Corporations and transnational human rights litigation

Corporations and Transnational Human Rights Litigation

Volumn , Issue , 2004, Pages 1-177

  Joseph, Sarah ^a  

^a MONASH UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 85198576818     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: None     Document Type: Book

References (96)

1. C Grossman and D Bradlow, 'Are We Being Propelled Towards a People-Centered Transnational Legal Order?' (1993) 9 American University Journal of International Law and Policy 1, 8-9
2. D Cassel, 'International Security in the Post Cold-War Era': Can International Law Truly Affect Global Political and Economic Stability? Corporate Initiatives: A Second Human Rights Revolution?' (1996) 19 Fordham International Law Journal 1963, 1963 and 1979
3. F Johns, 'The Invisibility of the Transnational Corporation: An Analysis of International Law and Legal Theory' (1994) 19 Melbourne University Law Review 893, 904
4. S Joseph, 'Taming the Leviathans: Multinational Enterprises and Human Rights' (1999) 46 Netherlands International Law Review 171, 173-74.
5. See, eg, WH Meyer, 'Human Rights and TNCs: Theory Versus Quantitative Analysis' (1996) Human Rights Quarterly 368, 391-97.
6. K Pritchard, 'Human Rights and Development: Theory and Data' in DP Forsythe Human Rights and Development (Basingstoke, Macmillan, 1989) 329
7. J Eaton, 'The Nigerian Tragedy, Environmental Regulation of Transnational Corporations, and the Human Right to a Healthy Environment' (1997) 15 Boston University International Law Journal 261, 264-71
8. S Skogly, 'Complexities in Human Rights Protection: Actors and Rights Involved in the Ogoni Conflict in Nigeria' (1997) 15 Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights 47.
9. J Wike, 'The Marlboro Man in Asia: US Tobacco and Human Rights' (1996) 29 Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 330.
10. C Forcese, 'Deterring 'Militarized Commerce': The Prospect of Liability for 'Privatized' Human Rights Abuses' (2000) 31 Ottawa Law Review 171, 173.
11. S Zia-Zarifi, 'Suing Multinational Corporations in the US for Violating International Law' (1999) 4 University of California at Los Angeles Journal of International Law and Foreign Affairs 81, 86-7
12. J Cassels, 'Outlaws: Multinational Corporations and Catastrophic Law' (2000) 31 Cumberland Law Review 311, 313, 317-19
13. B Stephens, 'Corporate Liability: Enforcing Human Rights Law through Domestic Litigation' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 401, 402.
14. M Gibney and RD Emerick, 'The Extraterritorial Application of United States Law and the Protection of Human Rights: Holding Multinational Corporations to Domestic and International Standards' (1996) 10 Temple International and Comparative Law Journal 123.
15. J Ratner, 'Back to the Future: Why a Return to the Approach of the Filartiga Court is essential to Preserve the Legitimacy and Potential of the Alien Tort Claims Act' (2002) 35 Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems 83, 86.
16. WS Dodge, 'Which Torts are in Violation of the Law of Nations?' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 351, 355
17. S Zia-Zarifi, 'Suing Multinational Corporations in the US for Violating International Law' (1999) 4 University of California at Los Angeles Journal International Law and Foreign Affairs 81, 91.
18. SJ Adams Lien, 'Employer Beware? Enforcing Transnational Labour Standards in the United States under the Alien Tort Claims Act' 6 (2002) Journal of Small and Emerging Business Law 311, 324-25.
19. A Clapham and S Jerbi, 'Categories of Corporate Complicity in Human Rights Abuses' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 339
20. A Ramasastry, 'Corporate Complicity: From Nuremberg to Rangoon: An Examination of Forced Labour Cases and their Impact on the Liability of Multinational Corporations' (2002) 20 Berkeley Journal of International Law 91.
21. MD Ramsey, 'Multinational Corporate Liability under the Alien Tort Claims Act: Some Structural Concerns' (2001) Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 361, 364; see also Forcese, above n 124, at 497-98, and Khalil, above n 119, at 216-17.
22. J Terry, 'Taking Filartiga on the Road: Why Courts outside the United States should accept Jurisdiction over Actions involving Torture Committed Abroad' in Scott, above n 16, at 126-27.
23. M Bühler, 'The Emperor's New Clothes: Defabricating the Myth of 'Act of State' in Anglo-Canadian Law' in Scott, above n 19, at 343, 364. See below however, on how other allegations in Rio Tinto were dismissed for 'act of state' (text below at n 184).
