Limitations in actuarial risk assessment of sexual offenders: A methodological note

The British Journal of Forensic Practice

Volumn 6, Issue 1, 2004, Pages 16-32

  Craig, Leam ^a   Browne, Kevin ^a   Stringer, Ian ^a   Beech, Anthony ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84993083663     PISSN: 14636646     EISSN: 20428340     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1108/14636646200400003     Document Type: Review

References (118)

1. Alaska Department of Corrections (1996) Sex Offender Treatment Programs: Initial recidivism study. Alaska Justice Statistical Analysis Unit Justice Centre, University of Alaska-Anchorage.
2. Alexander MA (1999) Sexual offender treatment efficacy revisited. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 11 (2) 101-116.
3. Allam J (1999) Effective Practice in Work with Sex Offenders: A re-conviction study comparing treated and untreated offenders. West Midlands Probation Service, Sex Offender Unit.
4. Aos S., Phipps P Barnoski R & Lieb R (2001) The Comparative Costs and Benefits to Reduce Crime. Washington State Institute for Public Policy. Document Number: 01-05-1201 http://www.wa.gov/wsipp.
5. Aytes KE, Olsen SS, Takrajsek T., Murray P & Ireson R (2001) Cognitive behavioural treatment for sexual offenders: an examination of recidivism. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 13 (4) 223-231.
6. Bagley C & Pritchard C (2000) Criminality and violence in intra- and extra-familial child abusers in a 2-year cohort of convicted perpetrators. Child Abuse Review 9 264-274.
7. Barbaree HE (1997) Evaluating treatment efficacy with sexual offenders: the insensitivity of recidivism studies to treatment effects. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 9 111-128.
8. Barbaree HE & Marshall WL (1990) Outcome of comprehensive cognitive-behavioural treatment programs. In: WL Marshall, DR Laws & HE Barbaree (Eds) Handbook of Sexual Assault: Issues, Theories and Treatment of the Offender. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
9. Barbaree HE, Seto MC, Langton CM & Peacock EJ (2001) Evaluating the predictive accuracy of six risk assessment instruments for adult sex offenders. Criminal Justice and Behavior 28 (4) 490-521.
10. Beech A., Erikson M., Friendship C & Ditchfield J (2001) A Six-Year Follow-up of Men going through Representative Probation-Based Sex Offender Treatment Programmes. London: Home Office Publications Unit 114, 1-4.
11. Beech A., Friendship C., Erikson M & Hanson RK (2002) The relationship between static and dynamic risk factors and reconviction in a sample of UK child abusers. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 14 (2) 155-167.
12. Boer DP, Wilson RJ, Gauthier CM & Hart SD (1997) Manual for the Sexual Violence Risk-20. Vancouver, B.C.: The Mental Health, Law and Policy Institute and the Simon Fraser University.
13. Bonta J & Hanson RK (1995) Violent recidivism of men released from prison. Paper presented at the 103rd annual convention of the American Psychological Association: New York.
14. Bonta J., Law M & Hanson K (1996) The Prediction of Criminal and Violent Recidivism among Mentally Disordered Offenders: A meta-analysis. Ottawa, ONT: Solicitor General Canada.
15. Borduin CM, Schaeffer CM & Heiblum N (2000) Multisystemic treatment of aggressive and non-aggressive sexual offending adolescents: instrumental and ultimate outcomes. Manuscript submitted for publication.
16. Borum R (1996) Improving the clinical practice of violence risk assessment: technology, guidelines and training. American Psychologist 51 945-956.
17. Broadhurst RG & Maller RA (1992) The recidivism of sex offenders in the Western Australian prison population. British Journal of Criminology 32 (1) 54-77.
18. Browne KD, Foreman L & Middleton D (1998) Predicting treatment dropout in sex offenders. Child Abuse Review 7 402-419.
19. Cann J., Falshaw L & Friendship C (2003) Sexual offenders discharged from prison in England and Wales: a 21-year reconviction study. Paper presented at the 12th Annual Conference of the Division of Forensic Psychology, 26th-28th March 2003. Churchill College Cambridge.
20. Cohen LJ (1981) Can human irrationality be experimentally demonstrated? Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 317-331.
21. Cohn J (1969) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioural Sciences. New York: Academic Press.
22. Corbett C., Patel V., Erickson M & Friendship C (2003) The violent reconvictions of sexual offenders. Journal of Sexual Aggression 9 (1) 31-39.
