Towards explaining the health impacts of residential energy efficiency interventions - A realist review. Part 1: Pathways

Social Science and Medicine

Volumn 133, Issue , 2015, Pages 191-201

  Willand, Nicola ^a   Ridley, Ian ^a   Maller, Cecily ^b  

^a RMIT UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b RMIT UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

Energy efficiency; Evidence; Health; Heating; Housing; Realist review; Wellbeing

Indexed keywords

ECONOMICS; ELECTRICITY; ENERGY CONSERVATION; ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH; FAMILY SIZE; HEALTH IMPACT ASSESSMENT; HUMAN; INDOOR AIR POLLUTION; INSURANCE; PROGRAM EVALUATION;

AIR POLLUTION, INDOOR; CONSERVATION OF ENERGY RESOURCES; ELECTRICITY; ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH; FAMILY CHARACTERISTICS; HEALTH IMPACT ASSESSMENT; HUMANS; INSURANCE BENEFITS; PROGRAM EVALUATION;

EID: 84939950956     PISSN: 02779536     EISSN: 18735347     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.02.005     Document Type: Review

References (97)

1. Barton A., Basham M., Foy C., Buckingham K., Somerville M. The Watcombe Housing Study: the short term effect of improving housing conditions on the health of residents. J.Epidemiol. Community Health 2007, 61(9):771-777.
2. Basham M. Qualitative study of central heating - its influence on the use of the house, the behaviour and relationships of the household particularly in wintertime. Paper Presented at the (Un)healthy Housing: Promoting Good Health, Coventry, UK 2003, http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/healthatwarwick/research/devgroups/healthyhousing/healthhousing_papers/bashampaper2.pdf.
3. Basham M., Shaw S., Barton A. Central heating: uncovering the impact on social relationships and household management 2004, A final report to the Eaga Partnership Charitable Trust, Exeter, (Peninsula Medical School, Eaga Partnership Charitable Trust).
4. Bone A., Murray V., Myers I., Dengel A., Crump D. Will drivers for home energy efficiency harm occupant health?. Perspect. Public Health 2010, 130(5):233-238. 10.1177/1757913910369092.
5. Braubach M., Ferrand A. Energy efficiency, housing, equity and health. Int. J. Public Health 2013, 58(3):331-332.
6. Braubach M., Heinen D., Dame J. Preliminary Results of the WHO Frankfurt Housing Intervention Project 2008, World Health Organization Europe, Copenhagen.
7. Breysse J., Jacobs D.E., Weber W., Dixon S., Kawecki C., Aceti S., Lopez J. Health outcomes and Green renovation of affordable housing. Public Health Rep. 2011, 126(Suppl.1):64-75.
8. Combat Poverty Agency, & Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes. Fuel Poverty Action Research Report 1: Executive Summary Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes 2009, Department of Social and Family Affairs.
9. Combat Poverty Agency, & Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes. Fuel Poverty Action Research Report 3: Health Impacts Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes 2009, Department of Social and Family Affairs.
10. Combat Poverty Agency, & Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes. Fuel Poverty Action Research Report 4: Comfort and Indoor Temperature Impacts Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes 2009, Department of Social and Family Affairs.
11. Combat Poverty Agency, & Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes. Fuel Poverty Action Research Report 5: Household Expenditure on Fuel and Electricity Effectiveness of Domestic Energy Efficiency Programmes 2009, Department of Social and Family Affairs.
12. Chapman R., Howden-Chapman P., O'Dea D. ACost-benefit Evaluation of Housing Insulation: Results from the New Zealand 'Housing, Insulation and Health' Study 2004, Wellington School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Wellington.
13. Clinch J.P., Healy J.D. Cost-benefit analysis of domestic energy efficiency. Energy Policy 2000, 29(2):113-124. 10.1016/S0301-4215(00)00110-5.
14. Collins K. Cold- and heat-related illnesses in the indoor environment. Unhealthy Housing. Research, Remedies and Reform 1993, 117-140. E & F Spon, London. R. Burridge, D. Ormandy (Eds.).
