How does tillage intensity affect soil organic carbon? A systematic review

Environmental Evidence

Volumn 6, Issue 1, 2017, Pages

  Haddaway, Neal R ^a   Hedlund, Katarina ^b   Jackson, Louise E ^c   Kätterer, Thomas ^d   Lugato, Emanuele ^e   Thomsen, Ingrid K ^f   Jørgensen, Helene B ^b   Isberg, Per Erik ^b  

^a STOCKHOLM ENVIRONMENT INSTITUTE   (Sweden)

^b LUND UNIVERSITY   (Sweden)

^c UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^d SWEDISH UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES   (Sweden)

^e JOINT RESEARCH CENTRE   (Italy)

^f AARHUS UNIVERSITY   (Denmark)

Author keywords

Agriculture; Carbon sequestration; Climate change; Conservation; Farming; Land management; Land use change; Plough; Till

Indexed keywords

EID: 85038436414     PISSN: None     EISSN: 20472382     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1186/s13750-017-0108-9     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. Follett R. Soil management concepts and carbon sequestration in cropland soils. Soil Tillage Res. 2001;61(1):77-92.
2. Kimble JM, Follett RF, Cole CV. The potential of US cropland to sequester carbon and mitigate the greenhouse effect. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 1998.
3. 2 emissions and C sequestration by agriculture - perspectives and limitations. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst. 2001;60(1-3):253-66.
4. Schlesinger W. Biogeochemistry: an analysis of global change. San Diego: Academic Press; 1991.
5. Betts RA, Falloon PD, Goldewijk KK, Ramankutty N. Biogeophysical effects of land use on climate: model simulations of radiative forcing and large-scale temperature change. Agric For Meteorol. 2007;142(2):216-33.
6. Kucharik CJ, Brye KR, Norman JM, Foley JA, Gower ST, Bundy LG. Measurements and modeling of carbon and nitrogen cycling in agroecosystems of southern Wisconsin: potential for SOC sequestration during the next 50 years. Ecosystems. 2001;4(3):237-58.
7. 2 emissions and carbon sequestration: effect of secondary tillage and compaction. Conservation agriculture. Berlin: Springer; 2003. p. 291-300.
8. González-Sánchez E, Ordóñez-Fernández R, Carbonell-Bojollo R, Veroz-González O, Gil-Ribes J. Meta-analysis on atmospheric carbon capture in Spain through the use of conservation agriculture. Soil Tillage Res. 2012;122:52-60.
9. Lal R, Delgado J, Groffman P, Millar N, Dell C, Rotz A. Management to mitigate and adapt to climate change. J Soil Water Conserv. 2011;66(4):276-85.
10. Bolinder M, Kätterer T, Andrén O, Ericson L, Parent L-E, Kirchmann H. Long-term soil organic carbon and nitrogen dynamics in forage-based crop rotations in Northern Sweden (63-64N). Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2010;138(3):335-42.
11. Lal R, Follett R. Soils and climate change. Soil carbon sequestration and the greenhouse effect. Madison: SSSA Special Publication; 2009. p. 57.
12. Hati KM, Swarup A, Dwivedi A, Misra A, Bandyopadhyay K. Changes in soil physical properties and organic carbon status at the topsoil horizon of a vertisol of central India after 28 years of continuous cropping, fertilization and manuring. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2007;119(1):127-34.
13. Yang X, Li P, Zhang S, Sun B, Xinping C. Long-term-fertilization effects on soil organic carbon, physical properties, and wheat yield of a loess soil. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci. 2011;174(5):775-84.
14. Barrios E. Soil biota, ecosystem services and land productivity. Ecol Econ. 2007;64(2):269-85.
15. Lal R, Reicosky D, Hanson J. Evolution of the plow over 10,000 years and the rationale for no-till farming. Soil Tillage Res. 2007;93(1):1-12.
16. Kern J, Johnson M. Conservation tillage impacts on national soil and atmospheric carbon levels. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 1993;57(1):200-10.