24. B Stephens and M Ratner, International Human Rights Litigation in US Courts (New York, Transnational Publishers Inc, 1996) 88
25. C Scott, 'Translating Torture into Transnational Tort: Conceptual Divides in the Debate on Corporate Accountability for Human Rights Norms' C Scott (ed) Torture as Tort (Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2001) 62.
26. P Muchlinski, 'The Bhopal Case: Controlling Ultrahazardous Industrial Activity undertaken by Foreign Investors' (1987) 50 Modern Law Review 545.
27. MJ Rogge, 'Towards Transnational Corporate Liability in the Global Economy: Challenging the Doctrine of Forum non Conveniens in Re: Union Carbide, Alfaro, Sequihua, and Aguinda' (2001) 26 Texas International Law Journal 299, 302, 323.
28. GB Born, International Civil Litigation in United States Courts (3rd edn, The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 1996) 635-36.
29. S Joseph, 'Taming the Leviathans: Multinational Enterprises and Human Rights' (1999) 46 Netherlands International Law Review 171, 177-78.
30. Armin Rosencranz & Richard Campbell, 'Foreign Environmental and Human Rights Suits Against US Corporations in US Courts' (1999) 18 Stanford Envirnomental Law Journal 145, 171-75.
31. S Joseph, 'Taming the Leviathans: Multinational Enterprises and Human Rights' (1999) 46 Netherlands International Law Review 171, 177-78.
32. Armin Rosencranz & Richard Campbell, 'Foreign Environmental and Human Rights Suits Against US Corporations in US Courts' (1999) 18 Stanford Envirnomental Law Journal 145, 171-75.
33. JJ Paust, 'Human Rights Responsibilities of Private Corporations' (2002) 35 Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 801, 821.
34. A Rosencranz and R Campbell, 'Foreign Environmental and Human Rights Suits Against US Corporations in US Courts' (1999) 18 Stanford Environmental Law Journal 145, 180.
35. J Duval-Major, 'One Way Ticket Home: The Federal Doctrine of Forum non Conveniens and the International Plaintiff' (1992) 77 Cornell Law Review 650, 671-72.
36. DW Robertson, 'Forum Non Conveniens in America and England: "A Rather Fantastic Fiction"' 103 (1987) Law Quarterly Review 398.
37. C Scott, 'Multinational Enterprises and Emergent Jurisprudence on Violations of Economic Social and Cultural Rights' in A Eide, C Krause and A Rosas (eds) Economic Social and Cultural Rights 2nd edn, (The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 2001) 587-90.
38. KL Boyd, 'The Inconvenience of Victims: Abolishing Forum non Conveniens in US Human Rights Litigation' (1998) 39 Virginia Journal of International Law 41, 46.
39. LW Newman, 'Latin America and Forum non Conveniens Dismissals' (Feb 4, 1999) 221 New York Law Journal 3. The purpose of the laws is reflected in the name commonly given to these laws: 'Ley de Defensa de los Derechos Procesales de Nacionales y Residentes' (Law in Defence of the Procedural Rights of Nationals and Residents).
40. W Anderson, 'Forum non Conveniens Checkmated? The Emergence of Retaliatory Legislation' (2001) 10 Journal of Transnational Law and Policy 183, 186
41. S McNulty, 'Oil Major Forced to Answer Amazon Charge of Damaging the Environment' Financial Times (London, United Kingdom, 29 October 2003) 2, reports that proceedings have now opened against Texaco in Ecuador.
42. P Prince, 'Bhopal, Bougainville and Ok Tedi: Why Australia's Forum non Conveniens Approach is Better' (1998) 47 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 573, 585.
43. Kinley, 'Human Rights as Legally Binding or Merely Relevant' in S Bottomley and D Kinley (eds), Commercial Law and Human Rights (Aldershot, Ashgate, 2002) 25.
44. B Egelko, 'Nike settles suit for $1.5 million: Shoe giant accused of lying about workers' treatment', San Francisco Chronicle (San Fancisco, United States, 13 September 2003) B1.
45. Su-Ping Lu, 'Corporate Codes of Conduct and the FTC: Advancing Human Rights through Deceptive Advertising Law' (2000) 38 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 603.
46. T Spencer, 'Talking about Social Responsibility: Liability for Misleading and Deceptive Statements in Corporate Codes of Conduct' (2004) 30 Monash University Law Review (forthcoming).
