Lost in Translation? The Rhetoric of Protecting Indigenous Peoples' Knowledge in International Law and the Omnipresent Reality of Biopiracy

International Library of Environmental, Agricultural and Food Ethics

Volumn 11, Issue , 2007, Pages 111-142

  Mgbeoji, Ikechi ^a  

^a YORK UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Indigenous Knowledge; Indigenous People; Intellectual Property; Plant Genetic Resource; Traditional Knowledge

Indexed keywords

EID: 85101979542     PISSN: 15703010     EISSN: 22151737     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4020-5822-6_6     Document Type: Chapter

References (106)

1. Ackerknecht E (1991) Medicine and Ethnology. The Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, MD
2. Adair J (1997) The bioprospecting question: should the United States charge biotechnology companies for the commercial use of public wild genetic resources? Ecol Law Q 24(1):131–171
3. Adams N (1993) Worlds apart: The North-South divide and the international system. Zed Books, London
4. African Model Legislation for the Protection of the Rights of Local Communities, Framers, and Breeders, and for the Regulation of Biological Resources (2000) OAU Model Law. (Available online: http://www.grain.org/brl_files/oau-model-law-en.pdf. [Last visited June 10, 2006]).
5. Agrawal A (1999) On power and indigenous knowledge. In: Posey D (ed) Cultural and spiritual values of biodiversity: a complementary contribution to global biodiversity assessment. UNEP, Nairobi
6. Anghie A (2004) Imperialism, Sovereignity and the Making of International Law, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
7. Balick M, Cox PA (1996) Plants, people and culture-the science of ethnobotany. Freeman and Company, New York
8. Battiste M, Henderson J (2000) Protecting indigenous knowledge and heritage: a global challenge. Purich Publishing, Saskatoon
9. Battiste M (ed) (2000) Reclaiming indigenous voices and vision. UBC Press, Vancouver
10. Bedjaoui M (1985) Poverty of the international order. In: Falk R, Kratochwil F, Mendlovitz S (eds) International law: a contemporary perspective. pp. 152–163, Boulder, CO: Westview Press
11. Bosselman K (1995) Plants and politics: the international legal regime concerning biotechnology and biodiversity. Colo J Int Environ Law and Policy 7
12. Christina-Butera A (2001) Assimilation, pluralism, and multiculturalism: the policy of racial/ethnic identity in America. Buffalo Human Rights Journal 7
13. Cobo M (2000) Study of the problem of discrimination against indigenous populations. U.N. Doc.E/CN.4/Sub.2/1986/7 Add.4, U.N. Sales No. E.86.XIV.3.3
14. Cohen F (1942) The Spanish origin of Indian rights in the law of the United States. Georgetown Law J 31(1):1–21
15. Convention on Biological Diversity, entered into force on December 19, 1993, reprinted in (1992) 31 I.L.M. 813
16. Coombe R (1998) Intellectual property, human rights and sovereignty: new dilemma in international law posed by the recognition of indigenous knowledge and the conservation of biological diversity. Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies. Ind. J. Global Legal Stud 6(1):59–115
17. Coombe R (1995) The cultural life of things: anthropological approaches to law and society in conditions of globalization. Am Univ J Int Law Policy 10(2)
18. Coombe R (2001) The recognition of indigenous peoples’ and community traditional knowledge in international law. St. Thomas Law Rev 14(2):275–285.
19. Davidson B (1967) The African past: chronicles from antiquity to modern times. Grosset & Dunlap
20. Declaration of Belem (1988) Statement 4
21. Diop C A (1987) Precolonial black Africa. Lawrence Hill Books
22. Drahos P (1997) Indigenous knowledge and duties of intellectual property owners. 11 Intell Prop. J. 179
23. Easlea B (1980) Witch-Hunting, Magic, and the New Philosophy: An Introduction to Debates of the Scientific Revolution, 1450–1750. Haverfield Press, Brighton, Sussex
24. Edsman C-M (ed) (1962) Studies in shamanism. Almqvist & Boktryckeri, Uppsala
25. Ezeabasili N (1977) African Science: myth or reality. Vantage Press, New York
26. Food and Agriculture Organization The IBPGR and Its Policy on In Situ Conservation, FAO Doc/AGPG:IBFGRI/83/143
27. Food and Agriculture Organization (2001) International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture. concluded on 3 November 2001. Available online: http://www.fao.org/ag/crgrfa/itpgr.htm
28. Fitzpatrick P, Darian-Smith E (eds) (1999) Laws of the postcolonial. Michigan, Ann Arbor
29. Four Directions Council (1996) Forests, indigenous peoples and biodiversity: contributions of the four directions council. Submission to the Executive Secretary of the Convention on Biological Diversity by the Four Directions Council, Canada, 15th January 1996. Reproduced in, UNEP/CBD/SBTTA/2/7, 10 August 1996
30. Fowler C, Mooney P (1990) Shattering: Food, Politics, and The Loss of Genetic Diversity. Tucson: The University of Arizona Press
31. Fowler C (1994) Unnatural selection: technology, politics, and plant evolution. Gorden and Breach, Langhorne, PA, USA
32. Friends of The Earth (1995) Intellectual Property Rights and The Biodiversity Convention: The Impact of GATT. Berdfordshire
