The Social Construction of Validity in Estimates of US Crude Oil Reserves

Social Studies of Science

Volumn 15, Issue 2, 1985, Pages 207-240

  Bowden, Gary ^a  

^a MCMASTER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84972620680     PISSN: 03063127     EISSN: 14603659     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/030631285015002001     Document Type: Article

References (117)

1. T. H. McCulloch, ‘Oil and Gas’, in D. A. Brobst and W. P. Pratt (eds.), United States Mineral Resources (United States Geological Survey Professional Paper 820, 1973), 477–96.
2. M. King Hubbert, ‘US Petroleum Estimates, 1956–1978, (Annual Meeting Papers, American Petroleum Institute, Production Department, 1978).
3. H. Collins, ‘The Seven Sexes: A Study in the Sociology of a Phenomenon, or the Replication of Experiments in Physics’, Sociology, Vol. 9 (1975), 205–24.
4. Collins, ‘Son of Seven Sexes: The Social Destruction of a Physical Phenomenon’, Social Studies of Science, Vol. 11 (1981), 33–62.
5. A. Brannigan, The Social Basis of Scientific Discoveries (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981).
6. B. Barnes, Interests and the Growth of Knowledge (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1977).
7. S. Shapin, ‘The Politics of Observation: Cerebral Anatomy and Social Interests in the Edinburgh Phrenology Disputes’, in R. Wallis (ed.), On the Margins of Science: The Social Construction of Rejected Knowledge (Keele, Staffs.: University of Keele, Sociological Review Monograph No. 27, 1979), 139–78.
8. D. MacKenzie, Statistics in Britain, 1865–1930 (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1981).
9. J. Habermas, Knowledge and Human Interests (London: Heinemann, 1972).
10. B. Latour and S. Woolgar, Laboratory Life (Beverly Hills, Calif.: Sage, 1979).
11. M. Lynch, Art and Artifact in Laboratory Science (unpublished PhD dissertation, University of California at Irvine, 1979; London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1985).
12. Barnes, Art and Artifact in Laboratory Science, note 4, 58.
13. K. Weick, The Social Psychology of Organizing (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley, 1979).
14. C. Perrow, Complex Organizations: A Critical Essay (Glenview, 111.: Scott Forsman, 1979), Chapter 6.
15. M. Tanzer, The Political Economy of International Oil and the Underdeveloped Countries (Boston, Mass.: Beacon Press, 1969), 20–29.
16. Mackenzie, The Political Economy of International Oil and the Underdeveloped Countries, note 4.
17. S. Shapin, ‘Phrenological Knowledge and the Social Structure of Early 19th Century England’, Annals of Science, Vol. 32 (1975), 219–43.
18. B. Barnes, ‘On the “Hows” and “Whys” of Cultural Change’, Social Studies of Science, Vol. 11 (1981), 481–98, 482, 487.
19. Brannigan, Social Studies of Science note 3.
20. Collins, Social Studies of Science note 3.
21. Brannigan, Social Studies of Science, note 3, Chapters 6, 7.
22. G. Bowden, ‘Estimating US Crude Oil Resources: Organizational Interests, Political Economy and Historical Change’, Pacific Sociological Review, Vol. 25 (1982), 419–48.
23. Bowden, ‘The Structural Basis of a Scientific Controversy: The Case of US Crude Oil Estimates, 1957–1974’, paper presented to the Society for Social Studies of Science conference (Blacksburg, Virginia, November 1983).
24. M. Dennis, Drilling for Dollars: The Making of American Petroleum Reserve Estimates, 1921–1925 (unpublished BA thesis, University of Pennsylvania, 1982).
25. B. Wynne, ‘C. G. Barkla and the J Phenomenon: A Case Study of the Treatment of Deviance in Physics’, Social Studies of Science, Vol. 6 [1976], 307–47
26. S. Shapin, ‘Of Gods and Kings: Natural Philosophy and Politics in the Leibniz-Clarke Disputes’, Isis, Vol. 72 (1981), 187–215.
27. H. Hedberg, ‘The Volume of Sediment Fallacy in Estimating Petroleum Resources’, in J. Haun (ed.), Methods of Estimating the Volume of Undiscovered Oil and Gas Resources (Tulsa, Oklahoma: American Association of Petroleum Geologists, 1975), 160.
28. J. Harrison, ‘The Nature and Significance of Geological Maps’, in C. Albritton (ed.), The Fabric of Geology (San Francisco, Calif.: W. H. Freeman, 1963), 37–63.
29. M. King Hubbert, ‘Nuclear Energy and the Fossil Fuels’ (Annual Meeting Papers, American Petroleum Institute, Section on Drilling and Production Practice, 1956), Vol. 36, 7–25.
30. D. F. Hewett, ‘Cycles in Metal Production’, Transactions of the American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical Engineers, Petroleum Division, Vol. 82 (1929), 65–98.
