Task-shifting from physicians to nurses in primary care and its impact on resource utilization: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Medical Care Research and Review

Volumn 72, Issue 4, 2015, Pages 395-418

  Martínez González, Nahara Anani ^a   Rosemann, Thomas ^a   Djalali, Sima ^a   Huber Geismann, Flore ^a   Tandjung, Ryan ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Health care costs; Meta analysis; Physician nurse substitution; Physician nurse task shifting; Resource utilization; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; CLINICAL PRACTICE; CONSULTATION; HEALTH CARE COST; HEALTH CARE PLANNING; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; NURSE; PATIENT ASSESSMENT; PATIENT REFERRAL; PHYSICIAN; PRESCRIPTION; PRIMARY MEDICAL CARE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SALARY; SHIFT WORKER; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; NURSING PRACTICE; PRIMARY HEALTH CARE; PROFESSIONAL DELEGATION;

DELEGATION, PROFESSIONAL; HEALTH POLICY; HUMANS; PRACTICE PATTERNS, NURSES'; PRACTICE PATTERNS, PHYSICIANS'; PRIMARY HEALTH CARE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC;

EID: 84943238693     PISSN: 10775587     EISSN: 15526801     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1077558715586297     Document Type: Review

References (57)

1. Aiken, L. H., and Sloane, D. M., Bruyneel, L., Van den Heede, K., Griffiths, P., Busse, R.,... Sermeus, W. (2014). Nurse staffing and education and hospital mortality in nine European countries: A retrospective observational study. Lancet, 383, 1824-1830.
2. Buchan, J., & Calman, L. (2006). The global shortage of registered nurses: An overview of issues and actions. Geneva, Switzerland: International Council of Nurses.
3. Campbell, N. C., and Ritchie, L. D., Thain, J., Deans, H. G., and Rawles, J. M., & Squair, J. L. (1998). Secondary prevention in coronary heart disease: A randomised trial of nurse led clinics in primary care. Heart, 80, 447-452.
4. Campbell, N. C., Thain, J., Deans, H. G., and Ritchie, L. D., & Rawles, J. M. (1998). Secondary prevention in coronary heart disease: Baseline survey of provision in general practice. British Medical Journal, 316, 1430-1434.
5. Campbell, N. C., Thain, J., Deans, H. G., and Ritchie, L. D., Rawles, J. M., & Squair, J. L. (1998). Secondary prevention clinics for coronary heart disease: Randomised trial of effect on health. British Medical Journal, 316, 1434-1437.
6. Chan, D., Harris, S., Roderick, P., Brown, D., & Patel, P. (2009). A randomised controlled trial of structured nurse-led outpatient clinic follow-up for dyspeptic patients after direct access gastroscopy. BioMed Central Gastroenterology, 9, 12.
7. Chopra, M., Munro, S., Lavis, J. N., Vist, G., & Bennett, S. (2008). Effects of policy options for human resources for health: An analysis of systematic reviews. Lancet, 371, 668-674.
8. Cochrane Collaboration. (2012). Review Manager Software (Version 5.2.4) [Software]. Copenhagen, Denmark: Author.
9. Cooper, R. A. (2007). New directions for nurse practitioners and physician assistants in the era of physician shortages. Academic Medicine, 82, 827-828.
10. De Geest, S., Moons, P., Callens, B., Gut, C., Lindpaintner, L., & Spirig, R. (2008). Introducing advanced practice nurses/nurse practitioners in health care systems: A framework for reflection and analysis. Swiss Medical Weekly, 138(43-44), 621-628.
11. Delamaire, M., & Lafortune, G. (2010, July). Nurses in advanced roles: A description and evaluation of experiences in 12 developed countries (Working Paper No. 54). Retrieved from http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/nurses-in-advanced-roles-5kmbrcfms5g7-en?crawler=true
12. Delaney, E. K., Murchie, P., Lee, A. J., and Ritchie, L. D., & Campbell, N. C. (2008). Secondary prevention clinics for coronary heart disease: A 10-year follow-up of a randomised controlled trial in primary care. Heart, 94, 1419-1423.
13. Denver, E. A., Barnard, M., Woolfson, R. G., & Earle, K. A. (2003). Management of uncontrolled hypertension in a nurse-led clinic compared with conventional care for patients with type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Care, 26, 2256-2260.
14. Dierick-van Daele, A. T. M, Metsemakers, J. F. M., Derckx, E. W. C. C., Spreeuwenberg, C., & Vrijhoef, H. J. M. (2009). Nurse practitioners substituting for general practitioners: Randomized controlled trial. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 65, 391-401.
15. Dierick-van Daele, A. T. M, Spreeuwenberg, C., and Derckx, E. W., Metsemakers, J. F., & Vrijhoef, B. J. (2008). Critical appraisal of the literature on economic evaluations of substitution of skills between professionals: A systematic literature review. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 14, 481-492.
