Performance of subcutaneously implanted glucose sensors for continuous monitoring

Netherlands Journal of Medicine

Volumn 54, Issue 4, 1999, Pages 167-179

  Gerritsen, M ^a   Jansen, J A ^a   Lutterman, J A ^b  

^a RADBOUD UNIVERSITY NIJMEGEN   (Netherlands)

^b RADBOUD UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Continuous glucose sensing; Implantable glucose sensor; Subcutaneous tissue

Indexed keywords

GLUCOSE;

ANIMAL EXPERIMENT; ANIMAL TISSUE; CALIBRATION; CAT; DOG; GLUCOSE BLOOD LEVEL; HUMAN; IMPLANT; IMPLANTATION; MONITORING; NONHUMAN; PERFORMANCE; RABBIT; RAT; REVIEW; SENSOR; SHEEP; SUBCUTANEOUS TISSUE; SWINE;

ANIMALS; BIOSENSING TECHNIQUES; BLOOD GLUCOSE; EQUIPMENT DESIGN; EQUIPMENT FAILURE; HUMANS; PROSTHESES AND IMPLANTS; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY;

EID: 0033051709     PISSN: 03002977     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0300-2977(99)00006-6     Document Type: Review

References (103)

1. The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes on the development and progression of long-term complications in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. New Engl J Med. 329:1993;977-86.
2. Ohkubo Y., Kisikawa H., Araki E., Miyata T., Isami S., Motoyoshi S., Kojima Y., Furuyoshi N., Shichiri M. Intensive insulin therapy prevents the progression of diabetic microvascular complications in Japanese patients with non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus: A randomized prospective study. Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 28:1995;103-117.
3. Intensive blood-glucose control with sulphonylureas or insulin compared with conventional treatment and risk of complications in patients with type 2 diabetes (UKPDS 33. Lancet. 352:1998;837-853.
4. Arner P., Bolinder J. Microdialysis of adipose tissue. J Int Med. 230:1991;381-386.
5. Ash S.R., Rainier J.B., Zopp W.E., Truitt R.B., Janle E.M., Kissinger P.T., Poulos J.T. A subcutaneous capillary filtrate collector for measurement of blood chemistries. ASAIO J. 39:1993;M699-705.
6. Kayashima S., Arai T., Kikuchi M., Nagata N., Ito N., Kuriyama T., Kimura J. Suction effusion fluid from skin and constituent analysis: new candidate for interstitial fluid. Am J Physiol. 263:1992;H1623-H1627.
7. Tamada J.A., Bohannon N.J.V., Potts R.O. Measurement of glucose in diabetic subjects using noninvasive transdermal extraction. Nature Med. 1:(11):1995;1198-1201.
8. Heinemann L., Schmelzeisen-Redeker G, on behalf of the Non-invasive task force. Non-invasive continuous glucose monitoring in type 1 diabetic patients with optical glucose sensors. Daibetologia 1998;41:848-54.
9. Moscone D., Mascini M. Microdialysis and glucose biosensor for in vivo monitoring. Ann Biol Clin. 50:1992;323-327.
10. Meyerhoff C., Bischof F., Sternberg F., Zier H., Pfeiffer E.F. On line continuous monitoring of subcutaneous tissue glucose in men by combining portable glucosensor with microdialysis. Diabetologia. 35:1992;1087-1092.
11. Hashiguchi Y., Sakakida M., Nishida K., Uemura T., Kajiwara K., Shichiri M. Development of a miniaturized glucose monitoring system by combining a needle-type glucose sensor with microdialysis sampling method. Diabetes Care. 17:1994;387-396.
12. Skrabal F., Trajanoski Z., Kontscheider H., Kotanko P., Wach P. Portable system for on-line continuous ex vivo monitoring of subcutaneous tissue glucose using open tissue perfusion. Med Biol Eng Comput. 33:1995;116-118.
13. Schmidt F.J., Aalders A.L., Schoonen A.J.M., Doorenbos H. Calibration of a wearable glucose sensor. Int J Artif Organs. 15:(1):1992;55-61.
14. Meyerhoff C., Mennel F.J., Sternberg F., Hoss U., Pfeiffer E.F. Current status of the glucose sensor. Endocrinologist. 6:1996;332-339.
15. Moberg E., Hagstrom-Toft E., Bolinder J. Detection of hypoglycaemia by microdialysis measurements of glucose in subcutaneous adipose tissue. Horm Metab Res. 29:1997;440-443.
