Substitute or complement? Defining the relative place of EEG and fMRI in the detection of voluntary brain reactions

Neuroscience

Volumn 290, Issue , 2015, Pages 435-444

  Gabriel, D ^a,b   Henriques, J ^a   Comte, A ^a,b,c   Grigoryeva, L ^a   Ortega, J P ^a,d   Cretin, E ^b,e   Brunotte, G ^b   Haffen, E ^a,b,c   Moulin, T ^a,b,c   Aubry, R ^b,c   Pazart, L ^b  

^a UNIVERSITÉ DE FRANCHE COMTÉ   (France)

^b INSERM   (France)

^c UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL OF BESANÇON   (France)

^d CNRS   (France)

^e Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique ^*  (France)

Author keywords

Consciousness; EEG; Functional MRI; Mental imagery; Neuroimaging

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AGED; ARTICLE; AWARENESS; BRAIN DEPTH STIMULATION; BRAIN FUNCTION; CLASSIFICATION; COMMUNICATION SKILL; CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL; CONTROLLED STUDY; CORTICAL SYNCHRONIZATION; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; DATA ANALYSIS; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DIAGNOSTIC TEST ACCURACY STUDY; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPH ELECTRODE; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; IMAGE INTENSIFIER; IMAGING SYSTEM; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; MALE; MEDICAL ERROR; NEUROIMAGING; NORMAL HUMAN; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE SCANNER; PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT SYSTEM; RISK BENEFIT ANALYSIS; RISK REDUCTION; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; TASK PERFORMANCE; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; COGNITION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; IMAGINATION; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; MIDDLE AGED; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TEST; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; PHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; QUESTIONNAIRE;

ADULT; AGED; AWARENESS; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; COMMUNICATION; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; FEMALE; HUMANS; IMAGINATION; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TESTS; SURVEYS AND QUESTIONNAIRES; VOLITION;

EID: 84923037116     PISSN: 03064522     EISSN: 18737544     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroscience.2015.01.053     Document Type: Article

References (39)

