Systematic reviews and meta-analyses of the accuracy of HPV tests, visual inspection with acetic acid, cytology, and colposcopy

International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics

Volumn 132, Issue 3, 2016, Pages 259-265

  Mustafa, Reem A ^a,b   Santesso, Nancy ^b   Khatib, Rasha ^b,c   Mustafa, Ahmad A ^d   Wiercioch, Wojtek ^b   Kehar, Rohan ^b   Gandhi, Shreyas ^b   Chen, Yaolong ^e   Cheung, Adrienne ^f   Hopkins, Jessica ^b   Ma, Bin ^e   Lloyd, Nancy ^b   Wu, Darong ^g   Broutet, Nathalie ^h   Schünemann, Holger J ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI KANSAS CITY   (United States)

^b MCMASTER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^c MCMASTER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^d JORDAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY   (Jordan)

^e LANZHOU UNIVERSITY   (China)

^f UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA   (Canada)

^g GUANGZHOU UNIVERSITY OF CHINESE MEDICINE   (China)

^h WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Cervical intraepithelial neoplasia; Cervical smear; Colposcopy; Cytology; HPV; Meta analysis; Review; Visual inspection with acetic acid

Indexed keywords

ACETIC ACID;

CANCER SCREENING; COLPOSCOPY; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DIAGNOSTIC TEST ACCURACY STUDY; FEMALE; HPV TEST; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; SERODIAGNOSIS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; UTERINE CERVIX CANCER; UTERINE CERVIX CYTOLOGY; CERVICAL INTRAEPITHELIAL NEOPLASIA; EARLY CANCER DIAGNOSIS; ISOLATION AND PURIFICATION; PAPANICOLAOU TEST; PAPILLOMAVIRIDAE; PROCEDURES; STANDARDS; UTERINE CERVICAL NEOPLASMS; VAGINA SMEAR;

ACETIC ACID; CERVICAL INTRAEPITHELIAL NEOPLASIA; COLPOSCOPY; EARLY DETECTION OF CANCER; FEMALE; HUMANS; PAPANICOLAOU TEST; PAPILLOMAVIRIDAE; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; UTERINE CERVICAL NEOPLASMS; VAGINAL SMEARS;

EID: 84959098449     PISSN: 00207292     EISSN: 18793479     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijgo.2015.07.024     Document Type: Review

References (40)

