Applying the Seventeenth-Century Casuistry of Accommodation to HIV Prevention

Theological Studies

Volumn 60, Issue 3, 1999, Pages 492-512

  Keenan, James F ^a  

^a Weston Jesuit School of Theology   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84995478910     PISSN: 00405639     EISSN: 21691304     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/004056399906000305     Document Type: Review

References (83)

1. Albert Jonsen and Stephen Toulmin, The Abuse of Casuistry: A History of Moral Reasoning (Berkeley: University of California, 1988).
2. Louis Vereecke, "L'assurance maritime chez les théologiens des XVe et XVIe siècles," Studia Moralia 8 (1970) 347-85.
3. James Keenan, "The Casuistry of John Major, Nominalist Professor of Paris," in The Context of Casuistry, ed. James Keenan and Thomas Shannon (Washington: Georgetown University, 1995) 85-102.
4. Herbert Schlögel, "Tugend, Kasuistik, Biographie," Catholica 51 (1997) 187-200.
5. Keenan and Shannon, "Contexts of Casuistry: Historical and Contemporary," in The Context of Casuistry 221-31.
6. Edward Long, Conscience and Compromise: An Approach to Protestant Casuistry (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1954).
7. Johann P. Sommerville, "The 'New Art of Lying': Equivocation, Mental Reservation, and Casuistry," in Conscience and Casuistry in Early Modern Europe, ed. Edmund Leites (New York: Cambridge University, 1988) 159-84.
8. Stephen Toulmin, "Casuistry and Clinical Ethics," in A Matter of Principles?, ed. Edwin DuBose et al. (Valley Forge: Trinity Press International, 1994) 310-20.
9. Toulmin, "The Tyranny of Principles," The Hastings Center Report 13 (Dec. 1981) 31-39;
10. Josef Römelt, Vom Sinn moralischer Verantwortung: Zu den Grundlagen christlicher Ethik in komplexer Gesellschaft (Regensburg: Friedrich Pustet, 1996) 110-14.
11. Stuart Hampshire, Thought and Action (London: Chatto and Windus, 1959).
12. Stanley Hauerwas, "Casuistry as a Narrative Art," Interpretation 37 (1993) 377-88, at 381.
13. Thomas Kopfensteiner, "Science, Metaphor, and Moral Casuistry," in The Context of Casuistry 207-20.
14. Bruno Schüller, "Direct Killing/Indirect Killing," in Readings in Moral Theology 1: Moral Norms and the Catholic Tradition, ed. Charles Curran and Richard McCormick (New York: Paulist, 1979) 138-57;
15. James Keenan, "Taking Aim at the Principle of Double Effect," International Philosophical Quarterly 28 (1988) 201-6;
16. Richard McCormick, Notes on Moral Theology: 1965 through 1980 (Washington: University Press of America, 1981) 751-56;
17. Joseph Selling, "The Problem of Reinterpreting the Principle of Double Effect," Louvain Studies 8 (1980) 47-62.
18. Joseph Mangan, "An Historical Analysis of the Principle of Double Effect," Theological Studies 10 (1949) 41-61, at 54.
19. Josef Ghoos, "LActe à double effet, étude de théologie positive," Ephemerides theologicae lovanienses 27 (1951) 30-52.
20. Lucius Ugorji, The Principle of Double Effect (Frankfurt: Peter Lang, 1985).
21. T. Lincoln Bouscaren, Ethics of Ectopic Operations (Milwaukee: Bruce, 1944);
22. John Connery, Abortion: The Development of the Roman Catholic Perspective (Chicago: Loyola University, 1977);
23. John T. Noonan, Jr., "An Almost Absolute Value in History," in The Morality of Abortion, ed. John T. Noonan, Jr., (Cambridge: Harvard University, 1970) 1-59.
