Wing/vortex interactions and wing rock

Progress in Aerospace Sciences

Volumn 35, Issue 7, 1999, Pages 727-750

  Katz, Joseph ^a  

^a SAN DIEGO STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

FLUID STRUCTURE INTERACTION; OSCILLATIONS; VORTEX FLOW;

WING ROCK;

WINGS;

EID: 0033206715     PISSN: 03760421     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0376-0421(99)00004-4     Document Type: Review

References (118)

1. National Transportation Safety Board. Special study: general aviation stall/spin accidents 1967-1969. Rept NTSB-AAS-72-8, September 1972.
2. Anderson SB. Historical overview of stall/spin characteristics of general aviation aircraft. J Aircraft 1979;16:455-61.
3. Feistel TW, Anderson SB, Kroeger RA. Alleviation of spin-entry tendencies through localization of wing-flow separation. J Aircraft 1981;18:69-75.
4. Tischler MBB, Barlow JB. Dynamic analysis of the flat spin mode of general aviation aircraft. J Aircraft 1982;19:198-205.
5. Katz J, Feistel TW. Propeller swirl effect on single-engine general-aviation aircraft stall-spin tendencies. J Aircraft 1987;24(4):285-7.
6. Ericsson LE, Beyers ME. Flat spin of axisymmetric bodies. J Aircraft 1995;32(6):1205-13.
7. Bihrle Jr. W, Barnhart B. Spin prediction techniques. J Aircraft 1983;20:97-101.
8. Clarkson MH, Malcolm GN, Chapman GT. Experimental poststall rotary aerodynamic coefficients for airplane-like configurations. J Aircraft 1976;13(8):565-70.
9. Malcolm GN. Rotary-balance experiments on a modern fighter aircraft configuration at high Reynolds numbers. AIAA Paper 85-1829, August 1985.
10. Jermey C, Schiff LB. Wind tunnel investigation of the aerodynamic characteristics of the standard dynamic model in coning motion at mach 0.6. AIAA Paper 85-1828, August 1985.
11. Beyers ME. Unsteady wall interference in rotary tests. AIAA Paper 89-0046, January 1989.
12. Fremaux CM. Estimating moment coefficients for dynamically scalled free spinning wind-tunnel models. J Aircraft 1995;32(6):1407-9.
13. Katz J. Numerical simulation of aircraft rotary aerodynamics. J Aircraft 1989; 26(7):692-3, Also AIAA Paper 88-0399.
14. Katz J. Numerical simulation of aircraft rotary aerodynamics. J Aircraft 1989; 26(7):692-3, Also AIAA Paper 88-0399.
15. Stone RW Jr, Bryant RL. Summary of results of tumbling investigations made in the langley 20-foot free-spinning tunnel on 14 dynamic models. NACA RM L8J28, December 1948.
16. Whipple RD, Croom MA, Fears SP. Preliminary results of experimental and analytical investigations of the tumbling phenomenon for an advanced configuration. AIAA 84-2108, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, August 1984.
17. Murri DG, Nguyen LT, Grafton SB. Wind tunnel free-flight investigation of a model of a forward-swept wing fighter configuration. NASA TP-2230, February 1984.
18. Gallaway CR, Hankley WL. Free-falling autorotating plate - a coupled fluid and flight mechanics problem. J Aircraft 1985;22(11):983-7.
19. Fremaux CM, Vairo DM, Whipple RD. Effect of geometry and mass distribution on tumbling characteristics of flying wings. J Aircraft 1995;32(2):404-10.
20. Ross AJ. Investigation of nonlinear motion experienced on a slender-wing research aircraft. J Aircraft 1972;9(9):625-31.
21. Ross AJ. Lateral stability at high angle of attack, particularly wing rock, AGARD CP-260, Paper 10, May 1979.
22. Boyden RP. Effects of leading-edge vortex flow on the roll damping of slender wings. J Aircraft 1971;8(7):543-7.