1. Bardin J.C., Fins J.J., Katz D.I., Hersh J., Heier L.A., Tabelow K., Dyke J.P., Ballon D.J., Schiff N.D., Voss H.U. Dissociations between behavioural and functional magnetic resonance imaging-based evaluations of cognitive function after brain injury. Brain 2011, 134:769-782.
2. Bekinschtein T.A., Dehaene S., Rohaut B., Tadel F., Cohen L., Naccache L. Neural signature of the conscious processing of auditory regularities. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2009, 106:1672-1677.
3. Boly M., Coleman M.R., Davis M.H., Hampshire A., Bor D., Moonen G., Maquet P.A., Pickard J.D., Laureys S., Owen A.M. When thoughts become action: an fMRI paradigm to study volitional brain activity in non-communicative brain injured patients. NeuroImage 2007, 36:979-992.
4. Boynton G.M., Engel S.A., Glover G.H., Heeger D.J. Linear systems analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging in human V1. J Neurosci 1996, 16:4207-4221.
5. Chennu S., Finoia P., Kamau E., Monti M.M., Allanson J., Pickard J.D., Owen A.M., Bekinschtein T.A. Dissociable endogenous and exogenous attention in disorders of consciousness. NeuroImage Clin 2013, 3:450-461.
6. Cruse D., Chennu S., Chatelle C., Bekinschtein T.A., Fernandez-Espejo D., Pickard J.D., Laureys S., Owen A.M. Bedside detection of awareness in the vegetative state: a cohort study. Lancet 2011, 378:2088-2094.
7. Cruse D., Chennu S., Chatelle C., Bekinschtein T.A., Fernandez-Espejo D., Pickard J.D., Laureys S., Owen A.M. Reanalysis of "bedside detection of awareness in the vegetative state: a cohort study". Lancet 2013, 381:291-292. Authors' reply.
8. Cruse D., Chennu S., Chatelle C., Fernandez-Espejo D., Bekinschtein T.A., Pickard J.D., Laureys S., Owen A.M. Relationship between etiology and covert cognition in the minimally conscious state. Neurology 2012, 78:816-822.
9. Cruse D., Chennu S., Fernandez-Espejo D., Payne W.L., Young G.B., Owen A.M. Detecting awareness in the vegetative state: electroencephalographic evidence for attempted movements to command. PLoS One 2012, 7:e49933.
10. Cruse D., Gantner I., Soddu A., Owen A.M. Lies, damned lies and diagnoses: estimating the clinical utility of assessments of covert awareness in the vegetative state. Brain Inj 2014, 28:1197-1201.
11. Falkenstein M., Hohnsbein J., Hoormann J. Effects of choice complexity on different subcomponents of the late positive complex of the event-related potential. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1994, 92:148-160.
12. Fernandez-Espejo D., Norton L., Owen A.M. The clinical utility of fMRI for identifying covert awareness in the vegetative state: a comparison of sensitivity between 3T and 1.5T. PLoS One 2014, 9:e95082.
13. Fernandez-Espejo D., Owen A.M. Detecting awareness after severe brain injury. Nat Rev Neurosci 2013, 14:801-809.
14. Forman S.D., Cohen J.D., Fitzgerald M., Eddy W.F., Mintun M.A., Noll D.C. Improved assessment of significant activation in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI): use of a cluster-size threshold. Magn Reson Med 1995, 33:636-647.
15. Furdea A., Halder S., Krusienski D.J., Bross D., Nijboer F., Birbaumer N., Kubler A. An auditory oddball (P300) spelling system for brain-computer interfaces. Psychophysiology 2009, 46:617-625.
16. Ghaem O., Mellet E., Crivello F., Tzourio N., Mazoyer B., Berthoz A., Denis M. Mental navigation along memorized routes activates the hippocampus, precuneus, and insula. NeuroReport 1997, 8:739-744.
17. Gibson R.M., Chennu S., Owen A.M., Cruse D. Complexity and familiarity enhance single-trial detectability of imagined movements with electroencephalography. Clin Neurophysiol 2013.
18. Gibson R.M., Fernandez-Espejo D., Gonzalez-Lara L.E., Kwan B.Y., Lee D.H., Owen A.M., Cruse D. Multiple tasks and neuroimaging modalities increase the likelihood of detecting covert awareness in patients with disorders of consciousness. Front Hum Neurosci 2014, 8:950.
19. Goldfine A.M., Bardin J.C., Noirhomme Q., Fins J.J., Schiff N.D., Victor J.D. Reanalysis of "bedside detection of awareness in the vegetative state: a cohort study". Lancet 2013, 381:289-291.
20. Goldfine A.M., Victor J.D., Conte M.M., Bardin J.C., Schiff N.D. Determination of awareness in patients with severe brain injury using EEG power spectral analysis. Clin Neurophysiol 2011, 122:2157-2168.
21. Goldman R.I., Stern J.M., Engel J., Cohen M.S. Simultaneous EEG and fMRI of the alpha rhythm. NeuroReport 2002, 13:2487-2492.
22. Hayasaka S., Nichols T.E. Validating cluster size inference: random field and permutation methods. NeuroImage 2003, 20:2343-2356.
23. Henriques J., Gabriel D., Grigoryeva L., Haffen E., Moulin T., Aubry R., Pazart L., Ortega J.P. Protocol design challenges in the detection of awareness in aware subjects using EEG signals. Clin EEG Neurosci 2014.
24. Holler Y., Bergmann J., Thomschewski A., Kronbichler M., Holler P., Crone J.S., Schmid E.V., Butz K., Nardone R., Trinka E. Comparison of EEG-features and classification methods for motor imagery in patients with disorders of consciousness. PLoS One 2013, 8:e80479.
25. Lotze M., Montoya P., Erb M., Hulsmann E., Flor H., Klose U., Birbaumer N., Grodd W. Activation of cortical and cerebellar motor areas during executed and imagined hand movements: an fMRI study. J Cogn Neurosci 1999, 11:491-501.
26. Lule D., Noirhomme Q., Kleih S.C., Chatelle C., Halder S., Demertzi A., Bruno M.A., Gosseries O., Vanhaudenhuyse A., Schnakers C., et al. Probing command following in patients with disorders of consciousness using a brain-computer interface. Clin Neurophysiol 2013, 124:101-106.
27. Mo J., Liu Y., Huang H., Ding M. Coupling between visual alpha oscillations and default mode activity. NeuroImage 2013, 68:112-118.
28. Monti M.M., Vanhaudenhuyse A., Coleman M.R., Boly M., Pickard J.D., Tshibanda L., Owen A.M., Laureys S. Willful modulation of brain activity in disorders of consciousness. N Engl J Med 2010, 362:579-589.
29. Naci L., Owen A.M. Making every word count for nonresponsive patients. JAMA Neurol 2013, 70:1235-1241.
30. Noirhomme Q., Lesenfants D., Gomez F., Soddu A., Schrouff J., Garraux G., Luxen A., Phillips C., Laureys S. Biased binomial assessment of cross-validated estimation of classification accuracies illustrated in diagnosis predictions. NeuroImage Clin 2014, 4:687-694.
31. Owen A.M., Coleman M.R., Boly M., Davis M.H., Laureys S., Pickard J.D. Detecting awareness in the vegetative state. Science 2006, 313:1402.
32. Pfurtscheller G., Brunner C., Schlogl A., Lopes da Silva F.H. Mu rhythm (de)synchronization and EEG single-trial classification of different motor imagery tasks. NeuroImage 2006, 31:153-159.
33. Pfurtscheller G., Lopes da Silva F.H. Event-related EEG/MEG synchronization and desynchronization: basic principles. Clin Neurophysiol 1999, 110:1842-1857.
34. Ross B., Picton T.W., Herdman A.T., Pantev C. The effect of attention on the auditory steady-state response. Neurol Clin Neurophysiol 2004, 2004:22.
35. Schnakers C., Perrin F., Schabus M., Hustinx R., Majerus S., Moonen G., Boly M., Vanhaudenhuyse A., Bruno M.A., Laureys S. Detecting consciousness in a total locked-in syndrome: an active event-related paradigm. Neurocase 2009, 15:271-277.
36. Schnakers C., Perrin F., Schabus M., Majerus S., Ledoux D., Damas P., Boly M., Vanhaudenhuyse A., Bruno M.A., Moonen G., et al. Voluntary brain processing in disorders of consciousness. Neurology 2008, 71:1614-1620.
37. Smith S.M., Nichols T.E. Threshold-free cluster enhancement: addressing problems of smoothing, threshold dependence and localisation in cluster inference. NeuroImage 2009, 44:83-98.
38. Stender J., Gosseries O., Bruno M.A., Charland-Verville V., Vanhaudenhuyse A., Demertzi A., Chatelle C., Thonnard M., Thibaut A., Heine L., et al. Diagnostic precision of PET imaging and functional MRI in disorders of consciousness: a clinical validation study. Lancet 2014, 384:514-522.
39. Talairach J., Tournoux P. Co-planar stereotaxic atlas of the human brain: 3-dimensional proportional system: an approach to cerebral imaging 1988, Thieme Medical Publishers, New York.