Righteous anger at the wicked states: The meaning of the founders’ constitution

Righteous Anger at the Wicked States: The Meaning of the Founders' Constitution

Volumn , Issue , 2005, Pages 1-294

  Johnson, Calvin H ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84923199730     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.1017/CBO9780511511141     Document Type: Book

References (521)

1. Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, 146 (2d ed. 1958).
2. Quentin Skinner, Meaning and Understanding the History of Ideas in Meaning and Understanding: Quentin Skinner and his Critics 55–65 (James Tully, ed., 1988).
3. Calvin H. Johnson, Purging out Pollock: The Constitutionality of Federal Wealth or Sales Taxes, 97 Tax Notes 1723 (2002)
4. Edward Meese, Speech to American Bar Association, July 9, 1985
5. Wilson, Federal Convention (July 14, 1787), in 2 Farrand 10.
6. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 24, 1788), in 3 Elliot 600–601.
7. Madison, U.S. House of Representatives (Aug. 18, 1789), in 1 Annals 790
8. Jefferson, First Inaugural Address (March 4, 1801), in Basic Writings of TJ 641.
9. Madison, Continental Congress (Feb. 21, 1783), in 25 JCC 908
10. Madison, Continental Congress (Jan. 28, 1783), in 25 JCC 875
11. Robert Livingston, New York Convention (June 27, 1788), in 2 Elliot 342.
12. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 7, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1017
13. Ruth Bogin, Abraham Clark and the Quest for Equality in the Revolutionary Era, 1774–1794, at 127–131 (1982).
14. Charles Pinckney, South Carolina House of Representatives (Jan. 16, 1788)
15. Pelatiah Webster, Political Essays on the Nature and Operation of Money, Public Finances, and Other Subjects 362–363, 372 (1791)
16. Hamilton, The Defence of the Funding System (July 1795), in 19 PAH 22, 27
17. Randolph, Federal Convention (May 29,1787) 1 Farrand 25
18. Randolph, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 255
19. Madison, House of Representatives (April 8, 1789), in 12 JM 65
20. Archibald Maclaine, Publicola: Address to the Freemen of North Carolina, State Gazette of North Carolina (Mar. 20, 1788), reprinted in 16 DHRC 436
21. James Wilson, Public Meeting in Philadelphia (Oct. 6, 1787), in 13 DHRC 343
22. Hamilton, New York Convention (June 27, 1788), in 2 Elliot 352.
23. Hamilton, Defense of the Funding System (July 1795), 19 PAH 57.
24. James Iredell, North Carolina Convention, July 30, 1788, 4 Elliot 220–221.
25. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 7, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1021
26. Madison, (June 6, 1788), in 9 DHRC 996–997
27. Christopher Gore, Massachusetts Convention (Jan. 22, 1788), in 2 Elliot 67.
28. Wilson, Pennsylvania Assembly (Sept. 17, 1787), in 2 DHRC 58.
29. Edward Rutledge, South Carolina Legislature (Jan. 16, 1788), in 2 Debate 23.
30. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 4, 1788), in 2 Elliot 189.
31. Hugh Williamson, Speech at Edenton, N.C., N.Y. Daily Advertiser, (Feb. 26, 1788), in 25 DHRC 206.
32. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 7, 1788), in 3 Elliot 115
33. Madison, Notes on Debates in the Congress (Feb. 21, 1783), in 6 JM 270, 271
34. James Bowdoin, Massachusetts Convention (Jan. 23, 1788), in 2 Elliot 82
35. Aristedes, Remarks on the Proposed Plan of a Federal Government (Jan. 31, 1788), in 15 DHRC 538
36. Madison, Vices of the Political System of the United States (April 1787), in 9 JM 348
37. Madison, Notes on Ancient and Modern Confederacy (1786 or 1787), in 9 JM 6, 8, 11, 16, 22.
38. Madison (member of Congress representing Virginia) to Jefferson (Governor of Virginia) (April 16, 1781), in 3 JM 71
39. William Davie, North Carolina Convention (July 24, 1788), in 4 Elliot 19
40. Hamilton, New York Convention (June 28, 1788), in 2 Elliot 366
41. Madison (serving in Virginia Assembly) to Jefferson (Ambassador in Paris) (Oct. 3, 1786), in 8 JM 373
42. Madison, Address to the States, by the United States in Congress Assembled (April 26, 1783), in 24JCC 277, 282.
43. Madison, “Preface to the Constitution” (circa 1820s), in 3 Farrand 547.
44. James Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 24, 1787), in 2 DHRC 360
45. Hamilton, Report Relative to a Provision for the Support of Public Credit (Jan. 9, 1790), in 6 PAH 51, 69.
46. Madison, Notes on Debates in Congress (Jan. 28, 1783), in 6 JM 142–149.
47. Madison, Address to the Nation (April 26, 1783), in 24 JCC 281.
48. Erna Risch, “Supplying Washington’s Army” 257 (U.S. Army Center of Military History 1981),
49. Madison, Address to the States, by the United States in Congress Assembled (April 26, 1783), in 24 JCC 277, 282.
50. Madison, Virginia Convention, June 6, 1788, 3 Elliot 1 36
51. Madison, Address to the States, by the United States in Congress Assembled (April 26, 1783), in 24 JCC 282.
52. Madison, Address to the States, by the United States in Congress Assembled (April 26, 1783), in 24 JCC 277, 282–283
53. William Davie, North Carolina Convention (July 24, 1788), in 4 Elliot 19.
54. Madison, Address to the States (April 26, 1783), in 24 JCC 277, 282.
55. Rufus King (Massachusetts), Federal Convention (June 30, 1787), in 1 Farrand 490.
56. Charles W. Calomiris, Institutional Failure, Monetary Scarcity, and the Depreciation of the Continental, 48 J. of Econ. History 47, 60 (1988).
