Science and technology of novel processes for deep desulfurization of oil refinery streams: A review

Fuel

Volumn 82, Issue 6, 2003, Pages 607-631

  Babich, I V ^a,b   Moulijn, J A ^a  

^a DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Netherlands)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TWENTE   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Hydrodesulfurization; Oil refinery; Sulfur removal

Indexed keywords

ADSORPTION; CATALYSTS; DESULFURIZATION; DISTILLATION; OXIDATION;

HYDRODESULFURIZATION;

PETROLEUM REFINERIES;

EID: 0037374776     PISSN: 00162361     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0016-2361(02)00324-1     Document Type: Review

References (147)

1. Katzer J.R., Ramage M.P., Sapre A.V. Chem Engineering and Processing. 6:2000;41.
2. Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council. Brussels COM(2001) 11.05.2001 241final.
3. US EPA Clean Air Act Tier 2; 1999.
4. The Kyoto protocol to the convention of climate change; December 1997.
5. Venner S.F. Hydrocarbon Process. 5:2000;51.
6. Parkinson G., Crabb C., Enright A., Kamiya T., Ondrey G. Chem Engng. 8:1999;. 48R&P3.
7. Hattiangadi U., Spoor M., Pal S.C. Petr Tech Quart. 4:2000;35.
8. Miller R.B., Macris A., Gentry A.R. Petr Tech Quart. 2:2001;69.
9. Larivé J.F. Hydrocarbon Engng. 4:2000;15.
10. Gangwal S.K., Harkins S.M., Woods M.C., Jain S.C., Bossart S.J. Environ Progress. 8:1989;265.
11. Ayala RE, Venkataramani V. Technical report 98CRD179. GE Research & Development Center; 1998. 111p.
12. Khare G.P., Delzer G.A., Kubicek D.H., Greenwood G.J. Environ Progress. 14:1995;146.
13. Ben-Slimane R., Hepworth M.T. Energy Fuels. 9:1995;372.
14. Bakker W.J.W., Vriesendorp M., Kapteijn F., Moulijn J.A. Can J Chem Engng. 74:1996;713.
15. Bakker W.J.W., van Rossen J.C.P., Mugge J.M., Kapteijn F., Moulijn J.A. Atimtay A.T., Harrison D.P. NATO ASI series. G42:1998;243 Springer, Berlin.
16. Muñoz-Guillena M.J., Linares-Solano A. Salinas-Martínez de Lecea C. Appl Surf Sci. 99:1996;111.
17. Svoboda K., Lin W., Hannes J., Korbee R., van de Bleek C.M. Fuel. 73:1994;1144.
18. Akiti T.T. Jr., Constant K.P., Doraiswamy L.K., Wheelock T.D. Adv Environ Res. 5:2001;31.
19. Adáanez J., García-Labiano F., de Diego L.F., Fierro V. Energy Fuels. 12:1998;726.
20. Clarke S.C. Petr Tech Quart. 2:2001;77.
21. Topsøe H., Clausen B.S., Massoth F.E. Catalysis: science and technology. vol. 11:1996;. 310p.
22. Furimsky E., Massoth F.E. Catal Today. 27:1999;381.
23. Holbrook O.L. UOP Merox process. Meyers R.A. Handbook of petroleum refining processes. 1997;11.29 McGraw-Hill, New York.
24. Davis BH. AIChE Spring National Meeting 2000, Atlanta, GA; March 5-9, 2000. p. 68a.
25. Shafi R., Hutchings G.J. Catal Today. 59:2000;423.
26. Ma X., Sakanishi K., Mochida I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 33:1994;218.
27. Knudsen K.G., Cooper B.H., Topsøe H. Appl Catal A: Gen. 189:1999;205.
28. Vasudevan P.T., Fierro J.L.G. Catal Rev Sci Engng. 38:1996;161.
29. Gates B.C., Topsøe H. Polyhedron. 16:1997;3213.
30. Bataille F., Lemberton J.L., Michaud P., Pérot G., Vrinat M., Lemaire M., Schulz E., Breysse M., Kasztelan S. J Catal. 191:2000;409.
31. Lecrenay E., Sakanishi K., Mochida I. Catal Today. 39:1997;13.
32. Qabazard H., Abuseedo F., Stanislaus A., Andari M., Absihalabi M. Fuel Sci Technol Int. 13:1995;1135.
33. Iwamoto R., Grimblot J. J Catal. 172:1997;252.
