Voxel-based meta-Analytical evidence of structural disconnectivity in major depression and bipolar disorder

Biological Psychiatry

Volumn 79, Issue 4, 2016, Pages 293-302

  Wise, Toby ^a   Radua, Joaquim ^a,b   Nortje, Gareth ^c   Cleare, Anthony J ^a   Young, Allan H ^a   Arnone, Danilo ^a  

^a KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b CENTRO DE INVESTIGACIÓN BIOMÉDICA EN RED DE SALUD MENTAL CIBERSAM   (Spain)

^c STELLENBOSCH UNIVERSITY   (South Africa)

Author keywords

Bipolar; Connectivity; Depression; Diffusion; Imaging; MRI

Indexed keywords

ANALYSIS; ARTICLE; BIPOLAR DISORDER; CINGULUM (BRAIN); COMPARATIVE STUDY; CORPUS CALLOSUM; DIFFUSION TENSOR IMAGING; FRACTIONAL ANISOTROPY; HUMAN; MAJOR DEPRESSION; META ANALYSIS; NEUROIMAGING; PRIORITY JOURNAL; VOXEL BASED ANALYSIS; WHITE MATTER; AFFECT; ANISOTROPY; DIFFUSION WEIGHTED IMAGING; PATHOLOGY;

AFFECT; ANISOTROPY; BIPOLAR DISORDER; CORPUS CALLOSUM; DEPRESSIVE DISORDER, MAJOR; DIFFUSION MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; DIFFUSION TENSOR IMAGING; HUMANS; WHITE MATTER;