16. Dierick-van Daele, A. T. M, Steuten, L. M. G., Metsemakers, J. F. M., Derckx, E. W. C. C., Spreeuwenberg, C., & Vrijhoef, H. J. M. (2010). Economic evaluation of nurse practitioners versus GPs in treating common conditions. British Journal of General Practice, 60, 28-33.
17. Fergusson, D., and Aaron, S. D., Guyatt, G., & Hebert, P. (2002). Post-randomisation exclusions: The intention to treat principle and excluding patients from analysis. British Medical Journal, 325, 652-654.
18. Flynn, B. C. (1974). The effectiveness of nurse clinicians' service delivery. American Journal of Public Health, 64, 604-611.
19. Hemani, A., and Rastegar, D. A., Hill, C., & al-Ibrahim, M. S. (1999). A comparison of resource utilization in nurse practitioners and physicians. Effective Clinical Practice, 2, 258-265.
20. Hesselink, A. E., and Penninx, B. W., van der Windt, D. A., van Duin, B. J., de Vries, P., Twisk, J. W.,... van Eijk, J. T. (2004). Effectiveness of an education programme by a general practice assistant for asthma and COPD patients: Results from a randomised controlled trial. Patient Education and Counseling, 55, 121-128.
21. Higgins, J. P., & Thompson, S. G. (2002). Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Statistics in Medicine, 21, 1539-1558.
22. Higgins, J. P. T., and Altman, D. G., Gotzsche, P. C., Juni, P., Moher, D., and Oxman, A. D.,... Sterne, J. A. (2011). The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. British Medical Journal, 343, d5928.
23. Higgins, J. P. T., & Green, S. (Eds.). (2011). Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions (Version 5.1.0, updated March 2011). Retrieved from http://handbook.cochrane.org/
24. Hiss, R. G., and Armbruster, B. A., Gillard, M. L., & McClure, L. A. (2007). Nurse care manager collaboration with community-based physicians providing diabetes care: A randomized controlled trial. Diabetes Educator, 33, 493-502.
25. Hollinghurst, S., Horrocks, S., Anderson, E., & Salisbury, C. (2006). Comparing the cost of nurse practitioners and GPs in primary care: Modelling economic data from randomised trials. British Journal of General Practice, 56, 530-535.
26. Horrocks, S., Anderson, E., & Salisbury, C. (2002). Systematic review of whether nurse practitioners working in primary care can provide equivalent care to doctors. British Medical Journal, 324, 819-823.
27. Houweling, S. T., Kleefstra, N., van Hateren, K. J. J, Groenier, K. H., Meyboom-de Jong, B., & Bilo, H. J. G. (2011). Can diabetes management be safely transferred to practice nurses in a primary care setting? A randomised controlled trial. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1264-1272.
28. Jarman, B., Hurwitz, B., Cook, A., Bajekal, M., & Lee, A. (2002). Effects of community based nurses specialising in Parkinson's disease on health outcome and costs: Randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal, 324, 1072-1075.
29. Juni, P., Witschi, A., Bloch, R., & Egger, M. (1999). The hazards of scoring the quality of clinical trials for meta-analysis. Journal of the American Medical Association, 282, 1054-1060.
30. Kernick, D., Cox, A., Powell, R., Reinhold, D., Sawkins, J., & Warin, A. (2000). A cost consequence study of the impact of a dermatology-trained practice nurse on the quality of life of primary care patients with eczema and psoriasis. British Journal of General Practice, 50, 555-558.
31. Kernick, D., Powell, R., & Reinhold, D. (2002). A pragmatic randomised controlled trial of an asthma nurse in general practice. Primary Care Respiratory Journal, 11, 6-8.
32. Kinnersley, P., Anderson, E., Parry, K., Clement, J., Archard, L., Turton, P.,... Rogers, C. (2000). Randomised controlled trial of nurse practitioner versus general practitioner care for patients requesting "same day" consultations in primary care. British Medical Journal, 320, 1043-1048.
33. Kreitzer, M. J., Kligler, B., & Meeker, W. C. (2009). Health professions education and integrative healthcare. Explore, 5, 212-227.
34. Kuethe, M., Vaessen-Verberne, A., Mulder, P., Bindels, P., & van Aalderen, W. (2011). Paediatric asthma outpatient care by asthma nurse, paediatrician or general practitioner: Randomised controlled trial with two-year follow-up. Primary Care Respiratory Journal, 20, 84-91.
35. Laurant, M., Harmsen, M., Wollersheim, H., Grol, R., Faber, M., & Sibbald, B. (2009). The impact of nonphysician clinicians: Do they improve the quality and cost-effectiveness of health care services? Medical Care Research and Review, 66, 36S-89S.
36. Laurant, M., Reeves, D., Hermens, R., Braspenning, J., Grol, R., & Sibbald, B. (2005). Substitution of doctors by nurses in primary care. Cochrane Database Systematic Reviews, 18(2), CD001271.
