Bilateral symmetry and sexual selection: A meta-analysis

American Naturalist

Volumn 151, Issue 2, 1998, Pages 174-192

  Moller A P ^a   Thornhill, R ^b  

^a CNRS   (France)

^b UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO   (United States)

Author keywords

Developmental instability; Fluctuating asymmetry; Mate choice; Meta analysis; Secondary sexual characters; Sexual selection

Indexed keywords

FLUCTUATING ASYMMETRY; MATING SUCCESS; META-ANALYSIS; SEXUAL SELECTION;

EID: 0031939433     PISSN: 00030147     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1086/286110     Document Type: Article

References (103)

1. Allen, G. R., and L. W. Simmons. 1996. Coercive mating, fluctuating asymmetry and male mating success in the dung fly, Sepsis cynipsea. Animal Behaviour 52:737-741.
2. Andersson, M. 1994. Sexual selection. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J.
3. Arcese, P. 1994. Harem size and horn symmetry in oribi. Animal Behaviour 48:1485-1488.
4. Arnqvist, G., and D. Wooster. 1995. Meta-analysis: synthesizing research findings in ecology and evolution. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 10:236-240.
5. Baker, R. 1997. Copulation, masturbation and infidelity: state-of-the-art. In Proceedings of the International Society of Human Ethology. Plenum, New York (in press).
6. Balmford, A., I. L. Jones, and A. L. R. Thomas. 1993. On avian asymmetry: evidence of natural selection for symmetrical tails and wings in birds. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 252:245-251.
7. Bennett, A. T. D., I. C. Cuthill, J. C. Partridge, and E. J. Maier. 1996. Ultraviolet vision and mate choice in zebra finches. Nature (London) 380:433-435.
8. Brookes, M., and A. Pomiankowski. 1994. Reply from M. Brookes and A. Pomiankowski. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 9:440.
9. Brooks, R. C, and N. Caithness. 1995. Female choice in a feral guppy population: are there multiple cues? Animal Behaviour 50:301-307.
10. Cohen, J. 1988. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 3d ed. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J.
11. Cooper, H., and L. V. Hedges, eds. 1994. The handbook of research synthesis. Russell Sage, New York.
12. Córdoba-Aguilar, A. 1995. Fluctuating asymmetry in paired and unpaired damselfly males Ischnura denticollis (Burmeister) (Odonata: Coenagrionidae). Journal of Ethology 13:129-132.
13. Darwin, C. 1871. The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex. John Murray, London.
14. Dunn, P. O., R. J. Robertson, D. Michaud-Freeman, and P. T. Boag. 1994. Extra-pair paternity in tree swallows: why do females mate with more than one male? Behavioural Ecology and Sociobiology 35:273-281.
15. Eggert, A. K., and S. Sakaluk. 1995. Fluctuating asymmetry and variation in the size of courtship food gifts in decorated crickets. American Naturalist 144:708-716.
16. Evans, M. R., T. L. F. Martins, and M. Haley. 1994. The asymmetrical cost of tail elongation in red-billed streamertails. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 256:97-103.
17. Fiske, P., and T. Amundsen. 1997. Female bluethroats prefer males with symmetric colour bands. Animal Behaviour (in press).
18. Fiske, P., J. A. Kålås, and S. A. Sæther. 1994. Correlates of male mating success in the lekking great snipe (Gallinago media): results from a four-year study. Behavioral Ecology 5:210-218.
19. Gangestad, S. W., and R. Thornhill. 1997. Human sexual selection and developmental stability. Pages 169-195 in J. A. Simpson and D. T. Kenrick, eds. Evolutionary social psychology. Erlbaum, Mahwah, N.J.
20. Gangestad, S. W., R. Thornhill, and R. A. Yeo. 1994. Facial attractiveness, developmental stability, and fluctuating asymmetry. Ethology and Sociobiology 15:73-85.
21. Gong, A., and R. Gibson. 1996. Reversal of a female preference after visual exposure to a predator in the guppy, Poedlia reticnlata. Animal Behaviour 52:1007-1015.
22. Graham, J. H., D. C. Freeman, and J. M. Emlen. 1993a. Antisymmetry, directional asymmetry, and chaotic morphogenesis. Genetica 89:121-137.
23. _. 1993b. Developmental stability: a sensitive indicator of populations under stress. Pages 136-158 in W. G. Landis, J. S. Hughes, and M. A. Lewis, eds. Environmental toxicology and risk assessment. American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia.