57. John P. Kaminski, New York: The Reluctant Pillar, in Reluctant Pillar 48, 54
58. John J. McCusker & Russell R. Menard, The Economy of British America, 1607–1789
59. McDonald, Hamilton at 88–89; Edmund Burnett, Continental Congress 540–46 (1941)
60. Irvin H. Polishook, Rhode Island and the Union, 1774–1795
61. Irvin H. Polishook, Rhode Island and the Union, 1774–1795, at 96 (1969).
62. D. Thatcher, Massachusetts Convention (Feb. 4, 1788)
63. Melancton Smith, New York Convention (June 27, 1788)
64. John P. Kaminski, New York: The Reluctant Pillar, in Reluctant Pillar at 48, 52–53, 56–58; Main at 76 (1961).
65. Robert A. Feer, Shays’s Rebellion and the Constitution: A Study in Causation, 42 New Eng. Q. 388, 398 (1969).
66. Robert Morris, Report of the Office of Finance (July 29, 1782)
67. E. James Ferguson, The Nationalists of 1781–1783 and the Economic Interpretation of the Constitution, 56 J. of Am. Hist. 241, 246, 252 (1969)
68. E. James Ferguson, Book Review of Forest McDonald, E Pluribus Unum, 23 Wm. & Mary Q. 149 (3rd Series, 1966)
69. Todd Sandler, Collective Action: Theory and Applications 5–6 (1992)
70. Keith Dougherty, Collective Action under the Articles of Confederation 8–10 (2001).
71. Courtland Canby, Robert Munford’s “The Patriots,” 6 Wm. & Mary Q. 437, 459 (3rd. Ser. 1949)
72. Letter of Washington to Hamilton, <>http://lcweb2.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/r?ammem/mgw:@fieldDOCID+@lit(gw260324) (March 31, 1783)
73. Glenn A. Phelps, George Washington and American Constitutionalism 47–53 (1993)
74. Hugh Grigsby, The History of the Virginia Federal Convention of 1788, 160 (1890, 1969 reprint)
75. John W Blassingame, American Nationalism and Other Loyalties in the Southern Colonies 1763–1775, 34 J. of S. Hist. 50, 63 (1968)
76. James Thomas Flexner, Washington: The Indispensable Man 60 (1969).
77. Jefferson, Notes on Debates on the Continental Congress (July 29, 1775)
78. Edmond Burnet, The Continental Congress 215–20 (1941); Rakove, Beginnings at 205–15.
79. Charles W. Calomiris, Institutional Failure, Monetary Scarcity, and the Depreciation of the Continental, 48 J. of Econ. History 47, 59 (1988)
80. Robert A. Becker, Evolution and Reform: An Interpretation of Southern Taxation, 1763 to 1783, 32 Wm. & Mary Q. 417, 433–439
81. John Jay, Draft of a Circular from the Congress to the States (Sept 13, 1779), in 15 JCC 1060.
82. Robert Morris, Report of the Office of Finance in 22 JCC 435 (Aug. 5, 1782).
83. Erna Risch, supra note 62, at 231–258
84. E. Wayne Carp at 171–187 (1984)
85. Madison (member of Congress representing Virginia) to Jefferson (Governor of Virginia) (May 6, 1780), in 2 JM 19.
86. E. Wayne Carp at 85–86.
87. James Bowdoin to President of the Congress Samuel Huntington (Sept. 1780), quoted in Rakove, Beginnings at 277.
88. Major J. Burnett to Jeremiah Wadsworth (Mar. 18, 1780), quoted in E. Wayne Carp at 179.
89. Robert Morris, Draft of Proposed Letter to the Governors of the States (May 16, 1782), in 5 DCAR 425.
90. Sung Bok Kim, The Limits of Politicization in the American Revolution: The Experience of Westchester County, New York, 3 J. of Amer. History 868, 883–84 (1993).
91. Robert Morris, Report of the Office of Finance in 22 JCC 435 (Aug. 5, 1782).
92. Allan Nevins, The American States during and after the Revolution 1775–1789, at 506 (1924).
93. John P. Kaminski, New York: The Reluctant Pillar, in Reluctant Pillar 48, 52–53, 56–58.
94. Ruth Bogin, supra note 83 at 127–131 (1982).
95. Douglas Adair, A Note on Certain of Hamilton’s Pseudonyms, 12 Wm. & Mary Q. 282, 283–284
96. Gordon Woods, Ideology and the Origins of Liberal America, 44 Wm. & Mary Q. 628, 633 (1987)
97. William Pierce, Character Sketches of Delegates (undated), in 3 Farrand 94–95.
98. Lance Banning, James Madison and the Nationalists, 1780–1783, 40 Wm. & Mary Q. 227 (3d Series 1983)
99. Rakove, Beginnings 387–388.
100. Madison, “Preface to the Constitution” (circa 1820s), in 3 Farrand 539, 547.
101. Madison, Notes on Contemporaneous and Ancient Confederacies (April–June, 1786), in 9 JM 3.
102. Dennis J. Mahoney, Edmund Pendleton, 3 Ency. of the Amer. Const. 1373 (Leonard W. Levy, ed. 1986).
103. Jack N. Rakove, Madison Theorizing at 35 (presented Nov. 13, 2000, The University of Texas).
104. Madison, Notes on Confederacies, in 9 JM 22.
105. Madison, Federal Convention (June 19, 1787) in 1 Farrand 326–327
106. Madison, Federal Convention (June 29, 1787), in 1 Farrand 478
107. Madison, Federal Convention (June 28, 1787), in 1 Farrand 448
108. Wilson, Federal Convention (June 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 143
109. Hamilton, Federal Convention (June 18, 1787), in 1 Farrand 283–292
110. Madison, Unsent letter to John Tyler (1833), in 3 Farrand 530–531
111. Henry Mayer, A Son of Thunder: Patrick Henry and the American Republic (1986).
112. Patrick Henry, Virginia Assembly (Mar. 23, 1775), http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/patrick.htm
113. Charles Beard, Economic Origins of Jeffersonian Democracy at 270 (1915).
114. Emory G. Evans, Private Indebtedness and the Revolution in Virginia, 1776 to 1796, 28 Wm. & Mary Q. 349, 363 (3rd. Ser. 1971).
115. Emory G. Evans, The Rise and Decline of the Virginia Aristocracy in the Eighteenth Century: The Nelsons, in The Old Dominion: Essays for Thomas Perkins Abernathy 77 (Darrett B. Ruttman, ed. 1964).
116. Edward C. Papenfuse, Pursuit of Profit: The Annapolis Merchants in the Eras of American Revolution, 1763–1805, at 170 (1975).
117. The Paris Peace Treaty of September 3, 1783, Art. IV in http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/diplomacy/paris.htm (accessed May 30, 2001).
118. Jay, Report of the Office of Foreign Affairs, Oct. 13, 1786, 13 JCC 781–874.
119. Madison, Notes on Debates in Continental Congress (March 21, 1787), in 9 JM 326–327.
120. Evans, supra note 85, at 363–366
121. Evans, supra note 85, at 363; Risjord at 114.
122. Evans, supra note 85, at 364–365
123. Evans, supra note 85, at 367.
124. Charles R. Ritcheson, Aftermath of Revolution: British Policy toward the United States, 1783–1795, at 334–338 (1969)
125. Julius Goebel, History of the Supreme Court: Antecedents and Beginnings to 1801, at 748–756 (1971).
126. Julius Goebel, supra note 102, at 748–756 (1971)
127. Evans, supra note 85, at 372–373
128. James Iredell, North Carolina Convention (July 28, 1788)
129. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 26, 1787), in 2 Elliot 431
130. Brant, The Nationalists at 358–359 (1948).
131. Madison, Federal Convention (June 19, 1787), in 1 Farrand 318.
132. Gordon S. Wood, Interests and Disinterested in the Making of the Constitution, in Beyond Confederation 106–107.
133. Madison, Virginia Convention (June 6, 1788), in 11 JM 79.
134. Madison, Vices of the Political System of the United States (April 1787), in 9 JM 349.
135. Madison, Federal Convention (June 19, 1787), in 1 Farrand 318.
136. Madison, Notes for a Speech for the Virginia Assembly Opposing Paper Money (ca. Nov. 1, 1786), in 9 JM 158.
137. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 17, 1788)
138. Douglas Laycock, Nonpreferential Aid to Religion: A False Claim About Original Intent, 27 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 875, 895–899 (1986).
