I., Luqing Y.E., Shouping W.E.I., Malik O.P., Hope G.S., et al. Fault tolerance aspects of a highly reliable microprocessor-based water turbine governor. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 7 (1992) 1-7
61. Zhaohui L.I., and Malik O.P. An orthogonal test approach based control parameter optimization and its application to a hydro-turbine governor. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 12 (1997) 388-393
62. Lim C.M. A self-tuning stabilizer for excitation or governor control of power systems. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 4 (1989) 152-159
63. ∞ governor/exciter controller design for a power system. In: 1st IEEE Conference on Control Applications, vol 2, 1992. p.770-775.
64. Jiang J. Design of an optimal robust governor for hydraulic turbine generating units. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 10 (1995) 188-194
65. Malik O.P., and Zeng Y. Design of a robust adaptive controller for a water turbine governing system. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 10 (1995) 354-359
66. Siljak D.D., and Stipanovic D.M. Robust decentralized turbine/governor control using linear matrix inequalities. IEEE Trans Power Syst 17 (2002) 715-722
67. Lansberry J.E., and Wozniak L. Optimal hydro generator governor tuning with a genetic algorithm. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 7 (1992) 623-630
68. Lansberry J.E., and Wozniak L. Adaptive hydrogenerator governor tuning with a genetic algorithm. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 9 (1994) 179-183
69. Yamamoto T, Kanedam M, Oki T, Watanbe E, Tanaka K. Intelligent tuning of PID controllers. In: IEEE Conference on Intelligent Systems for 21st Century, Proceedings of Systems, Man and Cybernetics, vol. 3, 1995. pp. 2610-2615.
70. Cheng Y-C, Ye Lu-Q, Chuang Fu, Cai W-Y. Anthropormorphic intelligent PID control and its application in the hydro turbine governor. In: 1st International Conference on Machine Learning and Cybernetics, vol. 1, 2002. pp. 391-395.
71. Djukanovi M., Novicevic M., Dobrijevic D.J., Babic B., Sobajic D.J., and Pao Y- H. Neural-net based coordinated stabilizing control for the exciter and governor loops of low head hydropower plants. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 10 (1995) 760-767
72. Djukanovic M.B., Calovic M.S., Vesovic B.V., and Sobajic D.J. Neuro-fuzzy controller of low head power plants using adaptive-network based fuzzy inference system. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 12 (1997) 375-381
73. Djukanovic M.B., Dobrijevic D.M., Caovic M.S., Novicevic M., and Sobajic D.J. Coordinated-stabilizing control for the exciter and governor loops using fuzzy set theory and neural nets. Elect Power Energy Syst 19 (1997) 489-499
74. Chen G-Da, Cai W-You, Xu H-Ke, Huang M-Hua. The application of intelligent integral realized by fuzzy logic for hydroturbine governing system. In: 1st International Conference on Machine Learning and Cybernetics, vol. 2, 2002. pp. 674-678.
75. Garcez JN, Garcez AR. A connectionist approach to hydro turbine speed control parameters tuning using artificial neural network. In: 38th Midwest Symposium on Circuits and Systems, vol. 2, 1995. pp. 641-644.
76. Zhang Z. Huo Z, Xiao Z. PID control with fuzzy compensation for hydroelectric generating unit. In: International Conference on Power System Technology, vol. 4, 2002. pp. 2348-2352.
77. Jing L., Ye L., Malik O.P., and Zeng Y. An intelligent discontinuous control strategy for hydroelectric generating unit. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 13 (1998) 84-89
78. Sun Y, Sun Y, Lu Q, Shao Y. Nonlinear decentralized robust governor control for hydro turbine-generator sets of multi-machine system. In: 3rd World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation, vol. 1, 2000. pp. 45-52.
79. Watanabe T. Robust decentralized turbine-governor control subject to saturation nonlinearity. In: American Control Conference, 2002. pp. 948-1953.
80. Chang J, Bingwen L, Cai W. Nonlinear simulation of hydro turbine governing system based on neural network. In: IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, Cybernetics, vol. 1, 1996. pp. 784-787.
81. Eker İ, Aydin İŞ. Governors for hydroturbines: new control schemes and robust designs. In: 36th Universities Power Engg Conf (UPEC'2001), Power generation Part-3A, 2001.
82. Eker İ, Aydin İŞ. Robust cascade design of governors. In: 36th Universities Power Engineering Conference (UPEC'2001), Power generation Part-3A, 2001.
83. Eker İ, Aydin İŞ. Design of multi-loop multivariable cascade hydro governors. In: 36th Universities Power Engineering Conference (UPEC'2001), Power generation Part-3A, 2001.
84. Eker İ, Aydin İŞ. Design and performance requirements for improved governor control. In: 4th International Energy Congress (ITEC-2001), 2001.