24. Grammer, K., and R. Thornhill. 1994. Human (Homo sapiens) facial attractiveness and sexual selection: the role of symmetry and averageness. Journal of Comparative Psychology 108:233-242.
25. Harvey, I. F., and K. J. Walsh. 1993. Fluctuating asymmetry and lifetime mating success are correlated in males of the damselfly Coenagrion pnella (Odonata: Coenagrionidae). Ecological Entomology 18:198-202.
26. Hasegawa, M. 1995. Sexual selection among peafowl: fluctuating asymmetry and parasite resistance. Bulletin of the Association of the Natural Sciences of Senshu University 26:19-25.
27. Hedges, L. V. 1994. Fixed effects models. Pages 285-299 in H. Cooper and L. V. Hedges, eds. The handbook of research synthesis. Russell Sage, New York.
28. Hedges, L. V., and I. Olkin. 1985. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Academic Press, Orlando, Fla.
29. Hunt, M. 1997. How science takes stock: the story of meta-analysis. Russell Sage, New York.
30. Hunter, J. E., and F. L. Schmidt. 1990. Methods of metaanalysis: correcting error and bias in research findings. Sage, Beverly Hills, Calif.
31. Jennions, M. D. 1997. The effect of leg band symmetry on female-male association in zebra finches. Animal Behavior (in press).
32. Kimball, R. T. 1995. Sexual selection in house sparrows, Passer domesticus. Ph.D. thesis. University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.
33. Kodric-Brown, A. 1997. Sexual selection, natural selection and fluctuating asymmetry in two populations of pupfish (Cyprinodon pecosensis). Biological Journal of the Linnaean Society (in press).
34. Kowner, R. 1996. Facial asymmetry and attractiveness judgment in developmental perspective. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 22:662-675.
35. Langlois, J. H., L. A. Roggman, and L. Musselman. 1994. What is average and what is not average about attractive faces? Psychological Science 5:214-219.
36. Leung, B., and M. R. Forbes. 1996. Fluctuating asymmetry in relation to stress and fitness: effects of trait type as revealed by meta-analysis. Ecoscience 3:400-413.
37. Liggett, A. C., I. F. Harvey, and J. T. Manning. 1993. Fluctuating asymmetry in Scatophaga stercoraria L: successful males are more symmetrical. Animal Behaviour 45:1041-1043.
38. Ligon, J. D., R. Kimball, and M. Merola-Zwartjes. 1997. Responses of female red jungle fowl to symmetry-challenged males. Animal Behaviour (in press).
39. Manning, J. T., and A. T. Chamberlain. 1993. Fluctuating asymmetry, sexual selection and canine teeth in primates. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 251:83-87.
40. Manning, J. T., and L. Ockenden. 1994. Fluctuating asymmetry in racehorses: the quick and the asymmetric. Nature (London) 370:185-186.
41. Manning, J. T., D. Scutt, G. H. Whitehouse, and S. J. Leinster. 1997. Breast asymmetry and phenotypic quality in women. Evolution and Human Behavior 18: 223-236.
42. Markow, T. A. 1987. Genetics and sensory basis of sexual selection in Drosophila. Pages 89-94 in M. D. Huettel, ed. Evolutionary genetics and invertebrate behavior. Plenum, New York.
43. Markow, T., and J. P. Ricker. 1992. Male size, developmental stability, and mating success in natural populations of three Drosophila species. Heredity 69:122-127.
44. Markow, T. A., D. Bustoz, and S. Pitnick. 1996. Sexual selection and a secondary sexual character in two Drosophila species. Animal Behaviour 52:759-766.
45. McLachlan, A., and M. Cant. 1995. Small males are more symmetrical: mating success in the midge Chironomus plumosus L. (Diptera: Chironomidae). Animal Behaviour 50:841-846.
46. Møller, A. P. 1990. Fluctuating asymmetry in male sexual ornaments may reliably reveal male quality. Animal Behaviour 40:1185-1187.
47. _. 1991. Sexual ornaments size and the cost of fluctuating asymmetry. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 243:59-62.
48. _. 1992a. Females prefer large and symmetrical ornaments. Nature (London) 357:238-240.
49. _. 1992b. Fluctuating asymmetry and the evolution of signals. Pages 96-98 in P. Bateson and M. Gomendio, eds. Workshop on behavioural mechanisms in evolutionary perspective. Instituto Juan March de Estudios e Investigaciones, Madrid.
