Pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled ventilation for surgical patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia

Volumn 30, Issue 2, 2016, Pages 501-514

  Jiang, Jia ^a   Li, Bo ^b   Kang, Na ^a   Wu, Anshi ^a   Yue, Yun ^a  

^a CAPITAL MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

^b XIYUAN HOSPITAL   (China)

Author keywords

Adult; Oxygenation; Pressure controlled ventilation; Pulmonary complication; Surgery; Volume controlled ventilation

Indexed keywords

ARTIFICIAL VENTILATION; HUMAN; LUNG INJURY; MECHANICAL VENTILATOR; META ANALYSIS; OXYGENATION; POSITIVE END EXPIRATORY PRESSURE; PRESSURE CONTROLLED VENTILATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SURGICAL PATIENT; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; VOLUME CONTROLLED VENTILATION; BREATHING MECHANICS; COMPARATIVE STUDY; METABOLISM; SURGERY;

OXYGEN;

HUMANS; OXYGEN; POSITIVE-PRESSURE RESPIRATION; RESPIRATION, ARTIFICIAL; RESPIRATORY MECHANICS; SURGICAL PROCEDURES, OPERATIVE;

EID: 84942044519     PISSN: 10530770     EISSN: 15328422     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1053/j.jvca.2015.05.199     Document Type: Review

References (71)

