The Effects of Financial Incentives in Experiments: A Review and Capital-Labor-Production Framework

Journal of Risk and Uncertainty

Volumn 19, Issue 1-3, 1999, Pages 7-42

  Camerer, Colin F ^a   Hogarth, Robin M ^b  

^a CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO   (United States)

Author keywords

Bounded rationality; Experimental economics; Experimental methodology; Incentives; Judgment; Rationality

Indexed keywords

EID: 0033270827     PISSN: 08955646     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/a:1007850605129     Document Type: Article

References (124)

1. Andreoni, James and John H. Miller. (1997). "Giving According to GARP: An Experimental Study of Rationality and Altruism," University of Wisconsin Department of Economics Working Paper, October.
2. Arkes, Hal R., Robyn M. Dawes, and Caryn Christensen. (1986). "Factors Influencing the Use of a Decision Rule in a Probabilistic Task," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 37, 93-110.
3. Ashton, Robert H. (1990). "Pressure and Performance in Accounting Decision Settings: Paradoxical Effects of Incentives, Feedback, and Justification," Journal of Accounting Research 28, 148-180.
4. Atkinson, John W. (1958). "Towards Experimental Analysis of Human Motivation in Terms of Motives, Expectancies, and Incentives." In John W. Atkinson (ed.), Motives in Fantasy, Action, and Society. New York: Van Nostrand.
5. Aumann, Robert. (1990). "Foreword." In Alvin E. Roth and Marilda A. Oliveira Sotomayor (ed.), Two-Sided Matching: A Study in Game-Theoretic Modeling and Analysis, p. xi. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
6. Awasthi, Vidya and Jamie Pratt. (1990). "The Effects of Monetary Incentives on Effort and Decision Performance: the Role of Cognitive Characteristics," The Accounting Review 65, 797-811.
7. Bahrick, Harry P. (1954). "Incidental Learning under Incentive Conditions," Journal of Experimental Psychology 47, 170-172.
8. Baker, S. L. and I. Kirsch. (1991). "Cognitive Mediators of Pain Perception and Tolerance," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 61, 504-510.
9. Ball, Sheryl B. and Paula-Ann Cech. (1996). "Subject Pool Choice and Treatment Effects in Economic Laboratory Research." In R. Mark Isaac (ed.), Research in Experimental Economics Vol. 6, pp. 139-292. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
10. Battalio, Raymond C., John H. Kagel, and Komain Jiranyakul. (1990). "Testing between Alternative Models of Choice under Uncertainty," Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 3, 25-50.
11. Baumeister, Roy F. (1984). "Choking Under Pressure: Self Consciousness and Paradoxical Effects of Incentives on Skillful Performance," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 46, 610-620.
12. Beattie, Jane and Graham Loomes. (1997). "The Impact of Incentives upon Risky Choice Experiments," Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 14, 155-168.
13. Binswinger, Hans P. (1980). "Attitudes Toward Risk: Experimental Measurement in Rural India," American Journal of Agricultural Economics 62, 395-407.
14. Bohm, Peter. (1994). "Time Preference and Preference Reversal among Experienced Subjects: The Effects of Real Payments," The Economic Journal 104, 1370-1378.
15. Bolle, Friedel. (1990). "High Reward Experiments without High Expenditure for the Experimenter?" Journal of Economic Psychology 11, 157-167.
16. Bonner, Sarah E. S., Mark Young, and Reid Hastie. (1996). "Financial Incentives and Performance in Laboratory Tasks: The Effects of Task Type and Incentive Scheme Type," Unpublished manuscript, University of Southern California Department of Accounting.
17. Bull, Clive, Andrew Schotter, and Keith Weigelt. (1987). "Tournaments and Piece Rates: An Experimental Study," Journal of Political Economy 95, 1-33.
18. Camerer, Colin F. (1987). "Do Biases in Probability Judgment Matter in Markets? Experimental Evidence," American Economic Review 77, 981-997.
19. Camerer, Colin F. (1989). "An Experimental Test of Several Generalized Utility Theories," Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 2, 61-104.
20. Camerer, Colin F. (1990). "Behavioral Game Theory." In R. Hogarth (ed.), Insights in Decision Making: Theory and Applications. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990, pp. 311-336.