23. Craig LA, Browne KD & Stringer I (2003a) Risk scales and factors predictive of sexual offence recidivism. Trauma, Violence and Abuse: A Review Journal 4 (1) 45-67.
24. Craig LA, Browne KD & Stringer I (2003b) Treatment and sexual offence recidivism. Trauma, Violence and Abuse: A Review Journal 4 (1) 70-89.
25. Craig LA, Browne KD & Stringer I (2004) Comparing sex offender risk assessment measures on a UK sample. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 48 (1) 7–27.
26. Craig LA, Browne KD & Stringer I & Beech A (in press) Sexual recidivism: a review of static, dynamic and actuarial predictors. Journal of Sexual Aggression.
27. Craig LA, Browne KD, Beech A & Stringer I (2003c) Evaluating the predictive accuracy of sex offender risk assessment measures. Manuscript in preparation.
28. Craig LA, Stringer I., Ostapiuk EB, Hobson J & Royle A (1999) A role for the forensic psychologist within the probation service. Probation Journal 46 (2) 116-119.
29. Craissati J (2003) Adjusting standard assessment and treatment models to meet the needs of sex offenders in the community. Paper presented at the 12th Annual Conference of the Division of Forensic Psychology, 26th-28th March 2003. Churchill College Cambridge.
30. Dempster R & Hart SD (2002) The relative utility of fixed and variables risk factors in discriminating sexual recidivists and nonrecidivists. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 14 (2) 121-138.
31. Dolan M & Doyle M (2000) Violence risk prediction -clinical and actuarial measures and the role of the Psychopathy Checklist. British Journal of Psychiatry 177 303-311.
32. Doren D (2001) The relative value of the RRASOR and Static-99 in assessing sexual recidivism risk within the context of U. S. A. Sex Offender Civil Commitment Statutes. Unpublished manuscript. (Available from author).
33. Doren DM (2002) Evaluating Sex Offenders: A Manual for Civil Commitments and Beyond. California: Sage Publications.
34. Doren DM & Epperson DL (2001) Great analysis, but problematic assumptions: a critique of Janus and Meehl (1997). Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 13 (1) 45-51.
35. Doren D & Roberts CF (1998) The proper use and interpretation of actuarial instruments in assessing recidivism risk. Paper presented at the 17th Annual Research and Treatment Conference of the Association for Treatment of Sexual Abusers, Vancouver, British Columbia.
36. Epperson DL, Kaul JD & Hesselton D (1998) Final report on the development of the Minnesota Sex Offender Screening Tool-Revised (MnSOST-R). Paper presented at the 17th Annual Conference of the Association for the Treatment of Sexual Abusers, Vancouver, Canada.
37. Epperson DL, Kaul JD, Hout SJ et al (2000) Cross-validation of the Minnesota Sex Offender Screening Tool-Revised (MnSOST-R). Paper presented at the 19th Annual Conference of the Association for the Treatment of Sexual Abusers, San Diego, California.
38. Erickson M & Friendship C (2002) A typology of child abduction events. Legal and Criminological Psychology 7 115-120.
39. Falshaw L (2002) Assessing reconviction, re-offending and recidivism in a sample of UK sexual offenders. Paper presented at the Eleventh Annual Conference of the Division of Forensic Psychology, Manchester, April.
40. Falshaw L., Friendship C & Bates A (2003) Sexual Offenders: Measuring Reconviction, Reoffending and Recidivism. Research Development and Statistics Directorate: Findings Report 183. Home Office: available from the Research Development and Statistics Directorate, Communication Development Unit, Room 275, Home Office, 50 Queen Anne's Gate, London, SW1H 9AT. Available electronically from: http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs2/r183.pdf
41. Finkelhor D (1984) Child Sexual Abuse: New Theory and Research. New York: Free Press.
42. Fisher D., Beech A & Browne K (2000) The effectiveness of relapse prevention training in a group of incarcerated child molesters. Psychology, Crime & Law00 1-5.
43. Friendship C & Corbett C (2003, March) The violent reconvictions of sexual offenders. Paper presented at the 12th Annual Conference of the Division of Forensic Psychology, 26th-28th March 2003. Churchill College Cambridge.
