Diagnosis and Management of Adults with Pharyngitis: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

Annals of Internal Medicine

Volumn 139, Issue 2, 2003, Pages 113-122

  Neuner, Joan M ^b   Hamel, Mary Beth ^b   Phillips, Russell S ^b   Bona, Kira ^b   Aronson, Mark D ^a  

^a BETH ISRAEL DEACONESS MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

^b NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

PENICILLIN DERIVATIVE;

ADULT; ANAPHYLAXIS; ANTIBIOTIC THERAPY; ARTICLE; CONSERVATIVE TREATMENT; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; COST UTILITY ANALYSIS; DIAGNOSTIC TEST; DRUG EFFICACY; EMPIRICAL THERAPY; HUMAN; IMMUNOASSAY; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MODEL; OBSERVATION; OPTICAL IMMUNOASSAY; PHARYNGITIS; PREVALENCE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY ADJUSTED LIFE YEAR; RHEUMATIC FEVER; STREPTOCOCCUS GROUP A; THROAT CULTURE; UNITED STATES; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM; DISEASE MANAGEMENT; ECONOMICS; METHODOLOGY; MICROBIOLOGICAL EXAMINATION; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; STREPTOCOCCUS INFECTION; STREPTOCOCCUS PYOGENES;

ADULT; BACTERIOLOGICAL TECHNIQUES; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; DECISION SUPPORT TECHNIQUES; DISEASE MANAGEMENT; HUMANS; IMMUNOASSAY; PENICILLINS; PHARYNGITIS; PREVALENCE; QUALITY-ADJUSTED LIFE YEARS; RHEUMATIC FEVER; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; STREPTOCOCCAL INFECTIONS; STREPTOCOCCUS PYOGENES;

EID: 0041302111     PISSN: 00034819     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.7326/0003-4819-139-2-200307150-00011     Document Type: Article

References (102)

