Defining and measuring urban sustainability: a review of indicators

Landscape Ecology

Volumn 30, Issue 7, 2015, Pages 1175-1193

  Huang, Lu ^a   Wu, Jianguo ^b,c   Yan, Lijiao ^a  

^a ZHEJIANG UNIVERSITY   (China)

^b ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c BEIJING NORMAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

Author keywords

Indicator frameworks; Landscape sustainability; Sustainable cities; Urban sustainability indicators; Urbanization

Indexed keywords

ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS; LANDSCAPE ECOLOGY; SPATIAL ANALYSIS; SUSTAINABILITY; URBAN AREA; URBANIZATION;

EID: 84934830263     PISSN: 09212973     EISSN: 15729761     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s10980-015-0208-2     Document Type: Review

References (122)

1. Alberti M (1996) Measuring urban sustainability. Environ Impact Assess Rev 16:381–424
2. Anielski M, Johannessen H (2009) The Edmonton 2008 Genuine Progress Indicator Report, Edmonton
3. Ayres RU (2000) Commentary on the utility of the ecological footprint concept. Ecol Econ 32:347–349
4. Batty M (2011) When all the world’s a city. Environment and Planning A 43(4):765–772
5. Baumann H (2010) Life cycle assessments (LCAs). In: Christensen K, Fogel D, Wagner G, Whitehouse P (eds) Berkshire encyclopedia of sustainability, vol II., The business of sustainabilityBerkshire Publishing, Great Barrington, pp 309–314
6. Bell S, Morse S (2008) Sustainability indicators: measuring the immeasurable?. Earthscan, London
7. Bohringer C, Jochem PEP (2007) Measuring the immeasurable—a survey of sustainability indices. Ecol Econ 63(1):1–8
8. Braat L (1991) The predictive meaning of sustainability indicators. In: Kuik O, Verbruggen H (eds) In search of indicators of sustainable development. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 57–70
9. Bringezu S, Schutz H, Moll S (2003) Rational for and interpretation of economy-wide materials flow analysis and derived indicators. J Ind Ecol 7:43–64
10. Camagni R (1998) Sustainable urban development: definition and reasons for a research programme. Int J Environ Pollut 10(1):6–27
11. Chester M, Pincetl S, Allenby B (2012) Avoiding unintended tradeoffs by integrating life-cycle impact assessment with urban metabolism. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 4(4):451–457
12. Clark WC, Dickson NM (2003) Sustainability science: the emerging research program. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA), vol 100, pp. 8059–8061
13. Costanza R, Erickson J, Fligger K, Adams A, Adams C, Altschuler B, Balter S, Fisher B, Hike J, Kelly J, Kerr T, McCauley M, Montone K, Rauch M, Schmiedeskamp K, Saxton D, Sparacino L, Tusinski W, Williams L (2004) Estimates of the Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) for Vermont, Chittenden County and Burlington, from 1950 to 2000. Ecol Econ 51(1–2):139–155
14. Daly HE (1995) On Wilfred Beckerman’s critique of sustainable development. Environ Values 4:49–55
15. Daly HE, Cobb J (1989) For the common good: redirecting the economy towards community, the environment, and a sustainable future. Beacon Press, Boston
16. Decker EH, Elliott S, Smith FA, Blake DR, Rowland FS (2000) Energy and material flow through the urban ecosystem. Annu Rev Energy Environ 25:685–740
17. Dietz S, Neumayer E (2007) Corruption, the resource curse and genuine saving. Environ Dev Econ 12:33–53
18. Eddy IMS, Gergel SE (2015) Why landscape ecologists should contribute to life cycle sustainability approaches. Landscape Ecol. doi:10.1007/s10980-014-0135-7
19. Ekins P (2011) Environmental sustainability: from environmental valuation to the sustainability gap. Prog Phys Geog 35(5):629–651
20. Ekins P, Simon S (1999) The sustainability gap: a practical indicator of sustainability in the framework of the national accounts. Int J Sustain Dev 2:32–58
21. Ekins P, Simon S, Deutsch L, Folke C, De Groot R (2003) A framework for the practical application of the concepts of critical natural capital and strong sustainability. Ecol Econ 44:165–185
