The new ethnic politics of welfare: Struggles over legal immigrants' rights to welfare in California

Journal of Poverty

Volumn 6, Issue 3, 2002, Pages 29-62

  Reese, Ellen ^a   Ramirez, Elvia ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

Asian Americans; Ethnic politics; Framing; Immigrants; Latinos; Political opportunity model; Resource mobilization; Social movement; Welfare reform; Welfare rights

Indexed keywords

EID: 84929069681     PISSN: 10875549     EISSN: 15407608     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1300/J134v06n03_02     Document Type: Article

References (102)

1. Abramovitz, M. 1989. Regulating the lives of women: Social policy from colonial times to the present. Boston: South End Press.
2. Albano, L. March 10 1997. “ Up in arms over welfare reform; 2000 attend rally to protest cuts in aid to immigrants. ”. In The Daily News of Los Angeles. March 10, N4 News.
3. Armbruster, R., Geron, K. and Bonacich, E. 1995. The assault on California's Latino immigrants: The politics of proposition 187. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 19 4: 655 – 663.
4. Asian Pacific American Legal Center [APALC] staff. July 17 2001. [Interview in Los Angeles, California]. July 17.
5. Asian Pacific Policy and Planning Council [AP3CON] staff. July 17 2001. [Interview in Los Angeles, California]. July 17.
6. Bean, F. D., Van Hook, J. V.W. and Glick, J. 1997. Country of origin, type of public assistance, and patterns of welfare recipiency among U.S. immigrants and natives. Social Science Quarterly, 78 2: 432 – 451.
7. Bee, P. J. May 29 1997. “ Immigrants lobby state to address welfare losses; protesters urge lawmakers to restore key benefits at Capitol rally. ”. In The Fresno Bee. May 29, 1 P. B.
8. Bell, W. 1965. Aid to dependent children. New York and London: Columbia University Press.
9. Blau, F. D. 1984. The use of transfer payments by immigrants. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 37: 222 – 239.
10. Bloom, D. March 29 1997. “ Mass ceremonies yield 22,000 new citizens. ”. In The Daily News of Los Angeles. March 29.
11. Brugge, D. 1995. The anti-immigrant backlash. Public Eye Magazine, 9 2: 1 – 13.
12. Bruner, K. April 13 1997. “ Wanted: work, not welfare; immigrants find U.S. a land of opportunity; census report refutes notion that foreign-born residents just want an easy ride. ”. In The Fresno Bee. April 13, 1 A.
13. California Department of Social Services. October 23 2000. Cash assistance program for immigrants. Monthly caseload movement statistical report. July 2000 version 1. Sacramento: Data Systems and Survey Design Bureau October 23, Retrieved September 24, 2001
14. California Department of Social Services. November 16 2000. Public assistance facts and figures. July 2000. Sacramento: Data Systems and Survey Design Bureau. November 16, Retrieved September 24, 2001.
15. California Immigrant and Welfare Collaborative [CIWC] staff. September 17, 2001 2001. [Interview in Sacramento, California]. September 17, 2001.
16. California State Assembly. 1997. “ Roll call votes for assembly bill 1576 ”. In Assembly Record. Sacramento: California State Government.
17. California State Assembly. 2001. “ Roll call vote for assembly bill 989 ”. In Assembly Record. Sacramento: California State Government.
18. Campus Coalitions for Human Rights and Social Justice. 1995. California at the crossroads: Social strife or social unity?. Social Justice, 22 3: 53 – 63.
19. Calavita, K. 1996. The new politics of immigration: Balanced-budget conservativism and the symbolism of proposition 187. Social Problems, 43 3: 284 – 305.
20. Capps, S. A. 1997a, March 19. “ Welfare cuts unite those with benefits; immigrants take their cause to Wilson's doorstep. ”. In The San Francisco Examiner. 14 P. A.
21. Capps, S. A. 1997b, March 26. “ Wilson identifies cuts for illegal immigrants; 200 public programs will now require legal residence proof. ”. In The San Francisco Examiner. P.A 5.
22. Catania, Sara. November 22 1996. “ Patriot games; county pushes immigrants into citizenship pipeline. ”. In L.A. Weekly. November 22, 15.
