Non-EEG seizure detection systems and potential SUDEP prevention: State of the art: Review and update

Seizure

Volumn 41, Issue , 2016, Pages 141-153

  Van de Vel, Anouk ^a   Cuppens, Kris ^b   Bonroy, Bert ^b   Milosevic, Milica ^c,d   Jansen, Katrien ^e   Van Huffel, Sabine ^c,d   Vanrumste, Bart ^c,d   Cras, Patrick ^f   Lagae, Lieven ^e,g   Ceulemans, Berten ^a,g  

^a ANTWERP UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL   (Belgium)

^b Thomas More University College   (Belgium)

^c UNIVERSITY OF LEUVEN   (Belgium)

^d IMinds Medical Information Technology Department   (Belgium)

^e UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS LEUVEN   (Belgium)

^f UNIVERSITY OF ANTWERP   (Belgium)

^g Rehabilitation Centre for Children and Youth Pulderbos   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Alarm system; Epilepsy; Non EEG based seizure detection; Sudden unexpected death; SUDEP

Indexed keywords

ACCELEROMETER; BIOSENSOR; BLOOD PRESSURE; BREATHING; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; ELECTROMAGNETIC RADIATION; ELECTROMYOGRAPHY; EPILEPSY ALARM MONITOR; EYE MOVEMENT; GYROSCOPE; HEART RHYTHM; HUMAN; MAGNETOMETER; MOISTURE; MOTOR ACTIVITY; NEUROLOGICAL DIAGNOSTIC DEVICE; OXYGEN SATURATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SEIZURE; SKIN CONDUCTANCE; SMARTPHONE; SUDDEN DEATH; TEMPERATURE; COMPLICATION; EPILEPSY; ETIOLOGY; MORTALITY; PREVENTION AND CONTROL;

DEATH, SUDDEN; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EPILEPSY; HUMANS;

EID: 84983460192     PISSN: 10591311     EISSN: 15322688     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.seizure.2016.07.012     Document Type: Review

References (88)

