Problematizing Bayesian approaches to prehistoric chronologies

World Archaeology

Volumn 47, Issue 4, 2015, Pages 525-542

  Pettitt, Paul ^a   Zilhão, João ^b  

^a DURHAM UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF BARCELONA   (Spain)

Author keywords

Bayesian statistics; Middle to Upper Paleolithic transition; modern humans; Neanderthals; radiocarbon

Indexed keywords

EID: 84940904609     PISSN: 00438243     EISSN: 14701375     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00438243.2015.1070082     Document Type: Editorial

References (71)

1. W.E.Banks,, F.d’Errico, and J.Zilhão. 2013. “Revisiting the Chronology of the Proto-Aurignacian and the Early Aurignacian in Europe: A Reply to Higham et al.’s Reply to Banks et al. (2013).” Journal of Human Evolution 64: 39–55. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2012.10.001.
2. A.Bayliss, 2009. “Rolling Out Revolution: Using Radiocarbon Dating in Archaeology.” Radiocarbon 51 (1): 123–47.
3. S.Benazzi,, K.Douka, C.Fornai, C.C.Bauer, O.Kullmer, J.Svoboda, I.Pap,. et al. 2011. “Early Dispersal of Modern Humans in Europe and Implications for Neanderthal Behaviour.” Nature 479: 525–28. doi:10.1038/nature10617.
4. N.Bicho,, J.Marreiros, J.Cascalheira, T.ereira, and J.Haws. 2014. “Bayesian Modeling and the Chronology of the Portuguese Gravettian.” Quaternary International 359–360, 499–509. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2014.04.040.
5. 14C Analysis of Chronologically Ordered Samples: A Critical Analysis’.” Radiocarbon 42 (2): 199–202.
6. C.Bronk Ramsey, 2009a. “Bayesian Analysis of Radiocarbon Dates.” Radiocarbon 51 (1): 337–60.
7. C.Bronk Ramsey, 2009b. “Dealing with Outliers and Offsets in Radiocarbon Dating.” Radiocarbon 51 (3): 1023–45.
8. M.Camps,, and T.Higham. 2012. “Chronology of the Middle to Upper Palaeolithic transition at Abric Romaní, Catalunya.” Journal of Human Evolution 62: 89–103. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2011.10.010.
9. F.Caron,, F.d’Errico, P.Del Moral, F.Santos, and J.Zilhão. 2011. “The Reality of Neanderthal Symbolic Behaviour at the Grotte du Renne, Arcy-sur-Cure, France.” PLoS ONE 6: e21545.
10. N.Conard,, and M.Bolus. 2003. “Radiocarbon Dating the Appearance of Modern Humans and Timing of Cultural Innovations in Europe: New Results and New Challenges.” Journal of Human Evolution 44: 331–71. doi:10.1016/S0047-2484(02)00202-6.
11. E.R.Crema,, K.Edinborough, T.Kerig, and S.J.Shennan. 2014. “An Approximate Bayesian Computation Approach for Inferring Patterns of Cultural Evolutionary Change.” Journal of Archaeological Science 50: 160–70. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2014.07.014.
12. F.d’Errico,, V.Borgia, and A.Ronchitelli. 2012. “Uluzzian Bone Technology and its Implications for the Origin of Behavioural Modernity.” Quaternary International 259: 59–71. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2011.03.039.
13. F.d’Errico,, and M.F.Sánchez-Goñi. 2003. “Neandertal Extinction and the Millennial Scale Climatic Variability of Ois 3.” Quaternary Science Reviews 22: 769–88. doi:10.1016/S0277-3791(03)00009-X.
14. R.Dawkins, 2007. The God Delusion. London: Black Swan.