139. Madison, Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments (ca. June 20, 1785), in 8 JM 298, 299.
140. Madison, Federal Convention (June 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 136.
141. Madison, Vices of the Political System of the United States (April 1787)
142. Martin Diamond, Democracy and the Federalist, in Confederation and the Constitution: The Critical Issues 137 (Gordon Wood, ed. 1973).
143. John Martin Dawson, Baptists and the American Republic 90 (1956)
144. Carla Gardina Pestana, The Quaker Executions as Myth and History, 80 J. of Am. Hist. 441, 454. (1993)
145. O. S. Ireland, The Crux of Politics: Religion and Party in Pennsylvania, 1778–1789, 42 Wm. & Mary Q. 455–456
146. Madison, Virginia Convention (June 12, 1787), in 3 Elliot 330–331.
147. Irving Brant, James Madison: The Virginia Revolutionist 68 (1941).
148. Paul F. Boller, George Washington and Religious Liberty, 17 Wm. & Mary Q. 486 (1960)
149. Brutus I, New York Journal. (Oct. 18, 1787), reprintedin 13 DHRC 417.
150. Federal Farmer, Letters to the Republican IX (Jan. 4, 1788), reprinted in 17 DHRC 288, 295
151. John Tyler, Virginia Convention (June 21, 1788), in 10 DHRC 1527–1528.
152. Brutus I, New York Journal (Oct. 18, 1787), reprinted in 13 DHRC 417
153. Luther Martin, Genuine Information IV, Baltimore Maryland Gazette (Jan. 8, 1788), reprinted in 15 DHRC 296
154. James Bowdoin Jr., Debate in Massachusetts Ratification Convention (Feb. 1, 1788), in 2 Elliot 126.
155. Brutus I, New York Journal (Oct. 18, 1787), reprinted in 13 DHRC 417.
156. James Monroe, Virginia Convention (June 10, 1788), in 3 Elliot 215.
157. Montesquieu, Spirit of the Laws, Book 9, Chapter 1, reprinted in 1 Founders’ Constitution 247.
158. Cecelia M. Kenyon, Men of Little Faith: The Anti-Federalists on the Nature of Representative Government, 12 Wm. & Mary Q. 3 (1955).
159. Douglas Adair, That Politics May be Reduced to a Science, in Fame and the Founding Fathers 93, 98–104 (Trevor Colbin, ed. 1974).
160. David Hume, The Idea of a Perfect Constitution, in Hume’s Political Essays 221,2 29 (Knud Haakonssen, ed. 1994).
161. David Hume, of Taxes in from Part II of Essays: Moral, Political, and Literary II.VIII.11(1752), http://www.econlib.org/library/Hume/HumeEssTax.htm (accessed Aug. 22, 2001)
162. Edmund S. Morgan, Safety in Numbers: Madison, Hume, and the Tenth Federalist, in Huntington Lib. Q. 49 (1986)
163. Hamilton, Federal Convention (June 18, 1787), in 1 Farrand 288.
164. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 30, 1787), in 2 Elliot 424.
165. John Marshall, Virginia Convention, (June 10, 1788), in 3 Elliot 232.
166. Douglas Jaenick, Madison v. Madison: the Party Essays v. the Federalist Papers, in Reflections on the Constitution: The American Constitution after Two Hundred Years 116 (Richard Maidment & John Zvesper, eds. 1989)
167. John Zvesper, The Madisonian Systems, 37 W. Pol. Q.236, 250 (1984).
168. David F. Epstein, The Political Theory of the Federalist 59 (1984)
169. David F. Epstein, Remarks on the Federalist Number 10, 16 Harv. J. of Law & Pub. Policy 43 (1993)
170. Isaac Kramnick, The “Great National Discussion”: The Discourse of Politics in 1787, 45 Wm. & Mary Q. 3 (3d Series 1988)
171. Robert A. Dahl, Pluralist Democracy in the United States 5–5, 25, 41–32 (1966)
172. Larry D. Kramer, Madison Audience, 112 Harv. L. Rev. 611, 612–613 (1999).
173. Mancur Olson, Jr., The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups 35, 164–166
174. Nicolas Copernicus, quotedin A. R. Hall, The Scientific Revolution 1500–1800, at 67 (1960).
175. Charles Pinckney, South Carolina House of Representatives (Jan. 16, 1788), in 4 Elliot 256.
176. William E. Nelson, Reason and Compromise in the Establishment of the Federal Constitution, 1787–1801, 44 Wm. & Mary Q. 458 (1987).
177. John P. Roche, The Founding Fathers: A Reform Caucus in Action, 55 Am. Pol. Sci. Rev. 799, 803 (1961)
178. Gouverneur Morris, Federal Convention (May 30, 1787), in 1 Farrand 34.
179. Wilson, Speech to the Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 26, 1787), in 2 Elliot 422.
180. Nathaniel Gorham, Federal Convention (July 23, 1787), in 2 Farrand 90.
181. Madison, Unsent letter to John Tyler (1833), in 3 Farrand 530–531
182. Robert Yates and John Lansing, Jr., to Governor George Clinton, Daily Advertiser (Jan. 14, 1788), reprinted in 2 Debate 3, 4.
183. Nathaniel Gorham, Federal Convention (July 23, 1787), in 2 Farrand 90.
184. R. D. Spaight, North Carolina Convention (July 30, 1788), in 4 Elliot 207.
185. James Iredell, North Carolina Convention (July 31, 1788), in 4 Elliot 228–229.
186. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 4, 1788), in 3 Elliot 28.
187. John K. Alexander, The Selling of the Constitutional Convention 23 (quoting Salem, Massachusetts Mercury (1787)).
188. Madison, Vices of the Political System, in 9 JM 352–353.
189. Madison, Federal Convention (June 19, 1787), in 1 Farrand 315.
190. Hamilton, Federal Convention (June 19, 1787), in 1 Farrand 324.
191. Oliver Ellsworth, Federal Convention, June 20, 1787, in 1 Farrand 335
192. Bruce Ackerman & NealKumar Katyal, Our Unconventional Founding, 62
193. Robert Yates and John Lansing, Jr., to Governor George Clinton, The Dissent of the Two New York Delegates to the Philadelphia Convention, Daily Advertiser (Jan. 14, 1788)
194. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Dec. 4, 1787), in 2 Elliot 469.