1. [1] Mormann, F., Elger, C.E., Lehnertz, K., Seizure anticipation: from algorithms to clinical practice. Curr Opin Neurol 19:2 (2006), 187–193.
2. [2] Nijsen, T., Arends, J., Griep, P., Cluitmans, P., The potential value of three-dimensional accelerometry for detection of motor seizures in severe epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav 7:1 (2005), 74–84.
3. [3] Van de Vel, A., Cuppens, K., Bonroy, B., Milosevic, M., Jansen, K., Van Huffel, S., et al. Non-EEG seizure-detection systems and potential SUDEP prevention: state of the art. Seizure 22 (2013), 345–355.
4. [4] Samson, K., Wearing the Detectives: wristbands, smartwatches, and other wearable devices allow for more real-time monitoring of seizures and other neurologic symptoms—and, possibly, more precise treatment. Neurol Now 11:4 (2015), 34–36.
5. [5] Ryvlin, P., Nashef, L., Tomson, T., Prevention of sudden unexpected death in epilepsy: a realistic goal?. Epilepsia 54:Suppl. 2 (2013), 23–28.
6. [6] Verma, A., Kumar, A., Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy: some approaches for its prevention and medico-legal consideration. Acta Neurol Belg 115:September (3) (2015), 207–212.
7. [7] Arthurs, S., Zaveri, H.P., Frei, M.G., Osorio, I., Patient and caregiver perspectives on seizure prediction. Epilepsy Behav 19:3 (2010), 474–477.
8. [8] Osorio, I., Manly, B.F.J., Probability of detection of clinical seizures using heart rate changes. Seizure 30 (2015), 120–123.
9. [9] Malarvili, M.B., Mesbah, M., Newborn seizure detection based on heart rate variability. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 56:11 (2009), 2594–2603.
10. [10] Mormann, F., Andrzejak, R.G., Elger, C.E., Lehnertz, K., Seizure prediction: the long and winding road. Brain 130:Pt. 2 (2007), 314–333.
11. [11] Osorio, I., Manly, B.F., Is seizure detection based on EKG clinically relevant?. Clin Neurophysiol 125:10 (2014), 1946–1951.
12. [12] Boylan, G.B., Stevenson, N.J., Vanhatalo, S., Monitoring neonatal seizures. Semin Fetal Neonatal Med 18:4 (2013), 202–208.
13. [13] Yamamoto, H., Okumura, A., Fukuda, M., Epilepsies and epileptic syndromes starting in the neonatal period. Brain Dev 33:3 (2011), 213–220.
14. [14] Karayiannis, N.B., Xiong, Y., Tao, G., Frost, J.D. Jr., Wise, M.S., Hrachovy, R.A., et al. Automated detection of videotaped neonatal seizures of epileptic origin. Epilepsia 47:6 (2006), 966–980.
15. [15] Ntonfo, G.M.K., Ferrari, G., Raheli, R., Pisani, F., Low-complexity image processing for real-time detection of neonatal clonic seizures. IEEE Trans Inf Technol Biomed 16:3 (2012), 375–382.
16. [16] Doyle, O.M., Temko, A., Marnane, W., Lightbody, G., Boylan, G.B., Heart rate based automatic seizure detection in the newborn. Med Eng Phys 32:8 (2010), 829–839.
17. [17] Greene, B.R., Boylan, G.B., Reilly, R.B., de Chazal, P., Connolly, S., Combination of EEG and ECG for improved automatic neonatal seizure detection. Clin Neurophysiol 118:6 (2007), 1348–1359.
18. [18] Greene, B.R., de Chazal, P., Boylan, G.B., Connolly, S., Reilly, R.B., Electrocardiogram based neonatal seizure detection. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 54:4 (2007), 673–682.
19. [19] Pantelopoulos, A., Bourbakis, N.G., A survey on wearable sensor-based systems for health monitoring and prognosis. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cyber 40:1 (2010), 1–12.
20. [20] Zheng, Y.-L., Ding, X.-R., Chung Yan Poon, C., Ping Lai Lo, B., Zhang, H., Zhou, X.-L., et al. Unobtrusive sensing and wearable devices for health informatics. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 61:5 (2014), 1538–1554.
21. [21] Jeppesen, J., Beniczky, S., Johansen, P., Sidenius, P., Fuglsang-Frederiksen, A., Exploring the capability of wireless near infrared spectroscopy as a portable seizure detection device for epilepsy patients. Seizure 26 (2015), 43–48.
22. [22] Ramgopal, S., Thome-Souza, S., Jackson, M., Kadish, N.E., Sánchez Fernández, I., Klehm, J., et al. Seizure detection, seizure prediction, and closed-loop warning systems in epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav 37C (2014), 291–307.
23. [23] Becq, G., Bonnet, S., Minotti, L., Antonakios, M., Guillemaud, R., Kahane, P., Classification of epileptic motor manifestations using inertial and magnetic sensors. Comput Biol Med 41:1 (2011), 46–55.
24. [24] Borujeny, G.T., Yazdi, M., Keshavarz-Haddad, A., Borujeny, A.R., Detection of epileptic seizure using wireless sensor networks. J Med Signals Sens 3:2 (2013), 63–68.