1. R.M. Determann, A. Royakkers, E.K. Wolthuis, and et al. Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with conventional tidal volumes for patients without acute lung injury: a preventive randomized controlled trial Crit Care 14 2010 R1
2. D. Dreyfuss, and G. Saumon Ventilator-induced lung injury: Lessons from experimental studies Am J Respir Crit Care Med 157 1998 294 323
3. E.K. Wolthuis, A.P. Vlaar, G. Choi, and et al. Mechanical ventilation using non-injurious ventilation settings causes lung injury in the absence of pre-existing lung injury in healthy mice Crit Care 13 2009 R1
4. G. Tusman, S.H. Bohm, D.O. Warner, and et al. Atelectasis and perioperative pulmonary complications in high-risk patients Curr Opin Anaesthesiol 25 2012 1 10
5. A.S. Eichenberger, S. Proietti, P. Wicky, and et al. Morbid obesity and postoperative pulmonary atelectasis: An underestimated problem Anesth Analg 95 2002 1788 1792
6. A. Kozian, T. Schilling, F. Freden, and et al. One-lung ventilation induces hyperperfusion and alveolar damage in the ventilated lung: An experimental study Br J Anaesth 100 2008 549 559
7. P. Misthos, S. Katsaragakis, D. Theodorou, and et al. The degree of oxidative stress is associated with major adverse effects after lung resection: A prospective study Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 29 2006 591 595
8. K.C. Sharma, R.D. Brandstetter, J.M. Brensilver, and et al. Cardiopulmonary physiology and pathophysiology as a consequence of laparoscopic surgery Chest 110 1996 810 815
9. E.M. Manna, O.A. Ibraheim, A.H. Samarkandi, and et al. The effect of prone position on respiratory mechanics during spinal surgery Middle East J Anaesthesiol 18 2005 623 630
10. J. Canet Prediction of postoperative pulmonary complications in a population-based surgical cohort Anesthesiology 113 2010 1338 1350
11. T.G. Weiser, S.E. Regenbogen, K.D. Thompson, and et al. An estimation of the global volume of surgery: A modelling strategy based on available data Lancet 372 2008 139 144
12. A.A. Ghaferi, J.D. Birkmeyer, and J.B. Dimick Variation in hospital mortality associated with inpatient surgery N End J Med 361 2009 1368 1375
13. S.N. Hemmes, M.G. de Abreu, P. Pelosi, and et al. ESA clinical trials network 2012: LAS VEGAS - Local assessment of ventilatory management during general anaesthesia for surgery and its effects on postoperative pulmonary complications: A prospective, observational, international, multicentre cohort study Eur J Anaesthesiol 30 2013 205 207
14. G. Cinnella, S. Grasso, S. Spadaro, and et al. Effects of recruitment maneuver and positive end-expiratory pressure on respiratory mechanics and transpulmonary pressure during laparoscopic surgery Anesthesiology 118 2013 114 122
15. M.B. Amato, C.S. Barbas, D.M. Medeiros, and et al. Effect of a protective-ventilation strategy on mortality in the acute respiratory distress syndrome N Engl J Med 338 1998 347 354
16. G. Tusman, S.H. Bohm, F.S. Sipmann, and et al. Lung recruitment improves the efficiency of ventilation and gas exchange during one-lung ventilation anesthesia Anesth Analg 98 2004 1604 1609
17. A. Serpa Neto, S.O. Cardoso, J.A. Manetta, and et al. Association between use of lung-protective ventilation with lower tidal volumes and clinical outcomes among patients without acute respiratory distress syndrome: A meta-analysis JAMA 308 2012 1651 1659
18. S.N. Hemmes, A. Serpa Neto, and M.J. Schultz Intraoperative ventilatory strategies to prevent postoperative pulmonary complications: A meta-analysis Curr Opin Anaesthesiol 26 2013 126 133
19. J.U. Schreiber, M.D. Lance, M. de Korte, and et al. The effect of different lung-protective strategies in patients during cardiopulmonary bypass: A meta-analysis and semiquantitative review of randomized trials J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 26 2012 448 454
20. M. Aldenkortt, C. Lysakowski, N. Elia, and et al. Ventilation strategies in obese patients undergoing surgery: A quantitative systematic review and meta-analysis Br J Anaesth 109 2012 493 502
21. R.S. Campbell, and B.R. Davis Pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled ventilation: Does it matter? Respir Care 47 2002 416 424
22. A.M. Markstrom, M.L. Aschoff, B.A. Svensson, and et al. Ventilation with constant versus decelerating inspiratory flow in experimentally induced acute respiratiory failure Anesthesiology 84 1996 882 889
23. A.M. Al Shehri, M.R. El-Tahan, R. Al Metwally, and et al. Right ventricular function during one-lung ventilation: effects of pressure-controlled and volume-controlled ventilation J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 2014 892 896
