Science vs. fear: the Ebola quarantine debate as a case study that reveals how the public perceives risk

Journal of Risk Research

Volumn 20, Issue 5, 2017, Pages 611-633

  Gesser Edelsburg, Anat ^a   Shir Raz, Yaffa ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF HAIFA   (Israel)

Author keywords

Ebola; Hickox quarantine incident; media characterization of spreading disease; perceived risk; qualitative research

Indexed keywords

BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH; DISEASES; NEWSPRINT;

EBOLA; HICKOX QUARANTINE INCIDENT; PERCEIVED RISK; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; SPREADING DISEASE;

RISK PERCEPTION;

EID: 84946434554     PISSN: 13669877     EISSN: 14664461     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/13669877.2015.1100659     Document Type: Article

References (73)

1. van Asselt, M. B. A., and Ellen, Vos. 2008. “Wrestling with Uncertain Risks:EU Regulation of GMOs and the Uncertainty Paradox.” Journal of Risk Research 11 (1):281–300.10.1080/13669870801990806
2. Associated Press. 2013. “Top 10 Newspapers by Circulation:Wall Street Journal Leads Weekday Circulation.” Huffington Post, April 30.
3. Bidgood, J., and D., Philipps. 2014. “Judge in Maine Eases Restrictions on Nurse.” The New York times, October 31.
4. Blau, R., S., Goldstein, and E., Durkin. 2014. “Quarantined Nurse Blasts Gov. Christie as Lawyer Prepares to Fight for Her Freedom.” New York Daily News, October 26.
5. Braun, V., and V., Clarke. 2006. “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in Psychology 3 (2):77–101.10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
6. Bryman, A., 2001. Social Research Methods. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
7. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2014. “Ebola (Ebola Virus Disease).” Transmission, November 5. http://www.cdc.gov/vhf/ebola/transmission/index.html?s_cid=cs_284.
8. Charlton, C., and L., Crossley. 2014. “Doomsday Warning:UN Ebola Chief Raises ‘Nightmare’ Prospect That Virus Could Mutate and Become Airborne–Making It Much More Infectious.” MailOnline, October 2. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2778022/UN-Ebola-chief-raises-nightmare-prospect-virus-mutate-airborne.html#ixzz3GhvDVnIB.
9. Clarke, J. N., and M. M., Everest. 2006. “Cancer in the Mass Print Media:Fear, Uncertainty and the Medical Model.” Social Science & Medicine 62 (10):2591–2600.10.1016/j.socscimed.2005.11.021
10. Dalgard, D. W., R. J., Hardy, S. L., Pearson, G. J., Pucak, R. V., Quander, P. M., Zack, C. J., Peters, and P. B., Jahrling. 1992. “Combined Simian Hemorrhagic Fever and Ebola Virus Infection in Cynomolgus Monkeys.” Laboratory Animal Science 42 (2):152–157.
11. De Vocht, M., A. S., Claeys, V., Cauberghe, M., Uyttendaele, and B., Sas. 2014. “Won’t We Scare Them? The Impact of Communicating Uncontrollable Risks on the Public’s Perception.” Journal of Risk Research 1–15. doi:10.1080/13669877.2014.971336.10.1080/13669877.2014.971336
12. Drazen, J. M., R., Kanapathipillai, E. W., Campion, E. J., Rubin, S. M., Hammer, S., Morrissey, and L. R., Baden. 2014. “Ebola and Quarantine.” New England Journal of Medicine 371 (21):2029–2030.10.1056/NEJMe1413139
13. Einhorn, H. J., and R. M., Hogarth. 1985. “Ambiguity and Uncertainty in Probabilistic Inference.” Psychological Review 92 (4):433–461.10.1037/0033-295X.92.4.433
14. Elo, S., and H., Kyngäs. 2008. “The Qualitative Content Analysis Process.” Journal of Advanced Nursing 62 (1):107–115.10.1111/j.1365-2648.2007.04569.x
15. Faust, S. J., 2014. “Dr Jeremy Faust:Kaci Hickox is Right to Contest Her Quarantine.” New York Daily News, October 30.
