Overcoming theory-practice inconsistencies: Critical realism and information systems research

Information and Organization

Volumn 16, Issue 3, 2006, Pages 191-211

  Smith, Matthew Longshore ^a  

^a LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Causality; Critical realism; Determinism; Generative mechanism; Interpretivism; Positivism; Social construction of technology

Indexed keywords

EID: 33746773121     PISSN: 14717727     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.infoandorg.2005.10.003     Document Type: Article

References (118)

1. Angell I.O., and Ilharco F.M. Solution is the problem: a story of transitions and opportunities. In: Avgerou C., Ciborra C., and Land F. (Eds). The social study of information and communication technology: innovation, actors, and contexts (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford 38-61
2. In: Archer M., Bhaskar R., Collier A., Lawson T., and Norrie A. (Eds). Critical realism: essential readings (1998), Routledge, London
3. Archer M.S. Realist social theory: the morphogenetic approach (1995), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
4. Archer M.S. Being human: the problem of agency (2000), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
5. Archer M.S. Realism and the problem of agency. Journal of Critical Realism (incorporating Alethia) 5 1 (2002) 11-20
6. Avgerou C. Information systems: what sort of science is it?. Omega 28 5 (2000) 567-579
7. Avgerou C. Information systems and global diversity (2002), Oxford University Press
8. Avgerou C., Ciborra C., and Land F. Introduction. In: Avgerou C., Ciborra C., and Land F. (Eds). The social study of information and communication technology: innovation, actors, and contexts (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford 1-14
9. Avgerou C., and Madon S. Framing IS studies: understanding the social context of IS innovation. In: Avgerou C., Ciborra C., and Land F. (Eds). The social study of information and communication technology: innovation, actors, and contexts (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford 162-182
10. Avgerou C., and Walsham G. Introduction: IT in developing countries. In: Avgerou C., and Walsham G. (Eds). Information technology in context: studies from the perspective of developing countries (2000), Ashgate Publishing Ltd, London
11. Baroudi J.J., and Orlikoswki W.J. The problem of statistical power in MIS research. MIS Quarterly 13 1 (1989) 87-106
12. Befani B. The mechanisms of suicide: a realist approach. International Review of Sociology 1 1 (2005) 51-75
13. Bhaskar R. A realist theory of science. second ed. (1978), The Harvester Press Limited, Sussex
14. Bhaskar R. Philosophy and scientific realism. In: Archer M., Bhaskar R., Collier A., Lawson T., and Norrie A. (Eds). Critical realism: essential readings (1998), Routledge, London 16-47
15. Bhaskar R. The possibility of naturalism: a philosophical critique of the contemporary human sciences. third ed. (1998), Routledge, London
16. Bhaskar R. From science to emancipation: alienation and the actuality of enlightenment (2002), Sage Publications India Pvt Ltd., Delhi
17. Bijker W.E. Understanding technological culture. In: Cutcliffe S.H., and Mitcham C. (Eds). Visions of STS: counterpoints in science, technology, and society studies (2001), State University of New York Press, Albany 19-34
18. Bunge M. How does it work? The search for explanatory mechanisms. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34 2 (2004) 182-210
19. Carlsson S.A. Advancing information systems evaluation (research): a critical realist approach. Electronic Journal of Information Systems Evaluation 6 2 (2003) 11-20
20. In: Carter B., and New C. (Eds). Making realism work: realist social theory and empirical research (2004), Routledge, Oxfordshire
21. Cartwright N. How the laws of physics lie (1983), Clarendon Press, Oxford
22. Cartwright N. Nature's capacities and their measurement (1989), Clarendon Press, Oxford
23. Cartwright N. From causation to explanation and back. In: Leiter B. (Ed). The future for philosophy (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford 230-245
24. Ciborra C. The labyrinths of information: challenging the wisdom of systems (2002), Oxford University Press, Oxford
25. Ciborra, C., & associates. (2000). From control to drift. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
26. Crotty M. The foundations of social research: meaning and perspective in the research process (1998), Sage Publications, London
27. Danermark B., Ekstrom M., Jokobsen L., and Karlsson J.C. Explaining society: critical realism in the social sciences (2003), Routledge, London
