Why do women choose or reject careers in academic medicine? A narrative review of empirical evidence

The Lancet

Volumn 388, Issue 10062, 2016, Pages 2948-2958

  Edmunds, Laurel D ^a   Ovseiko, Pavel V ^a   Shepperd, Sasha ^a   Greenhalgh, Trisha ^a   Frith, Peggy ^a,b   Roberts, Nia W ^c   Pololi, Linda H ^d   Buchan, Alastair M ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^b JOHN RADCLIFFE HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^d BRANDEIS UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT; DECISION MAKING; FINANCE; HUMAN; MEDICAL EDUCATION; MEDICINE; MOTIVATION; PERSONAL EXPERIENCE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RESEARCH; REVIEW; SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE; SEX DIFFERENCE; SOCIAL PARTICIPATION; TEACHER; TEACHING; FEMALE; FEMALE PHYSICIAN; MEDICAL RESEARCH; MENTOR; PSYCHOLOGY; SEXISM; SUPPLY AND DISTRIBUTION; UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL;

ACADEMIC MEDICAL CENTERS; BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH; CAREER CHOICE; FEMALE; HUMANS; MENTORS; PHYSICIANS, WOMEN; SEXISM; TEACHING;

EID: 84963961049     PISSN: 01406736     EISSN: 1474547X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(15)01091-0     Document Type: Review

References (87)