16. Finucane, M. L., A., Alhakami, P., Slovic, and S. M., Johnson. 2000. “The Affect Heuristic in Judgments of Risks and Benefits.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 13 (1):1–17.10.1002/(ISSN)1099-0771
17. Fitzsimmons, E. G., 2014. “Nurse Who Spoke out about Quarantine Felt a Calling for Health Care, Friends Say.” The New York times, October 26.
18. Frewer, L., S., Hunt, M., Brennan, S., Kuznesof, M., Ness, and C., Ritson. 2003. “The Views of Scientific Experts on How the Public Conceptualize Uncertainty.” Journal of Risk Research 6 (1):75–85.10.1080/1366987032000047815
19. Gesser-Edelsburg, A., Y., Shir-Raz, and M. S., Green. 2014. “Why Do Parents Who Usually Vaccinate Their Children Hesitate or Refuse? General Good vs. Individual Risk.” Journal of Risk Research 1–20. doi:10.1080/13669877.2014.983947.10.1080/13669877.2014.983947
20. Gigerenzer, G., P. M., Todd, and ABC Reserach Group. 1999. Simple Heuristics That Make Us Smart. New York:Oxford University Press.
21. Gonsalves, G., and P., Staley. 2014. “Panic, Paranoia, and Public Health–The AIDS Epidemic’s Lessons for Ebola.” New England Journal of Medicine 371 (25):2348–2349.10.1056/NEJMp1413425
22. Griffin, R. J., S., Dunwoody, and K., Neuwirth. 1999. “Proposed Model of the Relationship of Risk Information Seeking and Processing to the Development of Preventive Behaviors.” Environmental Research 80 (2):S230–S245.10.1006/enrs.1998.3940
23. Haidt, J., 2001. “The Emotional Dog and Its Rational Tail:A Social Intuitionist Approach to Moral Judgment.” Psychological Review 108 (4):814–834.10.1037/0033-295X.108.4.814
24. Hartocollis, A., and Fitzsimmons, E. G., 2014. “Tested Negative for Ebola, Nurse Criticizes Her Quarantine.” The New York times, October 25.
25. Holton, A., N., Lee, and R., Coleman. 2014. “Commenting on Health:A Framing Analysis of User Comments in Response to Health Articles Online.” Journal of Health Communication 19 (7):825–837.10.1080/10810730.2013.837554
26. Howell, T., 2014. “Airborne Ebola Spread Can’t Be Ruled out, Docs from Infamous ‘Hot Zone’ Episode Say.” The Washington Times, October 16. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/oct/16/airborne-ebola-outbreak-in-monkeys-raises-possibil/?page=all.
27. Huurne, E. T., and J., Gutteling. 2008. “Information Needs and Risk Perception as Predictors of Risk Information Seeking.” Journal of Risk Research 11 (7):847–862.10.1080/13669870701875750
28. Irwin, A., 1995. Citizen Science:A Study of People, Expertise and Sustainable Development. London:Routledge.
29. Jaax, N., P., Jahrling, T., Geisbert, J., Geisbert, K., Steele, K., McKee, D., Nagley, E., Johnson, G., Jaax, and C., Peters. 1995. “Transmission of Ebola Virus (Zaire Strain) to Uninfected Control Monkeys in a Biocontainment Laboratory.” The Lancet 346 (8991–8992):1669–1671.10.1016/S0140-6736(95)92841-3
30. Johnson, E., N., Jaax, J., White, and P., Jahrling. 1995. “Lethal Experimental Infections of Rhesus Monkeys by Aerosolized Ebola Virus.” International Journal of Experimental Pathology 76 (4):227–236.
31. Johnson, B. B., and P., Slovic. 1995. “Presenting Uncertainty in Health Risk Assessment:Initial Studies of Its Effects on Risk Perception and Trust.” Risk Analysis 15 (4):485–494.10.1111/risk.1995.15.issue-4
32. Kahlor, L., 2010. “PRISM:A Planned Risk Information Seeking Model.” Health Communication 25 (4):345–356.10.1080/10410231003775172
33. Kahneman, D., and S., Frederick. 2002. “Representativeness Revisited:Attribute Substitution in Intutive Judgment.” In Heuristics and Biases, edited by T., Gilovich, D., Griff, and D., Kahneman. New York:Cambridge University Press.
34. Klein, G., 1998. Sources of Power:How People Make Decisions. Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
