Performance track's postmortem: Lessons from the rise and fall of epa's "flagship" voluntary program

Harvard Environmental Law Review

Volumn 38, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 1-86

  Coglianese, Cary ^a   Nash, Jennifer ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA   (United States)

^b HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; PARTICIPATORY APPROACH; PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT; VOLUNTARY APPROACH;

UNITED STATES;

EID: 84994430484     PISSN: 01478257     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (119)

1. Cary Coglianese, Social Movements, Law, and Society: The Institutionalization of the Environmental Movement, 150 U. PA. L. REV. 85, 97-98 (2001).
2. Richard j. Lazarus, the making of environmental law (2004).
3. Environmental Policy: New Directions For The Twenty-First Century (Norman J. Vig & Michael E. Kraft eds., 6th ed. 2006).
4. David Shoenbrod Et Al., BREAKING THE LOGJAM: ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION THAT WILL WORK (2010).
5. Richard B. Stewart, A New Generation of Environmental Regulation?, 29 CAP. U. L. REV. 21 (2001).
6. Reality Check: The Nature And Performance Of Voluntary Environmental Programs In The United States, Europe, and Japan (Richard D. Morgenstern & William A. Pizer eds., 2007).
7. Daniel j. Fiorino, the new environmental regulation (2006);.
8. Industrial Transformation: Environmental Policy Innovation In The United States And Europe (Theo de Bruijn & Vicki Norberg-Bohm eds., 2005).
9. Cary Coglianese & Jennifer Nash, Government Clubs: Theory and Evidence from Voluntary Environmental Programs, in VOLUNTARY PROGRAMS: A CLUB THEORY PERSPECTIVE 304 n.10 (Matthew Potoski & Aseem Prakash eds., 2009).
10. EPA office of inspector gen., voluntary programs could benefit from internal policy controls and a systematic management approach: at a glance (2007), available at http://perma.cc/QD6E-XNSV.
11. http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0pMzeeTEQyq.
12. About Energy Star, Energystar. GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/05NBZwBjbqo.
13. EPA, FY 2008: Budget In Brief III (2007), available at http://perma.cc/TJY5-SMJS.
14. 5 EPA OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GEN., Voluntary Programs Could Benefit From Internal Policy Controls And A Systematic Management Approach 4 (2007), available at http://perma.cc/C7KA-VHRF.
15. EPA OFFICE OF POL'Y, Econ., & innovation, the United States experience with economic incentives for protecting the environment 174 (2001) [hereinafter ECONOMIC INCENTIVES], available at http://perma.cc/TM8G-TWHS.
16. Donald Elliott, Toward Ecological Law and Policy, In Thinking Ecologically: The Next Generation Of Environmental Policy 174 (Marian R. Chertow & Daniel C. Esty eds., 1997).
17. Madhu Khanna, Non-Mandatory Approaches to Environmental Protection, 15 J. ECON. SURVEYS 291 (2001).
18. Andrew Jordan, Rüdiger K.W. Wurzel & Anthony R. Zito, "New" Instruments of Environmental Governance: Patterns and Pathways of Change, in "NEW" INSTRUMENTS OF ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE? NATIONAL EXPERIENCES AND PROSPECTS 3 (Andrew Jordan, Rudiger K.W. Wurzel & Anthony R. Zito eds., 2003).
19. Thomas P. Lyon, Environmental Governance: An Economic Perspective, in GOVERNANCE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT: NEW PERSPECTIVES 56 (Magali A. Delmas & Oran R. Young eds., 2009).
20. Charles C. Caldart, Government Regulation, In Occupational and Environmental Health 39, 70 (Barry S. Levy & David H. Wegman eds., 2005).
21. Jennifer Nash & Cary Coglianese, EPA's Performance Track: Origins, Objectives, and Operating Practices, In Beyond Compliance: Business Decision Making And The Epa's Performance Track Program 25 (Cary Coglianese & Jennifer Nash eds., 2006) [hereinafter BEYOND COMPLIANCE], available at http://perma.cc/LSQ3-E7VE.
22. National Environmental Performance Track: History, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0MTfTeb3CBJ.
23. National Environmental Performance Track: Recognition, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/QQ2SDLTH.
24. National Environmental Performance Track: Low Priority for Routine Inspections, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/5UEY-EGE9.
25. Three EPA Programs Nominated for Government Oscars, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0QvxM5zZwN4.
