Reviving Rylands: How the doctrine could be used to claim compensation for environmental damages caused by fracking

Review of European, Comparative and International Environmental Law

Volumn 23, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 134-143

  Costello, Rõisín Áine ^a  

^a TRINITY COLLEGE DUBLIN   (Ireland)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; HUMAN ACTIVITY;

IRELAND; UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84939204343     PISSN: 20500386     EISSN: 20500394     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/reel.12059     Document Type: Review

References (86)

1. Rylands v. Fletcher, [1868] UKHL 1.
2. BBC, "What is Fracking: The Process Explained in 15 Seconds", BBC News (13 December 2012), found at: <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-20710481>. Gas extracted through fracking is commonly referred to as "shale gas".
3. BBC, "What is Fracking and Why is It Controversial?", BBC News (27 June 2013), found at: <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk- 14432401>.
4. Join the Debate, The Economist (2 March 2013), found at: <http://www.economist.com/debate/overview/246>.
5. D.C. Holzman, "Methane Found in Well Water Near Fracking Sites", 119:7 Environmental Health Perspectives (2011), 289.
6. Bureau of Oil and Gas Regulation, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, Preliminary Revised Draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement on the Oil and Gas and Mining Regulatory Program (2009), found at: <http://www.dec.ny.gov/data/dmn/ogprdsgeisfull.pdf>, Chapter 6
7. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Hydraulic Fracturing Research Study (2010), at 1.
8. M. McCarthy, "Fracking for Gas Allowed in UK Despite Earthquakes", The Independent (17 April 2012), found at: <http://www .independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/fracking-for-gas-allowed-inuk- despite-earthquakes-7648265.html>.
9. Shale Gas in Europe and America: Fracking Here, Fracking There, The Economist (26 November 2011) (Fracking Here, Fracking There).
10. H. Rogers, "Shale Gas: The Unfolding Story", 27:1 Oxford Review of Economic Policy (2011), 117, at 118
11. The Hunt for Shale Gas in Europe, The Economist (3 December 2009) (The Hunt for Shale Gas).
12. The Hunt for Shale Gas, n. 8 above.
13. Fracking Here, Fracking There, n. 7 above.
14. Irish Petroleum and Other Minerals Development Act 1960, Section 35. For the full text of the Act, see: <http://www.irishstatutebook .ie/1960/en/act/pub/0007/index.html>.
15. Rylands v. Fletcher, n. 1 above.
16. Transco plc v. Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council, [2003] UKHL 61 (Transco), at paragraph 29.
17. Burnie Port Authority v. General Jones Pty, [1994] 179 CLR 520.
18. Cambridge Water Co. Ltd v Eastern Counties Leather plc, [1994] 1 All ER 53 (Cambridge Water).
19. Transco, n. 20 above.
20. Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v. Morts Dock and Engineering Co Ltd., [1961] UKPC 1.
21. Ballard v. Tomlinson, [1885] 29 ChD 115.
22. Precedent and Analogy in Legal Reasoning, in: The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2006), found at: <http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/legal-reas-prec/index.html#PreLayDowRul>, at paragraph 2.1.2.
23. Cambridge Water, n. 23 above, at 7.
24. Transco, n. 20 above, at paragraphs 89.
25. Healy v. Bray UDC, [1962/1963] 3 Ir Jur Rep 9.
26. Mullen v. Forrester, [1921] 2 IR 412.
27. Transco, n. 20 above, at paragraph 29.
28. Wildtree Hotels Ltd v. Harrow London Borough Council, [2001] 2 AC 1, at 89.
29. Mark Stannard (t/a Wyvern Tyres) v. Robert Raymond Harvey Gore, [2012] EWCA Civ 1248.
30. Jones v. Festiniog Railway Company, [1868] LR 3 QB 733.
31. Musgrove v. Pandelis, [1919] 2 KB 43.
32. Mason v. Levy Auto Parts of England Ltd, [1967] 2 QB 530 per MacKenna J, at 542.
33. W. Binchy, "Recent Developments in the Law of Torts", 4:1 Judicial Studies Institute Journal (2004), 8.
34. Fiorentino v Cabot & Gas Corp, 50 F.Supp. 2d. 506 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 15, 2010) (Fiorentino).
35. C. Bateman, "A Colossal Fracking Mess", Vanity Fair (21 June 2010), found at: <http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2010/06/fracking-in-pennsylvania-201006>.
36. Fiorentino, n. 46 above.
37. L.S. Rubin, "Frack to the Future: Considering a Strict Liability Standard for Hydraulic Fracturing Activities", 3:1 George Washington Journal of Energy and Environmental Law (2012), 117, at 121.
38. Press Release, Pennsylvania. Department of Environmental Protection, "DEP Secretary Issues Open Letter to Citizens of Susquehanna County Community Impacted by Ongoing Gas Migration Issues" (19 October 2010), found at: <http://www.portal.state.pa.us/portal/server.pt/community/newsroom/14287?id=14827&typeid=1>.
