Behavioural assessment of pain in horses and donkeys: Application to clinical practice and future studies

Equine Veterinary Journal

Volumn 37, Issue 6, 2005, Pages 565-575

  Ashley, F H ^a   Waterman Pearson, A E ^a   Whay, H R ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Behaviour; Donkey; Horse; Pain

Indexed keywords

EQUIDAE; EQUUS ASINUS; EQUUS CABALLUS;

EID: 27744577081     PISSN: 04251644     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2746/042516405775314826     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. Anon (1983) International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP). Pain 16, 109-110.
2. Bernard, W. (2002) Colic in foals. In: Proceedings of the 41st British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. pp 31-32.
3. Budras, K.D., Scheibe, K., Patan, B., Streich, W.J. and Kim, K. (2001) Laminitis in Przewalski horses kept in a semireserve. J. vet. Sci. 2, 1-7.
4. Cambridge, A.J., Tobias, K.M., Newberry, R.C. and Sarkar, D.K. (2000) Subjective and objective measurements of post-operative pain in cats. J. Am. vet. med. Ass. 217, 685-690.
5. Casey, R.A. (2004) Clinical problems associated with the intensive management of performance horses. In: The Welfare of Horses, Ed: N. Waran, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht. pp 19-44.
6. Crane, M. (2002) Colic in the donkey. In: Proceedings of the 41st British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. pp 33-34.
7. Dabareiner, R.M. and Carter, G.K. (2003) Diagnosis, treatment and farriery for horses with chronic heel pain. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 19, 417-441.
8. Daunt, D.A. and Steffey, E.P. (2002) Alpha-2 adrenergic agonists as analgesics in horses. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 39-46.
9. DeRossi, R., Sampaio, B.F.B., Varela, J.V. and Junqueira, A.L. (2004) Perineal analgesia and haemodynamic effects of the epidural administration of meperidine or hyperbaric bupivacaine in conscious horses. Can. vet. J. 45, 42-47.
10. Duffield, H.F., Bell, N. and Henson, F.M.D. (2002) Factors associated with impactive colic in the donkey. In: Proceedings of the 7th International Equine Colic Research Symposium, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. p 122.
11. DuPreez, P. (2002) Pelvic fractures: diagnosis and management. In: Proceedings of the 41st British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. pp 71-72.
12. Dyson, S. (2002) It's just the way I walk! A review of gait characteristics. In: Proceedings of the 41st British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. p 69.
13. Dyson, S. and Marks, D. (2003) Foot pain and the elusive diagnosis. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 19, 531-565.
14. Dyson, S.J. and Murray, R. (2003) Pain associated with the sacroiliac joint region: a clinical study of 74 horses. Equine vet. J. 35, 240-245.
15. Dzikiti, T.B., Hellebrekers, L.J. and Von-Dijk, P. (2003) Effects of intravenous lidocaine on isoflurane concentration, physiological parameters, metabolic parameters and stress-related hormones in horses undergoing surgery. J. vet. med. Ass. 50, 190-195.
16. Easley, J.K. (1999) Dental and oral examination. In: Equine Dentistry, Ed: G.J. Baker and J.K. Easley, W.B Saunders Co., London. pp 114-117.
17. Fleming, P. (2002) Non traditional approaches to pain management. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 83-105.
18. Goodrich, L.R., Nixon, A.J., Fubini, S.L., Ducharme, N.G., Fortier, L.A., Warnick, L.D. and Ludders, J.W. (2002) Epidural morphine and detomidine decreases post operative hindlimb lameness in horses after bilateral stifle arthroscopy. Vet. Surg. 31, 232-239.
19. Graham, B.P. (2002) Dental care in the older horse. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 509-522.
20. Green, P. (2001) Castration of horses and analgesia. Vet. Rec. 149, 159-160.
21. Green, P. and Tong, M. (2002) Step-by-step approach to the acute abdomen in the mature horse. In: Proceedings of the 41st British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. pp 29-30.