34. Atanasova P., Vladov C., Halachev T., Fierro J.L.G., López Agudo A. Bull Soc Chim Belg. 104:1995;219.
35. Nagai M., Goto Y., Ishii H., Omi S. Appl Catal A: Gen. 192:2000;189.
36. Sajkowski DJ, Oyama ST. The Symposium on Chemistry of Transition Metal Sulfides in Heterogeneous Catalysis, Boston; April 22-27, 1990. p. 233.
37. Reinhoudt H.R., Troost R., van Schalkwijk S., van Langeveld A.D., Sie S.T., van Veen J.A.R., Moulijn J.A. Fuel Process Technol. 61:1999;117.
38. Reinhoudt H.R., Troost R., van Langeveld A.D., Sie S.T., van Veen J.A.R., Moulijn J.A. Fuel Process Technol. 61:1999;133.
39. Song C. CHEMTECH. 3:1999;26.
40. Yoshinaka S., Segawa K. Catal Today. 45:1998;293.
41. Ram̀rez J., Gutiérrez-Alejandre A. Catal Today. 43:1998;123.
42. Pawelec B., Mariscal R., Fierro J.L.G., Greenwood A., Vasudevan P.T. Appl Catal A: Gen. 206:2001;295.
43. Yoshimura Y., Yasuda H., Sato T., Kijima N., Kameoka T. Appl Catal A: Gen. 207:2001;303.
44. Michaud P., Lemberton J.L., Pérot G. Appl Catal A: Gen. 169:1998;343.
45. Ishihara A., Qian W.H., Kabe T. Sekiyu Gakkaishi (J Jpn Petr Inst). 44:2001;80.
46. Medici L., Prins R. J Catal. 163:1996;38.
47. Inamura K., Uchikawa K., Matsuda S., Akai Y. Appl Surf Sci. 121/122:1997;468.
48. Fedin V.P., Czyzniewska J., Prins R., Weber T. Appl Catal A: Gen. 213:2001;123.
49. Etienne E., Ponthieu E., Payen E., Grimblot J. J Non-Cryst Solids. 147/148:1992;764.
50. Labruyére F., Dufresne P., Lacroix M., Breysse M. Catal Today. 43:1998;111.
51. Mayo S., Brevoord E., Gerritsen L., Plantenga F. Hydrocarbon Process. 2:2001;84A.
52. Brevoord E, Gerritsen LA, Plantenga FL. The European Refinery Technology Conference, Rome, Italy; November 13-15, 2000.
53. Gerritsen LA, Stoop F, Low P, Townsend J, Waterfield D, Holder K. WEFA Conference, Berlin, Germany; June 2000.
54. Gerritsen LA, Eijsbouts S, Inoue Y, Desai PH. Catal Courier (Akzo Nobel) N34.
55. Mayo S, Plantenga F, Leliveld B, Miyauchi YA. NPRA 2001 Annual Meeing, AM-01-09, New Orleans; March 18-20, 2001.
56. Shiflett W. NPRA 2001 Annual Meeting, AM-01-29, New Orleans; March 18-20, 2001.
57. Reinhoudt HR. PhD Thesis. Delft University of Technology; 1999. 225p.
58. van der Linde B, Menon R, Davé D, Gustas S. Asian Refining Technology Conference, DD-ARTC-99; 1999. 24p.
59. Langston J., Allen L., Davé D. Petr Tech Quart. 2:1999;65.
60. Colyar JJ. Ebullated-bed reactor technology. IFP Industrial Division Reprint; 1997. 10p.
61. Billon A., Duddy J., Morel F., Wisdom L.I. Petr Tech Quart. 4:1999;51.
62. Kasztelan S, Morel F, Le Loarer JL, Sarrazin P, Plumail JC. NPRA 1999 Annual Meeting, AM-99-56, San Antonio, Texas; March 21-23, 1999.
63. Nocca JL, Cosyns J, Debuisschert Q, Didillon B. NPRA 2000 Annual Meeting, AM-00-61, San-Antonio, Texas; March 26-28, 2000. 14p.
64. Drake CA, Love SD. US Patent 6,083,379.
65. Martinez NP, Salazar JA, Tejada J, Antos GJ, Anand M, Houde EJ. NPRA 2000 Annual Meeting, AM-00-52, San-Antonio, Texas; March 26-28, 2000.
66. Gasoline sulfur reduction without octane loss. Chem Engng 2000;5:21.
67. UOP technical data sheet on ISAL process, Des Plaines, IL; 2000. 2p.
68. Salazar JA, Cabrera LM, Palmisano E, Garcia WJ, Solari RB. US Patent 5,770,047.
69. Rock KL. Japan Petroleum Institute Conference, Tokyo, Japan; October 2000.
70. Rock K.L., Foley R.M., Putman H.M., Bakshi A.S., Som M. Petr Tech Quart. 1:1998;51.