33. General Act of The Conference of Berlin (1973) Reprinted in Garvin RJ, Betley JA (eds) The scramble for Africa: documents on the Berlin West African conference and related subjects 1884–1885. Ibadan University Press, Ibadan, Nigeria, p 288
34. Halewood M (1999) Indigenous and local knowledge in international law: a preface to sui generis intellectual property protection. McGill Law J 44(4):953–996
35. Hall WE (1977) A Treatise on International Law. Butterworths, London
36. Hardy C (1994) Patent protection and raw materials: the convention on biological diversity and its implications for U.S. policy on the development and commercialization of biotechnology. University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Business Law 15(2):299–326
37. Hunn E (1993) What is traditional knowledge? In: Williams N, Barnes G (eds) Traditional Ecological knowledge: wisdom for sustainable development. Australian National University, Canberra
38. Indigenous and Tribal Peoples available online
39. International Labour Organization (No. 169) (1989) Concerning indigenous and tribal peoples in independent countries, concluded at Geneva, 27 June 1989, reprinted in 28 I.L.M. 1382. This instrument has not yet come into effect
40. Isaac E (1970) Geography of domestication. Prentice-Hall Englewood Chiffs, New Jersey
41. Javis M (ed) (1991) The influence of religion on the development of international law. Martinus Nijhoff The Hague
42. Jessup P (1973) Non-universal international law. Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 12(3):415–429.
43. Johannes RE (ed) (1989) Traditional ecological knowledge: a collection of essays. Gland, IUCN
44. Johnson M (ed) (1992) Lore: Capturing Traditional Environmental Knowledge. Dene Cultural Institute, International Development Research Center, Ottwa
45. Kameri-Mbote, AP, Cullet P (1999) Agro-biodiversity and international law: a conceptual framework. Journal of Environmental Law 11(2):257–279
46. Kloppenburg J. (1988) First The Seed–The Political Economy of Plant Biotechnology, 1492–2000. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
47. Lagos Observer (1970) February 19, 1885, quoted in Umozurike UO, International law and colonialism. East African Law Review 3
48. Lama A (2000, January 12) Law to protect native intellectual property. IPS News Bulletin,. Available online http://www.ips.org
49. Landy D (ed) (1977) Culture, disease, and healing-studies in medical anthropology. Macmillan Publishing Co. Inc., New York
50. Langley W (1981) The third world: towards a definition. Boston Coll Third World Law J 2:1–28
51. Lesser W (1997) Sustainable use of genetic resources under the convention on biological diversity: exploring access and benefit sharing issues. CAB International, Oxford
52. Lindley M (1969) The acquisition and government of backward territory in international law: being a treatise on the law and practice relating to colonial expansion. Negro Universities Press, New York
53. Lommel A (1967) Shamanism-the beginnings of art. Mcgraw-Hill Book Company, Toronto
54. Loudon JB (ed) (1976) Social anthropology and medicine. Academic Press, London
55. Margadant GF (1980) Official Mexican attitudes towards the Indians: an historical essay. Tulane Law Rev 54
56. Marx K (1977) Capital, vol 1. Vintage Books, New York
57. McClellan T (2001) The role of international law in protecting the traditional knowledge and plant life of indigenous peoples. Wisconsin International Law J 19
58. Meyer G, Blum K, Cull J (eds) (1981) Folk medicine and herbal healing. Charles Thomas Publisher, Illinois
59. Mgbeoji I (2001a) Patents and traditional knowledge of the uses of plants: is a communal patent regime part of the solution to the scourge of biopiracy? Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 9(1):163–186
60. Mgbeoji I (2001b) Patents and plant resources-related knowledge: towards a regime of communal patents for plant resources-related knowledge. In: Islam N et al (eds) Environmental law in developing countries: selected issues. IUCN, Cambridge
61. Mgbeoji I (2003) The juridical origins of the international patent system: towards a historiography of the role of patents in industrialization. Journal of the History of International Law 5(2):403–422
62. Mgbeoji I (2005) Global Biopiracy: patents, plants and indigenous knowledge. UBC Press, Vancouver
63. Miller K et al (1991) Deforestation and species loss: responding to the crisis. In: Matthews JT (ed) Preserving the global environment: the challenge of shared leadership. Norton, New York
64. Morley P (1978) Culture and the cognitive world of traditional medical beliefs: some preliminary considerations. In: Morley P, Wallis R (eds) Culture and curing-anthropological perspectives on traditional medical beliefs and practices. University of Pennsylvania Press, Pennsylvania
65. Muchena ON, Vanek E (1995) From ecology through economics to ethno-science: changing perceptions on natural resource management. In: Warren DM, Slikkerveer LJ, Brokensha D (eds) The cultural dimensions of knowledge: indigenous knowledge systems. Intermediate Technology Publications, London
