Emerging nephron sparing treatments for kidney tumors: A continuum of modalities from energy ablation to laparoscopic partial nephrectomy

Journal of Urology

Volumn 171, Issue 2 I, 2004, Pages 553-560

  Mabjeesh, Nicola J ^a   Avidor, Yoav ^b   Matzkin, Haim ^c  

^a EMORY UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^b ETHICON INC   (United States)

^c TEL AVIV SOURASKY MEDICAL CENTER   (Israel)

Author keywords

Carcinoma, renal cell; Catheter ablation; Kidney neoplasms surgery; Nephrectomy methods; Surgical procedures, minimally invasive

Indexed keywords

CANCER CONTROL; CANCER SURVIVAL; CATHETER ABLATION; CLINICAL TRIAL; CRYOSURGERY; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; KIDNEY TUMOR; LAPAROSCOPIC PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY; MEDICAL LITERATURE; META ANALYSIS; MINIMALLY INVASIVE ABLATIVE THERAPY; MINIMALLY INVASIVE SURGERY; NEPHRON SPARING SURGERY; PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; PATIENT CARE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RADIOFREQUENCY RADIATION; REVIEW; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE;

EID: 0347759904     PISSN: 00225347     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/01.ju.0000093441.01453.68     Document Type: Review

References (75)