195. William Davie, North Carolina Convention (July 24, 1788), in 4 Elliot 16–17
196. Tom Paine, Rights of Man, pt. II (1792)
197. Edmund Randolph, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 255
198. Hamilton, Federal Convention (June 18, 1787), in 1 Farrand 283–292
199. George Read (Delaware), Federal Convention (June 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 136–137.
200. Charles Pinckney, South Carolina House of Representatives (Jan. 16, 1788), in 4 Elliot 255.
201. Charles Cotesworth Pinckney, South Carolina Legislature (Jan. 18, 1788), in 4 Elliot 301–302.
202. http://www.britanica.com/
203. Randolph, Reasons for Not Signing the Constitution (Dec. 27, 1787), in 8 DHRC 260, 266.
204. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 4, 1788), in 3 DHRC 545
205. Randolph, Reasons for not Signing the Constitution (Dec. 27, 1787), in 8 DHRC 266
206. Madison, Federal Convention (May 31, 1787), in 1 Farrand 53.
207. Hamilton, New York Convention (June 20, 1788) in 2 Elliot 232
208. Madison, Federal Convention (May 31, 1787), in 1 Farrand 53.
209. Hamilton, New York Ratifying Convention (June 20, 1788), in 2 Elliot 231.
210. James Iredell, North Carolina Convention (July 28, 1788), in 4 Elliot 146.
211. Madison, Federal Convention (May 30, 1787), in 1 Farrand 34.
212. Madison, Motion in the Continental Congress (Jan. 28, 1783), in 25 JCC 870.
213. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 7, 1788), in 2 Elliot 191.
214. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 7, 1788), in 5 DHRC 274.
215. Douglass C. North & Barry R. Weingast, Constitutions and Commitment: The Evolution of Institutional Governing Public Choice in Seventeenth-Century England, 49 J. of Econ. Hist. 803, 816 (1989)
216. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Dec. 11, 1787), in 2 Elliot 502.
217. Pierce Butler (So. Carolina), Federal Convention (July 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 542
218. Martin Diamond, What the Framers Meant by Federalism, in A Nation of States 24 (Robert Goldwin, ed. 1961)
219. Martin Diamond, The Ends of Federalism, in Reluctant Pillar 16, 19–20
220. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Dec. 11, 1787), in 2 Elliot 497–498.
221. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 26, 1787), in 2 Elliot 433.
222. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 26, 1787), in 2 Elliot 432.
223. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 26, 1787), in 2 Elliot 432.
224. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Dec. 1, 1787), in 2 Elliot 443.
225. Wilson, Federal Convention (June 16 1787), in 1 Farrand 279
226. Hamilton, Federal Convention (June 18, 1787), in 1 Farrand 283.
227. Charles Pinckney, Federal Convention (May 31, 1787), in 1 Farrand 59
228. Benjamin Franklin, Debates in the Federal Convention (Aug. 7, 1787)
229. David Conway, Development of a Revolutionary Organization, 1765–1775
230. Oscar Handlin & Mary F. Handlin, Introduction. The Popular Sources of Political Authority: Documents on the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780, at 18–26 (1966)
231. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 4, 1788), in 3 Elliot 22–23.
232. Samuel Nasson, Massachusetts Convention (Feb. 1, 1788), in 2 Elliot 134.
233. David Caldwell, North Carolina Convention (July 24, 1788), in 4 Elliot 15–16.
234. William Pinckney, Argument before the Supreme Court in McCullough v. Maryland, 17 U.S. (Wheat) 316, 377 (1819).
235. Madison, Vices of Political System 8, in 9 JM 352.
236. Jack Rakove, Concept of Ratification, in Rakove. Original Meanings 94–108 (1996).
237. Madison, Federal Convention (Aug. 31, 1787), in 2 Farrand 476.
238. Randolph, Federal Convention (July 23, 1787), in 2 Farrand 89.
239. George Read (Del.), Federal Convention (June 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 137.
240. Wilson, A Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 253.
241. Madison, Federal Convention, July 14, 1787, in 2 Farrand 8.
242. Wilson, Continental Congress (Aug. 1, 1776), in 6 JCC 1105.
243. Madison, Federal Convention (July 7, 1787), in 1 Farrand 554
244. Benjamin Franklin, Federal Convention (Aug. 7, 1787), in 2 Farrand 204
245. Wilson, Speech to the Federal Convention (July 11, 1787), in 1 Farrand 587.
246. Nathaniel Gorham, Speech to the Federal Convention (July 11, 1787), in 1 Farrand 587.
247. Madison, Federal Convention (July 11, 1787), in 1 Farrand 585.
248. Madison, Federal Convention (June 28, 1787), in 1 Farrand 449.
249. The New Jersey Amendments to the Articles of Confederation 2–3 (June 15, 1787), in 1 DHRC 251, 1 Farrand 242–245.
250. Charles Pinckney, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 255.
251. Lynn A. Baker & Samuel H. Dinkin, The Senate: An Institution Whose Time Has Gone? 13 J.L. & Pol. 21, 25–30 (1997)
252. Madison, Federal Convention, June 28, 1787, 1 Farrand 446–447
253. Randolph, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 256.
254. William H. Riker, The Senate and American Federalism, 49 Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev. 452, 456 (1956).
255. Charles Pinckney, U.S. House of Representatives (Feb. 14, 1820) in 3 0
256. Calvin H. Johnson, Apportionment of Direct Taxes: The Foul-Up in the Core of the Constitution, 7 Wm. & Mary Bill of Rts. J. 84–96 (1998).
257. Madison, Federal Convention (June 28, 1787), in 1 Farrand 449
258. Charles F. Hobson, The Negative on State Laws: James Madison, the Constitution, and the Crises of Republican Government, 36 Wm. & Mary Q. 215 (3d Ser. 1979)
259. Madison, Federal Convention (June 28, 1787), in 1 Farrand 447.
260. Madison, Federal Convention (Aug. 28, 1787), in 2 Farrand 440.
261. Madison, Federal Convention, July 17, 1787, 2 Farrand 28.
262. Charles Pinckney, Federal Convention (June 8, 1787), in 1 Farrand 167
263. Madison, Federal Convention (June 8, 1787), in 1 Farrand 168
264. Wilson, Federal Convention (Aug. 23, 1787), in 2 Farrand 391.
265. Madison, Federal Convention (June 8, 1787), in 1 Farrand 168
266. John Lansing, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 250.
267. Gunning Bedford, Federal Convention (June 8, 1787), in 1 Farrand 167.
268. Benjamin Franklin, Federal Convention (June 4, 1787), in 1 Farrand 98–99.
269. Gouverneur Morris, Federal Convention (July 17, 1787), in 2 Farrand 27.
270. Madison, Federal Convention (July 17, 1787), in 2 Farrand 27.
271. Pauline Maier, American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence 107 (1997).
272. Mason, Virginia Convention (June 17, 1788), in 3 Elliot 452.
273. Jack P. Greene, Ongoing Disputes over the Prerogative, 1767–1776, in Jack Green & J. R. Pole, The Blackwell Encyclopedia of the American Revolution 171–176 (1991).