26. Aseem Prakash & Matthew Potoski, The Voluntary Environment ALISTS: GREEN CLUBS, ISO 14001, AND Voluntary Regulations 56, 63-64 (2006).
27. Jonathan C. Borck, Cary Coglianese & Jennifer Nash, Environmental Leadership Programs: Toward an Empirical Assessment of Their Performance, 35 ECOLOGY L.Q. 771-776 (2008).
28. Debra Kahn, EPA: Two House Dems Question Performance Track Spending, Results, E&E NEWS PM, Apr. 17, 2007.
29. Anthony Lacey, EPA Performance Track Spending Renews Criticism of Ad Campaign, INSIDE EPA WKLY. REP., Oct. 19, 2007.
30. Anthony Lacey, Democrats May Ignore Bush's Request for Steep Cuts to EPA FY09 Budget, INSIDE EPA WKLY. REP., Feb. 8, 2008.
31. Performance Track Could Improve Program Design and Management To Ensure Value 4, 15 (2007).
32. http://perma.cc/ML8M-4WGD.
33. Sonja Ryst, U.S. Agencies Try to Restore Faith in Energy Star Appliance Testing, WASH. POST (Jul. 10, 2010), http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0zmKHrHt3sH;ListofPrograms, .
34. EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0Yv3RtG7hzV (listing some of EPA's voluntary programs).
35. Better Plants, U.S. DEP'T OF ENERGY, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0nbyAWCxrrv.
36. ISO 50001 Energy Management Standard, U.S. DEP'T OF ENERGY, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0Wd1rF22ySH.
37. Creating a Sustainable World, STEWARDSHIP ACTION COUNCIL, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0mad4ShN8yb/.
38. Lisa C. Lund, Project XL: Good for the Environment, Good for Business, Good for Communities, ELR NEWS & ANALYSIS, 10, 140 (2000).
39. Project XL, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0TUFVYM33xJ/.
40. Seema Arora & Timothy N. Cason, An Experiment in Voluntary Environmental Regulation: Participation in EPA's 33/50 Program, 28 J. ENVTL. ECON. & MGMT. 271 (1995).
41. Seema Arora & Timothy N. Cason, Why Do Firms Volunteer to Exceed Environmental Regulations? Understanding Participation in EPA's 33/50 Program, 72 LAND ECON. 413 (1996).
42. Terry Davies & Jan Mazurek, industry incentives for environmental improvement: evaluation of U.S. Federal INITIATIVES (1996).
43. Shanti Gamper-Rabindran, Did the EPA's Voluntary Industrial Toxics Program Reduce Emissions? A GIS Analysis of Distributional Impacts and By-Media Analysis of Substitution, 52 J. ENVTL. ECON. & MGMT. 391 (2006).
44. Madhu Khanna & Lisa A. Damon, EPA's Voluntary 33/50 Program: Impact on Toxic Releases and Economic Performance of Firms, 37 J. ENVTL. ECON. & MGMT. 1 (1999).
45. Abdoul G. Sam & Robert Innes, Voluntary Pollution Reductions and the Enforcement of Environmental Law: An Empirical Study of the 33/50 Program (Univ. of Ariz., Dep't of Agric. & Res. Econ. Working Paper, 2004), available at http://perma.cc/U4HR-KSEZ.
46. JAMES BOYD ET AL., Intel's Xl Permit: A Framework For Evaluation, Discussion Paper 98-11 (1998), available at http://perma.cc/39ZC-PMPT.
47. Thomas E. Caballero, Project XL: Making It Legal, Making It Work, 17 STAN. ENVTL. L.J. 399 (1998).
48. Dennis D. Hirsch, Bill and Al's XL-ent Adventure: An Analysis of the EPA's Legal Authority to Implement the Clinton Administration's Project XL, 1998 U. ILL. L. REV. 129 (1998).
49. George B. Wyeth, "Standard" and "Alternative" Environmental Protection: The Changing Role of Environmental Agencies, 31 WM. & MARY ENVTL. L. & POL'Y REV. 5-41 (2006).
50. Thinking Ecologically: The Next Generation Of Environmental Policy (Marian R. Chertow & Daniel C. Esty eds., 1997).
51. Environmental Governance: A Report on The Next Generation Of Environmental Policy (Donald F. Kettl ed., 2002).
52. Neil Gunningham & Darren Sinclair, Leaders And Laggards: Next-Generation Environmental Regulation (2002).
53. Neil Gunningham Et AL., SHADES OF GREEN: BUSINESS, REGULATION, AND ENVIRONMENT (2003).
54. GALE BOYD & GANG ZHANG, MEASURING IMPROVEMENT IN THE ENERGY PERFORMANCE OF THE U.S. CEMENT INDUSTRy (May 2011), available at http://perma.cc/AMB5-XGSV.
55. ALIANNUZZI JR., INDUSTRY SELF-REGULATION AND VOLUNTARY ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE 68 (2002).
56. VPP Participants' Association, VOLUNTARY PROT PROGRAMS PARTICIPANTS' ASS'N, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0PpCdmttGpz/.
57. Ira R. Feldman & Michael C. Schiavo, Developing New Environmental Excellence Programs: Lessons from EPA's Environmental Leadership Program, 5 Total Quality Envtl. Mgmt. 15-16 (1995).
