A predisposition to cowardice? Aviation psychology and the genesis of 'lack of moral fibre'

War and Society

Volumn 13, Issue 1, 1995, Pages 15-34

  English, Allan D ^a  

^a QUEEN S UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84976716001     PISSN: 07292473     EISSN: 20424345     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1179/072924795791200169     Document Type: Article

References (111)

1. E.R. Ludlow-Hewitt, Inspector-General's Report No. 271, 'Visits to Air Crew Disposal and Suspendair Centres.', 26 December 1942, AIR 33/5.
2. Max Hastings, Bomber Command, (New York 1979), 249-50.
3. John Terraine, The Right of the Line (London 1985), 521, 532
4. John McCarthy, 'Aircrew and "Lack of Moral Fibre" in the Second World War', War & Society, 2: 2 (September 1984), 97.
5. McCarthy, 'Aircrew', 96.
6. F.I. Wilbur, 'Aviation and Common Sense', Flight, 3 (1911): 399.
7. Sheldon F. Dudley, 'Active Service Flying: the Medical Point of View', Journal of the Royal Naval Medical Service, 4 (1918): 131,140.
8. H. Graeme Anderson, 'The Selection of Candidates for the Air Service', Lancet (16 March 1918), 395.
9. Norman S. Gilchrist, 'An Analysis of Causes of Breakdown in Flying', British Medical Journal, 2 (1918): 401
10. Dudley, 'Active Service Flying', 131.
11. Martin Flack, 'Applied Physiology of Aviation', in H. Graeme Anderson, The Medical and Surgical Aspects of Aviation (London 1919), 41
12. H. Graeme Anderson, Medical and Surgical Aspects, 67.
13. Isaac Jones, Flying Vistas (Philadelphia 1937), 192
14. J.L. Birley, 'The Principles of Medical Science as Applied to Military Aviation, Lecture I', Lancet (29 May 1920), 1148,1151.
15. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1150.
16. John Brophy and Eric Partridge, The Long Trail (London 1969), 163.
17. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1151
18. Dudley, 'Active Service Flying', 132, 134
19. Gilchrist, 'Causes of Breakdown in Flying', 401.
20. Anderson, Medical and Surgical Aspects, 88-93
21. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1149
22. Dudley, 'Active Service Flying', 133.
23. Anderson, Medical and Surgical Aspects, 63-4
24. Dudley, 'Active Service Flying', 133-4
25. Oliver H. Gotch, 'The Aero-Neuroses of War Pilots', in Anderson, Medical and Surgical Aspects, 28-33.
26. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1151.
27. Who Was Who, Vol. 3 (London 1947), 115-16.
28. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1149.
29. L.A. Strange, Recollections of an Airman (London 1989), 169.
30. Strange, Recollections, 79
31. Gwilym Lewis (ed. Chaz Bowyer), Wings Over the Somme (London 1976), 81, 140, 175
32. Rothesay Stuart Wortley, Letters From a Flying Officer (London 1929), 168.
33. Gordon Taylor, Sopwith Scout 7309 (London 1968), 107.
34. F.C. Dockeray and S. Isaacs, 'Psychological Research in Aviation in Italy, France, England, and the American Expeditionary Forces', Journal of Comparative Psychology, 1 (1921): 127-33
35. Flack in Anderson, Medical and Surgical Aspects, 41, 55-8.
36. US National Research Council, Division of Medical Science Committee, Aviation Medical Reports, Report 43, 3 April 1942, HQS 47-6-3, vol. 3, Vol. 5383, RG 24, National Archives of Canada.
37. J.L. Birley, 'A Lecture on the Psychology of Courage. Delivered at the RAF Staff College on March 1st, 1923', Lancet (21 April 1923), 781, 783-4.
38. E.J. Dearnaley and P.B. Warr (eds), Aircrew Stress in Wartime Operations (London 1979), v.
39. F.C. Bartlett, Psychology and the Soldier (London 1927), 11, 35-6.