17. West TO, Post WM. Soil organic carbon sequestration rates by tillage and crop rotation. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2002;66(6):1930-46.
18. Holland J. The environmental consequences of adopting conservation tillage in Europe: reviewing the evidence. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2004;103(1):1-25.
19. Davies DB, Finney JB. Reduced cultivations for cereals: research, development and advisory needs under changing economic circumstances. Kenilworth: Home Grown Cereals Authority; 2002.
20. Pittelkow CM, Linquist BA, Lundy ME, Liang X, Van Groenigen KJ, Lee J, Van Gestel N, Six J, Venterea RT, Van Kessel C. When does no-till yield more? A global meta-analysis. Field Crops Res. 2015;183:156-68.
21. Van den Putte A, Govers G, Diels J, Gillijns K, Demuzere M. Assessing the effect of soil tillage on crop growth: a meta-regression analysis on European crop yields under conservation agriculture. Eur J Agron. 2010;33(3):231-41.
22. Basche AD, Miguez FE, Kaspar TC, Castellano MJ. Do cover crops increase or decrease nitrous oxide emissions? A meta-analysis. J Soil Water Conserv. 2014;69(6):471-82.
23. 2O emissions from agricultural soils in Canada. I. Development of a country-specific methodology. Can J Soil Sci. 2008;88(5):641-54.
24. Alvarez R. A review of nitrogen fertilizer and conservation tillage effects on soil organic carbon storage. Soil Use Manag. 2005;21(1):38-52.
25. Amini S, Asoodar MA. The effect of conservation tillage on crop yield production (The Review). N Y Sci J 2015;8(3):25-9.
26. Angers D, Eriksen-Hamel N. Full-inversion tillage and organic carbon distribution in soil profiles: a meta-analysis. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2008;72(5):1370-4.
27. Govaerts B, Verhulst N, Castellanos-Navarrete A, Sayre KD, Dixon J, Dendooven L. Conservation agriculture and soil carbon sequestration: between myth and farmer reality. Crit Rev Plant Sci. 2009;28(3):97-122.
28. Six J, Feller C, Denef K, Ogle S, de Moraes Sa JC, Albrecht A. Soil organic matter, biota and aggregation in temperate and tropical soils-effects of no-tillage. Agronomie. 2002;22(7-8):755-75.
29. Dimassi B, Mary B, Wylleman R, Labreuche J, Couture D, Piraux F, Cohan J-P. Long-term effect of contrasted tillage and crop management on soil carbon dynamics during 41 years. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2014;188:134-46.
30. Powlson DS, Stirling CM, Jat M, Gerard BG, Palm CA, Sanchez PA, Cassman KG. Limited potential of no-till agriculture for climate change mitigation. Nat Clim Change. 2014;4(8):678-83.
31. Baker JM, Ochsner TE, Venterea RT, Griffis TJ. Tillage and soil carbon sequestration - What do we really know? Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2007;118(1):1-5.
32. Virto I, Barré P, Burlot A, Chenu C. Carbon input differences as the main factor explaining the variability in soil organic C storage in no-tilled compared to inversion tilled agrosystems. Biogeochemistry. 2012;108(1-3):17-26.
33. Haddaway NR, Hedlund K, Jackson LE, Kätterer T, Lugato E, Thomsen IK, Jørgensen HB, Söderström B. What are the effects of agricultural management on soil organic carbon in boreoerate systems? Environ Evid. 2015;4(1):1.
34. Amini S, Asoodar MA. The effect of conservation tillage on crop yield production. NY Sci J. 2016;8(3):25-9.
35. Haddaway NR, Hedlund K, Jackson LE, Jørgensen HB, Kätterer T, Lugato E, Söderström B, Thomsen IK. What are the effects of agricultural management on soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks? A systematic map. Environ Evid. 2015;4(1):23.
36. Söderström B, Hedlund K, Jackson LE, Kätterer T, Lugato E, Thomsen IK, Jørgensen HB. What are the effects of agricultural management on soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks? Environ Evid. 2014;3(1):1.
