The unsteady aerodynamics of slender wings and aircraft undergoing large amplitude maneuvers

Progress in Aerospace Sciences

Volumn 39, Issue 2-3, 2003, Pages 185-248

  Nelson, Robert C ^a   Pelletier, Alain ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

AERODYNAMIC LOADS; COMPUTER SIMULATION; DELTA WING AIRCRAFT; FUSELAGES; MANEUVERABILITY; WINGS;

ROLLING DELTA WINGS;

FLIGHT DYNAMICS;

EID: 0037292759     PISSN: 03760421     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0376-0421(02)00088-X     Document Type: Review

References (170)

1. Herbst W.B. Future fighter technologies. J Aircr. 17(8):1980;561-566.
2. Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Aerodynamics of manoeuvring aircraft. Can Aeronaut Space J. 38(3):1992;106-115.
3. Kalviste J. Aircraft stability characteristics at high angles of attack. AGARD-CP-235, Paper #29, 1978.
4. Evans C. An investigation of large amplitude wing-rock. Aeronaut J. 88(873):1984;51-57.
5. Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Aerodynamic aspects of aircraft dynamics at high angles of attack. J Aircr. 20(9):1983;737-752.
6. Orlik-Rückemann K.J. Dynamic stability testing of aircraft - needs versus capabilities. Prog Aerosp Sci. 16(4):1975;431-447.
7. Brown C.E., Michael W.H. Jr. Effect of leading-edge separation on the lift of a delta wing. J R Aeronaut Sci. 21:1954;690-706.
8. Hummel D., Srinivasan P.S. Vortex breakdown effects on the low speed aerodynamic characteristics of slender delta wings in symmetrical flow. J R Aèronaut Soc. 71:1967;319-322.
9. Wentz WH. Wind tunnel investigations of vortex breakdown on slender sharp-edged wings. PhD thesis, University of Kansas, June 1968.
10. Wentz W.H., Kohlman D.L. Vortex breakdown on slender sharp edged wings. J Aircr. 8(3):1971;319-322. (AIAA Paper #69-778 July 14-16, 1969).
11. McKernan JF. An investigation of the breakdown of leading edge vortices on a delta wing at high angles of attack. Master's thesis, University of Notre Dame, January 1983.
12. McKernan JF, Nelson RC. An investigation of the breakdown of leading edge vortices on a delta wing at high angles of attack. AIAA Paper #83-2114, August 1983.
13. Lan CE, Hsu CH. Effects of vortex breakdown on longitudinal and lateral-directional aerodynamics of slender wings by the suction analogy. AIAA Paper #82-1385, August 1982.
14. Bradley R.G., Wray W.O. A conceptual study of leading-edge-vortex enhancement by blowing. J Aircr. 11(1):1973;33-38.
15. Campbell J.F. Augmentation of vortex lift by spanwise blowing. J Aircr. 13(9):1976;727-732.
16. Er-El J, Seginer A. Effects of spanwise blowing on pressure distribution and leading-edge vortex stability. ICAS-86-2.5.1, 15th Congress of the International Council of the Aeronautical Sciences, London, September 1986.
17. Visser KD, Iwanski KP, Nelson RC, Ng TT. Control of leading-edge vortex breakdown by blowing. AIAA Paper #88-0504, January 1988.
18. Iwanski KP, Ng TT, Nelson RC. An experimental investigation of delta wing vortex flow with and without external jet blowing. AIAA Paper #89-0084, January 1989.
19. Magness C, Robinson O, Rockwell D. Control of leading-edge vortices on a delta wing. AIAA Paper #89-0999, March 1989.
20. Gu W., Robinson O., Rockwell D. Control of vortices on a delta wing by leading-edge injection. AIAA J. 31(7):1976;1177-1186.
21. Mitchell A, Barberis D, Délery J. Oscillation of vortex breakdown location and its control by tangential blowing. AIAA Paper #98-2914, June 1998.