40. Charles Symonds, 'The Neurological Approach to Mental Disorder', in Symonds, Studies in Neurology (New York 1970), 246-9.
41. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine in 1941.
42. Air Ministry, 'Notes for Medical Officers on the Psychological Care of Flying Personnel', Air Ministry Pamphlet [AMP] 100,1st edn (May 1939), 9, 16,18, AIR 2/8591.
43. Freud hypothesised that the demands of the id (the 'lower', 'instinctive' drives) and the demands of the superego (moral demands) were mediated by the ego which arrived at compromises resulting in observable behaviour.
44. R.E. Fancher, Pioneers of Psychology, 2nd edn (New York 1990), 380-2.
45. AMP 100, 2, 4-5, 8-9,15,16,18-19.
46. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1150-1.
47. Birley,'Lecture I', 1148,1151
48. 'Courage', 784.
49. AMP 100,19.
50. R.E. Fancher, The Intelligence Men (New York 1985), 84-6, 170, 228
51. Fancher, Pioneers, 213,219,237.
52. D.F. Buckle, 'The Prevention of Psychiatric Disorders in Flying Personnel', The Medical Journal of Australia, 2 (1942): 125.
53. R.D. Gillespie, Psychological Effects of War on Citizen and Soldier (New York 1942), 180, 221
54. AMP 100, 8.
55. D.D. Reid, 'Historical Background to Wartime Research in Psychology in the RAF', in Dearnaley and Warr, Aircrew Stress, 1.
56. FPRC Reports 86b, 86c, 121,122, AIR 57.
57. C.P. Symonds, 'Memorandum on the Use and Abuse of the Term "Flying Stress'", FPRC Report 412 [1941], 3, AIR 57. The complete list comprised anxiety, depression, elation, fatigue syndrome, hysteria, obsessional, schizophrenia, organic acute, and organic chronic.
58. FPRC Report 412, 3. AMP 100 used the term 'neurasthenia' and did not. refer to 'fatigue syndrome' in.its nomenclature, AMP 100,10.
59. C.P. Symonds and Denis Williams, 'Psychological Disorders in Flying Personnel, Section 1. A Critical Review of Published Literature', FPRC Report 412(c), January 1942,1,5, 7, 8-11, AIR 57.
60. C.P. Symonds, 'The Human Response to Flying Stress', December 1943, in Air Ministry, Psychological Disorders in Flying Personnel of the RAF [PDFP] (Air Publication 3139) (Londonl947), 110-11.
61. C.P. Symonds and Denis Williams, 'Psychological Disorders in Flying Personnel, Section 2. Review of Reports Submitted to Air Ministry since the Outbreak of the War, April 1942', FPRC Report 412(d) [1942], 4, 6, AIR 57.
62. FPRC Report 412 (d), 17
63. PDFP, i.
64. Many military psychiatrists accepted research that suggested that one tenth of the population of the British Isles was 'psychopathic' and as much as 25 per cent composed 'the dull and backward, the feeble-minded, the imbeciles, or idiots'.
65. J.R. Rees, 'Three Years of Military Psychiatry in the United Kingdom', British Medical Journal, 1 (1943): 3.
66. Coastal Command reported 1.4 per cent, and Fighter command 1.2 per cent, FPRC Report 412(d), 5.
67. D. Stafford-Clark 'Morale and Flying Experience: Results of a Wartime Study', Journal of'Mental Science, 95 (1949): 10-50
68. R.N. Ironside and I.R.C. Batchelor, Aviation Neuro-Psychiatry (Edinburgh 1945).
69. Lord Moran, The Anatomy of Courage, 2nd edn (London 1966), xv-xvi, 22-3.
70. Ironside and Batchelor, Aviation Neuro-Psychiatry, 10-12,14-16,34.
71. Denis J. Williams, 'Predisposition to Psychological Disorder in Normal Flying Personnel', FPRĆ Report 516, February 1943, in PDFP, 192.
72. PDFP, I
73. Department of National Defence, Canada, Defence Research Board Operational Research Group [ORG], 'A Follow-up Study of Initial Psychiatric Appraisal of Wartime RCAF Aircrew', ORG Report No. 2, (Ottawa October 1950), 1-2, 6.