274. Great Britain Parliament, The Declaratory Act of March 18, 1766, http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/amerrev/parliament/declaratory_act_1766.htm
275. Mason, Virginia Convention (June 18, 1788), in 3 Elliot 521
276. Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution §§ 1105 (1833), reprinted in 2 The Founders’ Constitution 639, 641.
277. Rhett Frimet, The Birth of Bankruptcy in the United States, 96 Com. L.J. 160 (1991)
278. Brutus I, New York Journal (Oct. 18, 1787), reprinted in 13 DHRC 414
279. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 24, 1788), in 3 Elliot 600–601.
280. Randolph, Reasons for not Signing the Constitution (Dec. 27, 1787), in 8 DHRC 263
281. Madison, Notes of the Continental Congress Debates (Jan. 24, 1783), in 19 LDCC, at 608
282. Wilson, Federal Convention, July 14, 1787, in 2 Farrand 10.
283. Roger Sherman & Oliver Ellsworth to Governor Samuel Huntington, The Report of Connecticut’s Delegates to the Constitutional Convention (Sept. 26, 1787), in 13 DHRC 471
284. John Lansing, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 249
285. Alexander Hamilton, New York Convention (June 28, 1788), in 2 Elliot 364.
286. Randolph, Federal Convention (Sept. 17, 1787), in 2 Farrand 564.
287. Randolph, Reasons for Not Signing the Constitution (Dec. 27, 1787), in 8 DHRC 273
288. George Mason, Alterations Proposal (Aug. 31, 1787), in Supplement to Max Farrand’s The Records of the Federal Convention 25 (James H. Hutson ed., 1987).
289. Norman J. Singer, Sutherland Statutory Construction §47.17, at 188–200 (5th ed. 1992).
290. Oliver Ellsworth, Federal Convention (June 20, 1787), in 1 Farrand 335.
291. William Samuel Johnson, Federal Convention (June 21, 1787), in 1 Elliot 431
292. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 6, 1788), in 2 Elliot 71.
293. Madison, Virginia Convention (June 16, 1787), m 3 Elliot 415 (emphasis added).
294. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 4, 1788), in 2 Elliot 186 (emphasis added).
295. Randolph, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 256
296. Randolph, Federal Convention (Aug. 30, 1787), in 2 Farrand 469.
297. Washington, Letter to Congress by Unanimous Order of the Convention (Sept. 17, 1787), in 2 Farrand 667
298. Robert Rutland, Ratification of the Constitution, in 2 Encyclopedia of the Constitution 1512–1514 (Leonard Levy et al., eds. 1986).
299. Madison (writing anonymously), A Candid State of Parties, National Gazette, Sept. 22, 1792, reprinted n 14 JM 370, 371.
300. John P. Kaminski, New York: The Reluctant Pillar, in Reluctant Pillar, 99, 114 (Clinton in control of two-thirds majority).
301. Federal Farmer, Letters to the Republican 1 (Oct. 8, 1787)
302. Patrick Henry, Virginia Ratification Convention (June 9, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1068
303. William Findley, History of the Insurrection 43 (1796).
304. Eldridge Gerry, House of Representatives, Aug. 15, 1789, 1 Annals 759.
305. Daniel A. Farber, The Constitution’s Forgotten Cover Letter: An Essay on the New Federalism and the Original Understanding: Reflections on United States v. Lopez, 94 Mich. L. Rev. 615, 628 n. 73 (1995)
306. Randolph, Federal Convention, May 30, 1787, in 1 Farrand 33.
307. Robert Livingston, New York Convention (June 27, 1787)
308. Gordon Wood, Political Ideology of the Founders, in Toward a more Perfect Union 1, 17 (Neil York, ed. 1988)
309. Murray Dry, The Anti-Federalists and the Constitution, in Principles of the Constitutional Order: The Ratification Debates 64 (Robert L. Utley, Jr., ed., 1989)
310. Giorgio De Santillana, Galileo, in 19 Ency. Britannica 640, 641 (15th ed. 1985)
311. Paul Finkelman, Turning Losers into Winners: What Can We Learn If Anything, from the Anti-Federalists?, 79 Tex. L. Rev. 877 (2001)
312. Madison, Virginia Convention (June 24, 1788), in 3 Elliot 618–619
313. Hamilton, Federal Convention (Sept. 17, 1787), in 2 Farrand 645
314. Benjamin Franklin, Federal Convention (Sept. 17, 1787), in 2 Farrand 641.
315. Charles Pinckney, South Carolina House of Representatives (Jan. 16, 1788), in 4 Elliot 261.
316. “A Farmer and Planter,” Maryland Journal (April 1, 1788)
317. Henry Abbot, North Carolina Convention (July 30, 1788), in 4 Elliot 191–2
318. Joseph Story, 1 Constitutional Commentary 388–389 (1833).
319. David McGowan, Ethos in Law and History: Alexander Hamilton, The Federalist, and the Supreme Court, 85 Minn. L. Rev. 755, 825 (2001)
320. Linda Grant De Pauw, The Eleventh Pillar: New York State and the Federal Constitution 278 (1966), at 106–117
321. John Kaminski, New York: The Reluctant Pillar, in Reluctant Pillar 71–72.
322. Louis G. Otto, Liste des Membres et Officiers du Congrés. 1788, French Archives: Ministère des Affaires Etrangères, in 3 Farrand 232, 234, 237.
323. Rufus King (Massachusetts), Federal Convention (June 19, 1787), in 1 Farrand 324.
324. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 9, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1058.
325. Stanley Elkins & Eric McKitrick, The Founding Fathers: Young Men of the Revolution, 76 Pol. Sci. Q. 181, 202–203 (1961)
326. Randolph, Federal Convention (July 23, 1787), in 2 Farrand 89.
327. Robert Yates and John Lansing, Jr., to Governor George Clinton, The Dissent of the Two New York Delegates to the Philadelphia Convention, Daily Advertiser (Jan. 14, 1788), reprinted in 2 Debate 3, 4.
328. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 7, 1788), in 2 Elliot 190–197
329. Madison, Unsent letter to John Tyler (1833), in 3 Farrand 530–531.
330. O. S. Ireland, The Crux of Politics: Religion and Party in Pennsylvania, 1778–1789, 42 Wm. & Mary Q. 453, 456
331. Robert Brunhouse, The Counter-revolution in Pennsylvania, 1776–1790, at 80 (1942).
332. E. Bruce Thomas, Political Tendencies in Pennsylvania, 1783–1794, at 199 (1938)
333. David Gordon, Eldridge Gerry, in 2 Encyclopedia of the American Constitution 838–9 (Leonard Levy, ed. 1986)
334. Dennis J. Mahoney, John Lansing, Jr., in 3 id. 1124.
335. George Billias, Elbridge Gerry: Founding Father and Republican Statesman 23–24 (1976).
336. Saul Cornell, The Other Founders (2000).
337. Mason, Federal Convention (May 30, 1787), in 1 Farrand 34.
338. Mason, Federal Convention (June 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 133
339. Mason, Objections to the Constitution of Government formed by the Convention (Oct. 7, 1787), in 8 DHRC 44.
340. Mason, Federal Convention (Aug. 16, 1787)
341. Mason, Federal Convention (June 26, 1787), in 1 Farrand 428
342. Mason, Federal Convention (Aug. 7, 1787), in 2 Farrand 201–202
343. Mason, Objections to the Constitution of Government formed by the Convention (Oct. 7, 1787), in 8 DHRC 45.
344. Mason, Objections to the Constitution of Government formed by the Convention (Oct. 7, 1787), in 8 DHRC 43, 45.
345. Mason, Federal Convention (Sept. 13, 1787)
346. Randolph, Federal Convention (June 16, 1787), in 1 Farrand 256.
347. RR Livingston, New York Convention (June 24, 1788), in 2 Elliot 291.
348. Hamilton, Federal Convention (June 18, 1787), in 1 Farrand 287.
349. Wilson, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 30, 1787), in 2 Elliot 433.
350. Madison, Federal Convention (June 12 and 21, 1787), in 1 Farrand 214, 361.
351. Madison, Federal Convention (Aug. 9, 1787)
352. Cecelia M. Kenyon, Men of Little Faith: The Anti-Federalists on the Nature of Representative Government,12 Wm. & Mary Q. 3 (1955).
353. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 4, 1788), in 2 Elliot 189.
354. Thomas McKean, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 28, 1787), in 2 DHRC 415.
355. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 9, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1054.
356. William Grayson, Virginia Convention (June 16, 1788)
357. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 9, 1788)
358. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 9, 1788)
359. Melancton Smith, Address to the People of New York (Apr 1787), in Pamphlets 87, 108.
360. John Smilie, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 28, 1787), in 2 DHRC 408.
361. Melancton Smith, New York Convention (June 27, 1787), in 2 Elliot 333.
362. Calvin Johnson, Apportionment of Direct Taxes: The Foul-up in the Core of the Constitution, 7 Wm. & Mary Bill of Rts. J. 1, 48–51(1998).
363. Amos Singletary, Massachusetts Convention (Jan. 25, 1788)
364. Federal Farmer, Letters to the Republican III (Oct. 10, 1787), reprinted in 14 DHRC 35–36
365. Cato Uticensis, To the Freemen of Virginia, Virginia Independent Chronicle (Oct. 17, 1787)
366. John Smilie, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 28, 1788), in 2 DHRC 408–09
367. Robert Whitehill, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 28, 1787), in 2 DHRC 396.
368. Brutus V, New York Journal (Dec. 13, 1787), reprinted in 14 DHRC 427.
369. Mason, Virginia Convention (June 4, 1788), in 9 DHRC 936.
370. James Monroe, Virginia Convention (June 10, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1109.
371. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 7, 1788)
372. Madison, Virginia Convention (June 11, 1788)
373. Hamilton, New York Convention (June 28, 1788), in 2 Elliot 369.
374. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 12, 1788), in 3 Elliot 320.
375. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 7, 1788) in 3 Elliot 148.
376. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 17, 1788), in 10 DHRC 1341–1342
377. Madison, Notes on Debates in the Congress (Jan. 28, 1783)
378. Forest McDonald, E Pluribus Unum, The Formation of the American Republic 1776–1790, at 199 (1965).
379. Bruce Ackerman & Neal Kumar Katyal, Our Unconventional Founding, 62 U. Chi. L. Rev. 475, 533–536 (1995)
380. Robin Brooks, Alexander Hamilton, Melancton Smith, and the Ratification of the Constitution in New York, 24 William & Mary Q. 339, 351 (3rd series, 1967).
381. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 16, 1788), in 3 Elliot 410.
382. Henry Abbot, North Carolina Convention (July 30, 1788), in 4 Elliot 191–192 (reporting fears by “some people”).
383. James Iredell, North Carolina Convention (July 30, 1788), in 4 Elliot 195 (reporting pamphlet he had just read).
384. Mason, Virginia Convention (June 16, 1788), in 3 Elliot 331.
385. Abraham Holmes, Massachusetts Convention (Jan. 30, 1788), in 2 Elliot 111.
386. “A Farmer and a Planter,” Maryland Journal (April 1, 1788)
387. Madison, Virginia Convention (June 12, 1787), in 3 Elliot 330–331
388. Luther Martin, Genuine Information X, Baltimore Maryland Gazette, Feb. 1, 1788, reprinted in 16 DHRC 9.
389. Madison, Virginia Convention, June 20, 1788, 3 Elliot 537.
390. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 12, 1788), in 3 Elliot 318–319.
391. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 16, 1788), in 3 Elliot 461.
392. William Grayson, Virginia Convention (June 21, 1788), in 3 Elliot 566.
393. Rawlins Lowndes, South Carolina Legislature, Jan 18, 1788, in 4 Elliot 309.
394. Richard B. Morris, Class Struggle and the American Revolution, 19 William & Mary Q. 3, 7 (3d Series 1962)
395. Luther Martin, Federal Convention (June 27, 1787), in 1 Farrand 439 (Yates notes).
396. Thomas Rusk, Massachusetts Convention (Feb. 4, 1788), in 2 Elliot 148.
397. Federal Farmer, Letterto the Republican XII, New York Journal (Jan. 12, 1788), reprinted in 17 DHRC 310.
398. Edward Rutledge, South Carolina Legislature (Jan. 16, 1788), in 2 Elliot 274–275.
399. Edmund Pendleton, Virginia Convention (June 12, 1788), in 3 Elliot 300–301.
400. Washington, Inaugural Address (April 30, 1789), in http://elsinore.cis.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/presiden/inaug/wash1.htm (accessed Oct. 16, 2002).
401. Melancton Smith, “Address to the People of New York” (April 1787), in Pamphlets 87, 89–109
402. Donald Lutz, The Pedigree of the Bill of Rights, in The Bill of Rights: Government Proscribed 42, 47–52
403. Kenneth R. Bowling, “A Tub to the Whale”: The Founding Fathers and Adoption of the Federal Bill of Rights, 8 J. of the Early Rep. 223–251 (1988)
404. Gordon Wood, The Irrelevance of a Bill of Rights, in Wood 536–543
405. Paul Finkelman, James Madison and the Bill of Rights: A Reluctant Paternity, Sup. Crt. Rev. 1990 at 344
406. Robert Rutland, The Birth of the Bill of Rights 1776–1791, at 197–125 (1955).
407. Aedanus Burke, Gazette of the United States (Aug. 19, 1789)
408. Staughton Lynd, Abraham Yates’s History of the Movement for the United States Constitution, 20 Wm. & Mary Q. 223, 227 (3d series 1963).
