The whole language-phonics controversy: An historical perspective

Educational Psychology

Volumn 17, Issue 4, 1997, Pages 399-418

  Hempenstall, Kerry ^a  

^a RMIT UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84933479809     PISSN: 01443410     EISSN: 14695820     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/0144341970170403     Document Type: Article

References (91)

1. Adams, M.J., 1990. Beginning to Read: thinking and learning about print, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
2. Adams, M.J., and Bruck, M., 1995. Word recognition: the interface of educational policies and scientific research. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 5: 113–139.
3. Anderson, R.C., Hiebert, E.H., Scott, J.A., and Wilkinson, I.A.G., 1985. Becoming a Nation of Readers: the report of the Commission on Reading, Champaign, IL: The Centre for the Study of Reading.
4. Arter, J.A., and Jenkins, J.R.V., 1979. Differential diagnosis-prescriptive teaching: a critical appraisal. Review of Educational Research, 49: 517–555.
5. Australian Government House of Representatives Enquiry. 1993. The Literacy Challenge, Canberra: Australian Printing Office.
6. Ball, E.W., 1993. Phonological awareness: what's important and to whom?. Reading & Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 5: 141–159.
7. Barmby, S., Bonham, D., Lawry, F., and Nissner, H., 1986. Real Literacy: shifting the focus, Vic, Australia: Maroondah Region Publication.
8. Bateman, B., 1991. Teaching word recognition to slow learning children. Reading, Writing and Learning Disabilities, 7: 1–16.
9. Becker, W.C., and Gersten, R., 1982. A follow-up of Follow Through: the later effects of the Direct Instruction model on children in fifth and sixth grades. American Educational Research Journal, 19: 75–92.
10. Bereiter, C., and Kurland, M., 1981. A constructive look at Follow Through results. Interchange, 12: 1–22.
11. Bond, G.L., and Dykstra, R., 1967. The co-operative research program in first grade reading instruction. Reading Research Quarterly, 2: 5–142.
12. Carbo, M., 1988. Debunking the great phonics myth. Phi Delta Kappan, 70: 226–240.
13. Carbo, M., 1992. Giving unequal learners an equal chance: a reply to a biased critique of learning styles. Remedial and Special Education, 13: 19–29.
14. Carnine, D., Approaches to Reading: psycholinguistics and Direct Instruction methods. Paper presented at the Conference of the Australian Association for Direct Instruction. NSW: Kuringai CAE.
15. Carnine, D., 1995. Trustworthiness, useabiliry, and accessibility of educational research. Journal of Behavioral Education, 5: 251–258.
16. Carnine, D., and Silbert, J., 1979. Direct Instruction Reading, Columbus, OH: Charles Merrill.
17. Castle, J.M., Riach, J., and Nicholson, T., 1994. Getting off to a better start in reading and spelling: the effects of phonemic awareness instruction within a whole language classroom. Journal of Educational Psychology, 86: 350–359.
18. Chall, J.S., 1967. The Great Debate, New York: McGraw Hill.
19. Chall, J.S., 1979. “ The great debate: ten years later, with a modest proposal for reading stages ”. In Theory and Practice in Early Reading, Edited by: Resnick, L.B., and Weaver, P.A., Vol. 1, 29–54. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
20. Chaney, C., 1990. Evaluating the Whole Language approach to language arts: the pros and cons. Language, Speech, and Hearing in Schools, 21: 244–249.
21. Crowder, R., and Wagner, R., 1992. The Psychology of Reading: an introduction, New York: Oxford University Press.
22. Davis, A., 1988. “ A historical perspective ”. In Teaching Reading, 3rd edn, Edited by: Estill Alexander, J., 532–553. USA: Scott, Foresman & Co.
23. Davis, W., 1973. Teaching Reading in Early England, London: Pitman.
24. Dunn, R., Beaudry, J.S., and Klavas, A., 1989. Survey of research on learning styles. Educational Leadership, March: 50–58.
25. Edelsky, C., 1990. Whose agenda is this anyway? A response to McKenna, Robinson & Miller. Educational Researcher, 19: 7–11.
26. Eldredge, L., 1991. An experiment with a modified whole language approach in first grade classrooms. Reading Research and Instruction, 30: 21–38.
27. Engelmann, S., and Bruner, E.C., 1988. Reading Mastery, Chicago, IL: Science Research Associates.
28. Fields, B.A., and Kempe, A., 1992. Corrective feedback in Whole Language teaching: implications for children with learning problems. Australian Journal of Special Education, 16: 22–31.
29. Flesch, R., 1955. Why Johnny Can't Read, New York: Harper & Row.
30. Foorman, B.R., 1995. Research on ‘The Great Debate’: code-oriented versus Whole Language approaches to reading instruction. School Psychology Review, 24: 376–392.