23. Orlik-Ruckemann KJ. Aerodynamic aspects of aircraft dynamics at high angles of attack. J Aircraft 1983;20:737-52.
24. Schmidt LV. Wing rock due to aerodynamic hysteresis. J Aircraft 1979;16(3):129-33.
25. Ross AJ, Nguyen LT. Some observations regarding wing-rock oscillations at high angles of attack. AIAA 88-4371 CP, August 1988.
26. Hwang C, Pi WS. Investigation of steady and fluctuating pressures associated with the transonic buffeting and wing rock of a one-seventh scale model of the F-5A aircraft. NASA Contractor Report 3061, 1978.
27. Hwang C, Pi WS. Some observations on the mechanism of aircraft wing rock. J Aircraft 1979;16(6):366-73.
28. Nguyen LT, Yip L, Chambers JR. Self-induced wing rock of slender delta wings. AIAA paper 81-1883, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Albuquerque, NM, August 1981.
29. Levin D, Katz J. Dynamic load measurements with delta wings undergoing self-induced roll-oscillations. AIAA 82-1320. August 1982. Also J Aircraft 1984;21(1):30-6.
30. Levin D, Katz J. Dynamic load measurements with delta wings undergoing self-induced roll-oscillations. AIAA 82-1320. August 1982. Also J Aircraft 1984;21(1):30-6.
31. Katz J, Levin D. Self-induced roll oscillations measured on a delta wing/canard configuration. J Aircraft 1986;23(11)814-9, Also AIAA Paper 85-1830-cp.
32. Katz J, Levin D. Self-induced roll oscillations measured on a delta wing/canard configuration. J Aircraft 1986;23(11)814-9, Also AIAA Paper 85-1830-cp.
33. Polhamus EC. Prediction of vortex characteristics by a leading-edge suction analogy. J Aircraft 1971;8(4):193-9.
34. Rusak Z, Wang S. Review of theoretical approaches to the vortex breakdown phenomena. AIAA paper 96-2126, New Orleans, LA.
35. Leibovich S. Vortex stability and breakdown: survey and extension. AIAA J 1984;22(9):1192-206.
36. Payne FM, Ng TT, Nelson RC, Schiff LB. Visualization and wake surveys of vortical flow over a delta wing. AIAA J 1988;26(2):137-43.
37. Kowal HJ, Vakili AD. An investigation of unsteady vortex flow for a pitching-rolling 70° delta wing. AIAA paper 98-0416, 36th Aerospace Sciences Meeting & Exhibit, Reno, NV, January 1998.
38. Ng TT, Malcolm GN. Effect of leading edge roundness on a delta wing-rock motion. AIAA paper 90-3080, 8th Applied Aerodynamics Conference, 1990.
39. Arena AS Jr, Nelson RC. Unsteady surface pressure measurements on a slender delta wing undergoing limit cycle wing rock. AIAA paper 91-0434, 29th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1991.
40. Ericsson LE. The fluid mechanics of slender wing rock. J Aircraft 1984;21(6):322-8.
41. Ericsson LE. Flow phenomena causing wing and body rock. AIAA paper 84-2177, AIAA 2nd Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Seattle, WA, August 1984.
42. Jun YW, Nelson RC. Leading edge vortex dynamics on a delta wing undergoing a wing rock motion. AIAA paper 87-0332, AIAA 25th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1987.
43. Jun YW, Nelson RC. Leading edge vortex dynamics on a slender oscillating wing. J Aircraft 1988;25(9):815-9.
44. Arena AS Jr, Nelson RC. The effect of asymmetric vortex wake characteristics on a slender delta wing undergoing wing-rock motion. AIAA paper 89-3348, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Boston, MA, August 1989.
45. Arena AS Jr, Nelson RC. Experimental investigations on limit cycle wing rock of slender wings. J Aircraft 1994;31(5):1148-55.
46. Morris SL, Ward DT. A video-based experimental investigation of wing rock. AIAA Paper 89-3349-CP, 1989.