85. Eker I., and Tumay M. Robust multivariable-cascade governors for hydroturbine controls. Elect Engg 84 (2002) 229-237
86. Eker İ. Hydro-turbine models for robust governor designs in hydro-power generation. In: 2nd International Conference on Responsive Manufacturing, 2002. pp. 609-613.
87. Eker I. The design of robust multi-loop cascaded hydro governors. Eng Comput 20 (2004) 45-53
88. Eker I. Governors for hydro-turbine speed control in power generation: a SIMO robust design approach. Energy Conv Mgmt 45 (2004) 2207-2221
89. Wozniak L. Determining hydro generating system stability and performance. Int Water Power Dam Constr 43 (1991) 25-30
90. Dobrijevic D.M., and Jankovic M.V. An approach to the damping of local modes of oscillations resulting from large hydraulic transients. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 14 (1999) 754-759
91. Jones D.I. Multivariable control analysis of a hydro turbine. Trans. on Instrumentation MC 21 2/3 (1999) 122-136
92. Mansoor SP, Jones DI, Bradley, DA, Aris FC, Jones, GR. Stability of a pumped storage hydro-power station connected to a power system. In: IEEE Power Society Meeting, New York, 1999. pp. 646-650.
93. Mansoor SP, Jones DI, Bradley DA, Aris FC, Jones GR. Development of a black-start regime for a pumped storage hydro station. In: 4th IASTED International Conference on Power and Energy Systems, 1999. pp. 588-593.
94. Mansoor S.P. Modelling and simulation of a hydro-power station, Ph.D. thesis (2000), University of Wales, Bangor
95. Mansoor S.P., Jones D.I., Bradley D.A., Aris F.C., and Jones G.R. Reproducing oscillatory behavior of a hydroelectric power station by computer simulation. Control Eng Pract 8 (2000) 1261-1272
96. King DJ, Bradley DA, Mansoor SP, Jones DI, Aris FC, Jones GR. Using a fuzzy inference system to control a pumped storage hydro plant. In: 10th IEEE Conference on Fuzzy Systems, vol. 3, 2001. pp. 1008-1011.
97. Mansoor S.P., Jones D.I., Bradley D.A., Aris F.C., and Jones G.R. Hardware-in-the-loop simulation of a pumped storage hydro station. Int J Power Energy Syst 23 (2003) 127-133
98. Jones D., Mansoor S.P., Aris F.C., Jones G.R., Bradley D.A., and King D.J. A standard method for specifying the response of hydroelectric plant in frequency-control model. Elect Power Syst Res 69 (2004) 19-32
99. Jones D., and Mansoor S.P. Predictive feedforward control for a hydroelectric plant. IEEE Trans Control Syst Technol 12 (2004) 956-965
100. Lindenmeyer D., Moshref A., Schaeffer C., and Benge A. Simulation of a start-up of a hydro power plant for the emergency power supply of a nuclear power station. IEEE Trans Power Syst 16 (2001) 2001
101. Dai J.J., Xiao D., Shokooh F., Schaeffer C., and Benge A. Emergency generator startup study of a hydro turbine unit for a nuclear generation facility. IEEE Trans Industry Appl 40 (2004) 1191-1199
102. Doan R.E., and Natarajan K. Modeling and control design for governing hydroelectric turbines with leaky wicket gates. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 19 (2004) 449-455
103. Konidaris D.N., and Tegupoulos J.A. Investigation of oscillatory problems of hydraulic generating units equipped with Francis turbine. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 12 (1997) 419-425
104. Blommaert G, Prenat J-E, Avellan F, Boyer A. Active control of Francis turbine operation stability. In: 3rd ASME/JSME Joint Fluids Engineering Conference 1999. pp. 1-8.
105. Nicolet C, Sapin A, Prenat J-E, Simond J-J, Avellan F. A new tool for the simulation of dynamic begavoiur of hydroelectric power plants. In: 10th International Meeting of the Work Group on The Behavior of Hydraulic Machinery under Steady Oscillatory Conditions, 2001. pp. 1-12.
106. Nicolet C, Avellan F, Allenbach P, Sapin A, Simond J-J, Kvicinsky S, et al. Simulation of transient phenomenon in Francis turbine power plants: hydroelectric interaction. In: Waterpower XIII, 2003.
107. Erikson R. Maximum stew-rate governor control for Impulse turbines. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1999) 419-425
108. Wozniak L., Collier F., and Foster J. Digital simulation of an impulse turbine: The Bradley Lake project. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1991) 39-46
109. Collier F., and Wozniak L. Control synthesis for an impulse turbine: The Bradley Lake project. IEEE Trans Energy Conv 6 (1991) 639-648
110. Johnson RM, Chow JH, Hickey B. Pelton turbine deflector control designs for Bradley Lake hydro units. In: American Control Conference 2002. pp. 4855-4860.
111. Johnson R.M., Chow J.H., and Dillon M.V. Pelton turbine deflector overspeed control for a small power system. IEEE Trans Power Syst 19 (2004) 1032-1037