16. Best T. Physiological basis of medical practice. 12th ed :1989;Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, USA.
17. Zijlstra W.G., Brunsting J.R., Ter Hoor F., Mook G.A., Rispens P. Fysiology of the milieu interieur. 1973;Van gorcum and comp. B.V, Assen, The Netherlands.
18. Eggins B. Biosensors: an introduction. 1996;Wiley and Teubner, Chichester, England and Stuttgart, Germany.
19. Black J. Biological performance of materials, fundamentals of biocompatibility. 2nd ed :1992;Marcel Dekker, New York.
20. Wilkins E., Atanasov P. Glucose monitoring: state of the art and future possibilities. Med Eng Phys. 18:(4):1996;273-288.
21. Wilson G.S., Zhang Y., Reach G., Moatti-Sirat D., Poitout V., Thevenot D.R., Lemonnier F., Klein J.C. Progress toward the development of an implantable sensor for glucose. Clin Chem. 38:(9):1992;1613-1617.
22. Turner A.P.F., Pickup J.C. Diabetes mellitus: biosensors for research and management. Biosensors. 1:1985;85-115.
23. Updike S.J., Shults M.C., Rhodes R.K., Gilligan B.J., Luebow J.O., von Heimburg D. Enzymatic glucose sensors: improved long-term performance in vitro and in vivo. ASAIO J. 40:1994;157-163.
24. Gilligan B.J., Shults M.C., Rhodes R.K., Updike S.J. Evaluation of a subcutaneous glucose sensor out to 3 months in a dog model. Diabetes Care. 17:1994;882-887.
25. Shults M.C., Rhodes R.K., Updike S.J., Gilligan B.J., Reining W.N. A telemetry-instrumentation system for monitoring multiple subcutaneously implanted glucose sensors. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 41:1994;937-942.
26. Pickup J.C., Thevenot D.R. European achievements in sensor research dedicated to in vivo monitoring. Advances in biosensors, supplement 1. 1993;201-225 JAI Press Ltd, London, UK.
27. Pickup J.C. In vivo glucose monitoring: sense and sensorbility. Diabetes Care. 16:(2):1993;535-539.
28. Kyrolainen M., Rigsby P., Eddy S., Vadgama P. Bio-/haemocompatibility: implications and outcomes for sensors>. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 39:(suppl. 104):1995;55-60.
29. Cammann K. Implantable electrochemical glucose sensors: state of the art. Horm Metab Res Suppl. 20:1988;4-8.
30. Gough D.A., Armour J.C. Development of the implantable glucose sensor: what are the prospects and why is it taking so long? Diabetes. 44:1995;1005-1009.
31. Wilkins E.S. Towards implantable glucose sensors: a review. J Biomed Eng. 11:1989;354-361.
32. Fischer U. Fundamentals of glucose sensors. Diabetic Medicine. 8:1991;309-321.
33. Moussy F., Jakeway S., Harrison J.D., Rajotte R.V. In vitro and in vivo performance and lifetime of perfluorinated ionomer-coated glucose sensors after high-temperature curing. Anal Chem. 66:1994;3882-3888.
34. Kerner W., Kiwit M., Linke B., Keck F., Zier H., Pfeiffer E.F. The function of a hydrogen peroxide-detecting electroenzymatic glucose sensor is markedly impaired in human subcutaneous tissue and plasma. Biosens Bioelectr. 8:1993;473-482.
35. Fraser D.M. Biosensors in the body. Continuous in vivo monitoring. 1997;John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Chichester, UK.
36. Abel P., Muller A., Fischer U. Experience with an implantable glucose sensor as a prerequisite of an artificial beta cell. Biomed Biochim Acta. 43:1984;577-584.
37. 2-electrode as an approach to implantable glucose sensors. Horm Metab Res Suppl. 20:1988;26-29.
38. Shichiri M., Kawamori R., Yamasaki Y. The development of artificial endocrine pancreas. Medical Progress through Technology. 12:1987;39-50.
39. Rebrin K., Fischer U., von Woedtke T., Abel P., Brunstein E. Automated feedback control of subcutaneous glucose concentration in diabetic dogs. Diabetologia. 32:1989;573-576.
40. Pickup J.C., Shaw G.W., Claremont D.J. In vivo molecular sensing in diabetes mellitus: an implantable glucose sensor with direct electron transfer. Diabetologia. 32:1989;231-217.
