35 years of studies on business failure: An overview of the classic statistical methodologies and their related problems

British Accounting Review

Volumn 38, Issue 1, 2006, Pages 63-93

  Balcaen, Sofie ^a   Ooghe, Hubert ^b  

^a GHENT UNIVERSITY   (Belgium)

^b VLERICK BUSINESS SCHOOL   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Business failure; Failure prediction models; Overview; Problem topics

Indexed keywords

EID: 33144462955     PISSN: 08908389     EISSN: 10958347     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bar.2005.09.001     Document Type: Article

References (148)

1. E.I. Altman Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy The Journal of Finance 23 4 1968 589-609
2. E.I. Altman The success of business failure prediction models - An international survey Journal of Banking and Finance 8 1984 171-198
3. E.I. Altman R.A. Eisenbeis Financial applications of discriminant analysis: A clarification Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 1978 185-195
4. E.I. Altman P. Narayanan An international survey of business failure classification models Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments 6 2 1997 1-57
5. E.I. Altman A. Saunders Credit risk measurement: Developments over the last 20 years Journal of Banking and Finance 21 11-12 1998 1721-1742
6. E.I. Altman R.G. Haldeman P. Narayanan ZETA analysis: A new model to identify bankruptcy risk of corporations Journal of Banking and Finance 1 1 1977 29-51
7. E.I. Altman R.B. Avery R.A. Eisenbeis J.F. Sinkey Application of classification techniques in business, banking and finance 1981 JAI Press Greenwich (Connecticut)
8. E.I. Altman Y.H. Eom D.W. Kim Failure prediction: Evidence from Korea Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting 6 3 1995 230-249
9. J. Argenti Corporate Collapse: The Causes and Symptoms 1976 Mc Graw-Hill Londen
10. A.F. Atiya Bankruptcy prediction for credit risk using neural networks: a survey and new results IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 12 4 2001 929-935
11. A. Aziz G. Lawson Cash flow reporting and financial distress models: testing of hypotheses Financial Management 18 1 1989 55-63
12. A. Aziz D.C. Emanuel G.H. Lawson Bankruptcy prediction - An investigation of cash flow based models Journal of Management Studies 25 5 1988 419-437
13. Back, B., Laitinen, T., Sere, K., Van Wezel, M., 1996. Choosing bankruptcy predictors using discriminant analysis, logit analysis and genetic algorithms, Technical Report from Turku Centre for Computer Science, Report number 40, September, pp. 1-18.
14. Back,B., Laitinen, T., Hekanaho, J., Sere, K., 1997. The effect of sample size on different failure prediction methods, Technical Report from Turku Centre for Computer Science, Report number, 155, December, pp. 1-23.
15. W. Beaver Financial ratios predictors of failure. Empirical research in accounting: Selected studies 1966 Journal of Accounting Research 4 Suppl. 1967 71-111
16. W. Beaver Alternative accounting measures as predictors of failure American Accounting Association Manuscript Contest for 1967 1967 113-121
17. P. Barnes Methodological implications of non-normality distributed financial ratios Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 9 1 1982 51-62
18. P. Barnes The analysis and use of financial ratios: A review article Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 14 4 1987 449-461
19. L. Becchetti J. Sierra Bankruptcy risk and productive efficiency in manufacturing firms Journal of Banking and Finance 27 2003 2099-2120
20. J. Betts D. Belhoul The effectiveness of incorporating stability measures in company failure models Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 14 3 1987 323-334
21. Bhattacharjee, A., Higson, C., Holly, S., Kattuman, P., 2002. Macro economic instability and business exit: Determinants of failures and acquisitions of large UK firms, Cambridge Working Papers in Economics, Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge, Working paper number 0206, March.
22. Bijnen, E.J., Wijn, M.F., 1994. Corporate prediction models: Ratios or regression analysis?, Research memoranda, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Tilburg University, Paper number, 658, May, pp. 1-23.