22. Grondahl-Nielsen, C., Simonsen, H.B., Damkerlund, J. and Hesselholt, M. (1999) Behavioural, endocrine and cardiac responses in young calves undergoing dehorning without and with use of sedation and analgesia. Vet. J. 158, 14-20.
23. Gross, D.R., Tranquill, W.J., Greene, S.A. and Grimm, K.A. (2003) Critical anthropomorphic evaluation and treatment of post-operative pain in rats and mice. J. Am. vet. med. Ass. 222, 1505-1510.
24. Grulke, S., Olle, E., Detilleux, J., Gangl, M., Caudron, I. and Serteyn, D. (2001) Determination of a gravity and shock score for prognosis in equine surgical colic. J. vet. med. Ass. 48, 465-473.
25. Guthrie, D.M. (1980) Neuroethology: An Introduction, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford.
26. Harris, R. (2001) Castration of horses and analgesia. Vet. Rec. 149, 279-280.
27. Hay, M., Vulin, A., Genin, S., Sales, P. and Prunier, A. (2003) Assessment of pain induced by castration in piglets: behavioural and physiological responses over the subsequent five days. Appl. anim. behav. Sci. 82, 201-218.
28. Hellyer, P.W., Keeler, G.A., Everding, H.E., Gaynor, J.S., Wagner, A.E. and Glawe, C. (2002) Preliminary evaluation of the pain behaviours following neutering in dogs: effect of acepromazine dose. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 29, 101-102.
29. Herthel, D. and Hood, D.M. (1999) Clinical presentation, diagnosis and prognosis of chronic laminitis. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 15, 375-394.
30. Hewetson, M. (2003) Reproducibility of a visual analogue scale, numerical rating scale and verbal rating scale for the assessment of lameness in the horse. In: Proceedings of the 42nd British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. p 295.
31. Hood, D.M., Wagner, I.P., Taylor, D.D., Brumbaugh, G.W. and Chaffin, K. (2001) Voluntary limb-load distribution in horses with acute and chronic laminitis. Am. J. vet. Res. 62, 1393-1398.
32. Houpt, K.A. and Feldman, J. (1993) Animal behaviour case of the month: aggression toward a neonatal foal by its dam. J. Am. vet. med. Ass. 203, 1279-1280.
33. Hubbell, J.A.E. (1999) Recovery from anaesthesia in horses. Equine vet. Educ. 11, 160-167.
34. Hunt, R.J. (2002) Laminitis in the geriatric horse. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 439-452.
35. Jochle, W. (1989) Field trial evaluation of detomidine as a sedative and analgesic in horses with colic. Equine vet. J., Suppl. 7, 117-120.
36. Jochle, W., Moore, J.N., Brown, J., Baker, G.J., Lowe, J.E., Fubini, S., Reeves, M.J., Watkins, J.P. and White, N.A. (1989) Comparison of detomidine, butorphanol, flunixin meglumine and xylazine in clinical cases of equine colic. Equine vet. J., Suppl. 7, 111-116.
37. Juarbe-Diaz, S.V., Houpt, K.A. and Kusunose, R. (1998) Prevalence and characteristics of foal rejection in Arabian mares. Equine vet. J. 30, 424-428.
38. Judy, C.E., Galuppo, L.D., Snyder, J.R. and Willits, N.H. (2001) Evaluation of an in-shoe pressure measurement system in horses. Am. J. vet. Res. 62, 23-28.
39. Kay, G. (2001) Castration of horses and analgesia. Vet. Rec. 149, 500.
40. Knottenbelt, D.C. (1999) The systemic effects of dental disease. In: Equine Dentistry, Ed: G.J. Baker and J. Easley, W.B. Saunders Co., London. pp 127-138.
41. Lane, J.G. (1994) A review of dental disorders of the horse, their treatment, and possible fresh approaches to management. Equine vet. Educ. 6, 13-21.
42. Lascelles, B.D.X., Waterman, A.E., Cripps, P.J., Livingston, A. and Henderson, G. (1995) Central sensitisation as a result of surgical pain. Investigation of the preemptive value of pethidine for ovariohysterectomy in the rat. Pain 62, 201-212.