58. Cary Coglianese & Jennifer Nash, Environmental Management Systems and the New Policy Agenda, in Regulating From The Inside: Can Environmental Management Systems Achieve Policy Goals? 1 (Cary Coglianese & Jennifer Nash eds., 2001).
59. E. Donald Elliott, Environmental TQM: Anatomy of a Pollution Control Program that Works!, 92 MICH. L. REV. 1840 (1994).
60. Robert C. Anderson & Alan Carlin, The United States Experience With Economic Incentives In Environmental Pollution Control 10.5 (1997).
61. Daniel J. Fiorino, Toward a New System of Environmental Regulation: The Case for an Industry Sector Approach, 26 ENVTL. L. 457- 475 (1996).
62. Christopher Mcgrory Klyza & David j. Sousa, American environmental policy, 1990-2006: beyond gridlock 223-28 (2008).
63. Jodi Perras, Reinventing Epa New England: An Epa Regional Office Tests Innovative Approaches To Environmental Protection 34 (2000). 99.
64. Gregory J. Hale & Caroline G. Hemenway, Boon or Bane? ISO 14001 Likely to Join Regulatory Framework, QUALITY DIG., http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0mxi3M8eBQj/.
65. Rhea Hale, The National Expansion Of Star track: Issues Regarding The Delegation Of Environmental Compliance Oversight 21 (1998).
66. John Macarthur & Gordon Bellen, ISO 14001 in State Regulatory Offices: A Survey of Activities, ENVTL. QUALITY & MGMT., Summer 1998, at 19-22.
67. leading change: performance track fourth annual progress report 24 (2006) [hereinafter leading change] (on file with the harvard law school library); 2003-2008.
68. Daniel J. Fiorino, Environmental Performance and Green Clubs: A New Tool for Governance? 4 (June 29, 2007).
69. National Environmental Performance Track: Recognition, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/3C8LC2WT.
70. National Environmental Performance Track: Performance Track Endorser Network, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/6FY-CE4Y.
71. EPA, National Environmental Performance Track Brochure 4 (on file with the Harvard Law School Library).
72. National Environmental Performance Track: Hall of Fame, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/G2VFHWA8 (listing five awards for 2006).
73. National Environmental Performance Track: Green Investment Firms Recognize Performance Track, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/C2SY-B7NQ.
74. National Environmental Performance Track: Networking, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/W425-UYGS.
75. National Environmental Performance Track: Regulatory and Administrative Benefits, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/Q5XG-JCEJ.
76. National Environmental Performance Track: Water Benefits, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/LS6FD3L8.
77. National Environmental Performance Track: Benefits, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/C6BE-M9LE.
78. National Environmental Performance Track: Air Benefits, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/Q3GL-AKQC.
79. National Environmental Performance Track: State Programs, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0ZktNsZwv3d.
80. National Environmental Performance Track: State By State Summary of Available Performance Track Incentives, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0HsmVnASnnr.
81. National Environmental Performance Track: Performance Track/State Memoranda of Agreement (MOAs), EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0DVbD6WEB13.
82. National Environmental Performance Track: Performance Track Corporate Leaders, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0XDBiuWSQWt.
83. Home, National Environmental Partnership Summit 2006, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/07zygkd3LBM.
84. Stewardship Action Council, Stewardshipactioncouncil.Org, http://perma.law.harvard.edu.
85. Robin Bravender, EPA's Voluntary Programs Under Scrutiny as Regulatory Obligations Rise, N.Y. TIMES (Feb. 5, 2010), http://perma.cc/QUQ6-54ZD.
86. Climate Leadership Awards, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0PPAtGw5x8J.
87. Cary Coglianese, Empirical Analysis and Administrative Law, 2002 UNIV. ILL. L. REV. 1111-1114 (2002).
88. NVTL. Integrity project, wrong track? Some Performance Track Facilities Report Increased Levels Of Toxic Pollution 1 (2006) (emphasis in original), available at http://perma.cc/J3T6-PBF6.
