Socio-economic segregation with (without) competitive education policies. A comparative analysis of Argentina and Chile

Comparative Education

Volumn 38, Issue 4, 2002, Pages 429-451

  Narodowski, Mariano ^a   Nores, Milagros ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COMPETITIVENESS; EDUCATION POLICY; INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON; SOCIAL SEGREGATION;

ARGENTINA; CHILE;

EID: 0036872687     PISSN: 03050068     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/0305006022000030720     Document Type: Article

References (56)

1. AEDO, C. and LARRAǸGA, O. (1994) Sistemas de entrega de los servicios sociales: la experiencia Chilena [Social services' delivery systems: the Chilean experience], in: AEDO, C. and LARRANAGA, O. (Eds) Sistemas de Entrega de los Servicios Sociales: una agenda para la reforma [Social Services' Delivery Systems: an agenda for reform], pp. 33-74 (Washington DC, Interamerican Development Bank).
2. AOKI, M. and FEINER, S. F. (1996) The economic of market choice and at-risk students, arguments in favor and against, in: C. A. TORRES and A. PUIGGRÓS (Eds) Latin American Education, pp. 79-100 (Boulder, CO, Westview Press).
3. ARNOVE, R. F. (1997) Neoliberal education policies in Latin America: arguments in favor and against, in: C. A. TORRES and A. PUIGGRÓS (Eds) Latin American Education, pp. 79-100 (Boulder, CO, Westview, Press).
4. ARONS, S. (1971) Equity, option, and vouchers, Teachers College Record, 72 (3), pp. 337-364.
5. BELFIELD, C. R. (2001) International Experience with Demand-led Financing: education vouchers in the USA, Great Britain and Chile. Occasional Paper No. 23, NCSPE, Teachers College, Columbia University.
6. BRAVO, D., CONTRERAS, D., and SANHUEZA, C. (1999) Educational Achievement, Inequalities and Private/Public, Gap: Chile 1982-1997 (Chile, Universidad de Chile),
7. BULLOCK, A. and THOMAS, H. (1997) Schools at the Centre? A study of decentralisation (New York, Routledge).
8. CARNOY, M. (1997) Is privatization through education vouchers really the answer? A comment on West, The World Bank Research Observe, 12 (1), pp. 105-116.
9. CARNOY, M. (1998) National voucher plans in Chile and Sweden: did privatization reforms make for better education? Comparative Education Review, (42) 3, pp. 309-337.
10. CARNOY, M. and MCEWAN, P. (1998) Is Privatization More Effective and Cost-Effective for the Public? The case of Chile. Draft. (Palo Alto, CA, Stanford University).
11. CARNOY, M. and MCEWAN, P. (2000) The effectiveness and efficiency of private schools in Chile's voucher system, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 22 (3), pp. 213-239.
12. COBB, C. D. and GLASS, G. V. (1999) Ethnic segregation in Arizona charter schools, Education Policy Analysis Archives, 7 (1), (Arizona, Arizona State University). http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7nl/
13. CONTRERAS, D. (2001) Evaluating a Voucher System in Chile. Individual, family and school characteristics. Working Paper No. 175, Economics Department (Chile, Universidad de Chile).
14. COX, C. (1997) La Reforma de la Educación Chilena [The Chilean Educational Reform] No. 8. (Chile, PREAL).
15. CULLIS, J. G. and JONES P. (1998) Public Finance and Public Choice (2nd edition) (Oxford and New York, Oxford University Press).
16. DOERR, E., MENENDEZ, A. J., and SWOMLEY, J. M. (1996) The Case Against School Vouchers (New York, Prometheus Books).
17. ESKELAND, G. S. and FILMER, D. (2000) Does Decentralization Improve Learning? Autonomy and parental participation in Argentine schools. Preliminary draft, November 3, 2000.
18. GAURI, V. (1999) School of Choice in Chile: two decades of educational reform. (Pittsburgh, PA, University of Pittsburgh Press).