22. Mitchell AM, Molton P, Barberis D, Délery J. Control of vortex breakdown location by symmetric and asymmetric blowing. AIAA Paper #99-3652, June-July 1999.
23. Mitchell AM, Molton P, Barberis D, Délery J. Control of vortex breakdown location by symmetric and asymmetric blowing. AIAA Paper #99-3652, 1999.
24. Malcolm G.N. Forebody vortex control. Prog Aerosp Sci. 28:1991;171-234.
25. Malcolm GN, Ng TT. Forebody vortex manipulation for aerodynamic control of aircraft at high angles of attack. SAE Paper #892220, 1989.
26. Murri DG, Rao DM. Exploratory studies of actuated forebody strakes for yaw control at high angles of attack. AIAA Paper #87-2557-CP, 1987.
27. Malcolm GN, Ng TT, Lewis LL, Murri DG. Development of non-conventional control methods for high angle of attack flight using vortex manipulation. AIAA Paper #89-2192, 1989.
28. Brandon JM, Simon JM, Owens DB, Kiddy JS. Free-flight investigation of forebody blowing for stability and control. AIAA Paper #96-3444, July 1996.
29. Fisher DF, Murri DG, Lanser WR. Effect of actuated forebody strakes on the forebody aerodynamics of the NASA F-18 HARV. NASA TM-4774, October 1996.
30. Thompson JS, Fail RA, Inglesby JV. Low-speed wind-tunnel measurements of oscillatory lateral stability derivatives for a model of a slender aircraft (HP 115) including the effects of frequency parameter. Aeronautical Research Council, C.P. No. 1097, February 1969.
31. Ross A.J. Investigation of nonlinear motion experienced on a slender-wing research aircraft. J Aircr. 9(9):1972;625-631.
32. AGARD Advisory Report No. 155A. Maneuver limitations of combat aircraft, 1979.
33. Anderson SB, Ernst EA, Van Dyke RD. Flight measurements of the wing-dropping tendency of a stright-wing jet airplane at high subsonic Mach numbers. NACA RM A51B28, 1951.
34. Chambers JR, Anglin EL, Bowman Jr JS. Effects of a pointed nose on spin characteristics of a fighter airplane model including correlation with theoretical calculations. NASA TN D-5921, 1970.
35. Chambers JR, Gilbert WP, Grafton SB. Results of recent NASA studies on spin resistance. Stall/spin problems of military aircraft. AGARD-CP-199, June 1976.
36. Coe Jr PL, Chambers JR, Letko W. Asymmetric lateral-directional characteristics of pointed bodies of revolution at high angles of attack. NASA TN D-7095, 1972.
37. Critical review of methods to predict the buffet capability of aircraft. Advisory Group for Aerospace Research and Development, Paris, France. AGARD-R-623, September 1974.
38. The effects of buffeting and other transonic phenomena on maneuvering combat aircraft. AGARD-AR-82, 1975.
39. Peckham DH. Low speed wind tunnel tests on a series of uncambered slender pointed wings with sharp edges. A.R.C., R&M. No. 3186, December 1958.
40. Earnshaw PB, Lawford JA. Low-speed wind tunnel experiments on a series of sharp-edged delta wings. A.R.C., R&M. No. 3424, March 1964.
41. Hummel D. Untersuchungen über das Aufplatzen der Wu bei an Schlanken Deltaflügeln. Z Flugwiss. 13:1965.
42. Elle B.J. On the breakdown at high incidences of the leading edge vortices on delta wings. J R Aeronaut Soc. 64:1960;491-493.
43. Harvey J.K. Some observations of the vortex breakdown phenomena. J Fluid Mech. 14:1962;585-592.
44. Lowson M.V. Some experiments with vortex breakdown. J R Aeronaut Soc. 68:1964;343-346.
45. Lambourne NC, Bryer DW. The bursting of leading edge vortices - some observations and discussion of the phenomena. A.R.C., R&M. No. 3282, April 1961.
46. Earnshaw PB. An experimental investigation of the structure of a leading edge vortex. RAE Tech Note No. Aero. 2740, March 1961.