23. Chang, G. 2000. Disposable domestics: Immigrant women workers in the global economy. Cambridge, MA: South End Press.
24. Coalition for Humane Immigrants Rights in Los Angeles [CHIRLA] staff. August 9 and 13 2001. [Interview in Los Angeles, California]. August 9 and 13.
25. Cimons, Marlene. February 10 1997. “ GOP leader vows fight on immigrant aid. ”. In Los Angeles Times. February 10, P. A1.
26. City News Service. October 11 1996. “ Midnight headlines. ”. In City News Service. October 11.
27. Cress, D. M. and Snow, D. A. 2000. The outcomes of homeless mobilization: The influence of organization, disruption, political mediation, and framing. American Journal of Sociology, 105 4: 1063 – 1104.
28. Diamond, S. 1996. Right-wing politics and the anti-immigrant cause. Social Justice, 23 3: 154 – 168.
29. Egelko, B. October 30 1998. “ New governor to get decision on prenatal care; Davis favors benefits. ”. In The Associated Press State and Local Wire. October 30.
30. Ellis, V. 1997a, March 19. “ Immigrants rally against welfare cuts. ”. In Los Angeles Times. P. A:3.
31. Ellis, V. 1997b, May 9. “ Democrats propose welfare package. Aid: Plan calls for state to help legal immigrants whose benefits will be cut off under new U.S. rules. ”. In Los Angeles Times. P. A3.
32. Ellis, V. 1997c, July 22. “ State democrats call immigrant aid top budget issue: Bustamante says there won't be a deal unless governor agrees to replace benefits that many will lose under federal law. Wilson shows no signs of budging. ”. In Los Angeles Times. 1 P. A.
33. Ellis, V. May 27 1998. “ Study says more immigrants are going hungry. ”. In Los Angeles Times. May 27, A1.
34. Ellis, V. and Meyer, J. June 4 1997. “ Panel oks aid to counties for general relief, legal immigrants. ”. In Los Angeles Times. June 4, A:3.
35. Fagan, K. October 2 1996. “ Welfare limbo reigns as new reform kicks ”. In San Francisco Chronicle. October 2, A1.
36. Ferriss, S. April 27 1997. “ Panic sets in over severing of benefits; welfare reform proves frightening for legal immigrants who have worked in the U.S. for years. ”. In The San Francisco Examiner. April 27, B:1.
37. Fields, R. August 6 2001. “ Nineties saw a tide of new people. ”. In Los Angeles Times. August 6, A1 A13.
38. Fields, R. and Herndon, R. July 5 2001. “ Segregation of a new sort takes place. ”. In Los Angeles Times. July 5, A1.
39. Fiore, F. September 11 1996. “ Reform bolsters prop 187 Governor says. ”. In Los Angeles Times. September 11, 3 Metro Desk.
40. Freeman, J. 1975. The politics of women's liberation. New York: David McKay.
41. Bee, Fresno. February 10 1997. “ Fixing Congress' callousness. ”. In Fresno Bee. February 10, B4.
42. Gaytan, C. and Hernandez, J. A. January 1999. “ Beyond a culture of fear: How welfare reform has failed immigrants and public health in California. ”. In Latino Issues Forum. January.
43. Gerhards, J. and Rucht, D. 1992. Mesomobilization: Organizing and framing processes in two protest campaigns in West Germany. American Journal of Sociology, 98 3: 555 – 95.
44. Gilens, M. 1999. Why Americans hate welfare: Race, media, and the politics of antipoverty policy. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
45. Gladstone, M. March 21 1997. “ Immigrants' food stamp cut delayed. ”. In Los Angeles Times. March 21, A:3.
46. Goodwin, J. L. 1997. Gender and the politics of welfare reform: Mothers' pensions in Chicago, 1911–1929. Chicago: TheUniversity of Chicago Press.
47. Gordon, L. 1994. Pitied but not entitled: Single mothers and the history of welfare. New York: TheFree Press.
48. Gunnison, R. B. November 1 1996. “ Food stamp denial ruled illegal; cutting legal immigrants premature, judge says. ”. In The San Francisco Chronicle. November 1, A25.
49. Handler, J. and Hasenfeld, Y. 1991. The moral construction of poverty: Welfare reform in America. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.
50. Hayness, K. July 12 1997. “ Senior center offers citizenship program. ”. In Los Angeles Times. July 12, 4 B.
51. Healy, M. May 2 1997. “ GOP may agree to restore some non-citizen aid. ”. In Los Angeles Times. May 2, 1 A.
