Is the "ecological fallacy" a fallacy?

Human and Ecological Risk Assessment (HERA)

Volumn 6, Issue 6, 2000, Pages 921-941

  Seiler, Fritz A ^a   Alvarez, Joseph L ^b  

^a Sigma Five Consulting   (United States)

^b Auxier and Associates   (United States)

Author keywords

Ecological fallacy; Epidemiological studies; Lung cancer; Radon; Risk assessment

Indexed keywords

EID: 23044521829     PISSN: 10807039     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (48)

1. Alvarez, J. L. and. Seiler, F. A. 1996. New Approaches to Low-Dose Risk Modeling. Technol. J. Franklin Inst. 333A, 33-51.
2. Archer, V.E. 1998. Errors in Cohen's Home Radon-Lung Cancer Analyses. Health Phys. 75, 652-653.
3. Bevington, P. R. and Robinson, K. D. 1992. Data Reduction and Error Analysis in the Physical Sciences. McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.
4. Bogen, K. T. 1997. Do U.S. county data disprove linear no-threshold predictions of lung cancer risk for residential radon? - a preliminary assessment of biological plausibility. Human Ecol. Risk Assess. 3, 157-186.
5. Bogen, K. T. 1998. A mechanistic model predicts a U-shaped relation of radon exposure to lung cancer risk reflected in combined occupational and U.S. residential data. Human Exper. Toxicol. 17, 691-696.
6. Bunge, M. 1979. Causality and Modem Science. 3rd ed. Dover, New York, NY.
7. Brandt, S. 1976. Statistical and Computational Methods in Data Analysis. North Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
8. Cohen, B. L. 1995. Test of the linear-no threshold theory of radiation carcinogenesis for inhaled radon decay products. Health Phys. 68, 157-174.
9. Cohen, B. L. 1998a. Response to Lubin's proposed explanations of our discrepancy. Health Phys. 75, 18-22.
10. Cohen, B. L. 1998b. Response to criticisms of Smith et al. Health Phys. 75, 23-28.
11. Cohen, B. L. 1998c. Private Communication.
12. Cohen, B. L. 1998d. Response to Archer. Health Phys. 75, 653-654.
13. Cohen, B. L. 1999. Validity of the linear-no threshold of radiation carcinogenesis in the low dose region. Technology 6, 43-61.
14. Cox, D. C. and Baybutt, P. 1981. Methods of uncertainty analysis: a comparative survey. Risk Anal. 1, 251-258.
15. Descartes, R. 1968. Discourse on the Method of Rightly Conducting the Reason and Seeking the Truth in the Sciences. 1637.
16. Reprinted in: R. Descartes. 1968. Discourse on Method and the Meditations. Penguin Books, New York, NY.
17. Field, R. W., Smith, B. J., and Lynch, C. F. 1998. Ecological bias revisited, a rejoinder to Cohen's response to residential 222Rn exposure and lung cancer: testing the linear no-threshold theory with ecologic data. Health Phys. 75, 31-33.
18. Friedlander, M. W. 1995. At the Fringes of Science, Chap. 11, "Political Pseudoscience", The Lysenko Affair. Westview Press, Boulder, CO.
19. ICRP (International Committee on Radiological Protection) 1991. Recommendations of the International Commission on Radiological Protection. Oxford: Pergamon Press; ICRP Publication 60.
20. Kalos, M. H. and Whitlock, P.A. 1986. Monte Carlo Methods. Wiley & Sons, New York, NY.
21. Kuhn, T. S. 1970. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
22. Lancaster, P. and Salkauskas, K. 1986. Curve and Surface Fitting: An Introduction, Academic Press, New York, NY.
23. Lett, J. 1990. A field guide to critical thinking. The Skeptical Inquirer, Winter.
24. Lubin, J. H. and Boice, J. D. 1997. Lung cancer risk from residential radon: meta-analysis of eight epidemiological studies. J. Natl. Cancer Inst. 89, 49-57.