47. Peckham DH, Atkinson SA. Preliminary results of low speed wind tunnel tests on a gothic wing of aspect ratio 1.0. A.R.C., CP-508, April 1957.
48. Chu J, Luckring JM. Experimental surface pressure data obtained on 65° delta wing across Reynolds number and Mach number ranges. NASA TM-4645, February 1996.
49. Perry A., Chong M. A description of eddying motions and flow patterns using critical-point concepts. Annu Rev Fluid Mech. 19:1987;125-155.
50. Peake DJ, Tobak M. Three dimensional interactions and vortical flows with emphasis on high speeds. NASA TM-81169, AGARDograph No. 252, March 1980.
51. Délery J. Physique des Écoulements Tourbillonnaires. AGARD Symposium on Vortex Flow Aerodynamics, Scheveningen, The Netherlands, October 1990.
52. Délery J. Physics of vortical flows. J Aircr. 29(5):1992;856-876.
53. Payne FM. The structure of leading edge vortex flows including vortex breakdown. PhD dissertation, University of Notre Dame, May 1987.
54. Payne F.M., Ng T.T., Nelson R.C., Schiff L.B. Visualization and wake surveys of vortical flow over a delta wing. AIAA J. 26(2):1988;137-143.
55. Menke M., Yang H., Gursul I. Experiments on the unsteady nature of vortex breakdown over delta wings. Exp Fluids. 27:1999;262-272.
56. Pelletier A. An experimental investigation of vortex breakdown on slender delta-wing planforms. Master's thesis, University of Notre Dame, April 1994.
57. Pagan D., Solignac J.L. Experimental study of the breakdown of a vortex generated by a delta wing. Rech Aérosp. 3:1986;197-219.
58. Erickson GE. Vortex flow correlation. Tech Report AFWAL-TR-80-3143, 1980.
59. Lee MJ, Ho CM. Vortex dynamics of delta wings. In: Frontiers in experimental fluid mechanics, Lecture Notes in Engineering, vol. 46. Berlin: Springer, 1989. p. 365-427.
60. Délery J, Pagan D, Solignac JL. On the breakdown of the vortex induced by a delta wing. Colloquium on Vortex Control and Breakdown Behavior, Baden, Switzerland, ONERA TP 1987-105, April 6-7, 1987.
61. Brown G.L., Lopez J.M. Axisymmetric vortex breakdown part II. physical mechanisms J Fluid Mech. 221:1990;553-576.
62. Visser KD. An experimental analysis of critical factors involved in the breakdown process of leading edge vortex flows. PhD dissertation, University of Notre Dame, May 1991.
63. Visser K.D., Nelson R.C. Measurements of circulation and vorticity in the leading edge vortex of a delta wing. AIAA J. 31(1):1993;104-111.
64. Nelson RC, Visser KD. Breaking down the delta wing vortex: the role of vorticity in the breakdown process. AGARD Symposium on Vortex Flow Aerodynamics, Scheveningen, The Netherlands, October 1-4, 1990.
65. Hemsch M., Luckring J. Connection between leading-edge sweep, vortex lift, and vortex strength for delta wings. J Aircr. 7(5):1990;473-475.
66. Sychev V.V. Three dimensional hypersonic gas flow past slender bodies at high angles of attack. Prikl Mat Mech. 24:1960;205-212.
67. Wentz WH, MacMahon MC. Further experimental investigations of delta and double delta flowfields at low speeds. NASA CR-714, February 1967.
68. Smith JHB. Calculations of the flow over thick, conical, slender wings with leading edge separation. A.R.C., R&M. No. 3694, March 1971.