35. Krippendorff, K., 1980. Content Analysis:An Introduction to Its Methodology. Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
36. Lanard, J., and Sandman, P. 2014. “Ebola:Failures of Imagination.” The Peter M. Sandman Risk Communication Website, October 24. http://www.psandman.com/col/Ebola-3.htm.
37. Lehman-Wilzig, S., and M., Seletzky. 2012. “Elite and Popular Newspaper Publication of Press Releases:Differential Success Factors?” Public Relations Journal 6 (1):1–25.
38. Lofstedt, R. E., 2006. “How Can We Make Food Risk Communication Better:Where Are We and Where Are We Going?” Journal of Risk Research 9 (8):869–890.10.1080/13669870601065585
39. Lupica, M., 2014a. “Lupica:Treatment of Quarantined Nurse in Newark Shows U.S. Leaders Have Failed Us on Ebola.” New York Daily News, October 26.
40. Lupica, M., 2014b. “Lupica:NJ Gov. Chris Christie’s Quarantine Decisions Are Full of Baloney.” New York Daily News, October 29.
41. Maxim, L., P., Mansier, and N., Grabar. 2012. “Public Reception of Scientific Uncertainty in the Endocrine Disrupter Controversy:The Case of Male Fertility.” Journal of Risk Research 16 (6):677–695.
42. Mckenna, M., 2014. “Ebolanoia:The Only Thing We Have to Fear is Ebola Fear Itself.” Wired, October 22. http://www.wired.com/2014/10/ebolanoia/.
43. Palenchar, M. J., and R. L., Heath. 2002. “Another Part of the Risk Communication Model:Analysis of Communication Processes and Message Content.” Journal of Public Relations Research 14 (2):127–158.10.1207/S1532754XJPRR1402_3
44. Pengelly, M. 2014. “Kaci Hickox Accuses Governors of Exploiting Ebola Fears for Political Gain.” The Guardian, November 17.
45. Pompeo, J. 2011. “‘Journal,’ ‘Times’ and ‘News’ among the Top Five Biggest-selling Papers in the U.S.; ‘Post’ is No. 7.” Capital New York, Novmber 1.
46. Renn, O., 2006. “Risk Communication–Consumers between Information and Irritation.” Journal of Risk Research 9 (8):833–849.10.1080/13669870601010938
47. Reynolds, B., 2007. Crisis and Emergency Risk Communication:Pandemic Influenza. Atlanta, GA:Centers for Disease ntrol and Prevention. Accessed June 9, 2010. http://emergency.cdc.gov/cerc/resources/pdf/cerc-pandemicflu-oct07.pdf
48. Robbins, L., M. Barbaro, and M. Santora. 2014. “Unapologetic, Christie Frees Nurse From Ebola Quarantine”. The New York Times, October 27.
49. Roels, T. H., A. S., Bloom, J., Buffington, G. L., Muhungu, W. R., Mac Kenzie, A. S., Khan, R., Ndambi, et al. 1999. “Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever, Kikwit, Democratic Republic of the Congo, 1995:Risk Factors for Patients without a Reported Exposure.” The Journal of Infectious Diseases 179 (s1):S92–S97.10.1086/jid.1999.179.issue-s1
50. Rosenbaum, L., 2015. “Communicating Uncertainty–Ebola, Public Health, and the Scientific Process.” New England Journal of Medicine 372 (1):7–9.10.1056/NEJMp1413816
51. Ross, P., 2014. “Is Ebola Airborne? Aerial Transmission of the Virus Cannot Be ‘Excluded’.” International Business Times, October 17. http://www.ibtimes.com/ebola-airborne-aerial-transmission-virus-cannot-be-excluded-1706857.
52. Sanchez, R., C. E., Shoichet, and F., Karimi. 2014. “Ebola Update:Maine Judge Rejects Quarantine for Nurse Kaci Hickox.” CNN, November 1. http://edition.cnn.com/2014/10/31/health/us-ebola/
53. Sandman, P., 2003. Four Kinds of Risk Communication, April 11, 2003. Accessed January 29, 2010. http://www.psandman.com/col/4kind-1.htm
54. Sandman, P. M., 2006. “Crisis Communication Best Practices:Some Quibbles and Additions.” Journal of Applied Communication Research 34 (3):257–262.10.1080/00909880600771619
55. Sandman, P., 2014. “Ebola in the U.S. (so far):The Public Health Establishment and the Quarantine Debate.” The Peter M. Sandman Risk Communication Website, November 15. http://www.psandman.com/col/Ebola-4.htm.