66. Mutua M (2001) Savages, victims and saviours: the metaphor of human rights. Harvard Inte Law J 42(1):201–245
67. Mutua M (2000) What is TWAIL? American Society of International Law Proceedings 94:31–39
68. Nunes K (1995) We can do. better: rights of singular peoples and the United Nations declaration on the ‘rights of indigenous peoples.’ St Thomas Law Rev 7(3):521–555.
69. Oguamanam C (2004) The protection of traditional knowledge: towards a cross-cultural dialogue. Aust Intellect Prop J 15(1):34–59
70. Okpewho I (1975) The epic in Africa: toward a poetics of the oral performance. Columbia University Press
71. Onwuekwe CB (2004) The commons concept and intellectual property rights regime: whither plant genetic resources and traditional knowledge? Pierce Law Review 2(1)
72. Orr D (1999, July 31) India accuses US of stealing ancient cures. The Times, London
73. Osava M (1999, August 14) Brazil biodiversity: crackdown on eco-pirates. IPS
74. Rural Advancement Foundation International (1999) Aussies ‘Pirate’ Other’s Genius? Available online http://www.rafi.org/pr/release11.html
75. Rural Advancement Foundation International (1995a, September/October) Biopiracy update: a global pandemic. RAFI Communiqué
76. Rural Advancement Foundation International (1995b, September/October) RAFI’s List of bio-prospectors and biopirates. RAFI Communiqué
77. Roht-Arriaza N (1996) Of seeds and shamans: the appropriation of the scientific and technical knowledge of indigenous and local communities. Michigan Journal of International Law 17(4):919–965
78. Sanders D (1983) The re-emergence of indigenous questions in international law. Can Hum Rights Yearb 1:3–30
79. Santiago C et al (eds) (2004) Accessing biodiversity and sharing the benefits: lessons from implementing the convention on biological diversity. IUCN, Gland
80. Sarma L (1999) Biopiracy: twentieth century imperialism in the form of international agreements. Temple Int Comp Law J 13(1):107–136
81. Seidl-Hohenveldern I (1963) Transformation or adoption of international law into municipal law. Int Comp Law Q 12(1):88–124
82. Semali L, Kincheloe J (eds) (1999) What is indigenous knowledge: voices from the academy. Falmer, London
83. Shiva V (1988) Staying alive: women, ecology and development. Zed Books Ltd., London
84. Shiva V (1999) Biopiracy: need to change western IPR systems. The Hindu, Wednesday, July 28
85. Simmonds N (1979) Principles of crop improvement. Longman, New York
86. Sinha R (1996) Ethnobotany-the renaissance of traditional herbal medicine. Ina Shree Publishers, Jaipur, India
87. Slater D (1994, December) Contesting occidental visions of the global: the geopolitics of theory and North-South relations. Beyond Law 4(11):97–118
88. Stanley A (1993) Mothers and daughter of invention. The Scarecrow Press, Metuchen, NJ
89. Stenson A, Gray T (1999) The politics of genetic resource control. Macmillan Press, London
90. Tejera V (1999) Tripping over property rights: is it possible to reconcile the convention on biological diversity with Article 27 of The TRIPs agreement? New Eng Law Rev 33(4):967–987
91. The Convention Concerning The Protection And Integration Of Indigenous And Other Tribal And Semi-Tribal Populations In Independent Countries (1957) 26 June, reprinted in 328 U.N.T.S. 247
92. The Crucible Group (1994) People, plants, and patents: the impact of intellectual property on trade, plant, biodiversity, and rural society. IDRC, Ottawa
93. Tillford D (1998) Saving the blue prints: the international regime for plant resources. Case West Reserve J Int Law 30(2–3):373–446
94. United Nations Environment Programme, Convention on Biological Diversity, Report of the Intergovernmental Committee 2/13, 1994 par. 16
95. United Nations Treaty Series 993. 3. (1966)
96. United Nations Treaty Series 1155 339 Available online: http://untreaty.un.org/English/treaty.asp
97. Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Resolution (1948) 217 A(III) of December
98. Vienna Convention on The Law of Treaties. Available online: http://www.un.org/law/ilc/texts/treaties.htm
99. Villaema L (2000) Indians want patent: Chiefs Prepare International Law Suit Against Scientist Who Registered Indigenous Knowledge. ISTOE Magazine. No. 1581, Sao Paulo, 19 January
100. Vogel J (1994) Genes for sale: privatization as a conservation policy. Oxford University Press, Oxford United Kingdom
101. Vogel V (1992) American Indian influence on the American pharmacopoeia. In: Johnson M (ed) Lore: capturing traditional environmental knowledge. Ottawa, Dene Cultural Institute, International Development Research Center.
102. Wiessner S, Battiste M (2000) The 2000 revision of the united nations draft principles and guidelines on the protection of the heritage of indigenous knowledge. St. Thomas Law Rev 13(1):383–390
103. Wiessner S (1999, Spring) Rights and status of indigenous peoples: a global perspective and international legal analysis. Harv Hum Rights J 12: 57–128.
104. Wilkes G (1977) The World’s crop germ plasm-an endangered resource. Bull At Sci 8
105. Williamson E (1992) The penguin history of latin America. Penguin, London
106. WTO Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, 15 April 1994, 33 ILM 1197