1. Novick, A. C.: Nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma. Annu Rev Med, 53: 393, 2002
2. Desai, M. M. and Gill, I. S.: Current status of cryoablation and radiofrequency ablation in the management of renal tumors. Curr Opin Urol, 12: 387, 2002
3. Fergany, A. F., Hafez, K. S. and Novick, A. C.: Long-term results of nephron sparing surgery for localized renal cell carcinoma: 10-year followup. J Urol, 163: 442, 2000
4. Steinbach, F., Stockle, M. and Hohenfellner, R.: Clinical experience with nephron-sparing surgery in the presence of a normal contralateral kidney. Semin Urol Oncol, 13: 288, 1995
5. Mukamel, E., Konichezky, M., Engelstein, D. and Servadio, C.: Incidental small renal tumors accompanying clinically overt renal cell carcinoma. J Urol, 140: 22, 1988
6. Winfield, H. N., Donovan, J. F., Godet, A. S. and Clayman, R. V.: Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: initial case report for benign disease. J Endourol, 7: 521, 1993
7. Gill, I. S., Delworth, M. G. and Munch, L. C.: Laparoscopic retroperitoneal partial nephrectomy. J Urol, 152: 1539, 1994
8. McDougall, E. M., Elbahnasy, A. M. and Clayman, R. V.: Laparoscopic wedge resection and partial nephrectomy-the Washington University experience and review of the literature. JSLS, 2: 15, 1998
9. Hoznek, A., Salomon, L., Antiphon, P., Radier, C., Hafiani, M., Chopin, D. K. et al: Partial nephrectomy with retroperitoneal laparoscopy. J Urol, 162: 1922, 1999
10. Harmon, W. J., Kavoussi, L. R. and Bishoff, J. T.: Laparoscopic nephron-sparing surgery for solid renal masses using the ultrasonic shears. Urology, 56: 754, 2000
11. Stifelman, M. D., Sosa, R. E., Nakada, S. Y. and Shichman, S. J.: Hand-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. J Endourol, 15: 161, 2001
12. Jeschke, K., Peschel, R., Wakonig, J., Schellander, L., Bartsch, G. and Henning, K.: Laparoscopic nephron-sparing surgery for renal tumors. Urology, 58: 688, 2001
13. Yoshimura, K., Okubo, K., Ichioka, K., Terada, N., Matsuta, Y. and Arai, Y.: Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy with a microwave tissue coagulator for small renal tumor. J Urol, 165: 1893, 2001
14. Gill, I. S., Desai, M. M., Kaouk, J. H., Meraney, A. M., Murphy, D. P., Sung, G. T. et al: Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal tumor: duplicating open surgical techniques. J Urol, 167: 469, 2002
15. Kim, F. J., Hsu, T. H., Su, L.-M., Pinto, P. A., Jarrett, T. W. and Kavoussi, L. R.: Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. J Urol, suppl., 167: 3, abstract 13, 2002
16. Itoh, K., Suzuki, Y., Miuru, M., Tsukigi, M., Ichiyanagi, O. and Sasagawa, I.: Posterior retroperitoneoscopic partial nephrectomy using microwave tissue coagulator for small renal tumors. J Endourol, 16: 367, 2002
17. Murota, T., Kawakita, M., Oguchi, N., Shimada, O., Danno, S., Fujita, I. et al: Retroperitoneoscopic partial nephrectomy using microwave coagulation for small renal tumors. Eur Urol, 41: 540, 2002
18. Hernandez, A. D., Smith, J. A. Jr., Jeppson, K. G. and Terreros, D. A.: A controlled study of the argon beam coagulator for partial nephrectomy. J Urol, 143: 1062, 1990
19. Jackman, S. V., Cadeddu, J. A., Chen, R. N., Micali, S., Bishoff, J. T., Lee, B. R. et al: Utility of the harmonic scalpel for laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. J Endourol, 12: 441, 1998
20. Elashry, O. M., Wolf, J. S., Jr., Rayala, H. J., McDougall, E. M. and Clayman, R. V.: Recent advances in laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: comparative study of electrosurgical snare electrode and ultrasound dissection. J Endourol, 11: 15, 1997
21. Janetschek, G., Daffner, P., Peschel, R. and Bartsch, G.: Laparoscopic nephron sparing surgery for small renal cell carcinoma. J Urol, 159: 1152, 1998
22. Rozet, F., Mongiat-Artus, P. and Desgrandchamps, F.: Hand-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy. Curr Opin Urol, 12: 229, 2002
23. Ogan, K. and Cadeddu, J. A.: Minimally invasive management of the small renal tumor: review of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy and ablative techniques. J Endourol, 16: 635, 2002
24. Hafez, K. S., Fergany, A. F. and Novick, A. C.: Nephron sparing surgery for localized renal cell carcinoma: impact of tumor size on patient survival, tumor recurrence and TNM staging. J Urol, 162: 1930, 1999
25. Rassweiler, J. J., Abbou, C., Janetschek, G. and Jeschke, K.: Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. The European experience. Urol Clin North Am, 27: 721, 2000
26. Murphy, D. P. and Gill, I. S.: Energy-based renal tumor ablation: a review. Semin Urol Oncol, 19: 133, 2001
27. Michaels, M. J., Rhee, H. K., Mourtzinos, A. P., Summerhayes, I. C., Silverman, M. L. and Libertino, J. A.: Incomplete renal tumor destruction using radio frequency interstitial ablation. J Urol, 168: 2406, 2002
