Assessment of manual assembly complexity: A theoretical and empirical comparison of two methods

International Journal of Production Research

Volumn 55, Issue 24, 2017, Pages 7237-7250

  Falck, Ann Christine ^a   Tarrar, Malin ^a   Mattsson, Sandra ^a   Andersson, Lina ^b   Rosenqvist, Mikael ^a   Söderberg, Rikard ^a  

^a CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Sweden)

^b VOLVO AERO CORPORATION   (Sweden)

Author keywords

Assessment; Basic assembly complexity (cxb); Complexity index (cxi); Manual assembly; Method comparison; Product development; Production management; Sustainable manufacturing

Indexed keywords

INDIUM COMPOUNDS; LIFE CYCLE; PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT;

ASSESSMENT; BASIC ASSEMBLY COMPLEXITY (CXB); COMPLEXITY INDEX (CXI); MANUAL ASSEMBLY; METHOD COMPARISON; PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT; SUSTAINABLE MANUFACTURING;

ASSEMBLY;

EID: 85019756104     PISSN: 00207543     EISSN: 1366588X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00207543.2017.1330571     Document Type: Article

References (43)

1. Alkan, B., D. Vera, M. Ahmad, B. Ahmad, and R. Harrison. 2016. “A Model for Complexity Assessment in Manual Assembly Operations through Predetermined Motion Time Systems.” Procedia CIRP 44: 429–434.
2. Asadi, N., and S. Javadi. 2016. “Key Complexity Dimensions in Assembly Systems with Mixed-model Assembly Lines a Multiple Case Study.” 5th World Conference on Production and Operations Management, Havanna, September.
3. Boothroyd, G. 1980. Design for Assembly – A Designer’s Handbook, Amherst: Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Massachusetts.
4. Boothroyd, G., P. Dewhurst, and W. Knight. 2002. Product Design for Manufacture and Assembly. 2nd ed., New York: Marcel Dekker.
5. Chéramy, D., and A. Ittner. 2013. Adjustment Costs Related to Assembly Complexity and Ergonomics. Master of Science Thesis. Department of Product and Production Development, Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden.
6. Chryssolouris, G., K. Efthymiou, N. Papakostas, D. Mourtzis, and A. Pagoropoulos. 2013. “Flexibility and Complexity: Is It a Trade-off?” International Journal of Production Research 51 (23–24): 6788–6802.
7. Dunning, D., C. Heath, and J. M. Suls. 2004. “Flawed Self-assessment.” Psychological Science in the Public Interest 5 (3): 69–106.
8. Efthymiou, K., D. Mourtzis, A. Pagoropolous, N. Papakostas, and G. Chryssolouris. 2016. “Manufacturing Systems Complexity Analysis Methods Review.” International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing 2 (9).
9. ElMaraghy, W., H. ElMaraghy, T. Tomiyama, and L. Monostori. 2012. “Complexity in Engineering Design and Manufacturing.” CIRP Annals – Manufacturing Technology 61: 793–814.
10. Falck, A., and M. Rosenqvist. 2012. “What Are the Obstacles and Needs of Proactive Ergonomics Measures at Early Product Development Stages? – An Interview Study in Five Swedish Companies.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 42: 406–415.
11. Falck, A., and M. Rosenqvist. 2014. “A Model for Calculation of the Costs of Poor Assembly Ergonomics (Part 1).” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 44 (1): 140–147.
12. Falck, A., R. Örtengren, and M. Rosenqvist. 2014. “Assembly Failures and Action Cost in Relation to Complexity Level and Assembly Ergonomics in Manual Assembly (Part 2).” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 44 (3): 455–459.
13. Falck, A., L. Andersson, S. Mattsson, M. Karlsson, M. Rosenqvist, and R. Söderberg. 2015. “A Comparison of Two Methods for Assessment of Assembly Complexity – What Are They Good for?” Proceedings of Nordic Ergonomics Association (NES) Conference. November 2–4, Lillehammer.
14. Falck, A., R. Örtengren, M. Rosenqvist, and R. Söderberg. 2016. “Proactive Assessment of Basic Complexity in Manual Assembly: Development of a Tool to Predict and Control Operator-induced Quality Errors.” International Journal of Production Research. 55 (15).
15. Falck, A., R. Örtengren, M. Rosenqvist, and R. Söderberg. 2017. “Basic Complexity Criteria and Their Impact on Manual Assembly Quality in Actual Production.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 58 (2017): 1–12.
16. Frizelle, G., and Y. M. Suhov. 2001. “An Entropic Measurement of Queueing Behaviour in a Class of Manufacturing Operations.” Proceedings of Royal Society, 1579–1601. London.
17. Frizelle, G., and E. Woodcock. 1995. “Measuring Complexity as an Aid to Developing Operational Strategy.” International Journal of Operations & Production Management 15: 26–39.
18. Guimaraes, T., N. Martensson, J. Stahre, and M. Igbaria. 1999. “Empirically Testing the Impact of Manufacturing System Complexity on Performance.” International Journal of Operations & Production Management 19: 1254–1269.
19. Gullander, P., S. Mattsson, T. Fässberg, H. Van Landeghem, L. Zeltzer, L. Lime’re, E.H. Aghezzaf, and J. Stahre. 2012. “Comparing Two Methods to Measure Assembly Complexity from an Operator Perspective.” Swedish Production Symposium, SPS 12, 6–8/ 11, Linköping