28. Dobson, P. J. (1999, 1-3 December). Approaches to theory use in interpretive case studies - a critical realist perspective. Paper presented at the Australasian Conference on Information System, Wellington, New Zealand.
29. Dobson P.J. Critical realism and information systems research: why bother with philosophy. Information Research 7 2 (2002)
30. Dreyfus H.L. Between man and nature. The Harvard Review of Philosophy 1 1 (1991) 6-19
31. Eisenhardt K.M. Building theories from case study research. The Academy of Management Review 14 4 (1989) 532-550
32. Elster J. Nuts and bolts for the social sciences (1989), Cambridge University Press, New York
33. Fay B. General laws and explaining human behaviour. In: Martin M., and McIntyre L.C. (Eds). Readings in the philosophy of social science (1994), The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts 91-110
34. Fitzgerald B., and Howcroft D. Towards dissolution of the IS research debate: from polarisation to polarity. Journal of Information Technology 13 4 (1998) 313-326
35. Fitzgerald G. Evaluating information systems projects: a multidimensional approach. Journal of Information Technology 13 1 (1998) 15-27
36. Fleetwood S. Causal laws, functional relations and tendencies. Review of Political Economy 13 (2001) 201-220
37. In: Fleetwood S., and Ackroyd S. (Eds). Critical realist applications in organisation and management studies (2004), Routledge, London
38. George A.L., and Bennett A. Case studies and theory development in the social sciences (2005), MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts
39. Groff R. Critical realism, post-positivism and the possibility of knowledge (2004), Routledge, London
40. Guba E.G., and Lincoln Y.S. Fourth generation evaluation (1989), Sage, Newbury Park, CA.
41. Hacking I. The social construction of what? (1999), Harvard University Press, Cambridge
42. Hedström P., and Swedberg R. Social mechanisms: an introductory essay. In: Hedström P., and Swedberg R. (Eds). Social mechanisms: an analytical approach to social theory (1998), Cambridge University Press, New York 1-31
43. Hempel C. Philosophy of natural science (1966), Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River
44. Hernes G. Real virtuality. In: Hedström P., and Swedberg R. (Eds). Social mechanisms: an analytical approach to social theory (1998), Cambridge University Press, New York 74-101
45. Hirschheim R.A. Information systems epistemology: an historical perspective. In: Fitzgerald G., Hirschheim R., Mumford E., and Wood-Harper A.T. (Eds). Information systems research: issues, methods and practical guidelines (1985), Elsevier Science Publishers, Amsterdam 13-38
46. Houston S. Beyond social constructionism: critical realism and social work. British Journal of Social Work 31 6 (2001) 845-861
47. Hunt S.D. Truth in marketing theory and research. Journal of Marketing 54 3 (1990) 1-15
48. Hunt S.D. For truth and realism in management research. Journal of Management Inquiry 14 2 (2005) 127-138
49. Introna L.D., and Nissenbaum H. Shaping the web: why the politics of search engines matters. The Information Society 16 3 (2000) 169-185
50. Kallinikos, J. (2002, 15-18 December, 2002). Reopening the black box of technology artifacts and human agency. Paper presented at the Twenty-Third International Conference on Information Systems, Barcelona.
51. Kallinikos J. Farewell to constructivism: technology and context-embedded Action. In: Avgerou C., Ciborra C.U., and Land F.F. (Eds). The social study of information and communication technology: innovation, actors, and contexts (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford 140-161
52. Kallinikos J. The order of technology: complexity and control in a connected world. Information and Organization 15 3 (2005) 185-202
53. Kaplan B., and Duchon D. Combining qualitative and quantitative methods in information systems research: a case study. MIS Quarterly 12 4 (1988) 571-586
54. Kazi M.A.F. Realist evaluation in practice: health and social work (2003), Sage Publications, London
55. Khazanchi, D., & Munkvold, B. E. (2003, January 6-9). On the rhetoric and relevance of is research paradigms: a conceptual framework and some propositions. Paper presented at the 36th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Big Island, Hawaii.
56. KIein H.K., and Lyytinen K. The poverty of scientism in information systems. In: Mumford E., Hirschheim R., Fitzgerald G., and Wood-Harper A.T. (Eds). Research methods in information systems (1985), North Holland, Amsterdam 131-161