25. Lubin, J. H. 1998a. On the discrepancy between epidemiologic studies in individuals of lung cancer and residential radon and Cohen's ecologic regression. Health Phys. 75, 4-10.
26. Lubin, J. H. 1998b. Rejoinder: Cohen's response to the discrepancy between epidemiologic studies in individuals of lung cancer and residential radon and Cohen's ecologic regression. Health Phys. 75, 29-30.
27. Lubin, J. H. 1999. Private communication.
28. Luckey, T. D. 1991. Radiation Hormesis. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
29. Medical Tribune News Service. 1999. A Researcher on Power Line Effects Said to Have Faked Data. Medical Tribune, June 22, 1999. (See also at http://www.medtrib.com/cgi-bin/medtrib/articles / /record?record=1482.)
30. NRC (National Research Council). 1980. Committee on the Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation (BEIR III), The Effects on Population of Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation. National Academy Press, Washington DC.
31. NRC (National Research Council). 1988. The Health Risks of Radon and Other Internally Deposited Alpha-Emitters: BEIR W. National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
32. NRC (National Research Council). 1990. Health Effects of Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation, BEIR V. National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
33. NRC (National Research Council). 1999. Health Effects of Exposure to Radon, BEIR VI. National Academy Press, Washington, DC. In print. Available at the National Academy Press website with URL: http://www.nap.edu/readingroom/ books/beir6/.
34. Popper, K. R. 1968. The Logic of Scientific Discovery. Harper & Row, New York, NY.
35. Scotti, J. V. 1998. Fleeting expectations: the tale of an asteroid. Sky & Telescope, 96 (1), 30-34.
36. Seiler, F. A. 1987. Error propagation for large errors. Risk Anal. 7, 509-518.
37. Seiler, F. A. and Alvarez, J. L. 1994a. The scientific method in risk assessment. Technol. J. Franklin Inst. 331A, 53-58.
38. Seiler, F. A. and Alvarez, J. L. 1994b. The definition of a minimum significant risk. Technol. J. Franklin Inst. 331A, 83-95.
39. Seiler, F. A. and Alvarez, J. L. 1995. Toward a new risk assessment paradigm: variability, uncertainty, and errors. Technol. J. Franklin Inst., 332A, 221-235.
40. Seiler, F. A. and Alvarez, J. L. 1998a. Toward a new risk assessment paradigm: logical thresholds in linear and non-linear risk models. Technol. J. Franklin Inst. 335A, 31-34.
41. Seiler, F. A. and Alvarez, J. L. 1998b. On the use of the term Uncertainty. Hum. Ecol. Risk Assess. 4, 1041-1043.
42. Smith, B. J., Field, R. W., and Lynch, C. F. 1998. Residential 222Rn exposure and lung cancer: testing the linear no-threshold theory with ecologic data. Health Phys. 75, 10-17.
43. Sokal, R. R. and Rohlf, F.J. 1981. Biometry. Freeman, New York, NY.
44. Taubes, G. 1993. Bad Science: The Short Life and Very Hard Times of Cold Fusion. Random House, New York, NY.
45. Taylor, B. N. and Kuyatt, C. E. 1993. Guidelines for Evaluating and Expressing the Uncertainty of NIST Measurement Results. NIST Technical Note, TN 1297, Gaithersburg, MD.
46. Taylor, B. N. and Kuyatt, C. E. 1994. Guidelines for Evaluating and Expressing the Uncertainly of NIST Measurement Results. Appendix D: Clarification and Additional Guidance. NIST Technical Note, TN 1297, Gaithersburg, MD.
47. Thorne, K. S. 1994. Black Holes and Time Warps: Einstein's Outrageous Legacy. Norton & Co., New York, NY.
48. Walpole R. E. and Myers, R. H. 1985. Probability and Statistics for Engineers and Scientists. 3rd ed. Macmillan, New York, NY.