20. Hu, S. J., J. Ko, L. Weyand, H. A. ElMaraghy, T. K. Lien, Y. Koren, H. Bley, G. Chryssolouris, N. Nasr, and M. Shpitalni. 2011. “Assembly System Design and Operations for Product Variety.” CIRP Annals –Manufacturing Technology 60: 715–733.
21. Kuzgunkaya, O., and H. A. ElMaraghy. 2006. “Assessing the Structural Complexity of Manufacturing Systems Configurations.” International Journal of Flexible Manufacturing Systems 18 (2): 145–171.
22. Li, K., and P. A. Wieringa. 2001. “Structured Operation Environment Complexity in Human Supervisory Control.” Asian Journal of Control 3: 181–189.
23. Matt, D. 2012. “Application of Axiomatic Design Principles to Control Complexity Dynamics in a Mixed-model Assembly System: A Case Analysis.” International Journal of Production Research 50 (7): 1850–1861.
24. Mattson, S., P. Gullander, and A. Davidsson. 2011. “Method for Measuring Production Complexity.” International Manufacturing Conference, IMC28-Manufacturing Sustainability, Dublin City University, Ireland.
25. Mattsson, S. 2013. What is Perceived as Complex in Final Assembly? To Define, Measure and Manage Production Complexity, 44– 49. Thesis of Licentiate of Philosophy at Dep. of Product and Production Development, Chalmers University of Technology (Serie No. 81).
26. Mattsson, S., P. Gullander, U. Harlin, G. Bäckstrand, Å. Fasth, and A. Davidsson. 2012. “Testing Complexity Index – A Method for Measuring Perceived Production Complexity.” Procedia CIRP 45th CIRP Conference on Manufacturing Systems 3: 394–399.
27. Mattsson, S., M. Karlsson, P. Gullander, H. V. Landeghem, L. Zeltzer, V. Limère, E.-H. Aghezzaf, Å. Fasth, and J. Stahre. 2014. “Comparing Quantifiable Methods to Measure Complexity in Assembly.” International Journal of Manufacturing Research 9: 112–130.
28. Mattsson, S., M. Tarrar, and Å. Fasth. 2016. “Perceived Production Complexity – Understanding More than Parts of a System.” International Journal of Production Research 54 (20): 6008–6016.
29. Meyer, M. H., and K. F. Curley. 1993. “The Impact of Knowledge and Technology Complexity on Decision Making Software Development.” Expert Systems with Applications 8 (1): 111–134.
30. Orfi, N., J. Terpenny, and A. Sahin-Sariisik. 2011. “Harnessing Product Complexity: Step 1 – Establishing Product Complexity Dimensions and Indicators.” The Engineering Economist 56 (1): 59–79.
31. Richardson, M., G. Jones, and M. Torrance. 2004. “Identifying the Task Variables That Influence Perceived Object Assembly Complexity.” Ergonomics 47 (9): 945–964.
32. Richardson, M., G. Jones, M. Torrance, and T. Baguley. 2006. “Identifying the Task Variables That Predict Object Assembly Difficulty.” Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 48 (3): 511–525.
33. Rodriguez-Toro, C., S. Tate, G. Jared, and K. Swift. 2004. “Product-development Complexity Metrics: A Framework for Proactive DFA Implementation.” Proceedings of the International Design Conference, 483–490. Dubrovnik, May 18–21.
34. Samy, S. N., and H. A. ElMaraghy. 2012. “Complexity Mapping of the Product and Assembly System.” Assembly Automation 32 (2): 135–151.
35. Sivadasan, S., J. Efstathiou, A. Calinescu, and L. H. Huatuco. 2006. “Advances on Measuring the Operational Complexity of Supplier–Customer Systems.” European Journal of Operational Research 171: 208–226.
36. Tarrar, M., S. Mattsson, and Å. Fasth-Berglund. 2016. “Using the CompleXity Index to Discuss Improvements at Work: A Case Study in an Automotive Company.” 7th Swedish Production Symposium. Lund, October.
37. Urbanic, R. J., and W. H. ElMaraghy. 2006. “Modeling of Manufacturing Process Complexity.” In Advances in Design, 425–436. Springer series in Advanced Manufacturing. London: Springer-Verlag.
38. Vogel, W., and R. Lasch. 2016. “Complexity Drivers in Manufacturing Companies: A Literature Review.” Logistics Research 9: 1399.
39. Ward, M., L. Gruppen, and G. Regehr. 2002. “Measuring Self-assessment: Current State of the Art.” Advances in Health Sciences Education 7 (1): 63–80.
40. Zaeh, M. F., M. Wiesbeck, S. Stork, and A. Schubö. 2009. “A Multi-dimensional Measure for Determining the Complexity of Manual Assembly Operations.” Production Engineering 3: 489–496.
41. Zeltzer, L., V. Limère, E-H. Aghezzaf, and H. Van Landeghem. 2012. “Measuring the Objective Complexity of Assembly Workstations.” The Seventh International Multi-conference on Computing in the Global Information Technology. Venice, June 24–29.
42. Zeltzer, L., V. Limère, H. Van Landeghem, E-H. Aghezzaf and J. Stahre. 2013. “Measuring Complexity in Mixed-model Assembly Workstations.” International Journal of Production Research 51 (15): 4630–4643.
43. Zhu, X., J. Hu, Y. Koren, and S. Martin. 2008. “Modeling of Manufacturing Complexity in Mixed-model Assembly Lines.” Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering 130: 051013-1–051013-10.