50. _. 1992c. Patterns of fluctuating asymmetry in weapons: evidence for reliable signaling of quality in beetle horns and bird spurs. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 248:199-206.
51. _. 1993a. Developmental stability, sexual selection, and the evolution of secondary sexual characters. Etología 3:199-208.
52. _. 1993b. Female preference for apparently symmetrical male sexual ornaments in the barn swallow Hirundo rustica. Behavioural Ecology and Sociobiology 32:371-376.
53. _. 1993c. Patterns of fluctuating asymmetry in sexual ornaments predict female choice. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 6:481-491.
54. _. 1994. Sexual selection in the barn swallow (Hirundo rustica). IV. Patterns of fluctuating asymmetry and selection against asymmetry. Evolution 48:658-670.
55. _. 1995. Bumblebee preference for symmetrical flowers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 92:2288-2292.
56. b. Floral asymmetry, embryo abortion, and developmental selection in plants. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 263: 53-56.
57. _. 1996b. Parasitism and developmental stability of hosts: a review. Oikos 77:189-196.
58. _. 1996c. Sexual selection, viability selection, and developmental stability in domestic flies Musca domestica. Evolution 50:746-752.
59. _. 1997a. Developmental stability and fitness: a review. American Naturalist 149:916-932.
60. _. 1997b. Stress, developmental stability and behavior. In P. Slater and M. Milinski, eds. Advances in the study of behavior. Academic Press, San Diego, Calif, (in press).
61. Møller, A. P., and M. Eriksson. 1995. Flower asymmetry and sexual selection in plants. Oikos 73:15-22.
62. Møller, A. P., and J. Höglund. 1991. Patterns of fluctuating asymmetry in avian feather ornaments: implications for models of sexual selection. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 245:1-5.
63. Møller, A. P., and A. Pomiankowski. 1993. Fluctuating asymmetry and sexual selection. Genetica 89:267-279.
64. Møller, A. P., and J. P. Swaddle. 1997. Developmental stability and evolution. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
65. Møller, A. P., and R. Thornhill. 1997a. A meta-analysis of the heritability of developmental stability. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 10:1-16.
66. _. 1997b. Developmental stability is heritable: reply. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 10:69-76.
67. Møller, A. P., and C. Zamora-Munoz. 1997. Antennal asymmetry and sexual selection in a cerambycid beetle. Animal Behavior (in press).
68. Møller, A. P., M. Soler, and R. Thornhill. 1995. Breast asymmetry, sexual selection, and human reproductive success. Ethology and Sociobiology 16:207-219.
69. Møller, A. P., J. J. Cuervo, J. J. Soler, and C. Zamora-Muñoz. 1997. Horn asymmetry and fitness in gemsbok Oryx g. gazella. Behavioral Ecology (in press).
70. Morris, M. R., and K. Casey. 1997. Female preference for symmetrical males in Xiphophorus cortezi. (in press).
71. Oakes, E. J., and P. Barnard. 1994. Fluctuating asymmetry and mate choice in paradise whydahs (Vidua paradisaea): an experimental manipulation. Animal Behaviour 48:937-943.
72. Palmer, A. R. 1994. Fluctuating asymmetry analyses: a primer. Pages 355-364 in T. Markow, ed. Developmental instability: its origins and evolutionary implications. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht.
73. Palmer, A. R., and C. Strobeck. 1986. Fluctuating asymmetry: measurement, analysis and patterns. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 17:391-421.
74. Parsons, P. A. 1990. Fluctuating asymmetry: an epigenetic measure of stress. Biological Review 65:131-145.
75. Polak, M. 1997. Ectoparasitism in mothers causes high positional fluctuating asymmetry in their sons: implications for sexual selection. American Naturalist 149: 955-974.
76. Quinsey, V. L, M. Ketsetzis, C. Earls, and A. Karamanoukin. 1996. Viewing time as a measure of sexual interest. Ethology and Sociobiology 17:341-354.
77. Radesäter, T., and H. Halldórsdóttir. 1993. Fluctuating asymmetry and forceps size in earwigs, Forficula auricularia. Animal Behaviour 45:626-628.
78. Rintamaki, P. T., R. V. Alatalo, J. Höglund, and A. Lundberg. 1997. Fluctuating asymmetry in ornamental and non-ornamental traits in relation to copulation success in black grouse. Animal Behaviour (in press).