52. Hendrix, A. March 4 1997. “ San Francisco's welfare rolls surge; applicant boom expected in summer; the city faces $ 31 million tab for recipients who'll lose federal SSI benefits in August. ”. In The San Francisco Examiner. March 4, 1 P. A.
53. Hernandez, S. September 20 1996. “ Where's Riordan? Our man in New York N.Y. Mayor carries L.A. challenge to federal rules ”. In LA Weekly. September 20, 14.
54. Hicks, A. and Swank, D. H. 1983. Civil disorder, relief mobilization, and AFDC caseloads: A reexamination of the Piven and Cloward thesis. American Journal of Political Science, 27: 695 – 716.
55. Hondagneu-Sotelo, P. 1995. Women and children first: New directions in anti-immigrant politics. Socialist Review, 95 1: 169 – 190.
56. Hong, P. September 21 1996. “ Refugees caught between current, former policy. ”. In Los Angeles Times. September 21, A1.
57. Issac, L. and Kelly, W. R. 1981. Racial insurgency, the state, and welfare expansion: Local and national level evidence from the postwar United States. American Journal of Sociology, 86: 1346 – 86.
58. Issac, L. and Kelly, W. R. 1982. Developmental/modernization and political class struggle theories of welfare expansion: The case of the AFDC “explosion” in the states, 1960–1970. Journal of Political and Military Sociology, 10: 201 – 235.
59. Jacobs, J. July 29 1997. “ Bustamante champions legal aliens assembly speaker; he insists the budget agreement include $124 million in Food Stamps. ”. In The Ventura County Star. July 29, 9 P. D.
60. Jacobs, J. December 27 1996. “ The coming tidal wave. What will happen when legal immigrants lose government services? ”. In The San Diego Tribune. Opinion; Ed. P. B-7. 1,6–8, B-9 December 27, 2 – 5.
61. Jenkins, J. C. and Perrow, C. 1977. Insurgency of the powerless: Farm worker movements 1946–1972. American Sociological Review, 42 2: 249 – 268.
62. Jensen, L. 1988. Patterns of immigration and public assistance utilization, 1970–1980. International Migration Review, 22 1: 51 – 83.
63. Jewell, S. K. 1993. From mammy to miss America and beyond: Cultural images and the shaping of U.S. social policy. London and New York: Routledge.
64. Katz, M. B. 1996. “ [1986]. ”. In In the shadow of the poorhouse: A social history of welfare in America. New York: Basic Books.
65. Lattin, D. August 23 1996. “ Welfare cuts worry religious charities burden may fall on private aid programs. ”. In San Francisco Chronicle. August 23, P. A3.
66. Leiser, Ken. March 6 1997. “ Los Angeles County tries to restore credibility amid welfare debate. ”. In Copley News Service. March 6, Section: State and regional.
67. Lesher, D. September 20 1996. “ Wilson rescinds cutbacks in Food Stamps. ”. In Los Angeles Times. September 20, P. A1.
68. Lesher, D. March 26 1997. “ Wilson backs some aid for illegal immigrants. ”. In Los Angeles Times. March 26, A1.
69. Lesher, D. and McDonnell, P. August 28 1996. “ Wilson calls halt to much of aid for illegal immigrants. ”. In Los Angeles Times. August 28, A1.
70. Los Angeles Coalition to End Hunger Homelessness [LACEHH]. July 17 2001. [Interview in Los Angeles, California]. July 17.
71. Los Angeles Times. December 30 1996. “ Kinder care on immigrant aid. Editorial. ”. In Los Angeles Times. December 30, B:4.
72. Lucas, G. and Tuller, D. November 2 1996. “ Wilson sets date to end care for pregnant illegals but Bay Area counties refuse to halt benefits. ”. In The San Francisco Chronicle. November 2, A13.
73. MaCurdy, T. and O'Brien-Strain, M. 1998. Reform reversed? The restoration of welfare benefits to immigrants in California. Public Policy Institute of California.
74. McAdam, D. 1999. “ [1982]. ”. In Political process and the development of black insurgency, 1930–1970. Chicago and London: TheUniversity of Chicago Press.
75. McAdam, D., McCarthy, J. D. and Zald, M. N. 1996. “ Introduction: Opportunities, mobilizing structures, and framing processes-Toward a synthetic, comparative perspective on social movements. ”. In Comparative perspectives on social movements: Political opportunities, mobilizing structures and cultural framings Edited by: McAdam, D., McCarthy, J. D. and Zald, M. N. 1 – 20. New York: Cambridge University Press.
