A Meta-Analysis of the Rossell and Baker Review of Bilingual Education Research

Bilingual Research Journal

Volumn 21, Issue 2-3, 1997, Pages 103-122

  Greene, Jay P ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 85011139680     PISSN: 15235882     EISSN: 15235890     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/15235882.1997.10668656     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. Bacon, H. L., Kidd, K & Gerald D., et al. (1982, February). The effectiveness ofbilingual instruction with Cherokee Indian students. Journal of American Indian Education, 34-43.
2. Covey, D. D. (1973). An analytical study ofsecondary freshmen bilingual education and its effects on academic achievement and attitudes of Mexican American students. Doctoral dissertation, Arizona StateUniversity. Random assignment.
3. Danoff, M.N., Arias, B.M., Coles, G. J., and Others. (1977a). Evaluation of the impact ofESEA Title VII Spanish/English bilingual education program. Palo Alto: American Institutes for Research.
4. Huzar, H. (1973). The effects of an English-Spanish primary grade reading program on second and third grade students. Master’s thesis, Rutgers University. Random assignment.
5. Kaufman, M. (1968). Will instruction in reading Spanish affect ability in reading English? Journal of Reading, 11,521-527. Random assignment.
6. Plante, A. J. (1976). A study of effectiveness ofthe Connecticut "Paring” model of bilingual/bicultural education. Hamden: Connecticut Staff Development Cooperative. Random assignment.
7. Powers, S. (1978). The influence of bilingual instruction on academic achievement and self-esteem ofselected Mexican American junior high school students. Doctoral dissertation, University of Arizona.
8. Ramirez, J. D., Pasta, D. J, Yuen, S., Billings, D. K., & Rainey, D. R. (1991). Final report: Longitudinal study of structural immersion strategy, early-exit, and late-exit transitional bilingual education programs for language-minority children. Report to the U.S. Department of Education. San Mateo: Aguirre International.
9. Rossell, C. H. (1990). The effectiveness of educational alternatives for limited-English-proficient children. In G. Imhoff (Ed.), Learning in two languages. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.
10. Rothfarb, S. H., Ariza, M. J. & Urrutia, R. (1987). Evaluation of the Bilingual Curriculum Content (BCC) project: A three-year study, final report. Dade County: Office of Educational Accountability.
11. Skoczylas, R. V. (1972). An evaluation of some cognitive and affective aspects of a Spanish bilingual education program. Doctoral dissertation, University ofNew Mexico.
12. Ariza, M. (1988). Evaluating limited English proficient students’achievement: Does curriculum content in the home language make a difference? Paper presented at the April meetings of the AmericanEducational Research Association, New Orleans. Redundant with Rothfarb et al., 1987.
13. Barik, H., and Swain, M. (1978). Evaluation of a bilingual education program in Canada: The Elgin Study through grade six. Switzerland: Commission Interuniversitaire Suisse de Linguistique Appliquée. Redundant with Barik et al. 1977.
14. Cohen, A. D., Fathman, A. K., & Merino, B. (1976). The Redwood Citybilingual education report, 1971-1974: Spanish and English proficiency, mathematics, and language-use over time. Toronto: Ontario Institute for Studies in Education. Redundant with Cohen 1975.
15. Curiel, H., Stenning, W., & Cooper-Stenning, P. (1980). Achieved ready level, self-esteem, and grades as related to length of exposure to Bilingual education. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 2, 389-400. Redundantwith Curiel, 1979.
16. Danoff, M. N., Coles, G. J., McLaughlin, D. H., & Reynolds, D. J. (1977b). Evaluation of the impact of ESEA Title VII Spanish/English bilingual education programs, Vol. I: Study design and interim findings. Palo Alto: American Institutes for Research. Redundant with Danoff et al. 1977a.
17. Danoff, M. N., Coles, G. J., McLaughlin, D. H., & Reynolds, D. J. (1978a). Evaluation of the impact of ESEA Title VII Spanish/English bilingual education programs, Vol. Ill: Year two impact designs. Palo Alto: American Institutes for Research.