22. Elmqvist T, Fragkias M, Goodness J, Güneralp B, Marcotullio PJ, McDonald RI, Parnell S, Schewenius M, Sendstad M, Seto KC, Wilkinson C (eds) (2013) Urbanization, biodiversity and ecosystem services: challenges and opportunities. Springer, Dordrecht
23. Esty DC, Levy MA, Srebotnjak T, de Sherbinin A (2005) Environmental Sustainability Index: Benchmarking National Environmental Stewardship. Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy, New Haven
24. Eurostat (2001) Economy-wide material flow accounts and derived indicators: a methodological guide. Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg
25. Fiala N (2008) Measuring sustainability: Why the ecological footprint is bad economics and bad environmental science. Ecol Econ 67:519–525
26. Finnveden G, Hauschild MZ, Ekvall T, Guinee J, Heijungs R, Hellweg S, Koehler A, Pennington D, Suh S (2009) Recent developments in life cycle assessment. J Environ Manag 91:1–21
27. Fischer J, Manning AD, Steffen W, Rose DB, Daniell K, Felton A, Garnett S, Gilna B, Heinsohn R, Lindenmayer DB, MacDonald B, Mills F, Newell B, Reid J, Robin L, Sherren K, Wade A (2007) Mind the sustainability gap. Trends Ecol Evol 22(12):621–624
28. Fischer-Kowalski M, Krausmann F, Giljum S, Lutter S, Mayer A, Bringezu S, Moriguchi Y, Schutz H, Schandl H, Weisz H (2011) Methodology and indicators of economy-wide material flow accounting: state of the art and reliability across sources. J Ind Ecol 15:855–875
29. Forman RTT (2008) Urban regions: ecology and planning beyond the city. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
30. Gallopin GC (1997) Indicators and their use: information for decision-making. In: Moldan B, Billharz S (eds) Sustainability indicators. Wiley, New York, pp 13–28
31. Goldstein B, Birkved M, Quitzau MB, Hauschild M (2013) Quantification of urban metabolism through coupling with the life cycle assessment framework: concept development and case study. Environ Res Lett 8(3):035024
32. Golubiewski N (2012) Is there a metabolism of an urban ecosystem? An ecological critique. Ambio 41(7):751–764
33. Greasley D, Hanley N, Kunnas J, McLaughlin E, Oxley L, Warde P (2014) Testing genuine savings as a forward-looking indicator of future well-being over the (very) long-run. J Environ Econ Manag 67(2):171–188
34. Grimm NB, Faeth SH, Golubiewski NE, Redman CL, Wu J, Bai X, Briggs JM (2008) Global change and the ecology of cities. Science 319(5864):756–760
35. Haberl H, Fischer-Kowalski M, Krausmann F, Weisz H, Winiwarter V (2004) Progress towards sustainability? What the conceptual framework of material and energy flow accounting (MEFA) can offer. Land Use Policy 21:199–213
36. Hak T, Moldan B, Dahl AL (eds) (2007) Sustainability Indicators: a scientific assessment. Island Press, Washington, D.C
37. Hamilton K, Clemens M (1999) Genuine savings rates in developing countries. World Bank Econ Rev 13(2):333–356
38. Hamilton A, Mitchell G, Yli-Karjanmaa S (2002) The BEQUEST toolkit: a decision support system for urban sustainability. Buil Res Inform 30(2):109–115
39. Holland A (1997) Substitutability: or, why strong sustainability is weak and absurdly strong sustainability is not absurd. In: Foster J (ed) Valuing nature? Ethics, economics and the environment. Routledge, London, pp 119–134
40. Hsu A, Emerson J, Levy M, Sherbinin Ad, Johnson L, Malik O, Schwartz J, Jaiteh M (2014) The 2014 Environmental Performance Index. Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy, New Haven. Available from http://www.epi.yale.edu
41. Huang S-L, Chen L-L (2002) Urban indicators as measurement of Taiwan’s sustainability. In: Douglas I, Huang S-L (eds) Urbanization, East Asia and habitat II. Chung-Hua Institution of Economic Research, Taipei, pp 237–254
42. Huang SL, Hsu WL (2003) Materials flow analysis and emergy evaluation of Taipei’s urban construction. Landsc Urban Plan 63(2):61–74
43. Huang SL, Wong JH, Chen TC (1998) A framework of indicator system for measuring Taipei’s urban sustainability. Landsc Urban Planning 42(1):15–27
44. Iverson L, Echeverria C, Nahuelhual L, Luque S (2014) Ecosystem services in changing landscapes: an introduction. Landscape Ecol 29(2):181–186