25. [25] Cogan, D., Nourani, M., Harvey, J., Nagaraddi, V., Epileptic seizure detection using wristworn biosensors. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2015, 5086–5089.
26. [26] Conradsen, I., Beniczky, S., Wolf, P., Kjaer, T.W., Sams, T., Sorensen, H.B., Automatic multi-modal intelligent seizure acquisition (MISA) system for detection of motor seizures from electromyographic data and motion data. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 107:2 (2012), 97–110.
27. [27] Dalton, A., Patel, S., Chowdhury, A., Welsh, M., Pang, T., Schachter, S., et al. Development of a body sensor network to detect motor patterns of epileptic seizures. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 59:11 (2012), 3204–3211.
28. [28] Gubbi, J., Kusmakar, S., Rao, A.S., Yan, B., O'Brien, T.J., Palaniswami, M., Automatic detection and classification of convulsive psychogenic non-epileptic seizures using a wearable device. IEEE J Biomed Health Inform(June), 2015 [Epub ahead of print].
29. [29] Jallon, P., A Bayesian approach for epileptic seizures detection with 3D accelerometers. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2010, 6325–6328.
30. [30] Massé, F., Penders, J., Sereteyn, A., van Bussel, M., Arends, J., Miniaturized wireless ECG-monitor for real-time detection of epileptic seizures. Proc Wirel Health 11 (2010), 1–7.
31. [31] van Elmpt, W.J.C., Nijsen, T.M.E., Griep, P.A.M., Arends, J.B.A.M., A model of heart rate changes to detect seizures in severe epilepsy. Seizure 15:6 (2006), 366–375.
32. [32] Milosevic, M., Van de Vel, A., Bonroy, B., Ceulemans, B., Lagae, L., Vanrumste, B., et al. Automated detection of tonic-clonic seizures using 3D Accelerometry and surface electromyography in pediatric patients. IEEE J Biomed Health Inform(July), 2015 [Epub ahead of print].
33. [33] Nijsen, T.M.E., Aarts, R.M., Arends, J.B.A.M., Cluitmans, P.J.M., Automated detection of tonic seizures using 3-D accelerometry. IFMBE Proc 22 (2008), 188–191.
34. [34] Nijsen, T.M.E., Aarts, R.M., Cluitmans, P.J.M., Griep, P.A.M., Time-frequency analysis of accelerometry data for detection of myoclonic seizures. IEEE Trans Inf Technol Biomed 14:5 (2010), 1197–1203.
35. [35] Schulc, E., Unterberger, I., Saboor, S., Hilbe, J., Ertl, M., Ammenwerth, E., et al. Measurement and quantification of generalized tonic–clonic seizures in epilepsy patients by means of accelerometry—an explorative study. Epilepsy Res 95:1–2 (2011), 173–183.
36. [36] van Andel J, Ungureanu C, Petkov G, Kalitzin S, Gutter T, de Weerd A, et al. Multimodal, automated detection of nocturnal motor seizures at home: is a reliable seizure detector feasible? Unpublished results.
37. [37] Van de Vel, A., Cuppens, K., Bonroy, B., Milosevic, M., Van Huffel, S., Vanrumste, B., et al. Long-term home monitoring of hypermotor seizures by patient-worn accelerometers. Epilepsy Behav 26:1 (2013), 118–125.
38. [38] Beniczky, S., Polster, T., Kjaer, T.W., Hjalgrim, H., Detection of generalized tonic–clonic seizures by a wireless wrist accelerometer: a prospective, multicenter study. Epilepsia 54:4 (2013), e58–e61.
39. [39] Carlson, C., Arnedo, V., Cahill, M., Devinsky, O., Detecting nocturnal convulsions: efficacy of the MP5 monitor. Seizure 18:3 (2009), 225–227.
40. [40] Conradsen, I., Beniczky, S., Wolf, P., Jennum, P., Sorensen, H.B.D., Evaluation of novel algorithm embedded in a wearable sEMG device for seizure detection. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2012, 2048–2051.
41. [41] Fulton, S., Van Poppel, K., McGregor, A., Ellis, M., Patters, A., Wheless, J., Prospective study of 2 bed alarms for detection of nocturnal seizures. J Child Neurol 28:11 (2013), 1430–1433.
42. [42] Kramer, U., Kipervasser, S., Shlitner, A., Kuzniecky, R., A novel portable seizure detection alarm system: preliminary results. J Clin Neurophysiol 28:1 (2011), 36–38.
43. [43] Larsen, S.N., Conradsen, I., Beniczky, S., Sorensen, H.B., Detection of Tonic Epileptic Seizures Based on Surface Electromyography. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2014, 942–945.
44. [44] Lockman, J., Fisher, R.S., Olson, D.M., Detection of seizure-like movements using a wrist accelerometer. Epilepsy Behav 20:4 (2011), 638–641.
45. [45] Narechania, A.P., Garić, I.I., Sen-Gupta, I., Macken, M.P., Gerard, E.E., Schuele, S.U., Assessment of a quasi-piezoelectric mattress monitor as a detection system for generalized convulsions. Epilepsy Behav 28:2 (2013), 172–176.