23. J. Bilderbeek Het voorspellen van falingen. Financiële kengetallen als thermometer voor de ondernemingsdoorlichting Economisch en Sociaal Tijdschrift 32 1 1978 5-25
24. J. Bilderbeek An empirical study of the predictive ability of financial ratios in the Netherlands Zeitschrift Für Betriebswirtschaft 1979 388-407
25. Blazy, R., 2000. La faillite, éléments d'analyse économique, Préface de Pierre Morin, Paris (France): Economica.
26. M. Blum Failing company discriminant analysis Journal of Accounting Research 12 1 1974 1-25
27. D. Burgstahler I. Dichev Earnings management to avoid earnings decreases and losses Journal of Accounting and Economics 24 1 1997 99-126
28. C. Casey N. Bartczak Cash flow: It's not the bottom line Harvard Business Review 4 1984 60-66
29. P. Chalos Financial distress: A comparative study of individual, model and committee assessments Journal of Accounting Research 23 2 1985 527-543
30. Charitou, A., Trigeorgis, L., 2000. Option-based bankruptcy prediction, Paper presented at 6th Annual Real Options Confernce, Paphos, Cyprus, 4-6 July, pp. 1-25.
31. Charitou, A., Lambertides, N., 2003. Earnings management prior to bankruptcy, Working Paper, University of Cyprus, pp. 1-46.
32. A. Charitou E. Neophytou C. Charalambous Predicting corporate failure: empirical evidence for the UK European Accounting Review 13 3 2004 465-497
33. P. Cybinski The path to failure: Where are bankruptcy studies at now? Journal of Business and Management 7 1 2000 11-39
34. P. Cybinski Description. Explanation, Prediction: The Evolution of Bankruptcy Studies? Managerial Finance 27 4 2001 29-44
35. I. Dambolena S. Khoury Ratio stability and corporate failure Journal of Finance 33 4 1980 1017-1026
36. Daubie, M., Meskens, N., 2002. Business failure prediction: A review and analysis of the literature, Working Paper, Department of Productions and Operations Management, Catholic University of Mons (Belgium), pp. 1-15.
37. Davis, A.H.R., Huang, X., 2004. The stock performance of firms emerging from Chapter 11 and accidental bankruptcy, Paper presented at the FMA Meeting, New Orleans, USA, pp. 6-9 October 2004.
38. E. Deakin A discriminant analysis of predictors of business failure Journal of Accounting Research 10 1 1972 167-179
39. E. Deakin On the nature of the distribution of financial accounting ratios: Some empirical evidence The Accounting Review 51 1 1976 90-97
40. E. Deakin Business failure prediction: An empirical analysis B. Altman A. Sametz Financial crisis: Institutions and markets in a fragile environment 1977 Wiley New York 72-98
41. Declerc, M., Heins, B., Van Wymeersch, Ch. 1990. Flux financiers et prévision de faillite: Une analyse comportementale de l'entreprise, Paper presented at Colloque International sur «l'analyse financière par les flux: Mode ou modèle?», Institut d' Administration des Entreprises, Nice (France), December, pp. 1-26.
42. Declerc, M., Heins, B., Van Wymeersch, Ch., 1991. The use of value added ratios in statistical failure prediction models: Some evidence on Belgian annual accounts, Paper presented at the 1991 Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association, April 10-12 1991, Maastricht (The Netherlands), pp. 1-24.