47. Ng TT, Malcolm GN, Lewis LC. Experimental study of vortex flows over delta wings in wing-rock motion. AIAA paper 89-2187 CP, Applied Aerodynamics Conference, August 1989. Also J Aircraft 1992;29(4):598-603.
48. Ng TT, Malcolm GN, Lewis LC. Experimental study of vortex flows over delta wings in wing-rock motion. AIAA paper 89-2187 CP, Applied Aerodynamics Conference, August 1989. Also J Aircraft 1992;29(4):598-603.
49. Katz J, Levin D. Static measurements of slender delta wing rolling moment hysteresis. J Aircraft 1991;28(4):282-3.
50. Ericsson LE, Hanff ES. Unique high-alpha roll dynamics of a sharp-edged 65° delta wing. J Aircraft 1994;31(6):1350-7.
51. Ericsson LE, Hanff ES. Further analysis of high rate rolling experiments of a 65° delta wing. J Aircraft 1994;31(3):520-5.
52. Ericsson LE. Partial span leading-edge vortex characteristics in high-rate oscillations in pitch. J Aircraft 1997;34(3):443-5.
53. Ericsson LE. Impact of initial conditions on vortex breakdown on pitching delta-wings. J Aircraft 1997;34(3):452-4.
54. Nelson RC. Unsteady aerodynamics of slender wings. AGARD-R-776, 1991;1.1-26.
55. Prudnikov YA, Karaveyev EA, Rokmistrov OV. Wing rock of lifting systems. ICAS Paper 92-4.7.1, September 1992.
56. Ericsson LE. Various sources of wing-rock. J Aircraft 1990;27(6):488-94.
57. Brandon M, Nguyen LT. Experimental study of effects of forebody geometry on high angle-of-attack stability. J Aircraft 1988;25(7):591-7.
58. Ericsson LE. Wing rock generated by forebody vortices. J Aircraft 1989;26(2):110-6.
59. Ericsson LE. Critical issues in high-alpha vehicle dynamics. AIAA paper 91-3221, 1991.
60. Lamont PJ. Pressures around an inclined ogive cylinder with laminar, transitional, or turbulent separation. AIAA J 1982;20(11):1492-9.
61. Lamont PJ. The effect of Reynolds number on normal and side forces on ogive cylinders at high incidence. AIAA 85-1799, August 1985.
62. Klein V, Noderer KD. Aerodynamic parameters of the X-31 drop model estimated from flight data at high angles of attack. AIAA 92-4357, September 1992.
63. Ericsson LE, Mendenhall MR, Perkins SC Jr. Review of forebody-induced wing rock. J Aircraft 1996; 33(2):253-9.
64. Ericsson LE. Sources of high alpha vortex asymemetry at zero sideslip. J Aircraft 1992;29(6):1086-90.
65. Ericsson LE. Separated flow mechanisms in F-18 wing-rock. J Aircraft 1996;33(1):81-6.
66. Ericsson LE. Effect of deep-stall wing dynamics on forebody-induced wing-rock. J Aircraft 1997;34(3):448-50.
67. Fratello DJ, Croom MA, Nguyen LT, Domack CS. Use of updated NASA langley radio-controlled drop-model technique for high-alpha studies of the X-29A configuration. AIAA 87-2559, August 1987.
68. Merle AG. AFTI/F-16 pilot coupled roll oscillation. AIAA paper 83-2282-CP.
69. Levin D, Katz J. Self induced oscillations of low aspect ratio rectangular wings. J Aircraft 1992;29:698-702. Also AIAA 90-2811, presented at the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, August 1990.
70. Levin D, Katz J. Self induced oscillations of low aspect ratio rectangular wings. J Aircraft 1992;29:698-702. Also AIAA 90-2811, presented at the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, August 1990.
71. Williams II DL, Nelson RC. Roll behavior of low aspect ratio rectangular wings at high angle-of-attack. AIAA 95-3487, August 1995.
72. Williams II DL, Nelson RC. Fluid-dynamic mechanisms leading to the self-induced oscillations of low aspect ratio rectangular wings. AIAA 97-0830, January 1997.