21. Camerer, Colin F. (1996). "Rules for Experimenting in Psychology and Economics, and Why They Differ." In W. Guth and E. Van Damme (eds.), Essays in Honor of Reinhard Selten. New York: Springer-Verlag.
22. Camerer, Colin F. (1998). "Behavioral Economics and Nonrational Decision Making in Organizations." In J. Halpern and B. Sutton (eds.), Decision Making in Organizations. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
23. Camerer, Colin F. (in press). "Prospect Theory in the Wild: Evidence from the Field." In D. Kahneman and A. Tversky (eds.), Choices, Values, and Frames.
24. Camerer, Colin F. and Eric Johnson. (1991). "The Process-Performance Paradox in Expert Judgment: Why Do Experts Know So Much and Predict So Badly?" In A. Ericsson and J. Smith (eds.), Toward a General Theory of Expertise: Prospects and Limits, pp. 195-217. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
25. Camerer, Colin F., Eric Johnson, Talia Rymon, and Sankar Sen. (1993). "Cognition and Framing in Sequential Bargaining." In K. Binmore, A. Kirman, and P. Tani (eds.), Frontiers of Game Theory, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
26. Camerer, Colin F., Teck Ho, and Keith Weigelt. (1997). Unpublished data.
27. Camerer, Colin F. and Keith Weigelt. (1988). "Experimental Tests of a Sequential Equilibrium Reputation Model," Econometrica 56, 1-36.
28. Castellan, N. John. (1969). "Effect of Change of Payoff in Probability Learning," Journal of Experimental Psychology 79, 178-182.
29. Cheng, Patricia and Keith Holyoak. (1985). "Pragmatic Reasoning Schemas," Cognitive Psychology 17, 391-416.
30. Conlisk, John (1989). "Three Variants on the Allais Example." American Economic Review 79, 392-407.
31. Cooper, David J., John H. Kagel, Wei Lo, and Qingliang Gu. (in press). "An Experimental Study of the Ratchet Effect: The Impact of Incentives, Context, and Subject Sophistication on Behavior," American Economic Review.
32. Cosmides, Leda. (1985). "The Logic of Social Exchange: Has Natural Selection Shaped How Humans Reason? Studies with the Wason Selection Task," Cognition 31, 187-276.
33. Cox, James C. and David M. Grether. (1996). "The Preference Reversal Phenomenon: Response Mode, Markets, and Incentives," Economic Theory 1, 381-405.
34. Craik, Fergus I. M. and Endel Tulving. (1975). "Depth of Processing and the Retention of Words in Episodic Memory," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 104, 268-294.
35. Cubitt, Robin P, Chris Starmer, and Robert Sugden. (1998). "On the Validity of the Random Lottery Incentive System," Experimental Economics 1, 115-132.
36. Cummings, Ronald G., Glenn W. Harrison, and E. Elisabet Rutstrom. (1995). "Homegrown Values and Hypothetical Surveys: Is the Dichotomous Choice Approach Incentive-Compatible?" American Economic Review 85, 260-266.
37. Dawes, R. M., D. Faust and P. E. Meehl. (1989). "Clinical versus Actuarial Judgment," Science 243, 1668-1674.
38. Dickhaut, John, Kip Smith, Kevin McCabe, Nicole Peck, and Vijay Rajan. (1997). "The Emotional and Mental Effort Dynamics of the English Auction," University of Minnesota Working Paper, Presented at ESA Meeting, September.
39. Drago, Robert and John S. Heywood. (1989). "Tournaments, Piece Rates, and the Shape of Payoff Function," Journal of Political Economy 97, 992-998.
40. Edwards, Ward. (1953). "Probability Preferences in Gambling," American Journal of Psychology 66, 349-364.
41. Edwards, Ward. (1961). "Probability Learning in 1000 Trials," Journal of Experimental Psychology 62, 385-394.
42. Eger, Carol and John Dickhaut. (1982). "An Examination of the Conservative Information Processing Bias in an Accounting Framework," Journal of Accounting Research 20, 711-723.
43. Eisenberger, R. and J. Cameron. (1996). "Detrimental Effects of Rewards: Reality or Myth?" American Psychologist, 51, 1153-1166.
44. El-Gamal, Mahmoud and Thomas R. Palfrey. (1996). "Economical Experiments: Bayesian Efficient Experimental Design." International Journal of Game Theory, 25, 476-495.
45. Ericsson, K. Anders and Jacqui Smith, (eds). (1991). Toward a General Theory of Expertise: Prospects and Limits. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
46. Fehr, Ernst and Elena Tougareva. (1996). "Do High Monetary Stakes Remove Reciprocal Fairness? Experimental Evidence from Russia," University of Zurich Working Paper.
47. Fiorina, Morris P. and Charles R. Plott. (1978). "Committee Decisions under Majority Rule: An Experimental Study," American Political Science Review 72, 575-598.