43. Ley, S.J., Waterman, A.E. and Livingston, A. (1995) A field study of the effect of lameness on mechanical nociceptive thresholds in sheep. Vet. Rec. 137, 85-87.
44. Madigan, J.E. and Bell, S.A. (1998) Characterisation of headshaking syndrome - 31 cases. Equine vet. J. 27, 28-29.
45. Mair, T.S. and Lane, J.G. (1990) Headshaking in horses. In Pract. 9, 183-186.
46. Malone, E. and Graham, L. (2002) Management of gastrointestinal pain. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 133-158.
47. Matthews, N. (2002) Anaesthesia and analgesia for donkeys. In: Proceedings of the 41st British Equine Veterinary Association Congress, Equine Veterinary Journal Ltd, Newmarket. p 140.
48. Matthews, N.S. and Taylor, T.S. (2000) Anaesthetic management of donkeys and mules. In: Recent Advances in Anaesthetic Management of Large Domestic Animals, Ed: E.P Steffey, International Veterinary Information Services, Ithaca. [www.ivis.org Document No. A0607.0700].
49. Matthews, N.S. and Van Dijk, P. (2004) Anaesthesia and analgesia for donkeys. In: Veterinary Care of Donkeys, Eds: N.S. Matthews and T.S. Taylor, International Veterinary Information Services, Ithaca. [www.ivis.org Document No. A2902.0904].
50. Matthews, N.S., Taylor, T.S. and Hartsfield, S.M. (1997) Anaesthesia of donkeys and mules. Equine vet. Educ. 9, 198-202.
51. McCarthy, R.N., Jeffcot, L.B and Clarke, I.J. (1993) Preliminary studies on the use of plasma beta-endorphin in horses, as an indicator of stress and pain. J. equine vet. Sci. 13, 216-219.
52. Mellor, D.J., Cook, C.J. and Stafford, K.J. (2000) Quantifying some responses to pain as a stressor. In: The Biology of Animal Stress: Basic Principles and Implications for Animal Welfare, Eds: G.P. Moberg and J.A. Mench, CAB International, Oxfordshire. pp 171-198.
53. Mills, D.S., Cook, S., Jones, B. and Taylor, K. (2002) Analysis of the variations in clinical signs shown by 254 cases of equine head shaking. Vet. Rec. 150, 236-240.
54. Mircica, E., Clutton, E.R., Kyles, K.W. and Blissitt, K.J (2003) Problems associated with peri-operative morphine in horses: a retrospective case analysis. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 30, 147-155.
55. Moberg, G.P. (2000) Biological response to stress: implications for animal welfare. In: The Biology of Animal Stress: Basic Principles and Implications for Animal Welfare, Eds: G.P. Moberg and J.A. Mench, CAB International, Oxfordshire. pp 1-21.
56. Molony, V. and Kent, J.E. (1997) Assessment of acute pain in farm animals using behavioural and physiological measurements. J. anim. Sci. 75, 266-272.
57. Moses, V.S. and Bertone, A.L (2002) Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 21-37.
58. Muir, W.W. and Robertson, J.T. (1985) Visceral analgesia: effects of xylazine, butorphanol, meperidine and pentazocine in horses. Am. J. vet. Res. 46, 2081-2084.
59. Murrell, J.C., Johnson, C.B., White, K.L., Taylor, P.M., Haberham, Z.L. and Waterman-Pearson, A.E. (2003) Changes in the EEG during castration in horses and ponies anaesthetized with halothane. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 30, 138-146.
60. Olbrich, V.H. and Mosing, M. (2003) A comparison of the analgesic effects of caudal epidural methadone and lidocaine in the horse. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 30, 156-164.
61. Owens, J.G., Kamerling, S.G., Stanton, S.R. and Keowen, M.L. (1995) Effects of ketoprofen and phenylbutazone on chronic hoof pain and lameness in the horse. Equine vet. J. 27, 296-300.
62. Parry, B.W., Gay, C.C. and Anderson, G.A. (1983) Assessment of the necessity for surgical intervention in cases of equine colic: a retrospective study. Equine vet. J. 15, 216-221.