57. Kincaid H. Philosophical foundations of the social sciences: analyzing controversies in social research (1996), Cambridge University Press, New York
58. Klein H.K. Seeking the new and the critical in critical realism: deja vu?. Information and Organization 14 2 (2004) 133-144
59. Latour B. Pandora's hope (1999), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass
60. Latour B. On using ANT for studying information systems - a (somewhat) socratic dialog. In: Avgerou C., Ciborra C., and Land F. (Eds). Social study of ICT (2004), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
61. Lawson, C. (2004, Aug. 17-19). Technology, technological determinism and the transformational model of technical activity. Paper presented at the The 2004 Annual Conference of the International Association for Critical Realism, Girton College, Cambridge.
62. Lawson, T. (1998). Economic science without experimentation/abstraction. In M. Archer, R. Bhaskar, A. Collier, T. Lawson, & A. Norrie, (Eds.), Critical realism: essential readings (pp. 144-185). London.
63. Lee A. A scientific methodology for MIS case studies. MIS Quarterly 29 1 (1989) 33-50
64. Lee A.S. Integrating positivist and interpretive approaches to organizational research. Organization Science 2 4 (1991) 342-365
65. Lee A.S. Thinking about social theory and philosophy for IS. In: Mingers J., and Willcocks L.P. (Eds). Social theory and philosophy for information systems (2004), John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Sussex 1-26
66. Lee A.S., and Baskerville R.L. Generalizing generalizability in information systems research. Information Systems Research 14 3 (2003) 221-243
67. Lee B., Barua A., and Whinston A.B. Discovery and representation of causal relationships in MIS research: a methodological framework. MIS Quarterly 21 1 (1997) 109-136
68. Lewis P. Realism, causality and the problem of social structure. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 30 3 (2000) 249-268
69. Maxwell G. The ontological status of theoretical entities. In: Curd M., and Cover J.A. (Eds). Philosophy of science: the central issues. first ed. (1998), W.W. Norton & Company, New York 1052-1063
70. Maxwell J.A. Causal explanation, qualitative research, and scientific inquiry in education. Educational Researcher 33 2 (2004) 3-11
71. Mayntz R. Mechanisms in the analysis of social macro-phenomena. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34 2 (2004) 237-259
72. Meckler M., and Baillie J. The truth about social construction in administrative science. Journal of Management Inquiry 12 3 (2003) 273-284
73. Miles M.B., and Huberman A.M. Qualitative data analysis. second ed. (1994), SAGE Publications, Inc., Thousand Oaks
74. Mingers J. The contribution of critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for OR/MS and systems. Journal of Operational Research Society 51 111 (2000) 1256-1270
75. Mingers J. Critical realism and information systems: brief responses to Monod and Klein. Information and Organization 14 2 (2004) 145-153
76. Mingers J. Paradigm wars: ceasefire announced who will set up the new administration?. Journal of Information Technology 19 3 (2004) 165-171
77. Mingers J. Realizing information systems: critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for information systems. Information and Organization 14 2 (2004) 87-103
78. Mingers J. Re-establishing the real: critical realism and information systems. In: Mingers J., and Willcocks L.P. (Eds). Social Theory and Philosophy for Information Systems 372-406 (2004), John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Sussex
79. Mingers J., and Brocklesby J. Multimethodology: towards a framework for mixing methodologies. Omega 25 5 (1997) 489-509
80. Niiniluoto I. Critical scientific realism (2002), Oxford University Press, Inc., New York
81. Nissen H.-E. Acquiring knowledge of information systems: research in a methodological quagmire. In: Fitzgerald G., Hirschheim R., Mumford E., and Wood-Harper A.T. (Eds). Trevor wood-harpernformation systems research: issues, methods and practical guidelines (1985), Elsevier Science Publishers, Amsterdam 39-51
82. Orlikowski W.J. The duality of technology: rethinking the concept of technology in organizations. Organization Science 3 3 (1992) 398-427
83. Orlikowski W.J., and Baroudi J.J. Studying information technology in organizations: research approaches and assumptions. Information Systems Research 2 1 (1991) 1-28
84. Orlikowski W.J., and Iacono C.S. Research commentary: desperately seeking the "IT" in IT research - a call to theorizing the IT artifact. Information Systems Research 12 2 (2001) 121-134