48. Forsythe, Robert, Joel L. Horowitz, N. E. Savin, and Martin Sefton. (1994). "Fairness in Simple Bargaining Experiments," Games and Economic Behavior 6, 347-369.
49. Fouraker, Lawrence and Sidney Siegel. (1963). Bargaining and Group Decision Making. New York: McGraw-Hill.
50. Friedman, Daniel. (1998). "Monty Hall's Three Doors: Construction and Deconstruction of a Choice Anomaly," American Economic Review 88, 933-946.
51. Glucksburg, Sam. (1962). "The Influence of Strength and Drive on Functional Fixedness and Perceptual Recognition," Journal of Experimental Psychology 63, 36-41.
52. Grether, David. M. (1980). "Bayes' Rule as a Descriptive Model: The Representativeness Heuristic," Quarterly Journal of Economics 95, 537-557.
53. Grether, D. M. (1981). "Financial Incentive Effects and Individual Decision Making," California Institute of Technology Working Paper No. 401.
54. Grether, D. M. (1990). "Testing Bayes Rule and the Representativeness Heuristic: Some Experimental Evidence," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 17, 31-57.
55. Grether, David M. and Charles R. Plott. (1979). "Economic Theory of Choice and the Preference Reversal Phenomenon," American Economic Review 69, 623-638.
56. Güth, Werner, R. Schmittberger, and B. Schwarze. (1982). "An Experimental Analysis of Ultimatum Bargaining," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 3, 367-388.
57. Harless, David W. and Colin F. Camerer. (1994). "The Predictive Utility of Generalized Expected Utility Theories," Econometrica 62, 1251-1290.
58. Harrison, Glenn W. (1994). "Expected Utility Theory and the Experimentalists," Empirical Economics 19, 223-253.
59. Harrison, Glenn W. and E. Elisabet Rutstrom, (in press). "Experimental Evidence of Hypothetical Bias in Value Elicitation Methods." In C. R. Plott and V. L. Smith (eds.), Handbook of Experimental Economics Results.
60. Hertwig, Ralph and Andreas Ortmann, (in press). "Experimental Practices in Economics: A Methodological Challenge for Psychologists," Behavioral and Brain Sciences.
61. Hey, John D. (1982). "Search for Rules of Search," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 3, 65-81.
62. Hey, John D. (1987). "Still Searching," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 8, 137-144.
63. Hoffman, Elizabeth, Kevin McCabe, and Vernon Smith. (1996a). "On Expectations and Monetary Stakes in Ultimatum Games," International Journal of Game Theory 25, 289-301.
64. Hoffman, Elizabeth, Kevin McCabe, and Vernon L. Smith. (1996b). "Social Distance and Other-Regarding Behavior in Dictator Games," American Economic Review 86, 653-660.
65. Hogarth, Robin M. and Hillel J. Einhorn. (1990). "Venture Theory: A Model of Decision Weights," Management Science 36, 780-803.
66. Hogarth, Robin M., Brian J. Gibbs, Craig R. M. McKenzie, and Margaret A. Marquis. (1991). "Learning from Feedback: Exactingness and Incentives," Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 17, 734-752.
67. Irwin, Julie R., Gary H. McClelland, and William D. Schulze. (1992). "Hypothetical and Real Consequences in Experimental Auctions for Insurance against Low-Probability Risks," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 5, 107-116.
68. Irwin, Julie, Michael McKee, Gary McClelland, William Schulze, and Elizabeth Norden, (in press). "Payoff Dominance vs. Cognitive Transparency in Decision Making," Economic Inquiry.
69. Jamal, Karim and Shyam Sunder. (1991). "Money vs. Gaming: Effects of Salient Monetary Payments in Double Oral Auctions," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 49, 151-166.
70. Jenkins, G. Douglas, Jr., Atul Mitra, Nina Gupta, and Jason D. Shaw. (1998). "Are Financial Incentives Related to Performance? A Meta-Analytic Review of Empirical Research," Journal of Applied Psychology 83, 777-787.
71. Johannesson, Magnus, Bengt Liljas, and Per-Olov Johansson. (1998). "An Experimental Comparison of Dichotomous Choice Contingent Valuation Questions and Real Purchase Decisions," Applied Economics, 30, 643-647.
72. Kachelmeier, Steven J. and Mohamed Shehata. (1992). "Examining Risk Preferences under High Monetary Incentives: Experimental Evidence from the People's Republic of China," American Economic Review 82, 1120-1141.
73. Kagel, John H. and Dan Levin. (1986). "The Winner's Curse and Public Information in Common Value Auctions," American Economic Review 76, 894-920.