71. Foley R.M., Rock K.L., Bakshi A., Groten W., Gildert G., Weidert D., McGuirk T. Petr Tech Quart. 2:1998;71.
72. Peninger RS, Demeter JC, Schwarz EA, Rock KL. The European Refinery Technology Conference, Rome, Italy; November 13-15, 2000.
73. Wiltshire J. BP Technol Mag. 32:2000;10.
74. Burnett PT, Huff GA, Pradhan VR, Hodges M, Glassett JA, McDaniel SG, Hurst P. The European Refining Technology Conference, Rome, Italy; November 13-15, 2000.
75. BP tests alkylation/fractionation process for sulfur removal. Octane Week 9.10.2000.
76. Shiraishi Y., Taki Y., Hirai T., Komasawa I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 40:2001;1213.
77. Shiraishi Y., Taki Y., Hirai T., Komasawa I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 40:2001;1225.
78. Alexander BD, Huff GA, Pradhan VR, Reagan WJ, Cayton RH. US Patent 6,024,865.
79. BP Unveils OATS process; 99.5% desulfurization rates observed. Octane Week 4.12.2000.
80. Funakoshi I, Aida T. US Patent 5,753,102.
81. Forte P. US Patent 5,582,714.
82. Horii Yu, Onuki H, Doi S, Mori T, Takatori T, Sato H, Ookuro T, Sugawara T. US Patent 5,494,572.
83. Bonde SE, Chapados D, Gore WL, Dolbear G, Skov E. NPRA 2000 Annual Meeting, AM-00-25, San-Antonio, Texas; March 26-28, 2000.
84. Gentry JC, Lee FM, NPRA 2000 Annual Meeting, AM-00-35, San-Antonio, Texas; March 26-28, 2000. 16p.
85. Dolbear GE, Skov ER. ACS Division of Petroleum Chemistry. ACS National Meeting, San Francisco; March 2000. 7p.
86. Levy RE, Rappas AS, DeCanio SJ, Nero VP. NPRA 2001 Annual Meeting, AM-01-10, New Orleans; March 18-20, 2001.
87. Peckham J. Octane Week 15.01.2001.
88. Shake the sulfur right out of fuel. Chem Engng Proc 2001;5:15.
89. Scott CE, Altafulla JR, Bolívar C. 17th North American Catalysis Society Meeting 2001: horizons of catalysis, Toronto, Ontario, Canada; June 3-8, 2001. Technical program: 51.
90. Shiraishi Y., Hirai T., Komasawa I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 37:1998;203.
91. Shiraishi Y., Taki Y., Hirai T., Komasawa I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 38:1999;3310.
92. Shiraishi Y., Taki Y., Hirai T., Komasawa I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 38:1999;4538.
93. Shiraishi Y., Hirai T., Komasawa I. Ind Engng Chem Res. 40:2001;293.
94. Meille V., Shulz E., Vrinat M., Lemaire M. Chem Commun. 1998;305.
95. Milenkovic A., Shulz E., Meille V., Lofferda D., Forissier M., Vrinat M., Sautet P., Lemaire M. Energy Fuels. 13:1999;881.
96. Aida T., Yamamoto D., Iwata M., Sakata K. Rev Heteroatom Chem. 22:2000;241.
97. Ford JF, Rayne TA, Adlington DG. US Patent 3,341,448.
98. Salem A.B.S.H. Ind Engng Chem Res. 33:1994;336.
99. Salem A.B.S.H., Hamid H.S. Chem Engng Technol. 20:1997;342.
100. Savage DW, Kaul BK, Dupre GD, O'Bara JT, Wales WE, Ho TC. US Patent 5,454,933.
101. Irvine RL, Benson BA, Varraveto DM, Frye RA. NPRA 1999 Annual Meeting, AM-99-42, San Antonio, Texas; March 21-23, 1999.
102. Irvine R.L., Varraveto D.M. Petr Tech Quart. 3:1999;37.
103. Low-cost process for low-sulfur gasoline. Hydrocarbon Process 1999;5:39.
104. Irvine RL. US Patent 5,730,860.
105. Ma X., Schobert H.H. J Mol Catal A: Chem. 160:2000;409.
106. Black nad Veatch Pritchard Inc. Private communication.
107. Meier P.F., Reed L.E., Greenwood G.J. Hydrocarbon Engng. 1:2001;26.
108. Greenwood GJ, Kidd D, Reed L. NPRA 2000 Annual Meeting, AM-00-12, San-Antonio, Texas; March 26-28, 2000. 7p.