43. M.L. DeFond J. Jiambalvo Debt covenant violation and manipulation of accruals Journal of Accounting and Economics 17 1994 145-176
44. F. Degeorge J. Patel R. Zeckhauser Earnings management to exceed thresholds Journal of Business 72 1 1999 1-33
45. A. Dimitras S. Zanakis C. Zopoudinis A survey of business failures with an emphasis on failure prediction methods and industrial applications European Journal of Operational Research 90 3 1996 487-513
46. Y. Dirickx G. Van Landeghem Statistical failure prevision problems Tijdschrift voor Economie en Management 39 4 1994 429-462
47. M. Doumpos C. Zopoudinis A multicriteria discrimination method for the prediction of financial distress: The case of Greece Multinational Finance Journal 3 2 1999 71-101
48. R. Edmister An empirical test of financial ratio analysis for small business failure prediction Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 1972 1477-1493
49. R.A. Eisenbeis Pitfalls in the application of discriminant analysis in business Journal of Finance 32 3 1977 875-900
50. M. Ezzamel C. Mar-Molinero The distributional properties of financial ratios in UK manufacturing companies Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 17 1 1990 1-29
51. J.C. Flagg G.A. Giroux C.E. Wiggins Predicting corporate bankruptcy using failing firms Review of Financial Economics 1 1 1991 67-79 (Fall)
52. J.A. Gentry P. Newbold D.T. Whitford Funds flow components, financial ratios and bankruptcy Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 14 4 1987 595-606
53. J.A. Gentry P. Newbold D.T. Whitford Classifying bankrupt firms with funds flow components Journal of Accounting Research 2 1 1985 146-160
54. J.A. Gentry P. Newbold D.T. Whitford Predicting bankruptcy: If cash flow's not the bottom line, What is? Financial Analysts Journal 41 5 1985 47-56
55. L.R. Gilbert K. Menon K.B. Schwartz Predicting bankruptcy for firms in financial distress Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 17 1 1990 161-171
56. G. Gloubos T. Grammatikos The success of bankruptcy prediction models in Greece Studies in Banking and Finance 7 1988 37-46
57. M.J. Gombola J. Ketz Note on cash flow and classification patterns of financial ratios Accounting Review 58 1 1983 105-114
58. M. Gombola M. Haskins J. Ketz D. Williams Cash flow in bankruptcy prediction Financial Management 1987 55-65
59. Gujarati Basic Econometrics Fourth Ed. 2003 McGraw-Hill London
60. G. Hall Factors distinguishing survivors from failures amongst small firms in the UK construction sector Journal of Management Studies 31 5 1994 737-760
61. Hand D.J., 2004. Marginal classifier improvement and reality, Paper presented at the Symposium on Data Mining, Ghent University (Belgium), May 2004.
62. Hayden, E., 2003. Are credit scoring models sensitive with respect to default definitions? Evidence from the Austrian Market, Dissertation Paper, Department of Business Administration, University of Vienna, Austria, pp. 1-43.
63. N.T. Hill S.E. Perry S. Andes Evaluating firms in financial distress: An event history analysis Journal of Applied Business Research 12 3 1996 60-71
64. D.W. Hosmer S. Lemeshow Applied logistic regression 1989 Wiley New York
65. S. Hsieh A note on the optimal cutoff point in bankruptcy prediction models Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 20 3 1993 457-464
66. C.G. Johnson Ratio analysis and the prediction of firm failure Journal of Finance 1970 1166-1168
67. F.L. Jones Current techniques in bankruptcy prediction Journal of Accounting Literature 6 1987 131-164
68. Joos, P., Vanhoof, K., Ooghe, H., Sierens, N. 1998b. Credit classification: A comparison of logit models and decision trees, Proceedings Notes of the Workshop on Application of Machine Learning and Data Mining in Finance, 10th European Conference on Machine Learning, April, 24, Chemnitz (Germany), pp. 59-72.
69. O.M. Joy J.O. Tollefson On the financial applications of discriminant analysis Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 10 5 1975 723-739
70. O.M. Joy J.O. Tollefson Some clarifying comments on discriminant analysis Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 1978 197-200
71. Kahya, E., Theodossiou, P., 1996. Predicting corporate financial distress: A time-series CUSUM methodology, Paper presented at the Third Annual Conference of the Multinational Finance Association, June, 1996, pp. 1-38.
