Conservative surgery in ovarian borderline tumours: A meta-analysis with emphasis on recurrence risk

European Journal of Cancer

Volumn 51, Issue 5, 2015, Pages 620-631

  Vasconcelos, Inês ^a   De Sousa Mendes, Miguel ^b  

^a CHARITÉ UNIVERSITÄTSMEDIZIN BERLIN   (Germany)

^b Nuclear Medicine   (Germany)

Author keywords

Borderline ovarian; Conservative surgery; Fertility sparing surgery; Low malignant potential; ovarian tumours; Pregnancy rates; Recurrence; tumours

Indexed keywords

BILATERAL CYSTECTOMY; CANCER STAGING; CANCER SURGERY; CONSERVATIVE TREATMENT; CONTRALATERAL CYSTECTOMY; CYSTECTOMY; FEMALE; FEMALE FERTILITY; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; META ANALYSIS; MUCINOUS BORDERLINE OVARIAN TUMOUR; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; OVARY TUMOR; PREGNANCY RATE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROSPECTIVE STUDY; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); RECURRENCE RISK; RETROSPECTIVE STUDY; REVIEW; SALPINGOOOPHORECTOMY; SEROUS BORDERLINE OVARIAN TUMOUR; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TUMOR RECURRENCE; ADVERSE EFFECTS; FERTILITY; FERTILITY PRESERVATION; INFERTILITY, FEMALE; MORTALITY; NEOPLASMS, CYSTIC, MUCINOUS, AND SEROUS; OVARIAN NEOPLASMS; OVARIECTOMY; PATHOLOGY; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PREGNANCY; PROCEDURES; RISK; RISK FACTOR; SALPINGECTOMY; TIME; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

FEMALE; FERTILITY; FERTILITY PRESERVATION; HUMANS; INFERTILITY, FEMALE; NEOPLASM RECURRENCE, LOCAL; NEOPLASM STAGING; NEOPLASMS, CYSTIC, MUCINOUS, AND SEROUS; ODDS RATIO; OVARIAN NEOPLASMS; OVARIECTOMY; PREGNANCY; RISK FACTORS; SALPINGECTOMY; TIME FACTORS; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84924358941     PISSN: 09598049     EISSN: 18790852     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejca.2015.01.004     Document Type: Review

References (57)