109. Parkinson G. Chem Engng. 8:2000;45.
110. Khare GP, Engelbert DR, Cass BW. US Patent 5,914,292.
111. Khare GP, Engelbert DR, Cass BW. US Patent 6,056,871.
112. Phillips announced S Zorb sulfur removal technology for diesel. News of Phillips Petroleum Company Media Relations; October 3, 2000.
113. Poels E.K., van Beek W.P., den Hoed W., Visser C. Fuel. 74:1995;1800.
114. Tawara K., Imai J., Iwanami H. Sekiyu Gakkaishi. 43:2000;105.
115. Tawara K., Nishimura T., Iwanami H. Sekiyu Gakkaishi. 43:2000;114.
116. Tawara K., Nishimura T., Iwanami H., Nishimoto T., Hasuike T. Sekiyu Gakkaishi. 44:2001;43.
117. Tawara K., Nishimura T., Iwanami H., Nishimoto T., Hasuike T. Ind Engng Chem Res. 40:2001;2367.
118. Kidd DR. US Patent 4,990,318.
119. Siriwardane R.V., Gardner T., Poston J.A. Jr., Fisher E.P., Miltz A. Ind Engng Chem Res. 39:2000;1106.
120. Stankiewicz A., Moulijn J.A. Chem Engng Prog. 96:2000;22.
121. Cybulski A., Moulijn J.A. Chemical industries. Chemical industries. vol. 71:1998;Marcel Dekker, New York. 670p.
122. Kapteijn F., Heiszwolf J.J., Nijhuis T.A., Moulijn J.A. CATTECH. 3:1999;24.
123. Cybulski A., Moulijn J.A. Catal Rev Sci Engng. 36:1994;179.
124. Beers A.E.W., Spruijt R.A., Nijhuis T.A., Kapteijn F., Moulijn J.A. Catal Today. 66:2001;175.
125. Kapteijn F., Nijhuis T.A., Heiszwolf J.J., Moulijn J.A. Catal Today. 66:2001;133.
126. Nijhuis T.A., Kreutzer M.T., Romijn A.C.J., Kapteijn F., Moulijn J.A. Catal Today. 66:2001;157.
127. Nijhuis T.A., Beers A.E.W., Vergunst T., Hoek I., Kapteijn F., Moulijn J.A. Catal Rev. 43:2001;345.
128. Beers A.E.W., Hoek I., Nijhuis T.A., Downing R.S., Kapteijn F., Moulijn J.A. Topics in catalysis. 13:2000;275.
129. Marin G.B., Hoebink J.H.B.J. CATTECH. 1:1997;137.
130. Misono M. CATTECH. 2:1998;53.
131. Twigg M.V., Wilkins A.J.J. Cybulski A., Moulijn J.A. Chemical industries. Chemical industries. vol. 71:1998;91 Marcel Dekker, New York.
132. Beretta A., Tronconi E., Groppi G., Forzatti P. Cybulski A., Moulijn J.A. Chemical industries. Chemical industries. vol. 71:1998;121 Marcel Dekker, New York.
133. Topsøe N.Y. CATTECH. 1:1997;125.
134. Sie S.T., Lebens P.J.M. Cybulski A., Moulijn J.A. Chemical industries. Chemical industries. vol. 71:1998;305 Marcel Dekker, New York.
135. Maxwell I.E. CATTECH. 1:1997;5.
136. van Hasselt B.W., Lebens P.J.M., Calis H.P.A., Kapteijn F., Sie S.T., Moulijn J.A., van den Bleek C.M. Chem Engng Sci. 54:1999;4791.
137. Satterfield C.N., Özel F. Ind Engng Chem Fundam. 16:1977;61.
138. Hatziantoniou V., Andersson B. Ind Engng Chem Fundam. 23:1984;82.
139. Irandoust S., Andersson B. Chem Engng Sci. 43:1988;1983.
140. Irandoust S., Andersson B., Bengtsson E., Siverström M. Ind Engng Chem Res. 28:1989;1489.
141. Andersson B., Irandoust S., Cybulski A. Modeling of monolith reactors in three-phase processes. Cybulski A., Moulijn J.A. Chemical industries. Chemical industries. vol. 71:1998;267 Marcel Dekker, New York.
142. Smits H.A., Stankiewicz A., Glasz W.C., Fogl T.H.A., Moulijn J.A. Chem Engng Sci. 51:1996;3019.
143. Smits H.A., Moulijn J.A., Glasz W.C., Stankiewicz A. React Kinet Catal Lett. 60:(2):1997;351.
144. van Hasselt B.W., Lindenbergh D.J., Calis H.P., Sie S.T., van den Bleek C.M. Chem Engng Sci. 52:1997;3901.
145. Weissman J.G. Fuel Process Technol. 50:1997;199.
146. Wachs IE. US Patent 6,028,228.
147. Wachs IE. US patent 6,084,135.