72. G.V. Karels A.J. Prakash Multivariate normality and forecasting of business bankruptcy Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 14 4 1987 573-593
73. K. Keasey R. Watson The prediction of small company failure: Some behavioural evidence for the UK Accounting and Business Research 17 1986 49-57
74. K. Keasey R. Watson Non-financial symptoms and the prediction of small company failure: A test of Argenti's hypotheses Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 14 3 1987 335-354
75. K. Keasey P. McGuinness The failure of UK industrial firms for the period 1976-1984, logistic analysis and entropy measures Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 17 1 1990 119-135
76. K. Keasey R. Watson Financial distress models: A review of their usefulness British journal of Management 2 2 1991 89-102
77. K. Keasey P. McGuinness H. Short Multilogit approach to predicting corporate failure: Further analysis and the issue of signal consistency Omega International Journal of Management Science 18 1 1990 85-94
78. H.C. Koh The sensitivity of optimal cutoff points to misclassification costs of Type I and Type II errors in the going-concern prediction context Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 19 2 1992 187-197
79. P.A. Lachenbruch Discriminant Analysis 1975 Hafner Press New York
80. E.K. Laitinen Financial ratios and different failure processes Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 18 5 1991 649-673
81. E.K. Laitinen Prediction of failure of a newly founded firm Journal of Business Venturing 7 1992 323-340
82. E.K. Laitinen Financial predictors for different phases of the failure process Omega International Journal of Management Science 21 2 1993 215-228
83. E.K. Laitinen Traditional versus operating cash flow in failure prediction Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 21 2 1994 195-217
84. T. Laitinen M. Kankaanpää Comparative analysis of failure prediction methods: The Finnish case European Accounting Review 8 1 1999 67-92
85. W.R. Lane S.W. Looney J.W. Wansley An application of the Cox proportional hazards model to bank failure Journal of Banking and Finance 10 1986 511-531
86. Lehmann, B., 2003. Is it worth the while? The relevance of qualitative information in credit rating, Working Paper presented at the EFMA 2003 Meetings, Helsinki (Finland), 25-29 June, 2003 pp. 1-25.
87. M. Luoma E.K. Laitinen Survival analysis as a tool for company failure prediction Omega International Journal of Management Science 19 6 1991 673-678
88. R.N. Lussier A nonfinancial business success versus failure prediction model for young firms Journal of Small Business Management 33 1 1995 8-20
89. Lussier, R.N., Corman, J., 1994. A success vs. failure prediction model of the manufacturing industry, Paper presented at the Conference of the Small Business Institute Director's Association, San Antonio, Texas, February 1994, Paper number, 48, pp. 1-5.
90. G.S. Maddala Econometrics 1977 McGraw-Hill New York
91. A.C. Maltz A.J. Shenhar R.R. Reilly Beyond the balanced scorecard: refining the search for organizational success measures Long Range Planning 36 2003 187-204
92. S. McLeay A. Omar The sensitivity of prediction models tot the non-normality of bounded an unbounded financial ratios British Accounting Review 32 2000 213-230
93. Y.M. Mensah The differential bankruptcy predictive ability of specific price-level adjustments: Some empirical evidence Accounting Review 58 2 1983 228-246
94. Y.M. Mensah An examination of the stationarity of multivariate bankruptcy prediction models: A methodological study Journal of Accounting Research 22 1 1984 380-395
95. B. Micha Analysis of business failures in France Journal of Banking and Finance 8 1984 281-291
96. R.C. Moyer Forecasting financial failure: A re-examination Financial Management 6 1 1977 11-17
97. Ch.E. Mossman G.G. Bell L.M. Swartz H. Turtle An empirical comparison of bankruptcy models Financial Review 33 2 1998 35-54
98. D. Moses S.S. Liao On developing models for failure prediction Journal of Commercial Bank Lending 69 1987 27-38
99. J. Ohlson Financial ratios and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy Journal of Accounting Research 18 1 1980 109-131
100. H. Ooghe E. Verbaere Predicting business failure on the basis of accounting data: The Belgian experience The International Journal of Accounting 9 2 1985 19-44
101. Ooghe, H., Joos, P., 1990. Failure prediction, explanation of misclassifications and incorporation of other relevant variables: Result of empirical research in Belgium, Working paper, Department of Corporate Finance, Ghent University (Belgium).