EID: 84955207223     PISSN: 00063223     EISSN: 18732402     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.biopsych.2015.03.004     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. R.C. Kessler, P. Berglund, O. Demler, R. Jin, D. Koretz, K.R. Merikangas, and et al. The epidemiology of major depressive disorder: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication (NCS-R) JAMA 289 2003 3095 3105
2. K.R. Merikangas, H.S. Akiskal, J. Angst, P.E. Greenberg, R.M.A. Hirschfeld, M. Petukhova, and R.C. Kessler Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of bipolar spectrum disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey replication Arch Gen Psychiatry 64 2007 543 552
3. M.L. Phillips, C.D. Ladouceur, and W.C. Drevets A neural model of voluntary and automatic emotion regulation: Implications for understanding the pathophysiology and neurodevelopment of bipolar disorder Mol Psychiatry 13 2008 833 857
4. T. Wise, A.J. Cleare, A. Herane, A.H. Young, and D. Arnone Diagnostic and therapeutic utility of neuroimaging in depression: An overview Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat 10 2014 1509 1522
5. D. Arnone, A.M. McIntosh, K.P. Ebmeier, M.R. Munafò, and I.M. Anderson Magnetic resonance imaging studies in unipolar depression: Systematic review and meta-regression analyses Eur Neuropsychopharmacol 22 2012 1 16
6. E. Bora, A. Fornito, C. Pantelis, and M. Yücel Gray matter abnormalities in major depressive disorder: A meta-Analysis of voxel based morphometry studies J Affect Disord 138 2012 9 18
7. G. Delvecchio, P. Fossati, P. Boyer, P. Brambilla, P. Falkai, O. Gruber, and et al. Common and distinct neural correlates of emotional processing in bipolar disorder and major depressive disorder: A voxel-based meta-Analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging studies Eur Neuropsychopharmacol 22 2012 100 113
8. S. Selvaraj, D. Arnone, D. Job, A. Stanfield, T.F. Farrow, A.C. Nugent, and et al. Grey matter differences in bipolar disorder: A meta-Analysis of voxel-based morphometry studies Bipolar Disord 14 2012 135 145
9. J.D. Townsend, S.J. Torrisi, M.D. Lieberman, C.A. Sugar, S.Y. Bookheimer, and L.L. Altshuler Frontal-Amygdala connectivity alterations during emotion downregulation in bipolar I disorder Biol Psychiatry 73 2013 127 135
10. M.D. Greicius, B.H. Flores, V. Menon, G.H. Glover, H.B. Solvason, H. Kenna, and et al. Resting-state functional connectivity in major depression: Abnormally increased contributions from subgenual cingulate cortex and thalamus Biol Psychiatry 62 2007 429 437
11. M.S. Korgaonkar, A. Fornito, L.M. Williams, and S.M. Grieve Abnormal structural networks characterize major depressive disorder: A connectome analysis Biol Psychiatry 76 2014 567 574
12. Y. Liao, X. Huang, Q. Wu, C. Yang, W. Kuang, M. Du, and et al. Is depression a disconnection syndrome? Meta-Analysis of diffusion tensor imaging studies in patients with MDD J Psychiatry Neurosci 38 2013 49 56
13. G. Nortje, D.J. Stein, J. Radua, D. Mataix-Cols, and N. Horn Systematic review and voxel-based meta-Analysis of diffusion tensor imaging studies in bipolar disorder J Affect Disord 150 2013 192 200
14. A. Versace, J.R.C. Almeida, K. Quevedo, W.K. Thompson, R.A. Terwilliger, S. Hassel, and et al. Right orbitofrontal corticolimbic and left corticocortical white matter connectivity differentiate bipolar and unipolar depression Biol Psychiatry 68 2010 560 567
15. J. Radua, K. Rubia, E.J. Canales, E. Pomarol-Clotet, P. Fusar-Poli, and D. Mataix-Cols Anisotropic kernels for coordinate-based meta-Analyses of neuroimaging studies Front Psychiatry 5 2014 13
16. D. Moher, A. Liberati, J. Tetzlaff, and D.G. Altman Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-Analyses: The PRISMA statement Ann Intern Med 151 2009 264 269