19. GRAUBARD, A. and ROTHSTEIN, R. (1998) On the defense of public schools, and reply. Dissent, 45 (1), pp. 1990-1999 (New York, Dissent Publishing Company).
20. GORDON, L. and WHITTY, G. (1997) Giving the hidden hand a helping hand? Comparative Education, 33 (3), pp. 453-467.
21. HASSEL, B. (1997) Beyond the Schools: the charter idea's potential for impact on public education (Cambridge, Harvard University Press).
22. HIRSCHMAN, A. (1969) Exit, Voice and Loyalty (Cambridge, Harvard University Press).
23. LANE, B. (1999) Choice Matters. Policy alternatives and implications for charter schools (United States, Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory).
24. LATORE, C. R. (1997) Financiamiento de la educación en Chile. Situación actual y posibilidades futuras [Financing education in Chile: present state and future possibilities] Serie: Documentos de trabajo, Documento No. 6. Santiago de Chile, PIIE/PRIDE).
25. LEVIN, H. (1992) The economics of educational choice, Economics of Education Review, 11 (4), pp. 23-56.
26. LLACH, J., MONTOYA, S. and ROLDAN, F. (1999) Educación para Todos [Education for All] (Buenos Aires).
27. MATTE, P. and SANCHO, A. (1991) Primary and secondary school education, in: C. LARROULET (Ed.) Private Solutions to Social Problems (Chile, Libertad y Desarrollo) http://www.lyd.com/biblioteca/libros/private/school.html
28. MCEWAN, P. (2000a) Private and Public Schooling in the Southern Cone: a comparative analysis of Argentina and Chile. Occasional Paper No. 11, NCSPE, Teachers College, Columbia University.
29. MCEWAN, P. (2000b) The Potential Impact of Large-scale Voucher Programs. Occasional Paper No. 2, NCSPE, Teachers College, Columbia University.
30. MINISTRY OF PLANNING AND COOPERATION (1999a) Impacto de la Politica Educacional, 1990-1996 [The impact of education policy, 1990-1996] (Chile, Division Social).
31. MINISTRY OF PLANNING AND COOPERATION (1999b) Resultados de la VII Encuesta de Caracterización Socioeconómica Nacional (GASEAN 1998). Situación de to Educación en Chile. Documento No. 5. [Results for the VII Survey on National Socioeconomic Characterisation. The state of Chilean Education. Document No. 5] (Chile, División Social).
32. MINISTRY OF PLANNING AND COOPERATION (1999c) Resultados de la VII Encuesta de Caracterización Sociaeconómica Nacional (CASEN 1998). Situación de la Infancia en Chile. Documento No. 8 [Results for the V11 Survey on National Socioeconomic characterisation. State of the Chilean Children. Document No. 8] (Chile, División Social).
33. MIZALA, A. and ROMAGUERA, P. (1998) Desempe∼no escolar y eleccion de colegios: la experiencia chilena, [School outcomes and school choice: the Chilean experience] (Chile, Centre of Applied Economics, Universidad de Chile).
34. MIZALA A. and ROMAGUERA, P. (2000) Determinación de factores explicativos de los resultados escolares en educación media en Chile. [Determination of the explanatory variables of middle education outcomes in Chile] (Chile, Centre of Applied Economics, Universidad de Chile).
35. MORDUCHOWICZ, A., MARCON, A., IGLESIAS, G., ANDRADA, M., PEREZ, J., VICTORIA, A. and DURO, L. (1999) La educación privada en la Argentina: historia, regulaciones, y asignación de recursos públicos. Serie Documentos de Trabajo, Documento 38. [Private Education in Argentina: history, regulations and public resources allocation] (Buenos Aires, Fundación Gobierno y Sociedad).
36. NARODOWSKI, M. (1999) Hiper Regulación de la Escuela Publica y Desregulación de la Escuela Privada. El caso de los "consejos de convivencia" en la ciudad de Buenos Aires. Documento 24 [Hyper Regulation of Public Schools and Deregulation of Private Schools. The case of the 'Coexistence Councils' in the City of Buenos Aires] (Buenos Aires, FGyS).