1. 1 Bell, EHCM, Storming the Citadel. The rise of the woman doctor, 1953, Constable, London.
2. 2 Elston, MA, Women and medicine: the future, 2009, Royal College of Physicians, London.
3. 3 Lautenberger, DM, Dandar, VM, Raezer, CL, Sloane, RA, The state of women in academic medicine: the pipeline and pathways to leadership, 2013-2014. https://www.aamc.org/members/gwims/statistics/, 2014 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
4. 4 Centre for Workforce Intelligence. Shape of the medical workforce: starting the debate on the future consultant workforce. http://www.cfwi.org.uk/publications/leaders-report-shape-of-the-medical-workforce/attachment.pdf, 2012 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
5. 5 Medical Schools Council. A survey of staffing levels of medical clinical academics in UK medical schools as at 31 July 2013. http://www.medschools.ac.uk/AboutUs/Projects/Documents/2014-Clinical-Academic-Survey-Medicine-July-2013-data.pdf, 2014 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
6. 6 Association of American Medical Colleges, Group on Women in Medicine and Science. Table 1: Medical Students, Selected Years, 1965-2013. https://www.aamc.org/download/411782/data/2014_table1.pdf, 2014 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
7. 7 Medical Schools Council. A survey of staffing levels of medical clinical academics in UK medical schools as at 31 July 2014. http://www.medschools.ac.uk/SiteCollectionDocuments/MSC-survey-2015-web.pdf, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
8. 8 Shah, DN, Volpe, NJ, Abbuhl, SB, Pietrobon, R, Shah, A, Gender characteristics among academic ophthalmology leadership, faculty, and residents: results from a cross-sectional survey. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 17 (2010), 1–6.
9. 9 Carnes, M, Morrissey, C, Geller, SE, Women's health and women's leadership in academic medicine: Hitting the same glass ceiling?. J Womens Health 17 (2008), 1453–1462.
10. 10 Penny, M, Jeffries, R, Grant, J, Davies, SC, Women and academic medicine: a review of the evidence on female representation. J R Soc Med 107 (2014), 259–263.
11. 11 Tugwell, P, The campaign to revitalise academic medicine kicks off. Lancet, 363, 2004, 836.
12. 12 National Science Foundation. ADVANCE: Increasing the Participation and Advancement of Women in Academic Science and Engineering Careers (ADVANCE). http://www.nsf.gov/advance/, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
13. 13 National Initiative on Gender CaLiMC-C. About C-Change. http://www.brandeis.edu/cchange/about/index.html, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
14. 14 National Institutes of Health. Promoting innovation in diversity. https://diversity.nih.gov/, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
15. 15 Medical Schools Council. Women in clinical academia: attracting and developing the medical and dental workforce of the future. A report by the Medical Schools Council. http://www.medschools.ac.uk/AboutUs/Projects/clinicalacademia/Pages/Women-in-Clinical-Academia.aspx, 2007 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
16. 16 British Medical Association. Women in academic medicine: developing equality in governance and management for career progression. Full report. http://bma.org.uk/-/media/files/pdfs/about%20the%20bma/how%20we%20work/medical%20academics/womenacademicmedicineapril2008.pdf, 2008 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
17. 17 Academy of Medical Sciences. About the INSPIRE initiative. http://www.acmedsci.ac.uk/careers/mentoring-and-careers/INSPIRE/about-INSPIRE/, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
18. 18 Academy of Medical Sciences. SUSTAIN. http://www.acmedsci.ac.uk/careers/mentoring-and-careers/sustain/, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
19. 19 Davies, SC, Letter. http://www.medschools.ac.uk/SiteCollectionDocuments/Letter_from_Dame_Sally_Davies_-_Women_in_Science.pdf, 2011 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
20. 20 Equality Challenge Unit. Athena SWAN Charter. http://www.ecu.ac.uk/equality-charters/athena-swan/, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
21. 21 Straus, SE, Straus, C, Tzanetos, K, Career choice in academic medicine: systematic review. J Gen Intern Med 21 (2006), 1222–1229.
22. 22 Borges, NJ, Navarro, AM, Grover, A, Hoban, JD, How, when, and why do physicians choose careers in academic medicine? A literature review. Acad Med 85 (2010), 680–686.
23. 23 Abu-Zaid, A, Altinawi, B, Perceived barriers to physician-scientist careers among female undergraduate medical students at the College of Medicine-Alfaisal University: a Saudi Arabian perspective. Med Teach 36 (2014), S3–S7.
24. 24 Andriole, DA, Whelan, AJ, Jeffe, DB, Characteristics and career intentions of the emerging MD/PhD workforce. JAMA 300 (2008), 1165–1173.
25. 25 Andriole, DA, Jeffe, DB, Hageman, HL, et al. Variables associated with full-time faculty appointment among contemporary U.S. medical school graduates: Implications for academic medicine workforce diversity. Acad Med 85 (2010), 1250–1257.
26. 26 Andriole, DA, Jeffe, DB, The road to an academic medicine career: a national cohort study of male and female U.S. medical graduates. Acad Med 87 (2012), 1722–1733.
27. 27 Benson, MC, Linn, L, Ward, N, Wells, KB, Brook, RH, Leake, B, Career orientations of medical and pediatric residents. Med Care 23 (1985), 1256–1264.