44. Friendship C & Thornton D (2001) Sexual reconviction for sexual offenders discharged from prison in England and Wales. British Journal of Criminology 41 (2) 285-292.
45. Gallagher CA, Wilson DB, Hirschfield P., Coggeshall MB & MacKenzie DL (1999) A quantitative review of the effects of sex offender treatment on sexual reoffending. Corrections Management Quarterly 3 (4) 19-29.
46. Gordon A & Nicholaichuk T (1996) Applying the risk principle to the treatment of sexual offender. Forum on Corrections Research 8 (2) 36-38.
47. Grubin D (1997) Interring predictors of risk. Sex offenders. International Review of Psychiatry 9 (2-3) 225-231.
48. Grubin D (1998) Sex offending against children: understanding the risk. Home Office Research Development and Statistics Directorate Research Findings, Police Research Series, Paper 99.
49. Grubin D (1999) Actuarial and clinical assessment of risk in sex offenders. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 14 (3) 331-343.
50. Hagen MA (1997) Whores of the Court: The fraud of psychiatric testimony and the rape of American justice. New York: Regan/Harper Collins.
51. Hagan MP & Gust-Brey KL (1999) A ten-year longitudinal study of adolescent rapists upon return to the community. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 43 (4) 448-458.
52. Hall GCN (1995) Sexual offender recidivism revisited: a meta-analysis of recent treatment studies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 63 802-809.
53. Hall GCN & Hirschman R (1991) Towards a theory of sexual aggression: a quadripartite model. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 55 111-112.
54. Hanson RK (1997) The Development of a Brief Actuarial Risk Scale for Sexual Offence Recidivism. (User Report No. 1997-04). Ottawa: Department of the Solicitor General of Canada. http://www.sgc.gc.ca/epub/corr/e199704/e199704.htm
55. Hanson RK (2001) Age and Sexual Recidivism: A comparison of rapists and child molesters. (Cat No.: JS42-96/2001). Department of the Solicitor General of Canada. http://www.sgc.gc.ca/EPub/Corr/eAge200101/eAge200101.htm
56. Hanson RK (2003) Stable and acute risk factors in community supervision. Paper presented at the 13th Annual National Organisation for the Treatment of Abusers Conference, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, 24th-26th September.
57. Hanson RK & Bussiere MT (1996) Predictors of Sexual Offender Recidivism: A Meta-Analysis. (User Report No. 1996-04). Ottawa: Department of the Solicitor General of Canada. http://www.sgc.gc.ca/epub/corr/e199604/e199604.htm
58. Hanson RK & Bussiere MT (1998) Predicting relapse: a meta-analysis of sexual offender recidivism studies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 66 (2) 348-362.
59. Hanson RK, Gordon A., Harris AJR et al (2002) First report of the collaborative outcome data project on the effectiveness of psychological treatment for sex offenders. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 14 (2) 169-194.
60. Hanson RK & Harris A (1998) Dynamic Predictors of Sexual Recidivism. Corrections Research Ottawa: Department of the Solicitor General Canada. www.sgc.gc.ca/epub/corr/e199801b/e199801b.htm
61. Hanson RK & Harris A (2000) Where should we intervene? Dynamic predictors of sexual offense recidivism. Criminal Justice and Behavior 27 (1) 6-35.
62. Hanson RK, Scott H & Steffy RA (1995) A comparison of child molesters and non-sexual criminals: risk predictors and long-term recidivism. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 32 (3) 325-337.
63. Hanson RK, Steffy RA & Gauthier R (1993) Long-term recidivism of child molesters. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 61 646-652.
64. Hanson RK & Thornton D (2000) Improving risk assessment for sex offenders: a comparison of three actuarial scales. Law and Human Behavior 24 (1) 119-136.
65. Hare R (1991) Manual for the Revised Psychopathy Checklist. Toronto, Ontario: MultiHealth Systems.
66. Hart SD, Webster CD & Menzies RL (1993) A note on portraying the accuracy of violence predictions. Law and Human Behavior 17 695-700.
67. Hood R., Shute S., Feilzer M & Wilcox A (2002) Sex offenders emerging from long-term imprisonment - a study of their long-term reconviction rates and of parole board members' judgements of their risk. British Journal of Criminology 42 (2) 371-394.
68. Hudson SM, Wales DS, Bakker L & Ward T (2002) Dynamic risk factors: the Kia Marama evaluation. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 14 (2) 103-119.