1. A.W. Kennedy, and W.R. Hart Ovarian papillary serous tumors of low malignant potential (serous borderline tumors). A long-term follow-up study, including patients with microinvasion, lymph node metastasis, and transformation to invasive serous carcinoma Cancer 78 1996 278 286
2. E. Darai, R. Fauvet, C. Uzan, S. Gouy, and P. Duvillard, et al. Fertility and borderline ovarian tumor: a systematic review of conservative management, risk of recurrence and alternative options Hum Reprod Update 19 2013 151 166
3. C. Uzan, E. Muller, A. Kane, A. Rey, and S. Gouy, et al. Prognostic factors for recurrence after conservative treatment in a series of 119 patients with stage I serous borderline tumors of the ovary Ann Oncol 25 2014 166 171
4. S. Palomba, A. Falbo, S. Del Negro, M. Rocca, and T. Russo, et al. Ultra-conservative fertility-sparing strategy for bilateral borderline ovarian tumours: an 11-year follow-up Hum Reprod 25 2010 1966 1972
5. S. Palomba, E. Zupi, T. Russo, A. Falbo, and S. Del Negro, et al. Comparison of two fertility-sparing approaches for bilateral borderline ovarian tumours: a randomized controlled study Hum Reprod 22 2007 578 585
6. G. Zanetta, S. Rota, A. Lissoni, A. Meni, and G. Brancatelli, et al. Ultrasound, physical examination, and CA 125 measurement for the detection of recurrence after conservative surgery for early borderline ovarian tumors Gynecol Oncol 81 2001 63 66
7. D.R. Barnhill, R.J. Kurman, M.F. Brady, G.A. Omura, and E. Yordan, et al. Preliminary analysis of the behavior of stage I ovarian serous tumors of low malignant potential: a Gynecologic Oncology Group study J Clin Oncol 13 1995 2752 2756
8. A. Maneo, M. Vignali, S. Chiari, A. Colombo, and C. Mangioni, et al. Are borderline tumors of the ovary safely treated by laparoscopy? Gynecol Oncol 94 2004 387 392
9. G. Zanetta, S. Rota, S. Chiari, C. Bonazzi, and G. Bratina, et al. Behavior of borderline tumors with particular interest to persistence, recurrence, and progression to invasive carcinoma: a prospective study J Clin Oncol 19 2001 2658 2664
10. J.F. Leake, J.L. Currie, N.B. Rosenshein, and J.D. Woodruff Long-term follow-up of serous ovarian tumors of low malignant potential Gynecol Oncol 47 1992 150 158
11. J.Y. Park, D.Y. Kim, J.H. Kim, Y.M. Kim, and K.R. Kim, et al. Micropapillary pattern in serous borderline ovarian tumors: does it matter? Gynecol Oncol 123 2011 511 516
12. S. Camatte, P. Morice, P. Pautier, D. Atallah, and P. Duvillard, et al. Fertility results after conservative treatment of advanced stage serous borderline tumour of the ovary BJOG 109 2002 376 380
13. P. Morice, S. Camatte, A. Rey, D. Atallah, and C. Lhomme, et al. Prognostic factors for patients with advanced stage serous borderline tumours of the ovary Ann Oncol 14 2003 592 598
14. A. Kane, C. Uzan, S. Gouy, P. Pautier, and P. Duvillard, et al. Fertility results and outcomes after pure laparoscopic management of advanced-stage serous borderline tumors of the ovary Fertil Steril 94 2010 2891 2894
15. C. Uzan, A. Kane, A. Rey, S. Gouy, and P. Duvillard, et al. Outcomes after conservative treatment of advanced-stage serous borderline tumors of the ovary Ann Oncol 21 2010 55 60
16. S. Khunamornpong, J. Settakorn, K. Sukpan, P. Suprasert, and S. Siriaunkgul Mucinous tumor of low malignant potential ("borderline" or "atypical proliferative" tumor) of the ovary: a study of 171 cases with the assessment of intraepithelial carcinoma and microinvasion Int J Gynecol Pathol 30 2011 218 230
17. M. Koskas, C. Uzan, S. Gouy, P. Pautier, and C. Lhomme, et al. Prognostic factors of a large retrospective series of mucinous borderline tumors of the ovary (excluding peritoneal pseudomyxoma) Ann Surg Oncol 18 2011 40 48
18. H.W. Tsai, C.C. Ko, C.C. Yeh, Y.J. Chen, and N.F. Twu, et al. Unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy as fertility-sparing surgery for borderline ovarian tumors J Chin Med Assoc 74 2011 250 254