45. Jollands N (2006) How to aggregate sustainable development indicators: a proposed framework and its application. Intern J Agricul Resour Govern Ecol 5:18–34
46. Jones KB, Zurlini G, Kienast F, Petrosillo I, Edwards T, Wade T, Li B-l, Zaccarelli N (2013) Informing landscape planning and design for sustaining ecosystem services from existing spatial patterns and knowledge. Landscape Ecol 28(6):1175–1192
47. Kates RW, Clark WC, Corell R, Hall JM, Jaeger CC, Lowe I, McCarthy JJ, Schellnhuber HJ, Bolin B, Dickson NM, Faucheux S, Gallopin GC, Grubler A, Huntley B, Jager J, Jodha NS, Kasperson RE, Mabogunje A, Matson P, Mooney H, Moore III B, O'Riordan T, Svedin U (2001) Sustainability Science. Science 292:641–642
48. Kennedy C, Pincetl S, Bunje P (2011) The study of urban metabolism and its applications to urban planning and design. Environ Pollut 159(8–9):1965–1973
49. Kennedy C, Stewart ID, Ibrahim N, Facchini A, Mele R (2014) Developing a multi-layered indicator set for urban metabolism studies in megacities. Ecol Ind 47:7–15
50. Krajnc D, Glavi P (2005) A model for integrated assessment of sustainable development. Resour Conserv Recycl 43(2):189–208
51. Kubiszewski I, Costanza R, Franco C, Lawn P, Talberth J, Jackson T, Aylmer C (2013) Beyond GDP: measuring and achieving global genuine progress. Ecol Econ 93:57–68
52. Lawn PA (2003) A theoretical foundation to support the Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare (ISEW), Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI), and other related indexes. Ecol Econ 44:105–118
53. Lee Y-J, Huang C-M (2007) Sustainability index for Taipei. Environ Impact Assess Rev 27(6):505–521
54. Leigh A, Wolfers J (2006) Happiness and the human development index: Australia is not a paradox. Aust Econ Rev 39(2):176–184
55. Li C, Li J, Wu J (2013) Quantifying the speed, growth modes, and landscape pattern changes of urbanization: a hierarchical patch dynamics approach. Landscape Ecol 28:1875–1888
56. Liu ZF, He CY, Zhou YY, Wu JG (2014) How much of the world’s land has been urbanized, really? A hierarchical framework for avoiding confusion. Landscape Ecol 29:763–771
57. Luck M, Jenerette GD, Wu J, Grimm NB (2001) The urban funnel model and the spatially heterogeneous ecological footprint. Ecosystems 4:782–796
58. Meadows D (ed) (1998) Indicators and information systems for sustainable development. Sustainability Institute, Hartland Four Corners
59. Mega V (2013) Insights from the future: trends, risks, and opportunities. Springer, New York
60. Mega V, Pedersen J (1998) Urban Sustainability Indicators. European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin
61. Moffatt I (2000) Ecological footprints and sustainable development. Ecol Econ 32:359–362
62. Moldan B, Billharz S (eds) (1997) Sustainability indicators: report of the project on indicators of sustainable development. Wiley, New York
63. Moldan B, Janoušková S, Hák T (2012) How to understand and measure environmental sustainability: Indicators and targets. Ecol Ind 17:4–13
64. Morse S, McNamara N, Acholo M, Okwoli B (2001) Sustainability indicators: the problem of integration. Sustain Dev 9:1–15
65. Morse S, Vogiatzakis I, Griffiths G (2011) Space and sustainability: potential for landscape as a spatial unit for assessing sustainability. Sustain Dev 19:30–48
66. Munier N (2007) Handbook on urban sustainability. Springer, Dordrecht
67. Nardo M, Saisana M, Saltelli A, Tarantola S (2005) Tools for composite indicators building. European Commission, EUR 21682 EN, Institute for the Protection and Security of the Citizen, Ispra
68. Nassauer JI, Wu JG, Xiang WN (2014) Actionable urban ecology in China and the world: integrating ecology and planning for sustainable cities. Landsc Urban Plan 125:207–208
69. New Economics Foundation (2009) THE HAPPY PLANET INDEX 2.0
70. NRC (1999) Our common journey: a transition toward sustainability. National Academy Press, Washington D.C
71. NRC (2004) Materials count: the case for material flows analysis. National Academies Press, Washington D.C
