Manufacturing consent in cyberspace: China’s “Fifty-Cent Army”

Journal of Current Chinese Affairs

Volumn 44, Issue 2, 2015, Pages 105-134

  Han, Rongbin ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA   (United States)

Author keywords

China; Discourse competition; Internet commentators; Political astroturfing

Indexed keywords

EID: 84962356052     PISSN: 18681026     EISSN: 18684874     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/186810261504400205     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Anonymous 1 (2009), interview, student internet commentator, Beijing, 21 September.
2. Anonymous 2 (2009), interview, BBS forum managers, Beijing, 21 October.
3. Anonymous 3 (2009), interview, BBS forum managers, Suzhou, 24 October.
4. Bandurski, David (2008), China’s Guerrilla War for the Web, in: Far Eastern Economic Review, 171, 6, 41–44.
5. Bao, Qian (2009), (Shanghai shizhengfu jieru diaoyu zhifa shijian, Shanghai Municipal Government Steps in Illegal Cab Entrapment Case), in: (Fazhi Ribao, Legal Daily), 19 October.
6. Barboza, David (2011), China Leader Encourages Criticism of Government, in: New York Times, 27 January.
7. Boas, Taylor (2006), Weaving the Authoritarian Web: The Control of Internet Use in Nondemocratic Regimes, in: John Zysman and Abraham Newman (eds), How Revolutionary was the Digital Revolution? National Responses, Market Transitions, and Global Technology, Stanford: Stanford University Press, 361–378.
8. Cai, Xiaoquan (2005), (Suqian 26 wangpingyuan jin shanggang, Twenty-Six Internet Commentators in Position Today), in: (Yangzi Wanbao, Yangtse Evening Post), 29 April.
9. Cao, Li (2009), Building Collapse: Nine under Probe, in: China Daily, 30 June.
10. Ccthere Community (2011), (Nayou shenme kuzhong, nayou shenme hongshui mengshou, Where are those Hard-to-Explain Difficulties, where are those Dreadful Monsters), online: (20 July 2012).
11. Chen, Cheng, Kui Wu, Venkatesh Srinivasan, and Xudong Zhang (2011), Battling the Internet Water Army: Detection of Hidden Paid Posters, online: (20 February 2015).
12. Chen, Kai (2007), (Zhuoyan jiaqiang wangluo yulun yindao, tigao qingnian wangxuan shuiping, Focus on Strengthening Online Opinion Guidance, Promote Youth Internet Propaganda), online: (25 September 2012).
13. Chen, Xueyi, and Tianjian Shi (2001), Media Effects on Political Confidence and Trust in the PRC in the Post-Tiananmen Period, in: East Asia: An International Quarterly, 19, 3, 84–118.
14. China Digital Times (2011), Video: Xishui’s Fifty Cent Party Internal Training, online: (1 December 2011).
15. China Media Project (2010), Venting Mechanisms, online: (20 July 2012).
16. Damm, Jens (2007), The Internet and the Fragmentation of Chinese Society, in: Critical Asian Studies, 39, 2, 273–294.
17. Damm, Jens (2006), China’s E-policy: Examples of Local E-government in Guangdong and Fujian, in: Jens Damm and Simona Thomas (eds), Chinese Cyberspaces: Technological Changes and Political Effects, New York: Routledge, 102–131.
18. Boas, Taylor (2006), Weaving the Authoritarian Web: The Control of Internet Use in Nondemocratic Regimes, in: John Zysman and Abraham Newman (eds), How Revolutionary was the Digital Revolution? National Responses, Market Transitions, and Global Technology, Stanford: Stanford University Press, 361–378.
19. Cai, Xiaoquan (2005), (Suqian 26 wangpingyuan jin shanggang, Twenty-Six Internet Commentators in Position Today), in: (Yangzi Wanbao, Yangtse Evening Post), 29 April.
20. Cao, Li (2009), Building Collapse: Nine under Probe, in: China Daily, 30 June.