19. R. Fauvet, J. Boccara, C. Dufournet, E. David-Montefiore, and C. Poncelet, et al. Restaging surgery for women with borderline ovarian tumors: results of a French multicenter study Cancer 100 2004 1145 1151
20. T. Song, C. Hun Choi, Y.Y. Lee, T.J. Kim, and J.W. Lee, et al. Oncologic and reproductive outcomes of cystectomy compared with oophorectomy as a treatment for borderline ovarian tumours Hum Reprod 26 2011 2008 2014
21. P. De Iaco, A. Ferrero, F. Rosati, M. Melpignano, and N. Biglia, et al. Behaviour of ovarian tumors of low malignant potential treated with conservative surgery Eur J Surg Oncol 35 2009 643 648
22. C. Poncelet, R. Fauvet, J. Boccara, and E. Darai Recurrence after cystectomy for borderline ovarian tumors: results of a French multicenter study Ann Surg Oncol 13 2006 565 571
23. R. Seracchioli, S. Venturoli, F.M. Colombo, F. Govoni, and S. Missiroli, et al. Fertility and tumor recurrence rate after conservative laparoscopic management of young women with early-stage borderline ovarian tumors Fertil Steril 76 2001 999 1004
24. Y. Yinon, M.E. Beiner, W.H. Gotlieb, Y. Korach, and T. Perri, et al. Clinical outcome of cystectomy compared with unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy as fertility-sparing treatment of borderline ovarian tumors Fertil Steril 88 2007 479 484
25. M. Koskas, C. Uzan, S. Gouy, P. Pautier, and C. Lhomme, et al. Fertility determinants after conservative surgery for mucinous borderline tumours of the ovary (excluding peritoneal pseudomyxoma) Hum Reprod 26 2011 808 814
26. P. Morice, C. Uzan, R. Fauvet, S. Gouy, and P. Duvillard, et al. Borderline ovarian tumour: pathological diagnostic dilemma and risk factors for invasive or lethal recurrence Lancet Oncol 13 2012 e103 e115
27. E. Hernandez, B.S. Bhagavan, T.H. Parmley, and N.B. Rosenshein Interobserver variability in the interpretation of epithelial ovarian cancer Gynecol Oncol 17 1984 117 123
28. A. du Bois, N. Ewald-Riegler, N. de Gregorio, A. Reuss, and S. Mahner, et al. Borderline tumours of the ovary: a cohort study of the Arbeitsgmeinschaft Gynakologische Onkologie (AGO) Study Group Eur J Cancer 2013
29. I. Vasconcelos, J. Olschewski, I. Braicu, and J. Sehouli Limited efficacy of platinum-based adjuvant treatment on the outcome of borderline ovarian tumors Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 186C 2015 26 33
30. Vasconcelos I, Olschewski J, Braicu I, Sehouli J. A meta-analysis on the impact of platinum-based adjuvant treatment on the outcome of borderline ovarian tumors with invasive implants. Oncologist 2015.
31. C. Fotopoulou, G. Schumacher, J.C. Schefold, C. Denkert, and W. Lichtenegger, et al. Systematic evaluation of the intraoperative tumor pattern in patients with borderline tumor of the ovary Int J Gynecol Cancer 19 2009 1550 1555
32. J.D. Seidman, and R.J. Kurman Ovarian serous borderline tumors: a critical review of the literature with emphasis on prognostic indicators Hum Pathol 31 2000 539 557
33. D. Querleu, T. Papageorgiou, E. Lambaudie, Y. Sonoda, and F. Narducci, et al. Laparoscopic restaging of borderline ovarian tumours: results of 30 cases initially presumed as stage IA borderline ovarian tumours BJOG 110 2003 201 204
34. C.G. Trope, G. Kristensen, and A. Makar Surgery for borderline tumor of the ovary Semin Surg Oncol 19 2000 69 75
35. S. Camatte, P. Morice, A. Thoury, V. Fourchotte, and P. Pautier, et al. Impact of surgical staging in patients with macroscopic "stage I" ovarian borderline tumours: analysis of a continuous series of 101 cases Eur J Cancer 40 2004 1842 1849
36. D. Weinstein, and W.Z. Polishuk The role of wedge resection of the ovary as a cause for mechanical sterility Obstet Gynecol Surv 31 1976 227 228
37. W.R. Hart, and H.J. Norris Borderline and malignant mucinous tumors of the ovary. Histologic criteria and clinical behavior Cancer 31 1973 1031 1045
38. C. Uzan, M. Nikpayam, L. Ribassin-Majed, S. Gouy, and S. Bendifallah, et al. Influence of histological subtypes on the risk of an invasive recurrence in a large series of stage I borderline ovarian tumor including 191 conservative treatments Ann Oncol 25 2014 1312 1319