15. Critchley R., Gilbertson J., Grimsley M., Green G. Living in cold homes after heating improvements: Evidence from Warm Front, England's Home Energy Efficiency Scheme. Appl. Energy 2007, 84(2):147-158. 10.1016/j.apenergy.2006.06.001.
16. El Ansari W., El-Silimy S. Are fuel poverty reduction schemes associated with decreased excess winter mortality in elders? A case study from London, UK. Chronic Illn. 2008, 4(4):289-294. 10.1177/1742395308090620.
17. Fisk W.J., Lei-Gomez Q., Mendell M.J. Meta-analyses of the associations of respiratory health effects with dampness and mold in homes. Indoor Air 2007, 17(4):284-296. 10.1111/j.1600-0668.2007.00475.x.
18. Fung J., Porteous C.D.A., Sharpe T. Lifestyle as a mediator between energy efficiency and air quality in the home 2006, Paper presented at HB 2006 - Healthy Buildings: Creating a Healthy Indoor Environment for People.
19. Gilbertson J., Stevens M., Stiell B., Thorogood N. Home is where the hearth is: grant recipients' views of England's Home Energy Efficiency Scheme (Warm Front). Soc. Sci. Med. 2006, 63(4):946-956. 10.1016/j.socscimed.2006.02.021.
20. Gilbertson J., Grimsley M., Green G. Psychosocial routes from housing investment to health: evidence from England's home energy efficiency scheme. Energy Policy 2012, 49:122-133. 10.1016/j.enpol.2012.01.053.
21. Green, G., Gilbertson, J., Warm Front better health. Health impact evaulation of the Warm Front Scheme, Centre for Regional, Economic and Social Research - Sheffield Hallam University.
22. Green G., Ormandy D., Brazier J., Gilbertson J. Tolerant building: the impact of energy efficiency measures on living conditions and health status. Cutting the Cost of Cold: Affordable Warmth for Healthier Homes 2000, 87-103. E & F Spon, London. J. Rudge, F. Nicol (Eds.).
23. Guerra Santin O. Occupant behaviour in energy efficient dwellings: evidence of a rebound effect. J.Hous. Built Environ. 2012, 28(2):311-327. 10.1007/s10901-012-9297
24. Gupta R., Gregg M. Using UK climate change projections to adapt existing English homes for a warming climate. Build. Environ. 2012, 55:20-42. 10.1016/j.buildenv.2012.01.014.
25. Harrington B.E., Heyman B., Merleau-Ponty N., Stockton H., Ritchie N., Heyman A. Keeping warm and staying well: findings from the qualitative arm of the Warm Homes Project. Health Soc. Care Community 2005, 13(3):259-267.
26. Heyman B., Harrington B.E., Merleau-Ponty N., Stockton H., Ritchie N., Allan T.F. Keeping warm and staying well. Does home energy efficiency mediate the relationship between socio-economic status and the risk of poorer health?. Hous. Stud. 2005, 20(4):649-664.
27. Heyman B., Harrington B., Heyman A., The National Energy Action Research Arandomised controlled trial of an energy efficiency intervention for families living in fuel poverty. Hous. Stud. 2011, 26(1):117-132. 10.1080/02673037.2010.512787.
28. Hong S.H., Ridley I., Oreszczyn T., The Warm Front Study Group The impact of energy efficient refurbishment on the airtightness in English dwellings. Paper Presented at the 25th AVIC Conference 2004.
29. Hong S.H., Oreszczyn T., Ridley I. The impact of energy efficient refurbishment on the space heating fuel consumption in English dwellings. Energy Build. 2006, 38(10):1171-1181. 10.1016/j.enbuild.2006.01.007.
30. Hong S.H., Gilbertson J., Oreszczyn T., Green G., Ridley I. Afield study of thermal comfort in low-income dwellings in England before and after energy efficient refurbishment. Build. Environ. 2009, 44(6):1228-1236. 10.1016/j.buildenv.2008.09.003.
31. Hopton J., Hunt S. The health effects of improvements to housing: a longitudinal study. Hous. Stud. 1996, 11(2):271-286. 10.1080/02673039608720856.
32. Howden-Chapman P., Matheson A., Crane J., Viggers H., Cunningham M., Blakely T., Davie G. Retrofitting houses with insulation to reduce health inequalities: A community-based randomised trial. Paper Presented at the Second WHO Conference on Housing and Health, Vilnius, Lithuania 2004.
33. Howden-Chapman P., Matheson A., Crane J., Viggers H., Cunningham M., Blakely T., Davie G. Effect of insulating existing houses on health inequality: cluster randomised study in the community. Br. Med. J. 2007, 334(7591):460-464.
34. Howden-Chapman P., Pierse N., Nicholls S., Gillespie-Bennett J., Viggers H., Cunningham M., Crane J. Effects of improved home heating on asthma in community dwelling children: randomised controlled trial. Br. Med. J. 2008, 337:a1411. 10.1136/bmj.a1411.