79. Rosenthal, R. 1991. Meta-analytic procedures for social research. Sage, New York.
80. Ryan, M. J., K. M. Warkentin, B. E. McLelland, and W. Wilczynski. 1995. Fluctuating asymmetries and advertisement call variation in the cricket frog, Acris crepitans. Behavioral Ecology 6:124-131.
81. Savalli, U. M. 1997. Notes on the natural history and mating system of the pintailed whydah Vidua inacroura. Ostrich (in press).
82. Shadish, W. R., and C. K. Haddock. 1994. Combining estimates of effect size. Pages 261-284 in H. Cooper and L. V. Hedges, eds. The handbook of research synthesis. Russell Sage, New York.
83. Sheridan, L., and A. Pomiankowski. 1997. Fluctuating asymmetry, spot asymmetry and inbreeding depression in the sexual coloration of male guppy fish. Animal Behavior (in press).
84. Simmons, L. W. 1995. Correlates of male quality in the field cricket, Gryllus campestris L.: age, size and sym-metry determine pairing success in field populations. Behavioral Ecology 6:376-381.
85. Simmons, L. W., and M. G. Ritchie. 1996. Symmetry in the songs of crickets. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 263:305-311.
86. Singh, D. 1995. Female health, attractiveness, and desirability for relationships: role of breast asymmetry and waist-to-hip ratio. Ethology and Sociobiology 16:465-481.
87. Stockley, P., J. B. Searle, D. W. Macdonald, and C. S. Jones. 1996. Correlates of reproductive success within alternative mating tactics of the common shrew. Behavioral Ecology 7:334-340.
88. Swaddle, J. P., and I. C. Cuthill. 1994a. Female zebra finches prefer males with symmetric chest plumage. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 258:267-271.
89. _. 1994b. Preference for symmetric males by female zebra finches. Nature (London) 367:165-166.
90. _. 1995. Asymmetry and human facial attractiveness: symmetry may not always be beautiful. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, Biological Sciences 261:111-116.
91. Swaddle, J. P., M. S. Witter, I. C. Cuthill, A. Budden, and P. McCowen. 1997. Plumage condition affects flight performance in starlings: implications for developmental homeostasis, abrasion and moult. Journal of Avian Biology (in press).
92. Thornhill, R. 1992a. Female preference for the pheromone of males with low fluctuating asymmetry in the Japanese scorpionfly (Panorpa japonica, Mecoptera). Behavioral Ecology 3:277-283.
93. _. 1992b. Fluctuating asymmetry and the mating system of the Japanese scorpionfly, Panorpa japonica. Animal Behaviour 44:867-879.
94. _. 1992c. Fluctuating asymmetry, interspecific aggression and male mating tactics in two species of Japanese scorpionflies. Behavioural Ecology and Sociobiology 30:357-363.
95. Thornhill, R., and J. Alcock. 1983. The evolution of insect mating systems. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
96. Thornhill, R., and S. W. Gangestad. 1993. Human facial beauty: averageness, symmetry, and parasite resistance. Human Nature 4:237-269.
97. _. 1994. Human fluctuating asymmetry and sexual behavior. Psychological Science 5:297-302.
98. Thornhill, R., and A. P. Moller. 1997. Developmental stability, disease and medicine. Biological Reviews (in press).
99. Thornhill, R., and K. P. Sauer. 1992. Genetic sire effects on the fighting ability of sons and daughters and mat-ing success of sons in the scorpionfly (Panorpa vulgaris). Animal Behaviour 43:255-264.
100. Thornhill, R., S. W. Gangestad, and R. Comer. 1995. Human female orgasm and mate fluctuating asymmetry. Animal Behaviour 50:1601-1615.
101. Ueno, H. 1994. Fluctuating asymmetry in relation to two fitness components, adult longevity and male mating success in a ladybird beetle, Hannonia axyridis (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Ecological Entomology 19:87-88.
102. Uetz, G. W., W. J. McClintock, D. Miller, E. I. Smith, and K. K. Cook. 1996. Limb regeneration and subsequent asymmetry in a male secondary sexual character influences sexual selection in wolf spiders. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 38:253-257.
103. Watson, P. J., and R. Thornhill. 1994. Fluctuating asymmetry and sexual selection. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 9:21-25.