1. Schappert SM. Ambulatory Care Visits to Physician's Offices, Hospital Out-patient Departments, and Emergency Departments: United States, 1996. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics; 1998.
2. Horder J, Horder E. Illness in general practice. Pract. 1954;173:177-87.
3. Goslings WR, Valkenberg HA, Bots AW, Lorrier JC. Attack rates of streptococcal pharyngitis, theumatic fever and glomerulonephritis in the general population. A controlled pilot study of streptococcal pharyngitis in one village. N Engl J Med. 1963;268:687-94.
4. Huovinen P, Lahtonen R, Ziegler T, Meurman O, Hakkarainen K, Miettinen A, et al. Pharyngitis in adults: the presence and coexistence of viruses and bacterial organisms. Ann Intern Med. 1989;110:612-6. [PMID: 2494921]
5. Petersen K, Phillips RS, Soukup J, Komaroff AL, Aronson M. The effect of erythromycin on resolution of symptoms among adults with pharyngitis not caused by group A streptococcus. J Gen Intern Med. 1997;12:95-101. [PMID: 9051558]
6. Komaroff AL, Pass TM, Aronson MD, Ervin CT, Cretin S, Winickoff RN, et al. The prediction of streptococcal pharyngitis in adults. J Gen Intern Med. 1986;1:1-7. [PMID: 3534166]
7. Gonzales R, Steiner JF, Sande MA. Antibiotic prescribing for adults with colds, upper tespiratory respiratory tract infections, and bronchitis by ambulatory care physicians. JAMA. 1997;278:901-4. [PMID: 9302241]
8. Mandell GL, Petri WA Jr. Antimicrobial agents: penicillins, cephalosporins, and other β-lactam antibiotics. In: Hardman JG, Limberd LE, eds. Goodman and Gilman's The Pharmacologic Basis of Therapeutics. New York: Churchill Livingstone; 1995:272-8.
9. deShazo RD, Kemp SF. Allergic reactions to drugs and biologic agents. JAMA. 1997;278:1895-906. [PMID: 9396651]
10. Bisno AL, Gerber MA, Gwaltney JM Jr, Kaplan EL, Schwartz RH. Diagnosis and management of group A streptococcal pharyngitis: a practice guideline. Infectious Diseases Society of America. Clin Infect Dis. 1997;25:574-83. [PMID: 9314443]
11. Linder JA, Stafford RS. Antibiotic treatment of adults with sore throat by community primary care physicians: a national survey, 1989-1999. JAMA. 2001;286:1181-6. [PMID: 11559262]
12. Stollerman GH. Global changes in group A streptococcal diseases and strategies for their prevention. Adv Intern Med. 1982;27:373-406. [PMID: 7041547]
13. Seppala H, Nissinen A, Jarvinen H, Huovinen S, Henriksson T, Herva E, et al. Resistance to erythromycin in group A streptococci. N Engl J Med. 1992;326:292-7. [PMID: 1728733]
14. Martin JM, Green M, Barbadora KA, Wald ER. Erythromycin-resistant group A streptococci in schoolchildren in Pittsburgh. N Engl J Med. 2002;346:1200-6. [PMID: 11961148]
15. Wallace MR, Garst PD, Papadimos TJ, Oldfield EC III. The return of acute rheumatic fever in young adults. JAMA. 1989;262:2557-61. [PMID: 2681847]
16. Veasy LG, Tani LY, Hill HR. Persistence of acute rheumatic fever in the intermountain area of the United States. J Pediatr. 1994;124:9-16. [PMID: 7802743]
17. Sanford JP. Management of pharyngitis in an era of declining incidence of rheumatic fever: an overview and synthesis. In: Shulman ST, ed. Pharyngitis: Management in an Era of Declining Rheumatic Fever. New York: Praeger; 1984:251-4.
18. Chamovitz R, Stetson CA, Rammelkamp CH. Prevention of rheumatic fever by treatment of previous streptococcal infections. N Engl J Med. 1954;251:466-71.
19. Brink WR, Denny FW, Wannamaker LW. Effect of penicillin and auromycin on the natural course of streptococcal tonsillitis and pharyngitis. Am J Med. 1951;10:300-8.
20. Brumfitt WS, Slater DH. Treatment of acute sore throat with penicillin: a controlled trial among young soldiers. Lancet. 1957;1:8-11.
21. Del Mar C. Managing sore throat: a literature review. II. Do antibiotics confer benefit? Med J Aust. 1992;156:644-9. [PMID: 1625619]
22. Del Mar CB, Glasziou PP, Spinks AB. Antibiotics for sote throat. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2002;2.
