Tree-grass coexistence in savannas revisited - Insights from an examination of assumptions and mechanisms invoked in existing models

Ecology Letters

Volumn 7, Issue 6, 2004, Pages 480-490

  Sankaran, Mahesh ^a   Ratnam, Jayashree ^a   Hanan, Niall P ^a  

^a Veterinary Dentistry and Oral Surgery   (United States)

Author keywords

Climatic variability; Competition; Demographic bottlenecks; Disturbance; Models; Resource limitation; Savanna; Tree grass coexistence

Indexed keywords

COEXISTENCE; ECOLOGICAL MODELING; GRASS; NICHE PARTITIONING; SAVANNA; TREE;

POACEAE;

EID: 2542565108     PISSN: 1461023X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1461-0248.2004.00596.x     Document Type: Review

References (78)

1. Amarasekare, P. (2003). Competitive coexistence in spatially structured environments: a synthesis. Ecol. Lett., 6, 1109-1122.
2. Archer, S. (1989). Have southern Texas savannas been converted to woodlands in recent history? Am. Nat., 134, 545-561.
3. Belsky, A.J. (1990). Tree/grass ratios in East African savannas: a comparison of existing models. J. Biogeogr., 17, 483-489.
4. Belsky, A.J. (1994). Influence of trees on savanna productivity: tests of shade, nutrients and tree-grass competition. Ecology, 75, 922-932.
5. 2- controlled mechanism of woody plant invasion in grasslands and savannas. Global Change Biology, 6, 865-869.
6. Bond, W.J., Midgley, G.F. & Woodward, F.I. (2003). What controls South African vegetation - climate or fire? S. Afr. J. Bot., 69, 79-91.
7. Bond, W.J. & van Wilgen, B.W. (1996). Fire and Plants. Chapman and Hall, London.
8. Bragg, W.K., Knapp, A.K. & Briggs, J.M. (1993). Comparative water relations of seedling and adult Quercus species during gallery forest expansion in tallgrass prairie. For. Ecol. Manag., 56, 29-41.
9. Brown, J.R. & Archer, S. (1990). Water relations of a perennial grass and seedling vs. adult woody plants in a subtropical savanna, Texas. Oikos, 57, 366-374.
10. Brown, J.R., Scanlan, J.C. & McIvor, J.G. (1998). Competition by herbs as a limiting factor in shrub invasion in grassland: a test with different growth forms. J. Veg. Sci., 9, 829-836.
11. Casper, B.B., Schenk, H.J. & Jackson, R.R.B. (2003). Defining a plant's belowground zone of influence. Ecology, 84, 2313-2321.
12. Chesson, P. (2000). Mechanisms of maintenance of species diversity. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst., 31, 343-366.
13. Chesson, P. & Huntly, N. (1997). The role of harsh and fluctuating conditions in the dynamics of ecological communities. Am. Nat., 150, 519-553.
14. DeAngelis, D.L. & Waterhouse, J.C. (1987). Equilibrium and non-equilibrium concepts in ecological models. Ecol. Monogr., 57, 1-21.
15. Eagleson, P.S. (1989). Stability of tree/grass vegetation systems. In: Understanding climate change. Geophysical Monographs 52 (eds Berger, A., Dickinson, R.E. & Kidson, J.W.). Geophysical Union, Washington, DC, pp. 109-113.
16. Eagleson, P.S. & Segara, R.I. (1985). Water-limited equilibrium of savanna vegetation systems. Water Resour. Res., 21, 1483-1493.
17. Ellis, J.E. & Swift, D.M. (1988). Stability of African pastoral ecosystems: alternate paradigms and implications for development. J. Range. Manage., 41, 450-459.
18. Fernandez-Illescas, C.P. & Rodriguez-Iturbe, I. (2003). Hydrologically driven hierarchical competition-colonization models: the impact of interannual climate fluctuations. Ecol. Monogr., 73, 207-222.
19. Frost, P.G.H. & Robertson, F. (1987). The ecological effects of fire in savannas. In: Determinants of Tropical Savannas (ed. Walker, B.H.). IUBS, Paris, pp. 93-141.
20. Frost, P.G., Medina, E., Menaut, J.C., Solbrig, O., Swift, M. & Walker, B.H. (eds) (1986). Response of Savannas to Stress and Disturbance. Biology International Special Issue 10. IUBS, Paris.
21. Gignoux, J., Clobert, J. & Menaut, J.C. (1997). Alternate fire resistance strategies in savanna trees. Oecologia, 110, 576-583.
22. Harrington, G.H. (1991). Effects of soil moisture on shrub seedling survival in a semi-arid grassland. Ecology, 72, 1138-1149.
23. Helsa, B.I., Tieszen, H.L. & Boutton, T.W. (1985). Seasonal water relations of savanna shrubs and grasses in Kenya, East Africa. J. Arid. Environ., 8, 15-31.
24. Higgins, S.I., Bond, W.J. & Trollope, W.S.W. (2000). Fire, resprouting and variability: a recipe for grass-tree coexistence in savanna. J. Ecol., 88, 213-229.