46. [46] Patterson, A.L., Mudigoudar, B., Fulton, S., McGregor, A., Van Poppel, K., Wheless, M.C., et al. SmartWatch by SmartMonitor: assessment of seizure detection efficacy for various seizure types in children: a large prospective single-center study. Pediatr Neurol 53:4 (2015), 309–311.
47. [47] Poh, M.Z., Loddenkemper, T., Reinsberger, C., Swenson, N.C., Goyal, S., Sabtala, M.C., et al. Convulsive seizure detection using a wrist-worn electrodermal activity and accelerometry biosensor. Epilepsia 53:5 (2012), e93–7.
48. [48] Sabesan, S., Sankar, R., Improving long-term management of epilepsy using a wearable multimodal seizure detection system. Epilepsy Behav 46 (2015), 56–57.
49. [49] Szabó, C.Á., Morgan, L.C., Karkar, K.M., Leary, L.D., Lie, O.V., Girouard, M., et al. Electromyography-based seizure detector: preliminary results comparing a generalized tonic-clonic seizure detection algorithm to video-EEG recordings. Epilepsia 56:9 (2015), 1432–1437.
50. [50] Van Poppel, K., Fulton, S.P., McGregor, A., Ellis, M., Patters, A., Wheless, J., Prospective study of the Emfit movement monitor. J Child Neurol 28:11 (2013), 1434–1436.
51. [51] Teohari, V.-M., Ungureanu, C., Bui, V., Arends, J., Aarts, R.M., Epilepsy seizure detection app for wearable technologies. Conference Proceedings AmI, 11–13 November, 2014.
52. [52] van Andel, J., Ungureanu, C., Aarts, R., Leijten, F., Arends, J., Using photoplethysmography in heart rate monitoring of patients with epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav 45 (2015), 142–145.
53. [53] Renevey, P., Vetter, R., Krauss, J., Celka, P., Depeursinge, Y., Wrist-located pulse detection using IR signals, activity and nonlinear artifact cancellation. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 3 (2001), 3030–3033.
54. [54] Surges, R., Scott, C.A., Walker, M.C., Enhanced, Q.T., shortening and persistent tachycardia after generalized seizures. Neurology 74:5 (2010), 421–426.
55. [55] Jansen, K., Varon, C., Van Huffel, S., Lagae, L., Peri-ictal ECG changes in childhood epilepsy: implications for detection systems. Epilepsy Behav 29:1 (2013), 72–76.
56. [56] Zijlmans, M., Flanagan, D., Gotman, J., Heart rate changes and ECG abnormalities during epileptic seizures, prevalence and definition of an objective clinical sign. Epilepsia 43:8 (2002), 847–854.
57. [57] Jeppesen, J., Beniczky, S., Johansen, P., Sidenius, P., Fuglsang-Frederiksen, A., Detection of epileptic seizures with a modified heart rate variability algorithm based on Lorenz plot. Seizure 24 (2015), 1–7.
58. [58] Ponnusamy, A., Marques, J.L., Reuber, M., Comparison of heart rate variability parameters during complex partial seizures and psychogenic nonepileptic seizures. Epilepsia 53:8 (2012), 1314–1321.
59. [59] Boon, P., Vonck, K., van Rijckevorsel, K., El Tahry, R., Elger, C.E., Mullatti, N., et al. A prospective, multicenter study of cardiac-based seizure detection to activate vagus nerve stimulation. Seizure 32 (2015), 52–61.
60. [60] Fisher, R.S., Afra, P., Macken, M., Minecan, D.N., Bagić, A., Benbadis, S.R., et al. Automatic vagus nerve stimulation triggered by ictal tachycardia: clinical outcomes and device performance—the U.S. E-37 trial. Neuromodulation 19:2 (2016), 188–195.
61. [61] Khandoker, A.H., Karmakar, C.K., Palaniswami, M., Comparison of pulse rate variability with heart rate variability during obstructive sleep apnea. Med Eng Phys 33:2 (2011), 204–209.
62. [62] Simon, R.P., Heart and lung in the postictal state. Epilepsy Behav 19:2 (2010), 167–171.
63. [63] Hirsch, L.J., Donner, E.J., So, E.L., Jacobs, M., Nashef, L., Noebels, J.L., et al. Abbreviated report of the NIH/NINDS workshop on sudden unexpected death in epilepsy. Neurology 76:22 (2011), 1932–1938.
64. [64] Poets, C.F., Apparent life-threatening events and sudden infant death on a monitor. Paediatr Respir Rev 5:Suppl. A (2004), S383–S386.
65. [65] Binks, A.P., Banzett, R.B., Duvivier, C., An inexpensive, MRI compatible device to measure tidal volume from chest-wall circumference. Physiol Meas 28:2 (2007), 149–159.
66. [66] O'Regan, M.E., Brown, J.K., Abnormalities in cardiac and respiratory function observed during seizures in childhood. Dev Med Child Neurol 47:1 (2005), 4–9.
67. [67] Richerson, G.B., Buchanan, G.F., The serotonin axis: shared mechanisms in seizures, depression, and SUDEP. Epilepsia 52:Suppl. 1 (2011), 28–38.