35. Iversen M., Bach E., Lundqvist G.R. Health and comfort changes among tenants after retrofitting of their housing. Environ. Int. 1986, 12(1-4):161-166. 10.1016/0160
36. Jacobs D.E., Breysse J., Dixon S.L., Aceti S., Kaweck C., James M., Wilson J. Health and housing outcomes from green renovation of low-income housing in Washington, DC. J.Environ. Health 2014, 76(7):8-16.
37. Jagosh J., Pluye P., Macaulay A.C., Salsberg J., Henderson J., Sirett E., Green L.W. Assessing the outcomes of participatory research: protocol for identifying, selecting, appraising and synthesizing the literature for realist review. Implement. Sci. 2011, 6:24. 10.1186/1748-5908-6-24
38. Johnson V., Sullivan D. Improving the energy efficiency of homes in Moreland. Research sample, baseline measures and recruitment for the Warm Home Cool Home program evaluation 2011, Brotherhood of St Laurence, Melbourne.
39. Johnson V., Sullivan D., Totty J. Improving the energy efficiency of homes in Moreland 2013, Brotherhood of St Laurence, Melbourne.
40. Kearns A., Hiscock R., Ellaway A., MaCintyre S. Beyond four walls. The psycho-social benefits of Home: evidence from West Central Scotland. Hous. Stud. 2000, 15(3):387-410. 10.1080/02673030050009249.
41. Kearns A., Whitley E., Mason P., Petticrew M., Hoy C. Material and meaningful homes: mental health impacts and psychosocial benefits of rehousing to new dwellings. Int. J. Public Health 2011, 56(6):597-607. 10.1007/s00038-011-0275-3.
42. Liddell C., Morris C. Fuel poverty and human health: a review of recent evidence. Energy Policy 2010, 38(6):2987-2997. 10.1016/j.enpol.2010.01.037.
43. Lloyd C.R., Callau M.F., Bishop T., Smith I.J. The efficacy of an energy efficient upgrade program in New Zealand. Energy Build. 2008, 40(7):1228-1239. 10.1016/j.enbuild.2007.11.006.
44. Lloyd E.L., McCormack C., McKeever M., Syme M. The effect of improving the thermal quality of cold housing on blood pressure and general health: a research note. J.Epidemiol. Community Health 2008, 62(9):793-797.
45. Maidment C.D., Jones C.R., Webb T.L., Hathway E.A., Gilbertson J.M. The impact of household energy efficiency measures on health: a meta-analysis. Energy Policy 2013, 65(February 2014):583-593. 10.1016/j.enpol.2013.10.054i.
46. Manuel J. Avoiding health pitfalls of home energy-efficiency retrofits. Environ. Health Perspect. 2011, 119(2):A76-A79.
47. Marmot Review Team The Health Impacts of Cold Homes and Fuel Poverty (Pp. Marmot Review Team) 2011, University College London, London.
48. Míguez J.L., Porteiro J., López-González L.M., Vicuña J.E., Murillo S., Morán J.C., Granada E. Review of the energy rating of dwellings in the European Union as a mechanism for sustainable energy. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2006, 10(1):24-45. 10.1016/j.rser.2004.08.003.
49. Milner J., Shrubsole C., Das P., Jones B., Ridley I., Chalabi Z., Wilkinson P. Home energy efficiency and radon related risk of lung cancer: modelling study. BMJ 2014, 348:f7493. 10.1136/bmj.f7493
50. Morse J.M. Principles of mixed methods and multimethod research design. Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social & Behavioral Research 2003, Sage. A. Tashakkori, C. Teddlie (Eds.).
51. Noris F., Adamkiewicz G., Delp W.W., Hotchi T., Russell M., Singer B.C., Fisk W.J. Indoor environmental quality benefits of apartment energy retrofits. Build. Environ. 2013, 68:170-178. 10.1016/j.buildenv.2013.07.003.
52. Oreszczyn T., Hong S.H., Ridley I., Wilkinson P. Determinants of winter indoor temperatures in low income households in England. Energy Build. 2006, 38(3):245-252.
53. Oreszczyn T., Ridley I., Hong S., Wilkinson P., Warm Front Study Group Mould and winter indoor relative humidity in low income households in England. Indoor Built Environ. 2006, 15(2):125-135. 10.1177/1420326x06063051.
54. Ormandy D., Ezratty V. Health and thermal comfort: from WHO guidance to housing strategies. Energy Policy 2012, 49:116-121. 10.1016/j.enpol.2011.09.003.
55. Osman L.M., Ayres J.G., Garden C., Reglitz K., Lyon J., Douglas J.G., Ludbrook A. The effect of energy efficiency improvement on health status of COPD patients. AReport to the Eaga Partnership Charitable Trust: Eaga Partnership Charitable Trust 2008.