15. K.Douka,, S.Grimaldi, G.Boschian, A.Del Lucchese, and T.F.G.Higham. 2012. “A New Chronostratigraphic Framework for the Upper Palaeolithic of Riparo Mochi (Italy).” Journal of Human Evolution 62: 286–99. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2011.11.009.
16. K.Douka,, T.F.G.Higham, R.Wood, P.Boscato, P.Gambassini, P.Karkanas, M.Peresani, and A.M.Ronchitelli. 2014. “On the Chronology of the Uluzzian.” Journal of Human Evolution 68: 1–13. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.12.007.
17. F.G.Fedele,, B.Giaccio, and I.Hajdas. 2008. “Timescales and Cultural Process at 40,000 BP in the Light of the Campanian Ignimbrite Eruption, Western Eurasia.” Journal of Human Evolution 55: 834–57. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2008.08.012.
18. C.Finlayson,, D.A.Fa, F.J.Jimenez Espejo, J.S.Carrión, G.Finlayson, F.Giles Pacheco, J.Rodríguez-Vidal, C.B.Stringer, and F.Martinez Ruiz. 2008. “Gorham’s Cave, Gibraltar –the Persistence of a Neanderthal Population.” Quaternary International 181: 64–71. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2007.11.016.
19. C.Finlayson,, F.Giles Pacheco, J.Rodríguez-Vidal, D.A.Fa, J.M.Guiterrez López, A.Santiago Pérez, G.Finlayson. et al. 2006. “Late Survival of Neanderthals at the Southernmost Extreme of Europe.” Nature 443: 850–53. doi:10.1038/nature05195.
20. B.Gravina,, P.Mellars, and C.Bronk Ramsey. 2005. “Radiocarbon Dating of Interstratified Neanderthal and Early Modern Human Occupations at the Chatelperronian Type-Site.” Nature 438: 51–56. doi:10.1038/nature04006.
21. T.Higham,, L.Basell, R.Jacobi, R.Wood, C.Bronk Ramsey, and N.J.Conard. 2012. “Testing Models for the Beginnings of the Aurignacian and the Advent of Figurative Art and Music: The Radiocarbon Chronology of Geissenklösterle.” Journal of Human Evolution 62: 664–76. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2012.03.003.
22. T.Higham,, F.Brock, M.Peresani, A.Broglio, R.Wood, and K.Douka. 2009. “Problems with Radiocarbon Dating the Middle to Upper Palaeolithic Transition in Italy.” Quaternary Science Reviews 28: 1257–67. doi:10.1016/j.quascirev.2008.12.018.
23. T.Higham,, T.Compton, C.Stringer, R.Jacobi, B.Shapiro, E.Trinkaus, B.Chandler. et al. 2011. “The Earliest Evidence for Anatomically Modern Humans in Northwestern Europe.” Nature 479: 521–24. doi:10.1038/nature10484.
24. T.Higham,, K.Douka, R.Wood, C.Bronk Ramsey, F.Brock, L.Basell, M.Camps, et al. 2014. “The Timing and Spatiotemporal Patterning of Neanderthal Disappearance.” Nature 512: 306–09. doi:10.1038/nature13621.
25. T.Higham,, R.Jacobi, L.Basell, C.Bronk Ramsey, L.Chiotti, and R.Nespoulet. 2011. “Precision Dating of the Palaeolithic: A New Radiocarbon Chronology for the Abri Pataud (France), A Key Aurignacian Sequence.” Journal of Human Evolution 61: 549–63. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2011.06.005.
26. T.Higham,, R.M.Jacobi, and C.Bronk Ramsey. 2006. “AMS Radiocarbon Dating of Ancient Bone Using Ultrafiltration.” Radiocarbon 48 (2): 179–95.
27. T.F.G.Higham,, F.Brock, C.Bronk Ramsey, W.Davies, R.Wood, and L.Basell. 2011a. “Chronology of the Site of Grotte Du Renne, Arcy-Sur-Cure, France: Implications for Neanderthal Symbolic Behaviour.” Before Farming 2011 (2): 1–9.