17. N. Barnea-Goraly, V. Menon, M. Eckert, L. Tamm, R. Bammer, A. Karchemskiy, and et al. White matter development during childhood and adolescence: A Cross-sectional diffusion tensor imaging study Cereb Cortex 15 2005 1848 1854
18. D.C. Glahn, J.W. Kent, E. Sprooten, V.P. Diego, A.M. Winkler, J.E. Curran, and et al. Genetic basis of neurocognitive decline and reduced white-matter integrity in normal human brain aging Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 110 2013 19006 19011
19. J. Radua, D. Mataix-Cols, M.L. Phillips, W. El-Hage, D.M. Kronhaus, N. Cardoner, and S. Surguladze A new meta-Analytic method for neuroimaging studies that combines reported peak coordinates and statistical parametric maps Eur Psychiatry 27 2012 605 611
20. J. Radua, and D. Mataix-Cols Voxel-wise meta-Analysis of grey matter changes in obsessive-compulsive disorder Br J Psychiatry 195 2009 393 402
21. J. Radua, O. van Den Heuvel, S. Surguladze, and D. Mataix-Cols Meta-Analytical comparison of voxel-based morphometry studies in obsessive-compulsive disorder vs other anxiety disorders Arch Gen Psychiatry 67 2010 701 711
22. J. Radua, M. Romeo, D. Mataix-Cols, and P. Fusar-Poli A general approach for combining voxel-based meta-Analyses conducted in different neuroimaging modalities Curr Med Chem 20 2013 462 466
23. M. Egger, G.D. Smith, M. Schneider, and C. Minder Bias in meta-Analysis detected by a simple, graphical test BMJ 315 1997 629 634
24. W. Viechtbauer Conducting meta-Analyses in R with the metafor package J Stat Softw 36 2010 1 48
25. D.C. Van Essen, K. Ugurbil, E. Auerbach, D. Barch, T.E.J. Behrens, R. Bucholz, and et al. The Human Connectome Project: A data acquisition perspective Neuroimage 62 2012 2222 2231
26. M. Catani, and M.T. de Schotten Atlas of human brain connections 2012 Oxford University Press New York
27. D. Arnone, J. Cavanagh, D. Gerber, S.M. Lawrie, K.P. Ebmeier, and A.M. McIntosh Magnetic resonance imaging studies in bipolar disorder and schizophrenia: Meta-Analysis Br J Psychiatry 195 2009 194 201
28. C. Diener, C. Kuehner, W. Brusniak, B. Ubl, M. Wessa, and H. Flor A meta-Analysis of neurofunctional imaging studies of emotion and cognition in major depression Neuroimage 61 2012 677 685
29. J. Houenou, J. Frommberger, S. Carde, M. Glasbrenner, C. Diener, M. Leboyer, and M. Wessa Neuroimaging-based markers of bipolar disorder: Evidence from two meta-Analyses J Affect Disord 132 2011 344 355
30. M.M. Rive, G. van Rooijen, D.J. Veltman, M.L. Phillips, A.H. Schene, and H.G. Ruhé Neural correlates of dysfunctional emotion regulation in major depressive disorder. A systematic review of neuroimaging studies Neurosci Biobehav Rev 37 2013 2529 2553
31. L. Delano-Wood, N.H. Stricker, S.F. Sorg, D.A. Nation, A.J. Jak, S.P. Woods, and et al. Posterior cingulum white matter disruption and its associations with verbal memory and stroke risk in mild cognitive impairment J Alzheimers Dis 29 2012 589 603
32. K. Kantarci, M.L. Senjem, R. Avula, B. Zhang, A.R. Samikoglu, S.D. Weigand, and et al. Diffusion tensor imaging and cognitive function in older adults with no dementia Neurology 77 2011 26 34
33. B.D. Daniel, A. Montali, M.L. Gerra, M. Innamorati, P. Girardi, M. Pompili, and M. Amore Cognitive impairment and its associations with the path of illness in affective disorders: A comparison between patients with bipolar and unipolar depression in remission J Psychiatr Pract 19 2013 275 287
34. G. Xu, K. Lin, D. Rao, Y. Dang, H. Ouyang, Y. Guo, and et al. Neuropsychological performance in bipolar I, bipolar II and unipolar depression patients: A longitudinal, naturalistic study J Affect Disord 136 2012 328 339