85. Pawson R. Evidence-based policy: a realist perspective. In: Carter B., and New C. (Eds). Making realism work: realist social theory and empirical research (2004), Routledge, Oxfordshire 26-49
86. Pawson R., and Tilley N. Realistic evaluation (1997), SAGE publications Ltd., London
87. Pinch T.J., and Bijker W.E. The Social construction of facts and artefacts: or how the sociology of science and the sociology of technology might benefit each other. Social Studies of Science 14 3 (1984) 399-441
88. Porpora D.V. Four concepts of social structure. In: Archer M., Bhaskar R., Collier A., Lawson T., and Norrie A. (Eds). Critical realism: essential readings (1998), Routledge, London 339-355
89. Pratschke J. Realistic models? Critical realism and statistical models in the social sciences. Philosophica 71 1 (2003) 13-38
90. Psillos S. Scientific realism: how science tracks truth (1999), Routledge, London
91. Robson C. Real world research: a resource for social scientists and practitioner-researchers. second ed. (2002), Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, UK
92. Ron A. Regression analysis and the philosophy of social science. Journal of Critical Realism 1 1 (2002) 119-142
93. Sawyer R.K. Nonreductive individualism: Part I - supervenience and wild disjunction. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 32 4 (2002) 537-559
94. Sawyer R.K. Nonreductive individualism: Part II - social causation. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 33 2 (2003) 203-224
95. Sawyer R.K. The mechanisms of emergence. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 34 2 (2004) 260-282
96. Sayer A. Realism and social science (2000), SAGE Publications Ltd., London
97. Schech S. Wired for change: the links between ICTs and development discourses. Journal of International Development 14 1 (2002) 13-23
98. Searle J.R. The construction of social reality (1995), Penguin Books, London
99. Searle J.R. Mind: a brief introduction (2004), Oxford University Press, New York
100. Shadish W.R., Cook T.D., and Campbell D.T. Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference (2002), Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston
101. Stones R. Sociological reasoning: towards a past-modern sociology (1996), Macmillan Press Ltd., London
102. Stones R. Refusing the realism-structuration divide. European Journal of Social Theory 4 2 (2001) 177-197
103. Symons V., and Walsham G. The evaluation of information systems: a critique. Journal of applied systems analysis 15 (1988) 119-132
104. Townley B. Managing with modernity. Organization 9 4 (2002) 549-573
105. Tsoukas H. The validity of idiographic research explanations. Academy of Management Review 14 4 (1989) 551-561
106. Walsham G. Interpreting information systems in organizations (1993), John Wiley & Sons, West Sussex
107. Walsham G. The emergence of interpretivism in IS research. Information Systems Research 6 4 (1995) 376-394
108. Walsham G. Interpretative case studies in IS research: nature and method. European Journal of Information Systems 4 2 (1995) 74-81
109. Walsham G. Research methodologies for information systems in the development context: a tutorial. In: Krishna S., and Madon S. (Eds). The digital challenge: technology in the development context (2003), Ashgate, Aldershot 83-89
110. Weber R. Editor's comments: theoretically speaking. MIS Quarterly 27 3 (2003) iii-xiii
111. Weber R. Editors comments: the rhetoric of positivism versus interpretivism: a personal view. MIS Quarterly 28 1 (2004) iii-xiii
112. Williams M. Interpretivism and generalisation. Sociology 34 2 (2000) 209-224
113. Willmott R. Reclaiming metaphysical truth for educational research. British Journal of Educational Studies 50 3 (2002) 339-362
114. Winner L. Do artefacts have politics. In: Winner L. (Ed). The whale and the reactor: a search for limits in an age of high technology (1986), University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL 19-39
115. Winner L. Where technological determinism went. In: Cutcliffe S.H., and Mitcham C. (Eds). Visions of STS: counterpoints in science, technology, and society studies (2001), State University of New York Press, Albany 11-17
116. Woolgar S., and Grint K. Computers and the transformation of social analysis. Science, Technology & Human Values 16 3 (1991) 368-378
117. Yin R.K. Case study research: design and methods. third ed. 5 (2003), Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks
118. Zinkhan G.M., and Hirschheim R. Truth in marketing theory and research: an alternative perspective. Journal of Marketing 56 2 (1992) 80-88