41. Moatti-Sirat D., Capron F., Poitout V., Reach G., Bindra D.S., Zhang Y., Wilson G.S., Thevenot D.R. Towards continuous glucose monitoring: in vivo evaluation of a miniaturized glucose sensor implanted for several days in rat subcutaneous tissue. Diabetologia. 35:1992;224-230.
42. Moatti-Sirat D., Vehlo G., Reach G. Evaluating in vitro and in vivo the interference of ascorbate and acetaminophen on glucose detection by a needle-type glucose sensor. Biosens and Bioelectr. 7:1992;345-352.
43. Moatti-Sirat D., Poitout V., Thome V., Gangnerau M.N., Zhang Y., Hu Y., Wilson G.S., Lemonnier F., Klein J.C., Reach G. Reduction of acetaminophen interference in glucose sensors by a composite Nafion membrane: demonstration in rats and man. Diabetologia. 37:1994;610-616.
44. Poitout V., Moatti-Sirat D., Reach G., Wilson G.S., Lemonnier F., Klein J.C. A glucose monitoring system for on line estimation in man of blood glucose concentration using a miniaturized glucose sensor implanted in the subcutaneous tissue and a wearable control unit. Diabetologia. 36:1993;658-663.
45. Poitout V., Moatti D., Vehlo G., Reach G., Sternberg R., Thevenot D.R., Bindra D.S., Zhang Y., Wilson G.S. In vitro and in vivo evaluation in dogs of a miniaturized glucose sensor. ASAIO Trans. 37:1991;M298-M300.
46. Poitout V., Moatti-Sirat D., Reach G. Calibration in dogs of a subcutaneous miniaturized glucose sensor using a glucose meter for blood glucose determination. Biosens and Bioelectr. 7:1992;587-592.
47. Johnson K.W., Mastrototaro J.J., Howey D.C., Brunelle R.L., Burden-Brady P.L., Bryan N.A., Andrew C.C., Rowe H.M., Allen D.J., Noffke B.W., McMahan W.C., Morff R.J., Lipson D., Nevin R.S. In vivo evaluation of an electroenzymatic glucose sensor implanted in subcutaneous tissue. Biosens and Bioelectr. 7:1992;709-714.
48. Von Woedtke T., Fischer U., Brunstein E., Rebrin K., Abel P. Implantable glucose sensors: comparison between in vitro and in vivo kinetics. Int J Artif Organs. 14:1991;473-481.
49. Velho G., Froguel Ph., Thevenot D.R., Reach G. In vivo calibration of a subcutaneous glucose sensor for determination of subcutaneous glucose kinetics. Diab Nutr Metab. 3:1988;227-233.
50. Pfeiffer E.F., Meyerhoff C., Bischof F., Keck F.S., Kerner W. On line continuous monitoring of subcutaneous tissue glucose is feasible by combining portable glucose sensor with microdialysis. Horm Metab Res. 25:1993;121-124.
51. Koudelka M., Rohner-Jeanrenaud F., Terrettaz J., Bobbioni-Harsch E., de Rooij N.F., Jeanrenaud B. In vivo response of microfabricated glucose sensors to glycaemia changes in normal rats. Biomed Biochim Acta. 48:1989;953-956.
52. Koudelka M., Rohner-Jeanrenaud F., Terrettaz J., Bobbioni-Harsch E., de Rooij N.F., Jeanrenaud B. In vivo behaviour of hypodermically implanted microfabricated glucose sensors. Biosens Bioelectr. 6:1991;31-36.
53. Bobbioni-Harsch E., Rohner-Jeanrenaud F., Koudelka M., de Rooij N., Jeanrenaud B. Lifespan of subcutaneous glucose sensors and their performances during glycaemia changes in rats. J Biomed Eng. 15:1993;457-463.
54. Sternberg R., Barrau M.B., Gangiotti L., Thevenot D.R., Bindra D.S., Wilson G.S., Vehlo G., Froguel P., Reach G. Study and development of multilayer needle-type enzyme-based glucose microsensors. Biosensors. 4:1988;27-40.
55. Velho G., Froguel Ph., Thevenot D.R., Reach G. Strategies for calibrating a subcutaneous glucose sensor. Biomed Biochim Acta. 48:1989;957-964.
56. Von Woedtke T., Rebrin K., Fischer U., Abel P., Wilke W., Vogt L., Albrecht G. In situ calibration of implanted electrochemical glucose sensors. Biomed Biochim Acta. 48:1989;943-952.
57. Park J.B., Lakes R.S. Biomaterials, an introduction. 2nd ed :1992;Plenum Press, New York.
58. Williams D.F. Tissue-biomaterial interactions. J Mat Sci. 22:1987;3421-3445.
59. Spector M., Cease C., Tong-Li X. The local tissue response to biomaterials. Crit Rev Biocompatibility. 5:(3):1989;269-295.
60. Brash J.L., Wojciechowski P.W. Interfacial phenomena and bioproducts. 1996;Marcel Dekker, New York.