74. Kahneman, Daniel and W. Scott Peavler. (1969). "Incentive Effects and Pupillary Changes in Association Learning," Journal of Experimental Psychology 79, 312-318.
75. Kahneman, Daniel, W. Scott Peavler, and Linda Onuska. (1968). "Effects of Verbalization and Incentive on the Pupil Response to Mental Activity," Canadian Journal of Psychology 22, 186-196.
76. Kroll, Y., H. Levy, and A. Rapoport. (1988). "Experimental Tests of the Separation Theorem and the Capital Asset Pricing Model," American Economic Review 78, 500-519.
77. Kroll, Y., H. Levy, and A. Rapaport. (1988). "Experimental Tests of the Mean-Variance Model for Portfolio Selection," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 42, 388-410.
78. Lepper, Mark R., David Greene, and Richard E. Nisbett. (1973). "Undermining Childrens' Intrinsic Interest in with Extrinsic Reward: A Test of the 'Overjustification' Hypothesis," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 28, 129-137.
79. Libby, Robert and Marlys G. Lipe. (1992). "Incentives, Effort, and the Cognitive Processes Involved in Accounting-Related Judgments," Journal of Accounting Research 30, 249-273.
80. List, John A. and Jason F. Shogren. (1998). "The Deadweight Loss of Christmas: Comment," American Economic Review 88, 1350-1355.
81. Loomes, Graham and Caron Taylor. (1992). "Non-Transitive Preferences over Gains and Losses," Economic Journal 102, 357-365.
82. McGraw, Kenneth O. and John C. McCullers. (1979). "Evidence of a Detrimental Effect of Extrinsic Incentives on Breaking a Mental Set," Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 15, 285-294.
83. McKelvey, Richard and Ordeshook, Peter. (1988) "A Decade of Experimental Research on Spatial Models of Elections and Committees." In M. J. Hinich and J. Enelow (eds.), Government, Democracy, and Social Choice. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
84. McKelvey, Richard and Thomas Palfrey. (1992). "An Experimental Study of the Centipede Game," Econometrica 60, 803-836.
85. Merlo, Antonio and Andrew Schotter. (1999). "A Surprise-Quiz View of Learning in Economic Experiments," Games and Economic Behavior 28, 25-54.
86. Miller, Louise B. and Betsy W. Estes. (1961). "Monetary Reward and Motivation in Discrimination Learning," Journal of Experimental Psychology 61, 501-504.
87. Müller, W. G. and A. M. C. Ponce de Leon. (1996). "Optimal Design of an Experiment in Economics," Economic Journal 106, 122-127.
88. Neelin, Janet [now Currie], Hugo Sonnenschein, and Matthew Spiegel. (1988). "A Further Test of Noncooperative Bargaining Theory: Comment," American Economic Review 78, 824-836.
89. Nilsson, Lars-Goran. (1987). "Motivated Memory: Dissociation between Performance Data and Subjective Reports," Psychological Research 49, 183-188.
90. Phillips, Lawrence D. and Ward Edwards. (1966). "Conservatism in a Simple Probability Inference Task," Journal of Experimental Psychology 72, 346-354.
91. Prasnikar, Vesna. (1998). "How Well Does Utility Maximization Approximate Subjects' Behavior? An Experimental Study," University of Pittsburgh Department of Economics, December.
92. Prendergast, Canice. (in press). "The Provision of Incentives in Firms," Journal of Economic Literature.
93. Reber, Arthur S. (1989). "Implicit Learning and Tacit Knowledge," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 118, 219-235.
94. Riedel, James A., Delbert M. Nebeker, and Barrie L. Cooper. (1988). "The Influence of Monetary Incentive on Goal Choice, Goal Commitment, and Task Performance," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 42, 155-180.
95. Roth, Alvin E., Vesna Prasnikar, Masahiro Okuno-Fujiwara, and Shmuel Zamir. (1991). "Bargaining and Market Behavior in Jerusalem, Ljubljana, Pittsburgh and Tokyo: An Experimental Study," American Economic Review 81, 1068-1095.
96. Salthouse, Timothy A., Janice D. Rogan, and Kenneth A. Prill. (1984). "Division of Attention: Age Differences on a Visually Presented Memory Task," Memory and Cognition 12, 613-620.
97. Samuelson, William F. and Max H. Bazerman. (1985). "The Winner's Curse in Bilateral Negotiations," Research in Experimental Economics 3, 105-137.
98. Schoemaker, Paul J. H. (1990). "Are Risk Attitudes Related across Domains and Response Modes?" Management Science 36, 1451-1463.
99. Schwartz, Barry. (1982). "Reinforcement-Induces Behavioral Stereotypy: How Not to Teach People to Discover Rules," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 111, 23-59.
