The ambiguity of "Distinguishability" in statistical mechanics

American Journal of Physics

Volumn 83, Issue 6, 2015, Pages 545-554

  Swendsen, Robert H ^a  

^a CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84930208622     PISSN: 00029505     EISSN: 19432909     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1119/1.4906793     Document Type: Article

References (40)

1. R. H. Swendsen, " How physicists disagree on the meaning of entropy," Am. J. Phys. 79, 342-348 (2011).
2. R. H. Swendsen, " Statistical mechanics of classical systems with distinguishable particles," J. Stat. Phys. 107, 1143-1165 (2002).
3. R. H. Swendsen, " Statistical Mechanics of Classical Distinguishable Particles," in Computer Simulation Studies in Condensed Matter Physics XV, edited by D. P. Landau, S. P. Lewis, and H. B. Schttler (Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg, Berlin, 2003).
4. R. H. Swendsen, " Response to nagle's criticism of my proposed definition of the entropy," J. Stat. Phys. 117, 1063-1070 (2004).
5. R. H. Swendsen, " Statistical mechanics of colloids and Boltzmann's definition of the entropy," Am. J. Phys. 74, 187-190 (2006).
6. R. H. Swendsen, " Gibbs' paradox and the definition of entropy," Entropy, 10, 15-18 (2008).
7. R. H. Swendsen, " Choosing a definition of entropy that works," Found. Phys. 42, 582-593 (2012).
8. R. H. Swendsen, An Introduction to Statistical Mechanics and Thermodynamics (Oxford, London, 2012).
9. R. H. Swendsen, " Unnormalized probability: A different view of statistical mechanics," Am. J. Phys. 82, 941-946 (2014).
10. S. Ross and I. D. Morrison, Colloidal Systems and Interfaces (Wiley, New York, 1988).
11. L. Boltzmann, " Über die Beziehung zwischen dem zweiten Hauptsatze der mechanischen Wärmetheorie und der Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung respektive den Sätzen Über das Wärmegleichgewicht," Wien. Ber. 76, 373-435 (1877), reprinted in Wissenschaftliche Abhandlungen von Ludwig Boltzmann (Chelsea, New York, 1968), Vol. II, pp. 164-223. Available at http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=L.+Boltzmann+1877&btnG=&hl= en&as_sdt=0%2C39.
12. M. Planck, " Über das Gesetz der Energieverteilung im Normalspektrum," Drudes Annalen, 553-562 (1901), reprinted in Ostwalds Klassiker der exakten Wissenschaften, Band 206, " Die Ableitung der Strahlungsgesteze," pp. 65-74. The equation is given with an arbitrary additive constant on p. 68 of the reprinted text
13. M. Planck, Theorie der Wärmestrahlung (J. A. Barth, Leipzig, 1906), translated into English by Morton Masius in M. Planck, The Theory of Heat Radiation (Dover, New York, 1991), p. 119.
14. J. W. Gibbs, Elementary Principles of Statistical Mechanics (Yale U.P., New Haven, 1902), reprinted by Dover, New York, 1960.
15. O. Wiedeburg, " Das Gibbs'sche Paradoxon," Ann. Phys. 289, 684-697 (1894).
16. D. Dieks, " Is There a Unique Physical Entropy? Micro versus Macro," in New Challenges to Philosophy of Science (The Philosophy of Science in a European Perspective), edited by H. Andersen, D. Dieks, W. Gonzalez, T. Uebel, and G. Wheeler (Springer, New York, 2013).
17. N. G. van Kampen, " The Gibbs paradox," in Essays in Theoretical Physics, edited by W. E. Parry (Pergamon, Oxford, 1984).
18. J. F. Nagle, " Regarding the entropy of distinguishable particles," J. Stat. Phys. 117, 1047-1062 (2004).
19. J. F. Nagle, " In defense of gibbs and the traditional definition of the entropy of distinguishable particles," Entropy 12, 1936-1945 (2010).
20. C.-H. Cheng, " Thermodynamics of the system of distinguishable particles," Entropy 11, 326-333 (2009).
21. D. Dieks and M. A. M. Versteegh, " Identical quantum particles and weak discernibility," Found. Phys. 38, 923-934 (2008)
22. M. A. M. Versteegh and D. Dieks, " The Gibbs paradox and the distinguishability of identical particles," Am. J. Phys. 79, 741-746 (2011).
23. H. Peters, " Statistics of distinguishable particles and resolution of the gibbs paradox of the first kind," J. Stat. Phys. 141, 785-828 (2010).
24. H. Peters, " Demonstration and resolution of the Gibbs paradox of the first kind," Eur. J. Phys. 35, 015023 (2014).
25. E. T. Jaynes, " The Gibbs' Paradox," in Maximum Entropy and Bayesian Methods, edited by C. R. Smith, G. J. Erickson, and P. O. Neudorfer (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1992), pp. 1-21.
26. J. L. Lebowitz and C. Maes, " Entropy: A Dialogue," in Entropy, edited by A. Greven, G. Keller, and G. Warnecke (Princeton U. P., Princeton, 2003), .
27. D. S. Corti, " Comment on 'The Gibbs paradox and the distinguishability of identical particles,' by M. A. M. Versteegh and D. Dieks [Am. J. Phys. 79, 741-746 (2011)]," Am. J. Phys. 80, 170-173 (2012).
28. P. Enders, " Are there physical systems obeying the Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics?," Apeiron 16(4), 555-556 (2009).
29. P. Enders, " Equality and Identity and (In)distinguishability in Classical and Quantum Mechanics from the Point of View of Newton's Notion of State," in Frontiers of Fundamental and Computational Physics, Proc. 6th Int. Symp., Udine, Italy, 26-29 September, 2004, edited by B. G. Sidharth, F. Honsell, and A. de Angelis (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006), pp. 239-245.
30. P. Enders, " Gibbs' paradox in the light of Newton's notion of state," Entropy 11, 454-456 (2009).
31. A. Bach, Indistinguishable Classical Particles (Springer, Berlin, 1997).
32. A. Bach, " Boltzmann's probability distribution of 1877," Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 41, 1-40 (1990). Available at http://scholar.google.com/ scholar?hl=en&q=A.+Bach%2C+%E2%80%9CBoltzmann%E2%80%99s+ probability+distribution+of+1877%2C%E2%80%9D+Arch.+Hist.+Exact+ Sci.+41%2C+1%E2%80%9340+%281990%29.&btnG=&as_sdt=1%2C39 &as_sdtp=.
33. S. Saunders, " On the explanation for quantum statistics," Stud. His. Philos. Mod. Phys. 37, 192-211 (2006).
34. S. Saunders, " Indistinguishability," in Handbook of Philosophy of Physics, edited by R. Batterman (Oxford, London, 2013).
35. S. Saunders, " Identity," in Compendium of Quantum Physics: Concepts, Experiments, History and Philosophy, edited by Friedel Weinert, Klaus Hentschel, and Dan Greenberger (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2009).
36. D. Hestenes, " Entropy and indistinguishability," Am. J. Phys. 38, 840-845 (1970).
37. S. Fujita, " On the indistinguishability of classical particles," Found. Phys. 21, 439-457 (1991).
38. D. Dieks and A. Lubberdink, " How classical particles emerge from the quantum world," Found. Phys. 41, 1051-1064 (2011).
39. D. Dieks, private communication.
40. A. Ben-Naim, A Farewell to Entropy: Statistical Thermodynamics Based on Information (World Scientific, Singapore, 2008).