47. H Ward, 'Legal Issues in Corporate Citizenship', Swedish Partnership for Global Responsibility, February 2003 (29 December 2003) 21.
48. M Dobrusin, 'Crass Commercialism: Is it Public Debate or Sheer Profit? The Controversy of Kasky v Nike' (2003) 24 Whittier Law Review 1139.
49. S Joseph, 'A Rights Analysis of the Covenant on Civil and Political Rights' (1999) 5 Journal of International Legal Studies 57, 79.
50. S Joseph, J Schultz and M Castan, The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: Cases, Materials and Commentary 2nd edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2004) 68-70.
51. J Nolan, 'Research Summary Report: prepared as part of the Monash Global Initiative's project on Corporate Social Responsibility' (copy on file with the author, December 2003) 15-17.
52. S Joseph, 'Taming the Leviathans: Multinational Enterprises and Human Rights' (1999) 46 Netherlands International Law Review 171, 179.
53. M Anderson, 'Transnational Corporations and Environmental Damage: Is Tort Law the Answer?' (2002) 41 Washburn Law Journal 399, 413-14
54. G Virgo, 'Characterisation, Choice of Law and Human Rights' in C Scott (ed) Torture as Tort (Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2001) 325, 339-42
55. C Scott, 'Multinational Enterprises and Emergent Jurisprudence on Violations of Economic Social and Cultural Rights' in A Eide, C Krause and A Rosas (eds) Economic Social and Cultural Rights 2nd edn (The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 2001) 593.
56. H Ward, 'Securing Transnational Corporate Accountability through National Courts: Implications and Policy Options' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 451, 461-62.
57. J Terry, 'Taking Filartiga on the Road: Why Courts outside the United States should accept Jurisdiction over Actions involving Torture Committed Abroad' in Scott, above n 39, at 124.
58. M Byers, 'Decisions of British Courts during 1997 involving Questions of International Law' (1997) 68 British Yearbook of International Law 301, 316-18.
59. S Joseph and M Castan, Federal Constitutional Law: A Contemporary View (Sydney, Lawbook Co, 2001) 82.
60. P Nygh, 'The Common Law Approach' in C McLachlan and P Nygh (eds), Transnational Tort Litigation: Jurisdictional Principles (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1996) 28.
61. P Prince, 'Bhopal, Bougainville and Ok Tedi: Why Australia's Forum non Conveniens Approach is Better' (1998) 47 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 573, 594.
62. R Hawes, 'Politicians turn talk into intimidation' The Australian (New South Wales, Australia, 25 March 1997) 6, quoting plaintiffs' lawyer Nick Styant-Browne. Proceedings regarding Rio Tinto's actions in Bougainville were eventually commenced in the US in 2000, where they were dismissed for reasons other than FNC. See above, ch 2, pp 42, 45-47.
63. A Orange, 'Torture, Tort Choice of Law, and Tolofson' in Scott, above n 39, at 321-22.
64. W Loomis, 'The Responsibility of Parent Corporations for the Human Rights Violations of their Subsidiaries' in M Addo (ed), Human Rights Standards and the Responsibility of Transnational Corporations (The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 1999) 145.
65. D Prentice, 'Veil Piercing and Successor Liability in the United Kingdom' (1996) 10 Florida Journal of International Law 469, 474.
66. PI Blumberg, 'Accountability of Multinational Corporations: The Barriers Presented by Concepts of the Corporate Juridical Entity' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 297, 300-4.
67. E Marcks, 'Avoiding Liability for Human Rights Violations in Project Finance' (2001) 22 Energy Law Journal 301, 323
68. JL Westbrook, 'Theories of Parent Company Liability and the Prospects for an International Settlement' (1985) 20 Texas International Law Journal 321, 324.
69. RB Thompson, 'Piercing the Veil within Corporate Groups: Corporate Shareholders as Mere Investors' (1999) 13 Connecticut Journal of International Law 379, 379-83.
70. RB Thompson, 'Piercing the Corporate Veil: An Empirical Study' (1991) 76 Cornell Law Review 1036, 1038
71. C Mitchell, 'Lifting the Corporate Veil in the English Courts: An Empirical Study' (1999) 3 Company Financial and Insolvency Law Review 15, 22
72. MJ Rogge, 'Towards Transnational Corporate Liability in the Global Economy: Challenging the Doctrine of Forum non Conveniens in Re: Union Carbide, Alfaro, Sequihua, and Aguinda' (2001) 26 Texas International Law Journal 299, 313-14
73. S Zia-Zarifi, 'Suing Multinational Corporations in the US for Violating International Law' (1999) 4 University of California at Los Angeles Journal International Law and Foreign Affairs 81, 142-43
74. H Ward, 'Securing Transnational Corporate Accountability through National Courts: Implications and Policy Options' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 451, 470
75. B Stephens, 'Accountability: International Human Rights Violations Against Corporations in US Courts' in M Kamminga and S Zia-Zarifi (eds), Liability of Multinational Corporations under International Law (The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 2000) 223.