1. J. Ferlay, I. Soerjomataram, M. Ervik, R. Dikshit, S. Eser, C. Mathers, and et al. GLOBOCAN 2012 v1.0, Cancer Incidence and Mortality Worldwide: IARC CancerBase No. 11 2013 International Agency for Research on Cancer Lyon, France
2. H.J. Schünemann, R. Mustafa, and J. Brozek Diagnostic accuracy and linked evidence - testing the chain [in German] Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes 106 3 2012 153 160
3. N. Santesso, R.A. Mustafa, H.J. Schünemann, M. Arbyn, P.D. Blumenthal, J. Cain, and et al. World Health Organization Guidelines: Treatment of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 2-3 and Screen and Treat strategies to prevent cervical cancer Int J Gynecol Obstet 132 3 2016 252 258
4. G. Koliopoulos, M. Arbyn, P.P.L. Martin-Hirsch, M. Kyrgiou, W.J.P. Prendiville, and E. Paraskevaidis Cytology versus HPV testing for cervical cancer screening in the general population Cochrane Libr 7 2010 CD008587
5. L. Irwig, P. Bossuyt, P. Glasziou, C. Gatsonis, and J. Lijmer Designing studies to ensure that estimates of test accuracy are transferable BMJ 324 7338 2002 669 671
6. P. Whiting, A.W. Rutjes, J.B. Reitsma, P.M. Bossuyt, and J. Kleijnen The development of QUADAS: a tool for the quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy included in systematic reviews BMC Med Res Methodol 3 2003 25
7. H.J. Schünemann, A.D. Oxman, J. Brozek, P. Glasziou, R. Jaeschke, G.E. Vist, and et al. Grading quality of evidence and strength of recommendations for diagnostic tests and strategies BMJ 336 7653 2008 1106 1110
8. J. Belinson, Y.L. Qiao, R. Pretorius, W.H. Zhang, P. Elson, L. Li, and et al. Shanxi Province Cervical Cancer Screening Study: a cross-sectional comparative trial of multiple techniques to detect cervical neoplasia Gynecol Oncol 83 2 2001 439 444
9. H. De Vuyst, P. Claeys, S. Njiru, L. Muchiri, S. Steyaert, P. De Sutter, and et al. Comparison of pap smear, visual inspection with acetic acid, human papillomavirus DNA-PCR testing and cervicography Int J Gynecol Obstet 89 2 2005 120 126
10. Y.L. Qiao, J.W. Sellors, P.S. Eder, Y.P. Bao, J.M. Lim, F.H. Zhao, and et al. A new HPV-DNA test for cervical-cancer screening in developing regions: a cross-sectional study of clinical accuracy in rural China Lancet Oncol 9 10 2008 929 936
11. S.S. Shastri, K. Dinshaw, G. Amin, S. Goswami, S. Patil, R. Chinoy, and et al. Concurrent evaluation of visual, cytological and HPV testing as screening methods for the early detection of cervical neoplasia in Mumbai, India Bull World Health Organ 83 3 2005 186 194
12. P. Sodhani, S. Gupta, J.K. Sharma, A. Parashari, K. Halder, V. Singh, and et al. Test characteristics of various screening modalities for cervical cancer: a feasibility study to develop an alternative strategy for resource-limited settings Cytopathology 17 6 2006 348 352
13. M. Cremer, E. Conlisk, M. Maza, K. Bullard, E. Peralta, M. Siedhoff, and et al. Adequacy of visual inspection with acetic acid in women of advancing age Int J Gynecol Obstet 113 1 2011 68 71
14. L. Elit, G. Baigal, J. Tan, and A. Munkhtaivan Assessment of 2 cervical screening methods in Mongolia: cervical cytology and visual inspection with acetic acid J Low Genit Tract Dis 10 2 2006 83 88
15. F. Ghaemmaghami, N. Behtash, M.M. Gilani, A. Mousavi, M. Marjani, and R. Moghimi Visual inspection with acetic acid as a feasible screening test for cervical neoplasia in Iran Int J Gynecol Cancer 14 3 2004 465 469
16. A. Goel, G. Gandhi, S. Batra, S. Bhambhani, V. Zutshi, and P. Sachdeva Visual inspection of the cervix with acetic acid for cervical intraepithelial lesions Int J Gynecol Obstet 88 1 2005 25 30
17. D. Hedge, H. Shetty, P.K. Shetty, and S. Rai Diagnostic value of acetic acid comparing with conventional Pap smear in the detection of colposcopic biopsy-proved CIN J Cancer Res Ther 7 4 2011 454 458
18. V.V. Sahasrabuddhe, R.A. Bhosale, A.N. Kavatkar, C.A. Nagwanshi, S.N. Joshi, C.A. Jenkins, and et al. Comparison of visual inspection with acetic acid and cervical cytology to detect high-grade cervical neoplasia among HIV-infected women in India Int J Cancer 130 1 2012 234 240
19. R. Sankaranarayanan, R. Wesley, S. Thara, N. Dhakad, B. Chandralekha, P. Sebastian, and et al. Test characteristics of visual inspection with 4% acetic acid (VIA) and Lugol's iodine (VILI) in cervical cancer screening in Kerala, India Int J Cancer 106 3 2003 404 408
20. T. Agorastos, K. Dinas, B. Lloveras, S. de Sanjose, J.R. Kornegay, H. Bonti, and et al. Human papillomavirus testing for primary screening in women at low risk of developing cervical cancer. The Greek experience Gynecol Oncol 96 3 2005 714 720