72. OECD (1993) OECD Core set of indicators for environmental performance reviews. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris
73. Olewiler N (2006) Environmental sustainability for urban areas: the role of natural capital indicators. Cities 23(3):184–195
74. Pearce DW, Atkinson GD (1993) Capital theory and the measurement of sustainable development: an indicator of “weak” sustainability. Ecol Econ 8:103–108
75. Pickett STA, Cadenasso ML, Grove JM, Boone CG, Groffman PM, Irwin E, Kaushal SS, Marshall V, McGrath BP, Nilon CH, Pouyat RV, Szlavecz K, Troy A, Warren P (2011) Urban ecological systems: scientific foundations and a decade of progress. J Environ Manag 92(3):331–362
76. Pillarisetti JR (2005) The World Bank’s ‘genuine savings’ measure and sustainability. Ecol Econ 55(4):599–609
77. Pincetl S, Bunje P, Holmes T (2012) An expanded urban metabolism method: toward a systems approach for assessing urban energy processes and causes. Landsc Urban Plan 107(3):193–202
78. Posner SM, Costanza R (2011) A summary of ISEW and GPI studies at multiple scales and new estimates for Baltimore City, Baltimore County, and the State of Maryland. Ecol Econ 70(11):1972–1980
79. Potschin M, Haines-Young R (2013) Landscapes, sustainability and the place-based analysis of ecosystem services. Landscape Ecol 28(6):1053–1065
80. Powers CM, Dana G, Gillespie P, Gwinn MR, Hendren CO, Long TC, Wang A, Davids JM (2012) Comprehensive environmental assessment: a meta-assessment approach. Environ Sci Technol 46:9202–9208
81. Prescott-Allen R (1997) Barometer of sustainability. In: Moldan B, Billharz S, Matravers R (eds) Sustainability indicators: a report on the project on indicators of sustainable development. Wiley, Chichester, pp 133–137
82. Prescott-Allen R (2001) The wellbeing of nations: a country-by-country index of quality of life and the environment. Island Press, Washington, Covelo, London
83. Raudsepp-Hearne C, Peterson GD, Tengo M, Bennett EM, Holland T, Benessaiah K, MacDonald GK, Pfeifer L (2010) Untangling the environmentalalist’s paradox: why is human well-being increasing as ecosystem services degrade? Bioscience 60:576–589
84. Rees WE (1996) Revisiting carrying capacity: area-based indicators of sustainability. Popul Environ: J Interdiscip Stud 17(3):195–215
85. Rees WE (2000) Eco-footprint analysis: merits and brickbats. Ecol Econ 32(3):371–374
86. Rees W, Wackernagel M (1996) Urban ecological footprints: Why cities cannot be sustainable and why they are a key to sustainability. Environ Impact Assess Rev 16:223–248
87. Rogers P, Srinivasan S (2007) Comparing sustainable cities: examples from China, India and the USA. In: Keiner M (ed) Sustainable development in China: Wishful thinking or reality? Monsenstein and Vannerdat, Munich, pp 85–110
88. Shen L-Y, Jorge Ochoa J, Shah MN, Zhang X (2011) The application of urban sustainability indicators—a comparison between various practices. Habitat Intern 35(1):17–29
89. Stanners D, Bourdeau P (1995) Europe’s environment: the DobriS assessment. Eur Environ Agency, Copenhagen
90. Talberth J, Cobb C, Slattery N (eds) (2006) The Genuine Progress Indicator 2006: a tool for sustainable development. Redefining progress, The nature of economics. http://www.rprogress.org
91. Tanguay GA, Rajaonson J, Lefebvre J-Fo, Lanoie P (2010) Measuring the sustainability of cities: an analysis of the use of local indicators. Ecol Indic 10(2):407–418
92. Turner II BL, Lambin EF, Reenberg A (2007) The emergence of land change science for global environmental change and sustainability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol 104, pp. 20666–20671
93. Turner BL II, Janetos AC, Verburg PH, Murray AT (2013) Land system architecture: using land systems to adapt and mitigate global environmental change. Glob Environ Change 23(2):395–397
94. UN-Habitat (2002) Global Urban Indicators Database Version 2. United Nations Human Settlements Programme
95. UN-Habitat (2012) State of the World’s Cities 2012/2013: Prosperity of Cities. United Nations Human Settlements Programme