23. Baker DM, Cooper RM, Rhodes C, Weymouth LA, Dalton HP. Superiority of conventional culture technique over rapid detection of group A Streprococcus by optical immunoassay. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis. 1995;21:61-4. [PMID: 7628193]
24. Daly JA, Korgenski EK, Munson AC, Llausas-Magana E. Optical immunoassay for streprococcal pharyngiris: evaluation of accuracy with routine and mucoid strains associated with acute rheumatic fever outbreak in the intermountain area of the United States. J Clin Microbiol. 1994;32:531-2. [PMID: 8150968]
25. Fries SM. Diagnosis of group A streptococcal pharyngitis in a private clinic: comparadve evaluarion oran oprical comparative evaluation of an optical immunoassay method and culture. J Pediatr. 1995;126:933-6. [PMID: 7776098]
26. Gerber MA, Tanz RR, Kabat W, Dennis E, Bell GL, Kaplan EL, et al. Optical immunoassay test for group A beta-hemolytic streptococcal pharyngitis. An office-based, multicenter investigation. JAMA. 1997;277:899-903. [PMID: 9062328]
27. Harbeck RJ, Teague J, Crossen GR, Maul DM, Childers PL. Novel, rapid optical immunoassay technique for detection of group A streptococci from pharyngeal specimens: comparison with standard culture methods. J Clin Microbiol. 1993;31:839-44. [PMID: 8463394]
28. Heiter BJ, Bourbeau PP. Comparison of two rapid streptococcal antigen detection assays with culture for diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis. J Clin Microbiol. 1995;33:1408-10. [PMID: 7615768]
29. Kaltwasser G, Diego J, Welby-Sellenriek PL, Ferrett R, Caparon M, Storch GA. Polymerase chain reaction for Streptococcus pyogenes used to evaluate an optical immunoassay for the detection of group A streptococci in children with pharyngitis. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1997;16:748-53. [PMID: 9271035]
30. Kuhn S, Davies HD, Katzko G, Jadavji T, Church DL. Evaluation of the Strep A OIA assay versus culture methods: ability to detect different quantities of group A Streptococcus. Diagn Mictobiol Infect Dis. 1999;34:275-80. [PMID: 10459477]
31. Pitetti RD, Drenning SD, Wald ER. Evaluation of a new rapid antigen detection kit for group A beta-hemolytic streptococci. Pediatr Emerg Care. 1998;14:396-8. [PMID: 9881982]
32. Schlager TA, Hayden GA, Woods WA, Dudley SM, Hendley JO. Optical immunoassay for rapid detection of group A beta-hemolytic streptococci. Should culture be replaced? Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1996;150:245-8. [PMID: 8603215]
33. Smith JM, Bauman MC, Fuchs PC. An optical immunoassay for the direct detection of group A srrep antigen. Laboratory Medicine. 1995;26:408-10.
34. Centor RM, Witherspoon JM, Dalton HP, Brody CE, Link K. The diagnosis of strep throat in adults in the emergency room. Med Decis Making. 1981;1:239-46. [PMID: 6763125]
35. Cooper RJ, Hoffman JR, Bartlett JG, Besser RE, Gonzales R, Hickner JM, et al. Principles of appropriate antibiotic use for acute pharyngitis in adults: background. Ann Intern Med. 2001;134:509-17. [PMID: 11255530]
36. Snow V, Mottur-Pilson C, Cooper RJ, Hoffman JR. Principles of appropriate antibiotic use for acute pharyngitis in adults. American Academy of Family Physicians, American College of Physicians-American Society of Internal Medicine, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Ann Intern Med. 2001;134:506-8. [PMID: 11255529]
37. Hillner BE, Smith TJ, Desch CE. Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of autologous bone marrow transplantation in metastatic breast cancer. Estimates using decision analysis while awaiting clinical trial results. JAMA. 1992;267:2055-61. [PMID: 1552641]
38. Gonzales R, Bartlett JG, Besser RE, Cooper RJ, Hickner JM, Hoffman JR, et al. Principles of appropriate antibiotic use for treatment of acute respiratory tract infections in adults: background, specific aims, and methods. Ann Intern Med. 2001;134:479-86. [PMID: 11255524]
39. Dajani A, Taubert K, Ferrieri P, Peter G, Shulman S. Treatment of acute streptococcal pharyngitis and prevention of rheumatic fever: a statement for health professionals. Committee on Rheumatic Fever, Endocarditis, and Kawasaki Disease of the Council on Cardiovascular Disease in the Young, the American Heart Association. Pediatrics. 1995;96:758-64. [PMID: 7567345]