409. Bernard Schwartz, The Bill of Rights: A Documentary History 1032 (1990).
410. Cecelia M. Kenyon, Men of Little Faith: The Anti-Federalists on the Nature of Representative Government 12Wm. & MaryQ. 3rd. Ser. at 33, 42
411. George Clinton, New York Convention (June 28, 1788), in 2 Elliot 359.
412. Federal Farmer, Letters to the Republican V, New York Journal (Oct. 13, 1787), reprinted in 14 DHRC 50.
413. Federal Farmer, An Additional Number of Letters to the Republican XII, New York Journal (Jan. 12, 1788), reprinted in 17 DHRC 310, 311.
414. Elbridge Gerry, Federal Convention (July 25, 1787), in 2 Farrand 114 (Madison’s notes).
415. Elbridge Gerry, Federal Convention (June 7, 1787), in 1 Farrand 151.
416. Elbridge Gerry, Federal Convention (June 6, 1787), in 1 Farrand 132.
417. Mark David Hall, The Political and Legal Philosophy of James Wilson, 1742–1798
418. Benjamin Franklin, Federal Convention (Aug. 7, 1787)
419. Eric Foner, Tom Paine and Revolutionary America 34–35
420. Thomas Paine, Rights of Man (1791)
421. Eric Foner, Tom Paine and Revolutionary America 208–209 (1976)
422. Madison, Observations on Jefferson’s Draft of a Constitution for Virginia (Oct. 15, 1788), in 11 JM at 287.
423. John Smilie, Pennsylvania Convention (Nov. 28, 1787), in 2 DHRC 407, 408–409
424. James E. Viator, Give Me That Old-time Historiography: Charles Beard and the Study of the Constitution (part 2), 43 Loy. L. Rev. 311, 406 (1997)
425. Gilbert Livingston, New York Convention (June 24, 1787)
426. James H. Hutson, The Creation of the Constitution: Scholarship at a Standstill, 12 Reviews in American History 463, 466–472
427. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 24, 1788), in 10 DHRC 1476.
428. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 17, 1788), in 10 DHRC 1341
429. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 24, 1788), in 3 Elliot 591.
430. Abraham Lincoln, Address at a Sanitary Fair in Baltimore, April 15, 1864
431. Gary B. Nash & Jean R. Soderlund, Freedom By Degress: Emancipation in Pennsylvania and Its Aftermath 53, 78–105 (1991)
432. Linda Kerber, Federalists in Dissent: Imagery and Ideology in Jeffersonian America 23–66 (1970).
433. James H. Hutson, The Creation of the Constitution: Scholarship at a Standstill, 12 Reviews in American History 463, 464 (1984)
434. Calvin Johnson, The Panda’s Thumb: The Modest and Mercantilist Original Intent of the Commerce Clause, 13 Wm & Mary Bill of Rights J. 1 (2004).
435. Robert J. Steamer, Commerce Power in Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States 167 (Kermit Hall, ed., 1992).
436. Quentin Skinner, Meaning and Understanding the History of Ideas in Meaning and Understanding: Quentin Skinner and his Critics 3, 55–65
437. John O. McGinnis & Mark L. Movsesian, The World Trade Constitution, 114 Harv. L. Rev. 511, 527 (2000).
438. John Rutledge, Speech at the Federal Convention (Aug. 29, 1787)
439. Charles Pinckney, South Carolina House of Representatives (Jan. 16, 1788), in 4 Elliot 253–254
440. James Bowdoin, Massachusetts Convention (Jan. 23, 1788)
441. William R. Davie, North Carolina Convention (July 24, 1788)
442. Lord Sheffield, Observations on the Commerce of the United States 264–265 (6th ed. 1784)
443. Thomas Russell, Massachusetts Convention (Feb. 1, 1788), in 2 Elliot 139.
444. Thomas Dawes, Massachusetts Convention (Jan. 21, 1788)
445. Thomas Russell, Massachusetts Convention (Feb. 1, 1788)
446. Hugh Williamson, Speech at Edenton, North Carolina (Nov. 8, 1787) printed in Daily Advertiser (New York) (Feb. 25–27, 1788)
447. Winkfield F. Twyman, Jr., Justice Scalia and Facial Discrimination: Some Notes on Legal Reasoning, 18 Va.Tax Rev. 103, 108 (1998)
448. William Frank Zarnow, New York Tariff Policies, 1775–1789, 37 New York History: Proceedings of the New York Historical Association 40, 47 (1956) (New York exemptions).
449. Albert S. Abel, The Commerce Clause in the Constitutional Convention and in Contemporary Comment, 25 Minn. L. Rev. 470 (1941).
450. Gordon S. Wood, Interests and Disinterests in the Making of the Constitution, in Beyond Confederation 69.
451. Herbert E. Sloan, Principle and Interest: Thomas Jefferson and the Problem of Debt 26–32, 34–37
452. William Lee Miller, The Business of May Next: James Madison and the Founding 1 (1992).
453. Irving Brant, Two Neglected Madison Letters, 3 Wm. & Mary Q. 56, 572, 580 (1946)
454. Emory G. Evans, The Rise and Decline of the Virginia Aristocracy in the Eighteenth Century: The Nelsons James Wilson, 4 Encyclopedia of the American Constitution 2067 (1986).
455. McKitrick, The Founding Fathers: Young Men of the Revolution, 76 Pol. Sci. Q. 181, 195 (June 1961)
456. James Ferguson, Review of Forrest McDonald, E Pluribus Unum, 23 Wm. & Mary Q. (3d Series) 148, 150 (1966)
457. Robert Thomas, The Virginia Convention of 1788: A Criticism of Beard’s ‘An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution’, 57 Am. Hist. Rev. 570 (1952)
458. James E. Viator, Give Me That Old-time Historiography: Charles Beard and the Study of the Constitution (part 1), 36 Loy. L. Rev. 981, 1007 (1991).
459. Cecelia M. Kenyon, Men of Little Faith: The Anti-Federalists on the Nature of Representative Government, 12 Wm. & Mary Q. 3 (3rd Series 1955)
460. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 9, 1788), in 9 DHRC 1055.
461. William Grayson, Virginia Convention (June 9, 1788)
462. Mary M. Schweitzer, State-Issued Currency, Beyond Confederation at 314–315
463. Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Debates on the Continental Congress (July 29, 1775)
464. Gordon S. Wood, Interests and Disinterests in the Making of the Constitution, in Beyond Confederation 69, 72
465. Arnold Paul, Conservative Crisis and the Rule of Law: Attitudes of bar and bench, 1887–1895 (1960).
466. William Jennings Bryan, “Cross of Gold,” Democratic National Convention (July 9, 1896), available at http://douglass.speech.nwu.edu/bryaa26.htm (accessed Jan. 24, 2002).