18. Danoff, M. N., Coles, G. J., McLaughlin, D. H., & Reynolds, D. J. (1978b). Evaluation of the impact ofESEA Title VII Spanish/English bilingual education programs, Vol. IV: Overview of the study and findings. Palo Alto: American Institutes for Research.
19. Educational Operations Concepts, Inc. (1991b). An evaluation of the Title VII ESEA bilingual education program for Hmong and Cambodian students in kindergarten and first grade. St. Paul. Redundant with Educational Operations Concepts, Inc. 1991a.
20. El Paso Independent School District. (1990). Bilingual education evaluation: The sixth year in a longitudinal study. El Paso:Office for Research and Evaluation.
21. El Paso Independent School District. (1992). Bilingual educationevaluation. El Paso: Office for Research and Evaluation. Redundant with El Paso 1987.
22. Genesee, F., Lambert, W. E., & Tucker, G. E. (1977). An experiment in trilingual education. Montreal: McGill University. Redundant with Genesee et al 1983.
23. McConnell, B. B. (1980b). Individualized bilingual instruction, final evaluation, 1978-1979program. Pullman. Redundant with McConnell 1980a.
24. McConnell, B. B. (1980c). Individualized bilingual instruction formigrants. Paper presented at the October meeting of the International Congress for Individualized Instruction, Windsor.
25. McSpadden, J. R. (1980). Arcadia bilingual bicultural education program: Interim evaluation report, 1979-80. Lafayettee Parish. Redundant withMcSpadden 1979.
26. Teschner, R. V. (1990). Adequate motivation andbilingual education. Southwest Journal of Instruction, 9,1-42. Redundant with El Paso, 1990.
27. American Institutes for Research. (1975b). Bilingual education program (Aprendamos En Dos Idiomas). Corpus Christi. Palo Alto: Identification and Description ofExemplary Bilingual Education Programs.
28. Lambert, W. E., & Tucker, G. R. (1972). Bilingual education of children: The St. Lambert experience. Rowley, MA: Newbury House.
29. McSpadden, J. R. (1979). Arcadia bilingual bicultural education program: Interim evaluation report, 1978-79. Lafayettee Parish.
30. Morgan, J. C. (1971). The effects ofbilingual instruction of the English language arts achievement of first grade children. Doctoral dissertation, Northwestern State University of Louisiana.
31. Ramos, M., Aguilar, J. V., & Sibayan, B. F. (1967). The determination and implementation of language policy (Monograph Series 2). Quezon City: Philippine Center for Language Study.
32. Becker, W. C. & Gersten, R. (1982). A follow-up of follow through: The latter effects of the Direct Instruction Model on children in fifth and sixth grades. American Educational Research Journal, 19, 75-92.
33. Campeau, R L., Roberts, A., Oscar H., Bowers, J. E., Austin, M., & Roberts, S. J. (1975). The identification and description of exemplary bilingual education programs. Palo Alto: American Institutes for Research.
34. Webb, J. A., Clerc, R. J., & Gavito, A. (1987). Houston Independent School District: Comparison of bilingual and immersion programs using structural modeling. Houston Independent School District.
35. Barik, H., Swain, M. & Nwanunobi, E. A. (1977). English-French bilingual education: The Elgin Study through grade five. Canadian Modem Language Review, 33, 459-475.
36. Brack, M., Lambert, W. E., & Tucker, G. R. (1977). Cognitive consequences of bilingual schooling: The St. Lambert project through grade six. Linguistics, 24,13-33.
37. Burkheimer, G. J., Conger, A.J., Dunteman, G.H., Elliott, B.G., & Mowbray, K.A. (1989). Effectiveness of services for language-minority limited-English-proficient students. Report to the U.S. Department of Education.
38. Day, E. M., & Shapson, S. M. (1988). Provincial assessment of early and late French immersion programs in British Columbia, Canada. Paper presented at the April meetings of the American Educational Research Associates, New Orleans. No background controls or individual level data reported.
39. El Paso Independent School District. (1987). Interim report of thefive-year bilingual education pilot 1986-1987 school year. El Paso: Office for Research and Evaluation. No background or pretest controls.
40. Genesee, F., & Lambert, W. E. (1983). Trilingual education formajority-language children. Child Development, 54, 105-114. No background controls.