69. Huot S (1997) Community based sex offender program evaluation project. Minnesota Department of Corrections: 1997 Report to the Legislature, St. Paul.
70. Janus EA & Meehl PE (1997) Assessing the legal standard for predictions of dangerousness in sex offender commitment proceedings. Psychology, Public Policy and Law 3 33-64.
71. Koehler JJ (1996) The base rate fallacy reconsidered. Descriptive, normative, and methodological challenges. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19 1-17.
72. Langstrom N & Grann M (2000) Risk for criminal recidivism among young sex offenders. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 15 (8) 855-871.
73. Lees S (1996) Carnal Knowledge: Rape on Trial. London: Hamish Hamilton.
74. Leventhal JM (1988) Can child maltreatment be predicted during the peri-natal period: evidence of longitudinal cohort studies. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology 6 (3) 139-161.
75. Litwack TR (2001) Actuarial versus clinical assessments of dangerousness. Psychology, Public Policy and Law 7 (2) 409-443.
76. Looman J., Abracen J & Nicholiachuk TP (2000) Recidivism among treated sexual offenders and matched controls – data from the regional treatment centre (Ontario). Journal of Interpersonal Violence 15 (3) 279-290.
77. Marques JK (1982) Relapse prevention: a self-control model for the treatment of sex offenders. Paper presented at the 7th Annual Forensic Mental Health Conference, Asilomar, CA, USA.
78. Marques JK (1999) How to answer the question: does sex offender treatment work? Journal of Interpersonal Violence 14 (4) 437-451.
79. Marshall P (1994) Reconviction of imprisoned sexual offenders. Home Office Research Bulletin 36 23-29.
80. Marshall WL & Barbaree HE (1990) An integrated theory of the etiology of sexual offending. In: WL Marshall, DR Laws & HE Barbaree (Eds) Handbook of Sexual Assault: Issues, theories, and treatment of the offender. New York: Plenum.
81. McGrath J., Hoke SE & Vojtisek JE (1998) Cognitive-behavioural treatment of sex offenders. Criminal Justice and Behaviour 25 203-225.
82. McGuire TJ (2000) Correctional institution-based sex offender treatment: a lapse behaviour study. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 18 57-71.
83. McNeil DE, Sandberg DA & Binder RL (1998) The relationship between confidence and accuracy in clinical assessment of psychiatric patients' potential for violence. Law and Human Behavior 22 655-669.
84. Meehl PE & Rosen A (1955) Antecedent probability and the efficiency of psychometric signs, patterns or cutting scores. Psychological Bulletin 52 194-216.
85. Minnesota Department of Corrections (2000) Community Based Sex Offender Program Evaluation Project: 1999 Report to the Legislature.
86. Monahan J (1996) Violence prediction: the past twenty and the next twenty years. Criminal Justice and Behaviour 23 (1) 107-120.
87. Mulvey EP & Lidz CW (1998) Clinical prediction of violence as a conditional judgement. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 33 S107-S113.
88. Nicholaichuk T Gordon A., Andre G & Gu D (1995) Long-term outcome of the Clearwater Sex Offender Treatment program. Paper presented to the 14th Annual Conference of the Association for the Treatment of Sexual Abusers, New Orleans, LA.
89. Nicholaichuk T., Gordon A., Andre G., Gu D & Wong S (2000) Outcome of an institutional sexual offender treatment program: a comparison between treated and untreated offenders. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 12 (2) 139-153.
90. Pithers WD (1990) Relapse prevention with sexual aggressors: a method for maintaining therapeutic change and enhancing external supervision. In: WL Marshall, DR Laws & HE Barbaree (Eds) The Handbook of Sexual Assault: Issues, theories and treatment of the offender. New York: Plenum.
91. Pithers WD, Kashima KM, Cumming GF & Beal LS (1988) Relapse prevention: a method of enhancing maintenance of change in sex offenders. In: AC Salter (Ed) Treating Child Sex Offenders and Victims: A practical guide. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
92. Polizzi DM, MacKenzie DL & Hickman LJ (1999) What works in adult sex offender treatment? A review of prison and non-prison based treatment programs. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 43 (3) 357-374.