31. Francis, W.N., 1965. The English Language: an introduction, New York: Norton.
32. Gable, R.A., and Warren, S.F., 1993. “ The enduring value of instructional research ”. In Advances in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities: strategies for teaching students with mild to severe mental retardation, Edited by: Gable, R., and Warren, S., 1–7. Philadelphia, PA: Jessica Kingsley.
33. Gersten, R., and Dimino, J., 1993. Visions and revisions: a special education perspective on the Whole Language controversy. Remedial & Special Education, 14: 5–13.
34. Gersten, R., Keating, T., and Becker, W., 1988. The continued impact of the Direct Instruction model: longitudinal studies of Follow Through students. Education and Treatment of Children, 11: 318–327.
35. Gibson, E., and Levin, H., 1978. The Psychology of Reading, USA: MIT, MA.
36. Goodman, K.S., 1986. What's Whole in Whole Language, Richmond Hill, Ontario: Scholastic.
37. Goodman, K.S., 1989. Whole Language is whole: a response to Heymsfeld. Educational Leadership, March: 69–72.
38. Groff, P., 1990. An analysis of the debate: teaching reading without conveying phonics information. Interchange, 21: 1–14.
39. Hempenstall, K., 1996. The gulf between educational research and policy: the example of direct instruction and Whole Language. Behaviour Change, 13: 33–46.
40. Henry, M.K., 1993. The role of decoding in reading research and instruction. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 5: 105–112.
41. Heymsfeld, C.R., 1989. Filling the hole in Whole Language. Educational Leadership, March: 65–68.
42. House, E.R., Glass, G.V., McLean, L.D., and Waler, D.F., 1978. No simple answer: critique of the Follow Through evaluation. Harvard Educational Review, 48: 128–160.
43. Huang, H.S., and Hanley, R., 1994. Phonological awareness and visual skills in learning to read Chinese and English. Cognition, 54: 73–98.
44. Iverson, S., and Tunmer, W.E., 1993. Phonological processing skills and the Reading Recovery program. Journal of Educational Psychology, 85: 112–126.
45. Johnson, B., and Stone, E., 1991. Is whole language restructuring our classroom?. Contemporary Education, 62: 102–104.
46. Kameenui, E.J., and Simmons, D.C., 1990. Designing Instructional Strategies: the prevention of academic learning problems, Columbus, OH: Merrill.
47. Klesius, J.P., Griffith, P.L., and Zielonka, P., 1991. A Whole Language and traditional instruction cmparison: overall effectiveness and development of the alphabetic principle. Reading Research & Instruction, 30: 47–61.
48. Kirsch, I., and Guthrie, J., 1984. Adult reading practices for work and leisure. Adult Education Quarterly, 34: 213–232.
49. Liberman, I.Y., and Liberman, A.M., 1990. Whole Language vs. Code Emphasis: underlying assumptions and their implications for reading instruction. Annals of Dyslexia, 40: 51–75.
50. Mather, N., 1992. Whole Language reading instruction for students with learning disabilities: caught in the cross fire. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 7: 87–95.
51. McCaslin, M.M., 1989. Whole Language: theory, instruction, and future implementation. The Elementary School Journal, 90: 223–229.
52. McGee, L.M., and Lomax, R.G., 1990. On combining apples and oranges: a response to Stahl & Miller. Review of Educational Research, 60: 133–140.
53. McGinitie, W.H., 1991. Reading instruction: plus ça change. Educational Leadership, March: 55–58.
54. McKenna, M.C., Robinson, R.D., and Miller, J.W., 1990a. Whole Language and the need for open enquiry: a rejoinder to Edelsky. Educational Researcher, 19: 12–13.
55. McKenna, M.C., Robinson, R.D., and Miller, J.W., 1990b. Whole Language: a research agenda for the nineties. Educational Researcher, 19: 3–6.
56. McKenna, M.C., Stahl, S.A., and Reinking, D., 1994. A critical commentary on research, politics, and Whole Language. Journal of Reading Behavior, 26: 211–233.
57. Meyer, L.A., Gersten, R.M., and Gutkin, J., 1983. Direct Instruction: a project Follow Through success story in an inner-city school. The Elementary School Journal, 84: 241–252.
58. National Commission on Excellence in Education. 1983. A Nation at Risk: the imperative for educational reform, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
59. Newman, J.M., 1991. Whole language: a changed universe. Contemporary Education, 62: 70–75.
60. Pollack, M., and Pickarz, J., 1963. Reading Programs and Problem Readers, New York: David McKay.
61. Rayner, K., and Pollatsek, A., 1989. The Psychology of Reading, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