61. Horbett T.A., Brash J.L. Proteins at interfaces: fundamentals and applications. 1995;American Chemical Society, Washington DC, USA.
62. Ward W.K., Wilgus W., Troupe J.E. Rapid detection of hyperglycaemia by a subcutaneously implanted glucose sensor in the rat. Biosens Bioelectr. 9:1994;423-428.
63. Moussy F., Harrison D.J., Rajotte R.V. A miniaturized Nafion-based glucose sensor: in vitro and in vivo evaluation in dogs. Int J Artif Organs. 17:1994;88-94.
64. Moussy F., Harrison D.J., O'Brein D.W., Rajotte R.V. Performance of subcutaneously implanted needle-type glucose sensors employing a Novel trilayer coating. Anal Chem. 65:1993;2072-2077.
65. Shichiri M., Kawamori R., Hakui N., Asakawa N., Yamasaki Y., Abe H. The development of wearable-type artificial endocrine pancreas and its usefulness in glycaemic control of human diabetes mellitus. Biomed Biochim Acta. 5:1984;561-568.
66. Shichiri M., Yamasaki Y., Nao K., Sekiya M., Ueda N. In vivo characteristics of needle-type glucose sensor: measurements of subcutaneous glucose concentrations in human volunteers. Horm Metab Res Suppl. 20:1988;17-20.
67. Muller A., Abel P., Fischer U. Continuous monitoring of subcutaneous glucose concentration using implanted enzyme electrodes. Biomed Biochim Acta. 45:1986;769-777.
68. Brunstein E., Abel P., Gens A., Eich K., von Woedtke T. Preparation and validation of implantable electrodes for the measurement of oxygen and glucose. Biomed Biochim Acta. 48:1989;911-917.
69. Rigby G.P., Crump P., Vadgama P. Open flow microperfusion: approach to in vivo glucose monitoring. Med Biol Eng Comput. 33:1995;231-234.
70. Rigby G.P., Crump P., Vadgama P. Stabilized needle electrode system for in vivo glucose monitoring based on open flow microperfusion. Analyst. 121:1996;871-875.
71. Ertefai S., Gough D.A. Physiological preparation for studying the response of subcutaneously implanted glucose and oxygen sensors. J Biomed Eng. 11:1989;362-368.
72. Koudelka M., Rohner-Jeanrenaud F., Terrettaz J., Bobbioni-Harsch E., de Rooij N.F., Jeanrenaud B. In vivo behaviour of hypodermically implanted microfabricated glucose sensors. Biosens Bioelectr. 6:1991;31-36.
73. Remes A., Williams D.F. Immune response in biocompatibility. Biomaterials. 13:(11):1992;731-743.
74. Labow R.S., Erfle D.J., Santerre J.P. Neutrophil-mediated degradation of segmented polyurethanes. Biomaterials. 16:1995;51-59.
75. Wilson R., Turner A.P.F. Glucose oxidase: an ideal enzyme. Biosens Bioelectr. 7:1992;165-185.
76. Rebrin K., Fischer U., Hahn von Dorsche H., von Woetke T., Abel P., Brunstein E. Subcutaneous glucose monitoring by means of electrochemical sensors: fiction or reality? J Biomed Eng. 14:1992;33-40.
77. Updike S.J., Shults M., Ekman B. Implanting the glucose enzyme electrode: problems, progress, and alternative solutions. Diabetes Care. 5:(3):1982;207-212.
78. Fischer U., Hidde A., Herrmann S., von Woedtke T., Rebrin K., Abel P. Oxygen tension at the subcutaneous implantation site of glucose sensors. Biomed Biochim Acta. 48:1989;965-971.
79. Zhang Y., Wilson G.S. In vitro and in vivo evaluation of oxygen effects on a glucose oxidase based implantable glucose sensor. Anal Chim Acta. 281:1993;513-520.
80. Bessman S.P., Thomas L.J., Koijma H., Sayler D.F., Layne E.C. The implantation of a closed-loop artificial beta cell in dogs. Trans Am Soc Artif Int Organs. 27:1981;7-17.
81. Reach G., Feijen J., Alcock A. BIOMED concerted action chemical sensors for in vivo monitoring. The biocompatibility issue. Biosens Bioelectr. 9:(6):1994;21-28.
82. Woodward S.C. How fibroblasts and giant cells encapsulate implants: considerations in design of glucose sensors. Diabetes Care. 5:1982;278-281.
83. Sharkawy A.A., Klitzman B., Truskey G.A., Reichert W.M. Engineering the tissue which encapsulates subcutaneous implants. 1. Diffusion properties. J Biomed Mater Res. 37:1997;401-412.
