A critical and empirical analysis of the national-local ‘gap’ in public responses to large-scale energy infrastructures

Journal of Environmental Planning and Management

Volumn 58, Issue 6, 2015, Pages 1076-1095

  Batel, Susana ^a,b   Devine Wright, Patrick ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

^b INSTITUTO UNIVERSITÁRIO DE LISBOA ISCTE IUL   (Portugal)

Author keywords

community acceptance; large scale energy infrastructures; national local gap ; public responses; transmission lines

Indexed keywords

EID: 84925267891     PISSN: 09640568     EISSN: 13600559     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/09640568.2014.914020     Document Type: Article

References (59)

1. Aitken, Mhairi. 2010. “Why we Still Don't Understand the Social Aspects of Wind Power: A Critique of Key Assumptions within the Literature.” Energy Policy 38 (4): 1834–1841.
2. Batel, Susana, and Patrick Devine-Wright. Forthcoming. “Towards a Better Understanding of People's Responses to Renewable Energy Technologies: Insights from Social Representations Theory.” Public Understanding of Science. doi: 10.1177/0963662513514165. http://pus.sagepub.com/content/early/2014/01/19/0963662513514165.abstract
3. Batel, Susana, Patrick Devine-Wright, and Torvald Tangeland. 2013. “Social Acceptance of Low Carbon Energy and Associated Infrastructures: A Critical Discussion.” Energy Policy 58: 1–5.
4. Bauer, Martin. 2008. “Survey Research and the Public Understanding of Science.” In Handbook of Public Communication on Science and Technology, edited by M. Bucchi and B. Trench, 111–129. Abingdon: Routledge.
5. Bell, Derek, Tim Gray, and Claire Haggett. 2005. “The ‘Social Gap’ in Wind Farm Siting Decisions: Explanations and Policy Responses.” Environmental Politics 14: 460–477.
6. Blake, James. 1999. “Overcoming the Value-Action Gap in Environmental Policy: Tensions Between National Policy and Local Experience.” Local Environment 4 (3): 257–278.
7. Bonaiuto, Marino, Glynis M. Breakwell, and Ignacio Cano. 1996. “Identity Processes and Environmental Threat: The Effects of Nationalism and Local Identity Upon Perception of Beach Pollution.” Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology 6 (3): 157–175.
8. Bridge, Gavin, Stefan Bouzarovski, Michael Bradshaw, and Nick Eyre. 2013. “Geographies of Energy Transition: Space, Place and the Low-Carbon Economy.” Energy Policy 53: 331–340.
9. Bristow, Gillian, Richard Cowell, and Max Munday. 2012. “Windfalls for Whom? The Evolving Notion of ‘Community’ in Community Benefit Provisions from Wind Farms.” Geoforum 43: 1108–1120.
10. Butler, S. 2001. UK Electricity Networks: The Nature of UK Electricity Transmission and Distribution Networks in an Intermittent Renewable and Embedded Electricity Generation Future 2001. http://www.parliament.uk/documents/post/e5.pdf
11. Cass, Noel, Gordon Walker, and Patrick Devine-Wright. 2010. “Good Neighbours, Public Relations and Bribes: The Politics and Perceptions of Community Benefit Provision in Renewable Energy Development in the UK.” Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 12 (3): 255–275.
12. Castro, Paula, and Susana Batel. 2008. “Social Representation, Change and Resistance: On the Difficulties of Generalizing New Norms.” Culture & Psychology 14 (4): 475–497.
13. Castro, Paula, and Maria Luisa Lima. 2001. “Old and New Ideas about the Environment and Science.” Environment and Behavior 33 (3): 400–423.
14. Castro, Paula, and Carla Mouro. 2011. “Psycho-Social Processes in Dealing with Legal Innovation in the Community: Insights from Biodiversity Conservation.” American Journal of Community Psychology 47 (3): 362–373.
15. Cowell, Richard, and Susan Owens. 2006. “Governing Space: Planning Reform and the Politics of Sustainability.” Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 24 (3): 403–421.
16. Cresswell, Tim. 2003. Place: A Short Introduction. Oxford: Blackwell.