40. Gold MR, Siegel JE, Russell LB, Weinstein MC. Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine. New York: Oxford Univ Pr; 1996.
41. Weinstein MC, Siegel JE, Gold MR, Kamlet MS, Russell LB. Recommendations of the Panel on Cost-effectiveness in Health and Medicine. JAMA. 1996;276:1253-8. [PMID: 8849754]
42. Zwart S, Sachs AP, Ruijs GJ, Gubbels JW, Hoes AW, de Melker RA. Penicillin for acute sore throat: randomised double blind trial of seven days versus three days treatment or placebo in adults. BMJ. 2000;320:150-4. [PMID: 10634735]
43. Little P, Williamson I, Warner G, Gould C, Gantley M, Kinmonth AL. Open randomised trial of prescribing strategies in managing sore throat. BMJ. 1997;314:722-7. [PMID: 9116551]
44. Dagnelie CF, van der Graaf Y, De Melker RA. Do patients with sore throat benefit from penicillin? A randomized double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial with penicillin V in general practice. Br J Gen Pract. 1996;46:589-93. [PMID: 8945796]
45. Webb KH. Does culture confirmation of high-sensitivity rapid streptococcal tests make sense? A medical decision analysis. Pediatrics. 1998;101:E2. [PMID: 9445512]
46. Tsevat J, Kotagal UR. Management of sore throats in children: a cost-effectiveness analysis. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1999;153:681-8. [PMID: 10401800]
47. Ebell MH, Smith MA, Barry HC, Ives K, Carey M. The rational clinical examination. Does this patient have strep throat? JAMA. 2000;284:2912-8. [PMID: 11147989]
48. Hoffman S. An algorithm for a selective use of throat swabs in the diagnosis of group A streptococcal pharyngo-tonsillitis in general practice. Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care. 1992;10:295-300.
49. Walsh BT, Bookheim WW, Johnson RC, Tompkins RK. Recognition of streptococcal pharyngitis in adults. Arch Intern Med. 1975;135:1493-7. [PMID: 1103766]
50. Dobbs F. A scoring system for predicting group A streptococcal throat infection. Br J Gen Pract. 1996;46:461-4. [PMID: 8949324]
51. Wigton RS, Connor JL, Centor RM. Transportability of a decision rule for the diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis. Arch Intern Med. 1986;146:81-3. [PMID: 3510600]
52. Meland E, Digranes A, Skjaerven R. Assessment of clinical features predicting streptococcal pharyngitis. Scand J Infect Dis. 1993;25:177-83. [PMID: 8511511]
53. Poses RM, Cebul RD, Collins M, Fager SS. The importance of disease prevalence in transporting clinical prediction rules. The case of streptococcal pharyngitis. Ann Intern Med. 1986;105:586-91. [PMID: 3530079]
54. Holmberg SD, Faich GA. Streptococcal pharyngitis and acute rheumatic fever in Rhode Island. JAMA. 1983;250:2307-12. [PMID: 6355522]
55. Gerber MA. Comparison of throat cultures and rapid strep tests for diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1989;8:820-4. [PMID: 2687791]
56. Centor RM, Meier FA, Dalton HP. Throat cultures and rapid tests for diagnosis of group A streptococcal pharyngitis. Ann Intern Med. 1986;105:892-9. [PMID: 3535604]
57. Savoia D, Francesetti C, Millesimo M, Dotti G, Gatti G, Rurali C. Evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of a kit for the rapid detection of group A streptococci. Microbios. 1994;77:253-9. [PMID: 8208140]
58. Hoffmann S. Detection of group A streptococcal antigen from throat swabs with five diagnostic kits in general practice. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis. 1990;13:209-15. [PMID: 2200635]
59. Wegner DL, Witte DL, Schrantz RD. Insensitivity of rapid antigen detection methods and single blood agar plate culture for diagnosing streptococcal pharyngitis. JAMA. 1992;267:695-7. [PMID: 1731138]
60. Hillner BE, Centor RM. What a difference a day makes: a decision analysis of adult streptococcal pharyngitis. J Gen Intern Med. 1987;2:244-50. [PMID: 3302145]