56. Sandman, P., and J., Lanard. 2011. Explaining and Proclaiming Uncertainty:Risk Communication Lessons from Germany’s Deadly E. coli Outbreak. The Peter M. Sandman Risk Communication Website, August 14. http://www.psandman.com/col/GermanEcoli.htm.
57. Sandman, P., and J., Lanard. 2014. “Commentary:When the next shoe drops –Ebola crisis communication lessons from October.” Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy, December 9. Accessed December 10, 2014. http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2014/12/commentary-when-next-shoe-drops-ebola-crisis-communication-lessons-october
58. Sandoval, E., R., Blau, D., Friedman, and B., Hutchinson. 2014. “Nurse Kaci Hickox Fights to Get out of Ebola Quarantine in Newark as White House Expresses ‘Concern’ over Cuomo, Christie Policy.” New York Daily News, October 26.
59. Schapiro, R., 2014. “Ebola-negative nurse quarantined in Newark:I was treated ‘as if I was a criminal’.” New York Daily News, October 25.
60. Schnirring, L., 2014. “CDC, some states differ over quarantine for Ebola responders.” CIDRAP–Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy. October 27. http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2014/10/cdc-some-states-differ-over-quarantine-ebola-responders.
61. Sjoberg, L., 1998. “Worry and Risk Perception.” Risk Analysis 18 (1):85–93.10.1111/risk.1998.18.issue-1
62. Slovic, P., 1991. “Beyond Numbers:A Broader Perspective on Risk Perception and Risk Communication.” In Acceptable Evidence:Science and Values in Risk Management, edited by D. G., Mayo and R. D., Hollander, 48–65. New York:Oxford University Press.
63. Slovic, P., M., Finucane, E., Peters, and D., MacGregor. 2004. “Risk as Analysis and Risk as Feelings:Some Thoughts about Affect, Reason, Risk, and Rationality.” Risk Analysis 24 (2):311–322.10.1111/risk.2004.24.issue-2
64. Tversky, A., and D., Kahneman. 1974. “Judgment under Uncertainty:Heuristics and Biases.” Science 185 (4157):1124–1131.10.1126/science.185.4157.1124
65. Viebeck, E., 2014. “Health Officials Struggle to Control the Media Narrative about Ebola.” The Hill. October 12. http://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/220458-feds-struggle-to-control-the-media-narrative-about-ebola.
66. Wallsten, T. S., 1990. “The Costs and Benefits of Vague Information.” In Insights in Decision Making. A Tribute to the Late Hillel Einhorn, edited by R., Hogarth, 28–43. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
67. Weingartl, H. M., C., Embury-Hyatt, C., Nfon, A., Leung, G., Smith, and G., Kobinger. 2012. “Transmission of Ebola Virus from Pigs to Non-human Primates.” Science Reports 2:811.
68. Witte, K., 1992. “Putting the Fear Back into Fear Appeals:The Extended Parallel Process Model.” Communication Monographs 59 (4):329–349.10.1080/03637759209376276
69. World Health Organization. 2014. Ebola Virus Disease. Fact Sheet N°103, September 2014. Accessed October 7, 2014. http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs103/en/
70. Wulfhorst, E., and D., Morgan. 2014. “CDC Says Returning Ebola Medical Workers Should Not Be Quarantined.” Reuters, October 27. http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/28/us-health-ebola-usa-newyork-idUSKBN0IG12920141028.
71. Wynne, B., 1992. “Uncertainty and Environmental Learning:Reconceiving Science and Policy in the Preventive Paradigm.” Global Environmental Change 2 (2):111–127.10.1016/0959-3780(92)90017-2
72. Wynne, B., 2001. “Creating Public Alienation:Expert Cultures of Risk and Ethics on GMOs.” Science as Culture (London) 10 (4):445–481.
73. Zernike, K., and E. G., Fitzsimmons. 2014. “Threat of Lawsuit Could Test Maine’s Quarantine Policy.” The New York Times, October 29.