73. Ericsson LE. Wing rock analysis of slender delta wings, review and extension. J Aircraft 1995;32(6):1221-6.
74. Ericsson LE. Slender wing rock revisited. J Aircraft 1993;30(3):352-6. Also AIAA paper 91-0417, 29th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1991.
75. Ericsson LE. Slender wing rock revisited. J Aircraft 1993;30(3):352-6. Also AIAA paper 91-0417, 29th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1991.
76. Lamont PJ, Kennaugh A. Total incidence plane aerodynamics: the key to understanding high incidence flight dynamics. J Aircraft 1991;28(7):431-5.
77. Tajfar AH, Lamont PJ. Sideslip behavior of elliptic cross-section forebodies at high angle of attack. J Aircraft 1997;34(4):472-8.
78. Quast T, Nelson RC, Fisher DF. A study of high alpha dynamics and flow visualization for a 2.5% model of the F-18 HARV undergoing wing rock. AIAA paper 91-3267-CP, 1991.
79. Mabey DG. Similitude relations for buffet and wing rock on delta wings. Progress Aerospace Sci 1997; 33(7/8):481-511.
80. Etkin B, Reid LD. Dynamics of flight stability and control, 3rd ed., New York: Wiley, 1996 (Chapter 4).
81. Hanff ES. Nonlinear representation of aerodynamics of wing rock of slender delta wing. AIAA 85-1831, August 1985.
82. Hanff ES, Kapoor K, Anstey CR, Prini A. Large-amplitude high-rate roll oscillation system for the measurement of non-linear airloads. AIAA paper 90-1426, AIAA 16th Aerodynamic Ground Testing Conference, Seattle, WA, June 1990.
83. Hsu C-H, Lan CE. Theory of wing rock. J Aircraft 1985;22(10):920-4. Also, AIAA paper 85-0199, AIAA 23rd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1985.
84. Hsu C-H, Lan CE. Theory of wing rock. J Aircraft 1985;22(10):920-4. Also, AIAA paper 85-0199, AIAA 23rd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1985.
85. Liebst BS, Nolan RC. Method for the prediction of the onset of wing rock. J Aircraft 1994;31(6):1419-21.
86. Jahnke CC, Culick FEC. Application of bifurcation theory to the high - a angle-of-attack dynamics of the F-14. J Aircraft 1994;31(1):26-34.
87. Elzebda JM, Mook DT, Nayfeh AH. Influence of pitching motion on subsonic wing rock of slender delta wings. J Aircraft 1989;26(6):503-7. Based on AIAA 87-0496.
88. Evans C. An investigation of large amplitude wing rock. Aeronaut J 1984;88(873):51-7.
89. Ericsson LE. Analytic prediction of slender wing rock. AIAA paper 87-2496, 1987.
90. Ericsson LE. Analytic prediction of the maximum amplitude of slender wing rock. J Aircraft 1989;26(1):35-9.
91. Ericsson LE. Difficulties in predicting vortex breakdown. J Aircraft 1996;33(3):454-77.
92. Ericsson LE, King HHC. Rapid prediction of high-alpha unsteady aerodynamics of slender-wing aircraft. J Aircraft 1992;29(1):85-92.
93. Arena AS Jr, Nelson RC. A discrete vortex model for predicting wing rock of slender wings. AIAA paper 92-4497, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Hilton Head, SC, August 1992.
94. Ize C, Arena, AS. Spanwise camber and quasisteady effects during wing rock. J Aircraft 1998;35(3):495-7. Also AIAA 97-0325, January 1997.
95. Mendenhall MR, Perkins SC, Ericsson LE. Prediction of forebody vortex-induced wing rock. AIAA 93-3451, August 1993.
96. Konstadinopoulos P, Mook DT, Nayfeh AH. Numerical simulation of the subsonic wing-rock phenomenon. AIAA paper 83-2115, AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Gatlinburg, TN, August 1983.
97. Konstadinopoulos P, Mook DT, Nayfeh AH. Subsonic wing rock of slender delta wings. J Aircraft 1985;22(3):223-8. Also AIAA paper 85-0198, AIAA 23rd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1985.