35. F.T. Maalouf, C. Klein, L. Clark, B.J. Sahakian, E.J. LaBarbara, A. Versace, and et al. Impaired sustained attention and executive dysfunction: Bipolar disorder versus depression-specific markers of affective disorders Neuropsychologia 48 2010 1862 1868
36. S.M. Smith, M. Jenkinson, H. Johansen-Berg, D. Rueckert, T.E. Nichols, C.E. Mackay, and et al. Tract-based spatial statistics: Voxelwise analysis of multi-subject diffusion data Neuroimage 31 2006 1487 1505
37. M.J. Kempton, Z. Salvador, M.R. Munafò, J.R. Geddes, A. Simmons, S. Frangou, and S.C.R. Williams Structural neuroimaging studies in major depressive disorder. Meta-Analysis and comparison with bipolar disorder Arch Gen Psychiatry 68 2011 675 690
38. C. Beaulieu The basis of anisotropic water diffusion in the nervous system - a technical review NMR Biomed 15 2002 435 455
39. S.-K. Song, S.-W. Sun, M.J. Ramsbottom, C. Chang, J. Russell, and A.H. Cross Dysmyelination revealed through MRI as increased radial (but unchanged axial) diffusion of water Neuroimage 17 2002 1429 1436
40. F. Benedetti, P.-H. Yeh, M. Bellani, D. Radaelli, M.A. Nicoletti, S. Poletti, and et al. Disruption of white matter integrity in bipolar depression as a possible structural marker of illness Biol Psychiatry 69 2011 309 317
41. M.S. Korgaonkar, S.M. Grieve, S.H. Koslow, J.D.E. Gabrieli, E. Gordon, and L.M. Williams Loss of white matter integrity in major depressive disorder: Evidence using tract-based spatial statistical analysis of diffusion tensor imaging Hum Brain Mapp 32 2011 2161 2171
42. M.L. Murphy, A. Carballedo, A.J. Fagan, D. Morris, C. Fahey, J. Meaney, and T. Frodl Neurotrophic tyrosine kinase polymorphism impacts white matter connections in patients with major depressive disorder Biol Psychiatry 72 2012 663 670
43. M.J. Kempton, J.R. Geddes, U. Ettinger, S.C.R. Williams, and P.M. Grasby Meta-Analysis, database, and meta-regression of 98 structural imaging studies in bipolar disorder Arch Gen Psychiatry 65 2008 1017 1032
44. J. Cole, C.A. Chaddock, A.E. Farmer, K.J. Aitchison, A. Simmons, P. McGuffin, and C.H.Y. Fu White matter abnormalities and illness severity in major depressive disorder Br J Psychiatry 201 2012 33 39
45. Gorgolewski KJ, Varoquaux G, Rivera G, Schwartz Y, Ghosh SS, Maumet C, et al. (2014): NeuroVault.org [published online October 2104]: A web-based repository for collecting and sharing unthresholded statistical maps of the human brain.
46. D. Arnone, S. McKie, R. Elliott, E.J. Thomas, D. Downey, G. Juhasz, and et al. Increased amygdala responses to sad but not fearful faces in major depression: Relation to mood state and pharmacological treatment Am J Psychiatry 169 2012 841 850
47. D. Arnone, S. McKie, R. Elliott, G. Juhasz, E.J. Thomas, D. Downey, and et al. State-dependent changes in hippocampal grey matter in depression Mol Psychiatry 18 2013 1265 1272
48. M.V. Zanetti, M.P. Jackowski, A. Versace, J.R.C. Almeida, S. Hassel, F.L. Duran, and et al. State-dependent microstructural white matter changes in bipolar I depression Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 259 2009 316 328
49. W.D. Taylor, J.R. MacFall, B. Boyd, M.E. Payne, Y.I. Sheline, K.R.R. Krishnan, and P.M. Doraiswamy One-year change in anterior cingulate cortex white matter microstructure: Relationship with late-life depression outcomes Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 19 2011 43 52
50. D. Arnone, A.M. McIntosh, P. Chandra, and K.P. Ebmeier Meta-Analysis of magnetic resonance imaging studies of the corpus callosum in bipolar disorder Acta Psychiatr Scand 118 2008 357 362
51. O. Abe, H. Yamasue, K. Kasai, H. Yamada, S. Aoki, H. Inoue, and et al. Voxel-based analyses of gray/white matter volume and diffusion tensor data in major depression Psychiatry Res 181 2010 64 70