28. 28 Bickel, J, Ruffin, A, Gender-associated differences in matriculating and graduating medical students. Acad Med 70 (1995), 552–559.
29. 29 Borges, NJ, Navarro, AM, Grover, AC, Women physicians: choosing a career in academic medicine. Acad Med 87 (2012), 105–114.
30. 30 Borges, NJ, Grover, AC, Navarro, AM, Raque-Bogdan, TL, Elton, C, International women physicians' on choosing an academic medicine career. Perspect Med Edu 2 (2013), 156–161.
31. 31 Brass, LF, Akabas, MH, Burnley, LD, Engman, DM, Wiley, CA, Andersen, OS, Are MD-PhD programs meeting their goals? An analysis of career choices made by graduates of 24 MD-PhD programs. Acad Med 85 (2010), 692–701.
32. 32 Bright, CM, Duefield, CA, Stone, VE, Perceived barriers and biases in the medical education experience by gender and race. J Natl Med Assoc 90 (1998), 681–688.
33. 33 Buddeberg-Fischer, B, Stamm, M, Buddeberg, C, Klaghofer, R, Career-success scale—a new instrument to assess young physicians' academic career steps. BMC Health Serv Res, 8, 2008, 120.
34. 34 Burgoyne, LN, O'Flynn, S, Boylan, GB, Undergraduate medical research: the student perspective. Med Educ Online, 2010, 15.
35. 35 Cain, JM, Schulkin, J, Parisi, V, Power, ML, Holzman, GB, Williams, S, Effects of perceptions and mentorship on pursuing a career in academic medicine in obstetrics and gynecology. Acad Med 76 (2001), 628–634.
36. 36 Cochran, A, Hauschild, T, Elder, WB, Neumayer, LA, Brasel, KJ, Crandall, ML, Perceived gender-based barriers to careers in academic surgery. Am J Surg 206 (2013), 263–268.
37. 37 Coleman, VH, Power, ML, Williams, S, Carpentieri, A, Schulkin, J, Continuing professional development: racial and gender differences in obstetrics and gynecology residents' perceptions of mentoring. J Contin Educ Health Prof 25 (2005), 268–277.
38. 38 Corrigan, MA, Shields, CJ, Redmond, HP, Factors influencing surgical career choices and advancement in Ireland and Britain. World J Surg 31 (2007), 1921–1929.
39. 39 Danczyk, RC, Sevdalis, N, Woo, K, et al. Factors affecting career choice among the next generation of academic vascular surgeons. J Vasc Surg, 55, 2012, 1509 14.e7.
40. 40 Donovan, A, Views of radiology program directors on the role of mentorship in the training of radiology residents. Am J Roentgenol 194 (2010), 704–708.
41. 41 Dorsey, ER, Raphael, BA, Balcer, LJ, Galetta, SL, Predictors of future publication record and academic rank in a cohort of neurology residents. Neurology 67 (2006), 1335–1337.
42. 42 Fang, D, Meyer, RE, Effect of two Howard Hughes Medical Institute Research Training Programs for medical students on the likelihood of pursuing research careers. Acad Med 78 (2003), 1271–1280.
43. 43 Freiman, A, Barzilai, DA, Barankin, B, Natsheh, A, Shear, NH, National appraisal of dermatology residency training: a Canadian study. Arch Dermatol 141 (2005), 1100–1104.
44. 44 Galletly, C, Chur-Hansen, A, Air, T, Chapman, I, Academics of the future? A survey of final year medical students. Australas Psychiatry 17 (2009), 502–505.
45. 45 Gerson, LB, Twomey, K, Hecht, G, et al. Does gender affect career satisfaction and advancement in gastroenterology? Results of an AGA institute-sponsored survey. Gastroenterology 132 (2007), 1598–1606.
46. 46 Golub, JS, Ossoff, RH, Johns Iii, MM, Fellowship and career path preferences in residents of otolaryngology-head and neck surgery. Laryngoscope 121 (2011), 882–887.
47. 47 Gordon, MB, Osganian, SK, Emans, SJ, Lovejoy, FH Jr, Gender differences in research grant applications for pediatric residents. Pediatrics 124 (2009), e355–e361.
48. 48 Guelich, JM, Singer, BH, Castro, MC, Rosenberg, LE, A gender gap in the next generation of physician-scientists: Medical student interest and participation in research. J Investig Med 50 (2002), 412–418.
49. 49 Haviland, MG, Yamagata, H, Werner, LS, Zhang, K, Dial, TH, Sonne, JL, Student mistreatment in medical school and planning a career in academic medicine. Teach Learn Med 23 (2011), 231–237.
50. 50 Heathcote, J, Cauch-Dudek, K, Rhyne, D, The professional lives of women in gastroenterology: a Canadian comparison study with men. Gastroenterology 113 (1997), 669–674.
51. 51 Jeffe, DB, Andriole, DA, Hageman, HL, Whelan, AJ, Reaping what we sow: the emerging academic medicine workforce. J Natl Med Assoc 100 (2008), 1026–1034.
52. 52 Jeffe, DB, Andriole, DA, A national cohort study of MD-PhD graduates of medical schools with and without funding from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences' Medical Scientist Training Program. Acad Med 86 (2011), 953–961.
53. 53 Jeffe, DB, Andriole, DA, Wathington, HD, Tai, RH, Educational outcomes for students enrolled in MD-PhD programs at medical school matriculation, 1995-2000: a national cohort study. Acad Med 89 (2014), 84–93.
54. 54 Jeffe, DB, Andriole, DA, Wathington, HD, Tai, RH, The emerging physician-scientist workforce: demographic, experiential, and attitudinal predictors of MD-PhD program enrollment. Acad Med 89 (2014), 1398–1407.
55. 55 Komaromy, M, Bindman, AB, Haber, RJ, Sande, MA, Sexual harassment in medical training. N Engl J Med 328 (1993), 322–326.
56. 56 Kong, X, Trajectory of medical students' research interest by gender, race/ethnicity, research experience, and program: a longitudinal analysis. http://libra.virginia.edu/catalog/libra-oa:6454, 2014 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
57. 57 Lanzon, J, Edwards, SP, Inglehart, MR, Choosing academia versus private practice: Factors affecting oral maxillofacial surgery residents' career choices. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 70 (2012), 1751–1761.