39. F. Trillsch, S. Mahner, L. Woelber, E. Vettorazzi, and A. Reuss, et al. Age-dependent differences in borderline ovarian tumours (BOT) regarding clinical characteristics and outcome: results from a sub-analysis of the Arbeitsgemeinschaft Gynaekologische Onkologie (AGO) ROBOT study Ann Oncol 25 2014 1320 1327
40. P. De Iaco, A. Ferrero, F. Rosati, M. Melpignano, N. Biglia, and M. Rolla, et al. Behaviour of ovarian tumors of low malignant potential treated with conservative surgery Eur J Surg Oncol 35 6 2009 643 648
41. Y. Yinon, M.E. Beiner, W.H. Gotlieb, Y. Korach, T. Perri, and G. Ben-Baruch Clinical outcome of cystectomy compared with unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy as fertility-sparing treatment of borderline ovarian tumors Fertil Steril 88 2 2007 479 484
42. N. Boran, A.P. Cil, G. Tulunay, E. Ozturkoglu, S. Koc, and D. Bulbul, et al. Fertility and recurrence results of conservative surgery for borderline ovarian tumors Gynecol Oncol 97 3 2005 845 851
43. G.G. Rao, E.N. Skinner, P.A. Gehrig, L.R. Duska, D.S. Miller, and J.O. Schorge Fertility-sparing surgery for ovarian low malignant potential tumors Gynecol Oncol 98 2 2005 263 266
44. C. Romagnolo, A. Gadducci, E. Sartori, P. Zola, and T. Maggino Management of borderline ovarian tumors: results of an Italian multicenter study Gynecol Oncol 101 2 2006 255 260
45. J.Y. Park, D.Y. Kim, J.H. Kim, Y.M. Kim, Y.T. Kim, and J.H. Nam Surgical management of borderline ovarian tumors: The role of fertility-sparing surgery Gynecol Oncol 113 1 2009 75 82
46. E. Suh-Burgmann Long-term outcomes following conservative surgery for borderline tumor of the ovary: a large population-based study Gynecol Oncol 103 3 2006 841 847
47. P. Morice, S. Camatte, J. El Hassan, P. Pautier, P. Duvillard, and D. Castaigne Clinical outcomes and fertility after conservative treatment of ovarian borderline tumors Fertil Steril 75 1 2001 92 96
48. L.W. Rice, R.S. Berkowitz, S.D. Mark, D.L. Yavner, and J.M. Lage Epithelial ovarian tumors of borderline malignancy Gynecol Oncol 39 2 1990 195 198
49. Y. Yokoyama, T. Moriya, T. Takano, T. Shoji, O. Takahashi, and K. Nakahara, et al. Clinical outcome and risk factors for recurrence in borderline ovarian tumours Br J Cancer 94 11 2006 1586 1591
50. K. Tamakoshi, F. Kikkawa, N. Nakashima, A. Tamakoshi, M. Kawai, and Y. Furuhashi, et al. Clinical behavior of borderline ovarian tumors: a study of 150 cases J Surg Oncol 64 2 1997 147 152
51. A. Ferrero, I. Strada, B. Di Marcoberardino, L.R. Maccarini, F. Pozzati, and M. Rossi, et al. Clinical significance of microinvasion in borderline ovarian tumors and its impact on surgical management Int J Gynecol Cancer 22 7 2012 1158 1162
52. H. Ji, M. Yliskoski, M. Anttila, K. Syrjanen, and S. Saarikoski, et al. Management of stage-I borderline ovarian tumors Int J Gynaecol Obstet 54 1 1996 37 44
53. T. Song, C.H. Choi, H.J. Kim, W. Lee, Y.Y. Lee, and T.J. Kim, et al. Oncologic and reproductive outcomes in patients with advanced-stage borderline ovarian tumors Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 156 2 2011 204 208
54. K. Kokawa, Y. Mikami, H. Sakata, N. Oki, T. Tanakas, and M. Yamazaki, et al. Clinical outcome and prognostic factors in borderline tumors of the ovary. Results from 17 years' experience in the Kinki District of Japan (1990-2006) Eur J Gynaecol Oncol 30 2 2009 155 161
55. M.E. Beiner, W.H. Gotlieb, B. Davidson, J. Kopolovic, and G. Ben-Baruch Infertility treatment after conservative management of borderline ovarian tumors Cancer 92 2 2001 320 325
56. M. Kanat-Pektas, M. Ozat, T. Gungor, T. Dikici, B. Yilmaz, and L. Mollamahmutoglu Fertility outcome after conservative surgery for borderline ovarian tumors: a single center experience Arch Gynecol Obstet 284 5 2011 1253 1258
57. N. Anfinan, K. Sait, P. Ghatage, J. Nation, and P. Chu Ten years experience in the management of borderline ovarian tumors at Tom Baker Cancer Centre Arch Gynecol Obstet 284 2011 731 735