68. [68] Ritchie, J.E., Williams, A.B., Gerard, C., Hockey, H., Evaluation of a humidified nasal high-flow oxygen system, using oxygraphy, capnography and measurement of upper airway pressures. Anaesth Intensive Care 39:6 (2011), 1103–1110.
69. [69] Corbishley, P., Rodríguez-Villegas, E., Breathing detection: towards a miniaturized, wearable, battery-operated monitoring system. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 55:1 (2008), 196–204.
70. [70] Jansen, K., Varon, C., Van Huffel, S., Lagae, L., Ictal and interictal respiratory changes in temporal lobe and absence epilepsy in childhood. Epilepsy Res 106:3 (2013), 410–416.
71. [71] Loddenkemper, T., Kellinghaus, C., Gandjour, J., Nair, D.R., Najm, I.M., Bingaman, W., et al. Localising and lateralising value of ictal piloerection. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 75:6 (2004), 879–883.
72. [72] Rémi, J., Silva Cunha, J.P., Vollmar, C., Topcuoglu, Ö.B., Meier, A., Ulowetz, S., et al. Quantitative movement analysis differentiates focal seizures characterized by automatisms. Epilepsy Behav 20:4 (2011), 642–647.
73. [73] Poh, M.Z., McDuff, D.J., Picard, R.W., Advancements in noncontact, multiparameter physiological measurements using a webcam. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 58:1 (2011), 7–11.
74. [74] Van Looy, W., Cuppens, K., Bonroy, B., Van de Vel, A., Ceulemans, B., Lagae, L., et al. Detection of body movement using optical flow and clustering. Conf Proc PoCA, 2011, 29–35.
75. [75] Lu, H., Pan, Y., Mandal, B., Eng, H.L., Guan, C., Chan, D.W., Quantifying limb movements in epileptic seizures through color-based video analysis. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 60:2 (2013), 461–469.
76. [76] Garbey, M., Sun, N., Merla, A., Pavlidis, I., Contact-free measurement of cardiac pulse based on the analysis of thermal imagery. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 54:8 (2007), 1418–1426.
77. [77] Murthy, J.N., van Jaarsveld, J., Fei, J., Pavlidis, I., Harrykissoon, R.I., Lucke, J.F., et al. Thermal infrared imaging: a novel method to monitor airflow during polysomnography. Sleep 32:11 (2009), 1521–1527.
78. [78] Cuppens, K., Chen, C.W., Wong, K.B., Van de Vel, A., Lagae, L., Ceulemans, B., et al. Using spatio-temporal interest points (STIP) for myoclonic jerk detection in nocturnal video. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2012, 4454–4457.
79. [79] Li, C., Lin, J., Xiao, Y., Robust overnight monitoring of human vital signs by a noncontact respiration and heartbeat detector. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 1 (2006), 2235–2238.
80. [80] Suzuki, S., Matsui, T., Kawahara, H., Ichiki, H., Shimizu, J., Kondo, Y., et al. A noncontact vital sign monitoring system for ambulances using dual-frequency microwave radars. Med Biol Eng Comput 47:1 (2009), 101–105.
81. [81] Shankar, R., Jory, C., Tripp, M., Cox, D., Hagenow, K., Monitoring nocturnal seizure in vulnerable patients. Learn Disabil Pract 16:9 (2013), 36–38.
82. [82] Blum, A.S., Respiratory physiology of seizures. J Clin Neurophysiol 26:5 (2009), 309–315.
83. [83] Chung, S.S., Gerber, P., Kirlin, K.A., Ictal eye closure is a reliable indicator for psychogenic nonepileptic seizures. Neurology 66:11 (2006), 1730–1731.
84. [84] Bonnet, S., Héliot, R., A magnetometer-based approach for studying human movements. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 54:7 (2007), 1353–1355.
85. [85] Luca, S., Karsmakers, P., Cuppens, K., Croonenborghs, T., Van de Vel, A., Ceulemans, B., et al. Detecting rare events using extreme value statistics applied to epileptic convulsions in children. Artif Intell Med 60 (2014), 89–96.
86. [86] De Cooman, T., Van de Vel, A., Ceulemans, B., Lagae, L., Vanrumste, B., Van Huffel, S., Online detection of tonic-clonic seizures in pediatric patients using ECG and low-complexity incremental novelty detection. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2015, 5597–5600.
87. [87] van Andel, J., Thijs, R.D., de Weerd, A., Arends, J., Leijten, F., Non-EEG based ambulatory seizure detection designed for home use: what is available and how will it influence epilepsy care. Epilepsy Behav 57:Pt. A (2016), 82–89.
88. [88] Jory, C., Shankar, R., Coker, D., McLean, B., Hanna, J., Newman, C., Safe and sound: a systematic literature review of seizure detection methods for personal use. Seizure 36 (2016), 4–15.