37. Haddaway NR, Hedlund K, Jackson LE, Kätterer T, Lugato E, Thomsen IK, Jørgensen HB, Isberg P-E. How does tillage intensity affect soil organic carbon? A systematic review protocol. Environ Evid. 2016;5(1):1.
38. Haddaway NR, Collins AM, Coughlin D, Kirk S. The role of Google Scholar in evidence reviews and its applicability to grey literature searching. PLoS ONE. 2015;10(9):e0138237.
39. Haddaway NR. The use of web-scraping software in searching for grey literature. Grey J. 2015;11(3):186-90.
40. Necpálová M, Anex R, Kravchenko AN, Abendroth LJ, Del Grosso SJ, Dick WA, Helmers MJ, Herzmann D, Lauer JG, Nafziger ED. What does it take to detect a change in soil carbon stock? A regional comparison of minimum detectable difference and experiment duration in the north central United States. J Soil Water Conserv. 2014;69(6):517-31.
41. Smith P. How long before a change in soil organic carbon can be detected? Glob Change Biol. 2004;10(11):1878-83.
42. Cohen J. Weighted kappa: nominal scale agreement provision for scaled disagreement or partial credit. Psychol Bull. 1968;70(4):213.
43. Soil Survey Staff. Soil survey manual. 1993.
44. Team RC. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vellore: Team RC; 2016.
45. Viechtbauer W. Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. J Stat Softw. 2010;36(3):1-48.
46. Zuur AF, Ieno EN, Walker NJ, Saveliev AA, Smith GM. Mixed effects modelling for nested data. Mixed effects models and extensions in ecology with R. Berlin: Springer; 2009. p. 101-42.
47. Poeplau C, Don A. Carbon sequestration in agricultural soils via cultivation of cover crops - a meta-analysis. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2015;200:33-41.
48. Wiesmeier M, von Lützow M, Spörlein P, Geuß U, Hangen E, Reischl A, Schilling B, Kögel-Knabner I. Land use effects on organic carbon storage in soils of Bavaria: the importance of soil types. Soil Tillage Res. 2015;146:296-302.
49. Mao D, Wang Z, Li L, Miao Z, Ma W, Song C, Ren C, Jia M. Soil organic carbon in the Sanjiang Plain of China: storage, distribution and controlling factors. Biogeosciences. 2015;12(6):1635-45.
50. Cochran WG. The combination of estimates from different experiments. Biometrics. 1954;10(1):101-29.
51. Viechtbauer W, Cheung MWL. Outlier and influence diagnostics for meta-analysis. Res Synth Methods. 2010;1(2):112-25.
52. Lal R. Global potential of soil carbon sequestration to mitigate the greenhouse effect. Crit Rev Plant Sci. 2003;22(2):151-84.
53. Busari MA, Kukal SS, Kaur A, Bhatt R, Dulazi AA. Conservation tillage impacts on soil, crop and the environment. Int Soil Water Conserv Res. 2015;3(2):119-29.
54. Sperow M. Estimating carbon sequestration potential on US agricultural topsoils. Soil Tillage Res. 2016;155:390-400.
55. Minoshima H, Jackson L, Cavagnaro T, Sánchez-Moreno S, Ferris H, Temple S, Goyal S, Mitchell J. Soil food webs and carbon dynamics in response to conservation tillage in California. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2007;71(3):952-63.
56. Olson KR. Impacts of tillage, slope, and erosion on soil organic carbon retention. Soil Sci. 2010;175(11):562-7.
57. Liu X, Zhang X, Chen S, Sun H, Shao L. Subsoil compaction and irrigation regimes affect the root-shoot relation and grain yield of winter wheat. Agric Water Manag. 2015;154:59-67.
58. 2 emissions the most under arid and sandy soil conditions: results from a meta-analysis. Biogeosci Discus. 2015;13:3619-33.
59. Xu X, Shi Z, Li D, Rey A, Ruan H, Craine JM, Liang J, Zhou J, Luo Y. Soil properties control decomposition of soil organic carbon: results from data-assimilation analysis. Geoderma. 2016;262:235-42.
60. Rasmussen PE, Goulding KW, Brown JR, Grace PR, Janzen HH, Körschens M. Long-term agroecosystem experiments: assessing agricultural sustainability and global change. Science. 1998;282(5390):893-6.