17. Demski, Christina. 2011. Public Perceptions of Renewable Energy Technologies – Challenging the Notion of Widespread Support. Cardiff: Cardiff University.
18. Department of Energy and Climate Change. 2011. Electricity Market Reform White Paper. London: Department of Energy and Climate Change.
19. Department of Energy and Climate Change. 2012a. Public Attitudes Tracking Survey 2012. http://www.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/statistics/public_att/public_att.aspx
20. Department of Energy and Climate Change. 2012b. Social Research and Costumer Insight 2012. http://www.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/about/ec_social_res/sr_cus_insight/sr_cus_insight.aspx
21. Devine-Wright, Patrick. 2007. “Energy Citizenship: Psychological Aspects of Evolution in Sustainable Energy Technologies.” In Framing the Present, Shaping the Future: Contemporary Governance of Sustainable Technologies, edited by J. Murphy, 63– 86. London: Earthscan.
22. Devine-Wright, Patrick. 2011. “From Backyards to Places: Public Engagement and the Emplacement of Renewable Energy Technologies.” In Renewable Energy and the Public, edited by P. Devine-Wright, 57–74. London: Earthscan.
23. Devine-Wright, Patrick. 2013a. “Explaining NIMBY Objections to a Power Line: The Role of Personal, Place Attachment and Project-Related Factors.” Environment and Behavior 45 (6): 761–781.
24. Devine-Wright, Patrick. 2013b. “Think Global, Act Local? The Relevance of Place Attachments and Place Identities in a Climate Changed World.” Global Environmental Change 23: 61–69.
25. Devine-Wright, Patrick, and Batel Susana. 2013. “Explaining Public Preferences for High Voltage Pylon Designs: An Empirical Study of Perceived Fit in a Rural Landscape.” Land Use Policy 31: 640–649.
26. Devine-Wright, Patrick, and Yuko Howes. 2010. “Disruption to Place Attachment and the Protection of Restorative Environments: A Wind Energy Case Study.” Journal of Environmental Psychology 30: 271–280.
27. Devine-Wright, Patrick, and Bouke Wiersma. 2013. “Opening up the Local to Analysis: Exploring the Spatiality of UK Urban Decentralised Energy Initiatives.” Local Environment 18 (10): 1099–1116.
28. Elliott, Paul, and Wadley, David. 2002. “The impact of transmission lines on property values: Coming to terms with stigma.” Property Management 2:137–152.
29. Ellis, Geraint, John Barry, and Clive Robinson. 2007. “Many Ways to Say No, Different Ways to Say Yes: Applying Q-Methodology to Understand Public Acceptance of Wind Farm Proposals.” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 50 (4): 517–551.
30. Ellis, H. 2008. “Planning and the People Problem (1).” Journal of Planning and Environmental Law 13: 75–86.
31. Firestone, Jeremy, Willett Kempton, and Andrew Krueger. 2009. “Public Acceptance of Offshore Wind Power Projects in the USA.” Wind Energy 12: 183–202.
32. Firestone, Jeremy, Willett Kempton, Meredith Lilley, and Kateryna Samoteskul. 2012. “Public Acceptance of Offshore Wind Power: Does Perceived Fairness of Process Matter?” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 55(10): 1387–1402.
33. Graham, Stephen, and Simon Marvin. 1995. “More than Ducts and Wires: Post-Fordism, Cities and Utilities Networks.” In Managing Cities: The New Urban Context, edited by P. Healey, S. Cameron, S. Davoudi, S. Graham and A. Madanipour, 169–189. London: John Wiley.
34. Gross, Catherine. 2007. “Community Perspectives of Wind Energy in Australia: The Application of a Justice and Community Fairness Framework to Increase Social Acceptance.” Energy Policy 35 (5): 2727–2736.
35. Haggett, Claire, and Beatrix Futak-Campbell. 2011. “Tilting at Windmills? Using Discourse Analysis to Understand the Attitude-Behaviour Gap in Renewable Energy Conflicts.” Journal of Mechanisms of Economic Regulation 1: 207–220.
36. Halfacree, Keith. 1993. “Locality and Social Representation: Space, Discourse and Alternative Definitions of the Rural.” Journal of Rural Studies 9 (1): 23–37.