52. J.F. Arnold, M.P. Zwiers, D.A. Fitzgerald, P. van Eijndhoven, E.S. Becker, M. Rinck, and et al. Fronto-limbic microstructure and structural connectivity in remission from major depression Psychiatry Res 204 2012 40 48
53. T. Bracht, A. Federspiel, S. Schnell, H. Horn, O. Höfle, R. Wiest, and et al. Cortico-cortical white matter motor pathway microstructure is related to psychomotor retardation in major depressive disorder PloS One 7 2012 e52238
54. K.S. Choi, P.E. Holtzheimer, A.R. Franco, M.E. Kelley, B.W. Dunlop, X.P. Hu, and H.S. Mayberg Reconciling variable findings of white matter integrity in major depressive disorder Neuropsychopharmacology 39 2014 1332 1339
55. R.B. Dalby, J. Frandsen, M.M. Chakravarty, J. Ahdidan, L. Sørensen, R. Rosenberg, and et al. Depression severity is correlated to the integrity of white matter fiber tracts in late-onset major depression Psychiatry Res 184 2010 38 48
56. W. Guo, F. Liu, J. Chen, X. Xu, R. Wu, C. Ma, and et al. Altered white matter integrity of forebrain in treatment-resistant depression: A diffusion tensor imaging study with tract-based spatial statistics Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 38 2012 201 206
57. W. Guo, F. Liu, Z. Xue, K. Gao, R. Wu, C. Ma, and et al. Altered white matter integrity in young adults with first-episode, treatment-naive, and treatment-responsive depression Neurosci Lett 522 2012 139 144
58. Z. Jia, X. Huang, Q. Wu, T. Zhang, S. Lui, J. Zhang, and et al. High-field magnetic resonance imaging of suicidality in patients with major depressive disorder Am J Psychiatry 167 2010 1381 1390
59. T. Kieseppä, T.G. van Erp, J. Haukka, T. Partonen, T.D. Cannon, V.-P. Poutanen, and et al. Reduced left hemispheric white matter volume in twins with bipolar I disorder Biol Psychiatry 54 2003 896 905
60. N. Ma, L. Li, N. Shu, J. Liu, G. Gong, Z. He, and et al. White matter abnormalities in first-episode, treatment-naive young adults with major depressive disorder Am J Psychiatry 164 2007 823 826
61. A. Osoba, J. Hänggi, M. Li, D.I. Horn, C. Metzger, U. Eckert, and et al. Disease severity is correlated to tract specific changes of fractional anisotropy in MD and CM thalamus - A DTI study in major depressive disorder J Affect Disord 149 2013 116 128
62. X. Ouyang, H.J. Tao, H.H. Liu, Q.J. Deng, Z.H. Sun, L. Xu, and et al. White matter integrity deficit in treatment-naïve adult patients with major depressive disorder East Asian Arch Psychiatry 21 2011 5 9
63. H. Peng, H. Zheng, Y. Ning, Y. Zhang, B. Shan, L. Zhang, and et al. Abnormalities of cortical-limbic-cerebellar white matter networks may contribute to treatment-resistant depression: A diffusion tensor imaging study BMC Psychiatry 13 2013 72
64. J.-H. Seok, S. Choi, H.K. Lim, S.-H. Lee, I. Kim, and B.-J. Ham Effect of the COMT val158met polymorphism on white matter connectivity in patients with major depressive disorder Neurosci Lett 545 2013 35 39
65. K.K. Tha, S. Terae, S. Nakagawa, T. Inoue, N. Kitagawa, Y. Kako, and et al. Impaired integrity of the brain parenchyma in non-geriatric patients with major depressive disorder revealed by diffusion tensor imaging Psychiatry Res 212 2013 208 215
66. T. Wang, X. Huang, P. Huang, D. Li, F. Lv, Y. Zhang, and et al. Early-stage psychotherapy produces elevated frontal white matter integrity in adult major depressive disorder PLoS One 8 2013 e63081
67. F. Wu, Y. Tang, K. Xu, L. Kong, W. Sun, F. Wang, and et al. Whiter matter abnormalities in medication-naive subjects with a single short-duration episode of major depressive disorder Psychiatry Res 191 2011 80 83
68. X. Zhu, X. Wang, J. Xiao, M. Zhong, J. Liao, and S. Yao Altered white matter integrity in first-episode, treatment-naive young adults with major depressive disorder: A tract-based spatial statistics study Brain Res 1369 2011 223 229