28. T.F.G.Higham,, F.Brock, C.Bronk Ramsey, W.Davies, R.Wood, and L.Basell. 2011b. “Chronology of the Grotte du Renne, Arcy-sur-Cure, France: a Response to Zilhão et al. (this issue).” Before Farming 2011 (3): 1–5.
29. T.F.G.Higham,, R.Jacobi, M.Julien, F.David, L.Basell, R.Wood, W.Davies, and C.Bronk Ramsey. 2010. “Chronology of the Grotte Du Renne (France) and Implications for the Context of Ornaments and Human Remains within the Châtelperronian.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 107: 20234–39. doi:10.1073/pnas.1007963107.
30. -J.-J.Hublin,, S.Talamo, M.Julien, F.David, N.Connet, P.Bodu, B.Vendermeersch, and M.P.Richards. 2012. “Radiocarbon Dates from the Grotte du Renne and Saint-Césaire Support a Neanderthal Origin for the Châtelperronian.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 109 (46): 18743–48. doi:10.1073/pnas.1212924109.
31. 14C Time Scale – the Middle to Upper Palaeolithic Record of Western Eurasia.” Journal of Human Evolution 55: 782–802. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2008.04.002.
32. D.Killick, 2015. “The Awkward Adolescence of Archaeological Science.” Journal of Archaeological Science 56: 242–47. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2015.01.010.
33. S.McPherron,, S.Talamo, P.Goldberg, L.Niven, D.Sandgathe, M.P.Richards, D.Richter, A.Turq, and H.L.Dibble. 2012. “Radiocarbon Dates for the Late Middle Palaeolithic at Pech de l’Azé, France.” Journal of Archaeological Science 39: 3436–42. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2012.05.017.
34. P.Mellars, 1999. “CA Forum on Theory of Anthropology: The Neanderthal Problem Continued.” Current Anthropology 40: 341–64. doi:10.2307/2991402.
35. P.Mellars, 2004. “Neanderthals and the Modern Human Colonization of Europe.” Nature 432: 461–65. doi:10.1038/nature03103.
36. P.Mellars, 2010. “Neanderthal Symbolism and Ornament Manufacture: The Bursting of a Bubble?” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 107 (47): 20147–48. doi:10.1073/pnas.1014588107.
37. P.Mellars,, B.Gravina, and C.Bronk Ramsey. 2007. “Confirmation of Neanderthal/Modern Human Interstratifications at the Châtelperronian Type-site.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 104: 3657–62. doi:10.1073/pnas.0608053104.
38. A.R.Millard, 2003. “Taking Bayes Beyond Radiocarbon: Bayesian Approaches to Some Other Chronometric Methods.” In Tools for Constructing Chronologies: Crossing Disciplinary Boundaries, edited by C.E.Buck and A.R.Millard, 231–48. London: Springer.
39. A.Moroni,, P.Boscato, and A.Ronchitelli. 2013. “What Roots for the Uluzzian? Modern Behaviour in Central-Southern Italy and Hypotheses on AMH Dispersal Routes.” Quaternary International 316: 27–44. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2012.10.051.
40. P.B.Pettitt,, S.W.G.Davies, C.S.Gamble, and M.B.Richards. 2003. “Palaeolithic Radiocarbon Chronology: Quantifying Our Confidence Beyond Two Half-lives.” Journal of Archaeological Science 30: 1685–93. doi:10.1016/S0305-4403(03)00070-0.
41. S.Pirson,, D.Flas, G.Abrams, D.Bonjean, M.Court-Picon, K.Di Modica, C.Draily. et al. 2012. “Chronostratigraphic Context of the Middle to Upper Palaeolithic Transition: Recent Data from Belgium.” Quaternary International 259: 78–94. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2011.03.035.