69. Leibovich S. The structure of vortex breakdown. Annu Rev Fluid Mech. 10:1978;221-246.
70. Leibovich S. Vortex stability and breakdown. AGARD-CP-342, No. 23, April 1983.
71. Leibovich S. Vortex stability and breakdown. survey and extension AIAA J. 22(9):1984;1192-1206.
72. Wedemeyer E. Vortex breakdown. AGARD-LS-121, No. 9, December 1982.
73. Benjamin T.B. Some developments in the theory of vortex breakdown. J Fluid Mech. 28:1967;65-84.
74. Hall M.G. A theory for the core of a leading-edge vortex. J Fluid Mech. 11:1961;209-228.
75. Hall M.G. The structure of concentrated vortex cores. Prog Aeronaut Sci. 7:1966;53-110.
76. Ludwieg H. Ergänzug zu der Arbeit. stabilität der stromung in einem Zylindrischen Ringraum Z Flugwiss. 9:1961;359-361.
77. Ludwieg H. Zur Erklärung der Instabilität der überangestellten Deltaflügeln abtretenden freien Wirbelkerne. Z Flugwiss. 10:1962.
78. Délery J.M. Aspects of vortex breakdown. Prog Aerosp Sci. 30:1994;1-59.
79. Escudier MP, Keller JJ. Vortex breakdown: a two stage transition. AGARD-CP-342, No. 25, April 1983.
80. Sarpkaya T. On stationary and travelling vortex breakdowns. J Fluid Mech. 45:1971;545-559.
81. Sarpkaya T. Vortex breakdown in swirling conical flows. AIAA J. 9:1971;1792-1799.
82. Sarpkaya T. Effect of the adverse pressure gradient on vortex breakdown. AIAA J. 12:1974;602-607.
83. Escudier M.P., Zehnder N. Vortex flow regimes. J Fluid Mech. 115:1982;105-121.
84. Escudier M.P., Bornstein J., Maxworthy T. The dynamics of confined vortices. Proc R Soc. A382:1982;335-360.
85. Faler J.H., Leibovich S. Disrupted states of vortex flow and vortex breakdown. Phys Fluids. 20(9):1977;1385-1400.
86. Faler J.H., Leibovich S. An experimental map of the internal structure of a vortex breakdown. J Fluid Mech. 86:1977;313-335.
87. Sarpkaya T. Vortex breakdown and turbulence. AIAA Paper #95-0433, January 1995.
88. Malcolm GN. Impact of high- α aerodynamics of dynamic stability parameters of aircraft and missiles. AGARD Lecture Series No. 114, Dynamic Stability Parameters, 1981.
89. Kegelman JT, Roos FW. Effects of leading-edge shape and vortex burst on the flowfield of a 70-degree-sweep delta wing. AIAA Paper #89-0086, January 1989.
90. O'Neil PJ, Roos FW, Kegelman JT, Barnett RM, Hawk JD. Investigation of flow characteristics of a developed vortex. Naval Air Development Center, Report No. NADC-89114-60, 1989.
91. Jobe CE, Vortex breakdown location over 65° delta wings empiricism and experiment. AIAA Paper #98-2526, 1998.
92. Huang XZ, Hanff ES. Prediction of normal forces on a delta wing at high incidence. AIAA Paper #93-3686, August 1993.
93. Iwanski KP. An investigation of the vortex flow over a delta wing with and without external jet blowing. Master's thesis, University of Notre Dame, April 1988.
94. Ng TT, Nelson RC, Payne FM. Flow field surveys of leading edge vortex flows. AGARD Symposium on Validation of Computational Fluid Dynamics, Lisbon, Portugal, May 2-5, 1988.
95. Rockwell D, Özgoren M, Sahin B. Vortex-structure on a delta wing at angle-of-attack. AIAA J (in press).
96. Jumper EJ, Nelson RC, Cheung K. A simple criterion for vortex breakdown. AIAA paper #93-0866, January 1993.
97. Raat J. Vortex development and breakdown. Technical Report AFFDL-TR-75-69, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH, 1975.
98. Krause E, Althaus W. Vortex breakdown: mechanism of initiation and change of mode. IUTAM Symposium on Fluid Dynamics of High Angle of Attack, September 1992.