61. Reeves D. The role of soil organic matter in maintaining soil quality in continuous cropping systems. Soil Tillage Res. 1997;43(1):131-67.
62. Carter M. Relative measures of soil bulk density to characterize compaction in tillage studies on fine sandy loams. Can J Soil Sci. 1990;70(3):425-33.
63. Ellert B, Janzen H, Entz T. Assessment of a method to measure temporal change in soil carbon storage. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2002;66(5):1687-95.
64. Wuest SB. Correction of bulk density and sampling method biases using soil mass per unit area. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2009;73(1):312-6.
65. Lee J, Hopmans JW, Rolston DE, Baer SG, Six J. Determining soil carbon stock changes: simple bulk density corrections fail. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2009;134(3):251-6.
66. Wendt J, Hauser S. An equivalent soil mass procedure for monitoring soil organic carbon in multiple soil layers. Eur J Soil Sci. 2013;64(1):58-65.
67. McBratney AB, Minasny B. Comment on "Determining soil carbon stock changes: simple bulk density corrections fail". Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2010;136(1):185-6.
68. Goidts E, Van Wesemael B, Crucifix M. Magnitude and sources of uncertainties in soil organic carbon (SOC) stock assessments at various scales. Eur J Soil Sci. 2009;60(5):723-39.
69. Doetterl S, Berhe AA, Nadeu E, Wang Z, Sommer M, Fiener P. Erosion, deposition and soil carbon: a review of process-level controls, experimental tools and models to address C cycling in dynamic landscapes. Earth Sci Rev. 2016;154:102-22.
70. Amundson R, Berhe AA, Hopmans JW, Olson C, Sztein AE, Sparks DL. Soil and human security in the 21st century. Science. 2015;348(6235):1261071.
71. Sommer M, Augustin J, Kleber M. Feedbacks of soil erosion on SOC patterns and carbon dynamics in agricultural landscapes - the CarboZALF experiment. Soil Tillage Res. 2016;156:182-4.
72. Pittelkow CM, Liang X, Linquist BA, Van Groenigen KJ, Lee J, Lundy ME, van Gestel N, Six J, Venterea RT, van Kessel C. Productivity limits and potentials of the principles of conservation agriculture. Nature. 2015;517(7534):365-8.
73. Ball B. Soil structure and greenhouse gas emissions: a synthesis of 20 years of experimentation. Eur J Soil Sci. 2013;64(3):357-73.
74. Awale R, Chatterjee A, Franzen D. Tillage and N-fertilizer influences on selected organic carbon fractions in a North Dakota silty clay soil. Soil Tillage Res. 2013;134:213-22.
75. Abdullah AS. Minimum tillage and residue management increase soil water content, soil organic matter and canola seed yield and seed oil content in the semiarid areas of Northern Iraq. Soil Tillage Res. 2014;144:150-5.
76. Johnston AE, Poulton PR, Coleman K. Soil organic matter: its importance in sustainable agriculture and carbon dioxide fluxes. Adv Agron. 2009;101:1-57.
77. Dimassi B, Cohan J-P, Labreuche J, Mary B. Changes in soil carbon and nitrogen following tillage conversion in a long-term experiment in Northern France. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2013;169:12-20.
78. Antille DL, Chamen WC, Tullberg JN, Lal R. The potential of controlled traffic farming to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and enhance carbon sequestration in arable land: a critical review. Trans ASABE. 2015;58(3):707-31.
79. Golchin A, Oades J, Skjemstad J, Clarke P. Study of free and occluded particulate organic matter in soils by solid state 13C CP/MAS NMR spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Soil Res. 1994;32(2):285-309.
80. Angers D, Bolinder M, Carter M, Gregorich E, Drury C, Liang B, Voroney R, Simard R, Donald R, Beyaert R. Impact of tillage practices on organic carbon and nitrogen storage in cool, humid soils of eastern Canada. Soil Tillage Res. 1997;41(3):191-201.