37. Lenz, E. R., and Mundinger, M. O., Kane, R. L., Hopkins, S. C., & Lin, S. X. (2004). Primary care outcomes in patients treated by nurse practitioners or physicians: Two-year follow-up. Medical Care Research and Review, 61, 332-351.
38. Leventhal, M. E., Denhaerynck, K., Brunner-La Rocca, H. P., Burnand, B., Conca-Zeller, A., Bernasconi, A. T.,... De Geest, S. (2011). Swiss Interdisciplinary Management Programme for Heart Failure (SWIM-HF): A randomised controlled trial study of an outpatient inter-professional management programme for heart failure patients in Switzerland. Swiss Medical Weekly, 141, w13171.
39. Lewis, C. E., & Resnik, B. A. (1967). Nurse clinics and progressive ambulatory patient care. New England Journal of Medicine, 277, 1236-1241.
40. Liberati, A., and Altman, D. G., Tetzlaff, J., Mulrow, C., Gotzsche, P. C., and Ioannidis, J. P.,... Moher, D. (2009). The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: Explanation and elaboration. PLoS Medicine, 6, e1000100.
41. Liu, N., and Finkelstein, S. R., & Poghosyan, L. (2014). A new model for nurse practitioner utilization in primary care: Increased efficiency and implications. Health Care Management Review, 39, 10-20.
42. Macdonald, L., Stubbe, M., Tester, R., Vernall, S., Dowell, T., Dew, K.,... Raphael, D. (2013). Nurse-patient communication in primary care diabetes management: An exploratory study. BMC Nursing, 12, 20.
43. Martinez-Gonzalez, N. A., Djalali, S., Tandjung, R., Huber-Geismann, F., Markun, S., Wensing, M., & Rosemann, T. (2014). Substitution of physicians by nurses in primary care: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Health Services Research, 14, 214.
44. Mundinger, M. O., and Kane, R. L., Lenz, E. R., Totten, A. M., and Tsai, W. Y., Cleary, P. D.,... Shelanski, M. L. (2000). Primary care outcomes in patients treated by nurse practitioners or physicians: A randomized trial. Journal of the American Medical Association, 283, 59-68.
45. Murchie, P., and Campbell, N. C., Ritchie, L. D., Deans, H. G., & Thain, J. (2004). Effects of secondary prevention clinics on health status in patients with coronary heart disease: 4 Year follow-up of a randomized trial in primary care. Family Practice, 21, 567-574.
46. Murchie, P., and Campbell, N. C., Ritchie, L. D., Simpson, J. A., & Thain, J. (2003). Secondary prevention clinics for coronary heart disease: Four year follow up of a randomised controlled trial in primary care. British Medical Journal, 326, 84.
47. Raftery, J. P., and Yao, G. L., Murchie, P., Campbell, N. C., & Ritchie, L. D. (2005). Cost effectiveness of nurse led secondary prevention clinics for coronary heart disease in primary care: Follow up of a randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal, 330, 707.
48. Salsberg, E., & Grover, A. (2006). Physician workforce shortages: Implications and issues for academic health centers and policymakers. Academic Medicine, 81, 782-787.
49. Shum, C., Humphreys, A., Wheeler, D., Cochrane, M. A., Skoda, S., & Clement, S. (2000). Nurse management of patients with minor illnesses in general practice: Multicentre, randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal, 320, 1038-1043.
50. Sibbald, B., Shen, J., & McBride, A. (2004). Changing the skill-mix of the health care workforce. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 9(Suppl. 1), 28-38.
51. Starfield, B. (1994). Is primary care essential? Lancet, 344, 1129-1133.
52. Sterne, J. A., and Sutton, A. J., Ioannidis, J. P., Terrin, N., Jones, D. R., Lau, J.,... Higgins, J. P. (2011). Recommendations for examining and interpreting funnel plot asymmetry in meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials. British Medical Journal, 343, d4002.
53. Thomas, L., Cullum, N., McColl, E., Rousseau, N., Soutter, J., & Steen, N. (2000). Guidelines in professions allied to medicine. Cochrane Database Systematic Reviews, 2, CD000349.
54. Venning, P., Durie, A., Roland, M., Roberts, C., & Leese, B. (2000). Randomised controlled trial comparing cost effectiveness of general practitioners and nurse practitioners in primary care. British Medical Journal, 320, 1048-1053.
55. World Health Organisation. (2011). Global health workforce alliance: Reviewing progress, renewing commitment: Progress report on the Kampala declaration and agenda for global action. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
56. World Health Organisation. (2013). A universal truth: No health without a workforce. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
57. World Health Organisation & U.S. National Institute of Aging. (2011). Global health and ageing. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.