98. Konstadinopoulos P, Mook DT, Nayfeh AH. Subsonic wing rock of slender delta wings. J Aircraft 1985;22(3):223-8. Also AIAA paper 85-0198, AIAA 23rd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1985.
99. Levin D, Katz J. Vortex-lattice method for the calculation of the nonsteady separated flow over delta wings. J Aircraft 1981;18(12):1032-7.
100. Lee EM, Batina JT. Conical euler methodology for unsteady vortical flows about rolling delta wings. AIAA paper 91-0730, 29th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1991.
101. Lee EM, Batina JT. Conical euler simulation of wing rock for delta wing planform. J Aircraft 1991;28(1):94-6.
102. Charderjian NM. Navier-stokes prediction of large amplitude delta-wing roll oscillations. J Aircraft 1994;31(6):1333-40.
103. Charderjian NM, Schiff LB. Numerical simulation of forced and free-to-roll delta-wing motions. J Aircraft 1996;33(1):93-9.
104. Luo J, Lan EC. Control of wing-rock motion of delta slender wings. AIAA paper 91-2886, August 1991.
105. Malcolm G, Ng T, Lewis L. Development of non-conventional control methods for high angle of attack flight using vortex manipulation. AIAA paper 89-2192, AIAA 7th Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Seattle, WA, August 1989.
106. Ng TT, Malcolm GN. Aerodynamic control using forebody strakes. AIAA paper 91-0618, 29th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1991.
107. Ng TT, Malcolm GN. Aerodynamic control using forebody blowing and suction. AIAA paper 91-0619, 29th Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, NV, January 1991.
108. Ng TT, Suarez CJ, Kramer BR, Ong LY, Ayers B, Malcolm GN. Forebody vortex control for wing rock suppression. J Aircraft 1994;31(2):298-305.
109. Rao DM, Puram CK. Chine forebody vortex manipulation by mechanical and pneumatic techniques on a delta wing configuration. AIAA paper 91-1812, AIAA 22nd Fluid Dynamics, Plasma Dynamics & Lasers Conference, Honolulu, HI, June 1991.
110. Ng TT, Ong LY, Suarez CJ, Malcolm GN. Wing rock supression using forebody vortex control. AIAA paper 91-3227-CP, 1991.
111. Suárez C, Kramer B, Ayers B. Forebody vortex control for suppressing wing rock on a highly-swept wing configuration. AIAA paper 92-2716, AIAA 10th Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Palo Alto, CA, June 1992.
112. Wong GS, Rock SM, Wood NJ, Roberts L. Active control of wing rock using tangential leading-edge blowing. J Aircraft 1994;31(3):659-65. Also AIAA 93-0056.
113. Katz J, Walton J. Control of wing rock using leading-edge vortex manipulations. AIAA Paper No. 92-0279, presented at the AIAA Aerospace Sciences meeting in Reno, 1992.
114. Walton J, Katz J. Application of leading-edge vortex manipulations to reduce wing rock amplitudes. J Aircraft 1993;30(4):555-7.
115. Ng TT, Skaff T, Kountz J. Effect of leeward flow dividers on the wing rock of a delta wing. J Aircraft 1994;31(6):1148-55.
116. Synolakis CE, Breuel BD, Tegulapalle M, Ho CH. Passive control of delta wing rock. J Aircraft 1993; 30(1):131-5.
117. Roberts SD, Arena AS Jr. An inviscid model for evaluating wing rock supression methodologies. AIAA paper 94-0808, 32nd Aerospace Sciences Meeting & Exhibit, Reno, NV, January 1994.
118. Kandil OA, Menzies MA. Effective control of computationally simulated wing rock in subsonic flow. AIAA paper 97-0831, AIAA 35th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, NV, January 1997.