63. Peham, C., Licka, T., Girtler, D. and Scheidl, M. (1999) Supporting forelimb lameness: clinical judgement vs. computerised symmetry measurement. Equine vet. J. 31, 417-421.
64. Peham, C., Licka, T., Girtler, D. and Scheidl, M. (2001) The influence of lameness on equine stride length consistency. Vet. J. 162, 153-157.
65. Price, J., Marques, J.M., Welsh, E.M. and Waran, N.K. (2002) Pilot epidemiological study of attitudes towards pain in horses. Vet. Rec. 151, 570-575.
66. Price, J., Clarke, N., Welsh, E.M. and Waran, N. (2003a) Preliminary evaluation of subjective scoring systems for assessment of post-operative pain in horses. Ass. vet. Anaesth. 30, 97.
67. Price, J., Catriona, S., Welsh, E.M. and Waran, N.K. (2003b) Preliminary evaluation of post-operative pain in horses following arthroscopic surgery. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 30, 124-137.
68. Pritchett, L.C., Ulibarri, C., Roberts, M.C., Schneider, R.K. and Sellon, D.C. (2003) Identification of potential physiological and behavioural indicators of post-operative pain in horses after exploratory celiotomy for colic. Appl. anim. behav. Sci. 80, 31-43.
69. Queiroz-Neto, A., Zamur, G., Goncalves, S.C., Carregaro, A.B., Mataquiero, M.I., Harkins, J.D. and Tobin, T. (1998) Characterization of the anti-nociceptive and sedative effect of Amitraz in horses. J. vet. Pharmacol. Ther. 21, 400.
70. Raekallio, M., Taylor, P.M. and Bloomfield, M. (1997a) A comparison of methods for evaluation of pain and distress after orthopaedic surgery in horses. J. vet. Anaesth. 24, 17-20.
71. Raekallio, M., Taylor, P.M. and Bennett, R.C. (1997b) Preliminary investigations of pain and analgesia assessment in horses administered phenylbutazone or placebo after arthroscopic surgery. Vet. Surg. 26, 150-155.
72. Raekallio, M., Heinonen, K.M., Kuussaari, J. and Vainio, O. (2003) Pain alleviation in animals: Attitudes and practices of Finnish veterinarians. Vet. J. 165, 131-135.
73. Redua, M.A., Valadao, C.A., Duque, J.C. and Balestrero, L.T. (2002) The preemptive effect of epidural ketamine on wound sensitivity in horses tested by Von Frey filaments. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 29, 200-206.
74. Rietmann, T.R., Stauffacher, M., Bernasconi, P., Auer, J.A. and Weishaupt, M.A. (2004a) The association between heart rate, heart rate variability, endocrine and behavioural pain measures in horses suffering from laminitis. J. vet. med. Ass. 51, 218-225.
75. Rietmann, T.R., Stuart, A.E.A., Bernasconi, P., Stauffacher, M., Auer, J.A. and Weishaupt, M.A. (2004b) Assessment of mental stress in warmblood horses: heart rate variability in comparison to heart rate and selected behavioural parameters. Appl. anim. behav. Sci. 88, 121-136.
76. Sanford, J., Ewbank, R., Molony, V., Tavernor, W.D., and Uvarov, O. (1989) Working Party of the Association of Veterinarians, Teachers and Research Workers: Guidelines for the Recognition and Assessment of Pain in Animals. Universities Federation of Animal Welfare (UFAW), Potters Bar, UK.
77. Searle, D., Dart, A.J., Dart, C.M. and Hodgson, D.R. (1999) Equine castration: review of anatomy, approaches, techniques and complications in normal, cryptorchid and monorchid horses. Aust. vet. J. 77, 428-434.
78. Seibert, L.M., Parthasarathy, V., Trim, C.M. and Crowell-Davies, S.L. (2003) An ethogram of post-anaesthetic recovery behaviours in horses: comparison of pre and post anaesthetic behaviours. Ass. vet. Anaesth. 30, 112.