61. Feinstein AR, Harrison FW, Spagnuolo M, Taranta A, Jonas S, Kleinberg E, et al. Rheumatic fever in children and adolescents: a long-term epidemiologic study of subsequent prophylaxis, streptococcal infections, and clinical sequelae. Ann Intern Med. 1964;60:87-123.
62. De Meyere M, Mervielde Y, Verschraegen G, Bogaert M. Effect of penicillin on the clinical course of streptococcal pharyngitis in general practice. Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 1992;43:581-5. [PMID: 1493837]
63. Valkenburg HA, Haverkom MJ, Goslings WR, Lorrier JC, De Moor CE, Maxted WR. Streptococcal pharyngitis in the general population. II. The attack rate of rheumatic fever and acute glomerulonephritis in patients. J Infect Dis. 1971;124:348-58. [PMID: 5143843]
64. Denny LW, Hahn EO. Comparative effects of penicillin, auromycin and terramycin on streptococcal tonsillitis and pharyngitis. Pediatrics. 1953;11:7-14.
65. Little P, Gould C, Williamson I, Warner G, Gantley M, Kinmonth AL. Clinical and psychosocial predictors of illness duration from randomised controlled trial of prescribing strategies for sore throat. BMJ. 1999;319:736-7. [PMID: 10487997]
66. Tengs TO, Wallace A. One thousand health-related quality-of-life estimates. Med Care. 2000;38:583-637. [PMID: 10843310]
67. Herman JM. Patients' willingness to take risks in the management of pharyngitis. J Fam Pract. 1984;19:767-72. [PMID: 6502081]
68. Finkler SA. The distinction between cost and charges. Ann Intern Med. 1982;96:102-9. [PMID: 7053682]
69. Drug Topics Red Book. Montvale. NJ: Medical Economics; 2000.
70. Tsevat J, Duke D, Goldman L, Pfeffer MA, Lamas GA, Soukup JR, et al. Cost-effectiveness of captopril therapy after myocardial infarction. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1995;26:914-9. [PMID: 7560617]
71. Kirschner CG, Burkett RC, Kotowicz GM, et al. eds. Physicians' Current Procedural Terminology: CPT '97. Chicago: American Medical Assoc; 1997.
72. Health Care Financing Administration, Public Use Datafiles. 30 December 2000. Accessed at http://cms.hhs.gov/surveys/hos/pufs.asp on 1 December 2001.
73. Goldman L, Bennett JC, eds. Cecil Textbook of Medicine. 21st ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 2000.
74. Doubilet P, Begg CB, Weinstein MC, Braun P, McNeil BJ. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis using Monte Carlo simulation. A practical approach. Med Decis Making. 1985;5:157-77. [PMID: 3831638]
75. Tompkins RK, Burnes DC, Cable WE. An analysis of the cost-effectiveness of pharyngitis management and acute rheumatic fever prevention. Ann Intern Med. 1977;86:481-92. [PMID: 403842]
76. Wegner DL, Witte DL, Schrantz RD. Insensitivity of rapid antigen detection methods and single blood agar plate culture for diagnosing streptococcal pharyngitis. JAMA. 1992;267:695-7. [PMID: 1731138]
77. Roddey OF Jr, Clegg HW, Martin ES, Swetenburg RL, Koonce EW. Comparison of throat culture methods for the recovery of group A streptococci in a pediatric office setting. JAMA. 1995;274:1863-5. [PMID: 7500536]
78. Kaplan EL, Top FH Jr, Dudding BA, Wannamaker LW. Diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis: differentiation of active infection from the carrier state in the symptomatic child. J Infect Dis. 1971;123:490-501. [PMID: 5115179]
79. Gunnarsson RK, Holm SE, Soderstrom M. The prevalence of beta-haemolytic streptococci in throat specimens from healthy children and adults. Implications for the clinical value of throat cultures. Scand J Prim Health Care. 1997;15:149-55. [PMID: 9323783]
80. Butler CC, Rollnick S, Pill R, Maggs-Rapport F, Stott N. Understanding the culture of prescribing: qualitative study of general practitioners' and patients' perceptions of antibiotics for sore throats. BMJ. 1998;317:637-42. [PMID: 9727992]
81. Steinhoff MC, Abd el Khalek MK, Khallaf N, Hamza HS, el Ayadi A, Orabi A, et al. Effectiveness of clinical guidelines for the presumptive treatment of streptococcal pharyngitis in Egyptian children. Lancet. 1997;350:918-21. [PMID: 9314870]