96. United Nations (2007) Indicators of sustainable development: guidelines and methodologies, 3rd edn. United Nations, New York
97. United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat) (1997) Regional development planning and management of urbanization: experiences from developing countries. United Nations Centre for Human Settlements, Nairobi
98. United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-Habitat) (1996) The habitat agenda goals and principles, commitments and the global plan of action. http://www.un-documents.net/ha-1.htm
99. Van de Kerk G, Manuel AR (2008) A comprehensive index for a sustainable society: the SSI—the Sustainable Society Index. Ecol Econ 66(2–3):228–242
100. van den Bergh JCJM, Grazi F (2010) On the policy relevance of ecological footprints. Environ Sci Technol 44:4843–4844
101. van den Bergh JCJM, Verbruggen H (1999) Spatial sustainability, trade and indicators: an evaluation of the ‘ecological footprint’. Ecol Econ 29:61–72
102. Venetoulis J, Cobb C (2004) The Genuine Progress Indicator 1950–2002 (2004 Update). San Francisco
103. Verburg PH, Erb K-H, Mertz O, Espindola G (2013) Land System Science: between global challenges and local realities. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 5(5):433–437
104. Wackernagel M, Rees WE (1996) Our ecological footprint: reducing human impact on the earth. New Society Publishers, British Columbia
105. Wackernagel M, Schulz NB, Deumling D, Linares AC, Jenkins M, Kapos V, Monfreda C, Loh J, Myers N, Norgaard R, Randers J (2002) Tracking the ecological overshoot of the human economy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 99:9266–9271
106. WCED (1987) Our common future. Oxford University Press, New York
107. Wen ZG, Zhang KM, Huang L, Du B, Chen WQ, Li W (2005) Genuine saving rate: an integrated indicator to measure urban sustainable development towards an ecocity. Int J Sustain Dev World Ecol 12(2):184–196
108. Wen Z, Zhang K, Du B, Li Y, Li W (2007) Case study on the use of genuine progress indicator to measure urban economic welfare in China. Ecol Econ 63:463–475
109. Wieldmann T, Barrett J (2010) A review of the ecological footprint indicator—perceptions and methods. Sustainability 2:1645–1693
110. Wolman A (1965) The metabolism of cities. Sci Am 213(3):179–190
111. World Bank (1997) Expanding the measure of wealth: indicators of environmentally sustainable development. The World Bank, Washington, D.C.
112. Worldwatch Institute (2007) State of the world: our urban future. W.W. Norton & Company, New York, London
113. Wu JG (1999) Hierarchy and scaling: extrapolating information along a scaling ladder. Can J Remote Sens 25(4):367–380
114. Wu JG (2010) Urban sustainability: an inevitable goal of landscape research. Landscape Ecol 25(1):1–4
115. Wu JG (2013) Landscape sustainability science: ecosystem services and human well-being in changing landscapes. Landscape Ecol 28(6):999–1023
116. Wu JG (2014) Urban ecology and sustainability: The state-of-the-science and future directions. Landsc Urban Plan 125:209–221
117. Wu JG, Wu T (2010) Green GDP. In: Christensen K, Fogel D, Wagner G, Whitehouse P (eds) Berkshire encyclopedia of sustainability, vol II., The business of sustainabilityBerkshire Publishing, Great Barrington, pp 248–250
118. Wu JG, Wu T (2012) Sustainability indicators and indices: an overview. In: Madu CN, Kuei C (eds) Handbook of Sustainable Management. Imperial College Press, London, pp 65–86
119. Wu JG, Xiang W-N, Zhao JZ (2014) Urban ecology in China: Historical developments and future directions. Landsc Urban Plan 125:222–233
120. Zhang K, Wen Z, Du B, Song G (2008) A multiple-indicators approach to monitoring urban sustainable development. In: Carreiro MM, Song YC, Wu JG (eds) Ecology, planning and management of urban forests: international perspectives. Springer, New York, pp 35–52
121. Zhao JZ (2011) Towards sustainable cities in China: analysis and assessment of some Chinese Cities in 2008. Springer, New York
122. Zhao CR, Zhou B, Su X (2014) Evaluation of urban eco-security—a case study of Mianyang City, China. Sustainability 6(4):2281–2299