99. Hummel D. On the vortex formation over a slender wing at large angles of incidence. AGARD-CP-247, October 1978.
100. Polhamus EC. A concept of the vortex lift of sharp-edge delta wings based on a leading-edge suction analogy. NASA TN D-3767, December 1966.
101. Polhamus E.C. Predictions of vortex-lift characteristics by a leading-edge suction analogy. J Aircr. 8(4):1971;193-199.
102. Purvis J.W. Analytical prediction of vortex lift. J Aircr. 18(4):1981;225-230.
103. Huang XZ, Hanff ES, Jenkins JE, Addington G. Leading-edge vortex behavior on a 65° delta wing oscillating in roll. AIAA Paper #94-3507, 1994.
104. Huang XZ, Hanff ES. Prediction of leading-edge vortex breakdown on a delta wing oscillating in roll. AIAA Paper #92-2677, June 1992.
105. Huang XZ, Sun YZ, Hanff ES. Further investigations of leading-edge vortex breakdown over delta wings. AIAA Paper #97-2263, 1997.
106. Ericsson LE. Further analysis of fuselage effects on delta wing aerodynamics. AIAA Paper #2000-0981, 2000.
107. Stanbrook A., Squire L.C. Possible types of flow at swept leading edges. Aeronaut Q. 15:1964;72-82.
108. Miller DS, Wood RM. An investigation of wing leading edge vortices at supersonic speeds. AIAA Paper #83-1816, July 1983.
109. Donehoe SR. Vortex flow and vortex breakdown above a delta wing in high subsonic flow: an experimental investigation. PhD dissertation, Delft University of Technology, June 1996.
110. Stallings RL. Low aspect ratio wings at high angles of attack. In: Progress in astronautics and aeronautics, tactical missile aerodynamics, vol. 104. New York: AIAA, 1987 [chapter 3].
111. Rockwell D. Three dimensional flow structure on delta wings at high angle-of-attack: experimental concepts and issues. AIAA Paper #93-0550, January 1993.
112. Huang XZ, Hanff ES. Roll rate induced camber effect on delta wing leading-edge vortex breakdown. AIAA Paper #95-1793, June 1995.
113. Ericsson L.E. Pitch rate effect on delta wing vortex breakdown. J Aircr. 33(3):1996;639-642.
114. Ericsson L.E. Difficulties in predicting vortex breakdown effects on a rolling delta wing. J Aircr. 33(3):1996;477-484.
115. Ericsson LE. Effect of pitch rate on delta wing vortex characteristics AIAA Paper #96-3405, 1996.
116. Ericsson LE. Effect of angle of attack on roll characteristics of 65 deg delta wing. AIAA Paper #96-3443, 1996.
117. Ericsson LE. Nonlinear unsteady aerodynamics of pitching delta wings. AIAA Paper #98-2518, 1998.
118. Ashley H, Katz J, Jarrah MAM, Vaneck T. Unsteady aerodynamic loading of delta wings for low and high angles of attack. International Symposium on Nonsteady Fluid Dynamics, June 1990.
119. Bragg MB, Soltani MR. An experimental study of the effect of asymmetrical vortex bursting on a pitching delta wing. AIAA Paper #88-4334, August 1988.
120. Brandon JM, Shah GH. Effect of large amplitude pitching motions on the unsteady aerodynamic characteristics of flat-plate wings. AIAA Paper #88-4331, August 1988.
121. Jarrah M-AM. Unsteady aerodynamics of delta wings performing maneuvers to high angle of attack. PhD dissertation, Stanford University, December 1988.
122. Nelson RC, Thompson SA. Flow visualization of the leading edge vortices on slender wings undergoing large amplitude unsteady motions. Sixth International Symposium on Flow Visualization, Yokohama, Japan, October 1992.
123. LeMay S.P., Batill S.M., Nelson R.C. Dynamics of leading edge vortices on pitching delta wing. J Aircr. 27(2):1990;131-138.
124. Thompson S.A., Batill S.M., Nelson R.C. The separated flow field on a slender wing undergoing transient pitching motions. J Aircr. 28(8):1991;489-495.