82. Kljakovic M. Sore throat presentation and management in general practice. N Z Med J. 1993;106:381-3. [PMID: 8367095]
83. McIsaac WJ, White D, Tannenbaum D, Low DE. A clinical score to reduce unnecessary antibiotic use in patients with sore throat. CMAJ. 1998;158:75-83. [PMID: 9475915]
84. Komaroff AL, Pass TM, Aronson MD, Ervin CT, Cretin S, Winickoff RN, et al. The prediction of streptococcal pharyngitis in adults. J Gen Intern Med. 1986;1:1-7. [PMID: 3534166]
85. Crawford G, Brancato F, Holmes KK. Streptococcal pharyngitis: diagnosis by gram stain. Ann Intern Med. 1979;90:293-7. [PMID: 85421]
86. Moyer NP, Quinn PJ, Showalter CA. Evaluation of the Directigen 1,2,3 Group A Strep Test for diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis. J Clin Microbiol. 1990;28:1661-3. [PMID: 2199526]
87. Kellogg JA. Suitability of throat culture procedures for detection of group A streptococci and as reference standards for evaluation of streptococcal antigen detection kits. J Clin Microbiol. 1990;28:165-9. [PMID: 2179252]
88. Kellogg JA, Manzella JP. Detection of group A streptococci in the laboratory or physician's office. Culture vs antibody methods. JAMA. 1986;255:2638-42. [PMID: 3517397]
89. Wegner DL, Witte DL, Schrantz RD. Insensitivity of rapid antigen detection methods and single blood agar plate culture for diagnosing streptococcal pharyngitis. JAMA. 1992;267:695-7. [PMID: 1731138]
90. Bellon J, Weise B, Verschraegen G, De Meyere M. Selective streptococcal agar versus blood agar for detection of group A beta-hemolytic streptococci in patients with acute pharyngitis. J Clin Microbiol. 1991;29:2084-5. [PMID: 1774341]
91. Lauer BA, Reller LB, Mirrett S. Effect of atmosphere and duration of incubation on primary isolation of group A streptococci from throat cultures. J Clin Microbiol. 1983;17:338-40. [PMID: 6339551]
92. Graham L Jr, Meier FA, Centor RM, Garner BK, Dalton HP. Effect of medium and cultivation conditions on comparisons between latex agglutination and culture detection of group A streptococci. J Clin Microbiol. 1986;24:644-6. [PMID: 3095365]
93. Anhalt JP, Heiter BJ, Naumovitz DW, Bourbeau PP. Comparison of three methods for detection of group A streptococci in throat swabs. J Clin Microbiol. 1992;30:2135-8. [PMID: 1500522]
94. Fries SM. Diagnosis of group A streptococcal pharyngitis in a private clinic: comparative evaluation of an optical immunoassay method and culture. J Pediatr. 1995;126:933-6. [PMID: 7776098]
95. Roddey OF Jr, Clegg HW, Martin ES, Swetenburg RL, Koonce EW. Comparison of throat culture methods for the recovery of group A streptococci in a pediatric office setting. JAMA. 1995;274:1863-5. [PMID: 7500536]
96. Centor RM, Dalton HP, Campbell MS, Lynch MR, Watlington AT, Garner BK. Rapid diagnosis of streptococcal pharyngitis in adult emergency room patients. J Gen Intern Med. 1986;1:248-51. [PMID: 3534175]
97. Siegel AC, Johnson EE, Stollerman G. Controlled studies of streptococcal pharyngitis in a pediatric population. I. Factors related to the attack rate of rheumatic fever. N Engl J Med. 1961;265:559-66.
98. Cantanzaro FJ, Morris AJ, Chamovitz R, Rammelkamp CH, Stolzer B, Perry WD. Symposium on rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease. The role of streptococcus in the pathogenesis of rheumatic fever. Am J Med. 1954;17:749-56.
99. Denny LW, Brink WR, Rammelkamp CH, Custer EA. Prevention of rheumatic fever: treatment of the preceding streptococcal infection. JAMA. 1950;143:151-3.
100. Wannamaker LW, Rammelkamp CH, Denny FW, Brink WR, Houser HB, Hahn EO. Prophylaxis of acute rheumatic fever by treatment of the preceding streptococcal infection with various amounts of depot penicillin. Am J Med. 1951;10:673-94.
101. Kirschner CG, Burkett RC, Kotowicz GM, et al., eds. Physicians' Current Procedural Terminology: CPT '95. Chicago: American Medical Assoc; 1994.
102. Tsevat J, Wong JB, Pauker SG, Steinberg MH. Neonatal screening for sickle cell disease: a cost-effectiveness analysis. J Pediatr. 1991;118:546-54. [PMID: 1901081]