31. M. King Hubbert, ‘Survey of World Energy Resources’, Canadian Mining and Metallurgical Bulletin, Vol. 66 (1973), 41–42.
32. M. King Hubbert, Energy Resources (Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council, 1962).
33. Energy Resources., 50–73.
34. M. King Hubbert, ‘Degree of Advancement of Petroleum Production in the United States’, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Vol. 51 (1967), 2207–27.
35. Hubbert, ‘Energy Resources’, in National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council, Resources and Man (San Francisco, Calif.: W. H. Freeman, 1969), 157–242.
36. Hubbert, ‘US Energy Resources, A Review as of 1972, Part 1’, background paper prepared for US Senate, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs (Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, 1974).
37. A. Zapp, ‘Future Petroleum Producing Capacity of the United States’ (USGS Bulletin No. 1142-H, 1962).
38. T. Hendricks, ‘Resources of Oil, Gas, and Natural-Gas Liquids in the United States and the World’ (USGS Circular No. 522, 1965).
39. V. McKelvey and D. Duncan, ‘United States and World Resources of Energy’, Symposium on Fuel and Energy Economics, Proceedings of the American Chemical Society, Division of Fuel Chemistry, Vol. 9, No. 2 (1965), 1–17.
40. P. Theobald et al., ‘Energy Resources of the United States’ (USGS Circular No. 650, 1972).
41. McKelvey, ‘USGS Releases Revised US Oil and Gas Estimates’ (US Department of Interior, News Release, 26 March 1974).
42. Hubbert, Symposium on Fuel and Energy Economics, Proceedings of the American Chemical Society, note 24.
43. T. Pinch, The Development of Solar Neutrino Astronomy (unpublished PhD thesis, University of Bath, UK, 1982).
44. Hubbert, The Development of Solar Neutrino Astronomy, note 23.
45. Independent Petroleum Association of America, Petroleum in the Western Hemisphere (Washington, DC: IPAA, 1952).
46. Hubbert, Petroleum in the Western Hemisphere, note 1, 4.
47. Anonymous, ‘Is Oil Nearing a Production Crisis?’, Petroleum Week (16 March 1956), 9–10.
48. Hubbert, Petroleum Week, note 1, 5.
49. Hubbert, Petroleum Week, note 25, 132–33.
50. A. Wildavsky and E. Tenenbaum, The Politics of Mistrust (Beverly Hills, Calif.: Sage, 1981).
51. R. Gonzalez, ‘Petroleum for our Future Progress’, Journal of Petroleum Technology (March 1957), 44–51.
52. M. Davis, ‘The Dynamics of Domestic Petroleum Resources’, Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute, Vol. 38, No. 1(1958), 22–27.
53. Gonzalez, Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute, note 40, 49.
54. L. Weeks, ‘Estimation of Petroleum Resources: Commentary’, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Vol. 50 (1966), 2009.
55. D. Robbins and R. Johnston, ‘The Role of Cognitive and Occupational Differentiation in Scientific Controversies’, Social Studies of Science, Vol. 6 (1976), 349–68.
56. Hubbert, Social Studies of Science, note 25, 64–73.
57. J. Ryan, ‘National Academy of Sciences Report on Energy Resources: Discussion of Limitations of Logistic Projections’, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Vol. 49 (1965), 1713–20.
58. M. King Hubbert, ‘Reply’, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, 1720–27.
59. Ryan, ‘Limitations of Statistical Methods for Predicting Petroleum and Natural Gas Reserves and Availability’, Journal of Petroleum Technology (March 1966), 281–84.
60. Hubbert, ‘Reply to J. M. Ryan’, Journal of Petroleum Technology, 284–86.
61. Ryan (1965), Journal of Petroleum Technology, note 45, 1713.
62. Journal of Petroleum Technology., 1715–19.
63. Hubbert, Journal of Petroleum Technology. note 27.
64. Hubbert, Journal of Petroleum Technology. note 25.
65. Hubbert, Journal of Petroleum Technology. note 1, 13.
66. ‘US Reserves Put at 600 Billion Barrels’, Oil and Gas Journal (2 September 1963), 78–79.
67. ‘Those who have studied Zapp’s method are much impressed with it, and we in the Geological Survey have much confidence in his estimates’: quoted in Hubbert, Oil and Gas Journal, note 25, 48.
68. ‘John Ryan’s fine analysis of recent attempts to estimate the extent of potential petroleum resources correctly identifies their weakness’: quote taken from V. McKelvey, ‘Reply to J. M. Ryan’, Journal of Petroleum Technology (March 1966), 287.
69. McKelvey and Duncan, Journal of Petroleum Technology, note 29.
70. McKelvey, Journal of Petroleum Technology, note 29.
71. McKelvey, Journal of Petroleum Technology note 52.
72. V. McKelvey, ‘Contradictions in Energy Resource Estimates’, Proceedings, 7th Biennial Gas Dynamics Symposium, The Technological Institute, Northwestern University, 1967, 5–23.