125. Thompson SA, Batill SM, Nelson RC. Unsteady surface pressure distributions on a delta wing undergoing large amplitude oscillations. AIAA Paper #90-0311, January 1990.
126. Thompson SA, Nelson RC, Batill SM. Delta wing surface pressures for high angle of attack maneuvers. AIAA Paper #90-2813, August 1990.
127. Thompson SA. The unsteady aerodynamics of a delta wing undergoing large amplitude motions. PhD dissertation, University of Notre Dame, May 1992.
128. Katz J. Wing/vortex interactions and wing rock. Prog Aerosp Sci. 35:1999;727-750.
129. Arena Jr A. An experimental study of the nonlinear wing rock phenomenon. Master's thesis, University of Notre Dame, April 1990.
130. Arena Jr A. An experimental and computational investigation of slender wings undergoing wing rock. PhD dissertation, University of Notre Dame, April 1992.
131. Nguyen LT, Yip L, Chambers JR. Self-induced wing rock of slender delta wings. AIAA Paper #81-1883, August 1981.
132. Jun Y.-.W., Nelson R.C. Leading-edge vortex dynamics on a slender oscillating wing. J Aircr. 25(9):1988;815-819.
133. Konstadinopoulos P., Mook D.T., Nayfeh A.H. Subsonic wing rock of slender delta wings. J Aircr. 22(3):1985;223-228.
134. Ericsson L.E. The fluid mechanics of slender wing rock. J Aircr. 21(5):1984;322-328.
135. Arena A.S. Jr., Nelson R.C. Measurement of unsteady surface pressure on a slender wing undergoing a self-induced oscillation. Exp Fluids. 16(6):1994;414-416.
136. Lee EM, Batina JT. Conical Euler methodology for unsteady vortical flows about rolling delta wings. AIAA Paper #91-0730, January 1991.
137. Legendre R. Écoulement au Voisinage de la Pointe Avant d'une Aile à Forte Flêche aux Incidences Moyennes. Rech Aéronaut 1952;(30):3-8.
138. Brown CE, Michael Jr WH. On slender delta wings with leading edge separation. NACA TN-3430, April 1955.
139. Mangler KW, Smith JHB. Calculation of the flow past slender delta wings with leading edge separation. RAE Report No. Aero. 2593, May 1957.
140. Arena Jr AS, Nelson RC. A discrete vortex model for predicting wing rock of slender wings. AIAA Paper #92-4497, August 1992.
141. Pelletier A. A study of the nonlinear aerodynamic characteristics of a slender double-delta wing in roll. PhD dissertation, University of Notre Dame, April 1998.
142. Pelletier A, Nelson RC. Dynamic behavior of an 80°/65° double-delta wing in roll. AIAA Paper #98-4353, August 1998.
143. Pelletier A, Nelson RC. The importance of critical states in nonlinear aerodynamics. AIAA Paper #2000-3909, August 2000.
144. Hanff ES, Ericsson LE. Multiple roll attractors of a delta wing at high incidence. AGARD-CP-494, 1990.
145. Myatt JH, Jenkins JE. A nonlinear indicial response model for the rolling 65-degree delta wing. AIAA Paper #96-3406-CP, 1996.
146. Ericsson LE. Flow physics of critical states for rolling delta wings. AIAA Paper #93-3683, 1993.
147. Fisher DF, Richwine DM, Banks DW. Surface flow visualization of separated flows on the forebody of an F-18 aircraft and wind-tunnel model. NASA TM-100436, 1988. Also published as AIAA #88-2112, 1988.
148. Fisher DF, Meyer Jr RR. Flow visualization techniques for flight research. NASA TM-100455, 1988. Also published in Flight Test Techniques, AGARD CP 452, Paper No. 20.
149. Fisher DF, Curry RE, Del Frate JH, Richwine DM. In-flight flow visualization techniques on a vortex-lift fighter aircraft. SAE 892222, Aerospace Technology Conference and Exhibition, 1989. Also published as NASA TM-4193, 1990.
