Golden ears and meter readers: The contest for epistemic authority in audiophilia

Social Studies of Science

Volumn 34, Issue 5, 2004, Pages 783-807

  Perlman, Marc ^a  

^a BROWN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Absolute sound; Alternative medicine; Digital versus analog; Double blind testing; Experimenter's regress; Listening

Indexed keywords

EID: 10244252779     PISSN: 03063127     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0306312704047613     Document Type: Article

References (71)

1. Akrich, Madeleine (1992) 'The De-Scription of Technical Objects', in W. Bijker & J. Law (eds), Shaping Technology/Building Society (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press): 205-24.
2. Anonymous (1990) 'Absolute', New Yorker (18 June): 28-29.
3. Atkinson, John (1988) 'Stereophile and You', Stereophile 11(10): 69-77.
4. Atkinson, John (1992a) 'The Puzzle of Perception', Stereophile 15(2): 7-11.
5. Atkinson, John (1992b) 'Who Are You?', Stereophile 15(6): 7-10.
6. Atkinson, John (1994) 'Conflicts', Stereophile 17(6): 3.
7. Bailar, J. (2001) 'The Powerful Placebo and the Wizard of Oz', New England Journal of Medicine 344(21): 1630-32.
8. Bodewitz, Henk, Henk Buurma & Gerard de Vries (1987) 'Regulatory Science and the Social Management of Trust in Medicine', in Wiebe E. Bijker, Thomas P. Hughes & Trevor J. Pinch (eds), The Social Construction of Technological Systems (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press): 243-59.
9. Brown, Phil (1992) 'Popular Epidemiology and Toxic Waste Contamination: Lay and Professional Ways of Knowing', Journal of Health and Social Behavior 33: 267-81.
10. Cohen, Robert A. (1993) 'Analogue Lives!', The Absolute Sound 18(87): 17-18.
11. Collins, H.M. (1985) Changing Order (London: SAGE).
12. Collins, H.M. & Trevor Pinch (1998) The Golem at Large (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
13. Coulter, Harris (1984) 'Homoeopathy', in J. Warren Salmon (ed.), Alternative Medicines: Popular and Policy Perspectives (New York: Tavistock): 57-79.
14. Cowan, Ruth Schwartz (1987) 'The Consumption Junction', in W. Bijker, T. Hughes & T. Pinch (eds), The Social Construction of Technological Systems (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press): 261-80.
15. Denby, David (1990) 'Twin Tweaks', New York 23(27): 44-45 (16 July).
16. Eargle, John (1990) 'An 'Earing 'Earing', Audio 74(9) (September): 25-32.
17. Epstein, Steven (1995) 'The Construction of Lay Expertise: AIDS Activism and the Forging of Credibility in the Reform of Clinical Trials', Science, Technology, and Human Values 20(4):408-37.
18. Fantel, Hans (1986a) 'Debate over Analog vs. Digital may be Pointless', New York Times (8 June) Sec. 2: 26.
19. Fantel, Hans (1986b) 'Numbers Aren't Always a True Measure of Quality', New York Times (3 August) Sec. 2: 21.
20. Fantel, Hans (1990) 'Brush Aside the Idea of Painting CD's', New York Times (3 June) Sec. 2: 26.
21. Glick, Stewart (1993) 'Audiophilia Nervosa', Stereophile 16(4): 67-69.
22. Greene, Robert E. (1993) 'On the Record', Absolute Sound 17(86): 190-94.
23. Hamm, Russell O. (1973) 'Tubes Versus Transistors - Is There an Audible Difference?', Journal of the Audio Engineering Society 21(4): 267-73.
24. Harley, Robert (1990) 'Deeper Meanings', Stereophile 13(7): 5-15.
25. Harley, Robert (1994) 'Critical Listening', Stereophile 17(7): 52-77.
26. Heyser, Richard (1974) 'Geometrical Considerations of Subjective Audio', Journal of the Audio Engineering Society 22: 674-82.
27. Heyser, Richard (1977) 'Perception and Geometry', Audio 61(6) (June): 52-60.
28. Heyser, Richard (1988) An Anthology of the Works of Richard C. Heyser on Measurement, Analysis, and Perception (New York: Audio Engineering Society).
29. Hirsch, Julian (1992) 'The Quest for Audio Perfection', Stereo Review 57(10): 26.
30. Hodges, Ralph (1990) 'Testing', Stereo Review 55 (October): 128.
31. Holt, J. Gordon (1992) 'How It All Began', Stereophile 15(1): 101.
32. Holt, J. Gordon (1993) 'Sounds Like?', Stereophile 16(7): 59-69.
33. Hróbartsson, A. & P. Gøtzsche (2001) 'Is the Placebo Powerless?', New England Journal of Medicine 344(21) (24 May): 1594-1602.
34. Kaptchuk, Ted & David Eisenberg (2001) 'Varieties of Healing 1: Medical Pluralism in the United States', Annals of Internal Medicine 135(3): 189-95.