42. P.J.Reimer,, M.G.L.Baillie, E.Bard, A.Bayliss, J.W.Beck, P.G.Blackwell, C.Bronk Ramsey. et al. 2009. “Intcal09 and Marine09 Radiocarbon Age Calibration Curves, 0-50,000 Years Cal BP.” Radiocarbon 51 (4): 1111–50.
43. P.J.Reimer,, E.Bard, A.Bayliss, J.W.Beck, P.G.Blackwell, C.Bronk Ramsey, C.E.Buck. et al. 2013. “Intcal13 and Marine13 Radicoarbon Age Calibration Curves 0-50,000 Years Cal BP.” Radiocarbon 55 (4): 1869–87. doi:10.2458/azu_js_rc.55.16947.
44. F.Riede,, and K.Edinborough. 2012. “Bayesian Radiocarbon Models for the Cultural Transition during the Allerød in Southern Scandinavia.” Journal of Archaeological Science 39: 744–56. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2011.11.008.
45. W.Roebroeks, 2008. “Time for the Middle to Upper Paleolithic Transition in Europe.” Journal of Human Evolution 55: 918–26. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2008.08.008.
46. 14C Dates of Chronologically Ordered Samples: A Critical Analysis.” Radiocarbon 42 (2): 183–98.
47. 14C Calibration.” Radiocarbon 43 (2A): 373–380.
48. 14C Is Confirmed.” Journal of Archaeological Science 39: 2464–67. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2012.01.042.
49. S.Talamo,, and M.Richards. 2011. “A Comparison of Bone Pretreatment Methods for AMS Dating of Samples >30,000 BP.” Radiocarbon 53 (3): 443–49.
50. S.Talamo,, M.Soressi, M.Roussel, M.Richards, and -J.-J.Hublin. 2012. “A Radiocarbon Chronology for the Complete Middle to Upper Palaeolithic Transitional Sequence of Les Cottés (France).” Journal of Archaeological Science 39: 175–83. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2011.09.019.
51. N.Teyssandier, 2003. “Les débuts de l’Aurignacien en Europe. Discussion à partir des sites de Geissenklösterle, Willendorf II, Krems-Hundsteig et Bacho Kiro.” PhD diss., University of Paris X.
52. P.C.Tzedakis,, K.A.Hughen, I.Cacho, and K.Harvati. 2007. “Placing Late Neanderthals in a Climatic Context.” Nature 449: 206–08. doi:10.1038/nature06117.
53. S.Unwin, 2003. The Probability of God. A Simple Calculation that proves the Ultimate Truth. New York: Three Rivers.
54. M.Vaquero,, and E.Carbonell. 2012. “Some Clarifications on the Middle-Upper Palaeolithic Transition in Abric Romaní: Reply to Camps and Higham (2012).” Journal of Human Evolution 63: 711–17. doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2012.07.007.
55. A.Verpoorte, 2005. “The First Modern Humans in Europe? A Closer Look at the Dating Evidence from the Swabian Jura (Germany).” Antiquity 79: 269–79.
56. M.J.Walker,, J.Gibert, M.V.López, A.V.Lombardi, A.Pérez-Pérez, J.Zapata, J.Ortega. et al. 2008. “Late Neanderthals in Southeast Iberia: Sima de las Palomas del Cabezo Gordo, Murcia, Spain.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 105: 20631–36. doi:10.1073/pnas.0811213106.
57. F.Weninger,, P.Steier, W.Kutschera, and E.M.Wild. 2010. “Robust Radiocarbon Analysis, an Attempt to Improve Bayesian Sequencing.” Radiocarbon 52 (2–3): 962–83.