79. Short, C.E. (1998) Fundamentals of pain perception in animals. Appl. anim. behav. Sci. 59, 125-133.
80. Skarda, R.T. and Muir, W.W. (1996) Comparison of antinociceptive, cardiovascular and respiratory effects, head ptosis, and position of pelvic limbs in mares after caudal epidural administration of xylazine and detomidine hydrochloride solution. Am. J. vet. Res. 57, 1338-1345.
81. Spadavecchia, C., Spadavecchia, L., Anderson, U.K., Arendt-Nielsen, L., Doherr, M. and Schatzmann, U. (2003) Comparison of nociceptive withdrawal reflexes and recruitment curves between the forelimbs and hindlimbs in conscious horses. Am. J. vet. Res. 64, 700-707.
82. Stashak, T.S. (Ed) (2002) Examination for lameness. In: Adams' Lameness in Horses, 5th edn., Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia. pp 113-183.
83. Steffey, E.P., Brosnan, R.A., Imai, A. and Mama, K.R. (2002) A laboratory study of horses recovering from desflurane and isoflurane anaesthesia. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 29, 90-91.
84. Swanson, T.D. (1999) Clinical presentation, diagnosis and prognosis of acute laminitis. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 15, 311-319.
85. Taylor, T.S. and Matthews, N.S. (1998) Mammoth asses - selected behavioural considerations for the veterinarian. Appl. anim. behav. Sci. 60, 283-289.
86. Taylor, P.M., Pascoe, P.J. and Mama, K.R. (2002a) Diagnosing and treating pain in the horse; where are we today? Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 1-19.
87. Taylor, D., Hood, D.M. and Wagner, I.P. (2002b) Short term effect of therapeutic shoeing on severity of lameness in horses with chronic laminitis. Am. J. vet. Res. 63, 1629-1633.
88. Thoefner, M.B., Ersboll, B.K., Jansson, N. and Hesselholt, M. (2003) Diagnostic decision rule for support in clinical assessment of the need for surgical intervention in horses with acute abdominal pain. Can. J. vet. Res. 67, 20-29.
89. Trawford, A.F. and Crane, M.A. (1995) Nursing care of the donkey. Equine vet. Educ. 7, 36-38.
90. Van Dijk, M., De Boer, J., Koot, H.M., Tibboel, D., Passchier, J. and Duivenvoorden, H.J. (2000) The reliability and validity of the COMFORT scale as a post-operative pain instrument in 0 to 3yr old infants. Pain 84, 367-377.
91. Wagner, A.E., Mama, K.R., Steffey, E.P., Brevard, L.F. and Hellyer, P.W. (2002) Behavioural responses following eight anaesthetic induction protocols in horses. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 29, 207-211.
92. Welsh, E.M. and Nolan, A.M. (1995) The effect of abdominal surgery on thresholds to thermal and mechanical stimulation in sheep. Pain 60, 159-166.
93. Whay, H.R., Waterman, A.E. and Webster, A.J.F. (1997) Associations between locomotion, claw lesions and nociceptive threshold in dairy heifers during the peri-partum period. Vet. J. 154, 155-161.
94. Whay, H.R., Waterman, A.E., O'Brien, J.K. and Webster, A.J.F. (1998) The influence of lesion type on duration of hyperalgesia associated with hindlimb lameness in dairy cattle. Vet. J. 156, 23-29.
95. Whitehead, G., French, J. and Ikin, P. (1991) Welfare and veterinary care of donkeys. In Pract. 13, 62-68.
96. Williams, G.E. (2001) Locomotor characteristics of horses with navicular disease. Am. J. vet. Res. 62, 206-210.
97. Wolf, L. (2002) The role of complementary techniques in managing musculoskeletal pain in performance horses. Vet. Clin. N. Am.: Equine Pract. 18, 107-115.
98. Wright, I.M. (1993) A study of 118 cases of navicular disease: clinical features. Equine vet. J. 25, 488-492.
99. Zimmerman, M. (1984) Ethical considerations in relation to pain in animal experimentation. In: Biomedical Research Involving Animals, Eds: Z. Bankowski and N. Howard-Jones, Council for International Organisations of Medical Sciences, Geneva. pp 132-139.