37. NARODOWSKI, M. (2000) Elements for research in the macro-politics of the Argentinean educational reforms. Paper presented at the Comparative Education Seminar: Argentina and England. (Buenos Aires, Universidad de San Andrés).
38. NARODOWSKI, M. and ANDRADA, M. (2001) Tne privatisation of education in Argentina, Journal of Education Policy, 16 (6), pp. 585-595.
39. NARODOWSKI, M. and NORES, M. (2001) A taxonomy of models for the provision of education: theory about competition and cooperation. Unpublished. (Buenos Aires, Fundacion Gobierno y Sociedad).
40. PANADEIROS, M., SUSMEL, N. and NORES, M. (1998) La experiencia internacional, in; FIEL/CEP. Una Educación para el Siglo XXI. El caso Argentino y otras experiencias internacionales [An Education for the XXIst Century. The Argentina Case and other international experiences], pp. 257-313 (Buenos Aires, Fundación de Investigaciones Economicas Latinoamericanas).
41. PARRY, T. (1997a) Theory meets reality in the education voucher debate: some evidence from Chile, Education Economics, 5 (3), pp. 307-331.
42. PARRY, T. (1997b) How will schools respond to incentives of privatization? Evidence from Chile and implications for the United States, American Review of Public Administration, 27 (3), pp. 248-269.
43. PATRINOS, H. A. and ARIASINGMAN, D. L. (1998) Decentralization of Education. Demand-side financing. (Washington DC, World Bank).
44. RIDEOUT, W. M. and URAL, I. (1993) Centralised and Decentralised Models of Education: comparative studies, Policy Working Papers No 1, Occasional paper, (Centre for Policy Analysis, Development Bank of Southern Africa).
45. REIMERS, F. (2000) Educational opportunity and policy in Latin America, in: F. REIMERS (Ed.) Unequal Schools, Unequal Chances. The challenges to equal opportunities in the Americas (Cambridge and London, DRCLAS/Harvard University).
46. RODRIGUEZ, J. (1988) School Achievement and Decentralization Policy: the Chilean Case. Draft (Chile, ILADES).
47. SIEMPRO (1997) Encuesta de Desarrollo Social (Buenos Aires, SIEMPRO).
48. SMITH, K. B. and MEIER, K. J. (1995) The Case Against School Choice. Politics, markets and fools (Armonk and London, M.E. Sharpe, Inc.)
49. TORRES, C. A. and PUIGGRÓS A. (1997) Introduction: the state and public education in Latin America, in: C. A. TORRES and A. PUIGGRÓS (Eds) Latin American Education (Boulder, CO, Westview Press).
50. VANDENBERGHE, V. (1999) Combining market and bureaucratic control in education: an answer to market and bureaucratic failure? Comparative Education, 35 (3), pp. 271-282.
51. VIOLA ESPINOLA H. (undated) Revisión de Quince Años de Politica Educativa en Chile: ajustes en función de la equidad [Fifteen Years of Education Policies in Chile Revised: adjustments for equity] (Washington DC, BID).
52. VIOLA ESPINOLA, H. (1992) Decentralization of the Education System and the Introduction of Market Rules in the Regulation of Schooling. The case of Chile (Santiago, Centro de Investigación y Desarrollo de la Educaci).
53. WEINBERG, G. (1984) Modelos Educativos en la Historia de América Latina [Education Models in Latin American History] (Buenos Aires, UNESCO-CEPAL-PNUD-Kapelusz).
54. WELSH, T. and MCGINN, N. F. (1998) Decentralization of Education: what and how? Draft (Cambridge, Harvard University).
55. WEST, E. G. (1996) Education Vouchers in Practice and Principle: a world survey. Human Capital Development and Operations Policy Working Papers (Washington DC, World Bank).
56. WHITTY, G., POWER, S. and HALPIN, D. (1998) Devolution and Choice in Education. The school, the state and the market (Buckingham and Philadelphia, Open University Press).