73. McKelvey, ‘Mineral Resource Estimates and Public Policy’, in D. Brobst and W. Pratt (eds.), United States Mineral Resources (USGS Professional Paper 820, 1973), 9–19.
74. Hubbert, United States Mineral Resources, note 1, 5.
75. W. Davis, ‘Future Productive Capacity and Probable Reserves of the US’, Oil and Gas Journal, Vol. 56 (1958), 105–19.
76. H. Hudson, ‘Is the “Song of Plenty” a Siren Song?’, Oil and Gas Journal, Vol. 61 (1963), 131–36.
77. American Petroleum Institute, Basic Petroleum Data Book, Vol. 2, No. 3 (1982), 9.
78. J. Omang, ‘Oil Prophet Cited: Geologist Saw Crisis in 1948’, Washington Post (15 November 1977), A-1.
79. P. Feyerabend, Against Method (London: New Left Books, 1975).
80. Collins, Against Method, note 3.
81. Brannigan, Against Method, note 3, Chapter 6.
82. B. Miller et al., ‘Geological Estimates of Undiscovered Recoverable Oil and Gas Resources in the United States’ (USGS Circular 725, 1975).
83. B. Grossling, ‘In Search of a Statistical Probability Model of Petroleum Resource Assessment’ (USGS Circular 724, 1975).
84. R. Lyons, ‘Interior Secretary Will Replace Head of US Geological Survey’, New York Times (7 September 1977), 134.
85. T. O'Toole, ‘Chief Geologist’s Downfall’, Washington Post (13 November 1977), A-6.
86. B. Bartlett, ‘Killing the Messenger: The Carter Administration and the Facts about Oil and Gas’, The Washington Monthly, Vol. 10 (1978), 57–60.
87. Omang, The Washington Monthly, note 57.
88. US Congress, ‘Adequacy of US Oil and Gas Reserves’, Hearing before the Joint Economic Committee, 94th Congress, 1st Session, 1975, 3.
89. Brannigan, Hearing before the Joint Economic Committee, note 3, Chapter 7.
90. R. Gillette, ‘Oil and Gas Resources: Did the USGS Gush Too High?’, Science, Vol. 185 (12 July 1974), 127–30.
91. A. Martinez, ‘The Estimation of Petroleum Resources’, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Vol. 50 (1966), 2001–08.
92. Hubbert, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, note 25, Figure 24b.
93. W. Stannage, ‘Resource Estimates and Politics Don't Mix’, World Oil, Vol. 189(1979), 113–18.
94. Collins (1981), World Oil, note 3.
95. Collins (1975), World Oil, note 3.
96. Committee, World Oil, note 65, 1.
97. B. Netschert, The Future Supply of Oil and Gas (Baltimore, Md: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1958).
98. Bowden (1983), The Future Supply of Oil and Gas note 19.
99. IPAA, The Future Supply of Oil and Gas, note 34.
100. L. Weeks, ‘Fuel Reserves of the Future’, Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Vol. 42 (1958), 431–41.
101. Bowden (1983), Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, note 19.
102. C. Goodwin (ed.), Energy Policy in Perspective (Washington, DC: Brookings Institute, 1981).
103. National Petroleum Council, US Energy Outlook, 1971–1985 (Washington, DC: NPC, 1971).
104. F. Al-Chalabi, OPEC and the International Oil Industry: A Changing Structure (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980).
105. J. Blair, The Control of Oil (London: Macmillan, 1976).
106. N. Jacoby, Multinational Oil (New York: Macmillan, 1974).
107. P. Odell, Oil and World Power: A Geographical Interpretation(Harmondsworth, Middx: Penguin, 6th edn, 1981).
108. A. Sampson, The Seven Sisters: The Great Oil Companies and the World They Shaped (New York: Bantam, 1975).
109. Tanzer, The Seven Sisters: The Great Oil Companies and the World They Shaped, note 10.
110. Gillette (he Seven Sisters: The Great Oil Companies and the World They Shaped, note 67) claims that Moody’s estimates contradict industry
111. J. Moody and R. Geiger, ‘Petroleum Resources: How Much Oil and Where?’, Technology Review, Vol. 77, No. 5 (March/April 1975), 45.
112. C. Lam mers and D. Hickson (eds.), Organizations Alike and Unalike: National and International Studies in the Sociology of Organizations(London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1979).
113. Latour and Woolgar, Organizations Alike and Unalike: National and International Studies in the Sociology of Organizations, note 8.
114. Lynch, Organizations Alike and Unalike: National and International Studies in the Sociology of Organizations, note 8.
115. R. Anderson, ‘The Necessity of Field Methods in the Study of Scientific Research’, in E. Mendelsohn and Y. Elkana (eds.), Sciences and Cultures, Sociology of the Sciences Yearbook, Vol. 5 (Dordrecht and Boston, Mass.: Reidel, 1981), 213–44.
116. R. Anderson, Building Scientific Institutions in India: Saha and Bhabha (Montreal: McGill University Center for Developing Area Studies, 1975).
117. Perrow, Building Scientific Institutions in India: Saha and Bhabha, note 10.