93. Prentky RA & Burgess AW (2000) Forensic Management of Sexual Offenders: Perspectives in sexuality, behavior, research and therapy. New York. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
94. Prentky RA, Lee AFS, Knight RA & Cerce O (1997) Recidivism rates among child molesters and rapists: a methodological analysis. Law and Human Behaviour 21 (6) 635-659.
95. Proulx J., Pellerin B., McKibben A., Aubut J & Ouimet M (1997) Static and dynamic risk predictors of recidivism in sexual offenders. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 9 7-27.
96. Proulx J., Pellerin B., McKibben A., Aubut J & Ouimet M (1999) Recidivism in sexual aggressors: static and dynamic predictors of recidivism in sexual aggressors. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 11.
97. Quackenbush R (2000) The assessment of sex offenders in Ireland and the Irish sex offender risk tool. Unpublished manuscript, Granada Institute, Dublin, Ireland.
98. Quinsey VL, Harris GT, Rice ME & Cormier CA (1998a) Violent Offenders: Appraising and Managing Risk. Washington DC. American Psychological Association.
99. Quinsey VL, Khanna A & Malcolm B (1998b) A retrospective evaluation of the Regional Treatment Centre Sex Offender Treatment Programme. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 13 21-644.
100. Quinsey VL, Rice ME & Harris GT (1995) Actuarial prediction of sexual recidivism. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 10 (1) 85-105.
101. Rice ME & Harris GT (1997) Cross-validation and extension of the Violence Risk Appraisal Guide for Child Molesters and Rapists. Law and Human Behaviour 21 (2) 231-241.
102. Rice ME, Harris GT & Quinsey VL (1990) A follow-up of rapists assessed in a maximum-security psychiatric facility. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 5 435-448.
103. Roberts CF, Doren DM & Thornton D (in press) Dimensions associated with assessments of sex offender recidivism risk. Criminal Justice and Behavior.
104. Robinson D (1995) The Impact of Cognitive Skills Training on Post-Release Recidivism among Canadian Federal Offenders. Research Report No. R-41. Correctional Research and Development, Correctional Service Canada. Also available at www.cscscc.gc.ca/text/rsrch/reports/r41/r4le.shtlm.
105. Rogers R (2000) The uncritical acceptance of risk assessment in forensic practice. Law and Human Behavior 24 (5) 595-605.
106. Serin RC, Mailloux DL & Malcolm PB (2001) Psychopathy, deviant sexual arousal, and recidivism among sexual offenders. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 16 (3) 234-246.
107. Seto MC & Barbaree HE (1999) Psychopathy, treatment behaviour, and sex offender recidivism. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 14 (12) 1, 235-248.
108. Steadman HJ (1987) How well can we predict violence in adults? A review of the literature and some commentary. In: F Dutile & C Foust (Eds) The Prediction of Criminal Violence. Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas.
109. Szmukler G (2001) Volence risk prediction in practice. British Journal of Psychiatry 178 84-85.
110. Thornton D (1997) Structured Anchor Clinical Judgement Risk Assessment (SACJ). Proceedings of the NOTA Conference, Brighton, September.
111. Thornton D (2001) Constructing and testing a framework for dynamic risk assessment. Manuscript submitted for publication.
112. Thornton D (2002) Constructing and testing a framework for dynamic risk assessment. Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 14 (2) 137-151.
113. Thornton D & Travers R (1991). A Longitudinal Study of the Criminal Behaviour of Convicted Sexual Offenders. Proceedings of the Prison Psychologists' Conference. HM Prison Service.
114. Weiss P (1999) Assessment and treatment of sex offenders in the Czech Republic and in Eastern Europe. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 14 (4) 411-421.
115. Witt PH, DelRusso J., Oppenheim J & Ferguson G (1996) Sex offender risk assessment and the law. Journal of Psychiatry and Law 343-377.
116. Worling J (2001) Personality-based typology of adolescent male sexual offenders: differences in recidivism rates, victim-selection characteristics and personal victimisation histories. Sexual Abuse: A Journal or Research and Treatment 13 (3) 149-166.
117. Worling J & Curwen T (1998) The Adolescent Sexual Offender Project: A 10-years follow-up study. Report on the SAFE-T Program, Thistletown Regional Centre for Children and Adolescents, Toronto: Ontario Ministry of Community and Social Services.
118. Worling J & Curwen T (2000) Adolescent sexual offender recidivism: success of specialized treatment and implications for risk prediction. Child Abuse and Neglect 24 (7) 965-982.