150. Fisher DF, Del Frate JH, Richwine DM. In-flight flow visualization characteristics of the NASA F-18 High Alpha Research Vehicle at high angles of attack. Fifth International Symposium on Flow Visualization, Prague, Czechoslovakia, August 21-25, 1989.
151. Del Frate JH, Fisher DF, Zuniga FA. In-flight flow visualization with pressure measurements at low speeds on the NASA F-18 High Alpha Research Vehicle. AGARD Vortex Flow Aerodynamics Conference, Paper No. 13, October 1-4, 1990. Also published as NASA TM-101726, 1990.
152. Del Frate JH, Zuniga FA. In-flight flow field analysis on the NASA F-18 High Alpha Research Vehicle with comparisons to ground facility data. AIAA Paper #90-0231, 1990.
153. Fisher DF, Banks DW, Richwine DM. F-18 High Alpha Research Vehicle surface pressures: initial in-flight results and correlation with flow visualization and wind tunnel data. AIAA Paper # 90-3018, 1990. Also published as NASA TM-101724, 1990.
154. Quast T. A study of high alpha dynamics and flow visualization for a 2.5% model of the F-18 HARV undergoing wing rock. Master's thesis, University of Notre Dame, April 1991.
155. Quast T, Nelson RC, Fisher DF. A study of high alpha dynamics and flow visualization for a 2.5% model of the F-18 HARV undergoing wing rock. AIAA Paper #91-3267, September 1987.
156. Williams DL, Quast T, Nelson RC. Comparison of flight and sub-scale model wing rock characteristics of an F-18 aircraft. Final Report for NASA Grant NCA2-513, April, 1993.
157. Alcorn C.W., Croom M.A., Francis M.S., Ross H. The X-31 aircraft. advances in aircraft agility and performance Prog Aerosp Sci. 32:1996;377-413.
158. Williams DL, Nelson RC, Fisher DF. An investigation of the X-31 roll characteristics at high angle-of-attack through subscale model testing. AIAA Paper #94-0806, January 1994.
159. Croon MA, Fratello DJ, Whipple RD, O'Rourke MJ, Trilling TW. Dynamic model testing of the X-31 configuration for high angle-of-attack flight dynamics research. AIAA Paper #93-3674, August 1993.
160. Viletta JR. Lateral-directional static and dynamic stability analysis at high angles-of-attack for the X-31 configuration. Master's thesis, The George Washington University, August 1992.
161. Tobak M, Pearson WE. A study of nonlinear longitudinal dynamic stability. NASA TR-R-209, September 1964.
162. Tobak M. Chapman GT. Nonlinear problems in flight dynamics involving aerodynamic bifurcations. AGARD CP 386, Paper 25, May 1985.
163. Tobak M., Chapman G.T.Ü, nal A. Modeling aerodynamic discontinuities and onset of chaos in flight dynamical systems. Extraits Ann Télécommun. 42:1987;300-314.
164. Volterra V. Theory of functionals and of integral and integro-differential equations. 1959;Dover, New York.
165. Rennie MR, Jumper EJ. Experimental measurements of dynamic control surface effectiveness. AIAA Paper #94-0504, January 1994.
166. Jenkins JE, Myatt JH, Hanff ES. Body-axis rolling motion critical states of a 65-degree delta wing. AIAA Paper #93-0621, January 1993.
167. Hsia AH, Jenkins JE. Simplified nonlinear indicial response models of a rolling 65 degree delta wing. AIAA Paper #94-3493, August 1994.
168. Jenkins J.E. Simplification of nonlinear indicial response models. assessment for the two-dimensional airfoil case J Aircr. 28(2):1991;131-138.
169. Myatt JH. Modeling the roll moment on the 65-degree delta wing for rolling motions at high angles of attack. PhD dissertation, Stanford University, April 1997.
170. Reisenthel P, Bettencourt M, Myatt J, Grismer D. A nonlinear indicial prediction for unsteady aerodynamic modelling. AIAA Paper #98-4350, August 1998.