84. Chang K.W., Aisenberg S., Soeldner J.S., Hiebert J.M. Validation and bioengineering aspects of an implantable glucose sensor. Trans Am Soc Artif Int Organs. 19:1973;352-360.
85. Shichiri M., Yamasaki Y., Kawamori R., Hakui N. Wearable artificial endocrine pancreas with needle-type glucose sensor. Lancet. 20:1982;1129-1130.
86. Shichiri M., Asakawa N., Yamasaki Y., Kawamori R., Abe H. Telemetry glucose monitoring device with needle-type glucose sensor: a useful tool for blood glucose monitoring in diabetic individuals. Diabetes Care. 9:1986;298-301.
87. Shichiri M., Kawamori R., Goriya Y., Yamasaki Y., Nomura M., Hakui N., Abe H. Glycaemic control in pancreatectomized dogs with a wearable artificial endocrine pancreas. Diabetologia. 24:1983;179-184.
88. Nishida K., Sakakida M., Ichinose K., Uemura T., Uehara M., Kajiwara K., Miyata T., Shichiri M., Ishihara K., Nakabayashi N. Development of a ferrocene-mediated needle-type glucose sensor covered with newly designed biocompatible membrane, 2-methacryloyloxyethyl phosphorylcholine-co-n-butyl methacrylate. Medical Progress Through Technology. 21:1995;91-103.
89. Claremont D.J., Sambrook I.E., Penton C., Pickup J.C. Subcutaneous implantation of a ferrocene-mediated glucose sensor in pigs. Diabetologia. 29:1986;817-821.
90. Pickup J.C., Claremont D.J., Shaw G.W. Responses and calibration of amperometric glucose sensors implanted in the subcutaneous tissue of man. Acta Diabetologia. 30:1993;143-148.
91. Shichiri M., Kawamori R., Hakui N., Yamasaki Y., Abe H. Closed-loop glycaemic control with a wearable artificial endocrine pancreas: variations in daily insulin requirements to glycaemic response. Diabetes. 33:1984;1200-1202.
92. Bruckel J., Kerner W., Zier H., Steinbach G., Pfeiffer E.F. In vivo measurement of subcutaneous glucose concentrations with an enzymatic glucose sensor and a wick method. Klin Wochenschr. 67:1989;491-495.
93. Fischer U., Ertle R., Abel P., Brunstein E., Hahn von Dorsche H., Freyse E.J. Assesment of subcutaneous glucose concentration: validation of the wick technique as a reference for implanted eletrochemical sensors in normal and diabetic dogs. Diabetologia. 30:1987;940-945.
94. Fischer U., Ertle R., Rebrin K., Freyse E.J. Wick technique: reference method for implanted glucose sensors. Artif Organs. 13:1989;453-458.
95. Vehlo G., Froguel P., Sternberg R., Thevenot D.R., Reach G. In vitro and in vivo stability of electrode potentials in needle-type glucose sensors. Influence of needle material. Diabetes. 38:1989;164-171.
96. McKean B.D., Gough D.A. A telemetry-instrumentation system for chronically implanted glucose and oxygen sensors. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 35:1988;526-532.
97. Matthews D.R., Bown E., Beck T.W., Plotkin E., Lock L., Gosden E., Wickham M. An amperometric needle-type glucose sensor tested in rats and man. Diabetic Med. 5:1988;248-252.
98. Quinn C.P., Pishko M.V., Schmidtke D.W., Ishikawa M., Wagner J.G., Raskin P., Hubbell J.A., Heller A. Kinetics of glucose delivery to subcutaneous tissue in rats measured with 0.3-mm amperometric microsensors. Am J Physiol. 269:1995;E155-E161.
99. Linke B., Kerner W., Kiwit M., Pishko M., Heller A. Amperometric biosensor for in vivo glucose sensing based on glucose oxidase immobilized in a redox hydrogel. Biosens Bioelectr. 9:1994;151-158.
100. Clark L.C. Jr., Duggan C.A. Implanted electroenzymatic glucose sensors. Diabetes Care. 5:(3):1982;174-180.
101. Wilkins E., Atanasov P. Integrated implantable device for long-term glucose monitoring. Biosens Bioelectr. 10:1995;485-494.
102. Shichiri M., Sakakida M., Nishida K., Shimoda S. Enhanced, simplified glucose sensors: long-term clinical application of wearable artificial endocrine pancreas. Artif Organs. 22:(1):1998;32-42.
103. Pfeiffer E.F. On the way to the automated (blood) glucose regulation in diabetes: the dark past, the grey present and the rosty future. Diabetologia. 30:1987;51-65.