467. James Monroe, Virginia Convention (June 10, 1788), in 3 Elliot 212.
468. Jonathan Chu, Debt and Taxes: Public Finance and Private Economic Behavior in Postrevolutionary Massachusetts, in Entrepreneurs: The Boston Business Community, 1700–1850
469. Jonathan Smith, The Depression of 1785 and Daniel Shays’ Rebellion (1905), reprinted in 5 Wm. & Mary Q. 77, 88–89
470. Robert Brown, Shays’ Rebellion and the Ratification of the Constitution in Massachusetts, in Beyond Confederation, 116.
471. Richard D. Brown, Shays’ Rebellion and Its Aftermath: A View from Springfield, Massachusetts, 1787, 40 Wm. & Mary Q. 598, 609–610
472. George Clinton, Journal of the Assembly of the state of New York, 10th Sess, at 62 (Jan. 12, 1787).
473. Melancton Smith, An Address to the People of the State of New York (April 17, 1788), reprinted in 17 DHRC 151.
474. Charles Warren, Proceedings, 64 Mass. Hist. Soc. 157 (1932).
475. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 5, 1788), in 3 Elliot 48
476. Robert D. Brown, Shays’ Rebellion and the Ratification of the Federal Constitution in Massachusetts, in Beyond Confederation 113.
477. Richard Morris, Insurrection in Massachusetts, in America in Crisis: Fourteen Crucial Episodes in American History 23 (Daniel Aaron, ed. 1952)
478. http://www.census.gov/prod/2001pubs/statab/sec1 3.pdf
479. Phillip J. Greven, Jr. Average Size of Families and Households in Household and family in past time (Peter Laslett and Richard Wall, eds., 1972)
480. Jefferson, Second Inaugural Address (March 4, 1805), http://etext.virginia.edu/jefferson/texts/ (accessed Oct. 16, 2002)
481. Hamilton, New York Convention, (June 28, 1788) in 2 Elliot 369.
482. Madison, House of Representatives, in 14 DHFFC, 1789–1791 at 195.
483. William D. Barber, “Among the Most Techy Articles of Civil Police”: Federal Taxation and the Adoption of the Whiskey Excise, 25 Wm. & Mary Q. 58, 77–78
484. Oliver Ellsworth, Connecticut Convention (Jan. 7, 1788)
485. Elbridge Gerry, Federal Convention (Aug. 25, 1787)
486. Elbridge Gerry, Federal Convention (Aug. 25, 1787)
487. Robert Morris, Report of the Office of Finance (Aug. 5, 1782)
488. James C. Riley, Foreign Credit and Fiscal Stability: Dutch Investment in the United States, 1781–1794, 65 J. Amer. History 654, 672–678 (1978)
489. E. James Ferguson, The Nationalists of 1781–1783 and the Economic Interpretation of the Constitution, 56 J. of Amer. History 241, 256 (1969)
490. Mason, Federal Convention (Aug. 25, 1787), in 2 Farrand 413.
491. Patrick Henry, Virginia Convention (June 17, 1788), in 3 Elliot 475.
492. Madison, Speech on Discrimination (Feb. 11, 1790), in 13 JM 34, 36. 50 Id at 37.
493. Madison, Address to the States (April 26, 1783), in 24 JCC 277, 282–283.
494. Robert M. Jennings, Donald F. Swanson, & Andrew P. Trout, Alexander Hamilton’s Tontine Proposal 45 Wm & Mary Q. 107 (3rd. Ser., 1988)
495. Donald F. Swanson, Andrew P. Trout, Alexander Hamilton’s Hidden Sinking Fund 49 Wm & Mary Q. 108 (3rd Ser., 1992)
496. Charles W. Calomiris, Institutional Failure, Monetary Scarcity, and the Depreciation of the Continental, 48 J. of Econ. History 47, 48–49 (1988)
497. Whitney K. Bates, Northern Speculators and Southern State Debts: 1790, 19 Wm. & Mary Q. 30, 42 (3rd Series, Jan. 1962)
498. Edwin J. Perkins, American Public Finance, 1775–1815 at 225 (1994).
499. Hamilton, Report Relative to a Provision for the Support of Public Credit (Jan. 9, 1790)
500. Madison, Notes of the Debates (Feb. 26, 1783), in 25 JCC 913 n. 1.
501. Luther Martin, Defense of Gerry, Maryland Journal (Jan. 18, 1788)
502. Mason, Virginia Convention (June 16, 1788), in 3 Elliot 442.
503. John Lansing, New York Convention (June 20, 1788), in 2 Elliot 217.
504. James Madison, The Bank Bill, House of Representatives (Feb. 2, 1791), in 13 JM 372. See discussion, Chapter 9, pp. 209–210.
505. John Zvesper, The Madisonian Systems, 37 W. Pol.Q. 236, 250 (1984)
506. David N. Mayer, The Constitutional Thought of Thomas Jefferson 244–251 (1994)
507. David Curie, The Constitution in Congress: Jefferson and the West, 1801–1809, 39 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 1441, 1474 (1998)
508. Drew McCoy, James Madison and Visions of American Nationality in the Confederation Period: A Regional Perspective, in Beyond Confederation 226.
509. Madison, Federal Convention (July 7, 1787), in 1 Farrand 551
510. Madison, Federal Convention (June 30, 1787), in I Farrand 485
511. Madison, Federal Convention (June 28, 1787), in 1 Farrand 446
512. Doyle Mathis, Chisholmv. Georgia: Background and Settlement, 54 J. of Am. Hist. 19 (1967).
513. Christine Desan, Contesting the Character of the Political Economy in the Early Republic, in The House and Senate in the 1790s: Petitioner, Lobbying and Institutional Development 178, 185–186 (2002).
514. Randolph, Virginia Convention (June 17, 1788), in 3 Elliot 469–470
515. David Currie, The Constitution in Congress: The Federalist Period 1789–1801
516. John Gibbons, Eleventh Amendment and State Sovereign Immunity: A Reinterpretation, 83 Colum. L. Rev. 1889, 1899–1826
517. William Fletcher, The Diversity Explanation of the Eleventh Amendment: A Reply to Critics, 56 U. Chi. L. Rev. 1261 (1989).
518. Robert G. McCloskey, James Wilson in 1 The Justices of the United States Supreme Court 1789–1969
519. Frank J. Michelman, Property, Utility, and Fairness: Comments on the Ethical Foundations of “Just Compensation” Law, 80 Harv. L. Rev. 1165, 1165 (1967)
520. John Rutledge, Motion at the Federal Convention (Aug. 18, 1787), in 2 Farrand 327
521. Jefferson, First Inaugural Address (March 4, 1801), in Basic Writings of TJ 334.