58. 58 Larsson, C, Hensing, G, Allebeck, P, Sexual and gender-related harassment in medical education and research training: Results from a Swedish survey. Med Educ 37 (2003), 39–50.
59. 59 Leonard, JC, Ellsbury, KE, Gender and interest in academic careers among first- and third-year residents. Acad Med 71 (1996), 502–504.
60. 60 Ley, TJ, Rosenberg, LE, The physician-scientist career pipeline in 2005: build it, and they will come. JAMA 294 (2005), 1343–1351.
61. 61 McDonald, A, Paterson, H, Herbison, P, Registrar interest in academic obstetrics and gynaecology: a cross-sectional survey. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol 52 (2012), 476–482.
62. 62 McGinty, KL, Martin, CA, Demoss, KL, Hill, KK, Future career choices of women psychiatric residents: is research included?. Acad Psychiatry 18 (1994), 95–102.
63. 63 Nikkar-Esfahani, A, Jamjoom, AAB, Fitzgerald, JEF, Extracurricular participation in research and audit by medical students: Opportunities, obstacles, motivation and outcomes. Med Teach 34 (2012), e317–e324.
64. 64 Nomura, K, Yano, E, Fukui, T, Gender differences in clinical confidence: a nationwide survey of resident physicians in Japan. Acad Med 85 (2010), 647–653.
65. 65 Osborn, EHS, Ernster, VL, Martin, JB, Women's attitudes toward careers in academic medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. Acad Med 67 (1992), 59–62.
66. 66 Pincus, S, Women in academic dermatology. Results of survey from the professors of dermatology. Arch Dermatol 130 (1994), 1131–1135.
67. 67 Primack, BA, Dilmore, TC, Switzer, GE, et al. Burnout among early career clinical investigators. Clin Transl Sci 3 (2010), 186–188.
68. 68 Salgueira, A, Costa, P, Goncalves, M, Magalhaes, E, Costa, MJ, Individual characteristics and student's engagement in scientific research: a cross-sectional study. BMC Med Educ, 12, 2012, 95.
69. 69 Silberman, EK, Belitsky, R, Bernstein, CA, et al. Recruiting researchers in psychiatry: the influence of residency vs. early motivation. Acad Psychiatry 36 (2012), 85–90.
70. 70 Smith, WH, Rogers, JG, Hansen, TN, Smith, CV, Early career development in academic pediatrics of participants in the APS-SPR medical student research program. Pediatr Res 65 (2009), 474–477.
71. 71 Smith, F, Lambert, TW, Goldacre, MJ, Demographic characteristics of doctors who intend to follow clinical academic careers: UK national questionnaire surveys. Postgrad Med J 90 (2014), 557–564.
72. 72 Watt, CD, Greeley, SAW, Shea, JA, Ahn, J, Educational views and attitudes, and career goals of MD-PhD students at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. Acad Med 80 (2005), 193–198.
73. 73 Yamazaki, Y, Uka, T, Shimizu, H, Miyahira, A, Sakai, T, Marui, E, Characteristics of physicians engaged in basic science: a questionnaire survey of physicians in basic science departments of a medical school in Japan. Tohoku J Exp Med 228 (2012), 75–82.
74. 74 Yang, G, Villalta, JD, Weiss, DA, Carroll, PR, Breyer, BN, Gender differences in academic productivity and academic career choice among urology residents. J Urol 188 (2012), 1286–1290.
75. 75 Beddoes K, Schimpf CT, Pawley A. Engaging Foucault to better understand underrepresentation of female STEM faculty. Paper ID#5863. The ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition; Atlanta, GA, USA; 2013.
76. 76 Mendick, H, Social class, gender and the pace of academic life: what kind of solution is slow? Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research. http://www.qualitative-research.net/index.php/fqs/article/view/2224, 2014 (accessed June 15, 2015).
77. 77 World Bank. Country and lending groups. http://data.worldbank.org/about/country-and-lending-groups, 2015 (accessed Oct 20, 2015).
78. 78 Jagsi, R, Butterton, JR, Starr, R, Tarbell, NJ, A targeted intervention for the career development of women in academic medicine. Arch Intern Med 167 (2007), 343–345.
79. 79 Caniano, DA, Sonnino, RE, Paolo, AM, Keys to career satisfaction: Insights from a survey of women pediatric surgeons. J Pediatr Surg 39 (2004), 984–990.
80. 80 Tacconelli, E, Poljak, M, Cacace, M, et al. Science without meritocracy. Discrimination among European specialists in infectious diseases and clinical microbiology: a questionnaire survey. BMJ Open, 2012, 2.
81. 81 Sambunjak, D, Straus, SE, Marusic, A, Mentoring in academic medicine: a systematic review. JAMA 296 (2006), 1103–1115.
82. 82 Craig, L, Mullan, K, How mothers and fathers share childcare: a cross-national time-use comparison. Am Sociol Rev 76 (2011), 834–861.
83. 83 Schroen, AT, Brownstein, MR, Sheldon, GF, Women in academic general surgery. Acad Med 79 (2004), 310–318.
84. 84 Ovseiko, PV, Buchan, AM, Organizational culture in an academic health center: an exploratory study using a Competing Values Framework. Acad Med 87 (2012), 709–718.
85. 85 Burgess, DJ, Joseph, A, van Ryn, M, Carnes, M, Does stereotype threat affect women in academic medicine?. Acad Med 87 (2012), 506–512.
86. 86 Pololi, LH, Civian, JT, Brennan, RT, Dottolo, AL, Krupat, E, Experiencing the culture of academic medicine: gender matters, a national study. J Gen Intern Med 28 (2013), 201–207.
87. 87 Krupat, E, Pololi, L, Schnell, ER, Kern, DE, Changing the culture of academic medicine: the C-Change learning action network and its impact at participating medical schools. Acad Med 88 (2013), 1252–1258.