76. Mcallister, K. July 15 1997. “ Hundreds receive U.S. citizenship; some immigrants say they wanted to ensure they wouldn't lose benefits. ”. In The Fresno Bee. July 15, A:1.
77. McBride, M. J. 1999. Migrants and asylum seekers: Policy responses in the United States to immigrants and refugees from Central America and the Caribbean. International Migration, 37 1: 289 – 314.
78. McDonnell, P. 1996a, October 17. “ Plan to end funding for prenatal care is assailed. ”. In Los Angeles Times. A3.
79. McDonnell, P. 1996b, October 18. “ Legal advocacy groups sue over Food Stamp changes. ”. In Los Angeles Times. A3.
80. McDonnell, P. 1997a, February 1. “ Immigrants warned of impending aid cuts. ”. In Los Angeles Times.
81. McDonnell, P. 1997b, February 3. “ INS backlog growing as aid cutoff gets closer. ”. In Los Angeles Times.
82. McDonnell, P. 1997c, February 13. “ Wilson assails U.S. plan to restore aid to legal immigrants. ”. In Los Angeles Times. A:3.
83. McDonnell, P. 1997d, May 30. “ Mahoney says poor need a safety net, welfare: Cardinal speaks out on recent reforms, urges state and county lawmakers to help legal immigrants who could lose their aid. ”. In Los Angeles Times. B:1.
84. Mehan, H. 1997. The discourse of the illegal immigration debate: A case study in the politics of representation. Discourse Society, 8 2: 249 – 270.
85. Mendel, E. 1997a, July 22. “ Wilson urged to back legal immigrant aid. ”. In The San Diego Union-Tribune. A:3.
86. Mendel, E. 1997b, August 8. “ Agreement reached on state budget; Food Stamps included for legal immigrants. ”. In The San Diego Union-Tribune. A:3.
87. Mettler, S. B. 1994. Divided citizens: State building, federalism, and gender in the New Deal. Cornell University. PhD Dissertation.
88. Mink, G. 1995. The wages of motherhood: Inequality in the welfare state, 1917–1942. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
89. Mink, G. 1990. “ The lady and the tramp: Gender, race, and the origins of the American welfare state. ”. In Women, the state, and welfare Edited by: Gordon, Linda. 92 – 122. Madison: TheUniversity of Wisconsin Press.
90. Minton, T. March 21 1997. “ Wilson postpones cutoff of immigrant Food Stamps. ”. In The San Francisco Chronicle. March 21, A:30.
91. Misra, J., Moller, S. and Lenzo, C. 1998. “ Race, class, and gender and the U.S. welfare state: Exploring state-level variations in ADC/AFDC comprehensiveness ”. In Paper presented at the 1998 annual meeting of the American Sociological Association. San Francisco, CA.
92. Morain, D. January 14 1999. “ Prenatal care for immigrants in Davis Budget. ”. In Los Angeles Times. January 14, A1.
93. Morain, D. June 14 1997. “ Estimated cost of state food stamp plan for legal immigrants quadruples; panel to urge states' Congress members to seek restoration of federal aid. ”. In Los Angeles Times. June 14, A:19.
94. Moore, S. 1998. A fiscal portrait of the newest Americans. National Immigration Forum and Cato Institute.
95. National Immigration Law Center. Guide to immigrant eligibility for federal programs. Los Angeles: National Immigration Law Center. Forthcoming.
96. Neubeck, K. J. and Cazenave, N. A. 2001. Welfare racism: Playing the race card against America's poor. Routledge.
97. Neubeck, K. J. and Roach, J. L. 1981. “ Racism and poverty policies. ”. In Impacts of racism on white Americans Edited by: Bowser, Benjamin P. and Hunt, Raymond G. 153 – 164. Beverly Hills and London: Sage Publications.
98. Parenti, C. 1999. Lockdown America: Police and prisons in the age of crisis. London: Verso.
99. PEOPLE's Community Organization for Reform and Empowerment [People's CORE] staff. August 9 2001. [Interview in Los Angeles, with staff member of a Los Angeles-based Filipino-American organization]. August 9.
100. Pierson, P. 1994. Dismantling the welfare state? Reagan, Thatcher, and the politics of retrenchment. New York: Cambridge University Press.
101. Piven, F. F. May 8 2000. “ Welfare movement rises. ”. In The Nation. May 8.
102. Piven, F. F. and Cloward, R. 1993. “ [1971]. ”. In Regulating the poor: The functions of public welfare. New York: Vintage Books. Updated Version.