24. S.M. Burns Pressure modes of mechanical ventilation: The good, the bad, and the ugly AACN Adv Crit Care 19 2008 399 411
25. M. Merca, L. Gralni, J.L. Teboul, and et al. Anesthetic considerations for bariatric surgery Chest 104 1993 871 875
26. N. Al-Saady, and E.D. Bennett Decelerating inspiratory flow waveform improves lung mechanics and gas exchange in patients on intermittent positive-pressure ventilation Intensive Care Med 11 1985 68 75
27. A. Esteban, I. Alia, F. Gordo, and et al. Prospective randomized trial comparing pressure-controlled ventilation and volume-controlled ventilation in ARDS. For the Spanish Lung Failure Collaborative Group Chest 117 2000 1690 1696
28. H. Roze, M. Lafargue, H. Batoz, and et al. Pressure-controlled ventilation and intrabronchial pressure during one-lung ventilation Br J Anaesth 105 2010 377 381
29. Y. Maeda, Y. Fujino, A. Uchiyama, and et al. Effects of peak inspiratory flow on development of ventilator-induced lung injury in rabbits Anesthesiology 101 2004 722 728
30. R. Dembinski, D. Henzler, R. Bensberg, and et al. Ventilation-perfusion distribution related to different inspiratory flow patterns in experimental lung injury Anesth Analg 2004 211 219
31. Higgins JP, Green S: Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions Version 5.0.1. The Cochrane Collaboration 2008. Available at: www.cochrane-handbook.org.
32. M. Egger, G. Davey Smith, M. Schneider, and et al. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test BMJ 315 1997 629 634
33. J.P. Higgins, S.G. Thompson, J.J. Deeks, and et al. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses BMJ 327 2003 557 560
34. A. Vickers, N. Goyal, R. Harland, and et al. Do certain countries produce only positive results? A systematic review of controlled trials Control Clin Trials 19 1998 159 166
35. N.S. Boules, and H.Z. Ghobrial Efficiency of the newly introduced ventilatory mode "pressure controlled ventilation-volume guaranteed" in thoracic surgery with one lung ventilation Egypt J Anaesth 27 2011 113 119
36. P. Cadi, T. Guenoun, D. Journois, and et al. Pressure-controlled ventilation improves oxygenation during laparoscopic obesity surgery compared with volume-controlled ventilation Br J Anaesth 100 2008 709 716
37. E.M. Choi, S. Na, S.H. Choi, and et al. Comparison of volume-controlled and pressure-controlled ventilation in steep Trendelenburg position for robot-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy J Clin Anesth 23 2011 183 188
38. Y.S. Choi, J.K. Shim, S. Na, and et al. Pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled ventilation during one-lung ventilation in the prone position for robot-assisted esophagectomy Surg Endosc 23 2009 2286 2291
39. Z.G. Dai, F. He, Y.L. Gao, and et al. Effect of pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled ventilation on oxygenation and intrapulmonary shunt during one-lung ventilation for thoracic surgery Progin Mod Biomed 9 2009 3304 3307
40. L.E. De Baerdemaeker, C. Van der Herten, J.M. Gillardin, and et al. Comparison of volume-controlled and pressure-controlled ventilation during laparoscopic gastric banding in morbidly obese patients Obes Surg 18 2008 680 685
41. S.D. Gupta, S.B. Kundu, T. Ghose, and et al. A comparison between volume-controlled ventilation and pressure-controlled ventilation in providing better oxygenation in obese patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy Indian J Anaesth 56 2012 276 282
42. G.A. Hans, A.A. Pregaldien, A. Kaba, and et al. Pressure-controlled ventilation does not improve gas exchange in morbidly obese patients undergoing abdominal surgery Obes Surg 18 2008 71 76
43. C. Heimberg, M. Winterhalter, M. Struber, and et al. Pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled one-lung ventilation for MIDCAB Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 54 2006 516 520
44. W.J. Jeon, S.Y. Cho, M.R. Bang, and et al. Comparison of volume-controlled and pressure-controlled ventilation using a laryngeal mask airway during gynecological laparoscopy Korean J Anesthesiol 60 2011 167 172
45. Y.Y. Jo, J.Y. Kim, Y.L. Kwak, and et al. The effect of pressure-controlled ventilation on pulmonary mechanics in the prone position during posterior lumbar spine surgery: A comparison with volume-controlled ventilation J Neurosurg Anesthesiol 24 2012 14 18
46. W.S. Kang, S.H. Kim, and J.W. Chung Comparison of pulmonary gas exchange according to intraoperative ventilation modes for mitral valve repair surgery via thoracotomy with one-lung ventilation: A randomized controlled trial J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 28 2014 920 925