41. Genesee, F., Holobow, N. E., Lambert, W. E, & Chartrand, L. (1989). Three elementary school alternatives for learning through a second language. The Modem Language Journal, 73, 250-263. No background controls.
42. Gersten, R. (1985). Structured immersion for language-minority students: Results of a longitudinal evaluation. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 7, 187-196. No background controls.
43. Malherbe, E. C. (1946). The bilingual school. London: Longmans Green. No background or pretest controls.
44. McConnell, B. B. (1980a). Effectiveness of individualized bilingual instruction for migrant students. Doctoral dissertation, Washington State University.
45. Medina, M., & Escamilla, K. (1992). Evaluation of transitional and maintenance bilingual programs. Urban Education, 27,263-290.
46. Melendez, W. A.(1980). The effect ofthe language ofinstruction on the reading achievement of limited English speakers in secondary schools. Doctoral dissertation, Loyola University of Chicago. No background controls.
47. Stem, C. (1975). Final report to the Compton Unified School District s Title VII Bilingual/Bicultural Project: September 1969 through June 1975. Compton: Compton City Schools.
48. Vasquez, M. (1990). A longitudinal study of cohort academic success and bilingual education. Doctoral dissertation, University of Rochester. No background controls.
49. Barclay, L. (1969). The comparative efficacies of Spanish, English, and Bilingual Cognitive Verbal Instruction with Mexican American Head Start children. Doctoral dissertation, Stanford University. Positive Average Effect
50. Layden, R. G. (1972). The relationship between the language of instruction and the development of self-concept, classroom climate, and achievement of Spanish speaking Puerto Rican children. Doctoral dissertation, University of Maryland. Negative Average Effect.
51. Alvarez, J. (1975). Comparison of academic aspirations and achievement in bilingual versus monolingual classrooms. Doctoral dissertation, University of Texas at Austin. Negative Average Effect.
52. Ames, J., & Bicks, P. (1978). An evaluation of Title VII Bilingual/Bicultural Program, 1977-1978 school year, final report. Community School District 22. Brooklyn. School District of New York. Positive Average Effect.
53. Balasubramonian, K., Seelye, H., & Elizondo de Weffer, R. (1973). Do bilingual education programs inhibit English languageachievement: A report on an Illinois experiment. Paper presented at the 7th Annual Convention of Teachers of Englishto Speakers of Other Languages, San Juan. Positive Average Effect.
54. Barik, H, & Swain, M. (1975). Three year evaluation of a large-scale early grade French immersion program: The Ottawa-Study. Language Learning, 25,1-30. Negative Average Effect.
55. Bates, E. M. B. (1970). The effects of one experimental bilingualprogramon verbal ability and vocabulary of first grade pupils. Doctoraldissertation, Texas Tech University. Negative Average Effect.
56. JE'£E/47Ti/e VII Bilingual Program: Final report. Austin: Austin Independent School District. No statistical tests reported. Positive Average Effect.
57. Ciriza, F. (1990a). Evaluation report of the Preschool Projectfor Spanishspeaking children, 1989-1990. San Diego: Planning, Research and Evaluation Division. San Diego City Schools. Positive Average Effect.
58. Cohen, A. D. (1913). A sociolingustic approach to bilingual education. Rowley, MA: Newbury House Press. Negative Average Effect.
59. Cottrell, M. C. (1971). Bilingual education in San Juan Co., Utah: A cross-cultural emphasis. Paper presented at the April meetings of the American Educational Research Association, New York City. Negative Average Effect.
60. Curiel, H. (1979). A comparative study investigating achieved reading level, self-esteem, and achieved grade point average given varying participation. Doctoral dissertation, Texas A& M. Negative Average Effect.
61. de la Garza, J. V., & Marcella, M. (1985). Academic achievement asinfluencedby bilingual instruction for Spanish-dominant Mexican American children. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 7, 247-259. Positive Average Effect.
62. de Weffer, R. C. E. (1972). Effects of first language instruction in academic and psychological development of bilingual children. Doctoral dissertation, Illinois Institute of Technology. Positive Average Effect.
63. Educational Operations Concepts, Inc. (1991 a). St. Paul: An evaluation of the Title VII ESEA Bilingual Education Program for Hmong and Cambodian students in junior and senior high school. Positive Average Effect.