28. Rendon, R. A., Kachura, J. R., Sweet, J. M., Gertner, M. R., Sherar, M. D., Robinette, M. et al: The uncertainty of radio frequency treatment of renal cell carcinoma: findings at immediate and delayed nephrectomy. J Urol, 167: 1587, 2002
29. Gill, I. S., Novick, A. C., Meraney, A. M., Chen, R. N., Hobart, M. G., Sung, G. T. et al: Laparoscopic renal cryoablation in 32 patients. Urology, 56: 748, 2000
30. Shingleton, W. B. and Sewell, P. E., Jr.: Percutaneous renal cryoablation of renal tumors in patients with von Hippel-Lindau disease. J Urol, 167: 1268, 2002
31. Woolley, M. L., Schulsinger, D. A., Durand, D. B., Zeltser, I. S. and Waltzer, W. C.: Effect of freezing parameters (freeze cycle and thaw process) on tissue destruction following renal cryoablation. J Endourol, 16: 519, 2002
32. Orihuela, E., van Sonnenberg, E., Montamedi, M., Bell, B. and Warren, M.: Effect of warm arterial blood flow and multiple cryotherapy probes on cryotherapy of renal cell carcinoma (RCC). J Endourol, suppl., 13: A13, 1999
33. Chosy, S. G., Nakada, S. Y., Lee, F. T., Jr. and Warner, T. F.: Monitoring renal cryosurgery: predictors of tissue necrosis in swine. J Urol, 159: 1370, 1998
34. Shingleton, W. B. and Sewell, P. E., Jr.: Percutaneous renal tumor cryoablation with magnetic resonance imaging guidance. J Urol, 165: 773, 2001
35. Mogami, T., Dohi, M., Harada, J., Fukuda, K., Komura, K. and Takahashi, T.: A new image navigation system in MR-guided cryosurgery. Presented at Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of Radiological Society of North America, Chicago, Illinois, December 1-6, 2002
36. Nakada, S. Y., Lee, F. T., Jr., Warner, T., Chosy, S. G. and Moon, T. D.: Laparoscopic cryosurgery of the kidney in the porcine model: an acute histological study. Urology, 51: 161, 1998
37. Stephenson, R. A., King, D. K. and Rohr, L. R.: Renal cryoablation in a canine model. Urology, 47: 772, 1996
38. Savage, S. J. and Gill, I. S.: Renal tumor ablation: energy-based technologies. World J Urol, 18: 283, 2000
39. Pantuck, A. J., Zisman, A., Cohen, J. and Belldegrun, A.: Cryosurgical ablation of renal tumors using 1.5-millimeter, ultra-thin cryoprobes. Urology, 59: 130, 2002
40. Uchida, M., Imaide, Y., Sugimoto, K., Uehara, H. and Watanabe, H.: Percutaneous cryosurgery for renal tumours. Br J Urol, 75: 132, 1995
41. Delworth, M. G., Pisters, L. L., Fornage, B. D. and von Eschenbach, A. C.: Cryotherapy for renal cell carcinoma and angiomyolipoma. J Urol, 155: 252, 1996
42. Gill, I. S., Novick, A. C., Soble, J. J., Sung, G. T., Remer, E. M., Hale, J. et al: Laparoscopic renal cryoablation: initial clinical series. Urology, 52: 543, 1998
43. Bishoff, J. T., Chen, R. B., Lee, B. R., Chan, D. Y., Huso, D., Rodriguez, R. et al: Laparoscopic renal cryoablation: acute and long-term clinical, radiographic, and pathologic effects in an animal model and application in a clinical trial. J Endourol, 13: 233, 1999
44. Rodriguez, R., Chan, D. Y., Bishoff, J. T., Chen, R. B., Kavoussi, L. R., Choti, M. A. et al: Renal ablative cryosurgery in selected patients with peripheral renal masses. Urology, 55: 25, 2000
45. Rukstalis, D. B., Khorsandi, M., Garcia, F. U., Hoenig, D. M. and Cohen, J. K.: Clinical experience with open renal cryoablation. Urology, 57: 34, 2001
46. Sung, G. T., Meraney, A. M., Schweizer, D. K., Novick, A. C. and Gill, I. S.: Laparoscopic renal cryoablation in 50 patients: intermediate follow-up. J Urol, suppl., 165: 158, abstract 649, 2001
47. Campbell, S. C., Novick, A. C., Herts, B., Fischler, D. F., Meyer, J., Levin, H. S. et al: Prospective evaluation of fine needle aspiration of small, solid renal masses: accuracy and morbidity. Urology, 50: 25, 1997
48. Zlotta, A. R., Wildschutz, T., Raviv, G., Peny, M. O., van Gansbeke, D., Noel, J. C. et al: Radiofrequency interstitial tumor ablation (RITA) is a possible new modality for treatment of renal cancer: ex vivo and in vivo experience. J Endourol, 11: 251, 1997
49. Dickson, J. A. and Calderwood, S. K.: Temperature range and selective sensitivity of tumors to hyperthermia: a critical review. Ann N Y Acad Sci, 335: 180, 1980
50. Wood, B. J., Ramkaransingh, J. R., Fojo, T., Walther, M. M. and Libutti, S. K.: Percutaneous tumor ablation with radiofrequency. Cancer, 94: 443, 2002
51. Munver, R., Threatt, C. B., Delvecchio, F. C., Preminger, G. M. and Polascik, T. J.: Hypertonic saline-augmented radiofrequency ablation of the VX-2 tumor implanted in the rabbit kidney: a short-term survival pilot study. Urology, 60: 170, 2002
52. Ogan, K., Jacomides, L., Dolmatch, B. L., Rivera, F. J., Dellaria, M. F., Josephs, S. C. et al: Percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of renal tumors: technique, limitations, and morbidity. Urology, 60: 954, 2002