24. Charles Curran, The Origins of Moral Theology in the United States (Washington: Georgetown University, 1997) 128-66.
25. Pius XII, "Address to Delegates to the Ninth National Congress of the Italian Society of the Science of Anesthetics," Catholic Mind 55 (1957) 260-78.
26. Pius XII, "Allocution to Participants of the VII International Congress of Hematologists," Acta apostolicae sedis 91 (1958) 732-33;
27. Leandro Rossi, "Duplice effetto," in Dizionario enciclopedico di teologia morale, ed. Leandro Rossi and Ambrogio Valsecchi (Milan: Paoline, 1987) 293-308.
28. Gerald Kelly, "Notes in Moral Theology," TS 9 (1948) 89-98;
29. John T. Noonan, Jr., "The Development in Moral Doctrine," in The Context of Casuistry 188-203.
30. Kevin T. Kelly, New Directions in Sexual Ethics: Moral Theology and the Challenge of AIDS (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1998);
31. Richard Smith, AIDS, Gays, and the American Catholic Church (Cleveland: Pilgrim, 1994
32. Anthony M. Pilla, "Statement on Developing an Approach by the Church to AIDS Education," Origins 16 (March 12, 1987) 692-96.
33. Charles Bouchard and James Pollock, "Condoms and the Common Good," Second Opinion 12 (1989) 98-106.
34. David Hollenbach, "AIDS Education: The Moral Substance," America 157 (1987) 493-94.
35. Michael Place, "The Many Faces of AIDS," America 158 (February 13,1988) 135-41, 171, at 141.
36. James Keenan, "Prophylactics, Toleration and Cooperation: Contemporary Problems and Traditional Principles" International Philosophical Quarterly 28 (1988) 201-5.
37. Enda McDonagh, "Theology in a Time of AIDS," Irish Theological Quarterly 60 (1994) 81-99.
38. Hans Rotter, "AIDS: Some Theological and Pastoral Considerations," Theology Digest 39 (1992) 235-39.
39. Guido Davanzo, "Aspetti Morali," 114-30.
40. David Kelly, Criticai Care Ethics (Kansas City: Sheed and Ward, 1991) 204-9.
41. James Drane, "Condoms, AIDS and Catholic Ethics," Commonweal 189 (March 22, 1991) 188-92.
42. Béla Somfai, "AIDS, Condoms and the Church," Compass (November 1987) 44;
43. Dennis Regan, "Perspectives from Moral Theology," Dossiers and Documents The Pandemic of AIDS: A Response by the Confederation of Caritas International (February 1988) 58-67.
44. James Keenan, "Living with HIV/AIDS," The Tablet 249 (June 3, 1995) 701.
45. John Touhey, "Methodology or Ideology: The Condom and a Consistent Sexual Ethic," Louvain Studies 15 (1990) 53-69.
46. Josef Fuchs, "Epikie-Der praktizierte Vorbehalt," Stimmen der Zeit IIA (1996) 749-50.
47. Janet Smith, "The Many Faces of AIDS and the Toleration of the Lesser Evil," International Review of Natural Family Planning 12 (1988) 1-15.
48. Mark Johnson, "The Principle of Double Effect and Safe Sex in Marriage: Reflections on a Suggestion," Linacre Quarterly 60 (1993) 82-89.
49. Joseph Howard, "The Use of the Condom for Disease Prevention," Linacre Quarterly 63 (1996) 26-30.
50. Julie Hoffman, "Bennett and Carey Rap Condom Plan," National Catholic Register 68 (May 31, 1992) 1;
51. Russell Shaw, "Condom 'Cure' Questioned by Top AIDS Researcher," Our Sunday Visitor 82 (Jan. 23, 1994) 3;
52. Russell Shaw, "The Great Condom Con," Columbia 74 (June 1994) 5;
53. Jean-Marie Guenois, "Sex, Lies and Latex: Study Busts Condom Myth," Our Sunday Visitor 86 (Nov 2, 1997) 21.
54. Beverly Sottile-Malona, "Condoms and AIDS," America 165 (Nov 21, 1991) 317-19;
55. Jon Fuller, "AIDS Prevention: A Challenge to the Catholic Moral Tradition," America 175 (Dec 28, 1996) 13-20.