58. M.J.White,, and P.B.Pettitt. 2012. “Ancient Digs and Modern Myths. the Context and Age of the Kent’s Cavern 4 Maxilla and the Spread of Homo Sapiens in Europe.” European Journal of Archaeology 15: 1–30. doi:10.1179/1461957112Y.0000000019.
59. R.Wood, 2015. “From Revolution to Convention: The Past, Present and Future of Radiocarbon Dating.” Journal of Archaeological Science 56: 61–72. (Radiocarbon 43(2A), 373-80). doi:10.1016/j.jas.2015.02.019.
60. J.Zilhão, 2006. “Chronostratigraphy of the Middle to Upper Paleolithic Transition in the Iberian Peninsula.” Pyrenae 37 (1): 7–84.
61. J.Zilhão, 2013. “Neandertal-Modern Human Contact in Western Eurasia: Issues of Dating, Taxonomy, and Cultural Associations.” In Dynamics of Learning in Neanderthals and Modern Humans. Volume 1: Cultural Perspectives, edited by T.Akazawa, Y.Nishiaki, and K.Aoki, 21–57. Replacement of Neanderthals by Modern Humans Series, Tokyo: Springer.
62. J.Zilhão,, J.L.Cardoso, A.W.G.Pike, and B.Weninger. 2011. “Gruta Nova da Columbeira (Bombarral, Portugal): Site Stratigraphy, Age of the Mousterian Sequence, and Implications for the Timing of Neanderthal Extinction in Iberia.” Quartär 58: 93–112.
63. J.Zilhão,, and F.d’Errico. 1999. “The Chronology and Taphonomy of the Earliest Aurignacian and its Implications for the Understanding of Neanderthal Extinction.” Journal of World Prehistory 13: 1–68. doi:10.1023/A:1022348410845.
64. J.Zilhão,, and F.d’Errico. 2003a. “The Chronology of the Aurignacian and Transitional Technocomplexes. Where do We Stand?” In The Chronology of the Aurignacian and of the Transitional Technocomplexes. Dating, Stratigraphies, Cultural Implications, edited by J.Zilhão and F.d’Errico, 313–49. Trabalhos de Arqueologia 45. Lisboa: Instituto Português de Arqueologia.
65. J.Zilhão,, and F.d’Errico. 2003b. “An Aurignacian ‘Garden of Eden’ in Southern Germany? An Alternative Interpretation of the Geissenklösterle and a Critique of the Kulturpumpe Model.” Paleo 15: 69–86.
66. J.Zilhão,, F.d’Errico, J.-G.Bordes, A.Lenoble, J.-P.Texier, and J.-P.Rigaud. 2006. “Analysis of Aurignacian Interstratifications at the Châtelperronian Type Site and Implications for the Behavioural Modernity of Neanderthals.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 103: 12643–48. doi:10.1073/pnas.0605128103.
67. J.Zilhão,, F.d’Errico, J.-G.Bordes, A.Lenoble, J.-P.Texier, and J.-P.Rigaud. 2008a. “Grotte des Fées (Châtelperron): History of Research, Stratigraphy, Dating, and Archaeology of the Châtelperronian Type-Site.” Paleoanthropology 2008: 1–42.
68. J.Zilhão,, F.d’Errico, J.-G.Bordes, A.Lenoble, J.-P.Texier, and J.-P.Rigaud. 2008b. “Like Hobbes’ Chimney Birds.” Paleoanthropology 2008: 65–67.
69. J.Zilhão,, F.d’Errico, M.Julien, and F.David. 2011. “Chronology of the Site of Grotte du Renne, Arcy-sur-Cure, France: Implications for Radiocarbon Dating.” Before Farming 2011 (3): 1–14. doi:10.3828/bfarm.2011.3.3.
70. J.Zilhão,, S.J.M.Davis, C.Duarte, A.M.M.Soares, P.Steier, and E.Wild. 2010. “Pego do Diabo (Loures, Portugal): Dating the Emergence of Anatomical Modernity in Westernmost Eurasia.” PLoS ONE 5 (1): e8880.
71. J.Zilhão,, and P.Pettitt. 2006. “On the New Dates for Gorham’s Cave and the Late Survival of Iberian Neanderthals.” Before Farming 2006 (3): 95–122.