69. K. Zou, X. Huang, T. Li, Q. Gong, Z. Li, L. Ou-yang, and et al. Alterations of white matter integrity in adults with major depressive disorder: A magnetic resonance imaging study J Psychiatry Neurosci 33 2008 525 530
70. N. Zuo, J. Fang, X. Lv, Y. Zhou, Y. Hong, T. Li, and et al. White matter abnormalities in major depression: A tract-based spatial statistics and rumination study PLoS One 7 2012 e37561
71. S. Bruno, M. Cercignani, and M.A. Ron White matter abnormalities in bipolar disorder: A voxel-based diffusion tensor imaging study Bipolar Disord 10 2008 460 468
72. E.J. Canales-Rodríguez, E. Pomarol-Clotet, J. Radua, S. Sarró, S. Alonso-Lana, C. Del Mar Bonnín, and et al. Structural abnormalities in bipolar euthymia: A multicontrast molecular diffusion imaging study Biol Psychiatry 76 2014 239 248
73. C.A. Chaddock, G.J. Barker, N. Marshall, K. Schulze, M.H. Hall, A. Fern, and et al. White matter microstructural impairments and genetic liability to familial bipolar I disorder Br J Psychiatry 194 2009 527 534
74. W.-Y. Chan, G.-L. Yang, M.-Y. Chia, P.-S. Woon, J. Lee, R. Keefe, and et al. Cortical and subcortical white matter abnormalities in adults with remitted first-episode mania revealed by Tract-Based Spatial Statistics Bipolar Disord 12 2010 383 389
75. Z. Chen, L. Cui, M. Li, L. Jiang, W. Deng, X. Ma, and et al. Voxel based morphometric and diffusion tensor imaging analysis in male bipolar patients with first-episode mania Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 36 2012 231 238
76. L. Cui, Z. Chen, W. Deng, X. Huang, M. Li, X. Ma, and et al. Assessment of white matter abnormalities in paranoid schizophrenia and bipolar mania patients Psychiatry Res 194 2011 347 353
77. T.H. Ha, J.Y. Her, J.H. Kim, J.S. Chang, H.S. Cho, and K. Ha Similarities and differences of white matter connectivity and water diffusivity in bipolar I and II disorder Neurosci Lett 505 2011 150 154
78. J. Lagopoulos, D.F. Hermens, S.N. Hatton, J. Tobias-Webb, K. Griffiths, S.L. Naismith, and et al. Microstructural white matter changes in the corpus callosum of young people with bipolar disorder: A diffusion tensor imaging study PLoS One 8 2013 e59108
79. J.-X. Liu, Y.-S. Chen, J.-C. Hsieh, T.-P. Su, T.-C. Yeh, and L.-F. Chen Differences in white matter abnormalities between bipolar I and II disorders J Affect Disord 127 2010 309 315
80. L.H. Lu, X.J. Zhou, S.K. Keedy, J.L. Reilly, and J.A. Sweeney White matter microstructure in untreated first episode bipolar disorder with psychosis: Comparison with schizophrenia Bipolar Disord 13 2011 604 613
81. K. Mahon, J. Wu, A.K. Malhotra, K.E. Burdick, P. DeRosse, B.A. Ardekani, and P.R. Szeszko A voxel-based diffusion tensor imaging study of white matter in bipolar disorder Neuropsychopharmacology 34 2009 1590 1600
82. K. Mahon, K.E. Burdick, J. Wu, B.A. Ardekani, and P.R. Szeszko Relationship between suicidality and impulsivity in bipolar I disorder: A diffusion tensor imaging study Bipolar Disord 14 2012 80 89
83. E. Sprooten, M.S. Brumbaugh, E.E.M. Knowles, D.R. McKay, J. Lewis, J. Barrett, and et al. Reduced white matter integrity in sibling pairs discordant for bipolar disorder Am J Psychiatry 170 2013 1317 1325
84. J.E. Sussmann, G.K.S. Lymer, J. McKirdy, T.W.J. Moorhead, S. Muñoz Maniega, D. Job, and et al. White matter abnormalities in bipolar disorder and schizophrenia detected using diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging Bipolar Disord 11 2009 11 18
85. M. Wessa, J. Houenou, M. Leboyer, S. Chanraud, C. Poupon, J.-L. Martinot, and M.-L. Paillère-Martinot Microstructural white matter changes in euthymic bipolar patients: A whole-brain diffusion tensor imaging study Bipolar Disord 11 2009 504 514