21. Ccthere Community (2011), (Nayou shenme kuzhong, nayou shenme hongshui mengshou, Where are those Hard-to-Explain Difficulties, where are those Dreadful Monsters), online: (20 July 2012).
22. Chen, Cheng, Kui Wu, Venkatesh Srinivasan, and Xudong Zhang (2011), Battling the Internet Water Army: Detection of Hidden Paid Posters, online: (20 February 2015).
23. Chen, Kai (2007), (Zhuoyan jiaqiang wangluo yulun yindao, tigao qingnian wangxuan shuiping, Focus on Strengthening Online Opinion Guidance, Promote Youth Internet Propaganda), online: (25 September 2012).
24. Chen, Xueyi, and Tianjian Shi (2001), Media Effects on Political Confidence and Trust in the PRC in the Post-Tiananmen Period, in: East Asia: An International Quarterly, 19, 3, 84–118.
25. China Digital Times (2011), Video: Xishui’s Fifty Cent Party Internal Training, online: (1 December 2011).
26. China Media Project (2010), Venting Mechanisms, online: (20 July 2012).
27. Damm, Jens (2007), The Internet and the Fragmentation of Chinese Society, in: Critical Asian Studies, 39, 2, 273–294.
28. Damm, Jens (2006), China’s E-policy: Examples of Local E-government in Guangdong and Fujian, in: Jens Damm and Simona Thomas (eds), Chinese Cyberspaces: Technological Changes and Political Effects, New York: Routledge, 102–131.
29. Hengyang Wanbao (Hengyang Evening News) (2009), (Hengyang dangjianwang shouhuo rongyu yichuan, Hengyang Party Building Web Receives a Series of Honors), 17 April.
30. Hong, Yanqing (2009), (Wo qu shouci zuzhi wangpingyuan peixun, Our District Organizes First Internet Commentators Training), in: Jiangdong Today, 27 October, (20 June 2012).
31. Hou, Kai (2009), (Wuchu bu zai de wumao dang, Omnipresent Fifty-Cent Party), online: (25 July 2010).
32. Hu, Yong (2008), (Zhongsheng xuanhua: wangluo shidai de geren biaoda yu gonggong taolun, The Rising Cacophony: Personal Expression and Public Discussion in the Internet Age), Nanning: (Guanxi Shifan Daxue chubanshe, Guangxi Normal University Press).
33. Hung, Chin-Fu (2010), China’s Propaganda in the Information Age: Internet Commentators and Weng’an Incident, in: Issues & Studies, 46, 4, 149–181.
34. Jacobs, Andrew (2009), China Requires Censorship Software on New PCs, in: New York Times, 8 June.
35. Jiang, Min, and Heng Xu (2009), Exploring Online Structures on Chinese Government Portals: Citizen Political Participation and Government Legitimation, in: Social Science Computer Review, 27, 2, 174–195.
36. Jincheng Xinwenwang (Jincheng News Web) (2006), (Shanxi sheng shoupi wangluo bianji he wangluo pinglunyuan peixunban xueyuan zhengshi zai bing jieye, Commencement of Shanxi Province’s First Training Class of Internet Editors and Commentators), online: (20 July 2012).
37. July 1 Community (Qi Yi Shequ) (2010), 2009 Dangwang 2009 niandu youxiu tongxunyuan, shida wangpingren pingxuan, Please Vote for Outstanding Correspondents and Top 10 Internet Commentators of Party Web in 2009, online: (1 February 2011).
38. Kalathil, Shanthi, and Taylor C. Boas (2003), Open Networks Closed Regimes: The Impact of the Internet on Authoritarian Rule, Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
39. Kennedy, John (2009), Maintaining Popular Support for the Chinese Communist Party: The Influence of Education and the State- Controlled Media, in: Political Studies, 57, 3, 517–536.
40. King, Gary, Jennifer Pan, and Molly Roberts (2013), How Censorship in China Allows Government Criticism but Silences Collective Expression, in: American Political Science Review, 107, 2, 1–18.