56. Osman L.M., Ayres J.G., Garden C., Reglitz K., Lyon J., Douglas J.G. Arandomised trial of home energy efficiency improvement in the homes of elderly COPD patients. Eur. Respir. J. 2010, 35(2):303-309.
57. Paulin L.M., Diette G.B., Scott M., McCormack M.C., Matsui E.C., Curtin-Brosnan J., Hansel N.N. Home interventions are effective at decreasing indoor nitrogen dioxide concentrations. Indoor Air 2014, 24(4):416-424. 10.1111/ina.12085.
58. Pawson R. Digging for nuggets: how 'Bad' research can yield 'Good' evidence. Int. J. Soc. Res. Methodol. 2006, 9(2):127-142. 10.1080/13645570600595314.
59. Pawson R. The Science of Evaluation: A Realist Manifesto 2013, Sage Publications.
60. Pawson R., Greenhalgh T., Harvey G., Walshe K. Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions. J.Health Serv. Res. Policy. Suppl. 2005, 10(Suppl.1):S1:21-S21:34.
61. Pérez-Lombard L., Ortiz J., González R., Maestre I.R. Areview of benchmarking, rating and labelling concepts within the framework of building energy certification schemes. Energy Build. 2009, 41(3):272-278. 10.1016/j.enbuild.2008.10.004.
62. Pierse N., Arnold R., Keall M., Howden-Chapman P., Crane J., Cunningham M., Heating Housing and Health Study Group Modelling the effects of low indoor temperatures on the lung function of children with asthma. J.Epidemiol. Community Health 2013, 67(11):918-925. 10.1136/jech2013-202632.
63. Platt S., Mitchell R., Petticrew M., Walker J., Hopton J., Martin C., Hope S. The Scottish Executive Central Heating Programme: assessing impacts on health 2007, Scottish Executive Social Research, Edinburgh.
64. Pretlove S.E.C., Critchley R., Howard R., Oreszczyn T. The Nottingham energy, health and housing study: reducing relative humidity, dust mites and asthma. Build. Serv. Eng. Res. Technol. 2002, 23(1):43-55. 10.1191/0143624402bt030oa.
65. Richardson G., Eick S.A. The paradox of an energy-efficient home: is it good or bad for health?. Community Pract. 2006, 79(12):397-399.
66. Richardson G., Barton A., Basham M., Foy C., Eick S.A., Somerville M. The Watcombe housing study: the short-term effect of improving housing conditions on the indoor environment. Sci. Total Environ. 2006, 361(1-3):73-80. doi. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2005.05.007.
67. Rudge J., Winder R. Central heating installation for older, low income households: what difference does it make?. Paper presented at the Indoor Air 2002 2002.
68. Rugkåsa J., Shortt N., Boydell L. Engaging Communities. An Evaluation of a Community Development Model for Tackling Rural Fuel Poverty 2004, Institute of Public Health in Ireland, Dungannon, Northern Ireland.
69. Sharpe T. Adapting the Scottish tenement to twenty-first century standards: an evaluation of the performance enhancement of a nineteenth century "Category B" listed tenement block in Edinburgh. J.Cult. Herit. Manag. Sustain. Dev. 2013, 3(1):55-67. 10.1108/20441261311317400.
70. Sheldrick B., Hepburn D. Assessing the Impact of the Central Heating Programme on Tackling Fuel Poverty: Report on the Second Year of the Programme 2006, Scottish Executive Development Department.
71. Sheldrick B., Hepburn D. Assessing the Impact of the Central Heating Programme on Tackling Fuel Poverty: The First Three Years of the Programme 2001-2004 2007, Scottish Executive Social Research, Edinburgh, Final Report.
72. Shortt N., Rugkåsa J. The walls were so damp and cold" fuel poverty and ill health in Northern Ireland: results from a housing intervention. Health Place 2007, 13(1):99-110.
73. 2.5 exposure in London's domestic stock: modelling current and future exposures following energy efficient refurbishment. Atmos. Environ. 2012, 62:336-343.
74. Sixsmith J. The meaning of home: an exploratory study of environmental experience. J.Environ. Psychol. 1986, 6(4):281-298.
75. Somerville M., Mackenzie I., Owen P., Miles D. Housing and health: does installing heating in their homes improve the health of children with asthma?. Public Health 2000, 114(6):434-439. 10.1038/sj.ph.1900687.
76. Somerville M., Basham M., Foy C., Ballinger G., Gay T., Barton A.G. From local concern to randomized trial: the Watcombe housing project. Health Expect. 2002, 5(2):127-135.