76. P Muchlinski, 'Holding Multinationals to Account: Recent Developments in English Litigation and the Company Law Review' 23(6) The Company Lawyer 168 (2002) commenting on the English cases. Uprendra Baxi has wryly suggested that TNCs opt for settlements to avert any 'precedentcreating effects'
77. U Baxi, 'Geographies of Injustice: Human Rights at the Altar of Convenience' in C Scott (ed), Torture as Tort (Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2001) 197, 209, n 46.
78. U Baxi, Mass Torts, Multinational Enterprise Liability, and Private International Law, 1999 Hague Academy Lectures, 276 Recueil des Cours 305 (The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff, 2000), cited in Baxi, ibid at 207.
79. H Ward 'Towards a New Convention on Corporate Accountability? Some Lessons from the Thor Chemicals and Cape Plc cases' [2002] Yearbook of International Environmental Law 105, 140.
80. E Schrage, 'Judging Corporate Accountability in the Global Economy' (2003) 42 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 153, 165-66.
81. HJ Steiner and P Alston, International Human Rights in Context: Law, Politics, Morals: Text and Materials, 2nd edn (New York, Oxford University Press, 2000) 366.
82. DJ Doward, 'The Forum non Conveniens Doctrine and the Judicial Protection of Multinational Corporations from Forum Shopping Plaintiffs' (1998) 19 University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Economic Law 141.
83. MJ Rogge, 'Towards Transnational Corporate Liability in the Global Economy: Challenging the Doctrine of Forum non Conveniens in Re: Union Carbide, Alfaro, Sequihua, and Aguinda' (2001) 26 Texas International Law Journal 299, 314-17
84. M Anderson, 'Transnational Corporations and Environmental Damage: Is Tort Law the Answer?' (2002) 41 Washburn Law Journal 399, 401-2.
85. H Ward, 'Securing Transnational Corporate Accountability through National Courts: Implications and Policy Options' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 451
86. S Joseph, 'Taming the Leviathans: Multinational Enterprises and Human Rights' (1999) 46 Netherlands International Law Review 171, 192-97
87. PI Blumberg, 'Accountability of Multinational Corporations: The Barriers Presented by Concepts of the Corporate Juridical Entity' (2001) 24 Hastings International and Comparative Law Review 297, 316-17.
88. A Rosencranz and R Campbell, 'Foreign Environmental and Human Rights Suits Against US Corporations in US Courts' (1999) 18 Stanford Environmental Law Journal 145, 180.
89. J Duval-Major, 'One Way Ticket Home: The Federal Doctrine of Forum non Conveniens and the International Plaintiff' (1992) 77 Cornell Law Review 650, 671-72.
90. C Scott, 'Multinational Enterprises and Emergent Jurisprudence on Violations of Economic Social and Cultural Rights' in A Eide, C Krause and A Rosas (eds) Economic Social and Cultural Rights 2nd edn, (The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 2001) 587-90.
91. MR Skolnik, 'Comment: The Forum non Conveniens Doctrine in Alien Tort Claims Act Cases: A Shell of its Former Self after Wiwa' (2002) 16 Emory International Law Review 187, 207.
92. LW Newman, 'Latin America and Forum non Conveniens Dismissals' (Feb 4, 1999) 221 New York Law Journal 3.
93. B Stephens, 'Translating Filartiga: A Comparative and International Law Analysis of Domestic Remedies for International Human Rights Violations' (2002) 27 Yale Journal of International Law 1, 24.
94. M Kamminga and S Zia-Zarifi (eds), Liability of Multinational Corporations under International Law (The Hague, Kluwer Law International, 2000) 283-305.
95. H Ward, Legal Issues in Corporate Citizenship, Swedish Partnership for Global Responsibility, February 2003 (29 December 2003) 17.
96. DN Fagan, 'Achieving Restitution: The Potential Unjust Enrichment Claims of Indigenous Peoples Against Multinational Corporations' (2001) 76 New York University Law Review 626.