102. Ooghe, H., Balcaen, S., 2002. Are failure prediction models transferable from one country to another? An empirical study using Belgian financial statements, Proceedings of the 9th Annual Conference of the Multinational Finance Society, 30/06/02-03/07/02, Cyprus.
103. Ooghe, H., Balcaen, S., 2004. Alternative methodologies in studies on business failure: Do they produce better results than the classical statistical methods? Working Paper Series, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Ghent University (Belgium), Paper number, 04/ 249 June 2004.
104. H. Ooghe P. Joos D. De Vos Risico-indicator voor een onderneming aan de hand van falingspredictie-modellen Accountancy en Bedrijfskunde Kwartaalschrift 18 3 1993 3-26
105. Ooghe, H., Joos, P., De Vos, D., De Bourdeaudhuij, C., 1994a. Towards an improved method of evaluation of financial distress models and presentation of their results, Working Paper, Department of Corporate Finance, Ghent University (Belgium), January, pp. 1-22.
106. H. Ooghe P. Joos C. De Bourdeaudhuij Financial distress models in Belgium: The results of a decade of empirical research International Journal of Accounting 30 1995 245-274
107. H. Ooghe J. Camerlynck S. Balcaen The Ooghe-Joos-De Vos failure prediction models: A cross-industry validation Brussels Economic Review 46 1 2003 39-70
108. M.J. Peel D.A. Peel Some further empirical evidence on predicting private company failure Accounting and Business Research 18 1987 57-66
109. J. Piesse D. Wood Issues in assessing MDA models of corporate failure: A research note British Accounting Review 24 1992 33-42
110. H.D. Platt M.B. Platt Development of a class of stable predictive variables: The case of bankruptcy prediction Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 17 1 1990 31-51
111. H.D. Platt M.B. Platt A note on the use of industry-relative ratios in bankruptcy prediction Journal of Banking and Finance 15 1991 1183-1194
112. H.D. Platt M.B. Platt Predicting corporate financial distress: reflections on choice-based sample bias Journal of Economics and Finance 26 2 2002 184-199
113. Platt, H.D., Platt, M.B., 2004. Industry-relative ratios revisited: The case of financial distress, Paper presented at the FMA 2004 Meeting, New Orleans (USA), pp. 6-9, 2004.
114. H.D. Platt M.B. Platt J.G. Pedersen Bankruptcy discrimination with real variables Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 21 4 1994 491-510
115. P. Pompe J. Bilderbeek Faillissementspredictie: Een vergelijking tussen lineaire discriminant analyse en neurale netwerken Economisch Sociaal Tijdschrift 2 2000 215-242
116. F.M. Richardson L.F. Davidson On linear discrimination with accounting ratios Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 11 4 1984 511-525
117. F.M. Richardson G.D. Kane P. Lobingier The impact of recession on the prediction of corporate failure Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 2 1-2 1998 167-186
118. R.L. Rosner Earnings manipulation in failing firms Contemporary Accounting Research 20 2 2003 361-408
119. E. Scott On the financial applications of discriminant analysis: Comment Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 1978 201-205
120. J. Scott The probability of bankruptcy: A comparison of empirical predictions and theoretical models Journal of Banking and Finance 5 3 1981 317-344
121. Sharma, D.S., Iselin, E.R., 2003. The relative relevance of cash flow and accrual information for solvency assessments: A multi-method approach. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 30 (7-8), September, 1115-1140.
122. J.P. Sheppard Strategy and bankruptcy: An exploration into organizational death Journal of Management 20 4 1994 795-833
123. Shumway, T., 1999. Forecasting bankruptcy more accurately: A simple hazard model, Working Paper, University of Michigan Business School, USA, July, pp. 1-31.
124. R. Slowinski C. Zopudinis Application of the rough set approach to evaluation of bankruptcy risk Intelligent Systems in Accounting, Finance and Management 4 1995 27-41
125. Steele, A., 1995. Going concern qualifications and bankruptcy prediction, Paper presented at the 18th Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association, Birmingham (UK), 10-12 May, pp. 1-28.