35. Keightley, Keir (1996) '"Turn it Down!" She Shrieked: Gender, Domestic Space, and High Fidelity, 1948-59', Popular Music 15(2): 149-77.
36. Kessler, Ken (1991) 'Industry Update', Stereophile 14(1): 53-57.
37. Klein, Larry (1978) 'Stereo Review's Larry Klein Discusses Component Differences', The Absolute Sound 4(13): 7.
38. Klein, Larry (1992) 'Testing the Testers', Radio Electronics 63(6): 76-77.
39. Kline, Ronald & Trevor Pinch (1996) 'Users as Agents of Technological Change', Technology and Culture 37: 763-95.
40. Kuhn, Thomas (1957) The Copernican Revolution (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
41. Lie, Merete & K.H. Sorensen (eds) (1996) Making Technology Our Own? (Oslo: Scandinavian University Press).
42. Lindsay, Christina (2003) 'From the Shadows: Users as Designers, Producers, Marketers, Distributors, and Technical Support', in N. Oudshoorn & T. Pinch (eds), How Users Matter (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press): 29-50.
43. Lofft, Alan (1982) 'Sense and Nonsense in High-End Hi-Fi', Stereo Review 47(10) (October): 62-69.
44. Metaxas, Kostas (1991) 'Harry Pearson's "The Absolute Sound"', Vive Magazine. 〈www.vivelavie.com/vivestories2/harrypearson.html〉, accessed 3 April 1998.
45. Miller, Thomas O. (1993) 'Toward a Definition of Musicality', Absolute Sound 17(85): 68-91.
46. Monaghan, Lee (1999) 'Challenging Medicine? Bodybuilding, Drugs, and Risk', Sociology of Health and Illness 21(6): 707-34.
47. Nork, John (1993) 'The Dangers of Reviewing', Absolute Sound 18(88): 4-10.
48. Nousaine, Tom (1997) 'Flying Blind: The Case Against Long-Term Listening', Audio 81(5) (March): 26-30.
49. O'Connell, Joseph (1992) 'The Fine-Tuning of a Golden Ear: High-End Audio and the Evolutionary Model of Technology', Technology and Culture 33: 1-37.
50. Oudshoorn, Nelly & Trevor Pinch (eds) (2003) How Users Matter (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
51. Pae, Kyle (1996) 'The Usual Flak', Stereophile 19(6): 13-14.
52. Pearson, Harry (1973) 'Viewpoints', Absolute Sound 1(1): 4-6.
53. Perlman, Marc (2003) 'Consuming Audio: An Introduction to Tweak Theory', in R.T.A. Lysloff & L. Gay Jr (eds), Music and Technoculture (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press): 346-57.
54. Pietroni, Patrick (1991) The Greening of Medicine (London: Victor Gollancz).
55. Pinch, Trevor (1993) '"Testing - One, Two, Three . . . Testing!": Toward a Sociology of Testing', Science, Technology, and Human Values 18: 25-41.
56. Rosner, Alex (1990) 'Distortion in Wire - The Emperor's New Clothes', Sound and Communications 36(7): 18-21, 74.
57. Rothstein, Edward (1985) 'The Quest for Perfect Sound: The Myth of the CD and the Miracle of the LP', New Republic (30 December): 29.
58. Saks, Mike (1992) 'The Paradox of Incorporation: Acupuncture and the Medical Profession in Modern Britain', in M. Saks (ed.), Alternative Medicine in Britain (Oxford: Clarendon): 183-98.
59. Saks, Mike (1994) 'The Alternatives to Medicine', in J. Gabe, D. Kelleher & G. Williams (eds), Challenging Medicine (London: Routledge): 84-103.
60. Sanford, Paul (1989) 'Listening Tests and Contingency Tables', Stereophile 12(10): 33-37.
61. Scheiner, Bruce (1974) 'State-of-the-Art?', The Absolute Sound 1(4): 177-78.
62. Scull, Jonathan (1994) 'Shun Mook Resonance-Control Devices', Stereophile 17(2): 119-25.
63. Scull, Jonathan (1996) 'Four Tweaks and a Freebie', Stereophile 19(2): 177-83.
64. Self, D.R.G. (1988) 'Science v. Subjectivism in Audio Engineering', Electronic and Wireless World 94 (July): 692-96.
65. Strauss, Neil (1994) 'Music Lovers Are Voting for Vinyl', New York Times (8 December): C13.
66. Trumbull, Roy (1974) 'More About "Tubes Versus Transistors"', Journal of the Audio Engineering Society 22: 24.
67. Weaver, Donald (1994) 'Whither Shun Mook?', Stereophile 17(5): 17-21.
68. Williams, Gareth & Jennie Popay (1994) 'Lay Knowledge and the Privilege of Experience', in J.D. Gabe, D. Kelleher & G. Williams (eds), Challenging Medicine (London: Routledge): 118-39.
69. Willis, Barry (1994) 'The Art of Scientific Illusion', Stereophile 17(5): 49-51.
70. Wynne, Brian (1989) 'Sheepfarming after Chernobyl', Environment 31(2): 10-15, 33-39.
71. Zeugin, Michael (1993) 'Surrealistic Sound', Stereophile 16(11): 7-9.