100. Scott, W. E., Jing-Lih Farh, and Philip M. Podsakoff. (1988). "The Effects of 'Intrinsic' and 'Extrinsic' Reinforcement Contingencies on Task Behavior," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 41, 405-425.
101. Sefton, Martin. (1992). "Incentives in Simple Bargaining Games," Journal of Economic Psychology 13, 263-276.
102. Selten, Reinhard, A. Sadrieh, and Klaus Abbink. (1995). "Money Does Not Induce Risk Neutral Behavior, but Binary Lotteries Do Even Worse," University of Bonn Working Paper No. B-343.
103. Siegel, Sidney and Lawrence Fouraker. (1960). Bargaining and Group Decision Making: Experiments in Bilateral Monopoly. New York: McGraw-Hill.
104. Siegel, Sidney, Alberta Siegel, and Julia Andrews. (1964). Choice, Strategy, and Utility. New York: McGraw-Hill.
105. Slonim, Robert and Alvin E. Roth. (1998). "Learning in High Stakes Ultimatum Games: An Experiment in the Slovak Republic," Econometrica, 65, 569-596.
106. Slovic, Paul. (1969). "Differential Effects of Real versus Hypothetical Payoffs on Choices among Gambles," Journal of Experimental Psychology 80, 434-437.
107. Slovic, Paul and Douglas MacPhillamy. (1974). "Dimensional Commensurability and Cue Utilization in Comparative Judgment," Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 11, 172-194.
108. Smith, Vernon L. (1962). "An Experimental Study of Competitive Market Behavior," Journal of Political Economy 70, 111-137.
109. Smith, Vernon L. (1965). "Experimental Auction Markets and the Walrasian Hypothesis," Journal of Political Economy 387-393.
110. Smith, Vernon L. (1976). "Experimental Economics: Induced Value Theory," American Economic Review 66, 274-279.
111. Smith, Vernon L. (1991). "Experimental Economics: Behavioral Lessons for Microeconomic Theory and Policy," 1990 Nancy Schwartz Lecture, KGSM, Northwestern University.
112. Smith, Vernon L., Gerry Suchanek, and Arlington Williams. (1988). "Bubbles, Crashes, and Endogenous Expectations in Experimental Spot Asset Markets," Econometrica 56, 1119-1151.
113. Smith, Vernon L. and James M. Walker. (1993). "Rewards, Experience and Decision Costs in First Price Auctions," Economic Inquiry 31, 237-244.
114. Sniezek, Janet A. (1986). "The Role of Variable Labels in Cue Probability Learning Tasks," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 38, 141-161.
115. Straub, Paul G. and J. Keith Murnighan. (1995). "An Experimental Investigation of Ultimatum Games: Information, Fairness, Expectations, and Lowest Acceptable Offers," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 27, 345-364.
116. Tversky, Amos and Daniel Kahneman. (1992). "Advances in Prospect Theory: Cumulative Representation of Uncertainty," Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 5, 297-323.
117. Van Huyck, John, Raymond Battalio, and Richard Beil. (1990). "Tacit Coordination Games, Strategic Uncertainty, and Coordination Failure," American Economic Review 80, 234-248.
118. Wallsten, Thomas S., David V. Budescu, and Rami Zwick. (1993). "Comparing the Calibration and Coherence of Numerical and Verbal Probability Judgments," Management Science 39, 176-190.
119. Weber, Elke, Sharoni Shafir, and Ann-Renee Blais. (1998). "Predicting Risk-Sensitivity in Humans and Lower Animals: Risk as Variance or Coefficient of Variation," Ohio State University Department of Psychology Working Paper.
120. Weber, Martin, Graham Loomes, Hans-Jurgen Keppe, and Gabriela Meyer-Delius. (in press). "The Impact of Endowment Framing on Market Prices - An Experimental Analysis," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization.
121. Wilcox, Nathaniel. (1993). "Lottery Choice: Incentives, Complexity, and Decision Time," Economic Journal 103, 1397-1417.
122. Wright, William F. and Mohamed E. Aboul-Ezz. (1988). "Effects of Extrinsic Incentives on the Quality of Frequency Assessments," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 41, 143-152.
123. Wright, William F. and Urton Anderson. (1989). "Effects of Situation Familiarity and Financial Incentives on Use of the Anchoring and Adjustment Heuristic for Probability Assessment," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 44, 68-82.
124. Yerkes, R. M. and J. D. Dodson. (1908). "The Relation of Strength of Stimulus to Rapidity of Habit-Formation," Journal of Comparative and Neurological Psychology 18, 459-482.