25. Hipondoka, M.H.T., Aranibar, J.N., Chirara, C., Lihavha, M. & Macko, S.A. (2003). Vertical distribution of grass and tree roots in arid ecosystems of southern Africa: niche differentiation or competition? J. Arid. Environ., 54, 319-325.
26. Hochberg, M.E., Menaut, J.C. & Gignoux, J. (1994). The influences of tree biology and fire in the spatial structure of the West African savannah. J. Ecol., 82, 217-226.
27. Hoffman, W.A. (1996). The effects of fire and cover on seedling establishment in a neotropical savanna. J. Ecol., 84, 383-393.
28. House, J., Archer, S., Breshears, D.D., Scholes, R.J. & NCEAS Tree-Grass Interaction Participants (2003). Conundrums in mixed woody-herbaceous plant systems. J. Biogeogr., 30, 1763-1777.
29. Illius, A.W. & O'Connor, T.G. (1999). On the relevance of non-equilibrium concepts to arid and semiarid grazing systems. Ecol. Appl., 9, 798-813.
30. Jeltsch, F., Milton, S.J., Dean, W.R.J. & van Rooyen, N. (1996). Tree spacing and coexistence in semiarid savannas. J. Ecol., 84, 583-595.
31. Jeltsch, F., Milton, S.J., Dean, W.R.J., van Rooyen, N. & Moloney, K.A. (1998). Modelling the impact of small-scale heterogeneities on tree-grass coexistence in semi-arid savannas. J. Ecol., 86, 780-793.
32. Jeltsch, F., Weber, G.E. & Grimm, V. (2000). Ecological buffering mechanisms in savannas: a unifying theory of long-term tree-grass coexistence. Plant Ecol., 161, 161-171.
33. Johns, G.G. (1984). Soil water storage in a semi-arid Eucalyptus populnea woodland invaded by woody shrubs, and the effects of shrub clearing and tree ring-barking. Aust. Range. J., 6, 75-85.
34. Jurena, P.N. & Archer, S. (2003). Woody plant establishment and spatial heterogeneity in grasslands. Ecology, 84, 907-919.
35. Kneitel, J.M. & Chase, J.M. (2004). Trade-offs in community ecology: linking spatial scales and species coexistence. Ecol. Lett., 7, 69-80.
36. Knoop, W.T. & Walker, B.H. (1985). Interactions of woody and herbaceous vegetation in a southern African savanna. J. Ecol., 73, 235-253.
37. van Langevelde, F., van de Vijver, C.A.D.M., Kumar, L., van Koppel, J., de Ridder, N., van Andel, J. et al. (2003). Effects of fire and herbivory on the stability of savanna ecosystems. Ecology, 84, 337-350.
38. Le Roux, X., Bariac, T. & Mariotti, A. (1995). Spatial partitioning of the soil waterresource between grass and shrub components in a West African humid savanna. Oecologia, 104, 147-155.
39. Levine, J.M. & Rees, M. (2002). Coexistence and relative abundance in annual plant assemblages: the roles of competition and colonization. Am. Nat., 160, 452-467.
40. Levins, R. & Culver, D. (1971). Regional coexistence of species and competition between rare species. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 68, 1246-1248.
41. McNaughton, S.J. (1992). The propagation of disturbance in savannas through food webs. J. Veg. Sci., 3, 301-314.
42. McPherson, G.R. & Weltzin, J.F. (1998). Herbaceous response to canopy removal in southwestern oak woodlands. J. Range. Manage., 51, 674-678.
43. Medina, E. & Silva, J.F. (1990). Savannas of northern South America: a steady state regulated by water-fire interactions on a background of low nutrient availability. J. Biogeogr., 17, 403-413.
44. Menaut, J.C. & Cesar, J. (1982). The structure and dynamics of a west African savanna. In: Ecology of Tropical Savannas (eds Walker, B.J. & Huntley, B.H.). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 80-100.
45. Menaut, J.C., Gignoux, J., Prado, C. & Clobert, J. (1990). Tree community dynamics in a humid savanna of the Cote-d'Ivoire: modelling the effects of fire and competition with grass and neighbours. J. Biogeogr., 17, 471-481.
46. Midgley, J.J. & Bond, W.J. (2001). A synthesis of the demography of African acacias. J. Trop. Ecol., 17, 871-886.
47. Mordelet, P. & Menaut, J.C. (1995). Influence of trees on above-ground production dynamics of grasses in a humid savanna. J. Veg. Sci., 6, 223-228.
48. Mordelet, P., Menaut, J.C. & Mariotti, A. (1997). Tree and grass rooting patterns in an African humid savanna. J. Veg. Sci., 8, 65-70.
49. Murrell, D.J. & Law, R. (2003). Heteromyopia and the spatial coexistence of similar competitors. Ecol. Lett., 6, 48-59.
50. Pelaez, D.V., Distel, R.A., Boo, R.M., Elia, O.R. & Mayor, M.D. (1994). Water relations between shrubs and grasses in semi-arid Argentina. J. Arid. Environ., 27, 71-78.