39. URS Corporation, Engineering Study (2009), found at: <http://www.pressconnects.com/assets/pdf/CB1446181016 .PDF>, at 1-3.
40. Fiorentino, n. 46 above.
41. Memorandum of Law in Support of Defendants" Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint, Fiorentino, ibid., at 1.
42. Berish v. Southwestern Energy Production Co., 2011 WL 382420 (MD Pa. 3 February 2011).
43. F.C. Woodside III, M.L. Silbersack, T.L. Fliehman and D.J. Feichtner, "Why Absolute Liability under Rylands v. Fletcher is Absolutely Wrong!", 29:1 Dayton Law Review (2003), 1.
44. R. Byrne and P. McCutcheon, Byrne and McCutcheon on the Irish Legal System, 5th edn (Bloomsbury, 2009), at 403.
45. Bella v. Aurora Air Inc., 279 Or. 13, 566 P 2d 489 (1977)
46. Gotreaux v. Gary, 232 La 373, 94 So 2d 293 (1957)
47. Young v. Darter, 363 P.2d 829 (Okla. 1961).
48. Loe v. Lenhardt, 227 Or. 242, 362 P.2d 312 (1961).
49. Bella v. Aurora Air Inc., n. 62 above.
50. C.A. Kennedy, "Liability in the Aerial Application of Pesticides", 22:1 South Dakota Law Review (1977), 75
51. Boroughs v. Joiner, 337 So. 2d 340 (Ala. 1976)
52. Christensen v. Midstate Aerial Applicators Corp, 166 N.W.2d 386 (ND 1969).
53. Bella v. Aurora Air Inc., n. 62 above, at paragraph 24.
54. United States v. Causby, 328 US 256 (1946).
55. Coastal Oil and Gas Corp USA v. Garza Energy Trust et al., No. 05-0466, 2008 WL 3991029 (Tex. 29 August 2008) (Coastal Oil and Gas Corp USA).
56. Steve Crawford, S&M Oil Company v. Marvin Hrabe, Bruce Krob, Lucille Rogers and Patricia Irey (2002) Kan Sup Ct No 87/624 (Steve Crawford, S&M Oil Company).
57. Justice Willett"s concurrence in Coastal Oil and Gas Corp USA, n. 68 above.
58. Steve Crawford, S&M Oil Company, n. 69 above, at paragraph 7.
59. Starrh & Starrh Cotton Growers v. Area Energy LLC, [2007] Sup. Ct. No. CV 245287.
60. Northern Natural Gas Company v. Tract No. 1062710 et al., Case No. 10-1232-MLB-DWB.
61. Clean Air Act, 42 USC 7401ff. (1970).
62. Clean Water Act, 33 USC 1251ff. (1972).
63. Safe Drinking Water Act, 42 USC 300ff. (1974).
64. M. Brume, Executive Director of the Sierra Club, found at: <http://www.economist.com/debate/days/view/934>.
65. M. Hennessy and D. Keenan, "Tax Breaks Encourage Search for Shale Gas; Exploration", Irish Times (21 March 2013).
66. D. Healy, Hydraulic Fracturing or "Fracking": A Short Summary of Current Knowledge and Potential Environmental Impacts (Environmental Protection Agency 2012)
67. "No "Fracking" until Further Study, Says Rabbitte", Irish Times (14 May 2012).
68. F. Convery and Y. Scannell, "Fracking and Local Credibility in Ireland" (30 May 2012), found at: <http://www.irishenvironment.com/commentary/frank-convery-and-yvonne-scannell-fracking-and-localcredibility- in-ireland>.
69. Glencar Exploration plc v. Mayo County Council, [2002] 1 ILRM 481.
70. <http://www.dcenr.gov.ie/Natural/>.
71. Directive 2004/35/CE of 21 April 2004 on Environmental Liability with Regard to the Prevention and Remedying of Environmental Damage, [2004] OJ L143/56.
72. Consolidated Version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, [2010] OJ C83/47, Article 191.2.
73. ECJ, Case T-13/99, Pfizer Animal Health v. Council, [2002] ECR II-3305, at paragraph 149.
74. ECJ, Case C-41/02, Commission v. Netherlands (Dutch Vitamins), [2004] ECR I-11375.
75. M.A. Recuerda Girela, "Risk and Reason in the European Union Law", 1:5 European Food and Feed Law Review (2006), 270.
76. Irish Planning and Development Act 2000, found at: <http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/2000/en/act/pub/0030/>, Articles 3, 4.1 and 4.2.
77. Superquinn v. Bray UDC, [1998] 3 IR 542.
78. Gertsen v. Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto, [1973] DLR (3d) 641.
79. Dockery v. Manor Park Homebuilders Ltd, High Court 10 April 1995 (OHanlon J).
80. Poplar Homes Ltd v. Society of African Missions Trustees, [1997] Ir L Log W 367 (Laffroy J).
81. Cambridge Water, n. 23 above.
82. Smeaton v. Ilford Corporation, [1954] Ch 450.
83. Hanrahan v. Merck Sharpe and Dohme (Ireland) Ltd, [1988] IESC 1.
84. Theres Gold in Them There Wells, The Economist (21 December 2013), found at: <http://www.economist.com/news/christmasspecials/21591748-theres-gold-them-there-wells>.
85. M. Davis, "Lessons Unlearned: The Legal and Policy Legacy of the BP Deep-water Horizon Spill", 3:2 Washington and Lee Journal of Energy, Climate and Environment (2012), 155.
86. A Nolkaemper "Responsibility of Transnational Corporations in International Environmental Law: Three Perspectives", in: G. Winter (ed.), Multilevel Governance of Global Environmental Changes: Perspectives from Science Sociology and the Law (Cambridge University Press, 2006), 179, at 179-180.