64. Lampman, H. P. (1973). SoutheastemNew Mexico bilingual program: Final report. Artesia: Artesia Public Schools. Positive Average Effect.
65. Legarreta, D. (1979). The effects ofprogram models on language acquisition by Spanish-speaking children. TESOL Quarterly, 75,521-534. Positive Average Effect.
66. Lum, J. B. (1971). An effectiveness study of English as a second language (ESL) and Chinese bilingual methods. Doctoral dissertation, University of California, Berkeley. Negative Average Effect.
67. Maldonado, J. R. (1974). The effect ofthe ESEA Title VIIProgram onthe cognitive development of Mexican American students. Doctoral dissertation, University of Houston. Negative Average Effect.
68. Matthews, T. (1979). An investigation ofthe effects ofbackground characteristics and special language services on the reading achievement and English fluency of bilingual students. Seattle: Seattle Public Schools: Department of Planning, Research and Evaluation. Negative Average Effect.
69. Moore, F. B. & Parr, G. D. (1978). Models ofbilingual education: Comparisons of effectiveness. The Elementary School Journal, 79, 93-97. Negative Average Effect.
70. Pena-Hughes, E., & Solis, J. (1991). ABCs. McAllen: McAllen Independent School, District. Positive Average Effect.
71. PrewittDiaz, J. O. (1979). An analysis ofthe effects of abicultural curriculum on monolingual Spanish ninth graders as compared with monolingual English and bilingual ninth graders with regard tolanguage development, attitude toward school, and self-concept. Doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut. Positive Average Effect.
72. Stebbins, L. B., St. Pierre, R. G., Proper, E. C., Anderson, R.B.,& Carva, T. (1977). Education as experimentation: A Planned Variation Model, Vol. IVA. An evaluation of follow through. Cambridge: ABT Associates. Positive Average Effect.
73. Valladolid, L. A. (1991). The effects ofbilingual education of students’ academic achievement as they progress through a bilingual program. Doctoral dissertation, United States International University. No background or pretest controls. Negative Average Effect.
74. Yap, K. O., Enoki, D. Y., & Ishitani, P. (1988). SLEPstudent achievement: Some pertinent variables and policy implications. Paper presented at the April meetings of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans. No background or pretest controls. Negative Average Effect.
75. Zirkel, P. A. (1972). An evaluation ofthe effectiveness of selected experimental bilingual education programs in Connecticut. Doctoral dissertation, University of Connecticut. Positive Average Effect.
76. Baker, K. A. & de Kanter, A. A. (1981). Effectiveness ofbilingual education: A review of the literature. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department ofEducation, Office of Planning, Budget and Evaluation.
77. Cambell, D. T. & Stanley, J. C. (1963). Experimental andquasi-experimental designs for research. Chicago: Rand McNally.
78. Campbell, D. T. & Erlebacher, A. E. (1970). How regression artifacts in quasiexperimental evaluations can mistakenly make compensatory education look harmful. In J. Hellmuth (Ed.) Compensatory education: A national debate Vol. 3. Disadvantaged child. New York: Brunner/Mazel.
79. Greene, J. (1998). A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of bilingual education. Tomas Rivera Policy Institute, Public Policy Clinic of the Department, University of Texas at Austin, and the Program on Education Policy and Government, University of Texas at Austin, and the Program on Education Policy and Governance at Harvard University. Available at http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/jwcrawford/greene.htm
80. Hanushek, E. A. (1996). School resources and student performance. In G. Burtless (Ed.), Does money matter (pp. 43-73). Washington, DC: Brookings.
81. Hedges, L. V. & Greenwald, R. (1996). Have times changed? In G. Gurtless (Ed.), Does money matter (pp. 74-92). Washington, DC: Brookings.
82. National Research Council. (1997). Improving schooling for language- minority children: A research agenda. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
83. Rosenthal, R. (1991). Meta-analytic procedures for social research. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.
84. Rossell C. H. & Baker K. (1996). The educational effectiveness of bilingual education. Research in the Teaching of English, 30.
85. Willig, A. (1985). A meta-analysis of selected studies on the effectiveness of bilingual education. Review of Educational Research, 55.