126. E. Swanson J. Tybout Industrial bankruptcy determinants in Argentina Studies in Banking and Finance 7 1988 1-25
127. A.P. Sweeney Debt-covenant violations and managers' accounting responses Journal of Accounting and Economics 17 3 1994 281-308
128. R.J. Taffler Forecasting company failure in the UK using discriminant analysis and financial ratio data Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 145 1982 342-358 (Part 3)
129. R.J. Taffler The assessment of company solvency and performance using a statistical model Accounting and Business Research 15 52 1983 295-307
130. R.J. Taffler Empirical models for the monitoring of UK corporations Journal of Banking and Finance 8 1984 199-227
131. R.J. Taffler H. Tisshaw Going, Going, Gone-Four Factors Which Predict Accountancy 88 1977 50-54
132. Taffler, R.J., Agarwal, V., 2003. Do statistical failure prediction models work ex ante or only ex post?, Paper read in the Deloitte & Touche Lecture Series on credit risk, University of Antwerp (Belgium), February.
133. M. Tamari Financial ratios as a means of forecasting bankruptcy Management International Review 4 1966 15-21
134. Theil, H., 1971. Principles of econometrics. J. Wiley and Sons, New York.
135. P. Theodossiou Predicting shifts in the mean of a multivariate time series process: An application in predicting business failures Journal of the American Statistical Association 88 422 1993 441-449
136. Tucker, J., 1996. Neural networks versus logistic regression in financial modelling: A methodological comparison, Proceedings of the 1996 World First Online Workshop on Soft Computing (WSC1), Nagoya University (Japan), August, pp. 19-30.
137. Van Caillie, D., 1999. Business failure prediction models: What is the theory looking for? Paper presented at the Second International Conference on Risk and Crisis Management, Liège (Belgium), May, pp. 1-14.
138. Van Caillie, D., Arnould, S., 2001. The follow-up of financial value creation indicators to prevent bankruptcy in Belgian SMEs: An empirical multivariate approach, Paper presented at the 2001 Babson College Research Conference on Entrepreneurship, Jonköping (Sweden), June.
139. Van Caillie, D., Dighaye, A., 2002. The concept of «economic added result», a new tool to prevent bankruptcy? Paper presented at the European Accounting Association Congress, Copenhagen (Denmark), April, pp. 1-30.
140. van Frederikslust, R.A.I., 1978. Predictability of corporate failure: models for prediction of corporate failure and for evaluation of corporate debt capacity. PhD thesis in Economic Sciences, Martinus Nijhoff Social Science Division, Leiden/Boston, Erasmus University, Rotterdam (The Netherlands).
141. Van Wymeersch, Ch., Wolfs, A. 1996. La 'trajectoire de faillite' des entreprises: Une analyse chronologique sur base des comptes annuels, Working Paper, Faculté des Sciences Economiques et Sociales, Université Notre-Dame de la Paix (Belgium), Paper number 172, pp. 1-32.
142. T.J. Ward B.P. Foster A note on selecting a response measure for financial distress Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 24 6 1997 869-879
143. Watts, R.L., Zimmerman, J.L., 1986. Positive Accounting Theory. Prentice Hall Publishing Company.
144. J. Wilcox A simple theory of financial ratios as predictors of failure Journal of Accounting Research 9 2 1971 389-395
145. D. Wood J. Piesse The information value of MDA based financial indicators Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 14 1 1987 27-38
146. C. Zavgren The prediction of corporate failure: The state of the art Journal of Accounting Literature 2 1983 1-000mm37
147. C.V. Zavgren Assessing the vulnerability to failure of American industrial firms: A logistic analysis Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 12 1 1985 19-45
148. Zmijewski, M.E., 1984. Methodological issues related to the estimation of financial distress prediction models. Journal of Accounting Research 22 (Suppl.), 59-86. 59-86.