47. J. Li, X.H. Xu, X.H. Zou, and et al. Pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled ventilation during one-lung ventilation for thoracic surgery J Pract Med 25 2009 1771 1773
48. F.R. Montes, D.F. Pardo, H. Charris, and et al. Comparison of two protective lung ventilatory regimes on oxygenation during one-lung ventilation: A randomized controlled trial J Cardiothorac Surg 5 2010 99
49. Z.Q. Niu, L. Wang, G.Z. Song, and et al. The effect of two ventilation modes on oxygenation and peak aireway pressure in thoracoscopic surgery People's Mil Surg 56 2013 533 542
50. M. Ogurlu, M. Kucuk, F. Bilgin, and et al. Pressure-controlled vs volume-controlled ventilation during laparoscopic gynecologic surgery J Minim Invasive Gynecol 17 2010 295 300
51. P.C. Pardos, I. Garutti, P. Pineiro, and et al. Effects of ventilatory mode during one-lung ventilation on intraoperative and postoperative arterial oxygenation in thoracic surgery J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 23 2009 770 774
52. Sun GY. The application of pressure controlled ventilation in laparoscopic colorectal surgery. 2012. Available at: http://cdmd.cnki.com.cn/Article/CDMD-10183-1012367933.htm
53. H.Y. Sun, Z.Q. Hei, J.Q. Guan, and et al. The effect of pressure controlled and volume controlled ventilation on respiratory mechanics in gynecological laparoscopic surgery Guangdong Med J 26 2005 1389 1390
54. M. Tugrul, E. Camci, H. Karadeniz, and et al. Comparison of volume controlled with pressure controlled ventilation during one-lung anaesthesia Br J Anaesth 79 1997 306 310
55. A. Tyagi, R. Kumar, A.K. Sethi, and et al. A comparison of pressure-controlled and volume-controlled ventilation for laparoscopic cholecystectomy Anaesthesia 66 2011 503 508
56. M.C. Unzueta, J.I. Casas, and M.V. Moral Pressure-controlled versus volume-controlled ventilation during one-lung ventilation for thoracic surgery Anesth Analg 104 2007 1029 1033
57. Wang XF. The effect of two types of mechanical ventilation modes on obese patients undergoing gynecologic laparoscopic surgery in respiratory function. 2009. Available at: http://cdmd.cnki.com.cn/article/cdmd-10392-2009150513.htm
58. Z.P. Wu, and J.X. Zhao The application and exploration of pressure controlled ventilation in the anorectal laparoscopic surgery Chin J Mod Drug Appl 4 2010 17 18
59. S.G. Yang, and A.W. Yuan Comparison of volume controlled with pressure comtrolled one - lung ventilation during thoracic surgery Chin Clin Pract Med 2 2008 31 33
60. W.W. Zhang, B.G. Ye, C.Y. Han, and et al. The effect of two ventilation modes on respiratory function in elderly patients undergoing laparoscopic surgery with a LMA Chin J Gerontol 32 2012 387 388
61. H. Zetterstrom Assessment of the efficiency of pulmonary oxygenation The choice of oxygenation index. Acta Anaeslhesiol Scand 32 1988 579 584
62. E. Abraham, and G. Yoshihara Cardiorespiratory effects of pressure controlled ventilation in severe respiratory failure Chest 98 1990 1445 1449
63. S.H. Rappaport, R. Shpiner, G. Yoshihara, and et al. Randomized, prospective trial of pressure-limited versus volume-controlled ventilation in severe respiratory failure Crit Care Med 22 1994 22 32
64. M. Licker, M. de Perrot, A. Spiliopoulos, and et al. Risk factors for acute lung injury after thoracic surgery for lung cancer Anesth Analg 97 2003 1558 1565
65. S. Watanabe, E. Noguchi, S. Yamada, and et al. Sequential changes of arterial oxygen tension in the supine position during one-lung ventilation Anesth Analg 90 2000 28 34
66. R.A. Oeckler, and R.D. Hubmayr Ventilator-associated lung injury: A search for better therapeutic targets Eur Respir J 30 2007 1216 1226
67. Y.D. van der Werff, H.K. van der Houwen, P.J. Heijmans, and et al. Postpneumonectomy pulmonary edema. A retrospective analysis of incidence and possible risk factors Chest 111 1997 1278 1284
68. E.R. Fernandez-Perez, J. Sprung, B. Afessa, and et al. Intraoperative ventilator settings and acute lung injury after elective surgery: A nested case control study Thorax 64 2009 121 127
69. M. Boussarsar, G. Thierry, S. Jaber, and et al. Relationship between ventilatory settings and barotrauma in the acute respiratory distress syndrome Intensive Care Med 28 2002 406 413
70. J.J. Marini, and S.A. Ravenscraft Mean airway pressure: Physiologic determinants and clinical importance-Part 2: Clinical implications Crit Care Med 20 1992 1604 1616
71. D.J. Ross, P. Wu, and Z. Mohsenifar Assessment of postural differences in regional pulmonary perfusion in man by single-photon emission computerized tomography Clin Sci (Lond) 92 1997 81 85