21. G. Bigras, and F. de Marval The probability for a Pap test to be abnormal is directly proportional to HPV viral load: results from a Swiss study comparing HPV testing and liquid-based cytology to detect cervical cancer precursors in 13,842 women Br J Cancer 93 5 2005 575 581
22. M. Cárdenas-Turanzas, G.M. Nogueras-Gonzalez, M.E. Scheurer, K. Adler-Storthz, J.L. Benedet, J.R. Beck, and et al. The performance of human papillomavirus high-risk DNA testing in the screening and diagnostic settings Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 17 10 2008 2865 2871
23. P. de Cremoux, J. Coste, X. Sastre-Garau, M. Thioux, C. Bouillac, S. Labbé, and et al. Efficiency of the hybrid capture 2 HPV DNA test in cervical cancer screening. A study by the French Society of Clinical Cytology Am J Clin Pathol 120 4 2003 492 499
24. C.E. Depuydt, A.P. Makar, M.J. Ruymbeke, I.H. Benoy, A.J. Vereecken, and J.J. Bogers BD-ProExC as adjunct molecular marker for improved detection of CIN2 + after HPV primary screening Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 20 4 2011 628 637
25. S. Hovland, M. Arbyn, A.K. Lie, W. Ryd, B. Borge, E.J. Berle, and et al. A comprehensive evaluation of the accuracy of cervical pre-cancer detection methods in a high-risk area in East Congo Br J Cancer 102 6 2010 957 965
26. S.M. Mahmud, G. Sangwa-Lugoma, S.H. Nasr, P.K. Kayembe, R.R. Tozin, P. Drouin, and et al. Comparison of human papillomavirus testing and cytology for cervical cancer screening in a primary health care setting in the Democratic Republic of the Congo Gynecol Oncol 124 2 2012 286 291
27. J. Monsonego, M.G. Hudgens, L. Zerat, J.C. Zerat, K. Syrjänen, P. Halfon, and et al. Evaluation of oncogenic human papillomavirus RNA and DNA tests with liquid-based cytology in primary cervical cancer screening: the FASE study Int J Cancer 129 3 2011 691 701
28. K.U. Petry, S. Menton, M. Menton, F. van Loenen-Frosch, H. de Carvalho Gomes, B. Holz, and et al. Inclusion of HPV testing in routine cervical cancer screening for women above 29 years in Germany: results for 8466 patients Br J Cancer 88 10 2003 1570 1577
29. P.D. Blumenthal, L. Gaffikin, Z.M. Chirenje, J. McGrath, S. Womack, and K. Shah Adjunctive testing for cervical cancer in low resource settings with visual inspection, HPV, and the Pap smear Int J Gynecol Obstet 72 1 2001 47 53
30. S.B. Cantor, M. Cárdenas-Turanzas, D.D. Cox, E.N. Atkinson, G.M. Nogueras-Gonzalez, J.R. Beck, and et al. Accuracy of colposcopy in the diagnostic setting compared with the screening setting Obstet Gynecol 111 1 2008 7 14
31. M.L. Cremer, E.I. Peralta, S.G. Dheming, M.E. Jimenez, C.A. Davis-Dao, T.A. Alonzo, and et al. Digital assessment of the reproductive tract versus colposcopy for directing biopsies in women with abnormal Pap smears J Low Genit Tract Dis 14 1 2010 5 10
32. P.M. Cristoforoni, D. Gerbaldo, A. Perino, R. Piccoli, F.J. Montz, and G.L. Capitanio Computerized colposcopy: results of a pilot study and analysis of its clinical relevance Obstet Gynecol 85 6 1995 1011 1016
33. G.S. Durdi, B.Y. Sherigar, A.M. Dalal, B.R. Desai, and P.R. Malur Correlation of colposcopy using Reid colposcopic index with histopathology - a prospective study J Turk Ger Gynecol Assoc 10 4 2009 205 207
34. D.G. Ferris, and M.D. Miller Colposcopic accuracy in a residency training program: defining competency and proficiency J Fam Pract 36 5 1993 515 520
35. H.D. Homesley, V.W. Jobson, and R.L. Reish Use of colposcopically directed, four-quadrant cervical biopsy by the colposcopy trainee J Reprod Med 29 5 1984 311 316
36. D.E. Jones, W.T. Creasman, R.A. Dombroski, S.S. Lentz, and J.L. Waeltz Evaluation of the atypical Pap smear Am J Obstet Gynecol 157 3 1987 544 549
37. O. Kierkegaard, C. Byrjalsen, K.H. Frandsen, K.C. Hansen, and M. Frydenberg Diagnostic accuracy of cytology and colposcopy in cervical squamous intraepithelial lesions Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 73 8 1994 648 651
38. A.S. Mousavi, F. Fakour, M.M. Gilani, N. Behtash, F. Ghaemmaghami, and M. Karimi Zarchi A prospective study to evaluate the correlation between Reid colposcopic index impression and biopsy histology J Low Genit Tract Dis 11 3 2007 147 150
39. K. Patil, G. Durdi, K.S. Lakshmi, and M.K. Swamy Comparison of diagnostic efficacy of visual inspection of cervix with acetic acid and pap smear for prevention of cervical cancer: Is VIA superseding pap smear? J SAFOG 3 3 2011 131 134
40. J. Hsu, J.L. Brozek, L. Terracciano, J. Kreis, E. Compalati, A.T. Stein, and et al. Application of GRADE: making evidence-based recommendations about diagnostic tests in clinical practice guidelines Implement Sci 6 2011 62