62. Rosenshine, B.V., and Stevens, R., 1984. “ Classroom instruction in reading ”. In Handbook of Reading Research, 3rd edn, Edited by: Pearson, D., 376–391. New York: MacMillan.
63. Roth, S.F., and Beck, I.L., 1987. Theoretical and instructional implications of the assessment of two microcomputer word recognition programs. Reading Research Quarterly, 22: 197–218.
64. Schweinhart, L.J., Weikart, D.P., and Larner, W.B., 1986. Consequences of three pre-school curriculum models through age 15. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 1: 15–45.
65. Shannon, P., 1994. “ People who live in glass houses ”. In Whole Language: the debate, Edited by: Smith, C.B., 97–120. Bloomington, IN: ERIC.
66. Share, D.L., 1995. Phonological recoding and self-teaching: sine qua non of reading acquisition. Cognition, 55: 151–218.
67. Singer, H., and Balow, I.H., 1981. “ Overcoming educational disadvantageness ”. In Comprehension and Teaching: research review, Edited by: Guthrie, J.T., 101–114. Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
68. Smith, F., 1978. Understanding Reading, New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
69. Smith, F., 1992. Learning to read: the never-ending debate. Phi Delta Kappan, 74: 432–441.
70. Smith, P.G., 1991. A practical guide to whole language in the intermediate classroom. Contemporary Education, 62: 88–95.
71. Smith, S.B., Simmons, D.C., and Kameenui, E.J., 1995. Synthesis of Research on Phonological Awareness: principles and implications for reading acquisition NCITE Technical Report No. 21 (On-line) [http:darkwing.uoregon.edu/∼ncite/reading/PhonoSyn.html]
72. Snider, V.E., 1992. Learning styles and learning to read: a critique. Remedial and Special Education, 13: 6–18.
73. Spear-Swerung, L., and Sternberg, R.J., 1994. The road not taken: an integrative theoretical model of reading disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 27: 91–103.
74. Spiegel, D.L., 1992. Blending Whole Language and systematic direct instruction. The Reading Teacher, 46: 38–44.
75. Stahl, S.A., 1990. Riding the pendulum: a rejoinder to Schickedanz, and McGee & Lomax. Review of Educational Research, 60: 141–151.
76. Stahl, S.A., 1992. Saying the “p” word: Nine guidelines for exemplary phonics instruction. The Reading Teacher, 45(8): 618–625.
77. Stahl, S.A., and Kuhn, M.R., 1995. Does Whole Language or instruction matched to learning styles help children learn to read?. School Psychology Review, 24: 393–404.
78. Stahl, S.A., and Miller, P.D., 1989. Whole Language and language experience approaches for beginning reading: a quantitative research synthesis. Review of Educational Research, 59: 87–116.
79. Stahl, S.A., McKenna, M.C., and Pagnucco, J.R., 1994. The effect of Whole Language instruction: an update and a reappraisal. Educational Psychologist, 29: 175–185.
80. Stanovich, K.E., 1986. Matthew effects in reading: some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21: 360–406.
81. Stanovich, K.E., 1993. “ The language code: issues in word recognition ”. In Reading Across the Life Span, Edited by: Yussen, S.R., and Smith, M.C., 111–135. New York: Springer-Verlag.
82. Stanovich, K.E., 1994. Romance and reality. The Reading Teacher, 47: 280–291.
83. Stedman, L., and Kaestle, C., 1987. Literacy and reading performance in the United States, from 1880 to the present. Reading Research Quarterly, 23: 8–46.
84. Stone, J.E., 1996. Developmentalism: an obscure but pervasive restriction on educational improvement. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 23 April On-line 4, 1950 lines [http:seamonkey.ed.asu.edu/epaa]
85. Sykes, S., 1991. A Whole Language perspective on reading and writing. Australian Journal of Remedial Education, 23: 23–27.
86. Tunmer, W.E., and Hoover, W.A., 1993. Phonological recording skill and beginning reading. Reading & Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 5: 161–179.
87. Vellutino, F.R., 1991. Introduction to three studies on reading acquisition: convergent findings on theoretical foundations of code-oriented versus whole-language approaches to reading instruction. Journal of Educational Psychology, 83: 437–443.
88. Weaver, C., 1988. Reading Process and Practice: from socio-psycholinguistics to Whole Language, Portsmouth, New York: Heinemann Educational Books.
89. Weir, R., 1990. Philosophy, cultural beliefs and literacy. Interchange, 21: 24–33.
90. Weisberg, P., and Savard, C.F., 1993. Teaching preschoolers to read: don't stop between the sounds when segmenting words. Education & Treatment of Children, 16: 1–18.
91. Yates, G.C.R., 1988. Classroom research into effective teaching. Australian Journal of Remedial Education, 20: 4–9.