53. Crowley, J. D., Shelton, J., Iverson, A. J., Burton, M. P., Dalrymple, N. C. and Bishoff, J. T.: Laparoscopic and computed tomography-guided percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of renal tissue: acute and chronic effects in an animal model. Urology, 57: 976, 2001
54. Walther, M. M., Shawker, T. H., Libutti, S. K., Lubensky, I., Choyke, P. L., Venzon, D. et al: A phase 2 study of radio frequency interstitial tissue ablation of localized renal tumors. J Urol, 163: 1424, 2000
55. de Baere, T., Kuoch, V., Smayra, T., Dromain, C., Cabrera, T., Court, B. et al: Radio frequency ablation of renal cell carcinoma: preliminary clinical experience. J Urol, 167: 1961, 2002
56. Matlaga, B. R., Zagoria, R. J., Woodruff, R. D., Torti, F. M. and Hall, M. C.: Phase II trial of radio frequency ablation of renal cancer: evaluation of the kill zone. J Urol, 168: 2401, 2002
57. Gervais, D. A., Arellano, R. S., McGovern, F. J., McDougal, W. S. and Mueller, P. R.: The influence of the central tumor component on effectiveness of RF ablation of renal masses. Does central extension preclude successful ablation? Presented at Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of Radiological Society of North America, Chicago, Illinois, December 1-6, 2002
58. Roy-Choudhury, S. H., Cast, J. E., Lee-Elliott, C. E. and Breen, D. J.: Percutaneous radiofrequency ablation (RFA) of small renal cell carcinoma (RCC)-medium-term outcome. Presented at Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of Radiological Society of North America, Chicago, Illinois, December 1-6, 2002
59. Hsu, T. H., Fidler, M. E. and Gill, I. S.: Radiofrequency ablation of the kidney: acute and chronic histology in porcine model. Urology, 56: 872, 2000
60. Collyer, W. C., Landman, J., Olweny, E. O., Andreoni, C., Kerbl, K., Bostwick, D. G. et al: Comparison of renal ablation with cryotherapy, dry radiofrequency, and saline augmented radiofrequency in a porcine model. J Am Coll Surg, 193: 505, 2001
61. Ogan, K., Cadeddu, J. A. and Sagalowsky, A. I.: Radio frequency ablation induced acute renal failure. J Urol, 168: 186, 2002
62. ter Haar, G.: High intensity ultrasound. Semin Laparosc Surg, 8: 77, 2001
63. Madersbacher, S., Kratzik, C., Susani, M., Pedevilla, M. and Marberger, M.: Transcutaneous high-intensity focused ultrasound and irradiation: an organ-preserving treatment of cancer in a solitary testis. Eur Urol, 33: 195, 1998
64. Uchida, T., Sanghvi, N. T., Gardner, T. A., Koch, M. O., Ishii, D., Minei, S. et al: Transrectal high-intensity focused ultrasound for treatment of patients with stage T1b-2n0m0 localized prostate cancer: a preliminary report. Urology, 59: 394, 2002
65. Vallancien, G., Harouni, M., Guillonneau, B., Veillon, B. and Bougaran, J.: Ablation of superficial bladder tumors with focused extracorporeal pyrotherapy. Urology, 47: 204, 1996
66. Watkin, N. A., Morris, S. B., Rivens, I. H. and ter Haar, G. R.: High-intensity focused ultrasound ablation of the kidney in a large animal model. J Endourol, 11: 191, 1997
67. Vallancien, G., Chartier-Kastler, E., Harouni, M., Chopin, D. and Bougaran, J.: Focused extracorporeal pyrotherapy: experimental study and feasibility in man. Semin Urol, 11: 7, 1993
68. Köhrmann, K. U., Michel, M. S., Gaa, J., Marlinghaus, E. and Alken, P.: High intensity focused ultrasound as noninvasive therapy for multilocal renal cell carcinoma: case study and review of the literature. J Urol, 167: 2397, 2002
69. Lynch, J. H. and Hofner, K.: Transurethral microwave thermotherapy. Eur Urol, 35: 129, 1999
70. Strickland, A. D., Clegg, P. J., Cronin, N. J., Swift, B., Festing, M., West, K. P. et al: Experimental study of large-volume microwave ablation in the liver. Br J Surg, 89: 1003, 2002
71. de Jode, M. G., Vale, J. A. and Gedroyc, W. M.: MR-guided laser thermoablation of inoperable renal tumors in an open-configuration interventional MR scanner: preliminary clinical experience in three cases. J Magn Reson Imaging, 10: 545, 1999
72. Williams, J. C., Morrision, P. M., Swishchuk, P. N. and Chaio, J.: Laser induced thermotherapy of renal cell carcinoma in mandosimetry, ultrasound and histopathologic correlation. J Urol, suppl., 163: 9, abstract 38, 2000
73. Chan, D. Y., Koniaris, L., Magee, C., Ferrell, M., Solomon, S., Lee, B. R. et al: Feasibility of ablating normal renal parenchyma by interstitial photon radiation energy: study in a canine model. J Endourol, 14: 111, 2000
74. Chow, W. H., Devesa, S. S., Warren, J. L. and Fraumeni, J. F., Jr.: Rising incidence of renal cell cancer in the United States. JAMA, 281: 1628, 1999
75. Visioli, A. G., Rivens, I. H., ter Haar, G. R., Horwich, A., Huddart, R. A., Moskovic, E. et al: Preliminary results of a phase I dose escalation clinical trial using focused ultrasound in the treatment of localised tumours. Eur J Ultrasound, 9: 11, 1999