89. EPA Rewards Top Green Performers, GREENBIZ (Jul. 2, 2000), http://perma.cc/WU8H-VVK8.
90. NBC Nightly News: Feds Giving Suspect Green Rewards (NBC television broadcast Apr. 20, 2008), available at http://perma.cc/L6VR-AEJT.
91. Celeste Monforton, No Shortage of Ideas from OSHA Staff to Improve Oversight of Agency's Voluntary Protection Program, PUMP HANDLE (Aug. 22, 2012), http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0T2ivZgZBpk (noting that "serious questions have been raised about the integrity of the program and whether all VPP sites genuinely deserve a 'model workplace' designation.").
92. National Environmental Performance Track: Members by Sector, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/U98S-7MRR.
93. National Environmental Performance Track: Members by EPA Region, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/LBC5-ZLJT.
94. National Environmental Performance Track: Members by State, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/BVZ8-W35Q.
95. National Environmental Performance Track: Implementation, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/YD6X-96CS.
96. National Environmental Performance Track: Sustained Compliance, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/XY85-2YZM.
97. Jenna Johnson, Colleges Announce 2013 Acceptance Rates, WASH. POST, April 1, 2013, http://perma.cc/P63G-4DZU.
98. Lori S. Bennear & Cary Coglianese, Measuring Progress: Program Evaluation of Environmental Policies, 47 ENV'T 22- 33 (2005).
99. Risk Screening Environmental Indicators, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/09JP1Do8Agw.
100. Jennifer Howard-Grenville, Jennifer Nash & Cary Coglianese, Constructing the License to Operate: Internal Factors and Their Influence on Corporate Environmental Decisions, 30 LAW & POL'Y. 73 (2008).
101. Jonathan Borck & Cary Coglianese, Beyond Compliance: Explaining Business Participation in Voluntary Environmental Programs, in EXPLAINING COMPLIANCE: BUSINESS RESPONSES TO REGULATION 139 (Christine Parker & Vibeke Lehmann Nielsen eds., 2011).
102. Stuart Shapiro, Speed Bumps and Roadblocks: Procedural Controls and Regulatory Change, 1 J. PUB. ADMIN. RES. & THEORY 29-35 (2002).
103. Haitao Yin & Peter J. Schmeidler, Does ISO 14001 Certification Enhance Environmental Performance? - Conditions Under Which Environmental Performance Improvement Occurs 6-9 (Wharton Risk Ctr. Working Paper 07-07, Sept. 2007).
104. Mark Snyder, Self-Monitoring of Expressive Behavior, 30 J. PERSONALITY & SOC. PSYCHOL. 526, 526 (1974).
105. David W. Case, The EPA's HPV Challenge Program: A Tort Liability Trap?, 62 WASH. & LEE L. REV. 147-198 (2005).
106. Eric W. Orts, Reflexive Environmental Law, 89 NW. U. L. REV. 1227-1286 (1995).
107. Enforcement & Compliance History Online (ECHO), EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0g6AUdPUjs5.
108. Environmental Management Systems, EPA.GOV, http://perma.cc/3FTL-5RKZ.
109. List of Partnership Programs, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0Ns1sBATeuU.
110. Join Sunwise, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0URE4GVKtnN.
111. Benefits to Sustainable Futures Graduates, EPA.GOV, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/0PMesxp.
112. North Carolina Environmental Stewardship Initiative, Environmental Stewardship Annual Report 16-17 (2012), available at http://perma.cc/S3AV-94EP.
113. Extraordinary Environmental Enterprise (E4) Members, VA. DEP'T OF ENVTL. QUALITY, http://perma.law.harvard.edu/03iXk74aGZG?type=image.
114. Green Tier Charters, Tiers, and Applicants, WIS. DEP'T OF NATURAL REShttp://perma.law.harvard.edu/032FaY7BATA?type=image.
115. Performance Track Application Instructions 2 (2002) (on file with the Harvard Law School Library).
116. Daniel A. Farber, Taking Slippage Seriously: Noncompliance and Creative Compliance in Environmental Law, 23 HARV. ENVTL. L. REV. 297-305 (1999).
117. Mary E. Deily & Wayne B. Gray, Agency Structure and Firm Culture: OSHA, EPA, and the Steel Industry, 23 J.L. ECON. & ORG. 68-706 (2007).
118. Cary Coglianese, Richard Zeckhauser & Edward Parson, Seeking Truth for Power: Informational Strategy and Regulatory Policymaking, 89 MINN. L. REV. 277-310 (2004).
119. Michael Greenstone, Toward a Culture of Persistent Regulatory Experimentation and Evaluation, in NEW PERSPECTIVES ON REGULATION 111-12 (David Moss & John Cisternino eds., 2009).