56. Reed Jolley, "The Condom War on Children, Christianity Today 38 (1994) 19;
57. Lynda Richardson, "Condoms in School Said Not to Affect Teen-age Sex Rate," New York Times, 30 September 1997, Al, 33.
58. Mireya Navarro, "Ethics of Giving AIDS Advice Troubles Catholic Hospitals," New York Times, 3 January 1993, 1, 24;
59. Joseph Doolin, "The Trouble with Needle-Exchange Programs," The Boston Pilot (May 8,1998) 8;
60. Jon Fuller, "Needle Exchange: Saving Lives," America 179 (July 18-25,1998) 8-11;
61. Peter Cataldo, "The Ethics of Needle-Exchange Programs for Intravenous Drug Users," in the newsletter of the Pope John XXIII Center, 1997.
62. Jacques Normand, Preventing HIV Transmission: The Role of Sterile Needles and Bleach, (Washington: National Academy, 1995).
63. Katharine Seelye, "A.M.A. Backs Drug-User Needle Exchanges," New York Times, 27 June 1997,15.
64. Lawrence Gostin, "Prevention of HIV/AIDS and Other Blood-Borne Diseases Among Injection Drug Users," Journal of the American Medical Association 277 (January 1, 1997) 53-62.
65. Warren Leary, "Panel Endorses Disputed Study of Hypodermic Needle Program," New York Times 15 December 1996, A 41.
66. Martin Frischer, "Direct Evaluation of Needle and Syringe Exchange Programmes," The Lancet 347 (Mar 16, 1996) 768.
67. Bronwen Lichtenstein, "Needle Exchange Programs: New Zealand's Experience," American Journal of Public Health 86 (Sept 1996) 1319.
68. Peter Lurie, "An Opportunity Lost: HIV Infections Associated with Lack of a National Needle-Exchange Programme in the USA," The Lancet 349 (Mar 1,1997) 604-8.
69. Jack Anderson, "How Healthy is Healthy Enough? Canon Law Considerations in Matters of Health and HIV-AIDS Testing Policies," Horizon (Winter 1993) 8-18;
70. R. R. Calvo, "Admission to the Seminary and HIV Testing," Roman Replies and CLS Advisory Opinions 1991 (Washington: Canon Law Society of America, 1991) 72-75;
71. Jon Fuller, "HIV/AIDS: An Overview," in Clergy and Religious and the AIDS Epidemic (Chicago: National Federation of Priests' Councils, 1994) 3-50, esp. 27-29;
72. R. Gibbons, "Admission to the Seminary and HIV Testing," Roman Replies 76-77;
73. James Keenan, "HIV Testing of Seminary and Religious-Order Candidates," Review for Religious 55 (1996) 297-314;
74. James Keenan, "The Return of Casuistry," TS 57 (1996) 123-29;
75. Bill Kenkelen, "Dilemma for Religious Orders: To Test or Not to Test for AIDS," National Catholic Reporter (September 2, 1988);
76. Jay O'Connor, "HIV Testing of Applicants," Clergy and Religious and the AIDS Epidemic 77-82;
77. James Schexnayder, "HIV/AIDS Policy Department," ibide. 83-86;
78. William Rushing, The AIDS Epidemic: Social Dimensions of an Infectious Disease (Boulder: Westview, 1995);
79. J. Michael McDermott, "Is AIDS God's Punishment?" Homiletic and Pastoral Review 91 (April 1991) 32, 50-58.
80. Craig Whitney, "French Bishop Supports Some Use of Condoms to Prevent AIDS," New York Times, 13 February 1996, 1;
81. Pamela Schaeffer, "Condoms Tolerated to Avoid AIDS, French Bishops Say," National Catholic Reporter (February 23, 1996) 9;
82. Robert Vitillo, "HIV/AIDS Prevention Education: A Special Concern for the Church," Presentation for Discussion at Caritas Internationalis; CAFOD Theological Consultation on HIV/AIDS, Pretoria, South Africa, April 14, 1998.
83. Roger Burggraeve, "Une éthique de miséricorde," Lumen Vitae 49 (1994) 281-96.