37. Huber, Stefanie, and Robert Horbaty. 2010. IEA Wind Task 28: Social Acceptance of Wind Energy. Swiss Federal Office of Energy.
38. Huijts, Nicole M.A., Cees J.H. Midden, and Anneloes L. Meijnders. 2007. “Social Acceptance of Carbon Dioxide Storage.” Energy Policy 35 (5): 2780–2789.
39. Jones, Christopher R., and J. Richard Eiser. 2009. “Identifying Predictors of Attitudes Towards Local Onshore Wind Development with Reference to an English Case Study.” Energy Policy 37 (11): 4604–4614.
40. Jones, Christopher, and J. Richard Eiser. 2010. “Understanding ‘Local’ Opposition to Wind Development in the UK: How Big is a Backyard?” Energy Policy 38: 3106–3117.
41. Kyoto Protocol. 1998. Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. United Nations. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/convkp/kpeng.pdf
42. Montgomeryshire Againts Pylons. 2013. About Us. http://www.montgomeryshireagainstpylons.org/about-us/#.U3Dq7lyHOAc [Accessed 4 April 2013]
43. Moscovici, Serge, ed. 1961/76. La Psychanalyse, son image et son public. Paris: PUF.
44. Nailsea Against Pylons. 2013. About Us http://www.nailsea-against-pylons.co.uk/aboutus.html [Accessed 4 April 2013]
45. National Infrastructure Planning. 2012. Projects. The Planning Inspectorate.
46. No Moor Pylons. 2011. What is Proposed and Where it is Going. http://www.pylon-moor-pressure.co.uk/What%20and%20where.html.
47. Owens, Susan. 2000. “Engaging the Public: Information and Deliberation in Environmental Policy.” Environment and Planning A 32 (7): 1141–1148.
48. Owens, Susan, and Louise Driffill. 2008. “How to Change Attitudes and Behaviours in the Context of Energy.” Energy Policy 36 (12): 4412–4418.
49. Paasi, Anssi. 2004. “Place and Region: Looking through the Prism of Scale.” Progress in Human Geography 28 (4): 536–546.
50. Pidgeon, Nick, and Christina Demski. 2012. “From Nuclear to Renewable: Energy Systems Transformation and Public Attitudes.” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 68 (4): 1–12.
51. Renewables Directive. Directive 2009/28/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2009 on the Promotion of the Use of Energy from Renewable Sources and Amending and Subsequently Repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/30/EC. 2009 http://eurlex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2009:140:0016:0062:en:PDF
52. Schweizer-Ries, Petra. 2010. “Environmental-Psychological Study of the Acceptance of Measures for Integrating Renewable Energies into the Grid in the Wahle-Mecklar Region (Lower Saxony and Hesse).” Forschungruppe Umweltpsychologie.
53. Spaargaren, Gert. 2011. “Theories of Practice: Agency, Technology and Culture – Exploring the Relevance of Practice Theories for the Governance of Sustainable Consumption Practices in the New-World Order.” Global Environmental Change 21: 813–822.
54. Swofford, Jeffrey, and Michael Slattery. 2010. “Public Attitudes of Wind Energy in Texas: Local Communities in Close Proximity to Wind Farms and their Effect on Decision-Making.” Energy Policy 38 (5): 2508–2519.
55. Terwel, Bart W., and Dancker Daamen. 2012. “Initial Public Reactions to Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS): Differentiating General and Local Views.” Climate Policy 12: 288–300.
56. Upham, Paul, and Simon Shackley. 2006. “The Case of a Proposed 21.5 MWe Biomass Gasifier in Winkleigh, Devon: Implications for Governance of Renewable Energy Planning.” Energy Policy 34 (15): 2161–2172.
57. Wolsink, Maarten. 2000. “Wind Power and the NIMBY-Myth: Institutional Capacity and the Limited Significance of Public Support.” Renewable Energy 21: 49–64.
58. Wustenhagen, Rolf, Maarten Wolsink, and Mary Jean Burer. 2007. “Social Acceptance of Renewable Energy Innovation: An Introduction to the Concept.” Energy Policy 35 (5): 2683–2691.
59. Zoellner, Jan, Petra Schweizer-Ries, and Christin Wemheuer. 2008. “Public Acceptance of Renewable Energies: Results from Case Studies in Germany.” Energy Policy 36 (11): 4136–4141.