41. Kong, Pu (2008), (Jiemi wangluo weiji gongguan, Deciphering Online Crises Management), in (Xin Shiji Zhoukan, News Magazine), 340, 28, 62–63.
42. Lagerkvist, Johan (2010), After the Internet, Before Democracy, New York: Peter Lang.
43. Lagerkvist, Johan (2008), Internet Ideotainment in the PRC: National Responses to Cultural Globalization, in: Journal of Contemporary China, 17, 54, 121–140.
44. Lagerkvist, Johan (2007), The Internet in China: Unlocking and Containing the Public Sphere, Lund: Lund University.
45. Lei, Ya-Wen (2011), The Political Consequences of the Rise of the Internet: Political Beliefs and Practices of Chinese Netizens, in: Political Communication, 28, 3, 291–322.
46. Li, Cheng (2012), The End of the CCP’s Resilient Authoritarianism? A Tripartite Assessment of Shifting Power in China, in: The China Quarterly, 211, 595–623.
47. Lin, Qiling (2011), (Tianya chengren bufen yonghu mima xielou, Tianya Admits User Data Leakage), in: (Xin Jingbao, Beijing News), 26 December.
48. Lorentzen, Peter (2013), Regularizing Rioting: Permitting Public Protest in an Authoritarian Regime, in: Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 8, 127–158.
49. Ma, Yanjun (2004), (Zhongyang jiwei gaodu zhongshi wangluo pinglun gongzuo, Central Commission for Discipline Inspection Attaches Much Importance to Online Commendatory Work), online: (20 July 2012).
50. MacKinnon, Rebecca (2009), The Green Dam Phenomenon: Governments Everywhere Are Treading on Web Freedoms, in: Wall Street Journal Asia, 18 June, online: (20 July 2012).
51. Nanfang Dushibao (Southern Metropolis Daily) (2010), 650 (Gansu jiang jian 650 ren wangping duiwu tixi, Gansu Province Will Set Up an Internet Commentator Troop with 650 Members), 20 January.
52. Nathan, Andrew J. (2003), Authoritarian Resilience, in: Journal of Democracy, 14, 1, 6–17.
53. Newsmth (Shuimu Shequ) (2007) (Shuimu shequ zhanghao guanli banfa, NEWSMTH ID Management Rules), online: (1 March 2015).
54. News.163.com (Wang Yi Xinwen Luntan) (2013), (Huati: gongsufang: Bo Xilai ju bu renzui bixu congyan chengchu, Topic: The Prosecution: Bo Xilai Denies Charges, Must Be Severely Punished), online: (30 August 2013).
55. Popular Computer Weekly Microblog (Diannaobao Weibo) (2011), (Jinqi puchu le shishang zuida xiemi an, The Largest Scale of Data Leakage Case in History Exposed Recently), online: (10 November 2014).
56. Qian, Yanfeng (2010), Shanghai Residents Fight Forced Demolitions, in: China Daily, 26 February, online: (20 July 2012).
57. Qingyang Dangwugongkaiwang (Qingyang Party Affairs Web) (2009), (Qingyangqu jianli wangpingyuan duiwu, Qingyang District Establishes Internet Commentators Troops), online: (1 December 2009).
58. Red Net BBS (Hongwang Luntan) (2008), (Hengyangshi xuanchuan zhanxian “jiefang sixiang dajiatan” ji “wenji wangmin” taolun zhuantie, Hengyang Municipal Propaganda Branch “Big Discussion on Liberating Thoughts” Special Thread), online: (26 February 2011).
59. Richburg, Keith B. (2009), China’s “Netizens” Holding Officials Accountable, in: The Washington Post, 9 November, online: (20 July 2012).
60. Roberts, Dexter (2008), Inside the War against China’s Blogs, in: Businessweek, 12 June.
61. Shambaugh, David (2008), China’s Communist Party: Atrophy and Adaptation, Berkeley: University of California Press.
62. Shanghai Communist Youth League (2010), 2009 (Shiji jiguan tuangongwei 2009 niandu gongzuo zongjie, 2009 Annual Report of Shanghai Municipal Communist Youth League Work Committee), online: (25 January 2010).
63. Stern, Rachel, and Kevin O’Brien (2012), Politics at the Boundary: Mixed Signals and the Chinese State, in: Modern China, 38, 2, 175–199.