81. Kainiemi V, Arvidsson J, Kätterer T. Short-term organic matter mineralisation following different types of tillage on a Swedish clay soil. Biol Fertil Soils. 2013;49(5):495-504.
82. Kainiemi V, Arvidsson J, Kätterer T. Effects of autumn tillage and residue management on soil respiration in a long-term field experiment in Sweden. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci. 2015;178(2):189-98.
83. Kainiemi V, Kirchmann H, Kätterer T. Structural disruption of arable soils under laboratory conditions causes minor respiration increases. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci. 2015;179(1):88-93.
84. Ladygina N, Hedlund K. Plant species influence microbial diversity and carbon allocation in the rhizosphere. Soil Biol Biochem. 2010;42(2):162-8.
85. Kätterer T, Bolinder MA, Andrén O, Kirchmann H, Menichetti L. Roots contribute more to refractory soil organic matter than above-ground crop residues, as revealed by a long-term field experiment. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2011;141(1):184-92.
86. Tsiafouli MA, Thébault E, Sgardelis SP, Ruiter PC, Putten WH, Birkhofer K, Hemerik L, Vries FT, Bardgett RD, Brady MV. Intensive agriculture reduces soil biodiversity across Europe. Glob Change Biol. 2015;21(2):973-85.
87. Helgason T, Daniell T, Husband R, Fitter A, Young J. Ploughing up the wood-wide web? Nature. 1998;394(6692):431.
88. de Vries FT, Thébault E, Liiri M, Birkhofer K, Tsiafouli MA, Bjørnlund L, Jørgensen HB, Brady MV, Christensen S, de Ruiter PC. Soil food web properties explain ecosystem services across European land use systems. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2013;110(35):14296-301.
89. Six J, Frey SD, Thiet RK, Batten KM. Bacterial and fungal contributions to carbon sequestration in agroecosystems. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2006;70(2):555-69.
90. De Vries FT, Bracht Jørgensen H, Hedlund K, Bardgett RD. Disentangling plant and soil microbial controls on carbon and nitrogen loss in grassland mesocosms. J Ecol. 2015;103(3):629-40.
91. Bernes C, Carpenter SR, Gårdmark A, Larsson P, Persson L, Skov C, Speed JD, Van Donk E. What is the influence of a reduction of planktivorous and benthivorous fish on water quality in temperate eutrophic lakes? A systematic review. Environ Evid. 2015;4(1):1.
92. Haddaway NR, Burden A, Evans CD, Healey JR, Jones DL, Dalrymple SE, Pullin AS. Evaluating effects of land management on greenhouse gas fluxes and carbon balances in boreoerate lowland peatland systems. Environ Evid. 2014;3(1):1.
93. Haddaway NR, Verhoeven JT. Poor methodological detail precludes experimental repeatability and hampers synthesis in ecology. Ecol Evol. 2015;5(19):4451-4.
94. Brady MV, Hedlund K, Cong R-G, Hemerik L, Hotes S, Machado S, Mattsson L, Schulz E, Thomsen IK. Valuing supporting soil ecosystem services in agriculture: a natural capital approach. Agron J. 2015;107(5):1809-21.
95. REGULATION (EU) No 1307/2013. 2013.
96. Agenda L-PA. Join the 4/1000 Initiative Soils for Food Security and Climate: UNFCCC; 2016. http://newsroom.unfccc.int/lpaa/agriculture/join-the-41000-initiative-soils-for-food-security-and-climate/. Accessed 9 Dec 2016.
97. FAO. Global Soil Partnership: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations; 2016. http://www.fao.org/global-soil-partnership/en/. Accessed 9 Dec 2016.
98. Haddaway NR, Hedlund K, Jackson LE, Kätterer T, Lugato E, Thomsen IK, Jørgensen HB, Isberg P-E. Which agricultural management interventions are most influential on soil organic carbon (using time series data)? Environ Evid. 2016;5(1):1.
99. Kätterer T, Bolinder M, Berglund K, Kirchmann H. Strategies for carbon sequestration in agricultural soils in northern Europe. Acta Agric Scandinavica A-Anim Sci. 2012;62(4):181-98.