74. Shabtnai Noy, 'Combat Stress Reactions', in Reuven Gal and A. David Mangelsdorff (eds), Handbook of Military Psychology (Chichester 1991), 514.
75. Ironside and Batchelor, Aviation Neuro-Psychiatry, v.
76. F.C.R. Chalke, 'Psychiatric Screening of Recruits', Department of Veterans Affairs Treatment Services Bulletin, 9 (January-June 1954): 282-4, 290
77. H. J.C.J. L'Etang, 'A Criticism of Military Psychiatry in the Second World War', Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 97 (1951): 192-5.
78. Anderson, Medical and Surgical Aspects, 97
79. Birley, 'Lecture I', 1148.
80. D.D. Reid, 'Prognosis for a Return to Full Flying Duties after Psychological Disorder', FPRC Report 535 in PDFP, June 1943,241,243.
81. Bradford Hill and Denis Williams, 'Investigation into Psychological Disorders in Flying Personnel: The Reliability of Psychiatric Opinion in the RAF, FPRC Report 601, October 1944,1,11, AIR 57.
82. Ironside and Batchelor, Aviation Neuro-Psychiatry, 17-20.
83. D.D. Reid, 'A Study of Some Factors in the Causation of Flying Stress', FPRC Report 450, April 1942,10,14, AIR 57.
84. Charles P. Symonds and Denis J. Williams, 'Clinical and Statistical Study of Neurosis Precipitated by Flying Duties', FPRC Report 547, August 1943, in Dearnaley and Warr, Aircrew Stress, 33
85. Symonds, Studies, 19.
86. FPRC Report 547, 34.
87. Ironside and Batchelor, Aviation Neuro-Psychiatry, 74.
88. 'Our objective was the conservation of military manpower', Studies, 17.
89. C.P. Symonds and Denis Williams, 'The Probability of Return to Full Flying of Men Who Have Broken Down Under the Strain of Operational Duties', FPRC Report 561, November 1943,1, AIR 57.
90. C.P. Symonds and Denis Williams, 'Investigation of Psychological Disorders in Flying Personnel by Unit Medical Officers', FPRC Report 412(k), February 1945, 6, AIR 57.
91. FPRC Report 547, in Dearnaley and Warr, Aircrew Stress, 34.
92. FPRC Report 412(k), 6
93. Gillespie, Psychological Effects of War, 201-2.
94. C.P. Symonds and Denis Williams, 'Occurrence of Neurosis in Royal Air Force Air Crews in 1944 and 1945', FPRC Report 412(L), April 1945, in PDFP, 180.
95. FPRC Report 412(L) in PDFP, 178.
96. Terraine, The Right of the Line, 533-5. Terraine does not make clear what time frame is covered by these figures, although it appears to be late 1940 to 1945.
97. Terry Copp and Bill McAndrew, Battle Exhaustion: Soldiers and Psychiatrists in the Canadian Army, 1939-1945 (Montreal 1990), 58, 81,114.
98. Charles Webster and Noble Frankland, The Strategic Air Offensive Against Germany 1939-1945 (London 1961), 4: 440.
99. John A. English, On Infantry (New York 1984), 138.
100. S.C. Rexford-Welch (ed.), The Royal Air Force Medical Services (London 1954-55), 2: 123
101. Webster and Frankland, Strategic Air Offensive, 4: 403-6.
102. J. Douglas Harvey, Boys, Bombs and Brussels Sprouts (Toronto 1981), 159.
103. Hastings, Bomber Command, 248
104. Webster and Frankland, Strategic Air Offensive, 2:195-6
105. Norman Longmate, The Bombers (London 1983), 184.
106. Murray Peden, A Thousand Shall Fall (Stittsville, Ontario 1979), 416
107. Longmate, The Bombers, 188.
108. Interview with General (rtd) Chester Hull, CO of 428 Squadron in the Second World War, 28 May 1992.
109. Wing Commander J. Lawson in Terraine, The Right of the Line, 532.
110. Gillespie, Psychological Effects of War, 19, 32.
111. R.H. Ahrenfeldt, 'Military Psychiatry', in Arthur Salusbury MacNalty and W. Franklin Mellor (eds), Medical Services in War (London 1968), 176-7.