77. Sustainability Victoria Drivers of Demand for Zero and towards Zero Emissions Residential Retrofits 2012, ASBEC, Melbourne.
78. Takaro T.K., Krieger J., Song L., Sharify D., Beaudet N. The impact of asthma-friendly Home. Construction on clinical outcomes and trigger exposure. Am. J. Public Health 2001, 101(1):55-62. 10.2105/ajph.2010.
79. Telfar-Barnard L., Preval N., Howden-Chapman P., Arnold R., Young C., Grimes A., Denne T. The impact of retrofitted insulation and new heaters on health services utilisation and costs, pharmaceutical costs and mortality. Evaluation of Warm Up New Zealand: Heat Smart. Report to the Ministry of Economic Development 2011, Ministry of Economic Development, Wellington.
80. Thomson H., Thomas S. Developing empirically supported theories of change for housing investment and health. Soc. Sci. Med. 2015, 214:205-214. 10.1016/j.socscimed.2014.11.043.
81. Thomson H., Petticrew M., Morrison D. Health effects of housing improvement: systematic review of intervention studies. Br. Med. J. 2001, 323:187-190.
82. Thomson H., Thomas S., Sellstrom E., Petticrew M. The health impacts of housing improvement: a systematic review of intervention studies from 1887 to 2007. Am. J. Public Health 2009, 99(S3):S681-S692. 10.2105/ajph.2008.143909.
83. Thomson H., Thomas S., Sellstrom E., Petticrew M. Housing Improvements for Health and Associated Socioeconomic Outcomes (Review) 2013, The Cochrane Library, The Cochrane Library.
84. Tuomainen M., Tuomainen A., Liesivuori J., Pasanen A.-L. The 3-year follow-up study in a block of ats - experiences in the use of the Finnish indoor climate classification. Indoor Air 2003, 13(2):136-147.
85. Walker J., Mitchell R., Petticrew M., Platt S. The effects on health of a publicly funded domestic heating programme: a prospective controlled study. J.Epidemiol. Community Health 2009, 63(1):12-17.
86. Weaver A. Retrofitting Conventional Houses Inexpensively to Improve Energy Efficiency 2004, (Masters of Environmental Studies), University of Tasmania, Hobart.
87. WHO Closing the Gap in a Generation: Health Equity through Action on the Social Determinants of Health 2008, World Health Organization, Geneva, Final Report of the Commission on Social Determinants of Health.
88. WHO Europe Large Analysis and Review of European Housing and Health Status (LARES) 2007, WHO Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Preliminary overview.
89. WHO Expert Group Biological agents in indoor environments. Assessment of health risks 2009, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane. A. Nevalainen, L. Morawska (Eds.).
90. Wilkinson P., Landon M., Armstrong B., Stevenson S., Pattenden Sam, McKee M., Fletcher T. Cold Comfort. The Social and Environmental Determinants of Excess Winter Deaths in England, 1986-96 2001, The Policy Press.
91. Wilkinson P., Armstrong B., Oreszczyn T., Green G., Warm Front Study Group Health and environmental benefits of domestic energy efficiency: evidence from the UK. Epidemiology 2005, 16(5):S99.
92. Wilkinson P., Smith K.R., Davies M., Adair H., Armstrong B.G., Barrett M., Chalabi Z. Public health benefits of strategies to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions: household energy. Lancet 2009, 374(9705):1917-1929.
93. Williamson T., Grant E., Hansen A., Pisaniello D., Andamon M. An Investigation of Potential Health Benefits from Increasing Energy Efficiency Stringency Requirements 2009, University of Adelaide, Adelaide.
94. Wilson J., Dixon S.L., Jacobs D.E., Breysse J., Akoto J., Tohn E., Hernandez Y. Watts-to-Wellbeing: does residential energy conservation improve health?. Energy Effic. 2014, 7(1):151-160. 10.1007/s12053-013-9216-8.
95. Wilson J., Dixon S.L., Jacobs D.E., Breysse J., Akoto J., Tohn E., Hernandez Y. Watts-to-Wellbeing: does residential energy conservation improve health?. Erratum. Energy Effic. 2014, 7(1):151-160. 10.1007/s12053-013-9216-8.
96. Wong G., Greenhalgh T., Westhrop G., Pawson R. Quality Standards for Realist Syntheses and Meta-narrative Reviews 2014, Queen Mary University of London., London.
97. Xing Y., Hewitt N., Griffiths P. Zero carbon buildings refurbishment--A hierarchical pathway. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2011, 15:3229-3236. 10.1016/j.rser.2011.04.020.