51. Pellew, R.A. (1983). The giraffe and its food resource in the Serengeti. I. Composition, biomass and production of available browse. Afr. J. Ecol., 21, 241-267.
52. Peterson, D.W. & Reich, P.B. (2001). Prescribed fire in oak savanna: fire frequency effects on stand structure and dynamics. Ecol. Appl., 11, 914-927.
53. 2, soil water, and shrub/grass ratios on rangelands. J. Range. Manage., 50, 278-284.
54. Richards, J.H. & Caldwell, M.M. (1987). Hydraulic lift: substantial nocturnal transport between soil layers by Artemesia tridentata roots. Oecologa, 73, 486-489.
55. Sala, O.E., Golluscio, R.A., Lauenroth, W.K. & Soriano, A. (1989). Resource partitioning between shrubs and grasses in the Patagonian steppe. Oecologia, 81, 501-505.
56. Sala, O.E., Lauenroth, W.K. & Golluscio, R.A. (1997). Plant functional types in temperate semi-arid regions. In: Plant Functional Types: their Relevance to Ecosystem Properties and Global Change (eds Smith, T.M., Shugatt, H.H. & Woodward, F.I.). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 217-233.
57. Sarmiento, G. (1984). The Ecology of Neotropical Savannas. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
58. Schenk, H.J. & Jackson, R.B. (2002). Rooting depths, lateral root spreads and below-ground/above-ground allometries of plants in water-limited ecosystems. J. Ecol., 90, 480-494.
59. Scholes, R.J. & Archer, S.R. (1997). Tree-grass interactions in savannas. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst., 28, 517-544.
60. Scholes, R.J. & Walker, B.H. (1993). An African Savanna: Synthesis of the Nylsvley Study. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
61. Seghieri, J. (1995). The rooting patterns of woody and herbaceous plants in a savanna: are they complimentary or in competition? Afr. J. Ecol., 33, 358-365.
62. Skarpe, C. (1992). Dynamics of savanna ecosystems. J. Veg. Sci., 3, 293-300.
63. Smit, G.N. & Rethman, N.F.G. (2000). The influence of tree thinning on the soil water in a semi-arid savanna of southern Africa. J. Arid Environ., 44, 41-59.
64. Smith, T.M. & Goodman, P.S. (1986). The effect of competition on the structure and dynamics of Acacia savannas in southern Africa. J. Ecol., 74, 1031-1044.
65. Smith, T.M. & Grant, K. (1986). The role of competition in the spacing of trees in a Burkea africana-Terminalia sericea savanna. Biotropica, 18, 219-223.
66. Snyder, R.E. & Chesson, P. (2003). Local dispersal can facilitate coexistence in the presence of permanent spatial heterogeneity. Ecol. Lett., 6, 301-309.
67. Soriano, A. & Sala, O. (1983). Ecological strategies in a Patagonian arid steppe. Vegetatio, 56, 9-15.
68. Stott, P. (1991). Recent trends in the ecology and management of the world's savanna formations. Progr. Phys. Geogr., 15, 18-28.
69. Sullivan, S. & Rohde, R. (2002). On non-equilibrium in arid and semi-arid grazing systems. J. Biogeogr., 29, 1595-1618.
70. Trapnell, C.G. (1959). Ecological results of woodland burning in northern Rhodesia. J. Ecol., 47, 161-172.
71. Trollope, W.S.W. (1982). Ecological effects of fire in South African savannas. In: Ecology of Tropical Savannas (eds Walker, B.J. & Huntley, B.H.). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 292-306.
72. Walker, B.H. & Noy-Meir, I. (1982). Aspects of stability and resilience of savanna ecosystems. In: Ecology of Tropical Savannas (eds Walker, B.J. & Huntley, B.H.). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 556-590.
73. Walker, B.H., Ludwig, D., Rolling, C.S. & Peterman, R.M. (1981). Stability of semi-arid savanna grazing systems. J. Ecol., 69, 473-498.
74. Walter, H. (1971). Ecology of Tropical and Subtropical Vegetation. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh, UK.
75. Warner, R.R. & Chesson, P.L. (1985). Coexistence mediated by recruitment fluctuations: a field guide to the storage effect. Am. Nat., 125, 769-787.
76. Weltzin, J.F. & McPherson, G.R. (1997). Spatial and temporal soil moisture resource partitioning by trees and grasses in a temperate savanna, Arizona, USA. Oecologia, 112, 156-164.
77. van Wijk, M.T. & Rodriguez-Iturbe, I. (2002). Tree-grass competition in space and time: insights from a simple cellular automata model based on ecohydrological dynamics. Water Resour. Res., 38, 18.11-18.15.
78. Wilson, T. & Witkowski, E.T.F. (1998). Water requirements for germination and early seedling establishment in four African savanna woody plant species. J. Arid. Environ., 38, 541-550.