64. Stockmann, Daniela (2013), Media Commercialization and Authoritarian Rule in China, New York: Cambridge University Press.
65. Thornton, Patricia (2008), Manufacturing Dissent in Transnational China, in: Kevin J. O’Brien (ed.), Popular Protest in China, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 179–204.
66. Tong, Yanqi, and Shaohua Lei (2013), War of Position and Microblogging in China, in: Journal of Contemporary China, 22, 80, 292–311.
67. Unknown Space (Weiming Kongjian) (2010), (Jinian tuoli wumaodang liang zhounian, Memorial of the Two Years Anniversary since Quitting the Fifty-Cent Army), online: (20 July 2012).
68. Wang, Xing (2011), (Zhongshihua beibao zuzhi renyuan zai wangshang xuanchuan zhangjia heli, Sinopec Exposed for Organizing Personnel to Justify Price Increase Online), in: (Nanfang Dushibao, Southern Metropolis Daily), 13 February.
69. Wen, Jiabao (2010), Interview with Fareed Zakaria, in: CNN Global Public Square, 3 October.
70. Wen, Yunchao (2008), (Shouquan fabu: dalu wangluo pinglunyuan jianru gongzhong shiye, Authorized Release: China’s Internet Commentators Gradually Gaining Public Sight), online: (22 September 2011).
71. Xinkuaibao (New Express) (2010), (Wu Hao Renda yanjiang bei reng wumao zhibi, Wu Hao was Thrown 50-Cent Notes when Giving a Talk at Renmin University), 23 April.
72. Yang, Guobin (2009), The Power of the Internet in China: Citizen Activism Online, New York: Columbia University Press.
73. Yang, Guobin (2003), The Internet and the Rise of a Transnational Chinese Cultural Sphere, in: Media, Culture & Society, 25, 4, 469–490.
74. Ye, Juliet (2009), Online Ambassador: Chinese Province to Appoint “Internet Spokesperson”, in: China Realtime Report, 7 July.
75. Zhang, Lei (2010a), Invisible Footprints of Online Commentators, online: (20 July 2012).
76. Zhang, Lei (2010b), (Wumaodang de wangluo jianghu, The Cyberspace Rivers and Lakes of the Fifty-Cent Party), in: (Changcheng Yuebao, Changcheng News Digest), September.
77. Zhang, Shengjun (2010), “(“Wumaodang” maozi neng xiazhu shui?, Who is Afraid of Being Labelled as “Fifty-Cent Army?”), online: (20 November 2011).
78. Zhao, Yuezhi (2012), The Struggle for Socialism in China: The Bo Xilai Saga and Beyond, in: Monthly Review, 64, 5, 1–17.
79. Zhao, Yuezhi (1997), Toward a Propaganda/Commercial Model of Journalism in China? The Case of the Beijing Youth News, in: International Communication Gazette, 58, 143–157.
80. Zhejiang Zaixian (Zhejiang Online) (2008), (Zhejiang Zaixian shijia banzhu, shijia boke, shijia wangpingyuan pingxuan huodong, Selection of Top 10 Board Managers, Top 10 Bloggers, and Top 10 Internet Commentators of Zhejiang Online), online: (20 July 2012).
81. Zhonggong Hefei Shiwei Xuanchuanbu (Propaganda Department of CCP Hefei Municipal Committee) (2006), (Guanyu Nanchang, Changsha, Zhengzhou xuanchuan wenhua gongzuo de kaocha baogao, Research Report on Propaganda Cultural Work of Nanchang, Changshang and Zhengzhou), online: (25 August 2010).
82. Zhonggong Hengyang Shiwei Xuanchuanbu (Propaganda Department of CCP Hengyang Municipal Committee) (2008), (Gewei wangpingyuan qing zhuyi: jinji renwu!!!, Attention Online Commentators, Urgent Task!!!), online: (20 June 2009).
83. Zhonggong Zhengding Xianwei Xuanchuanbu (Propaganda Department of CCP Zhengding County Committee) (2009), (Guanyu zhaopin hulianwang wangluo xuanchuan pinglunyuan de tongzhi, Circular on Recruiting Internet Commentators by Propaganda Department of CCP Zhengding County Committee), online: (21 November 2009).